Taeyon has been hurt so many times. Not just because of the dating, also because of losing someone she loves, people manipulating what she has to feel. She deserves to rest, we don't deserve her, she's too much for us.
“People manipulating what she has to feel”. Damn that entire sentence alone was enough to properly explain what people has put her through. My heart aches for her and all the other idols out there who aren’t even treated as human beings in the first place.
@@schane9255 yeah :( I recently saw a video of Eunwoo/Dongmin (of ASTRO) saying he wants to get married, and then he bursted into tears. That HURT. I just want him and other idols to be able to fall in love and date freely. Why are people so mad at their idols for being with who they love? It seriously makes me so mad. And the fact Taeyeon was crying at the airport when she was apologizing to a fan really made me mad. She and all idols shouldn’t have to apologize for dating. Like, wtf is that? Why would someone apologize for dating?
@@nikis_bungeoppangs thats why we as a international fans should changes the idols culture in korea. I want them to be an artist, freely dating and get married but still famous like western artist as long as them talented. I hate it when Taeyeon said she dont want to write any song because she scared of expressing her feelings since fans so damn sensitive about her. It’s break my heart 🥺 Sorry for my english ✌🏻
This girl battled alot: •Got the most backlash from the public for dating Baekhyun(number one most hated relationship in the industry) •member left the group aka Jessica •Lost sulli •Lost Jonghyun •Lost Hara •lost her father •lost her grandmother This is all from 2014 to now
@@nevertrulyyours It is because at that time, exo is really getting big and so their exo-l fandom is big too. One factor that made exo-ls not accept teayeon for baek is because she is a noona.
@@txtaylorstan EXO was the most popular group when the news was released and they were still rookies. -They were using “secret signals” to each other though instagram,which made fans think it was for them when it wasnt (this was a strong assumption btw) -the photo released was baekhyun kissing taeyeon on the cheek -they had a 4 year difference -exols are and still known as the most obsessive fans in korea and even int, even their saesangs were one of the most dangerous, this is also a huge common agreement between korean fans, so imagine what the “non saesangs” were like.
@@nevertrulyyours EXO was the most popular group when the news was released and they were still rookies. -They were using “secret signals” to each other though instagram,which made fans think it was for them when it wasnt (this was a strong assumption btw) -the photo released was baekhyun kissing taeyeon on the cheek -they had a 4 year difference -exols are and still known as the most obsessive fans in korea and even int, even their saesangs were one of the most dangerous, this is also a huge common agreement between korean fans, so imagine what the “non saesangs” were like.
태연은 진짜 멘탈이 세계 최강인 느낌... 그런 일이 있었는데도 참고 견뎌서 콘서트도 하고 나오기로 되어있는 모든 시상식 다 나와준게 진짜... 콘서트에서도 자기 생각이 먼저가 아닌 팬들 걱정해서 팬들한테 저는 오랫동안 노래할거라고 말하고 진짜 태연님은 안 좋아할려고 할 수가 없는것 같다...
taeyeon has been thru so much already. she lost 4 of her best friends. jonghyun, sulli, and now her own father. especially on her birthday. how terrible :( and sometimes, she gets hate for literally doing nothing. she's letting out her emotions by singing a song. as a leader of snsd, she was also trying her best to be the strongest. edit : her grandmother also passed away on april 18 2020. :(
@@sm-lq5se yes, she posted it on instagram and said "see you in my dreams." and the comments were like "we're here for you, stay strong, rip" so im guessing she did pass away 2 days ago. :(
태연 진짜 대단한 사람 같다고 생각해.. 한 번 울컥하게 되면 쉽게 진정할수가 없는데 꾹 참고 다른 때와 별 차이 없이 끝까지 완벽한 수준의 라이브를 보여줬다는게 진짜 대단하고 멋있어 다른 얘기지만 목소리 떨리고 울음 참으려고 눈 꼭 감고 중간중간 계속 울컥하는데 진짜 나까지 마음 아파졌음.. 태연이 저 날 파인을 부르면서 느낀 감정의 다는 아니더라도 조금을 알 것 같은 느낌이었음
U can tell that she didn't care anything about expression, way of standing anything.. she juz wanted to finish this performance before burst into tears.. she is the only female korean star where i always googled up and watching her vlogs and songs.. her voice is really really peaceful.. but i always noticing that she didn't really happy at all.. always she forced herself to be strong and pretends to ok... Taeyeon ah u don't need to do this. U can cry.. after all we are all humans... so don't be hard on urself .. i love u so much u touched so many hearts through ur voice and am d one of them.. apart from my depression, ur voice makes me relax
You can tell when she’s holding back her tears and such. just like the time when she sang into the new world in Tokyo dome when Jessica left. her singing becomes really emotional and just because she’s the leader she herself thinks that she must be strong and not let anyone think that she’s weak by showing her tears
