MOWAS2 vs GATES OF HELL vs MEN OF WAR 2 | ULTIMATE COMPARISON (Part -1)
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 05. 2024
- If you enjoyed the video, drop a LIKE and SUBSCRIBE for more.
🌐Join my discord server: / discord
🛑Support me on Patreon / sturmfuhrerpk
#sturmfuhrerpk - Hry
Gates of Hell texture is AAA quality. The animation is top notch. Even the explosion effects are awesome, especially when the tank is cooking off.
So good. Best rts in the last decade imo. AI needs work and is pretty braindead but overall it's been so good.
Agreed, GOH has soooooooo much potential, every content drop and DLC they've had has been great so far and the mods are top notch. They need to keep it coming with good content and updates
Yeah, better AI and pathfinding would make GoH so much better. I do like the explosions and tank firing in mow2, though. They may not be as realistic, but they "feel" more powerful than GoH
Totally agree! I play and play through GoH on my channel in 8K resolution and with HDR, and it looks many times cooler than MoW 2.
The thing about gates is the optimization, soon as a bigger battle kicks of the fps drops are horrid even in higher end pcs. Men of war has always run amazing
That flak 88 has some crazy fast traverse in mow2 😂😂
yep to fast, but the tiger 1 is fine
lol its like an m1 abrams turret lol
I mean they turned it into an arcade game, everything looks weird as fuck in MoW2 lol
@@nachtmaerie I hope to play it, surely the community fixes the problems with mods, as happened in MoWAS2
I expected more from Men of War 2, especially with the competition from GoH.
Imo GoH takes the prize here.
There's no competition, both dev team work for the same publisher...
@@KaptifLaDistillerie GoH is published by Digitalmindsoft, and MoW2 is published by Fulqrum
@@scorpionarius5590 Yea, right.
Same devs.
@@sargentodapaz Not at all? I know the history of the games is confusing, but in this case it's quite simple.
MoW2 is developed by Bestway who in turn have nothing to do with GoH.
@@scorpionarius5590 No.
if GOH can add automatic vaulting and improve the AI then rip MOW2
YESS AUTOMATIC VAULTING IS WHAT I NEED HAHA
What is that?
@@stirpsromanica english mf, do you speak it ?
@@stirpsromanica In last part you see infantry automatically jump over fence because it is faster then running around it.
GOH you have to manually order them to vault it and then order them to advance again.
@@Sarfanger Ohh I see now, yeah, completely true
I dunno, but GoH is much better... the grafics, the physics, the explosions, the sounds... its just... nice. I mean you can see shrapnel hitting the ground around a explosion...
jajajajajajaja sure
Crazy bad optimization
Sound seems way better too. They did made a sound patch couple of weeks back and it is....ugh chief kiss.
@@skytabs6292 Not really runs fine
Gates of Hell > everything
I will say the lighting in MOW2 is nice and the auto fence jumping is good though everything else pales in comparison by so much, I mean that MG42 sound is terrible and they're still reusing much of the same audio from earlier games... That turret traversing sound has been in this franchise since 2004... with "soldiers heroes of world war 2"... The first entry!!
At least GOH made everything from scratch.
Yea, men of war devs getting lazy
Not to mention how overly arcadey MOW2 is, it feels more like a CoH game than MOW...
GoH devs have a burning passion for their game and for WW2 history. As someone who worked on voice acting with them, they are awesome people
@@KaptifLaDistillerie That's awesome dude! Which voices in the game are yours?
Can't say I disagree, it's been clear that MOW's main developers are just going to continue to reuse as much as possible and release as sequels what used to be considered "expansion packs" back in the day.
I kinda hope the GoH devs decide to build from scratch with a modern engine -- since they had the licensing issues that (Iirc) really held them back on doing what they wanted to do.
it truly amazes me how Gates of Hell is detailed, even when zooming in on a unit we can see a lot of details, crazy to think that modern RTS game like GoH is much more detailed than some FPS WWII shooters from many years back
So true!
GoH is better in everything exept gamemodes.
Like if u support GoH👍
Like beggar
except AI too.
and i bet, the modding scene will be bigger in mow2 than goh.
@@jacksheldon8566 idk, modding scene is not bad in GOH
@@Xanthira222 it's poor.
