Craftsdwarf
Craftsdwarf
  • 151
  • 4 475 572
Adaptations, Watch Orders, and Finding the Best Experience
More of a rumination on some topics I've been considering for a while: what good are 'inferior' versions of the media or ways to go through it?
Thumbnail made by MG: www.youtube.com/@LiterallyJustMG
Addendum: Literally yesterday the JoBros scan group uploaded a release of Phantom Blood that changes the names of the Viz release, and they're planning to do more: nyaa.si/view/1853015
Regarding Monogatari’s Watch Order, while poking around I did find this explanation of some issues that could arise when watching it in release order (spoilers of course). But I also want to point out that the currently ongoing Monster & Off Season is not going in LN order either! The title cards do specify ‘Broadcast Order’, which implies Shaft might put the BDs out in LN order like they did Seacond Season but that remains to be seen. And obviously it’s not finished and I haven’t read the source material so I have no personal comment, which is why I didn’t say much on that front to begin with.
docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1Wm8Lstrjeqi8L6HaqomSWatXFO_gItlD58dV41iHcVs/mobilebasic
Abandoned Blockbuster Footage czcams.com/video/QJOTBUivFPU/video.html
Batman Production Order: dcanimated.com/WF/batman/btas/guides/01.php
Batman Airdate Order: dcanimated.com/btas/batman-the-animated-series-episodes/?embed=true
Modded Skyrim Opening: czcams.com/video/hBreUJ7X-Os/video.html
Asylum Demon Mod: www.nexusmods.com/darksouls/mods/1143?tab=description
Used Music:
Zodiac - Persona 2 Innocent Sin OST
Masaru’s Daily Life - Karakuri Circus OST
City in France - Karakuri Circus OST
Cheerful Journey - Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure Stardust Crusaders (World) OST
Prayer and Immolation - Made in Abyss Dawn of the Deep Soul OST
Sad Lala - Star Twinkle Precure OST
Suck your Blood:[nZk] ver. -INST- - Kill La Kill OST
Disguise - Spy x Family OST
Blind Alley - Persona 3 FES OST
In Case of Trouble - Bastion OST
Text Version: pastebin.com/Shq20222
Side Channel: www.youtube.com/@dorfsdarkden7073/videos
Patreon: www.patreon.com/craftsdwarf
Twitter: Craftsdwarf
MAL: myanimelist.net/profile/Craftsdwarf
zhlédnutí: 1 490

