BABYMONSTER: The Return Of Vocals In Kpop?
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 05. 2024
- Tell a friend, tell a friend, tell a friend... let's go!
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Baby I'ma monster...
0:55 Vocal colors
3:58 Vocal skills
4:56 5
5:54 4
7:41 3
8:52 2
10:20 1
12:34 Live singing, MR removed videos
14:36 Overperforming?
15:31 The conclusion...
16:33 Outro
babymonster, babymonster sheesh, babymonster live vocals, babymonster vocal analysis, babymonster vocal ranking, blackpink, blackpink met gala, jennie, ruka, asa, ahyeon, rami, rora, pharita, chiquita, aespa, nmixx, le sserafim, coachella, kpop encore stages, kpop stage presence, kpop vocal technique, babymonster fanmeet tokyo, batter up, stuck in the middle, like that - Krátké a kreslené filmy
![[AI COVER] How would BABYMONSTER sing “Armageddon” by aespa](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jgUlZ63syFg/mqdefault.jpg)
Finally, a rookie group who can actually sing their songs live 🫠🥲
Don't forget Kiss of Life
Are you new? Because there's quite a few groups that can sing live since rookies before this
young posse always does great live
KISS OF LIFE , BOYNEXTDOOR, TWS , ZEROBASEONE, YOUNG POSSE,
Yep only em can save the industry now😭
I'm obsessed with Rora's voice,too. And sadly having the same concern like you have...Hope she's gonna be given more chances to showcase what she has to offer in the future.
Yes, I would love to hear her voice more, she's one of my favorite vocalists in Baemon together with Haram and Canny ❤
SAME!!!! MY FAVORITE VOICE 🩵🩵🩵
I think Rora's parents are pretty strict taking into account that she didn't stay in dorm despite living in Seul. So probably they put some kind of conditions (maybe until she finished grammar school). Like you can see that Rora is very outspoken but you couldn't see that in last evaluation because she had probably the least footage. This is a reason as well why she is less popular but that definitely would change soon. Probably she would MC on Inkyago or Mcountdown.
SAMEE🎉🎉
They’re just months into their debut and you’re worried? lol….they have another 7 yrs together. You kpop fans love to be so pessimistic. I can sense a bit of toxicity already. 😂
We can argue about Rora being a main vocalist but I think that atp Ahyeon and Rami are the main vocal duo chosen by the producers
yess sadly rora voice suit emotional and expressive song which is directly opposite to their songs🥲so it's hurt being a rora stan by seeing them, i fear they will ever use her properly. eg: haewon (she is used but lily and sullyoon are pushed vocally)
@@Binna4037don't worry ,it's just they only have 6 songs , wait until they release a full album . Even though main track will be hip hop b-sides will be vocal heavy . I think they are waiting for the right songs for rora .
@@Binna4037 you're wrong af. Sullyoon is not more pushed vocally than Haewon at all. Lily has high notes and that's it, Haewon is pushed as much as lily
@@Binna4037Haewon is pushed as much as lily and gets a lot of demanding parts.
@@Binna4037 I think Rora has less parts because she has to focus on studying while ending grammar school. Her parents despite having kid in show business looks pretty responsible taking into account that she didn't stay in dorm despite not living in Seul. Clearly this was a reason why she was less featured in their show while she is now pushed as main group speaker.
Honestly, Rami doesn't get enough praise despite being the strongest in the group vocally! (This comment section is proof of it)Her vocal agility, healthy belting, pitch accuracy and absolute comfort in all her registers is mind-blowing. She's definitely one to look out for and it's so frustrating to see someone so vocally endowed not get the recognition they deserve. However as you said, her voice is the most atypical in the group, which may deter some people but i honestly think its serves as a strength to have an extraordinary voice .
Rami does get praises. Wydm.
Most people in the comments is from other fandom ao expect already the jealousy and comparison and them inserting their so called vocal GODS of KPOP in the topic comparing them to kids 🤣 at the end of the day babymonster love because of their talent and Rami is appreciated as well in Twitter other social media also. So don't worry.
She doesn't get as much praises as she deserves unfortunately @@Boesisi_548
There is no best thing. Every voice matters. that makes baby monsters Comes with amazing sound Because they have very different tones, to the point of complete opposites.
Rami ❤❤
Rora has caught my eye since their evaluation period, sadly she isnt seemed to be pushed as much as other members yet. Hope to see more of her in upcoming album
Same girl 😭😭😭 in group where theres already so many talented memebers its gonna be hard to show everyones full potential....i hope next comeback we get to see more of rora
Rami Rora & Pharita’s voices are just soooo good
yessss
Pharita's vocal color is my favorite
Ikr
❤❤❤
Glad to see Pharita's praise😭
She is talented but underrated
I don't get people who put Pharita at the bottom, she consistenly gets some of the most difficult parts to sing for a reason
@@Robalexe true
Very true🥲Let's keep rooting for her
Yup.. I like her... Personality and voice... But seem a bit underrated... Need to support her more
her voice is kind of plain. i mean she's definitely stable but her voice feels flat most of tge time@@Robalexe
Rami and Rora are powerhouse and standout vocalists. Pharita shows potential as well. They bring something to the kpop sphere however, YG needs to play their cards right with their music and creative direction because they aren't utilising the full potential of the member's vocal skills, especially in ballads. So far, YG seems to still put them in their comfort zone with their formulaic and predictable song structures. Sheesh in fact, didn't bring variety to their discography. Sheesh sounds rather predictable and flat. I want to hear some early 2000s pop music from them specifically if they take notes from Birtney Spears since these members are highly stylistic vocalists. Birtney Spears is also a singer who relies on style over technique so I think it will fit the members a lot and it gives YG some variety in their catalogue.
Go listen to “LIKE THAT”…it’s so different than Sheesh. I don’t like Sheesh much, but at least they’re starting off better than NMixx. Even NMixx is coming around with their music now with their latest comeback.