Some big mods like hotmod require USA dlc to work even tho they aren't even set in WW2. But they have some unresolved bugs like invisible helicopters.
And overall there isn't many working TC.
The valour mod there isn't balanced either.
Compared to mowas2, GoH modding scene is abysmal.
GoH needs updated mod tools. A lot of the mods are basically ported from mowas2. If mow2 brings better mod support and new tools, it will actually improve the mods in GoH as a result.
Thing is it still looks like a 20 year old game with loads of polish. It doesn't look like a game from 2024 at all.
I would think just improving path finding to what MOW2 has and adding few more gamemodes would make GoH perfect. After that just add all the rest of the WW2 nations and you're done.
GoH feels like a game that was developed by people who loved the original MoW game. MoW feels like a game from a dev house that wants to keep selling us that same original MoW game.
If GoH announced a sequel on a new engine so they were free to do what they wanted, that'd be a day 1 backing from me. The details in their work show a lot of passion and that tends to make for a great game.
Thanks for the taking the time to do the comparison. Love gates of Hell.
They better fix that 88 before release on MOW2 lmao. That thing will dominate with how quick it moves.
the reason for that is that it is also an anti air. and to be effective at anti air it needs to aim fast. hence the high turning speed. (which i find kind of stupid too.)
sneaky infantry or artillery will counter it.
GoH looks and feels really dynamic in sound design, it feels like you are playing an RTS Hell Let Loose, AI for me seems pretty smart, don't see a lotta issues with path finding, MOWAS 2 is always a classic I will come back to yet , since release Men of War 2 Ive been jammin, I do love the introduction of echelon/ phases when in battle and the tech tree, AI needs some work with path finding and some elements seem bugged but overall is good feels like Men of War and War Thunder had a baby. I kinda feel the UI and Interface however is like CoH Company of Heroes.
Assuming that u used ultra graphic on all games , i can see that goh is better in everything except for human animations. Its also amazing to see mowas2 stands out after all these years
If there's one thing GoH is really better, it's animations lol
@@KaptifLaDistillerie tank animations maybe , but goh need to work more on human animation in my opinion
@@EagleTube777they recently redid every single german infantry uniform in the game with proper research put into every piece of equipment, the same dev that worked on them is also an animator and said in an interview with the youtuber Shermanator that he will now focus on animations so, maybe expect them to be improved tenfold in one of the next major updates since he will be using mocap for the new ones, they already redid the death animations with the release of the USF DLC and the improvement was massive
@@Partexedd yup , i know , really looking forward to it , it ill be great
looks like Gates of Hell wins in every category. Though I will still buy men of war 2. We must support these types of games.
Except when they constantly reuse assets with no real innovation by looking at whats currently on the market and what is their direct competitor (GoH).
I mean it has voice lines from Faces of war (2006) and the turret traversing sound is from the first entry which is even earlier in 2004.
I'm all for supporting smaller devs making ww2 games but this is a decently sized RTS IP and it feels like they're shoving sh*t in our face in some respects
@@iTomBassI saw the devs reply in the forums that it ‘keeps with tradition’ that they reuse voices lol
I never played the old ones but the charm is definitely not there
@@mangyminotaur30 lmao wtf really? If that doesn’t tell you all you need to know then I’m not sure what does.
I do wish Gates of Hell had some of the gamemodes and setup that Men of War 2 has.
Gates of Hell did nail the explosions and sounds though. Vehicles too in my opinion.
@@Techigai I think the conquest idea for MoW2 was unique, don’t know how I feel about the research and the battalion ideas since it’s practically just Echelons I feel. The research is shallower and I’ll prob understand it after quite a while
I want to like MOW2, but GOH still just seems better in every way (except maybe optimization) I dont see me buying MOW2, unless it goes on sale maybe.