Video

The BEST Joe References
zhlédnutí 1,2KPřed 2 měsíci
I may be far from comprehensive, but hopefully I’m able to share some interesting notes as I explore the favorite times I’ve seen a reference to the iconic Ashita no Joe! And if there’s a cool one I missed or haven't seen, feel free to share! Non explicitly mentioned series in order of appearance: Montage - Ginatama, Kaguya-sama Wants to Be Confessed To, Himitsu no Akko-chan 3, Boruto: Naruto N...
Danganronpa: An Ultimate Analysis
zhlédnutí 1,8KPřed 3 měsíci
Danganronpa: An Ultimate Analysis
Aikatsu is Love
zhlédnutí 1KPřed 4 měsíci
Aikatsu is Love
Of Dreams and Fate - A Speculative Blackbeard Analysis
zhlédnutí 10KPřed 9 měsíci
Of Dreams and Fate - A Speculative Blackbeard Analysis
Sabaody, Egghead, and the 3 Act Structure in One Piece
zhlédnutí 6KPřed 10 měsíci
Sabaody, Egghead, and the 3 Act Structure in One Piece
Wano: An Analysis in Three Acts
zhlédnutí 16KPřed 10 měsíci
Wano: An Analysis in Three Acts
Netflix One Piece is Different (And I Like It!)
zhlédnutí 7KPřed 11 měsíci
Netflix One Piece is Different (And I Like It!)
Delving into Dragon Ball's Villains
zhlédnutí 153KPřed rokem
Delving into Dragon Ball's Villains
Is Kill la Kill a Magical Girl Series? (Not Really, But We'll Entertain the Thought)
zhlédnutí 7KPřed 2 lety
Is Kill la Kill a Magical Girl Series? (Not Really, But We'll Entertain the Thought)
Iceborne, Colonialism, and Bad Faith Journalism
zhlédnutí 6KPřed 2 lety
Iceborne, Colonialism, and Bad Faith Journalism
The Fated Losers of Naruto
zhlédnutí 25KPřed 3 lety
The Fated Losers of Naruto
The Importance of Talk no Jutsu
zhlédnutí 31KPřed 3 lety
The Importance of Talk no Jutsu
The Gridman Problem
zhlédnutí 12KPřed 3 lety
The Gridman Problem
The Evil Justice of Akudama Drive
zhlédnutí 9KPřed 3 lety
The Evil Justice of Akudama Drive
I'm Glad It's Over | Part 4 of The Overly Long Tirade on the Overly Long Tirade
zhlédnutí 10KPřed 3 lety
I'm Glad It's Over | Part 4 of The Overly Long Tirade on the Overly Long Tirade
Love and War of Underworld
zhlédnutí 3,1KPřed 3 lety
Love and War of Underworld
Shounen Isn't For Me
zhlédnutí 17KPřed 3 lety
Shounen Isn't For Me
"I Didn't Get Anything Wrong Really" | Part 3 of The Overly Long Tirade on the Overly Long Tirade
zhlédnutí 11KPřed 3 lety
"I Didn't Get Anything Wrong Really" | Part 3 of The Overly Long Tirade on the Overly Long Tirade
The Nightmare of Losing Everything - Shadows Over Brook and Thriller Bark
zhlédnutí 17KPřed 3 lety
The Nightmare of Losing Everything - Shadows Over Brook and Thriller Bark
Time Paradox Ghostwriter is About PLAGIARISM!??!
zhlédnutí 4,9KPřed 3 lety
Time Paradox Ghostwriter is About PLAGIARISM!??!
Ordinal Scale - From Requiem and Remembrance
zhlédnutí 2,3KPřed 3 lety
Ordinal Scale - From Requiem and Remembrance
Franky, Iceburg, and a Creator's Responsibility
zhlédnutí 11KPřed 3 lety
Franky, Iceburg, and a Creator's Responsibility
Regarding Fairy Tail's Magic and Ladies | Part 2 of The Overly Long Tirade on the Overly Long Tirade
zhlédnutí 12KPřed 3 lety
Regarding Fairy Tail's Magic and Ladies | Part 2 of The Overly Long Tirade on the Overly Long Tirade
Greed is Good (?)
zhlédnutí 9KPřed 3 lety
Greed is Good (?)
"I Want to Live!" - My Favorite Moment in Fiction
zhlédnutí 11KPřed 3 lety
"I Want to Live!" - My Favorite Moment in Fiction
Fishman Island Analysis - The Path to the Sun
zhlédnutí 16KPřed 3 lety
Fishman Island Analysis - The Path to the Sun
Overcoming 'Power' - A Phantom Bullet Video
zhlédnutí 3,5KPřed 3 lety
Overcoming 'Power' - A Phantom Bullet Video
Alfheim and Aincrad - Systems and Reality in the Virtual
zhlédnutí 4,6KPřed 3 lety
Alfheim and Aincrad - Systems and Reality in the Virtual
Rukia, Renji, and Finding Courage
zhlédnutí 16KPřed 3 lety
Rukia, Renji, and Finding Courage

Komentáře

  • @foxzyx
    @foxzyx Před dnem

    This video enlightened me. Before I was unable to see certain themes and aspects of C;C. I took it to much at face value. But after watching this video I feel like I was able to see the truth of C;C

  • @palemeadows
    @palemeadows Před dnem

    please get dudebros out of one piece, they cant read or understand what a theme is. wano is so good

  • @DragonTamerCos
    @DragonTamerCos Před 2 dny

    I enjoyed the video until you got to the part about fate. I didn't enjoy it because, you didn't seem well read in the philosophical concept in which you are dealing with. When discussing the reactions of people from different cultures of fate in media, you shouldn't only pull up media which feature it, but the philosophical structures which in form the societies which we exist in now. Determinism vs Free Will, and, if you wanna talk about the bourgeois christian conceptions and reactions to it, you would need to talk about the historical arguments Christian theologians have had about fate and determinism, and, its roots in Plato. You would then need to talk about eastern conceptions of fate: Shintoism and Daoism specifically. And, you would need to finally talk about the modern scientific and philosophical debates around fate. Of Nature vs Nurture,. of humans born of our material conditions, unaccountable for our actions, as people who are rational actors, or not, and, the nature of the Gheist. The will of history, and the realization of man. I just felt that part of the video was very shallow, but, then again, asking for a wide ranging discussion of philosophy in a One Piece video is quite the tall order. Thank you for making what you made, its good as it is!

