Culture War and Content Creation 1: The 9 Types of Leaders (Distributist's Appendix)
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 09. 2024
- What survived of the original article can be found here on my wiki:
canissociety.o...
This was a living document and this video is an attempt to resurrect a lot of the ideas that have been lost in the collapse of the discord community. More to follow (obviously).
My main channel page: / thedistributist
Website: viaobscuramedi...
Twitter: / datadistribute
Facebook: / the-distributist-14928...
Discord Link: / discord
www.subscribes...
intro music is an unnamed instrumental piece by Hildegard Von Bingen which can be found in recording here: www.amazon.com...
outro music is another performance of "Ave Generosa" which can be found here: • Hildegard von Bingen -...
For alternative channels, please check out my lovely Fiancee's channel:
/ @tiltingturtle
as well as my general mirror channel "Traditionalist Codex":
/ @canissocietycodex8029
Please leave questions and reactions. As always, like, share, and subscribe!
I'm Mauritian Struggle, and this is my new channel.
What I have decided to attempt is, realising that primarily people need a strong meaning of life to do anything, Is to teach Christianity to the self improvement, PUA and incel community.
I noticed what it did to Roosh V and wondered If we could do this en masse. If we return the spirit of a civilisation, then I reason that we get stronger.
Not sure what you think, but It seems to be somewhat working
It is working i myself am evidence of your work. Hell im actually going to start a trending mass every sinday after my exams are done, my first willingful mass in years.
@@boguslav9502 That's excellent to hear. I'm glad I could help
Check out what Paul vanderklay has been doing in his conversations with young men. It initially bounced off of Jordan Peterson but has really gone a lot further.
@@marykochan8962 While Peterson was the great phenomenon that changed many things in internet culture, Vanderklay, Pageau and E.Michael Jones go a lot further and offer a lot of practical and theoretical information on how to live as a Christian.
@@carlotapuig agreed. I have been on Paul Vanderklay's Channel with him three times. I think what he is accomplishing is amazing.
This culture war is not a new thing. Whats happening here is that one side is just realizing it.
Its been going on literally forever...
The Host part spoke to me. I put off reading books because I can't get my friends to read them with me, and I'll have no one to talk with about them. I can't get them to read Dune, let alone Dostoevsky.
Never read the books myself but the 80's movie has stuck with me my whole life.
7’s my lucky number.
@@BenjaminABoyce Oh hello Benjamin! It seems this corner of the internet is indeed small
@@BenjaminABoyce book groups with 8+ are only bound for mutiny and entropy??
Charlemagne and Distributist uploading videos on the same day, what a treat
Distribust
Link to that other channel?
Never heard of Charlemagne. I can't find them on youtube, I will check Bitchute. edit: yea it appears they are on Bitchute, this may be them: www.bitchute.com/channel/DhuH5L3p1yPH/
@@watchmyplaylist6673 czcams.com/users/TheGh0st0fSpartavideos
Who?
Jonathan Pageau is both a great ambassador and an excellent artist.
Second that!
100% agreed. Pageau > Peterson all day, any day.
I want Pageau and Micheal Malice to have a sit down. They compliment each other in my opinion.
Pageau has been one of the greatest discoveries for me in the last years. His videos convinced me to become a Christian. He unites being a genius with being an extremely likeable humble person. I don't remember him being wrong on anything, a uniquely clear mind.
@SamuraiSquirrel Pageau is an Orthodox Christian, you can't get more Christian than that:) If I remember right, he says that Peterson is not a Christian. You definitely need to watch more Pageau, he speaks about a variety of topics and had conversations with very interesting people.. Rgds
19:30 Rightwing Leadership
21:50 1. The Ambassador
28:36 2. The Artist
33:25 3. The Engineer
36:20 4. The Intellectual
41:50 5. The Archivist
46:15 6. The Educator
50:40 7. The Host(ess)
55:25 8. The Spiritual Leader
59:00 9. The Networker
1:1:35 Summary Conclusion
Just wanted to say this is quality content, this is the Distributist are BEST.
I am personally a Zoomer ( a young one in particular) and have wondered for a while how to help in this so called Culture War. Know I have an archetype to work on.
Waiting impatiantly for part 2.
I don't see how it's possible for us to have a legitimate "ambassador" at this point. I agree that Spencer was a disaster; I've never liked the guy. But won't anyone that pokes the bear hard enough to get noticed be buried instantly regardless of their reputation? The fact is, you can be the sort of stand-up guy you're describing , but the system is organized such that the second you let it known that you have dissident right opinions, that's it - reputation zero.