Gosh is a masterpiece. Assault Squad 2 so fun. Men of War 2 has potential with more updates
"Excellent video, it's evident that throughout the three games there are different advantages and disadvantages for each one and modes. By the way, I know it's a lot to ask, but many people are really interested in a new DLC for a new campaign for Gates of Hell. Many have tried to send comments to the game developers and also to many players. We know that for a game to have excellence and appeal to the public, it's important to listen to feedback. I speak for many when I say it would be advisable, before diving into a new campaign, to fill in the gaps for the three existing nations regarding tanks, cannons, and units that are not yet in the game. This would be greatly appreciated by many players. So, from the bottom of our hearts and with all due respect, I ask that if you have the opportunity to give your humble opinion, as we eagerly watch the videos you upload every day in anticipation of a new game, if you could also convey these humble words to the creators, it would be greatly appreciated by many who are eagerly awaiting the completion of the nations with the final vehicles and artifacts, even though there weren't many, one or two were created during the war.🙏
i will play both MOW2 and GOH
I'm really hoping someone will do entire vehicle/emplacement showcase for MoWII, I just want to see if they add any cool new stuff
How good are the mod for mow2 and goh because assault squad so many amazing mods which make the game worth it
Sturm，what are your PC specs?
I wish they would make an effort on fixed guns with gunners just sliding around when the gun turns.
as a fan who has everysingle one of their games i personally love the gates of hell as their tanks are more detailed and more beautiful looking and shiny and the damage modules are good too and their animation i mean look at the guy on the right side sitting down he checks where the shot landed like a real one would do 3:29
I will get the game. See what kind of cinematic i can make. Like the infantry jumping the wall.! GoH is drop dead beautiful.!!!
hell yeah, cant wait to see it!
I feel like mow2 could use another year in the oven, there is nothing this game can offer at the moment that goh didn't do better.
I think GoH is better in everything except the sprinting moves from Mow2 at the end. they look awesome!
Cant say I have ever zoomed in this far to stare at units...I am glad the ones I play didnt waste time on making units hyperrealistic.
goh tanks look wet and shiney.
@SturmFuhrer, Is it just me or do the infantry and small arms models for GoH just look better, higher res. and of a higher quality then MoW2's? Also I would argue that the vehicle/tank models of MoW2 look about equal in both res. and quality to GoH. That worries me somewhat. Also this "healthbox" thing we've seen in the demo version makes it way too arcady. I hope there is an option to turn that off.
Yep, there Is, they created a "realism mode" which you can use in both SP and MP
Is MOW in beta rn or is it considered released? The dudes aren't even holding their rifles...
GoH is a nice sp game but MoW has so many good mp modes, im completely addicted to it and have over 60 hours now in that few days.
Gates of Hell wins completly. Best ww2 game out there.
Men of war assault squad two German equipment is cursed except some of the vehicles
I have played a little of Assault Squad 2 but neither of the other games. Just by watching this video I prefer the look of the Gates of Hell assets.
Is the supply truck still useful in MoW 2?
yes
Funny, I Watched The Vid From the Other Guy(made Ansys Sim) Saying that a Sherman 7.5cm Round Could Penetrate the Armor of the MG Mantlet of the Konigstiger.Perhaps? Hypothetically...
Also in addition
Just Seen a Vid Sujesting MOHAA Reimagined on the Unreal 5.
I will only love men of war 2 if i could mod everything of it
6:45
Man... even the MG42 sounds weak in MoW2, it was given its nickname ******'* Buzzsaw for a reason.
As much as I like GoH's visuals, vehicle modding is a pain in the game.
I loved playing MOWAS 2
Meh. GoH has that look that brings you into the game couple that with sound and physics that make you flinch, and it eclipses MoW2 in every aspect. I was extremely excited for MoW2. Figured itd be like GoH with modern graphics to make that color theme really pop along with sound and physics that comes closer to real world effects than its predessors. What a disappointment. Maybe ill buy it anyways, may not, but frim what ive seen, im not expecting much from it.
9:13 Причина по которой стоит купить эту игру
СКОЛЬКО ЛЕТ ЖДАЛИ.
А формации? НАКОНЕЦ-ТО.
А ВОЗМОЖНОСТЬ ЫБРАТЬ БОЛЬШЕ 10 СОЛДАТ! СКОЛЬКО ЛЕТ К ЭТОМУ ШЛИ?
Слабая причина
j'ai ma préférence pour GoH niveau des effets explosion et sons moteur et armes. il faut noter quand même que la course et le franchissement automatique de Mow 2 est intéressante voir innovante mais les animation , ligne de dialogue laisse a désirer je pense qu'il aurait pue approfondir cela pareil pour les formation de combat , prise de bâtiment. il n'empêche que personnellement je trouve que les effets visuel sont pas fous. qu'en pensez vous ?
don't know why they have men of war 2 when they already got GOH. I can see how bad the sale would be for MOW 2
Not the same Devs.