@inquisitvem6723 I listened to that. Despite giving variety, never release a track from assy Charlie Puth like I don't like this man. Like that is fine, but it's very sparse and bland like there is no oomph and substance. It's too simplistic. I need something more than just guitar samples like take OnlyOneOf's Instinct and Jaehyun's Forever Only as an example. They use guitar samples throughout the track, yet they sound more fulfilling, and they have distinctive personalities in their compositions. That is what Like That lacks music-wise.
@@slaystinn why not? Many kpop groups have songs written for them by western artists. Also they’re still only months into debut, I might not like Sheesh, but their other songs are decent. They still have 7 years.
Wait what you want them to be like Britney Spears? She never recognized as a good singer, if you actually have a great singer you should make them sing like Christina Aguilera, or Ariana Grande, not Britney Spears..
@ddhika7332 I say Britney Spear because she has one of the best discographies in Western pop. I listen to her albums, and they hold a lot of nostalgia and character to them. She has a distinctive early Y2k pop discography, and that is what I want Babymonster to do. I don't like Ariana Grande and Christina Aguilera's discographies a lot. Therefore, I chose Britney Spears, and Babymonster can enhance and further develop this Britney Spears inspiration by their vocals.
My favourite is Rami gotta say her agility is IMPRESSING at her age.
You know what's crazy? Some idols in their 20s and 30s can't even do half of what Rami did. It's wild 😭😭
Really loving her low tone. First time heard it i had to replay it couple times cause it was good. Since women has naturally high pitch voice a lower one gives her edge. If she develop more she could be like Miley Cyrus and her low tone agility
@@mooblink4ever899 exactly !!! and yet you find people hating on babymon even tho they are literally babies...
#BABYMONSTER is nominated for ROOKIE OF THE YEAR at 34th Seoul Music Awards vote in PODOAL.
I love their unique vocal colors. I strongly prefer when groups incorporate performers with more distinct voices because they yield much more interesting results than when every vocalist sounds the same.
Strongly agree!
Yes, the presence of BM has caused a hot issue. It is a good opportunity for a group that already has talent. Why do some people want to devalue others by saying who is better?
True, I genuinely get annoyed sometimes when I can't even tell which member is singing in some groups cuz they all just sound the same
I noticed most singer reactors find Rora as their favorite. I believe because of the emotion and technical ability is shown.
Hopefully, she gets to shine with more line distribution. But, also popularity plays a part.
Rora, Rami and Ahyeon are mostly the favourite of vocals coaches rami is already good some vocal coaches said Ahyeon and Rora have great potential and have great bright future as well
Ohhh I'm pretty sure Rami and Rora will be one of the greatest vocalist in kpop. They sound healthy, comfortable, confident🤍I especially enjoy Rami's voice, she loves to experiment, everytime we see her she shows something different, she's evolving so fast😳
There is no best thing. Every voice matters. that makes baby monsters Comes with amazing sound Because they have very different tones, to the point of complete opposites.
Pharita has improved so much !! I can tell that girl worked so hard!! Her tone of quality is mesmerizing ❤️🔥
Happy to see Pharita being praised for her vocals ❤ Girly is hella talented but underrated as a vocalist sometimes I see her being placed on the 5th rank before asa and ruka and Chiquita and Ahyeon are placed above no hate
Ahyeon is great at high notes and Chiquita has a soft soothing voice
Pharita's voice is a mix of chiqui and Aheyoniee
I agree.It sad she has shot line in Dream.I think Dream suit pharita voice.
Babymonster already a very good live performers like all YG artist, in such a young age that's incredible.
Look at their japan fan meet that's look like concert, the future is very bright for them.
People who understand music will definitely say that Rora's vocals are good..I like the vocals of the 3 Korean members..but Rora's vocals are my favorite.
I understand music as well I can tell babymonster have a bright future and their fan meet proved how vocally good they are what I love about these kids is they are not afraid to sing their hearts out loud.
More than good. Best
rami is 16 but sings like she’s been through 6 divorces
perfect description of Rami's voice. I find her tone to be dark, and mysterious. She has a way of expressing a dark and painful past. Her jazz cover was a surprise for me and I would really like to hear her cover some of Adele's work because, their styles seem to be a perfect match.
Thank you SO MUCH for putting some respect on Pharita and Rora's names - especially Pharita. I won't name names, but there's another vocalist that gets all the kind comments, credit, and attention for vocals with this group and it honestly frustrates me so much because fans hated this person at first and now they love them. They just follow trends and what they think they have to say, vs. realizing this group is stacked with MULTIPLE talented vocalist and Pharita frequently has the hardest, or one of the hardest, vocal parts in their songs and she crushes it. She's easily a Main/Lead Vocalist.
I really happy when you point out about the lack of intonation ahyeon has. She also one of the vocalist that lack dynamic which it is much more important that belt for me.
She literally have the most dynamic when she sings and her intonations is great as well I love her dangerously cover recently and her just one Bieber monster cover I love her scars to your beautiful high note as well she really sings well.
@@Francheska291 Do you know what dynamics are?
@@Francheska291okay…
@@martacastillo6272absolutely I know 😊 I mean I will not comment if I don't know to begin with and I will not also give an example which aong cover which Ahyeon nailed sheich she gave a amazing dynamics and intonation. I mean yes she's not the best out there but what I love about Ahyeon is her confidence in her singing which is rare in KPOP nowadays at the age of 17..
Yes she will improve so much cause she already has good control on her voice and she have so much potential to become one of the best vocalist in babymonster ❤
I only listen to them occasionally, but noticed that all of them sing well! Rami is crazily talented, she can easily pop up to the 6th octave and her voice is really agile. So she has the darkest voice in the group? Interesting. Rora sounds solid, hope to hear more from her.
