I think the possibly best way for this manga to have started off, was introducing (even if just briefly) the setting and powers FIRST, and then the subplot of Yakuza SECOND. It always feels much less jarring introducing the absurd world building first, and then the grounded plotline next, instead of the other way around. Even if it is all still in the same chapter.
I’ve been reading Astro Royale since chapter 1, and it’s genuinely super good. The powers are good and the characters are also amazing. I just hope it doesn’t get bad eventually
Even though I didn't like the rushed ending, I overall absolutely loved Tokyo Revengers. It was peak up until the end of the Bonten Arc. Imho It only started falling off for me during the second half of the final arc. I havent read Astro Royale yet bc, honestly, I didnt even know it existed until this vid 😂. Seems like it has potential, so Im gonna check it out.
I'm sure it'll get its readers as time goes on still the plot is bombastic in a way making Tokyo a collateral just to find the next heir to the Yakuza Group
what was cloud doing with a conical hat on😭😭 also good video, i think astro is kinda dipping in how much i’m invested but i quite liked the recent chapter.
Japanese people are NOT loving Astro Royale😂😂😂. It always in one of the last places in the Jump TOC,meaning reception is bad. After they cancel Psych house and Necromancer, Astro Royale is next.
Yeah TOC placement is really concerning for astro royale... But atleast it probably wont be U19 and its from a famous author so maybe they'll give him some extra months
I thought you had way more subs til I looked at the comments, awesome video. My only suggestion is raising the volume of your voice while editing, its pretty quiet at max YT volume.
0:22 This one hurts because it was SO good for SO many chapters! The end of Yuuta's arc is still the only moment in either manga or anime to ever make me shed real, actual tears. Not the Going Merry's funeral, not losing Major Hughes-Yuuta. The absolute fucking legend of TPN who started out being a-ok with these kids dying. And then it all just kinda...stopped. It went from great to something worse than bad-it became...ok. Average. Mid, as the kids say. I didn't even talk about the absolute insanity that was Goldy Pond, and we went from that to "lol, everything's ok, yay!" Tragic man, just tragic.
Genuinely a really good video. The editing and just general vibe of the video was super well done. We're in pretty similar areas of content, so I know how much effort goes into these. Keep making videos you want to make, and I'm sure you’ll make great videos.
Tokyo Revengers is awesome, except for the final arc imo. TR & Viral Hit are the only Animanga that have fights that feel atleast a little bit realistic/relatable
Hating a series just cause their last works began to fall off or had a bad ending is honestly weird to me like are we going to say Hunter X Hunter is bad because Togashi ended Yu Yu Hakusho badly? or are we going to say Jojo Part 7 is bad because Araki didn't cook with Part 6? 😐
What's with the weird America bashing. Ya'll throw that crap into these videos and it sours the whole thing. As far as I can tell. You aren't even right. Everything I've seen from Japanese twitter suggests they are doing all the same things. It's also literally last place on Jump consistently.
People just brush this series off just because his previous series is dog shit kinda understandable. Im one of them until I read it. I end up to really liking it. At first I read the series with the goal to shit on it. The premis is pretty simple but it carried by the dialog and characters that make the series is interesting. Currently, the only series that I follow weekly is Centuria, and one piece. And checkout this and sakamoto just from time to time. I cant get into Kagurabachi since the series is too edgy for me.
I heard the Japanese audience isn't big on this series either actually, the first volume just isn't selling well, or at least not to expectations. The series might have been given a bigger print run because of how well Tokyo Revengers did, which is backfiring on the sales.
I started it and it was really good. Currently watching gintama so manga are on hold. I swear all the haters are bandwagonists bc tenjiku and black dragons were peak tr. I could pit my head on a block defending ¾ of tr.
Im calling it now. Watch this do what fire force did. This is probably going to be something like a prequel to tokyo revengers where both stories are connected and people are going to hop on it and call the writer a genius.
i feel like this manga doesnt feel new at all, it seems like the author reecycled the concepts and characters of tokyo revengers, changed them a bit and trew them here, using his already established name as a way to get published (dont tell me that if this wasnt done by ken wakui it'd ever get accepted by shonen jump) The character designs suck ass, just looking at the main character pisses me off so much (but i do like the style of the drawings) The story feels boring af. the author isnt making any effort
As far the main character getting more development, if you read recent chapter and can guess what’s gonna happen in by two chapters later then yeah that’s gonna happen 😅(gonna premptively poor one out for my guy 🥺)
I hadn't read TR so I didn't go into AR with any bias and don't have anything against the art style mostly but I still ended up dropping the series out of disinterest in it.
Imo despite that the ending - and to some extent the entire last arc - was still pretty bad. And I was reading Tokyo revenger from the beginning so I'm not like a fake fan or anything. Real fans can also have their gripes with the story, there's a reason the ending is so universally hated.
You either get the kagura or the bachi when it comes to shonen jump
Spitting facts right here
"This was really... our... ASTRO ROYALE!" The end.
Stop it 😭
Astro has survived the first 19 chapters at least. It's at least beat Do Retry and Kyokuto Necromance, but that's not saying much.
