Video

I really enjoy hearing different theories about Midnight Motorist. And I can tell you've put a lot of effort into analyzing this. Are you going to do that follow up video you mentioned? I'm interested to hear what other ideas you have on it!

She’s been confirmed to be a girl over and over again. She’s appeared in the logbook, and ALSO in the book description it says a girl with black hair named Cassidy, and in the logbook she’s a girl wih two beads and black pigtails. And in the silver eyes trilogy she also appears as a girl. Cassidy is a girl.

I think Cassidy's pronouns are "they/them". A win-win option

I'm betting that the animatronic foot prints are golden Freddy's since they go nowhere and he is capable of appearing and vanishing where ever. I think that is Mike in the chair with the grey shirt he had back in FNAF 4 and that this is taking place after Charlie's death. William is drunk, so he is turned away from the bar (also hence the speeding, yelling, and short temper). I am theorizing that Cassidy is the victim before Charlie.

I was gonna say maybe the reason William isn’t purple is because he is not in his night guard suit, but I remembered that when he killed Charlie, he was purple, and this Minigame takes place after her death. So that can’t work either

I also think Cassidy is a boy (main reason why is because of the movie and the one you should not have killed) but I am fine with what anyone believes

Were/was

I think Duo Process Theory is correct. Cassidy is the CC and Michael is the VS. which would undo this theory or at least alter it.

Old sport?

any new video mate being cooked?

This is all debunked by the Old Man Consequences ending

Cassidy is not the vengefull spirit lololololol

Tbh, I’m sticking with the theory that’s it Fredbear/Golden Freddy (if you don’t believe those two animatronics are the same your gay) and that Michael broke out of his window and just saw the animatronic sitting there, since the phrase “it’s me” is being repeated to someone who is not William, and is a young adult so I say it’s Michael.

Mustard man and William have the same colored text. Both in the FNaF 4 mini games, and in Susie’s mini game.

I think that if we realy are playing as Michael then the vengeful spirit might be the bite victim

cassidy IS a boy

For everyone defending the “orange guy is Afton theory”: there is basically no evidence in support of it. Anything applied to it as evidence is a stretch. There is far more to suggest it depicts the family of an MCI victim. Note the line “he’s gonna be sorry when he gets back.” This line is clearly foreshadowing to suggest that the child doesn’t return, suggesting that they leave to their death, lured to Freddy’s (or kidnapped) by William. I would also like to suggest that we don’t technically know that Charlie comes first. Yes Henry says “a wound first inflicted on me” but withered Chica also says “I was the first - I have seen everything.” Not “everything after Charlie”, but “everything.” Give Gifts, Give Life possibly suggests that Charlie came first, but it certainly doesn’t confirm it, especially considering there’s recent evidence that Charlie actually came LAST.

I believe that "The one you shouldn't have killed" is Andrew and that the he him pronouns are referring to Andrew also. But I aldo believe that "the vengeful spirit" is Cassidy so I don't think "the one you shouldn't have killed" and "the vengeful spirit" are the same person. The Vengeful Spirit couldn't be Andrew tho since his voice and everything is described as rough and ordering wich wouldn't make any sense if he was tge vengeful spirit.

Cassidy's gender is revenge

Doesn't the game files call the person in the chain a "man" in the sprite name? Is that's true, then it means it cant be ms. afton.

I personally believe Cassidy is a boy in the cannon. As of now there’s just so much evidence I can write a whole list about it.

Last time i checked i was a girl.

No evidence except he drives the same purple car, those aren’t common

There's a big problem with dream Theory That being Scott was already thinking about the color pallet of Sister Location during the making of FNaF 2. Dream Theory was never canon.

Your comment on Mrs. Afton and the custody case gave a me an idea too; It could be possible that at some point, Mrs. Afton decides "Nope, I'm just gonna leave William" maybe due to the MCI or some other factor, and William wins the custody battle, which explains why there is no mother around to be with Elizabeth. Just a hypothesis.

I’m pretty sure Cassidy is female but the reason why their referring to Cassidy as a boy is because Cassidy possess a male animatronic Edit: Guys if I made a comment months ago and I don’t reply it’s probably cus I realized I was wrong and want to forget about the comment. Stop replying pls :) <3

All I know is that she killed Phone Guy in FNaF 1

I think that vanessa does not equal elizabeth. In the immortal and the restless, clara is vlads mistress, not his wife. What if vanessa is an affair baby?