The problem with folks that are "good optics" - you know, have full time jobs, families, social lives, etc. is that they have way too much to lose, and there's no right-wing safety net to catch them when they are inevitably demonized and fall. I'm one of these people, and I'm pretty sure that the folks I work with every day... kind, helpful individuals that have gone to bat for me many times... I'm pretty damn sure that if they even knew my politics they'd not only spit in my coffee, they'd sabotage my fucking career.
And on accelerationism, does it have to be total civil war, or nothing. I'm sure this has been addressed everywhere (I'm not well-read on the concept) and I'm just wondering, what's wrong with a form of moderate acceleration if such a thing can exist? If we're in the frog/boiling water situation and we're swiftly on the way to "too late," which is definitely the case in my opinion, don't we need some sort of shock to the system? Maybe I'm off base and not even talking about accelerationism anymore - again, I have a pretty rudimentary understanding of the concept.
It is impossible, another problem is like it or not, many people are "brainwashed" to believe that nationalism is inherently evil in the west, that alone means getting someone who can posit our agenda is near impossible, not to mention you'd need it in multiple countries, not just 1.
When most talk about accelerationism, they are usually talking about either a economic collapse or social collapse aka civil war, the reason for this is like it or not, the right is unlikely to ever regain power in the west simply because the politicians want leftist policies, the only way for that to change is to completely clean the government of it's current problems in the system, which cannot be done without some form of chaotic upheaval, as for civil war itself, it would likely be social conflict, mass rioting, etc, not 2 armies fighting each other.
The real problem and i'm sorry dave but i consider you one as well, the "normies" (for lack of a better word), will avoid the writing on the wall, will avoid doing anything about the terrible situation we're in, until it effects them, tens of thousands of children are being trafficked by people in power in the us alone and most of the normies will get annoyed at best then go about their day, doing nothing about it, epstien raped and molested thousands on his own most likely, yet none of his "clients" will ever see justice because the people won't push for it.
Accelerationists see the collapse of society as the only hope for a return to sanity, to avoid a apocalypse of it's own, ironically for a religious man, i do not see dave mentioning how similar we are to the days of noah and of sodom and gamorrah, which is one of the signs of the "end of days" to most christians.
For me i seek a collapse, which i will undoubtedly die in, as the only way to ensure that tomorrows children won't have to live through the hellscape that is coming.
@@PresidentSunday It might have been possible 5 years ago, but i'd say we're well passed the point of no return on that, since they essentially control not just the media, but now speech online, it's only a matter of time before they shut up conservative voices.
@@PresidentSunday Listen, and understand. The progressives are out there. They can’t be bargained with. They can’t be reasoned with. They don't feel pity, or remorse, or fear. And they absolutely will not stop, ever, until your reputation is dead.
@@PresidentSunday Well i wish i had your optimism, but like i said it's not the media that worries me, it's those who control internet speech.
9 classes? *TF2 theme starts playing*
Always enjoying your videos, dude. Interesting takes and good points galore. Very well presented, too. This one is no exception. Thanks a lot for all this great content lately.
Cheers and God Bless!
I think that it’s entirely possible to synthesize the accelerationist philosophy with the community building that you’re talking about. The problem you seem to be pointing to is the anarchic accelerationists, which I would say are in the majority as of now. However, we also have the separatist accelerationists, who seek to prepare for civil war by forming militias and sustainable communities. At this point, I would reckon that about 10% of the right think that a political solution is not feasible. That is a minority, but a minority we cannot afford to lose. Therefore, we need to take up the type of “separatist” mentality, finding common ground on the networks we are trying to form.
Essentially, sustainable communities that can operate outside of the mainstream, and when the time comes, reclaim the mainstream.
What the polish nationalist right has realized is that we must take politically radical action ergo work outside of the political seats of power at a local level and grow a base. Once we have this base we infiltrate and take over local power, starosta, skarbnik and burmistrz and wójt positions. This Way we gain power over entire cities and because we have some qutonomy we can start working nów at a higher level. This imo is the Way tj go.
Because we cannot win politically as of right nów So we need to put politics aside and create a competent base first before literally parasitically infecting politics. Having local power means your party albeit not in absolute position making decisions has enough power TK actually work within the system. And has power and finance to create a voting base. As well as support and give a base of operations for your leader and groups.
There are no political solution simply only radical ones, this is a Universal rule for the right right nów. We must work outside of the system doing things that are un acceptable to Our opponents all the Time and propagating ourselves in the process, never losing aight of optics. For example in Płock the lone Christian boy who stood against the lgbt march with his cross held high, is Just this kind of action the only mistake was a lack of escalation to violence if the Polic did not stóp the march.
My mom is the boomer fullstop. My father is of boomer age but a bit more open minded
@@SonofTiamat Indeed.
hey stalin long time no see
Do you still like huey long?