  • @deathlydashi
    @deathlydashi Před 6 dny

    10:09 what do you mean skipped?

  • @raf0096
    @raf0096 Před 10 dny

    Hi, has your Discord account been hacked? Just making sure since I got messages from you a day or so ago

  • @sharkanenoa5928
    @sharkanenoa5928 Před 11 dny

    FUCK THE RULES

  • @Jlacker
    @Jlacker Před 12 dny

    Danganronpa 3 would be better if it was a visual novel like it was originally intended to be and if the writers didn't waste their time with V3. Especially if it wasn't filled with retcons.

  • @TimAquila
    @TimAquila Před 15 dny

    Really like this video because I thought that some of these themes also apply to other JRPGs. For example, how you're able to face off against Monsters (representing nature) as a human by learning from experiences (EXP) and using tools. Also the Shinto Ideal of humanity and nature living in harmony by human efforts is very clearly visible in Pokémon (especially Ruby/Sapphire & Black/White)

  • @matt0044
    @matt0044 Před 18 dny

    A lot of comments below claiming along the lines of “your videos vocalized why I disliked Fairy Tail” are missing the point. Craft is going back to his earlier videos where he was early into his analysis days and finds that years of experience expose to him the fallacies, half-truths and flat out misinformation he perpetrated. No one has to agree with him but these videos advocate to be more open minded and to be less Nostalgia Critic-y.

  • @TheFuzzyOcelot
    @TheFuzzyOcelot Před 19 dny

    Fantastic video. As a LuPat enjoyer myself, I tend to notice that the trend is people getting so caught up on what the season *could've* been that they either fail to or refuse to see what's actually there.

  • @gabrielwright-dunn9355

    Yeah. I think the personal experience is more valuable than the consensus one especially with large franchises. At some point, I just end up going "fuck it" and starting somewhere because I really want to get into it, I will get into it. Even a sub-optimal experience is still an experience and can still be worth having.

  • @matt0044
    @matt0044 Před 23 dny

    I personally try to take risks. I've recently gotten into Sonic's IDW run despite having not played the games in a good while. I was able to catch onto how it takes place after Sonic Forces and is a story about a post war planet trying to recover in the face of Eggman's lingering prescene. Hell, I got into the comic run after picking up the "Tangle & Whisper" trade. Appealing character designs, a buddy-cop sort of story of the reckless hyper one helping the sullen veteran with their old demons, just... Whisper The Wolf in general. That sold me on the self-contained narrative and led me to the wider series.

  • @Jametsbond
    @Jametsbond Před 25 dny

    Luffy telling vivi people die because vivi are so naive for wanting no casuality at all while Luffy broke so hard when Ace die because he knows exactly how many casuality for saving Ace. from "sacrificing" Bon Chan, letting criminals go, Luffy know all the consequences and still choose to save Ace, the only thing that he want are saving Ace and he failed. as goofy as Luffy is he never naive, he know exactly what he want and what the consequences of his action

  • @xxxtimeghostxxx
    @xxxtimeghostxxx Před 25 dny

    "admiration is the furthest thing from understanding" - sosuke aizen

  • @yew2515
    @yew2515 Před 29 dny

    I think that alot of people forget that the celestial spirit's magic power is the summoners power. Lucy supplies her spirits with magic power to both fight and for them to pass through the gate. For example, in the tartoros arc, after she cast urano metria, she didn't have enough power to keep the celestial spirt king there. Pointed out by the king and mard geer. In a way she is sort of like a battery pack for her spirits.

  • @gergelybalint6996
    @gergelybalint6996 Před měsícem

    I really dread having to graduate and having to enter "real" society. Your videos, especially on Danganronpa, have helped me cope with and work on those feelings. Thank you for making videos.

  • @Apeeell
    @Apeeell Před měsícem

    It needs it

  • @attackofthecopyrightbots
    @attackofthecopyrightbots Před měsícem

    dont read the tsukihime manga in place of the game trust me bro, ruined my life

  • @BrokutheSonofSparda
    @BrokutheSonofSparda Před měsícem

    Lucy my forever fav #1 goat 😍😍😍

  • @ngtskynebula
    @ngtskynebula Před měsícem

    My Heartphilia baby 🥺💝

  • @se7enthsoul
    @se7enthsoul Před měsícem

    Does Urashima know Okiku is a..uh... nvm

  • @Yamartim
    @Yamartim Před měsícem

    This ties a lot into a discussion you see often about pixel art in video games, some nerds will tell you that pixel art was made to look good and rounded in CRTs so modern games that use pixel art are actually reproducing a fake nostalgia of a perception of pixel art that wasn't a thing in the 90s But then when you consider that probably most people even back then experienced these games through emulators in pc monitors that's how pixel art was in fact experienced even if it wasn't intended by the authors it's still just as valid

  • @TMitch3105
    @TMitch3105 Před měsícem

    wasnt expecting to see you snorting cereal today but here we are

  • @thatmanjames1647
    @thatmanjames1647 Před měsícem

    I like the stream of consciousness style this video has. It works well for a topic like this where it’s easy to get bogged down in the nuance of any one viewpoint.