jessica enthusiast she was kicked out right? Its been years but i cant still moved on. I was still hoping that one day they will pull off a stage with her suprisely. But i know its impossible
if u listen and watch carefully ... u can see that she is holding back her tears .. its been really hard on her when her best friend pass away .. but shes trying to not make us worry about her and hold back her tears .. T.T
ASH tysone i know right .. shes holding back her emotion because she knows .. if she falls down her member and the fan will falls down too ! shes the strongest leader ive ever seen
The people in the comments saying how they feel bad because they’re certain she’s sad during this performance because of Baekhyun when in reality she almost broke down because OF Jonghyun, minutes before this performance she was *crying* because there was a tribute/memorial show for him, and she went up on stage to perform after she *cried* for him, please respect that she was performing this song in tribute to her late close friend *Kim Jonghyun* and not because of her past relationship with *Baekhyun*
it’s really annoying whenever taeyeon sings a sad song people would be like “oh this is about baek” like seriously she didn’t even wrote those lyrics and fans be hallucinating. they dated, they broke up. no matter they remained as friends or not, people should stop bringing this up
Taeyeon lost Jonghyun, Sulli, Hara and her father in the recent years. I can't even imagine what she's gone through. I hope people can be nice with her. She said herself she's been struggling with depression. She's trying her best, she deserves love and support. ♡
i can feel the emotion that she tried to convey in this song. it makes me so emotional everytime i watch this videos. and when the part "it's not fine" when she make an eye contact with the camera it really looks like she want to say that she is not fine :(
She’s not just singing, but she’s singing with her experience in love. The BaekYeon couple we failed to protect,& how she move on from that part of her life. I
Only second gen SM artist can sing this beautifully, that too live..tbh SHINee does lives the best, and after them its just Taeyeon no one is doing it like them, because they can't..these are the idols that song live on their debut stage and there are idols nowadays who can't help just lipsync
This song is not about them after they broke up, but this song is Jonghyun's story, moreover, this song came out after Jonghyun was gone, so this song has nothing to do with Baekhyun or Taeyeon..mv release after jonghyun is gone,,okey
this song came out early 2017, way before jonghyun’s death, so it has nothing to do with him. the song is about the suffering taeyeon had to endure after losing a loved one, baekhyun, even if they didn’t want to let go of each other. can we please focus on taeyeon and her talent and not always make it about jonghyun, hara, sulli or someone else¿
@@larisastancu4012 A. This performance is literally a tribute to Jonghyun so of course people will acknowledge that. B. while it's true that the song came out early 2017 it doesn't mean that it's about a relationship that ended 3 years prior. That's the only public releationship people know of that's why y'all are so fixated on the fact that many of her songs about ending things is about him. D. She didn't even write the song. She may relate to it but it's not written by her which doesn't even matter since she's one of the strongest singers out there. D. People always praise her for her talent and tell her that all the time. The reason people mention her friends in the industry that died is because they all have something in common. Depression and them taking their lives. Since Taeyeon has stated that she also suffers with depression. Sulli and Hara got treated so terribly by the public even tho they didn't do anything. Lastly people need to let go of this Baekhyun shipping shit.
@@larisastancu4012 ironic how 'can we focus on Taeyeon?' when you're the one who mentioned Baekhyun lmao. Not every song she sings related to Baekhyun. 🤷🏻♀️
![[2017 골든디스크] 디지털음원부문 본상 태연 'Rain'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MnIlXN607cg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[듣는덕후관점] 태연 가창력 레전드 라이브 TOP10 Taeyeon Best vocal live TOP10](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ywDBAKs3DFA/mqdefault.jpg)
she's not singing, she's talking about her sadness
Your r right
You r right
You r right
mieraa serenity . Yep 😪 . She looks like she's holding back tears . Specially at the part 'The Word's Take Care Was It For Our Plain Breakup'
You are right 😢
She doesn't sing, she tells everything.