Then again, Mamayuyu got to 29 before the axe dropped.
the reverse kagura bacchi effect is so real for this
Astro royale is pretty good, I have been following it since it started being serialized and its my first ken wakui story. Fun little manga
Astro royale had the reverse kagura bachi effect except kb is a masterclass of art and writing 😭🙏
Bro, the hate for it was wild, like it really wasn’t that deep 😭
@@CloudManga people really jumped it with generational hating before a chapter dropped
It really was uncalled for
🥲
It's the evil kagura bachi
I think the possibly best way for this manga to have started off, was introducing (even if just briefly) the setting and powers FIRST, and then the subplot of Yakuza SECOND.
It always feels much less jarring introducing the absurd world building first, and then the grounded plotline next, instead of the other way around. Even if it is all still in the same chapter.
I’ve been reading Astro Royale since chapter 1, and it’s genuinely super good. The powers are good and the characters are also amazing. I just hope it doesn’t get bad eventually
Same, I hope the author doesn’t fumble this one
@@CloudManga “Guys…It’s time for a Astro Royale🤓”
I ain’t gonna even touch it until it’s at least 150 chapters deep and still peak, I can’t start believing in Ken Wakui again yet
Even though I didn't like the rushed ending, I overall absolutely loved Tokyo Revengers. It was peak up until the end of the Bonten Arc.
Imho It only started falling off for me during the second half of the final arc.
I havent read Astro Royale yet bc, honestly, I didnt even know it existed until this vid 😂. Seems like it has potential, so Im gonna check it out.
Had me suprised when I noticed your sub count. Fire vid I cant lie 🔥 keep up the bangers
Nice video. I didn’t hate Tokyo revengers either. I thought it was fine. This looks interesting I might have to check it out!
I'm sure it'll get its readers as time goes on
still the plot is bombastic in a way
making Tokyo a collateral just to find the next heir to the Yakuza Group
I subbed immediately, crazy how much u led me on, i thought u had like 2k-10k subs lol
Thanks for the support man 😂
what was cloud doing with a conical hat on😭😭
also good video, i think astro is kinda dipping in how much i’m invested but i quite liked the recent chapter.
Damn, now that I know this I think I will give a shot to Kagura Bachi, thanks man!
Using trails in the sky music earned you a sub from me
Hold up, I found another trails enjoyer? 😭
@@CloudManga do a review on it, it deserves more love
I love Tokyo Revengers. I didn't see Astro yet but I'm holding out
I hope Astro royale doesn’t get axed cause it sounds like it has potential
Japanese people are NOT loving Astro Royale😂😂😂.
It always in one of the last places in the Jump TOC,meaning reception is bad. After they cancel Psych house and Necromancer, Astro Royale is next.
Gotta fire my research team 💀
@@CloudMangadon't, look at astros first sale compared to its recent, they like it
That's not true. If it were below the bottom three, it'd be in the axe range, but it's not.
Yeah TOC placement is really concerning for astro royale... But atleast it probably wont be U19 and its from a famous author so maybe they'll give him some extra months
tbh I really like this manga and I'm hoping it doesn't get axed
what were the 3 manga you showed at 4:35
I thought you had way more subs til I looked at the comments, awesome video. My only suggestion is raising the volume of your voice while editing, its pretty quiet at max YT volume.
Gotcha, thanks for the tip, I’ll fix that up for my videos going forward!
I've also seen asta royale's mc design be criticized
I might give this a shot now.
0:22 This one hurts because it was SO good for SO many chapters! The end of Yuuta's arc is still the only moment in either manga or anime to ever make me shed real, actual tears. Not the Going Merry's funeral, not losing Major Hughes-Yuuta. The absolute fucking legend of TPN who started out being a-ok with these kids dying. And then it all just kinda...stopped. It went from great to something worse than bad-it became...ok. Average. Mid, as the kids say. I didn't even talk about the absolute insanity that was Goldy Pond, and we went from that to "lol, everything's ok, yay!" Tragic man, just tragic.
Genuinely a really good video. The editing and just general vibe of the video was super well done. We're in pretty similar areas of content, so I know how much effort goes into these. Keep making videos you want to make, and I'm sure you’ll make great videos.
Tokyo Revengers is awesome, except for the final arc imo. TR & Viral Hit are the only Animanga that have fights that feel atleast a little bit realistic/relatable
It’s ehh. The writing is pretty mediocre and the characters are pretty bland.
So it’s a dmc, smt, manga that looks like Tokyo revengers pretty much
Really high quality video! Criminally underrated channel 😤 (subbed!)
0:10 no way you used S8 man, S9 is when the fall off happened
Bro u got a lot of potential keep posting ❤
Your underated and funny earned a new sub
About time someone talk good on this manga besides one other person I saw
WAIT HE WROTE SHINJUKU SWAN??? WTF! THAT MANGA WAS SO FUCKING GOOD
0:15 Damn, did not expect Arc-V to appear...
