The Institute of Art and Ideas
The Institute of Art and Ideas
  • 1 159
  • 36 314 390
Can we really make progress? | John Mearsheimer and Steven Pinker clash
Professor of political science, John Mearsheimer, and professor of psychology, Steven Pinker go head to head on the betterment of humanity since The Englightenment. Which ideals are the best to guide human flourishing?
Watch the full debate at iai.tv/video/the-enlightenment-and-its-alternatives-steven-pinker-john-mearsheimer?CZcams&
The Enlightenment advocated reason, science, democracy, and universal human rights as a grounding for human morality and social organization. In the quarter millennium since, to what extent have these ideals been realized? Has the Enlightenment in fact been successful in bringing about moral progress? Are there viable alternatives to the Enlightenment vision?
#TheEnlightenment #CanWeMakeProgress #HumanFlourishing
John Mearsheimer is the R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Professor of Political Science at the University of Chicago and is considered to be one of the most influential international relations theorists of his generation. He is the author of How States Think: The Rationality of Foreign Policy and The Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities.
Steven Pinker is the Johnstone Family Professor of Psychology at Harvard University and one of the most prominent public intellectuals of our time. He has been named as one of Time magazine’s “100 Most Influential People in the World Today.” Pinker is the author of Rationality: What It Is, Why It Seems Scarce, Why It Matters and Enlightenment Now: The Case for Reason, Science, Humanism, and Progress.
The Institute of Art and Ideas features videos and articles from cutting edge thinkers discussing the ideas that are shaping the world, from metaphysics to string theory, technology to democracy, aesthetics to genetics. Subscribe today! iai.tv/subscribe?CZcams&
For debates and talks: iai.tv
For articles: iai.tv/articles
For courses: iai.tv/iai-academy/courses
zhlédnutí: 831