I don't know, sometimes Ahyeon's belt scares me. It reminds me of the rockers I used to listen to, and so many of them ended up having problems with their voice. I hope she can belt more comfortably and get even better vocally.
I feel you, Pharita's and Rami's belts are definitely less "scary" even though you could say they don't pack as much of a punch I guess
❤❤
Unpopular opinion but Pharita’s voice is my favourite. It’s as clear as glass and puts me to ease ☺️ She’s like a Disney Princess
Same
Glad to hear Pharita's praise 😭
Nobody Praise her as vocalist
Everybody are only Rami Rora Ahyeon's vocal
They are good but Pharita also deserves praise
❤ i think so ,i love Pharita.and her voice.
Pharita got beautiful face personality and voice...fans need to recognise her as well...
I love Pharita's voice.♥️
❤
Me too
They have so much potential
Ive loved Rami‘s voice since the beginning in their„survival show“, her runs are so amazing?? And then I was so disappointed when Ahyeon went viral for her singing and no one focused on Rami, who’s an objectively the better singer 😭
Wdym rami didn't get any credit? Literally went trending for that jasmine sullivan cover alone.
Let's not pretend Rami is underrated. She isn't.
Only Rora is
She went viral all over social media, you’re just too focused on Ahyeon’s popularity to notice that Rami is the most liked vocalist, most ppl like ahyeon’s stage presence, not necessarily her vocals
#BABYMONSTER is nominated for ROOKIE OF THE YEAR at 34th Seoul Music Awards vote in PODOAL.
Yeah rami is better vocals than ahyeon but ahyeon stage presence is caught by people attention. But i like ahyeon vocals though and ofcoure rora.
When i saw ahyeon's performances, my first thought was she's a bit "reckless" in singing and sometimes in dancing. That's why her belts sometimes are not easy on the ears and are more shouty.
Also, their music shows live performances was pretty sus from the start, you couldn't hear much movement in their voice and when some members put down their mics earlier than needed, you can still hear their vocals perfectly clear.
Backing vocals work like that especially ending are louder than beginning. Because you take breath at the beginning of your part and because you are dancing there is high probablity that your ending would be unstable or even you don't have time to sing that part because you would lack of breath. For example you can hear that ASA backing track is made that way that she never rap her last sentence. So girls put microphone down because that's how they are trained to work with backing track. Don't take a risk because there is high probablity of fuckup. Of course professionally they should pretend that still sing. But every group which sing pretty loudly do that.
Yeah she definitely likes taking risks
@@martacastillo6272 Well working well with backing is also part of professional craft of performers who sing ad dance simultaneously. In my opinion big reason of Le sserafim controversies on Coachella was lack of experience with that. That's why Sakura performance was clearly better than normally because she is the most experienced in this matter in this group. Of course good vocal training is needed as well for that.
Because the music shoe is pre recorded already the fan cam is definitely the not so live version of them singing while the broadcast one is them really singing LIVE which if you watch it again their mics and voices are in sync. I mean that's how music show works.
Music show use lot of camera & more than one take for performers, blame video editor for that, look at radio show, that's aired live if you want to hear their live vocals, lame ass used mushow to shade 😂😂😂
Thank you! I sometimes find people overhyping Ahyeon but I find her voice to be very sharp and not the best on the ear. I hope she gets to showcase other parts of her voice too besides belting.
I love love love Rora’s tone. She’s an amazing vocalist and she needs to be shown off.
I mean it their song of course she will belt make sense. People not overhyping her Ahyeon is really a great singer your taste and ear like is different from the other so I hope don't say random words because people have different taste they love her voice no need to belittle other people perspective just because they love Ahyeons voice 🙃
@@Francheska291 Yeah, Ahyeon really good at singing the n word
@@ChadGPT17401 she's a korean teenager that sang a song as it was written, she didn't know the cultural context behind it. she has also never repeated it. it's not like when Giselle said the n word bc in her case she attended an international school from a young age.
@ChadGPT17401
You ain't no chad, by hating on a teenager. Grow up
@@human7491 still a chad though?
Finally someone voice out my opinion
1. ahyeon high note isn't healthy at all it's risky for her future as a vocalist, she utilize her volume well but she needs to find healthier way to belt
2. Imo pharita voice suits low to middle more instead of higher notes, it sounds a bit shrill for me. I get it she gets tons of high and clear singing parts cuz she's stable and she has solid English pronunciation but I js enjoy her low middle more
3. YG producers dk what to do with rora 💀, I watched their 1st recording behind. She's a vocalist who knows how to sing not merely copying certain singing style like most of kpop idol but she's getting a bit mediocre? cuz they keep giving her random falsettos parts and done. with her type I feel like they should give the higher notes to her instead she has so much potential and I feel like SM would've handled her better
Agree with everything. I think the reason why rora's position as a vocalist is undetermined in a way is because yg is pushing ahyeon and rami as main vocals. Ahyeon got the high notes even tho rami would've done a better job on it and her vocals is clearly not up for it. They think powerful voice is best and fail to consider that those type of vocals can sound bad when not properly trained.
@@rosesyn I feel like if they start to a different approach musically like doing more singing chorus or rnb rora might have a chance, ahyeon stick to low and middle along with pharita ,give rami and rora the higher, and chiquita will make the balance among them
@@rosesyn Ahyeon barely even have a line on their song so what pushing are you talking about? They don't have positions to begin with they only yg position revealed is center which is Ahyeon that's all. And Ahyeon deserved to belt because she can do it their fan meeting literally proved how good she is she's so fcccking stable and her voice is so powerful even the audience are shock how good she is live..