That was the most on point and useful solution-oriented culture war video I think I've ever seen, congratulations.
Maybe we should start a goth country band and make it mainstream
czcams.com/video/Lwj5_SNWYc8/video.html
"make it mainstream"
As far as I understand that's hard to do since the algorithms on the streaming sites try to keep things down. Billie Eilish is actually a Hollywood project since she was a little girl, she was promoted and shot up quickly in the charts.
We can probably employ the Streisand effect to our favor if a band/artist gets shut down.
The CZcams channel “Freedom Alternative” has lots of good ideas for fighting the culture war. The channel is run by a brilliant man from Romania.
Although things look bleak in the west, the eastern Europeans had it much worse, yet they were able to defeat the communists by using a huge array of political techniques.
“Freedom Alternative” CZcams Channel,
czcams.com/channels/U-j4uuM70znbqYLORLp9NQ.htmlfeatured
“Freedom Alternative” has an excellent series on “practical politics” where they go over techniques used by political activists from all over the political spectrum.
“Freedom Alternative” Practical Politics playlist,
czcams.com/play/PLYIigOqDAKnSJ2pL7M6Hxh7vPXuXILrYq.html
Loving all the content, Dave. Hope your hiatus (when it comes) is peaceful.
10:30 I always took the JP focusing on yourself as more of an emphasis on focusing on yourself FIRST. It also seems to me that particular sentiment is directed at a younger crowd that projects all their own insecurities onto their perceived enemies.
55:00 I found myself in that exact position and came across this group: onlinegreatbooks.com/ a reading group that discusses the great books of western culture, if anyone knows of similar groups I'd love to hear about them.
Thanks for putting this together
Voxday is doing a book club it's starting with Mere Christianity.
1. Ambassador
2. Artist
3. Engineer
4. Intellectual
5. Archivist
6. Educator
7. Host
8. Spiritual Leader
9. Networker
The general sentiment is correct and I understand this is a throwaway, however some of the details are so incorrect that I'm not sure if it is a wise decision to even publish the video.
1) The problem with leadership is not that there are no leaders or that they are not being trained. Rather, the moral taste bud for authority is not trained. The people who would follow the leader will not do so due to a trained preference for disobedience. If there was a good leader, we wouldn't know and we wouldn't follow. Therefore there isn't a point in training in a leader who will have no support no matter how good he is.
2) You are severely downplaying the core reason why any right wing movement is limited - the family and loyalty moral tastebuds. Right wingers are either too young or preoccupied with protecting their families and their livelihoods to take any risks in the political or public arena. You can talk about optics all you want but any movement that doesn't give a voice to a family, and even some that do, is digging its own grave.
Like in a previous point, this is another instance of the general public being trained to undervalue family as a moral value.
3) Although I agree with the general desire for more art that depicts right wing values (like the above authority and loyalty), your approach is fatally flawed. Right wingers will NOT take risks associated with creating art. The CAN however very easily CURATE such art, especially if its already existing. Instead pushing people to take risks, why dont we support people who already are, like Trevor Moore. Why dont we order and patron the creation of another "Aeneid" to last throughout ages.
4) Much like in other 3 points, in this one you are also thinking like a leftist. You are trying to copy and make redundant what is already out there. You are making pepsi. Why not invert the patronage of patreon, and instead of giving money to peoples ideas, instead submit requested work and offer a payment and then wait for an artist to pick up the challenge. Just like moldbug is trying to take back the bit.
Moreover, its a better idea to make the worries of todays engineering and technology irrelevant - technology is stagnant and the next shift will make ALL past platforms obsolete. If you are to CURATE or ENGINEER techology - take control of that next shift.
I thumbs-downed this video because over and over again, my reaction to statements "of fact" were disbelief and shock. I don't know where you live, but a lot of what you say here is in sharp contrast to my experience.
Bad takes
"The left understands that when art is concerned, only the true, the good, and the beautiful can be given priority in any sense. Any political message that comes, must come as a secondary effect of the work itself."
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA good one Dave
Many might not like this statement but I think that Jordan Peterson is a spiritual leader masquerading as a psychologist/professor/media personality. He has been careful to present Christianity in a way that makes it seem compelling and unobjectionable to the atheistic-minded and has successfully made the case that one of the main streams our culture is downstream from (whether we know it or not) is Christianity.
@MrGuvnah Yura fraud.
@FifesAndClarions There's a lot there and I'd basically agree except to say that his eclecticism, like the fact that he draws inspiration from thinkers like Nietzsche/Jung and that his version of Christianity has a gnostic flavour, is much a part of why he's palatable to people, why they're willing to listen when he brings up Christianity. Like it or not, any appeal to the necessity for each individual to find "actual Jesus" simply wont convince anyone who is not already on that path in one form or another.