The major differences will be better multiplayer, better unit AI and better modding community.
That ‘modding community’ will have to do a lot of heavy lifting. Doesn’t help that GoH received a slew of upgrades recently
Mow2 community seems more eastern based + alot of mowas2 modders are devs on goh
GOH is clearly the GOAT
i used to be a Company of Heroes Fiend, then i played gates of hell.... it blew COH out of the water a mile high.
Man I was 100% ready to throw in with MaW 2… I never played the earlier titles and maybe I was spoiled by GoH but that game just hits right in every way. MaW2 just felt ‘lesser’. Like the combat is way more robust in GoH
The latest updates to GoH’s sounds & German skins couldn’t have come at a better time for that game
The only things holding GoH back are the bad optimization and the trash AI. It would make it a gem if they managed to fix that and expand the conquest mode.
$45 for what is essentially a MOWAS 2 remaster. Seems fairly priced for what it is, but I'll likely wait for the summer sale and try to nab it around $30.
you can buy it on instant gaming at $35
@@blust4r_687 it’s out of stock for now. Appreciate it tho
Not based on graphics and animations but:
GOH because men or war 2 once again didn’t add a dynamic, randomly generated, campaign.
You can spend hours in GOH after you beat the campaign while in MOW2 you’d have to play online or play the same mission, right?
I hope eventually they add some procedural stuff to the game.
I think i saw in a review that MoW2 did add a gamemode similar to conquest from GoH
Ive actually seen that even the historical missions have a variety of randomness to it. Not terrain or anything, unit placement, events that can happen, etc.
Goh detailing is looking like mow +coh
I like GOH, but man, the multiplayer is the worst stuff I've ever tried to play. Either get kicked, lag, or not have all the random mods someone has. It's an absolute nightmare to try to play.
Mow 2 multiplayer works well
I’m confused about who made these games, where they once the same company that split into 2?
GOH developer basically was from Robz Realism mod in MoWas 2 so when you play GoH it feels kinda smart playing with AI like in Robz mod
Oddly accurate judgment.
To me men of war seems more detailed (animation wise) sounds isnt bad
The Animations from Mow2 are very nice. 😊
Like the ancient idle smoking animation lol
GoH reste pour moi la suite de la licence Mow (1er opus). le nouveau MoW2 trop trop arcade Graphiquement tres moyen, que 3 nations malgré les 1er opus a 5 nations . j'hésite a prendre ce Mow2 dans l'état..... à 45e quand même. a éviter pour l'instant
shoud do valour and robz vs gates and mow2
I'm still waiting for a GoH huge campaign map and an AI map generator. 🙂
they milking same game since ''soldiers heroes of world war ii ''with little change🤦♂
For now, the sound and graphics of Gates of Hell is better than Men of War 2. I am going to buy Men of War 2 in the end of this month. :)
solo falto mostrar los soldados disparando mientras marchan, eso es lo unico que me encanto como lo hicieron en MOW2
extraño los fantasticos sonidos que antes tenia el GoH en sus cañones, y demas tanques. =(...... antes hasta los sonidos de los motores como el del panther, rugian y ensordecian, eso era vida jejeje o-´¨o------
los sonidos de ahora son tan mejores y estan hechos por un profesional no como antes que creo que eran de librerias de sonidos online
Fulloption???
Gates of Hell #1
And now add there grandfathers, Faces of war and Soldiers heroes of world war 2 :D
Yes yes.
@@SturmFuhrerPK really good video, doing great work 👍
Even though older GOH to me still looks the nicer textured graphical game?
well, i don't want to see both fandom to be fight each others, cause these three games are born from almost same engine and same genre... whice who better is not important, there always exist good or cons... but this is just comparison
i hope someone not to fight for these things
So Mow2 is still sub par to GOH. Spent their entire budget on adding black guys? Lol why is Mow2 not leaps and bounds ahead of goh.
Where they put shells in Flak88? MoW2))))
MOWAS2, GoH, MOW2 - In that order
Ah yes nothing better than the static and plasticky animations in MOWAS2
After watching MOW2 gameplay and style it really feels like they want to be new Company of Heroes rather then keep going what they had with Assault Squad 2.