She also sings btw
@@chizujazelledaichireimiko7119 you dont understand what the comment says
@@lany007 I also don't understand I am not dumb 😣
@@mafia6051 it means the ways she sing she also tell stories and her feelings
@@rslrsnd8254 yeah.....
"she was a poem but they stop him from reading"
Damn that's so true in their situation
Ohhh thats hurt :(
they've had enough pain :(
:--------(
it's so forking painful :((((
The fact that some of the comments are so fresh, wow.
Ikr
Always coming back, arent we?
@@cynaralle7150 literally me 💀
@@cynaralle7150 hahaha
@@cynaralle7150 yesss
Taeyon has been hurt so many times. Not just because of the dating, also because of losing someone she loves, people manipulating what she has to feel. She deserves to rest, we don't deserve her, she's too much for us.
Fr, such a queen 👑
“People manipulating what she has to feel”. Damn that entire sentence alone was enough to properly explain what people has put her through. My heart aches for her and all the other idols out there who aren’t even treated as human beings in the first place.
@@schane9255 yeah :( I recently saw a video of Eunwoo/Dongmin (of ASTRO) saying he wants to get married, and then he bursted into tears. That HURT. I just want him and other idols to be able to fall in love and date freely. Why are people so mad at their idols for being with who they love? It seriously makes me so mad. And the fact Taeyeon was crying at the airport when she was apologizing to a fan really made me mad. She and all idols shouldn’t have to apologize for dating. Like, wtf is that? Why would someone apologize for dating?
@@nikis_bungeoppangs thats why we as a international fans should changes the idols culture in korea. I want them to be an artist, freely dating and get married but still famous like western artist as long as them talented. I hate it when Taeyeon said she dont want to write any song because she scared of expressing her feelings since fans so damn sensitive about her. It’s break my heart 🥺
Sorry for my english ✌🏻
@@sailormoont1978 I don’t think we should change the culture, but I get what you’re trying to say. Your English is good btw
The only woman at SM Ent. that sings live with a little backing vicals.
That's the MAIN VOCALIST OF GIRLS GENERATION
u mean SNSD :D
Thats SoShi Kid Leader everyone 🥰
I think just bc she didn't have to dance while singing so she doesnt need backing vocals much
This is really sad. People really slept on Seohyun's solo i guess. 😀
This girl battled alot:
•Got the most backlash from the public for dating Baekhyun(number one most hated relationship in the industry)
•member left the group aka Jessica
•Lost sulli
•Lost Jonghyun
•Lost Hara
•lost her father
•lost her grandmother
This is all from 2014 to now
Can I ask one thing? Why was baekhyun and taeyeon's relationship got soo much hate? I am a new exol so I don't know but I am very curious about it 😅
Why did their relationship get so much hate??
@@nevertrulyyours It is because at that time, exo is really getting big and so their exo-l fandom is big too. One factor that made exo-ls not accept teayeon for baek is because she is a noona.
@@txtaylorstan EXO was the most popular group when the news was released and they were still rookies.
-They were using “secret signals” to each other though instagram,which made fans think it was for them when it wasnt (this was a strong assumption btw)
-the photo released was baekhyun kissing taeyeon on the cheek
-they had a 4 year difference
-exols are and still known as the most obsessive fans in korea and even int, even their saesangs were one of the most dangerous, this is also a huge common agreement between korean fans, so imagine what the “non saesangs” were like.
@@nevertrulyyours EXO was the most popular group when the news was released and they were still rookies.
-They were using “secret signals” to each other though instagram,which made fans think it was for them when it wasnt (this was a strong assumption btw)
-the photo released was baekhyun kissing taeyeon on the cheek
-they had a 4 year difference
-exols are and still known as the most obsessive fans in korea and even int, even their saesangs were one of the most dangerous, this is also a huge common agreement between korean fans, so imagine what the “non saesangs” were like.
I feel like shes going to breakdown suddenly 😔
Up
@@putriwulandari189 huh
Probably cause she was, this was only a few weeks after jonghyun died and everyone was hit pretty hard especially since she was good friends with him
she's been holding back tears so its kinda hard to reach those high note 😭
kim hyora did something happen?
Taehyungie's Jihoonie yaaa. i think its because of Lee Hi's performance. she cried and we all know how she miss jh so much. its not easy for her :(
Nina ya ikr ㅠㅠ
when I see this I think she thinks baekhyun...but I don't really sure
# VRENE143 this song was released for baekhyun (?) but i guess at this time all she think about is just jh but we cant read her heart so yeah
태연이 저노랠 부를 실력이 된다는 걸 너무 잘 알고있고, 딱 봐도 상태가 안좋은데 저정도로 컨트롤 했다는 게 진짜 프로임을 보여주는게 아닌가 싶음
가라고!