@FifesAndClarions there is a Catholic educator, it might have been Maria Montessori, who said that people cannot receive answers to questions they have not asked. I think the main contribution that Jordan Peterson has made is that he has gotten people to ask better questions and that has been a game-changer.
I would never be anywhere near this community without Peterson. I find the antipathy toward him in theses circles unfortunate, though I suppose it's to be expected considering his unorthodoxy.
It has more to do with him being a neolib individualist.
Even though I'm a leftist (progressive), I'm a huge fan of your channel. Not only are you one of the best resources for conservative thought online, you're also one of the few that can talk about progressives without a demonizing tone. I commend your thoughtful, balanced approach and I'm excited for your next installments.
he's catholic- hate the sin, not the sinner, as they say
Why do you hate white people and want to see us extinct?
@@MegaAvalonn i don't. a lot of progressives might, but that's their problem.
@@CobaltSthenia No, it's your problem, it's the movement you are identifying with. If you're opposed to a major part of what they're doing, you should be doing _something_ about it.
As part of art production, I would include satire and parody. These can be useful, despite often composed of memes these days. Just from anecdotal observation, normies who fall for a satirical piece are initially outraged. But sometimes this can be enough for some to look up other satirical pieces and see the underlying critiques.
There needs to be people who invest in a town. Buy it wholesale. Start a new kind of city. A right wing metropolitan that foils the left wing city.
A place for people from small towns to collectivise in. With it's own university, bank, media to capture the energy of youth in a new direction.
I think something not expanded upon enough was the fact that Right Wing Trolling can sometimes just target a non-issue or an easy target purely for the sake of humor. A great example was the entire "Saga" of "HWNDU", while hilarious and ultimatley effective, the amount of planning, analysis and math (look it up if you don't know it's really amazing) that went into the whole thing was insane, all by a bunch of non-centralized internet "Trolls". Could you imagine if all those "Trolls" got together to organize rallies or events or their own media campaigns, it could be truly something we've never seen before. But for whatever reason they don't.
If the right could channel into actual activism the effort the've put into past jokes we could really have something.
You're talking about nihilist anons, largely. Anonymity is kind of a necessary component for the way chans operate and they tend to be very nihilistic as a result. The purpose of memes is mostly for ridicule so it's not really possible to organize or build communities around them, even if they are useful for certain things.
> The Intellectual
I think we have a number of those, actually. The problem might be they aren't widely known, and/or the fragmentation of what used to be the trike into a number of pipelined splinter groups. (Foseti observed this happening, before he stopped blogging on his own blog).
I'm thinking of people like Bonald. In his own way, Kalb. Even Spandrell, though he's very much a Hedgehog and limited by his thoroughgoing materialism.
I'm sure I'm forgetting at least six other pepole.
Indeed, your section on the lack of dissident right intellectuals reminds me very much of this post by Bonald.
bonald.wordpress.com/2011/12/07/why-the-hell-do-i-bother/
What lack? It's more they're ignored or forgotten so we all end up being Sisyphus.
Oh: Feser is another intellectual who I would feel terrible to not name-drop here.
33:33 Hey look buddy, I'm an engineer. That means I solve problems, not problems like "What is beauty?" Because that would fall within the purview of your conundrums of philosophy. I solve practical problems, for instance: how am I going to stop some mean mother Hubbard from tearing me a structurally superfluous be-hind? The answer, use a gun, and if that don't work... Use more gun. Take for instance this heavy caliber tripod mounted lil' old number designed by me, built by me, and you best hope... Not pointed at you.
Also funny how this is the same number of classes as tf2
old meme but checks out
This is up there with Alinsky.
@The Rt. Hon. Lord High Distributionistinator from Wikipedia
"His goal for the Rules for Radicals was to create a guide for future community organizers, to use in uniting low-income communities, or "Have-Nots", in order for them to gain social, political, legal, and economic power."
What the "dissidence" needs is changing the narrative. To do that, what it probably needs is its own (very accomplished) movie... With the Internet, it now would not even depend on mainstream distribution, and could have a wider reach than independent pictures ever did before. Even epic special effects are far easier to do than they used to. How about an epic adaptation of "Camp of the Saints"? It is hugely epic, widely recognized, and incredibly sophisticated in its understanding of EVERYTHING that is going on today...
Joined Cainis Society on Facebook recently. Hope to make some efforts to really see where it goes! You’re a lovely man Dave and I’ve really found your videos a calming breath in a sea of manufactured chaos and sensationalism online.
Oh yeah, and I once again recommend having John C. Wright on for a talk. Here's his website.
www.scifiwright.com/
Just found your channel! Thank you for this beautifully concise vid. Subbed.
