Who should I react to next: www.maggierenee.com/book-me/sponsor-a-reaction-live What should I sing next: www.maggierenee.com/book-me/sponsor-a-song-liveAnd just for you: ‘Sing Better Instantly" my FREE Singing Course: skl.sh/3aHdSuy and for EXCLUSIVE VIDEOS AND PERKS: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee
Have you reacted to How Can I Go On? By Freddie Mercury and Monsteratt Cabale?Just a personal favorite of mine out of all their performances together. I could only find your reaction to Barcelona.
When her husband wrote the music with her vocals in mind, no wonder why she can deliver a great performance. That said, yes she is great. I've also seen Andrea live once, something I'll NEVER forget. I'm a fan for life. Not their best performance but maybe because later in the concert.
Love this performance and reaction. I'm a fan of both artists. But every time I see the name "Sarah Brightman" my first memory is of her as a young disco singer (Sarah Brightman and Hot Gossip) who had a minor hit with "I lost my heart to a starship trooper". VERY different to the Sarah Brightman most people know and love.
Brightman's history is musical theater. She uses vocal tricks to portray different characters and their emotions. It gets in the way of pure voice. This ain't Bel Canto. A singer friend who trained under Lotte Lehman would call her voice "Hooty" It is a beautiful voice for the right music. Where it really works is when she takes popular music and adds some juice to it. She sang "My Heart will go on" from "Titanic" (pretentiously in Italian).. but you can hear her transition from "Pop" voice, to "Theater" voice to "Opera" voice in the three verses. It's a neat trick.
She has the most gorgeous voice as does he. They may not fit into the “operatic “ mold but to me they are both perfection and emotionally moving. Listen to her sing some more
Andrea and Sarah - you know right away this is going to be something! Crossover? Yes but good crossover. Was that a scoop that Sarah did at the end? Good reaction, good analysis. And good Maggie performance along the way! 😍
I wonder if you have heard Sarah Brightman in Repo: The Genetic Opera? Not to mention so many other big names, Paul Sorvigno, Alexa Vega, Anthony Head, Paris Hilton and more! I have to say one of my favorite Rock Operas ever❤❤❤. Her part as Blind Mags still gives me chills just thinking about it!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and reaction. I don't think you were trying to be demeaning, just to share your opinion based on your training. You talked about the strengths of their voices and then the techniques they were using in light of how they're described by their fans and the market.
Love this reaction. I couldn't have imagined anyone could find fault with this performance. But you did - and listening to your explanation I understand. It doesn't mean the performance wasn't beautiful - it was. Finding the stones to criticize Andrea Bocelli for his lack of vibrato in pretty ballsy. And I love how you know all the lyrics even though it's a foreign language (Italian?) This is the best work I've seen from you - keep it up!
THANK YOU so much for this. I've been waiting years to get a clear explanation for why all my opera friends say Bocelli is a fraud, but everyone else loves him. Is it possible that the "opera voice" professional academies train into singers is barking up the wrong tree, going for resonance and vibrato that mostly appeals to other opera singers but not to ordinary humans?
I would assume he's not an operatic singer so he's not using operatic technique. Some of his notes were a few cents flat at the beginning to be hearing. His later recording I heard sounded much stronger.
Thank you for your reaction to a favorite song. Please consider the most recent duet that Diana Ankudinova performed with Brandon Stone. Miss Diana has definitely worked on her upper register.
I understand the need to stay in standard. However, especially with music, interpretation might not be the most correct. I took my elderly father to see Andrea for valentines day in 2019 Tampa. While Sara Brightman was not present, I had the most dynamic, intimate evening ever. Thank you Andrea for a beautiful last evening with my beloved father before he passed. IDC that it was not perfect.. who is? xo
I love your voice! So many talented people and not as famous! Wish you best of luck! I am not a professional but always felt something is off when Andrea sings and you just said what it is! Yes, he is talented and has a beautiful voice but … what you said is not there! I personally love love the voice and tone/timbre of Alessandro Safina! If you could do a video on him one day that would be great! Thank you sooo much! I enjoy listening to you analyze and sing!
Listening to her talk about how he has the wrong technique is just exhausting. Just listen to the fuking song. College kids always wanna critique because they learned something !!
He does need training. In this performance he hadn't finish working on his voice. In Italy, where they KNOW opera, there is a big dislike and debate on his voice. He isn't very famous in the classical world. He's more of a pop opera artist. Very over rated and the fact that he is blind just gave him a faster ticket towards stardom
I have seen them singing this song on other concerts on youtube and though sang well on this one i thought they sang it better on the other concerts especially at the end of the song. I dont know how early this version is.