Agree with all of this
She has a chorus and a rap part as well.... Wdym and she did get a lot of lines in their bsides...@@Francheska291
Im in love with Rora and Chiquita vocals❤️❤️❤️❤️
I all agree with you and thank you a lot for this candid review. As Nswer, I'm genuinely thrilled to see another group capable of live performances debut in the K-pop scene. It's even better that they're very young ones with high potential. Adding to the established groups like NMIXX, Aespa, STAYC and etc, I hope the new girl groups with true talent and passion, such as Kiss of Life, Young Posse, and Baby Monster, will continue to enrich the K-pop landscape. Here's to all the groups that work sincerely and earnestly-may they thrive and prosper!
Yes sadly Hybe girl groups have really good music but they don't have the proper vocal training, i know your comment has nothing to do with them but i wanted to point out the big difference in training system these companies have, it's quite surprising, when you hear for example the weakest vocalists of this group sounding much more better live than their regular idols even though i would agree NewJeans members have very good voices specially Danielle and Hanni, and Le Sserafim simply has a vocalist that is going through a bad vocal period.
this right here!! even if some ppl don't vibe with nmixx's or baemon's music, it's still SO GOOD to see talented idols slowing becoming the trend again. it's a shame that the biggest oligopoly in kpop has been pushing mediocre vocalists to the point that kpop as a whole had its image tarnished. at least we know that talent always wins in the end as it is the only thing that stands the test of time.
I agree! I don’t understand why the fandoms fight when more vocal groups in K-pop should be exciting for everyone
@@moonlightespt1946The problem with hybe is their obsession with beauty.Hybe just recently has hired female trainees and bought subsidiaries a few years ago.They usually ignore trainees or potential female trainees with good vocal foundations to create their cookie cutter visual groups.They also have a weird obsession with very young female trainees that lack proper training .R u next was a survival show under hybe ,where they had two very capable vocalists such as jiwoo and Chanelle but they didn’t fit their second version of new jeans ,so they ultimately eliminated both of them.They should focus on the quality of their artists skills instead of the looks as they would even go that far to destroy their very young idols teeth to get that "perfect" look with veneers.That company is such a shame honestly…
@@moonlightespt1946 It's all credited to the song producers. They're the talent behind all the catchy HYBE songs.
rora and rami are a great vocal duo and i honestly hope that they keep improving. knowing yg vocalists, they usually just stop developing their voices after debut which is a bummer so i hope these girls work on their vocals even more
rora is freaking amazing, i am SO excited to hear her vocal growth in the coming years 💘
Pharita had ever win in 1st place with chiquita in last evaluation vocal blind test ep.4 by Yang Hyun-suk
But many comment in this video say her voice is bad. How do you think of this to believe. Between Yang Hyun-suk who bring blackpink so many popular in this world or anonymous comment in this video who can't find what they are success.
Very fck funny 5555
Yes. Pharita is the most stable in live performance especialy fan meet in Japan.
Betul, YG yang mendidiknya bertahun-tahun, dia lebih tau mana yang terbaik, sedangkan orang-orang yang berkomentar disini baru melihat sebagian kecil sisi baby monster
I am so hyped for their possible progression especially Rami, Chiquita and Rora.. however the Nmixx comparisons.. yeah no maybe ZB1 their vocal line seriously doesn’t disappoint
i think zb1 are definitely solid but there's still a pretty gap between nmixx and zb1s vocal line, especially the main vocalists
taerae and hao are a decent main vocal duo but they're pretty far off from haely
i think the rest are pretty close tho
Frrr Rora voice deserve recognition
ahyoen her vocal is so beautiful and strong in same time and her present in stages is insane
Rami Pharita Rora vocal is so good
❤
I feel bad for Ahyeon cause having the most complete voice in terms of technique, she is sided by "fans". I think she is a good exemple of what is breath support n what it affects, her projection, confort and confidence singing.
아현과 치키타가 인기 있는 이유는 보컬 실력 때문이 아니다. 한국어에는 이들이 가진 강점을 표현하는 단어가 있는데 '끼'와 '흥'이야. 보편적으로는 무대존재감으로 일부 설명할수 있는 요소이지만 부족해. 거기에 더해 다른 사람을 즐겁게 하는 능력(끼)와 자신을 즐겁게 하는 능력(흥)으로 표현되는데 이는 YG가 가장 중요하게 생각하는 요소야. 실제로 YG의 last evaluation에서 높은 점수를 획득했어. 루카도 '흥'이 뛰어난 래퍼로 YG DNA를 갖췄다고 하지. YG는 애초에 SM이나 JYP에 비해 보컬에 강점이 있는 회사가 아니야. 스타일이나 '끼', '흥' 같은 평가하기 힘든 요소에 집착하는 회사야. 객관적으로 들으려 했을때 이 둘이 다른 뛰어난 보컬에 비해서 단점이 많이 부각되지만, 함께 즐기려고 마음 먹었을때는 사람을 흥분시키고 감정적으로 고조시키는 능력을 가지고 있기 떄문에 일반 대중들이 매혹되는 거야. 물론 그들이 열심히 트레이닝해서 더 좋은 보컬 실력을 갖추게 된다면 훨씬 좋겠지만 그들이 이미 가지고 있는 이 무기들이 충분히 강하다고 판단했기에 데뷔시킨거라 생각해. 이게 번역이 잘 될지 모르겠네. sorry for poor translation. 결론은, 한국인으로서 보기에 치키타는 훌륭한 '끼'를 가진 보컬이고, 루카는 '흥'이 대단한 래퍼야. 그리고 아현은 '끼'와 '흥'이 모두 뛰어나.
I agree with you,, idol bukan hanya tentang vokal saja 😊
I agree with you too. Charisma is hard to evaluate unless you really factor in the reaction from the mass or market itself..❤❤❤❤
They just debut and still a long way to go to reach that level of professional vocalists.
They're still better than most hybe's girl groups
@clips5299 and you are obsessed with them😂 why do you even care? Some singers are good some are bad, know what like and move on. All you do is talk about others instead of focusing on them. Like that's all you care about.