Read Siege.
The issue of the artist i find... Is thsg you never get enough good criticisms. I have tried writing and keep making works and no matter if i finish a project, i never get proper constructive criticisms which is beyond necessary for me. I crqve criticisms because the ultimate failure is never getting the feedback necessary. Which is why i Say we need forum for these creators. We need a place for them to i teract and spread these product of culture.
PS the only Time o get feedback is my poetry since its simply So short. But i o one of te most vital artforms we need is songs and music. Most movement in modernity have been embodied by certain songs. Songs that People pwrticipate in and that defi ę the spirit of their Time and their culture and views.
And finały some advice, dont write with a core message you want to get across that tends to form on its own. Distributist is right that Just mąkę up a story, its all there imbued by you into your story by defaukt. (When you read leftist art you will often see what they literally think, their work is to always be taken literally)
It's insanely alienating being a right-wing person who wants to do music or art for a living. Leftists just constantly hammer the idea that you can't be creative so much so that I don't even think I actually can. I mean, I can create but I'm missing that magical "it" that you are supposed to have when you do good art. They're actually successfully ruined my mental state when it comes to art and so I really think there needs to be some kind of place for right-wing artists to actually be amongst each other so that you don't end up like that.
@Boethius i agree it cant be Just this scary place it has to be quite open in fact. But even if its Just a place right wingers go, we can brand it in Such a Way that we can propagate right wing artists without scaring People off. Hell the classical art forum sounds decent. Or defiance art, that might sound more radical but could be Say a movie makers forum. The thing is 99 percent wont be good enough to break out from the forum but the point is to mąkę as much art, for the sake of practice, as possible. And then to propagate it some how in the internet, and Reality. Hell i have this fantasy that one Day a great scultpr shows up and mąkes an Amazing sculpture hailing the right and its heroes in a subtle but epic Way and simply with the help of this kind of forum manage to place it in his city Square as an art protest. People See the quality and passion behind it. The only way we go from forum to normie is generally art festivaks at peak Time in cities. Its a place to sell books have People read them out loud. And since they arent excplicitly for the sole purposes of being right wing right wing, hardly anyone Will detect what is going on. To this end you can hołd competitions and take your Best to thus place or choose their works. As far as branching out from the web, its going to be in protest form, imagine protest Theatre pkays put in by conpetent actos etc. Or nice graffiti or something along thoslines. Or simply as festivaks and competitions.
But then the issue is how do we mąkę sure this remains right wing, maybe an i tolerancję for progressive books, and a Policy that is subtly anti leftist with vague terms of Service meant to allow purges of leftists. While also never being excplicitly right wing and trad.
Either Way the general idea is that any Press, is good Press, as Long as you set your optics up right.
@@rhysf.505 I know the feeling most writers forum have become overrun and infestwd with lgbt and progressive writers. Mean while there are no other aspiring right wing writers and any art that cant wuickly be digested becomes aliebated yby virtue of People simply being Łazy.
And as far as that it, that something. We all have it, in particular the right has it and as bad as this sounds i often find that the Best Way to go about it is, to find an ideał you want to describe and let the emotion absolutely flow. Once you have a first draft then you go back and mąkę it technically sound, but the foundations of all art, in my opiniom, is that we imbue it with soul, spirit, and that is what mąkes it So animated. The left for all its follys and absolute stupidity at least let this over one them. IMO the right wing is far too obsessed with being rstional that we forget to let Our emotions into the Picture.
@FifesAndClarions i tend to like to give Everyone a chance that Way we catch as many of those that are destined to be great, while fostering a community and developing. Id rather have 10 geniuses, and a milion idiots than 1 genius and 10 idiots. With 3ach genius being worth their weight in Gold and the idiots forming the community and learning from them, we can See something great emerge and in fact change People from amateurs into competent artists.
@Boethius Boethius that is True, but thats the crux of the issue is how do we maintain those optics and avoid a take over. I think there might be a other option to simply have a toś that isnt as vague, but at the same Time mąkę the Focus of the forum something that Will naturalny attract right wing artists. Conbined with your idea and i think we have a solution on Our hands. Regardless its evident that we need a space for control. There could also be a means of promoting specific content to the top, by merit of course, and thus left wing content would simply Fall behind as well if it exists at all.
I would argue that a "content creator" is not an artist, unless that art is performative. Sitting and reading from a script is not the Artist, but the Educator. I think the right has far too many Educators, and not enough Artists. There are enough people writing scripts about ideas and too few doing things like making music, telling stories, or making other forms of art, and no, commenting on whatever trash was published by Vox yesterday is not ART. If you want to make a commentary channel, comment on the political implications of whatever is the favorite show right now. Byron de la Vandal made art, Xurious made art. Black Pilled's movie commentaries are more like art than most of these other moderately right wing channels. Go watch The Boys, and comments on how the villain is yet again a tall handsome blonde-haired blue-eyed white guy and how his foes are a black guy, a short goth woman and several other characters who look like they just crawled out of a sewer. Comment on how black clover uses royalty to portray how authority and power over the peasantry is bound to a duty to protect and possibly die for them.