Meanwhile GOH is just Assault Squad 2 that has been brought to 2024, with new campaign, better models and FPS system that was kinda shit in AS2.
MOW2 might succeed in what they want, seeing how disliked CoH3 was, but would have been happy to see real competitor to Gates of Hell in more realistic RTS.
I am satisfied with your answer.
Still supporting GoH
Gates of Hell is a Master piece
The antialiasing on mow2 looks better than goh, but that's about it
Gates of hell is so much fun and i love the sound design, the game sucks you in for hours, passing like minutes.
Men of War 2 has more realistic looking models. Just needs to touch up on some of the shadows. Too dark in some areas.
Wtfk. Did you see the details of units in GoH... The trucks details and tank details... Sooo far better
having played over 7 hours of mow2 which i got for free because of arena and the only reason i'm playing it it only does two things semi right and the rest of everything sucks ass, the units AI for targeting and using secondary weapons like grenades based on the situation and even then the grenade shit is still pretty broken.
Its basically the same engine only with little improvements.
MOW2 might have been acceptable... If GoH didn't exist.
Pra mim o maior defeito de men of war ll é o número de soldado e tanques nas batalhas
GoH is top tier, sry, mow2 is very arcady looking
AS2 tiger recoil was the best.
MoWAS 2 is still by far the best game of the series. Don't be fooled by the eye candy.
nah
Gates Of Hell has alot better tank gameplay, however infantry gameplay is dogwater....
why are mow2 germans so blue
Liked them all but GOH is the best IMHO
По мне GOH в лидерах. Как бы я не хотел что-бы Men Of War II стала хорошей игрой, в технической составляющей она проигрывает отсутствием логики в полоске здоровья техники, некоторых технических аспектах и графики, сверх выкрученной до мультяшности. Посему GOH по праву современный представитель стратегий про ВМВ и ВОВ.
We need a new modern engine for this genre!!! I am so sick of this GEM garbage that we have had for a decade or more now. I want a modern looking polished high quality game!
Gates of hell po enquanto em mods tem menos que o men of war 2 , questão melhor men of war ou gates para compra ?
Gates of hell is better, it is more realistic also better graphics
GOH é bem superior, principalmente no PVE e PVP
@@Kommando_Laake in PVP MOW2 wins, more stable and a lot of PVP modes
@@blust4r_687 While yes - server wise and with game mode choice you may be right, but the general PVP gameplay in GOH is far superior and leads to a lot more tactical thinking. No doubt many more hours to be spent PVP in Goh than Mow2
@@iTomBass Nicht wirklich. Wenn wir ein Spiel in Betracht ziehen, bei dem Online besser ist, dann wird es zweifellos MoW2 sein, denn in GoH ist der Multiplayer langweilig und schrecklich! In MoW2 ähnelt der Multiplayer mehr dem von CoH2 und ich kann Ihnen sagen, dass er viel cooler ist.
Hello. Found the editor and nothing happens.!! Just get the normal game.!!!
MoW2 is the same game as MoWAS2
Lmao mow2 pretending the US army wasn't segregated
Mg42 really sounded best in AS2, going to stick with Gates of Hell, Men of War 2 really didnt pay attencion to competitor, which is Gates of Hell. Not Company of Heroes 3.
Gates of Hell 😍
Gates off gel has more details
next gen
In my honest opinion.
MOWAS2 still holds up, but I think its only got a couple more years until it genuinely feels dated.
Gates of Hell I think is the best model wise, but when you compare say the download size of GoH to that of MOWAS2 or even the brand new MoW2 its nearly 3 times the size for MoW2 and almost 10 times the size of MOWAS2.
Now MoW2's models feel like a nice sweet spot of good looking while also giving it a pseudo retro feel due to the engine its using being more or less an updated version of the same engine used for MOWAS2.
All in all it boils down to personal preference, but for me I'd rather go from MOWAS2 and jump to MoW2 instead of GoH simply for the game size difference.
Cause steam says
MOWAS2 is 7.05 GB
GoH is 64.41 GB
MoW2 is 17.95 GB
You can't buy Call to Arms and best of all I wasn't wanting to buy this Men of Wars 2 now that I'm not going to
GoH❤❤❤
Can't really call it myself. They all have strong points and weak points.
I think GoH is superior but men of war is big competitor.