Video

Embracing solidarity in a secular age | Rowan Williams full interview
zhlédnutí 1,4KPřed 4 hodinami
Former Archbishop Rowan Williams discusses his life and work. What is the role of the church today? Watch Rowan Williams debate good and evil with Slavoj Žižek at iai.tv/video/the-end-of-good-and-evil?CZcams& Join Rowan Williams for an in-depth interview where he discusses everything from ritual, climate change, and moral responsibility. #archbishop #church #christianity Rowan Williams, the 104...
The human bias hidden within scientific practises | Neil Turok, Lisa Randall, Martin Cohen
zhlédnutí 11KPřed 12 hodinami
Neil Turok, Lisa Randall, Martin Cohen discuss the centre of the universe and topics from philosophy of science. Is our approach to studying the universe inherently biased? Watch the full debate at iai.tv/video/the-centre-of-the-universe?CZcams& We see Copernicus as a providing a key moment in history where we moved on from seeing ourselves at the centre of the universe. But our scientific acco...
Spacetime is doomed | Donald Hoffman on why perception is a fantasy #science #spacetime
zhlédnutí 16KPřed 16 hodinami
Donald Hoffman explains why there are intrinsic limits to human perception and consciousness. Is anything we perceive so-called 'reality'? Watch the full talk at iai.tv/video/perception-as-a-fantasy-donald-hoffman?CZcams& Join us as world-leading cognitive scientist Donald Hoffman discusses his cutting-edge research about consciousness and perception, as well as its astonishing implications for...
The Life and Philosophy of Alastair Campbell | Interview
zhlédnutí 1,3KPřed 21 hodinou
Alastair Campbell ruminates on Labour, Brexit, and the death of political culture. But does he ever want to go back to the beating heart of government? Watch the full interview at iai.tv/video/the-life-and-philosophy-of-alastair-campbell?CZcams& Alastair Campbell came to public prominence as Tony Blair's Director of Communications. Seen by friends and critics as hugely influential, he was a suc...
Can physics ever get to the truth? | Eric Weinstein & Hilary Lawson clash over the nature of reality
zhlédnutí 13KPřed dnem
Philosopher Hilary Lawson goes head to head with mathematical physicist Eric Weinstein over the nature of reality. Is metaphysics still relevant? This excerpt was taken from the debate 'The matrix, myths and metaphysics,' which took place at the HowTheLightGetsIn festival in Hay-on-Wye, Wales in May of 2023. Watch the full debate at iai.tv/video/the-matrix-myths-and-metaphysics?CZcams& Not so l...
We need capitalism to save the planet | Rebecca Henderson on the reasons why #capitalism
zhlédnutí 2,1KPřed 14 dny
Rebecca Henderson argues that the reason why capitalism and climate change are so interlinked is that we need the former to save us from the latter. Could reformed capitalism be our only hope? Watch the full debate at iai.tv/video/capitalism-and-the-climate?CZcams& With the world's largest corporations responsible for 71% of global greenhouse gas emissions, many, particularly on the left, have ...
Fascist Passions | Judith Butler responds to questions
zhlédnutí 2,7KPřed 14 dny
Fascist Passions | Judith Butler responds to questions
On scientists and their demons | Jimena Canales [Full Interview]
zhlédnutí 3,8KPřed 14 dny
On scientists and their demons | Jimena Canales [Full Interview]
New Perspectives: Challenging philosophical trends | Penrose, Žižek, Singer, Noble, and many more!
zhlédnutí 13KPřed 21 dnem
New Perspectives: Challenging philosophical trends | Penrose, Žižek, Singer, Noble, and many more!
Daniel Dennett: Arc of Life | Full interview
zhlédnutí 4,7KPřed 21 dnem
Daniel Dennett: Arc of Life | Full interview
Things that are self-refuting are false | Tim Maudlin and Michael Della Rocca battle over reality
zhlédnutí 4,1KPřed 21 dnem
Things that are self-refuting are false | Tim Maudlin and Michael Della Rocca battle over reality
The quantum age | Curt Jaimungal interviews Michio Kaku
zhlédnutí 14KPřed 28 dny
The quantum age | Curt Jaimungal interviews Michio Kaku
What is progress? | Rory Sutherland, Angus Deaton, Arlie Hochschild | The tears of the West
zhlédnutí 1,6KPřed měsícem
What is progress? | Rory Sutherland, Angus Deaton, Arlie Hochschild | The tears of the West
Scientists disagree on the origin of #life | Addy Pross, Chrisantha Fernando, Kate Adamala
zhlédnutí 14KPřed měsícem
Scientists disagree on the origin of #life | Addy Pross, Chrisantha Fernando, Kate Adamala
Physics at the limits of reality | Sabine Hossenfelder in conversation with Hilary Lawson | In full
zhlédnutí 109KPřed měsícem
Physics at the limits of reality | Sabine Hossenfelder in conversation with Hilary Lawson | In full
Searching for sanity in a chaotic world | Ruby Wax in conversation with Myriam François
zhlédnutí 1,8KPřed měsícem
Searching for sanity in a chaotic world | Ruby Wax in conversation with Myriam François
Consciousness and material reality | Avshalom Elitzur | Consciousness and material reality
zhlédnutí 29KPřed měsícem
Consciousness and material reality | Avshalom Elitzur | Consciousness and material reality
Rethinking the future of conservatism | The life and philosophy of Rory Stewart
zhlédnutí 5KPřed měsícem
Rethinking the future of conservatism | The life and philosophy of Rory Stewart
The AI Apocalypse | Leading thinkers Liv Boeree, Michael Wooldridge, Timothy Nguyen
zhlédnutí 2,7KPřed měsícem
The AI Apocalypse | Leading thinkers Liv Boeree, Michael Wooldridge, Timothy Nguyen
How destructive is Big Tech? | Aaron Bastani and Kenneth Cukier go head to head
zhlédnutí 1,5KPřed měsícem
How destructive is Big Tech? | Aaron Bastani and Kenneth Cukier go head to head
How to understand conspiracy theorists | Michael Shermer full interview
zhlédnutí 2,4KPřed měsícem
How to understand conspiracy theorists | Michael Shermer full interview
Why you can't buy a house | Kristen Ghodsee, Anna Minton, Liam Halligan, Tom Copley
zhlédnutí 1,6KPřed měsícem
Why you can't buy a house | Kristen Ghodsee, Anna Minton, Liam Halligan, Tom Copley
The future of physics | Suchitra Sebastian, Dominic Walliman
zhlédnutí 7KPřed měsícem
The future of physics | Suchitra Sebastian, Dominic Walliman
Best of Slavoj Žižek | On cynicism, pleasure, philosophy, and more
zhlédnutí 40KPřed měsícem
Best of Slavoj Žižek | On cynicism, pleasure, philosophy, and more
IN FULL Yanis Varoufakis welcomes us to the age of Technofeudalism | Full interview
zhlédnutí 109KPřed měsícem
IN FULL Yanis Varoufakis welcomes us to the age of Technofeudalism | Full interview
Is bias intrinsic to how we percieve the world? | Daniel Kahneman battles Ellen Langer
zhlédnutí 2KPřed 2 měsíci
Is bias intrinsic to how we percieve the world? | Daniel Kahneman battles Ellen Langer
The unselfish gene | Denis Noble challenges Richard Dawkins
zhlédnutí 173KPřed 2 měsíci
The unselfish gene | Denis Noble challenges Richard Dawkins
Redrawing the global order | Bill Browder, Yuan Yang, Sergei Guriev
zhlédnutí 3,3KPřed 2 měsíci
Redrawing the global order | Bill Browder, Yuan Yang, Sergei Guriev
Roger Penrose on quantum mechanics and consciousness | Full interview
zhlédnutí 465KPřed 2 měsíci
Roger Penrose on quantum mechanics and consciousness | Full interview