진짜 프로라면 상황 안가리고 항상 잘하는게
포로페셔널 아닌가?
지랄을해라ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 사람이 무슨 기계냐?
@@user-uc6df7jd2 그렇다고 해도..평소랑 같게 부르면 욕 먹어요
왜 이렇게 무덤덤하냐고
@@user-uc6df7jd2 저때 종현님이 돌아가신지 얼마 안된 시점이에요.그리고 태연님은 종현님이랑도 친분이 많으셨고요.
저 시기에 부르기에 가사가 너무 잔인하다....생각을 안할수가 없는 가사네
저 때 뭔일 있었음?
@@user-lo1bg9ul6d 종현 일 있고 몇 개월 밖에 안 지난 시기여서 추모하는 분위기 같은게 좀 있었던거 같음
@@user-lo1bg9ul6d 종현 그렇게 된지 두 달도 안됐었음
친했던 샤이니 종현 추모 영상, 추모 무대 끝난 직후에 무대 오른거라 ,,,,,,, 그래서 fine 부르는게 너무 힘들어보임 파인 다른 라이브 영상은 존나 잘하는데 저 날은 맴찢
태연은 진짜 멘탈이 세계 최강인 느낌... 그런 일이 있었는데도 참고 견뎌서 콘서트도 하고 나오기로 되어있는 모든 시상식 다 나와준게 진짜...
콘서트에서도 자기 생각이 먼저가 아닌 팬들 걱정해서 팬들한테 저는 오랫동안 노래할거라고 말하고 진짜 태연님은 안 좋아할려고 할 수가 없는것 같다...
원래 완벽주의 성향이 짙어서...공식석상에서 괜찮아보일지라도 사실은 많이 힘들거에요
저때 무슨일 있었나요?
열애설 때문이 아니라 종현님이 별이 된 지 얼마 되지 않았던 시기였습니다
@@user-dl6xr9lg9r 말 진짜 예쁘게 하세요
프로니까요...
다른 fine무대들은 좀 더 활기찼는데 이 무대는 금방이라도 울거같은 태연인거같아서 마음이 너무 아프다..
은채 저때 종현의 죽음때문에 생긴 슬픔에서 아직 못벗어난것 같아요
COA CO 그것도 그렇고 저때 태연무대 전에 이하이님 한숨무대로인해 분위기도 슬퍼지고 많이 다들 우셔서 태연도 덩달아 분위기가 다운된것같아ㅛㅇ
쟨 어딜가나 의미부여한다고 난리네
충분이 부여할만한 가사, 상황, 시기였는데...
하긴 그만한 소중한 사람이 없어봤으면 평생을 외롭게 살아왔으면 그런 감정 못느껴봤으면 그생각 할수도 잇겟다
슬프고 군침이 싹 도노
그냥 라이브소화 못하는거같은데 얼굴 쥐어짜면서 노래하는거 보니 제가 다 맘이 아프네요.
태연이 자기곡중에 원래도 울것 같아서 부르기 힘들다고 말한 곡이 Fine이랑 타임랩스인데 이 땐 소중한 사람을 잃은지 얼마 안된 때라 더욱 감정이 힘들어서 그런지 더 노래부르면서 울컥한것 같다ㅠㅠ 그래도 여전히 라이브 잘했고 노래도 너무 좋아ㅠㅠ
소중한 사람이 누군가요?
@@user-cy9bf4js2i 동료 가수입니다
@@user-cy9bf4js2i 샤이니 메인보컬이셨던 고 김종현씨입니다
아버지 + 샤이니 종현
그리고 엑소 박현
이게 라이브 논란이 된다고....? 그 일 때문에 울컥한 게 아니라 해도 저 시상식에서 fine 완창할 수 있는 가수 몇이나 됨?
연예계 잘몰라서 그러는데 그일이 뭐임
@@lilillliilililll6088 저 때가 샤이니 종현 추모 영상 후였어요 추모 영상 때 태연 울컥 하는 영상도 있고요
한 삼백명..?