OMG, this lady questioning Andrea and Sarah brightman. They are classical artists. They are world renowned and you are sitting here questioning them. So they chose success to be heard by millions. People like you may be heard by the hundreds.
Every operatic singer is constantly open to critique. Even the best. It's the nature of their vocal world. It's actually a way to study the voice though it may come across as criticizing or demeaning.
Strange critic considering opera didn't even become popular in the U.S. until the 1950s. It's been in europe since the 17th century. I'll ignore some of your comments 😂
Maybe she sing lower/warmer sound to let understand the voice, by Opera you know what they singing but you don’t understand what they singing, Opera is singing with voice, not with words, more than the half of the Opera lovers listen to the voices because they don’t hear what they sing, that’s probably why the most people don’t listen to Opera, more people listen to Operette or Musicals because they understand what the message is.
only question i have is how do you know he didnt have the proper classical training and decided to change his technique later to beter suite classical pop? I understand that your critiquing their voices as a classical singer but both of them where responsible to create and make popular the pop classical genre..
❤❤❤Noutăți!!! Dimash și Placido Domingo!!!! Interesată!!!???"Au fond du temple Saint"Mulțumesc❤❤❤Noutăți!❤❤❤❤❤❤ News!!! Dimash and Placido Domingo!!!! Interested!!!???"Au fond du temple Saint"Thanks❤❤❤News!!! Dimash and Placido Domingo!!!! Interested!!!???"Au fond du temple Saint"Thank you❤❤❤
You say Cindy aren’t she passed away at 55 Céline Dion died at 55. Yes hors d’oeuvres disorder new John passed away and 72 Jean Kelly was a movie interview dance with the beautiful songs dear Carol below the music and he passed away 80 years ago and did Joe and we lost. I can’t hear her name she take medicine woman mama is not, but she passed away too. We lost a lot of stars in the last few months.
As a Brightman fan, I can recognize she's not perfect with her technique, and that your critique isn't mean spirited (like a lot of Brightman critics,) so I appreciate that. I do think her voice is beautiful and her appeal definitely lies within the crossover genre as she's done a lot of different types of music over her career. Thank you for your review :)
You say “classical crossover” like it is like it is distasteful - a watered down version of the genuine. I like this version because so many of their versions are lip synced. I do doubt a more opera sound would sell as many records.
Who should I react to next: www.maggierenee.com/book-me/sponsor-a-reaction-live What should I sing next: www.maggierenee.com/book-me/sponsor-a-song-liveAnd just for you: ‘Sing Better Instantly" my FREE Singing Course: skl.sh/3aHdSuy and for EXCLUSIVE VIDEOS AND PERKS: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee
Always love you Maggie
can you react to the great joni mitchell live in chicago i think singing the song woodstock she's amazing !
would love to see you reaction to The Majestic 'The Phantom of The Opera' (Sarah Brightman & Antonio Banderas) | Phantom Of The Opera
Have you reacted to How Can I Go On? By Freddie Mercury and Monsteratt Cabale?Just a personal favorite of mine out of all their performances together. I could only find your reaction to Barcelona.
When her husband wrote the music with her vocals in mind, no wonder why she can deliver a great performance. That said, yes she is great.
I've also seen Andrea live once, something I'll NEVER forget.
I'm a fan for life.
Not their best performance but maybe because later in the concert.
Lloyd Weber did not write this
It’s been a while, but I watched this many times… I get full on chills every time I watch this
Love this performance and reaction. I'm a fan of both artists. But every time I see the name "Sarah Brightman" my first memory is of her as a young disco singer (Sarah Brightman and Hot Gossip) who had a minor hit with "I lost my heart to a starship trooper". VERY different to the Sarah Brightman most people know and love.
I believe Sarah was the original lead in Andrew Lloyd Webber's Phantom of the Opera on Broadway.
She was! They were also married.
Thanks for reacting to this beautiful duet.
love hearing your take on the singers-take your voice over them them anyday
Brightman's history is musical theater. She uses vocal tricks to portray different characters and their emotions. It gets in the way of pure voice. This ain't Bel Canto. A singer friend who trained under Lotte Lehman would call her voice "Hooty" It is a beautiful voice for the right music. Where it really works is when she takes popular music and adds some juice to it. She sang "My Heart will go on" from "Titanic" (pretentiously in Italian).. but you can hear her transition from "Pop" voice, to "Theater" voice to "Opera" voice in the three verses. It's a neat trick.