Finally, stop claiming that center-left liberals are on our side or ARE us. They're the ones who created this problem to begin with. They planted the seed which produced the vine that winnowed away the garden by its touch.
I love your insights, well thought out and pragmatic.
Here's a job for any archivists out there: Dave briefly refers to a female youtuber named "Critical Condition" who now seems completely wiped off of CZcams. Any old videos anywhere?
Still on Instagram, guest on the Blonde channel. Does mainly mommy content these days
I guess we can start Small
some small organization that helps people combat nihilism and mental illness by taking them to hikes, camping,
talking about philosphy, religion and workds of art.
nothing too fancy or expansive, nothing too political
for you to become a christian you need to live the christian life first (bishop barron)
i guess living one weekend like our ancestors, finding meaning though hardship can help people, scpecially white males.
you can do this twice a year with 20 people first. then you do in other states and expand.
One unfortunate thing about the Intellectual part is, that no matter how smart one might be, they are screamed down as a Racist, or as an ebil whrite wong Nazhi WAAAHH!!!! in most academic circles.
I think Keith Woods falls into category 4 the intellectual. I do wish he would publish his own work. He is very well read.
Sounds like a better game plan for Christianity.
Thats what I was thinking too. It seems like a game plan for a dogmatic system.
Question - would you consider Justin Murphy an ally/leader in this culture war? If anything he'd be an educator, but I'm not sure if he would even consider himself within this culture war.
33:09 That is very, very good advice for anybody entering a creative field.
The guy sold 'get your shit together' to millions of paying customers.
😆 🤣 smart dude.
1. The Ambassador
2. The Artist
3. The Engineer
4. The Intellectual
5. The Archivist
6. The Educator
7. The Host
8. The Spiritual Leader
9 The Networker
People need spirituality, but not necessarily Christianity. Paganism and the Western Esoteric Tradition could be more interesting alternatives.
You would seem to be the kind of guy who would shut down any of Lily Orchard's arguments for good.
We Brazillians got lucky this time in history. A philosopher named Olavo de Carvalho has served the archetype of The Intellectual and this has made a big difference in our path.Read the man. He has a thing or two to teach us.
Leadership is for chumps. The first thing an oppressor will ask a rebellion is "Who's your leader?", for obvious reasons : leaders can be corrupted or assassinated, and if they're not replacable then the rebellion will die out.
What you need is a set of simple, clearly defined, and immediately actionable goals (e.g. "repeal law X", "lower income tax to N%", "make peace with country X", etc.). Everything else can be achieved through organic emergence.
Do you think Trump would be in office if he’d spent his campaign putting people to sleep with easy, actionable solutions? In a democracy, the mob only responds to the loudest voice in the room
@@urthofthenewsun8465 Cultural emergence is very different from representative democracy.
Where can I get this in text? I tried the link up top but got a dead website.
Micheal Knowles is the best national young personality who fits the media personality role. He also doesnt fall into the ideological traps of the edgy alt-right (that is anti-Christian) and knows which battles to fight and which to not
If zoomers are like you say we are doomed. Tho being one of them I can confortably say that accelerationism is not popular.
how can one transform themselves into being an Ambassador?
Thanks for this. This is the way forward.
Finishing what you started is Conscientiousness and Order.
This is a fantastic summary. What are we waiting for? Who has a start on something where some of us could plug in?
I have a discord server and a wiki that I am working on. The Canis Society has a website at canissociety.org
We have intellectual leaders and a whole lot of philosophical basis. Greg Johnson, Collin Cleary, Kevin MacDonald, Ricardo Duchesne, Guillaume Faye, even Paul Gottfried and Richard Spencer (yes, his 2010-2014 articles used to be great) to name but a few living writers, and Sam Francis, Lothrop Stoddard, Yockey, Vico, Nietzsche, Spengler, Heidegger, Carl Schmitt, just off the top of my head as foundational thinkers. Moldbug is basically a computer nerd with megalomaniacal impulses and who -- ironically enough -- eschews mentioning his "precursors" (I'm using the term kindly, as these include no lesser names than Max freaking Weber) thus showing even petit intellectuals with an actual academic training that he's just a blabbering dilettante with a STEM background, not to be taken seriously. Thinking about it, maybe this is why this engineer has such a hard on for the guy...