@@user-it2ll9un8l ?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-it2ll9un8l 모든 가수 말고 저 시상식에 있는 아이돌들이요ㅠ
오히려 감정을 폭발시키기보다 억누르려고 애쓰니까 더 감정이 새어나오는 느낌? 더 안쓰럽다.. 고음도 더 힘들어보이고..원래 울컥하면 부르는거 힘들어지니까
그냥 노래 자체가 고음이라 힘들어 하는거야
@@user-uc6df7jd2 샤이니 종현님이 여행을 떠나시고 거의 첫 공식행사였어요
sunset lee 인성 존나꼬여서 어케살아요?
sunset lee 존나 꼬인거 봐라 사회 생활은 할 수있냐?
sunset lee 다른 fine 라이브 영상 보고오세요~
우리 마지막 그 순간이 자꾸 떠올라....
이 가사 진짜 슬프네...
안녕이란말이 전부였던 담담한 이별
taeyeon has been thru so much already. she lost 4 of her best friends. jonghyun, sulli, and now her own father. especially on her birthday. how terrible :( and sometimes, she gets hate for literally doing nothing. she's letting out her emotions by singing a song. as a leader of snsd, she was also trying her best to be the strongest.
edit : her grandmother also passed away on april 18 2020. :(
sir french fries yesterday her grandmother :
@@AwiwSison omg rlly ?? wtf that's even worse. taeyeon must feel really devastated and heartbroken rn. i really do feel so bad for her :((
@@sm-lq5se yes, she posted it on instagram and said "see you in my dreams." and the comments were like "we're here for you, stay strong, rip" so im guessing she did pass away 2 days ago. :(
Omgg she is very strong 😭
@@sm-lq5se i think she has posted something about her grandmother on instagram?
태연은 강해보이지만 감싸주고 싶은 마음이 생길 정도로 정이 감.. 왜 유독 태연에게만 이런지 모르겠지만 그냥 어느 순간부터 그럼.. 이젠 태연이 진짜 괜찮아졌으면 좋겠다
이런데까지 찾아와서 굳이 댓까지 달아서 남을 비난하는 네가 찐따같다 새끼야 남한테 그런말 못 하면 열등감때문에 일상생활이 불가능한가봐?
아직 누군가를 보내기에 어린 애들도 많고 힘들텐데 이렇게 자기 일을 다 끝내는게 너무 멋있다
??그니까 아이돌 연애? 결별 말하는건가
나나 아녀 종현님 돌아가시고̄̈ 부른 노래였던걸로 기억해요
어린애들?
@@queriesi1257 어린 나이
진짜 제일 슬픈 라이브다 점점 눈물 고임
아아아아아아 하는 이부분이 진짜 울음을 터트리는거 같은 느낌임
눈물이 점점 차오르면서 참으려는게 느껴짐 가사도 그렇고 너무 슬프다 ㅠㅠ
후반부로 갈수록 울면 안돼 울면 안돼...!! 하면서 부르는 느낌...끝까지 감정컨트롤 하면서 부르는 모습이 참 마음 아프고 대견하다
태연은 진짜 노래부를 때 제일 좋은게 가성을 잘 안 쓰고, 높은 음도 무조건 진성으로 내지름. 그래서 보컬이 엄청 짙게 꽉찬느낌. 감성도 더 호소력 있어지고.. 이런 부분이 너무 좋음. 앞으로도 여리여리하게 부르지말고 지금처럼 시원시원하게 호소력짙게 불러줬음 좋겠다.
인정. 다 좋은데 진짜 높은 음 진성으로 내는거 너무 좋고 가슴이 뻥 뚫리는 느낌.
가성도 많이 쓰긴 써요 노래마다 다르긴 하지만
fine참 좋아하는데 너무 쉽게 질러서 불렀다가 아 다 진성이었어 하고 포기했어요 ㅎㅎ
그거 AR 찐하게 깔아서 그래
@@user-gw1ki2jw8f이거 종현님... 보내고..얼마안되서 부른거예요.. 눈물 참고 감정 억누르느라 그런거 같네요..
확실히 태연이 노래에 감정을 잘 실어 부르는데 이번엔 목소리에서부터 뭔가 그때 일어난 일에 대한 트라우마에서 못벗어난것 같아서 너무 슬프고 안타까웠다 진심으로 이건 라이브 욕할게 아니라 위로해야한다
COA CO 확실히 느껴지네여..목소리도떨리고 울기직전...겨우참는모습...ㅜ맘아프다..