Interesting context. Thanks for sharing.
Love the song. love the reaction....
She has the most gorgeous voice as does he. They may not fit into the “operatic “ mold but to me they are both perfection and emotionally moving. Listen to her sing some more
Wooow beautiful from Australia more more ❤❤❤
Trying to critique Bocelli’s voice 🤣🤣 I’ve seen it all now
Anyone's voice can be critiqued. No one is immune to it.
Especially when your no where near their level.
Andrea and Sarah - you know right away this is going to be something! Crossover? Yes but good crossover. Was that a scoop that Sarah did at the end? Good reaction, good analysis. And good Maggie performance along the way! 😍
I have loved this ever since I saw him sing it to elmo on Sesame street!
I wonder if you have heard Sarah Brightman in Repo: The Genetic Opera? Not to mention so many other big names, Paul Sorvigno, Alexa Vega, Anthony Head, Paris Hilton and more! I have to say one of my favorite Rock Operas ever❤❤❤. Her part as Blind Mags still gives me chills just thinking about it!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and reaction.
I don't think you were trying to be demeaning, just to share your opinion based on your training.
You talked about the strengths of their voices and then the techniques they were using in light of how they're described by their fans and the market.
Andrea is the best of all time. Anyone that says otherwise is ignorant.
Or, has a different opinion.
Best "what" of all time?
Andrea is over rated. He barely studied. His voice is not developed
Love this reaction. I couldn't have imagined anyone could find fault with this performance. But you did - and listening to your explanation I understand. It doesn't mean the performance wasn't beautiful - it was. Finding the stones to criticize Andrea Bocelli for his lack of vibrato in pretty ballsy. And I love how you know all the lyrics even though it's a foreign language (Italian?) This is the best work I've seen from you - keep it up!
THANK YOU so much for this. I've been waiting years to get a clear explanation for why all my opera friends say Bocelli is a fraud, but everyone else loves him. Is it possible that the "opera voice" professional academies train into singers is barking up the wrong tree, going for resonance and vibrato that mostly appeals to other opera singers but not to ordinary humans?
I would assume he's not an operatic singer so he's not using operatic technique. Some of his notes were a few cents flat at the beginning to be hearing.
His later recording I heard sounded much stronger.
Do the "scoop" you sound terrific!
Sarah is iconic singer Diva her concerts will blow you away 💯
You should listen to Andre Bocelli and Hayley Westenra sing it as they did for a Smuckers Ice skating show
this is a must phantom with sarah and antonio banderas
Thank you for your reaction to a favorite song. Please consider the most recent duet that Diana Ankudinova performed with Brandon Stone. Miss Diana has definitely worked on her upper register.
Hey Maggie! Come mai canti così bene in italiano? "Partirò" is difficult for strangers ❤️
Have you reacted and analysed Jonathan Antoine yet? I'd be interested to get hear your expertise on him.
I understand the need to stay in standard. However, especially with music, interpretation might not be the most correct. I took my elderly father to see Andrea for valentines day in 2019 Tampa. While Sara Brightman was not present, I had the most dynamic, intimate evening ever. Thank you Andrea for a beautiful last evening with my beloved father before he passed. IDC that it was not perfect.. who is? xo
The best performance of this is their 1997 performance at the Royal Albert Albert
“I’m a 100-level opera singer. Let me tell you why some of the most famous opera sing
singers in the world suck.”
You should watch the video of Sarah's appearance in Las Vegas. At the end she flies.
Could listen to you all day Maggie ❤
She is the best selling Saprano of all time. She had to have tricks up her sleeve😅
Sapo means frog, which is appropriate for the discussion of her Kermit voice. In fact, rana means frog too.
@@oceanchaos1 tell that to her bank account.
I love your voice! So many talented people and not as famous! Wish you best of luck! I am not a professional but always felt something is off when Andrea sings and you just said what it is! Yes, he is talented and has a beautiful voice but … what you said is not there! I personally love love the voice and tone/timbre of Alessandro Safina! If you could do a video on him one day that would be great! Thank you sooo much! I enjoy listening to you analyze and sing!
Andrea Bocelli needs to improve? Really? He's not trying to sing opera.
LMAOO bro chill, she has had her training, she’s an expert in the operatic world 😆🤣
@@paulharris9250 but he was not trying to sing opera
Listening to her talk about how he has the wrong technique is just exhausting. Just listen to the fuking song. College kids always wanna critique because they learned something !!