    • @craftsdwarf
      @craftsdwarf Před měsícem

      Originally the video was more focused on Karakuri Circus, but as I thought more about the topic it broadened to the point where I had to either go into the exact kind of absurd amounts of consumption this video expresses the fears of having to do, or just do what I did, so I'm glad you enjoyed that method!

  • @korkad_
    @korkad_ Před měsícem

    Sorry but being reminded mid-video that people watch anime on 2x speed just makes me recoil

    • @PennFaulkner
      @PennFaulkner Před 26 dny

      Then you would get along HORRIBLY with my brother.

  • @Ronin11111111
    @Ronin11111111 Před měsícem

    The level of salt in the veins of the author of Gantz and Inuyashiki is unreal.

    • @craftsdwarf
      @craftsdwarf Před měsícem

      He's such a dedicated hater you gotta love it.

  • @RiderNexus
    @RiderNexus Před měsícem

    In late 2020, I randomly decided to watch the anime adaptation of Fate/Apocrypha during COVID lockdown and I was going through a major identity crisis The show was able to get me up to speed with how the Grail War worked and what the rules of the world were without any pre-conceived notions And I was able to follow the story just fine, able to find comfort and solace in its characters during one of the darkest parts of my life Now I'm beginning to get into Fate properly through the FSN visual novel

  • @justsomeguy299
    @justsomeguy299 Před měsícem

    its strange how you might develop very strong feelings on how to approach a media property, but if you think back how you stumbled on to it and still enjoyed it so much. really makes you wonder if it really even matters all that much. also being forced to engage with a piece of media by someone else through a method you wouldnt choose yourself can lead to finding your favourites you wouldnt have otherwise. like how when youre young your mom or grandma or whoever will buy something for you

  • @theiceking1035
    @theiceking1035 Před měsícem

    My primary way of playing games is with my switch, I don’t have PC, only a laptop. However, when I wanted to get Persona 3, I wanted to decide, should I wait until I get a powerful enough PC and get Persona 3 reloaded or get Persona 3 potable on switch? I ended up going with portable, because I felt I am not missing out on a completely different experience and I am experiencing in a way that lot of people have experienced and enjoyed it, they enjoyed the game before reloaded came out, so it's probably a great experience on it's own.

    • @jaidens.g.1920
      @jaidens.g.1920 Před měsícem

      my first ever experience with P3 was playing P3P on my Vita, as I didn't have access to FES and this was years before Reload. I won't deny that P3P is definitely a different experience from the PS2 versions of P3, but it is definitely a valid way to experience the game, if its alternate presentation and mechanics gel with you

  • @yungso1277
    @yungso1277 Před měsícem

    cool

  • @noahfischer3088
    @noahfischer3088 Před měsícem

    Yes.

  • @noobasaurus117
    @noobasaurus117 Před měsícem

    Maybe not 100% in line with what you’re talking about but another thing that complicates this for video games is that gameplay often shifts over time. If you wanted to get into a series like resident evil just bring told to start at the beginning might put you off if you’re uncomfortable with tank controls. But if you start with something like RE4, you may end up disappointed by how different the earlier entries are. Also, your interest in a game can come from just seeing some gameplay of it and thinking it’s interesting and maybe you don’t wanna play multiple other games just to play that one. A lot of games avoid this by not having the narratives of each game actually tie into each other. So if you don’t like turn based combat but you think a certain final fantasy game looks interesting, you have the option to start with those later entries and maybe if you get really into those you might be invested enough in trying out the older ones.

  • @metaj9278
    @metaj9278 Před měsícem

    Glad to see a new video from you!

  • @R7dman
    @R7dman Před měsícem

    I adore how you used the characters themes given by Kubo in this. Awesome touch.

