BFDI: What If the Squishy Cherries Chose Teardrop Instead of Snowball?

This has always been a moment that never made sense to me. Despite her alliance choosing Teardrop, Pencil chose Snowball, and thus got Teardrop out, putting her in 18th place. But what if Pencil instead elected to bring Teardrop in? Well, we're about to find out
All music belongs to their rightful owners, by the way

[@Battle_of_Inanimate_Objects]

Alternative title: What if the cherries were smart

[@kraniumnol1436]

"maybe she'll win in another season" bawomp

[@NEOFUNNYROCKMAN]

I’m still sad over her elimination

[@silasgrant1105]

@@NEOFUNNYROCKMANthe BFB one or the TPOT one because she wasn’t even supposed to be a contestant in TPOT

[@braydennelson1]

@@silasgrant1105it might be bfdia since that was rigged because of a youtubers audience voting her not knowing what bfdi was

[@Algodoo123]

@@silasgrant1105she got out unfairly every single time she got put Bfdi bfdia bfb and tpot were all rigged

[@F3verMations]

@@Algodoo123not bfb or tpot
Teardrop got 3rd in bfb, so that screwed TD over in Tpot
TD did get out unfairly in bfdi and bfdia

[@jellyandcats]

Wow great video! The amount of effort put into this is insane.

[@yngbro]

I think this makes sense but maybe a little favourited towards teardrop

[@nikodemi.8046]

In every what if ___ or how ___ could win dream island teardrop makes it atleast to points phase and some go to immunity phase
That shows that TD was unlucky in the original

[@XD-yn6hb]

3:32 This could bring a cool friendship between Golf Ball and Teardrop.
I feel really bad for Tennis Ball this time. He keeps getting put up for elimination.

[@kraniumnol1436]

22:42 OBJECTION! Teardrop didn't get her laser finger until bfdia, so this couldn't have happened!

[@mathguy37]

she didn't just get the power

[@Squirtle_Squad_Supremacy]

She just didnt show it off

[@DragonTheOneDZA]

She always had it. It was just first shown in bfdia

[@kraniumnol1436]

To everyone saying that she always had it, keep in mind, it was first shown almost immediately after she was given antipoison, implying that it was one of the side effects that gelatin mentioned

[@Squirtle_Squad_Supremacy]

@@kraniumnol1436 yeah but she didn't seem surprised she can literally shoot lazers out her fingers, she was just like :)

[@Anforkguy]

I like bubble and teardrop both but i do like teardrop more. But you did earn a new subscriber!

[@natalieheadley1287]

bubble always wins these kind of things let someone else win for once

[@NeverButter]

I mean, we’ve gotten other winners since this one

[@MeelinYT]

I was thinking that teardrop going after rocky in bfdi 1A implies TD doesn’t like rocky but they are also a more strategic person then the rest who were on the team

[@algomal5899]

I think that there is an alternate universe where this DID happen.

[@electrowarrior_pvz2]

I made a What if, it was about What if Pencil was eliminated over Firey in BFDIA 8 and Firey Would win 3rd place

[@slyar]

5:00 Canonically Coiny doesn't like Eraser but we don't know since when

[@slyar]

7:30 I'd assume both Firey and Match would go up for elimination, but I doubt that'd change results

[@djiboutiballmappingandanim9318]

what if snowball didnt ever say that ice cube will cool down the tlc

[@subhanlatif70]

It makes sense for them to pick TD bc pencil doesn’t like snowball

[@slyar]

30:16 Considering Rocky got out over Flower in canon, I doubt Rocky is popular enough, especially considering lots of his good episodes in canon he wouldnt compete in here

[@sonnygillie8592]

3:45 cannon event disrupted

[@RepublicOfTrythania]

10:40 And match, is like, out of the game

[@licenseplate3522]

27:48 Spongy voting Leafy because of her arms is kind of dumb when you consider everyone UFE in this What If at the time has arms. I would probably think he would vote David??? I don't know.

[@pabzplayz2330]

Can you do What if BFDI 18 was a viewer vote?