Anyways I'd like to talk to you on my channel sometime
I believe you forgot about an archetype that is necessary. See, as the communities the leaders you mentioned created grow from grassroots meeting and tea sessions and what not, into actual movements, they’re bound to face opposition from the Cathedral and its forces, and it seems to me that we, on the right, are completely ignorant of how powerful these forces actually are.
Those who control the press, the TV stations, social media, academia, will not entertain our ideas. They will not allow them to grow and will suppress them in any way we allow them to get away with. And while forming our own alternative means of communication is a necessity and a laudable goal, we have largely succeeded at that: there are countless blogs, a somewhat well developed community that you’re part of yourself, there are sites on DuckDuckGo and so on... everyone knows what I’m talking about.
Yet we are still seen as fringe, as hot headed outcasts, and more of the same will not help.
What we need is The Lawyer. Someone that:
1) Ensures that we use every opportunity the system gives us to protect our values
2)Manipulates and alters the system so that more opportunities are available to us
This is especially important in the Anglosphere, where legal systems work by precedent. We cannot allow them to supress right wing praxis, even is the person in question wasn’t engaging in it with the intention of benefiting us. I speak, eg, of the Bake the Cake controversy. Had the case gone over to the other side, a dangerous precedent would have been set, that would have forever limited proper resistance and organization on our part. This was all prevented by proper legal action.
Another example I can think of is the recent wave of pro-life legislation in America. While we are still far from our goal, it was a huge step forward, and we need more people to valiantly push forward for steps like these. Likewise, we need people to set precedents in other cases that would benefit us: squash any attempt at policing speech (and manipulate public opinion on this, though, this is the job of the Ambassador), punishing orthodox believers for their views, harshly punish any progressive teacher that forces their view in the classroom, etc.
Set precedents, introduce legislation, bombard them with lawsuits, and so on. As we, hopefully, grow, we will come in contact with the system of the Cathedral and its mecha-normative aspects. We need specialists suited for this.
Other than that, this was a great video.
You hit the nail right there I am an aspiring author and have about 6 open projects
Agent of Chaos !
Theories of Social Entropy !!!
It can all be summed up by saying complaining about the culture is not the same thing as fighting the culture war. To win, the first thing that needs to happen is that we need to show up and actually fight.
the wiki is down
Why do you make so much of the Brendon Iche case? He could've resisted the pressure and avoided resignation. Maybe the real fight only got started when he decided to step away from it.
So he couldn’t have. His entire company was revolting against him.
55:55 Well, I wonder how many people have a spiritual nature, and how many are just going through the motions. Sometimes I think about how maybe people would have spiritual experiences more often if they were getting shrooms or DMT. Maybe people should be allowed it and it should be destigmatized. I think about how many people only do God things because they were caught by hellfire and brimstone sermons, and only exist to dodge the wrath of Pascal's Wager.
I think the Left has plenty of leaders. I think the Right also has plenty of leaders. This issue is the poor quality of leaders. Too many people are forgetting what this country was founded on and go back to the foundation of our country. The Constitution was written for all citizens of the USA. Doing this will unite us so we can really work together. If we can’t respect these basic foundations, people will always be disrespected. I recently heard something this : “
In the USA, the Liberal Citizens need to fight for the Constitutional Rights of the Conservative and Independant Citizens.
The Conservative Citizens need to fight for the Constitutional Rights of the Liberal and the Independant Citizens.
The Independant Citizens need to fight for the Constitutional Rights of the Liberal and Conservative Citizens.
All the citizens regardless of their personal stance on faith, need to fight for all Constitutional Rights regarding religious freedoms.
All United States Citizens need to fight for all Constitutional Rights for all citizens. They must be from the Original Constitution and Amendments with their original meaning. They need to do fight for each other’s rights no matter if they do not agree to the Constitution Of the United States Of America.Then and only then, will true leadership work in the United States Of America.
The United States Of America is a Republic not a Democracy. Our pledge also says this. “ I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States Of America and to the REPUBLIC for which it stands, one nation under God, INDIVISIBLE, with LIBERTY and JUSTICE FOR ALL.” We must not focus on the things that divide us, we need to focus on the things that unite us. It doesn’t matter what side you are on. It matters that we stand together. madisonproject.com/2013/09/we-the-people-a-constitutional-republic-not-a-democracy/
nice
A hiatus from not making content? That would be nice.
Asking for a friend: I'm entering law school this fall and I'm a reactionary - what branch of law should I study to be most useful to the movement?
One that you can get you a job that works with your work life balance and location.
@@TheDistributist OK, but can we pretend that my friend is either independently wealthy or clever enough to have already taken care of the above and try to go beyond general career advice? It's fine if you don't think lawyers are important to the movement, or if you're not aware of any specific branch of law that would be more beneficial than others.