@@clips5299 i dont know any shit about hybe groups.I just prefer exo..
Hayoung and Jiwon are still there why you Forgot ?@@clips5299
Yep, but they have a great starting point, let's hope they improve upon what they already have
I don't really like their music, but i will never deny their amazing vocals, those girls are seriously awesome
As much talent as I think Ahyeon has, I just cannot stand her tone/intonation (or lack there of). She’s also currently doing stuff way too ambitious for her current technical level causing her to sound shouty and overall not too pleasant.
Now if only we could some better music and lyrics from them, and as much as Blinks are tired from him… I do think they would sound amazing on a Teddy track.
Ahyeon strength is her powerfull vocals which type of voice you don't like at the end of the day it's still base on people perspective and how people listen it love people who go to the fan meeting really wowed with Ahyeon vocals and they keep saying she really sounds so good live.
For my perspective I like Ahyeo vocal techniques and tone is rare to hear this kind of tone in KPOP she have a good powerful voice as well which added spice to her weapon
@@Francheska291her tone is definitely unique which is why her voice is so divisive. I also don’t mind a powerful vocalist (Rami is my favorite vocalist in the group), I just don’t like an untrained vocalist screaming in my ear because she doesn’t have the proper technical foundation to go that high safely. I hope Ahyeon improves cuz I actually quite like her voice when she’s rapping or ad libing
@@DeeDeeDeeeee I think she's a well trained she is just sometime reckless because when she enjoys to much that the time she going all out in her control. But well I still enjoy her high note still listenable for me .
@@DeeDeeDeeeee i see you but let's not forget this is ahyeon's debut, she's got here later than the rest of the girls. give her time
These girls have soooo much to offer. They are so good as a beginners. It's just a matter of time when everybody gonna accept the fact that Babymonster is really the new generation vocal powerhouse 🙌
Ahyeon and Aespa’s Winter high pitched belts physically hurt me.
I cannot deny that. Both of them have sharp voices, polarizing
Yea.... they tend to strain/pushed when sing higher. Well, i believe both will improve as time goes by, they still young and got great potential to develop
Don't worry they both in the end of the day can outsing half of the industry
I think both of them need to improve their mix in order to not sound as shrill.
I have to agree. Sometimes if not most of the times Winter's vocals come off as nasal and her high notes sound so forced which is why I prefer Ningning's high notes
It seems like some Kpop companies finally took the fans' demands about live vocals seriously. With Nmixx, Kiss of Life and now Babymonster, the new generation is in good hands
Nmixx and kiof are already there, the problem is they get buried and ignored by general consumer because their fans voices aren't heard by most people causing alot of them don't care about vocals before up until this controversy about not being able to sing live. I'm not making this about baemon but alot of the people started to switch after they got trending, making nmixx and kiof also shine together.
@@obriendenis3965 The unfortunate reasons why they haven't been that huge are: 1) Kiss of Life come from a small company, which is sadly always a big obstacle for groups to overcome; 2) Nmixx had one of the most disastrous debuts I've ever seen from a Big 4 group and they've been trying to restore their reputation ever since (and they've been doing a good job of it, they're slowly getting bigger).
rami's vocal color is just beautiful
Everytime i listen to their live performances i can hear that some certain notes from Ahyeon and Pharita sound a bit unhealthy. Especially for Pharita, I'm just so afraid such singing ESPECIALLY without a proper technique might damage their vocals too early 😭But thank god Rami and Rora feel comfortable in their parts❤
Please listen "Struck in the middle" (version OT6 - Live Stage) and "Christmas without you" carefully again, who did the best vocal in the same parts. The people's comments praised Pharita's vocal so good. Her voice is very stable and very smooth as the same record. (she did really good for Live Stage Presence).
@@gsp.th.youtube I'm not saying she did badly, maybe better to re read my comment? I'm saying that YG gives her parts with really high notes which might be damaging for her in future considering that she has a middle register
Yes I always find Pharita high notes very strained and sometimes unpleasant, whereas her voice can be so angelic
@@user-py8ox3ve9p You need to know YG producers' concept of the song STIM, they let Pharita do the high note like that because they needed people to imagine to the Galaxy. (you could see the background at the end of this song). It's big different from her high note in the song " All Of Me". (It depends on the concept of those songs.). She just did it as per YG produces' request. For as their Live Stage Presence, her high note was better than the MV a lots. In my opinion, she did the live state singing the most stable and the same as audio record.
There is no best thing. Every voice matters. that makes baby monsters Comes with amazing sound Because they have very different tones, to the point of complete opposites.
Thank you for making a video about wonderful Babymonster. They will blow everyone's minds in the future.
Rami is that friend you know you can trust to pull through. She’s just top notch level A. Rora, she’s def serving as the second strongest vocalist in terms of her her tone, technique and control… clearly shes underrated, as we’ve yet to seen her full potential shine in a song.
Ahyeon has tiny and very thin vocal tone that's why it's better for high or peak part of the song. And i like Rora's vocal tone the most too. It has warmth and raspiness
I love Chiquita & Rora're voice more than any members, but Rami 's the best voice too.
firstly I love the members vocal skills so much. like they‘re really nice to listen to. and rami has that special something to me personally. and second I really like the editing style of this video. I also hope the girls keep training and improving their vocals would be great to see and ofc listen to.