[@jingjingsun8782]

WHY DID SNOWBALL VOTE FOR TEARDROP IN THE FINLISTS I Don’t UNDERSTAND

[@Sammy-km3lb]

05:19 rocky and tb were freinds so hed pick tb (not that it matters)

[@freddy-g98]

32:15 i think teardrop would not be safe because she would evaporate maybe rocky or bubble

[@TristateArea-iv3ih]

Rocky actually helped his team win several times, Bfdi 2 when he sabotaged the alliance, and bfdi 4 when he baked the best cake out of his team.

[@henrystickmingames7760]

Objection rocky said in bfdi 1 that tennis ball is rocks friend so Rocky would pick tennis ball

[@bluyellow9787]

5:15 i know you wanted to have like a moment, but doesnt Rocky see TB as his good old friend?
This i pretty good tho :]

[@kraniumnol1436]

I was gonna say, not only has rocky referred to him directly as a friend, but also picked him first as the team captain of another name

[@MeelinYT]

Rocky would 100% percent pick tennis ball, it is canon that rocky sees him as a friend (it’s not mutual(

[@bobslapbattlesyt]

2:08 what is this song called i love it

[@CorsairAvia]

It’s called Places. Search “BFB ost places” and you’ll find it

[@cooperc69420]

I know this didn't affect anything, but why did Rocky choose Coiny? Tennis Ball's like his best friend.

[@TunaBear64]

27:50 Don't all four have arms? He would vote for Firey because he dislikes fire.

[@adonistaken]

what’s the music name for this?? i’ve been looking all over for it 34:03

[@vectroisded]

We're finally landing - Home

[@tristand7996]

i genuinly think Teaardrop could have won or atleast top 3 if it wasnt for the unfair elimination (i consider unfair elimination that the viewers couldnt decide or that were litterally rigged wich teardrop had 3 of)

[@slyar]

Can't wait for Flower to steal Dream Island

[@AAG_YT]

why tf did you comment like 2763 times in one video

[@slyar]

I commented like 4 times @@AAG_YT

[@cooperc69420]

​That's called an exaggeration.​@@slyar

[@slyar]

Treating 4 comments like too many just feels dumb @@cooperc69420

[@PopeePlayzRoblox]

2763 is the most popular number in bfdi

[@natthanonknot2974]

if teardrop can't talk...

[@natthanonknot2974]

how do you pick?

[@NeverButter]

She’d probably just point at the person she wants

[@superagaming_064]

Actually Leafy scadooed to yoyal land using his yoyal land map

[@slyar]

22:44 At this point in time, TD's laser powers haven't been shown to the viewers, so realistically Pencil still wins this

[@DragonTheOneDZA]

She most definitely can do it. They just showed it in bfdia

[@duckman1225]

yeah and she dosent act suprised either its like she had used it before@@DragonTheOneDZA

[@Just_Harry1]

Do bfdi but there is never any teams

[@redrhys1015]

This is clearly a way to let teardrop win the show

[@TheStellarMars]

She didn't even win

[@redrhys1015]

Ok another thing is giving teardrop plot armor

[@insert2006]

What should have happened here

[@user-tb7lb2mz5f]

wouldnt it be better if td takes snowball place instead of literally get second (no hate)

[@CocoaScratch]

can firey not get screwed over

[@Cocobutter_]

I’m down

[@MangoOHMYGOD]

thank god you kicked coiny over TB, a mistake you made was that rocky is friends with TB, so he would vote him

[@mackycabangon8945]

as much as I like Match I think this BFDI 12 elimination would play similarly to BFDI 13's, having Match be out. At least in the bottom two

[@carloobjects2006_official]

5:30 actually Rocky sees Tennis Ball as a friend, wich means he should've voted for him.

[@itz_kulerkas6875]

I like tennis ball

[@PopeePlayzRoblox]

No one aasked

[@PoliceRex]

I feel like when rocky had to choose tennis ball or coiny, he should’ve chose tennis ball.