@@newcomer3674 If you are in the US I would look at edge cases that could go to the SC. The one thing Trump achieved was tipping the balance of justices.
Shit, much better, switched over
Im gona disagree with the need to a spiritual leader. I come form an unorganized religion and its just fine learning your faith form your parrents and grandparrents.
You are definitely interesting, Sir. 😉
Good video, again.
I don't disagree with your spiritual leader section (as hazy as spirituality always is), but it is the most complicated when trying to create some sort of order, imo.
The one thing that speaks true with the majority of religions (in some way, at least) and even appeals to the majority of non-religious (in some way, at least. Believe it, or not) is, the survival of the human race.
I'd be interested in ideas on how to appeal to the majority in this area, without trying to rubber stamp the idea as Catholicism or some other such nonsense? Stubbornness is as sin isn't it, makes me wonder how far hypocrisy and misunderstanding goes?..
I look forward to your next video. 😀
This is strange, I just went from a vid where you said you were a progressive, and now you hate progressivism, that's a fast turn around.
Where did I say I was progressive?
@@TheDistributist Your Bioshock video.
I said I WAS a progressive after being an objectivist but I came back to the non libertarian right
@@TheDistributist Mustn't have been paying enough attention.
Have you ever tried contributing with bigger right wing channels to get this message across
Big right wing channels that solicit dissident content, on CZcams?
@@TheDistributist yeah, like John Doyle, Steven Crowder, etc
@@MikeP5830 well I don’t like those guys, why would they like me?
@@TheDistributist aw ):
our conservative " leaders in the west are progressive too. We don't need leadership. We need servants who are good administrators within constitutional bounds
Why are you deleting comments?
Horoúathos I’m not
@@TheDistributist I'm sorry for accusing you then, but my comment is missing. Don't know how it disappeared. I thought you deleted it because I was critical of one of your points.
I'm a mix of the Artist and The Intellectual. Though I've followed through on my projects. This is my side account so it's kind of weird to talk to you on this one.
I think it's a shame to frame this as a part of the culture war and the left-right bubble, I'd say we need these types of people in every community and realizing this would end the culture war. There is a lot of bias in your model, it sounds just as bad as the alt-right and ctrl-left models of this kind, but the structure is sound I would say.
@Skar Scalp :))) skills right there
@Skar Scalp boom!:))) didn't get that good old ignorant vibe for a while, let be enjoy it for a minute ey?:)
32.50
Well, I am a writer with right wing, if the term is broadly defined, political opinions.
I have actually completed a few short stories:
terrorhousemag.com/author/andrew-stallard/
Now that my shameless plug out of the way the editor of this magazine is a man named Matt Forney who was a former dissident right political activist who left the movement due to the gross failures in leadership discussed in this talk. He started this strictly non-ideological literary magazine precisely to encourage more of the sort of authentic content creation discussed in this talk.
You say almost everything twice, why?
not first
Way too much criticism of Trump guys. He's doing the best by far you can expect of anyone in his position.
Mold bug wannabee
What exactly does Christianity have to offer? For as long as this video is, your preaching to the choir far too much. You make claims matter of factly assuming your audience is already on board. For me, I'm listening to things that more or less make sense, but then you start talking about Christianity and it all goes off the rails. Christianity offers, if anything anything positive at all, a sense of community. Beyond that, it's literally just delusion.
This video is not about Christianity religion is mentioned only in passing.
@@TheDistributist okay that's fine. But if you care to, please answer the question.
What does Christianity have to offer? If you've answered this already in another video, perhaps I'll find it eventually as I binge your channel, but I really would like to know. From the videos I've watched, I've grown a respect for your intelligence, and to me, intelligent people believing God is the ultimate oxymoron, and it's a subject I'm very interested in. I'm not trying to debate you or anything neccessarilly, this is just something that fascinates me deeply.
@@TheDistributist also, I'm cringing my way through your debate with Vaush, and i gotta say, you did a great job. Much respect for even bothering to talk to that cesspool.
After the declain or colaps in which ever form it takes, once the landscape is filled with long dead pieces of technology we can start the classic Sci fi let's worship technology religion.
Peak bait and switch!
the problem is, there is no Divine -- your model crumbles.
Correction: There is no such thing as a "right wing atheist".
Great video otherwise!
That is not an argument, JBPtard.
That's a giant strawman. You didn't adress my point at all and you are moving a goalpost.
You are just a liberal larping as a traditionalist.
(Commenting in order to see future comments)
Caramel Johnson The secret to a happy life is not to argue with idiots.
@Caramel Johnson Thank you for informing me!
please get speech therapy when you go on your hiatus