"let's chill... let's not get too ahead of ourselves" lmao i mean they are definitely talented but their fans need to tone it down with comparing them with nmixx bc it's not even close vocally... and i mean this with no hate intended
I agree they're very good but let's not compare them to Aespa and especially Nmixx
Best vocalist in BM = or almost = Main rappers of Nmixx and Aespa
i get if they are comparing them with groups like kiof and nwjns but nmixx... gentle reminder that nmixx have two AA vocalists and rest WA with sullyoon and kyujin few steps to average tier 😭
@@nayeonisgonnabeastar real and that's a hard pill to swallow
Yes,I mean… they just debuted and we see them sing live not often. And Nmixx have debuted 2 years ago, and we have seen a looot of their singing live. Definitely not comparable. And the fans shouldn’t compare to criticize some groups…
I feel like people underestimate Pharita's vocals, but she is very consistent
It's from a certain fandom actually underestimating babymonster singing ability they acting like they are not kids and already in the industry for how Many years 🤣
Pharita's vocal is so good and many people know it. Just some people do not want her to standout. (she is perfect girl).
@somnukh.4377
Fact
Solo stans are jealous of Her🤣
My impression from Babymonster at this point is that Rami and Pharita are definitely main vocals, quite probably Rora too. I am an absolute sucker for unique tones, and YG has always been so great at this, plus balancing out can be tricky, they do this well too, hence why in my opinion those 3 are very much likely the main vocals, they also have the most developed technique and versatility.
Ahyeon can be tricky, I think YG's intention with her it's to stun the public, since she's probably FOTG, many see her as a "mini Jennie" so she has potential to bring A LOT of attention to the group, plus has a powerful tone. However, the belts are lacking technique. It's a comfortable area for her as you discussed but you can hear her faulter ever so slightly in the high note of "Sheesh" in some performances. She is an amazing singer and can become even better, but again, she's still so young, needs a lot of further training. It's the same with Chiquita. She has an interesting tone and she's versatile too, but she's so young, it's hard to say since her voice is still going to face several changes. She hasn't displayed much and has stayed in a comfortable range so far, but pre-debut has shown a lot of tension in a higher range when not doing falsetto. Asa, in my opinion, has shown better pre-debut vocal technique than her, even in "Stuck In The Middle" it's noticeable that Asa has vocal potential.
Anyway, these are my two cents :) I think they are all immensely talented and as always, YG chooses singers with such different vocal colours, I'm always fascinated by their singers.
And also, I love your videos! I'm a 10+ year musician, vocal teacher and have a BA and MA in vocals, so it's very hard to find opinions that aren't biased 😄 your videos are always very informative and accurate 👏
Please don't compare ahyeon as jennie... Too far.... Personality and rapping style also different.... Jennie more talented and cool... There is NO mini Jennie...
I think the tension in Chiquita’s voice while singing traitor was due to her being sick from COVID 19
Yeah.... I was always right about rami and rora having the most dynamics as singer than ahyeon. Ahyeon may sound absolutely beast with those high notes but those are emotionless 90% of time. I would say her technique is super solid but the way she channels it doesn't resonate with me like other two.... But I know she is in right hand ...as the time goes on she will definitely find her true potential. Actually it feels really weird to critique anything about baby monster's vocal line.... Collectively its just one of the best among 5th gen.... So as a listener i just want them to improve more and more in future and become the next big star.... Just like their sister group.
O meu tom favorito é o da chiquita, e a minha técnica favorita são as de rora e rami. Pharita faz um excelente trabalho também, queria ver ela ganhar confianca. Ahyeon é promissora, mas nao é a minha favorita pois sinto que ela tem muita dificuldade com a afinação e com a respiração, e quando ela nao está em um tom mais alto é extremamente instável... Mas ela é nova e tem muito potencial
im a blink, but i admit that vocals are not really blackpinks forte, but for sure, they are great performers.. babymonsters, on the other hand, have so much vocal potential, and yg is surely promoting that. im a little sad that you have not included asa and ruka in this video. asa can also sing, but yes, you are right that both of them lean more on the rap. i also agree with what you said for each of the 5, especially with ahyeon. ahyeon is no doubt vocally talented, but i feel that most fans are quite overhyping her. her belts scare me(both for dangerously cover and sheesh) because they dont seem really stable. my favorites are rami and rora, and also chiquita's style (but she didnt have any chance to showcase this so far) overall, thank you for finally reviewing babymoster, i hope you include them in some of your future videos because we are getting more and more live content especially now with their tour that kicked off in tokyo. i love to see more and more groups that actually pay attention to vocals.
Ahyeo deserves all the hyped she's getting g because she really can sing and bring sauce to their song and the fan meeti g proved how important Ahyeon voice is. Y'all just pushing g that overhying to much but y'all the one who do that to your faves.
@poporing856 ahyeon is great, and i agree with you that she gives color to the group and is undeniably the core centre. without her, it's just not the same, it's not babymonsters. but as the video mentioned, she hasnt fully mastered the belting, its quite rough on some of their performances, which is why i am saying she is overhyped and i meant this as "currently." im pretty sure she and the other members will just grow more and more and more. i also think the overhype was the cause of her not being in batter up.. but we know yg and the girls they practice and practice and oeactice til they master their craft which i love compared to some groups nowadays... anyway, tldr. she can belt but not always clean.
I don’t think Ahyeon’s belts are unstable tbh, but it still needs perfecting and she has to work on the rest of her voice.
@@ynachoi5072 overhyped is a bs word to say 🙂 because people see talents and skills from her they are not hyping her up without a reason.
@@ynachoi5072 the perfect example of overhyping by fans is LISA which is so evident. And so debatable yeah she's a good dancer but that's all she can offer stage presence is already a cheat code to all YG groups which is already a given that all of them has that. But if you watch babymonster fan meeting fan cam they are really on another level female group of YG they literally beat blackpink as a group even if I'm Jennie biased I admit that Blackpink really lacks something when they perform when I watched babymonster
When I watched this pre-debut video of Rora 9:11 I thought she was going to be the main vocalist of the group, however she's being treated as a sub-vocal at this point. She hasn't received any key point, vocal highlight, ''wow'' moment in their songs
well it’s true she quite only suits bridges the most, and more emotionally verses, sheesh and batter up are just not rlly for her
she stuck out so much in dream and stuck in the middle
They have like 5 songs
Saying sub vocal is such a reach..