Komentáře

  • @ahartify
    @ahartify Před 7 vteřinami

    A couple of intellectual scoundrels having a 'debate?' Mearsheimer, promoter of Russian barbarism and all things Putin!

  • @Anton_Sh.
    @Anton_Sh. Před 10 minutami

    Pseudo intellectual

  • @randywaldron2715
    @randywaldron2715 Před 18 minutami

    Evil, true evil, is something specific. Humans are only capable of true evil when their fear of life, which is characterized by chance, uncertainty, loss, spontaneity, etc, becomes so overwhelming that they become necrophiles and turn from life to embrace death. Good and evil are words defining the conflict between biophilla and necrophillia.

  • @geraldschepens7437
    @geraldschepens7437 Před 23 minutami

    A German, a Swede and a Brit Sat around, talkin bout 💩 Philosophies grand Which no one understands At least I do not - not a bit!

  • @thomashuston9180
    @thomashuston9180 Před 40 minutami

    What a wonderfully descriptive word! 🤓

  • @Archeidos-Arcana
    @Archeidos-Arcana Před 40 minutami

    Pinker once again demonstrating he's largely disconnected from reality and the bigger picture, abstracting things away from phenomenality again. Yes, nearly everyone agrees on the outward appearance of what a better world looks like, but what people have drastic disagreements on is HOW you get there, what they should value, and HOW those values should be prioritized.

  • @dadsonworldwide3238
    @dadsonworldwide3238 Před 49 minutami

    Computational plow is to academics as to what Jethro tulls plow was to farming on human labor

  • @UnfadeabLe11
    @UnfadeabLe11 Před 51 minutou

    Lol ❤

  • @jordanfalkowski6924
    @jordanfalkowski6924 Před 52 minutami

    I try to think about that myself. For example i have noticed how a section of floor is 12" tiles like at the entrance. I probably at 165lb, while my brother over 300lb. So ive noticed how some grout was chipping and devoloped cracks. I guess im not sure if a gentle step is effective because of the damage over the years.

  • @bestcongressmoneycanbuy9704
    @bestcongressmoneycanbuy9704 Před 55 minutami

    Aaron is spot on about state funded "smart-tech" that goes into iPhones. Look up Mariana Mazzucato's presentations about the iPhone.

  • @katiemiaana
    @katiemiaana Před 57 minutami

    When you look at what happened to Rushdie and the Orthodox bishop in Australia both men seem to be right, facts don't care about your feelings, but feelings don't care about your facts

  • @krsp420
    @krsp420 Před hodinou

    Who here after they proved microtubules are quantum?

  • @johnshanley83
    @johnshanley83 Před hodinou

    Constraining capitalism is an oxymoron. 3 letters more than the speaker

  • @TrackinDaMeta
    @TrackinDaMeta Před hodinou

    Well if you can change small things in the past, multiple small changes could not be called small

  • @TrackinDaMeta
    @TrackinDaMeta Před 2 hodinami

    Matter bends space. This bent space is gravity. Matter follows these geodesics because it is the shortest path.