And the movie

purple car in Charlotte death Mini Game... and a purple car in midnight motorist? have you ever seen a purple car in fnaf any other times?

Yeah, no, sorry, but I disagree. That is William. There is too much evidence to prove that William than there is proving that he is not.

Cassidy is girl she possess golden freddy is not vengeful spirit Andrew is vengeful spirit not golden freddy

I think it's incredible there's even a debate around this. 😂 There's no evidence this has anything to do with the Aftons that doesn't come with a huge "BUT!", and everyone's suddenly willing to accept that the Purple Guy is not purple. It's about William taking one of his victims, not that complicated.

nah cassidy's pronouns is ITS/ME

(*Wow they're just like me)

It's JR's not Jr's

I'm just gonna use she/him this crap is confusing

SOME people are saying that we play as jeremy fritzland and some think he locked Charlie/Charlotte out do you belive this therory?

I just realized that the FNAF1 newspaper easter egg about the MCI,one of the newspaper mention 2 children getting lured at night " TWO local children were reportedly lured into a backroom during the late hours of operation at freddy fazbear pizza on the NIGHT of June 26th" Suzie was Lured by Afton(Scott showing this even in fruity maze) this kid from midnight motorist its also lured by Afton.I think Scott wanted to show that these 2 kids were that special so he made 2 minigames to show how this happened

Cassidy isnt the Vengeful Spirit in UCN, its Andrew. I know it sucks but gotta role with the punches

Male, Female, they’re dead who cares!

1. if Scott had shown the orange guy as purple, this minigame wouldn't be so controversial. Scott probably confuses people, and in order not to reveal all his cards so easily, he made it orange. if it were purple it wouldn't make any sense at all. there would be no riddle, no meaning to this minigame 2. Crying child escapes through the window, and Michael sits in a chair. 3. Elizabeth is already dead. This could explain that very mound; it could be her grave. William loved his daughter Elizabeth. and Mrs. Afton is a really unimportant character. There’s no point in even showing her, even in the Fnaf 4 minigames there is no hint of Mrs. Afton, which may hint that she has already left the family. 4. I don’t think this is a babysitter 5. This animatronic is Shadow Freddy. Shadow Freddy also has 3 toes, and Crying child by the time of Midnight Motorist could well have highlighted the agony that became Shadow Freddy. On Crying child, William had already conducted experiments with the participation of nightmarish animatronics (as he did with Rory). And moreover, we see that William is a rather rude person, he could treat his children poorly, which could also help create agony. it even explains what Crying child could see (Plushbear's phrase). he could see Shadow Freddy and be very scared of it. 6. We don’t even know if the window in this room opened. it could very well be a window that doesn't open, given the fact that the Aftons were poor. Henry cut off business with William, and they may have become even poorer. especially considering their small house in the middle of the woods 7. Scott could well have missed the fact that there should be glass left there. He could simply not pay attention to this detail. Moreover, we see that the glass is gray, its color could merge with the color of the earth beneath it and be invisible 8. The child went to the pizzeria. He could run to Fredbear and Friends, or Juniors. does not matter. This restaurant could very well be Fredbear and Friends, considering that the classic animatronics (Freddy, Bonnie, Chica and Foxy) perform there. and Crying child also had toys of these four animatronics, so he obviously loved them and even more so called them his “friends.” 9. The mound is dedicated to Elizabeth. this is quite possible. considering that William loved his daughter more than anyone else

So in your theory, we’re playing as Cassidy’s dad which he’s in a drunken rage considering he’s speeding and on the highway driving on the opposite side of the highway. He’s not allowed in the bar because he was drinking too much alcohol who has the same color as the purple guy car, mind you the only person depicted with a purple car who coincidentally is in the same condition as the security puppet mini game and is tilted in the game files as "later that night".

So, there's a person in a chair, that because of them not saying anything just...didn't hear a huge window break? Are they even alive?

I think you’re the one who misunderstood the narrative

As Cassidy I can confirm, that I am a female like given in the survival logbook.

That's my theory

We're playing at 1 of charlie's bullies