근데 직캠보면 라이브 엄청잘했었어요.... 오디오문제같음.... 역시 프로 태연....
종현의 죽음...
뷰티플바이셉스. 초딩새끼는 어지간히 나대라 좀
직캠보면 되게 잘부르는데,,?
근데 저렇게 울컥했으면서도 끝까지 잘부르네... 단단한 사람인듯
태연 진짜 대단한 사람 같다고 생각해.. 한 번 울컥하게 되면 쉽게 진정할수가 없는데 꾹 참고 다른 때와 별 차이 없이 끝까지 완벽한 수준의 라이브를 보여줬다는게 진짜 대단하고 멋있어 다른 얘기지만 목소리 떨리고 울음 참으려고 눈 꼭 감고 중간중간 계속 울컥하는데 진짜 나까지 마음 아파졌음.. 태연이 저 날 파인을 부르면서 느낀 감정의 다는 아니더라도 조금을 알 것 같은 느낌이었음
울음참는거같아서 마음아프다..슬퍼보여..
우리 종현이 보고 싶어서 이런저런 영상 찾아보다가 이 영상을 다시 보게 됐는데 2:07 이때부터 보면 진짜 울음 참는 느낌... 목소리도 떨리고 표정도 그렇고 눈도 꾹 감고 있고.. 누가 툭 치면 그냥 울어버릴 것 같아..
오윤솔 가사도 그래요..
@@heunchae3562 툭치면 아프냐? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그냥 치면 뼈부러지겠다?
@@qwertqwert8389 왜이럴까,,
@@qwertqwert8389 왤케 꼬임 ? 니가 그러니까 니 인생이 그 꼴인거야 ㅋㅋㅋ 왜 학교 다닐때 애들이 너 툭툭치고 다녔나봐 ? ㅋㅌㅌㅋ
1절 사비 끝나고 2절 들어갈 때부터 위태위태했는데 그 이후로 눈물만 안 흘렸지 거의 울면서 부른 느낌임...
U can tell that she didn't care anything about expression, way of standing anything.. she juz wanted to finish this performance before burst into tears.. she is the only female korean star where i always googled up and watching her vlogs and songs.. her voice is really really peaceful.. but i always noticing that she didn't really happy at all.. always she forced herself to be strong and pretends to ok... Taeyeon ah u don't need to do this. U can cry.. after all we are all humans... so don't be hard on urself .. i love u so much u touched so many hearts through ur voice and am d one of them.. apart from my depression, ur voice makes me relax
This was the performance right after Jonghyun's death, she had just cried before this performance so spot on
@@Omgyoucanchangeyourhandle i knew .. she cried extremely hard in his funeral.. i really like taeyeon
계속 울라그래.. 태연 슬프게 무대하는거 첨봤어
가사가 어떻게.. 상황이랑... 들다보니 눈가에 눈물이 글썽거리네요.
프로는 프로구나 싶습니다.. 힘들었을텐데..
오히려 이곡을 빨리 끝내고싶어하는 것 같다 생각했었습니다 숙제처럼.. 감정배제하려고 애쓰는.. 힘들게 부르는것만 같고 목소리에 아픔이 느껴져 안타까웠던 영상이였네요
왜요?
@@Miaow._. 맞아요 잊고 있었네요
이렇게 잊게되네요 ㅠㅠㅠ
누군가의 ......
잊혀지네요...
저도 이렇게 느꼈어요.. 슬픔에 젖어있기보단 애써 감추려는듯한 느낌이 들었어요. 참아내느라 힘드셨을듯 ㅠ
개소리;; 종현죽은거랑 이노래랑 뭔상관인데
부산츄리닝 이 노래랑은 상관없겠지만 태연님이 아끼고 친했던 종현님이 저 당시에 그랬으니 힘드셨을거예요
Baekhyun: That was my girl, your gonna be okay:)
Please move on
We can’t move on🥺
@@noorenalfonso4303 you have to!
@@madison8272 but i hurts a lot..baekyeon hits different when falling in love
@@madison8272 it’s hard to move on
She's singing with like 99% real voice 1% backing vocals
시간이 얼마 지나지 않았지만 종현이 나와있는 영상들을 다시 보다 태연이 나온 영상들을 보게 됐는데 이 무대는 뭔가 정말 많은게 느껴지는 무대인 것 같다
아진짜 왜이날 울부짖는거같냐ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ눈물날뻔..........