She is not treated like sub-vocal at all and this is only BM start. Her parts always vocally complex and rich if you listen them carefully. I agree her parts dont have wow effect in public. The most usually notice only belts and hight notes. She will get them, and I really hope YG focuses on her lows too ("Forfeit" is the best she sang imo)
so glad to see rora appreciation. i remember she didn’t stand out that much for me during the evaluations (ahyeon was my fav) . after watching the last evaluations’ solos, rami and asa impressed me a lot. but when they released batter up, rora surprised me A LOT and i literally thought “i can’t believe yg was about to kick her out”, bc her voice is literally sooo good and in terms of skills she’s probably the best after rami. her tone is so soothing. i really hope she gets to showcase her vocals in future songs and that people stop undermining her talent as a vocalist, because she deserves as much praise as the other girls.
Finally rather accurate ranking Because WHO THE HELL PUTS AHYEON ABOVE RORA AND RAMI
I've never seen any non-delulu person put Ahyeon above them, but I have seen Pharita placed at the bottom way too much for how relatively impressive she is in the group. I've never understood that honestly, cuz I don't think Pharita does anything worse than Chiquita and Ahyeon (I'm not trying to hate on any of them, I like all the members, this is just how I feel about their vocals).
Rami's vocals really 'caught my ears', been obsessed with her parts in sheesh.
I love ahyeon strong voice 🥰 gives me goosbamps
The pattern continues that people who actually know something about vocals spots the stability and advanced vocal abilities of Rora. I too hope that they will give her material to show off her abilities more. This is such a powerful and skilled group that time will be the issue with 7 members and allowing each to shine enough. Hopefully the promised sub-groups will allow even more of their skills to be shone to the world. All 5 of the vocalists give hope to the industry in the 5th gen.
Sub-groups? When did YG say they'd have sub-units? Did I miss that?
I could see you put so much more effort into this. I appreciate it really much. Please it up
I like Rami and Rora tone of voice the most... hope to hear more from them. I stan talented kids not popular ones. Im not even a fan of the group...I'm almost into them except their music wise is not my thing I would listen frequently. But enjoy watching them.
Yo thanks for the analysis. Besides the fanmeeting in Japan, they had seven live music show performances, among sbs and mnet shows
They all will be improved even more in future like take a look they are doing soo good at fan meeting in Japan it feels like they are not rookies but professionals ❤️🤘
Ive always veen waiting for ur opinion on baby monster finally kets goo
I know they aren’t kpop, but what about a cover on vcha? They have immense growth from their survival show A2K😊
Nobody cares about them because theyre not kpop, they give the typical western dance cover group vibe
I WAS WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO, I'M FKING READY.
I agree with you that in the last two presentations they had on the TV programs Inkigayo and MCD they were and sounded more real, in fact they became my favorite live presentations, excellent video analysis.✅
Great video!!!!!! Thanks!!!!
Rami is, in my opinion, the only vocalist whose voice really stands out in the group. The other four, although I try and try, I cannot differentiate them since they all use the same style...
Also, I could not be less interested since all they've had to offer from debut has been the saaaame ooold YG boring trope. When a YG gg gives us real interesting and authentic music, then I'll consider what they might bring to the table. These girls deserve not to suffer from Girl Crush and empty unoriginal choruses and should actually have a decent career.
Same style lmao
No one in the history of yg has used rora's style
Asa, Rami, Ahyeon, and Ruka are my faves ❤
I really want to stan them, but i am afraid YG won't give them good music, and promotions will suck.
I really hate YG business strategy.
Yg has different plans for babymonster, yesterday and today Baemon had their own 30k sold out fan meeting in tokyo that they turned into their own concert. And they will be having full length album before this year end. Coz they are targeting them to have concert as soon as possible.. If you like cocomelon songs from other group just don't stan them coz yg already made it clear that they will never let go of their yg branding bec their songs are meant for big crowds like festivals and concerts were people are all jumping amd partying ( already experience it in BP concerts 🥹) but people always forgot to recognize how versatile yg artists bsides. Yes..their title tracks are banging songs but their bsides has different genre of music.
@@asdfghjk2019 I hope they release the full album this year.
They better change that strategy for BabyMonster.
@@asdfghjk2019 yep, in fact, yg has even promoted them on variety shows
YG always keep their best part and show us when the real candidates group(in future) may have come.
As we were introduced that, Rora & Pharita can play instruments and may be Rami (OP found her carrying kinda guitar or bass bag in her way back home from YG building) I wish to see these 3 in band project.🎉 They may have not much hype skill like Ahyoen and Ruka but these 3 have the most stable voice on live stage.
I think what stands out for me is how different the vocalists are. All of them are great and like rora and chiquita are so young they are only going to get better. Remember they are in YG so their vocals are only going to improve. Ahyeon isn’t just a belter. She has a very unique tone which is why it sounds amazing every time she follows Rami. She has a raspier growling voice which contrasts rora and pharita sweeter voices. And then Rami is just what I like to call the “mic dropper”. She is clearly the main vocalist and she’s special because she has a soulful voice which is so rare in kpop so she stands out.
I think in 5th gen there are no equals. When you start talking 4th gen you mentioned nmixx and what I would say is they are so young and they just debut so you can assume safely that they must get better with more experience. And we sleep on someone like Asa. I love Lisa but Asa is a better vocalist and I would argue is on par with her rapping. Lisa and blackpink have of course the ultimate weapon which is that they are the stage presence and performance masters but that’s with 7 years under their belts. Right now they are still not widely known but as they progress and collaborate with main stream artists people will start to ask who these girls arr
Finally a person who explains more than people's ranking
Every group has advantage and disadvantage. BM is pretty good vocal group, even taking into account age very good. But their biggest advantage is even something else which all YG artists have: charisma and ability to stand alone on the stage. So I agree that vocally they are not on the level of Nmixx or Aespa. But on the level charisma at least at both of these groups rookie time they are on another level. Like you can clearly see that YG trainees apparently have to just performance more live than others companies because most their idols even ex trainees just stand out even in their groups. This is definitely as well aspect which they search in trainees. Like girls after month of performance looks like most groups after one tour one the stage.