  • @thornray1025
    @thornray1025 Před měsícem

    You reminded my of how much I want to reread Ashita no Joe. (Though not for a while. Currently watching Hajime no Ippo for the first time. Been pretty fun. Always want to lift weights and shadow box while watching it.)

  • @blackcoffeguzzler
    @blackcoffeguzzler Před měsícem

    lol. Neji did due to bad writing. There was no purpose or significance. It's crazy how delusional fans try to rationalize that.

  • @magicvalgirl2309
    @magicvalgirl2309 Před měsícem

    "More content no one asked for" My man... I wanted this for YEARS!

  • @fey2450
    @fey2450 Před měsícem

    The reason "energy" is pronounced like that in Japanese is because it's borrowing the pronunciation from German, lol. It also doesn't exactly mean the same thing it does in English, because wasei-eigo.

  • @tfae
    @tfae Před měsícem

    Great analysis. Your note on magical girl stories having a nurturing, conciliatory tone reminds me a lot of _Steven Universe_. Despite being a boy raised by aliens, Steven very much has the personality of a magical girl who takes after his moms.

  • @notthefbi7015
    @notthefbi7015 Před měsícem

    A lot of people that try to argue that Naruto is lacking seem to want to argue that because not all the problems were solved in the series missed the point. Naruto wasn't going to solve all the problems, but what he will do is help push the world forward to a better future. Madara/Kaguya's defeat wasn't the solution it was the first step towards peace. It was about enduring the pain while seeking a solution.

  • @luispalacios9852
    @luispalacios9852 Před měsícem

    You guys think this game would work well with persona 5/3reload animations?

  • @ComunCoutinho
    @ComunCoutinho Před měsícem

    I missed this one, but just to confirm, Phoenix grade-school flashback hasn't happened yet, right?

  • @kelvinallen9327
    @kelvinallen9327 Před měsícem

    Bleach has so many well written characters. The females are great, the suppoorting characters are all awesome in many ways. 👍

  • @SunGodNika-bi2jr
    @SunGodNika-bi2jr Před měsícem

    🎱🎱🎱 likes

  • @Estianavara
    @Estianavara Před měsícem

    I watched the first ep. of YLIA and i couldn't shake off the fact that i didn't like how much of a pushover the main character is (and this video just explains it and i didn't even get past the first ep.) I'm glad i skipped it and gave MCILAL instead.

  • @talobsta
    @talobsta Před měsícem

    21:33 stg I thought he was gonna say seperate but equal

  • @fey2450
    @fey2450 Před měsícem

    Sad I missed this! I just started replaying the games in Japanese and have a lot to say. Some notes from this VOD, apologies if these have been addressed in the next one: 1. I believe the exact reason for why the first two cases reveal the murderer is because Shu Takumi was inspired by Columbo, and wanted to put emphasis on the the thrill of cornering the culprit rather than figuring out whodunit. Generally speaking (as I'm sure you've noticed) the AA games are far more focused on howdunits than whodunits as a whole, even in the cases where the culprit's identity is kept secret. 2. Redd White isn't actually American in Japanese-his name is Masaru Konaka. Rather, he's a Japanese businessman who *spent* a lot of time in America, so he pretends to speak mostly English, except a lot of the English he uses is intentionally broken and incorrect. He's essentially LARPing as an American business tycoon. That's why in the localization, he uses a lot of made up words in English, like Cogniferous, and uses other high vocabulary wrong. 3. Maya's "burgers" are "ramen" originally. The idea in localization is that ramen is cheap, somewhat unhealthy but tasty treat, and burgers can be considered similar from an American perspective. 4. Shu Takumi actually went to a few trials in order to study up for making the first Ace Attorney, though he ended up thinking they were really boring, which I think is funny. On that note, though, while the courtroom in Ace Attorney is definitely very whacky, it is very much based on the Japanese legal system and acts more as a satire, exaggerating all of its parts for entertainment value and to say something about it.

  • @CropseyManiac1981
    @CropseyManiac1981 Před měsícem

    Among the many great anime I've seen, "Aikatsu!" remains the pinnacle of my entertainment experiences and has left a lasting impression on me. It delivers a healing effect like the Iyashikei sub-genre. An English-friendly Blu-ray release would be great if it ever got licensed in the US.

  • @CureMizukiCrafts
    @CureMizukiCrafts Před měsícem

    Aikatsu is Love wins in english ❤❤❤ I think

  • @tigermafia6251
    @tigermafia6251 Před měsícem

    It’s up to the writer… but if there’s anyone get arroused by that, they need to get their brain check.