  • @TrackinDaMeta
    @TrackinDaMeta Před 2 hodinami

    First answer was terrible. That is what we call a stupid mans version of a smart man.

  • @fronabulax63
    @fronabulax63 Před 3 hodinami

    Mankind progresses in destroying the planet.

  • @crescentsi
    @crescentsi Před 3 hodinami

    Which layer of truth do you prefer?

  • @p_campbell
    @p_campbell Před 3 hodinami

    Back in the '80s in the sand dunes of California people chased jackrabbits with dunebuggies .

  • @veromescla4445
    @veromescla4445 Před 3 hodinami

    It means psychoanalyses theories are bullshit!

  • @DaboooogA
    @DaboooogA Před 3 hodinami

    Great discussion thanks - 'whole lot we don't know' vs 'whole lot we do know'.

  • @johndevine6687
    @johndevine6687 Před 3 hodinami

    Don’t believe it exists

  • @alanjones5639
    @alanjones5639 Před 3 hodinami

    “Embedded in liberalism is the belief in progress, the belief that it is possible to make the world a better place. Realism says that you can’t do that. International politics is a tragedy - it always has been, it is today, and it always will be. Those who believe that you can escape the iron cage, and transcend this Hobbesian world, are delusional. My argument disturbs liberals greatly.” John Mearsheimer speaking to Gavin Jacobson. From "The tragedy of John Mearsheimer: How the American realist became the world’s most hated thinker" - The New Statesman, Ideas, 27 September 2023 Mearsheimer's assumption that states act as rational thinkers and his reckless theorizing that the US and NATO caused Putin to order the invasion of Ukraine led Anne Applebaum to accuse Mearsheimer of being Putin’s useful idiot. Ideological thinkers will seemingly prefer theory, "first principles" and indefeasible assumptions to any encouragement, any efforts made for better solutions.

  • @jamesbluelightning358
    @jamesbluelightning358 Před 4 hodinami

    There are only theories...capitalism and socialism so if there is one and not the other then it is pretty obvious which one we are engaged in

  • @apabritobhattacharyya4292
    @apabritobhattacharyya4292 Před 4 hodinami

    please do not invite Michio Kaku again!

  • @jumakhanrahyab6666
    @jumakhanrahyab6666 Před 4 hodinami

    China lifted more people out of poverty than all liberal countries combined, without necessarily subscribing to liberal values. How come a country performing better across all indicators of “human flourishing” you mentioned is not “enlightened” and is not employing “reason”! A suggestion, maybe better off getting over with your “euro-centric” world view. 🤔 Just a thought.

  • @mk91-vz1oj
    @mk91-vz1oj Před 5 hodinami

    J. M. gets it, its one thing for countries to agree one something, its quite another to undermine your own interests to implement things on a bilateral basis

  • @IzitAllGoUnder
    @IzitAllGoUnder Před 5 hodinami

    Mearsheimer is an admitted realist not an idealist. He weighs his statements in light of what has and is going on and is being promoted at the controlling power levels of society. Hard to be optimistic when dealing with what the US and the west has been involved in this entire century and since the fall of the Soviet Union. Sad to say that a more optimistic future appears to be surfacing from the east and south with the BRICS win-win approach to international relationships.

  • @laninqko815
    @laninqko815 Před 5 hodinami

    I am grateful by Yanis appearance on the intellectual map. He is taking the guts to speak his mind out, consideration free of political self-censorship. My respect !

  • @pcbacklash_3261
    @pcbacklash_3261 Před 5 hodinami

    I don't know this Mearsheimer fellow, but in less than four minutes I was already getting annoyed by his deflection of Steven's challenge of his "morality" comments. The phenomena Steven mentioned (i.e. clean water, care for children, etc.) ARE moral issues, because they're based upon care and concern for others!

  • @hoohoohooboo
    @hoohoohooboo Před 5 hodinami

    I ❤ ILIUSHN

  • @user-nb3mq3cg8k
    @user-nb3mq3cg8k Před 5 hodinami

    Kurt Godel already confront strong emphasis in mathematical formalism and axiomazation during his time. And also proved that science has also limits. So it is definitely worth for open discussions on if everything that scientists proposed going to be as rigid as science supposed to be.