This comment section is wild. I'm just happy to have a new group to enjoy. They're actually pretty good and so far their performances are fun to watch.
Although not on a super developed level, Ruka and Asa are still considered vocalists though they have under-developed vocals because they both have shown the abilities to sing, Ruka probably has the most under-developed vocals which is why she does not sing often but she can and did sing. (they are an all rounder group)
Edit: Most of their performances was actually Live, the two hand mic ones were to prove it for people accusing them of not or sum i think, but if you listen to their other performances from the start most of it was live except the chorus and dance break part. (the hand mic were the fully live versions)
They have loads of potential my favorite things is rami's agility her runs reminds of Mariah but it's hard to be like Mimi !!!
2:17 the 5 vocals
This is sort of an out topic but i would love to hear Paritha and Rora rap (the rappers that were obvious was Asa and Ruka and then Ahyeon joined and then they showed that Chiquita can rap and Rami rapping in tokyo! 5 rappers now)
Ahyeon was always a rapper , in her introduction video she literally does both rap and vocals , id say Chiquita is the one who joined
@@selestealbert8585 no I meant like from their ot6 debut to ot7 debut and then the Tokyo events and behind the scenes of the choreo
What I love about this group is while they're all in varying stages of vocal development, everyone of them has been trained to project. No one sounds doubtful or disengaged when singing.
BabyMonster Have incredible Vocals In whole 5thGen❤❤
Love this kind of review. Isn't bias and focuses on the talents and skills
Rami’s voice is my fav, but Rora is no joke (the two of them together equals pure magic.) I was pleasantly surprised by Chiquita’s vibrato as KPOP in general has a “less is more” approach and I am def a vibrato stan!
I'm really hoping that Rami and/or Rora get the trademark early career YG solo release. Rami is easily the best female vocalist to come out of YG, a claim Rora could also make if not for Rami. I'm just hoping YG gives the girls actually hands on, in person regular vocal lessons, especially given their young ages. They have so much potential, but I'm afraid to get my hopes up too much considering YG usually has a tendency to let their vocalists stagnate or deteriorate in favor of stylistic vocals or just totally non-music related promotions.
I really love Ahy and Rami especially in Like that my favourite song🤍🖤
13:37 the way I've been saying this. You can easily recognize when it's pre-recorded (with any group really). I wish Babymonster had been able to perform live on more live stages but you're right, the ones they did do live were* amazing. I wish YG would stop trying to cheat the MR removed and trust their idols more, because they can ACTUALLY sing. Let them sing and perform, please.
There's lot of fancam from their fan meeting in japan if you want really hear BM sing live
Nice works~
Rami got strong and uniq voice.... Pharita and Rora got sweet,great and beautiful voice.... Both of them will carru any song very well...with 3 of them BM song will be sound great... Chiquita and ahyeon got strong personality..chiquita vocal also good...ahyeon rapping was ok because Asa and Ruka already manage that part so well... Both of them so great at rapping with each other
i dont know a thing abt babymon and i rlly didnt wanna look into them (didnt like any of their songs out rn), but ramis segment genuinely surprised me, especially the first half 🤣 so strong, so clean, especially for kpop oops zzz why are they not making songs just for her? sad that shes in yg 🤣 hope to see her in 7 years ig ?
Baby rami love u
the way they are all still young, they'll be so much better in the future
The fact that they were able to turn an existing problem into a hot topic is a great story for a talented group of people. Take this opportunity to show off your skills to get the most out of it.
Yes, definitely. They are saving Kpop with their vocals. All of them are so good.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
LMAO it hasnt been a year are people are acting like YG are mistreating the members already. LIKE CHILL...It's a 7 member group and obviously there will be some member who will get few line and won't be able to show full potential of their voice. Like what?? You guys want Rami to do whistle note every time?? Rora to do deep voice every time? there is time and place and these are their "Trump cards" using ittoo much will feel like force and people will say "we know you can do high notes but can you please stop and sing normally".
Recently on twitter I saw on twitter. They changed Chiquita centre chroe for japan fan meet and Chiquita fan were crying that why YG changed her part and they re doing her mistret.
They just debuted let them find their sound and let the girl mature further vocally and stop being a toxic solo stan.
Seriously it's ridiculous 😭 they debuted last month have like 5 actual songs and people are already fighting . Don't call them Chiquita stans cuz no true fan would fight only immature ones do we call them a fancy word ～toxic～
There is no need for anyone to be the main center. It must always be able to change in the performance in order for it to be correct.
BABY MONS7ER ALBUM with 401k sales in one week is the best-selling DEBUT kpop album in history, and SHEESH with 24.4 million views in 24 hours is the debut kpop song with the most views on CZcams in 24 hours.
Yet it lost to Illit
I have seen Pharita placed at the bottom way too much for how relatively impressive she is in the group. I've never understood that honestly, cuz I don't think Pharita does anything worse than Chiquita and Ahyeon (I'm not trying to hate on any of them, I like all the members, this is just how I feel about their vocals).
This comment section is really wild, give the girls more time they are just starting their idol careers. They still have a lot to learn, also some here are attacking Ahyeon like she's done so bad. Ahyeon just turned 17 and she just debuted a month ago please spare her some slack, the girl has been through a lot already. Maybe you don't like her vocal technique then skip her just don't downplay her effort in growing her abilities and keep comparing her to her other members. They are all good vocally with distinct voices and they will reach their full potential with years of experience.
I agree with you,, 😊