I'm enjoying it tbh, not everything needs to be some cutting edge manga or the leader of the pack.
Hating a series just cause their last works began to fall off or had a bad ending is honestly weird to me like are we going to say Hunter X Hunter is bad because Togashi ended Yu Yu Hakusho badly? or are we going to say Jojo Part 7 is bad because Araki didn't cook with Part 6? 😐
I'm enjoying it a lot
It's better then the Versus manga One was trying to make
Isn’t that still getting made?
hey can you make another video about dragon and chameleon? it really deserves more attention
I could have done without the soppy end of Tokyo revenge
What's with the weird America bashing. Ya'll throw that crap into these videos and it sours the whole thing. As far as I can tell. You aren't even right. Everything I've seen from Japanese twitter suggests they are doing all the same things. It's also literally last place on Jump consistently.
Everywhere I go I hear rean schwarzer
This Manga remind me of Ayashimon.
It will not last.
People just brush this series off just because his previous series is dog shit kinda understandable. Im one of them until I read it. I end up to really liking it. At first I read the series with the goal to shit on it. The premis is pretty simple but it carried by the dialog and characters that make the series is interesting. Currently, the only series that I follow weekly is Centuria, and one piece. And checkout this and sakamoto just from time to time. I cant get into Kagurabachi since the series is too edgy for me.
Did I? Did I hear Trails Music?
PEAAAAAK.
Another Barrier yet overcome......... Ha ha...
Another trails fan? Say less 😭
I wonder if there was a manga that started down hill but went uphill later on.
I like astro Royale but I think I'll drop it. If it does well ang gets an anime I'll watch it
welp can't find bone's video
It ain’t that bad people overreacting fr
Is that mikey ?
No, it’s a different manga by the same creator
@@CloudManga yea saw the full video that was just my first reaction 🤣
Got boring in a few chapters, dropped it. Never read or seen any of his other works.
Just begging Ken Wakui not to fumble the ending tho
My only issue is the characters look like alt universe versions of everyone from Tokyo revengers.
Concept kinda reminds me of Succession War arc of HXH.
nah this is not it maybe down the line it will get a anime but kagura is what people felt the most at the time
I heard the Japanese audience isn't big on this series either actually, the first volume just isn't selling well, or at least not to expectations. The series might have been given a bigger print run because of how well Tokyo Revengers did, which is backfiring on the sales.
The first volume had decent sales
I started it and it was really good. Currently watching gintama so manga are on hold. I swear all the haters are bandwagonists bc tenjiku and black dragons were peak tr. I could pit my head on a block defending ¾ of tr.
Tokyo Revengers was awesome
valid
Can we really say Seven Deadly Sins was ever *ON* to begin with?
Also, seeing ARC-V in that shot hurt me on both a physical and spiritual level.
🎉
It feels highly generic and boring, I dropped it like 10 chapters in. The MC is just so cookie cutter it's painful
people sometimes really have trouble realizing people can grow and change, or learn from past mistakes
Honestly the awful art is enough for me not to give it a chance
He should stop making manga halfway through tokyo revengers.
Gives me ayashimon vibes
Whats the manga at 1:23?
Im calling it now. Watch this do what fire force did. This is probably going to be something like a prequel to tokyo revengers where both stories are connected and people are going to hop on it and call the writer a genius.
Bones video is gone and so is his channel. Rip😭
Wait what? What happened???
@@CloudManga no idea
Pls don't remind me of the Tokyo Revengers ending, thank you very much 🙏
Terrible!?nahhhh this manga is good,fun unique and interesting tho!it ain"t terrible
+1 sub for you!
i feel like this manga doesnt feel new at all, it seems like the author reecycled the concepts and characters of tokyo revengers, changed them a bit and trew them here, using his already established name as a way to get published (dont tell me that if this wasnt done by ken wakui it'd ever get accepted by shonen jump)
The character designs suck ass, just looking at the main character pisses me off so much (but i do like the style of the drawings)
The story feels boring af. the author isnt making any effort
*Thanks for 250 subs
As far the main character getting more development, if you read recent chapter and can guess what’s gonna happen in by two chapters later then yeah that’s gonna happen 😅(gonna premptively poor one out for my guy 🥺)
what manga is in the middle at 4:37
Not sure abt the first 2 but the right one is kagurabachi
That was Choujin X
@@fatpurp4041yea, i knew kagura bachi and gachiakuta is the one on the lwft
@@CloudMangathanks
ken best mangaka oat
it’s the worst thing on jump plus easily
I hadn't read TR so I didn't go into AR with any bias and don't have anything against the art style mostly but I still ended up dropping the series out of disinterest in it.
Please read the Qur'an
Maybe if people read tokyo revengers and saw how is goal was to save EVERYONE then people wouldnt hate the ending😂
Imo despite that the ending - and to some extent the entire last arc - was still pretty bad. And I was reading Tokyo revenger from the beginning so I'm not like a fake fan or anything. Real fans can also have their gripes with the story, there's a reason the ending is so universally hated.
1:05 my Tweet made it to the video🤣
UhHAHHH