  • @glenncurry3041
    @glenncurry3041 Před 5 hodinami

    John Mearsheimer: "Stop bring up facts that expose my underlying lack of a positive notion of society".

  • @mdviz1
    @mdviz1 Před 5 hodinami

    the rest of this is behind a paywall

  • @markwrede8878
    @markwrede8878 Před 5 hodinami

    Socialism or barbarism.

    • @t.j.payeur5331
      @t.j.payeur5331 Před 5 hodinami

      What?! They're both terrible.

    • @glenncurry3041
      @glenncurry3041 Před 5 hodinami

      @@t.j.payeur5331 How horrible a society where people contribute based on their ability and receive to based on their needs!

    • @markwrede8878
      @markwrede8878 Před 4 hodinami

      @@t.j.payeur5331 Political parties are terrible and no one can come to grips with the matter because private ownership prevents it.

    • @brianthomassen2209
      @brianthomassen2209 Před 2 hodinami

      @@glenncurry3041 Who decides what ones ability contribution, and what the needs are? The model itself moves to a centralization of power. The 150 million odd deaths for the various strands of socialist models from 1917 forward speak directly to the horror. In Cambodia's case, some 25% of the population was killed for the utopian ideal.

    • @brianthomassen2209
      @brianthomassen2209 Před 2 hodinami

      @@markwrede8878 Private ownership is fundamental to the concepts of the social contract and the roots of the political Enlightenment that undergird civil rights law. Its erasure is where the blood letting begins in service of the collective.

  • @Zemphyrrian
    @Zemphyrrian Před 5 hodinami

    Just think of both particles as of one particle. You can't do it in diagrams but it helps things to start making sense.

  • @DrakeDietrick
    @DrakeDietrick Před 5 hodinami

    Now God is gonna pull his pants down and give him a spanking.

  • @spaceorbison
    @spaceorbison Před 6 hodinami

    You're not gonna catch anything but fire buddy. Why is his mouth so disgusting...

  • @jirizary73
    @jirizary73 Před 6 hodinami

    Sounds like how the whole world works to me.

  • @mrsullied
    @mrsullied Před 6 hodinami

    I'm a simple man. When I see Kaku, I skip.

  • @ALIhassan-rv4cr
    @ALIhassan-rv4cr Před 6 hodinami

    Too proud to deny the current bounds of his own knowledge, what he cannot comprehend he calls undefined.

  • @matt6250
    @matt6250 Před 6 hodinami

    If relativity never emerged we wouldn’t have spent the last 100 years studying the physics of science fiction and realized space is electric.

  • @ALIhassan-rv4cr
    @ALIhassan-rv4cr Před 6 hodinami

    Thats the stupidest and most incoherent thing i have ever heard

  • @SeumChhay-je7fv
    @SeumChhay-je7fv Před 7 hodinami

    Tax cut, interest rate from Fed ❤

  • @SinderellaScapegoat
    @SinderellaScapegoat Před 8 hodinami

    His tongue tasted the wrong vaginal sushi 🍣

  • @straightedgerc
    @straightedgerc Před 8 hodinami

    The flow of electricity within a person is measurable science. Let a person stand up and say, "my conscious choice to stand up and speak is not measurable science". They are therefore incorrect.

  • @maxbarker356
    @maxbarker356 Před 8 hodinami

    “Socialism in general has a record of failure so blatant that only an intellectual could ignore or evade it.” Thomas Sowell

    • @Philip5478
      @Philip5478 Před 4 hodinami

      She refers go Social Democracies. The have been implemented and successful in Europe for a very long time.

  • @immagina239
    @immagina239 Před 8 hodinami

    In a world of idiots, this man is seen as the most intelligent philosopher on the planet.

  • @oak_meadow9533
    @oak_meadow9533 Před 8 hodinami

    This man is making you numb and open by feeding nothing. Poor Prof kaku

  • @9114steve
    @9114steve Před 9 hodinami

    "something, but not information" - these people still worship Einstein, and they refuse to believe what is in front of their eyes, just because einstein said something doesn't mean its immutable.. there is no reason that information must only be transmitted by light, just because you don't know what it is, it doesn't mean its what you think its not - if you know what I mean.