@@RPitch07 I know. Read my next comment I was being sarcastic but I couldn’t stand listening to her critique him in this way.
He does need training. In this performance he hadn't finish working on his voice. In Italy, where they KNOW opera, there is a big dislike and debate on his voice. He isn't very famous in the classical world. He's more of a pop opera artist. Very over rated and the fact that he is blind just gave him a faster ticket towards stardom
LOVE LOVE LOVE this song!!!
Check out Lea Salonga singing this with Il Divo
I have seen them singing this song on other concerts on youtube and though sang well on this one i thought they sang it better on the other concerts especially at the end of the song. I dont know how early this version is.
You're an amazing but
You're a baby in front of them
Just discovered your channel.
Love it.
So glad! Welcome!! 🤗
Please do the Domingo - Dimash Duet next.
You should react to sugarland's stay
Want you listen to the Danish National Symphony do the theme from The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.
OMG, this lady questioning Andrea and Sarah brightman. They are classical artists. They are world renowned and you are sitting here questioning them. So they chose success to be heard by millions. People like you may be heard by the hundreds.
Every operatic singer is constantly open to critique. Even the best. It's the nature of their vocal world.
It's actually a way to study the voice though it may come across as criticizing or demeaning.
Sarah is, and will be the only Christine daaé in my book. This was my favorite song of hers since phantom of the opera!
SARA BRIGHTMAN has a duet song with Iraqi famous singer in Arab world the song is THE WAR IS OVER good combination of course
Can you react to Anna Prohaska? Soprano from Berlin xx
Sarah... greatest female voice ever. Best male operatic voice ever... debatable but my choice would be Caruso.
Maggie Voctave has a new release. Please react.
Andrea Bocelli is incredible! He needs no improvement. None. Enough said
Play Pat Benetar; Fire and Ice. Tell us what you think.
React andrea Bocelli ATi ft kenny G please
Strange critic considering opera didn't even become popular in the U.S. until the 1950s. It's been in europe since the 17th century. I'll ignore some of your comments 😂
1997
have a look for i lost my heart to a starship trooper, then you will see sarah brightman in 1978 and its nothing like this, quite the opposite in fact
Maybe she sing lower/warmer sound to let understand the voice, by Opera you know what they singing but you don’t understand what they singing, Opera is singing with voice, not with words, more than the half of the Opera lovers listen to the voices because they don’t hear what they sing, that’s probably why the most people don’t listen to Opera, more people listen to Operette or Musicals because they understand what the message is.
only question i have is how do you know he didnt have the proper classical training and decided to change his technique later to beter suite classical pop? I understand that your critiquing their voices as a classical singer but both of them where responsible to create and make popular the pop classical genre..
❤❤❤Noutăți!!! Dimash și Placido Domingo!!!! Interesată!!!???"Au fond du temple Saint"Mulțumesc❤❤❤Noutăți!❤❤❤❤❤❤ News!!! Dimash and Placido Domingo!!!! Interested!!!???"Au fond du temple Saint"Thanks❤❤❤News!!! Dimash and Placido Domingo!!!! Interested!!!???"Au fond du temple Saint"Thank you❤❤❤
You say Cindy aren’t she passed away at 55 Céline Dion died at 55. Yes hors d’oeuvres disorder new John passed away and 72 Jean Kelly was a movie interview dance with the beautiful songs dear Carol below the music and he passed away 80 years ago and did Joe and we lost. I can’t hear her name she take medicine woman mama is not, but she passed away too. We lost a lot of stars in the last few months.
You need to lay off the drugs
Is he not just playing it flat because it's with Sarah and a more popular audiance?
As a Brightman fan, I can recognize she's not perfect with her technique, and that your critique isn't mean spirited (like a lot of Brightman critics,) so I appreciate that. I do think her voice is beautiful and her appeal definitely lies within the crossover genre as she's done a lot of different types of music over her career. Thank you for your review :)
Always thought Sarah Brightman was pretty and a good singer. But, then I liked Judy Collins.
He's not an opera singer.
You say “classical crossover” like it is like it is distasteful - a watered down version of the genuine.
I like this version because so many of their versions are lip synced. I do doubt a more opera sound would sell as many records.
You are so jealous, with all your training you will never sound as good as either one of them.
That opera voice is for people who can't sing it straight. If you can sing it right it is unsennessary.
You talk to much.
Nessun Dorma and Un bel di are the only operetic tunes worth listening to. The rest of opera is tripe and trash.