저거 태연 운다음임 ㅠ 이하이님이 그 추모곡 부르면서 우셔서 태연도 듣다가 울고 안아주고 싶었다고 했음 자기는 저렇게 참고 있으면서 ...
10년정도를 같이한 소속사 식구를 잃은 저 상황에서 과연 노래하는게 기뻤을지... 항상 그립다 종현아.... 어디서나 함께할께
You can tell when she’s holding back her tears and such. just like the time when she sang into the new world in Tokyo dome when Jessica left. her singing becomes really emotional and just because she’s the leader she herself thinks that she must be strong and not let anyone think that she’s weak by showing her tears
mimithefifi جيو
just want to clarify, Jessica did not leave.
jessica enthusiast she was kicked out right? Its been years but i cant still moved on. I was still hoping that one day they will pull off a stage with her suprisely. But i know its impossible
@@jessica.enthusiast jessica ㅗ
@@rantatouille5696 yes :)
if u listen and watch carefully ... u can see that she is holding back her tears .. its been really hard on her when her best friend pass away .. but shes trying to not make us worry about her and hold back her tears .. T.T
Park Hyejung and also to get ride of those stupid antis comments who thinks she is an emotionless human they don't even treat her like human
ASH tysone i know right .. shes holding back her emotion because she knows .. if she falls down her member and the fan will falls down too ! shes the strongest leader ive ever seen
@@seashelae it's not sulli tho, it's jonghyun they are talkin about
@@seashelae it's jonghyun ... So uhm
@@seashelae ..this is about jonghyun.
이게 라이브 논란 됐었음? 상황도 상황이고 부르기 정말 힘들었을텐데도 ㄹㅇ 존나 잘했는데
The people in the comments saying how they feel bad because they’re certain she’s sad during this performance because of Baekhyun when in reality she almost broke down because OF Jonghyun, minutes before this performance she was *crying* because there was a tribute/memorial show for him, and she went up on stage to perform after she *cried* for him, please respect that she was performing this song in tribute to her late close friend *Kim Jonghyun* and not because of her past relationship with *Baekhyun*
wish I could upvote this a thousand times lmao shippers are so annoying
@@ilovetaeyeon6854 ikrrr like it’s been 6 years they need to move on lmao
finally someone felt the same. i expected when i view the comment that ppl will talk bout her and jjong but all i can see is his name wtf
it’s really annoying whenever taeyeon sings a sad song people would be like “oh this is about baek” like seriously she didn’t even wrote those lyrics and fans be hallucinating. they dated, they broke up. no matter they remained as friends or not, people should stop bringing this up
Please make this a top comment, newer fans misinterpreted this performance.
*i can feel you unnie :((*
when is your birthday pls
Diane Cajayon are you talking to me? 😳
yes
Diane Cajayon may i know why? 😂 i dont even know you
I'm just curious because u call her unnie😁😁😁
진짜 하늘을 향해 울부짖는 fine이다..
정말 정의하기 어려운 감정이다 어떤 마음으로 저 노래를 부르고 무대에 섰을지 연습생부터 보았던 동료가 곁에서 떠난 걸 받아드리기도 전에 무대를 섰던 태연이 그저 대단하고 고맙다
추모식 이후 며칠 안돼서 콘서트하고 콘서트에서 팬들한테 오래오래 노래하고 어디 안간다고 공약하고 사랑해라고 해준 너무너무 강한사람
우리 마지막 그순간이자꾸 떠올라 잘지내란 말이 전부였던 담담한이별.. 너무안타깝
2:56 여기서 참다가 터진 게 보인다 ㅠㅠ 너무 마음 아파 아직까지도
전혀
sunset lee 저 노래 부를때가 언젠지는 알고 그렇게 말하는거냐?
sunset lee 너는 뭔데 댓글마다 시비털고 다니냐
@@user-uc6df7jd2그만 꼬여
@@user-uc6df7jd2 고아라서그럼 이해해주셈
Taeyeon lost Jonghyun, Sulli, Hara and her father in the recent years. I can't even imagine what she's gone through. I hope people can be nice with her. She said herself she's been struggling with depression. She's trying her best, she deserves love and support. ♡
And her grandma too now
Rest in peace
@Tastes Like Water Don't say 'fans'..say psychos...who need to go to a mental hospital asap!!!
I do not want to say Baekhyun Also included
and she deseve to dating. have a someone who can always support him
진짜 태연같은 가수 없다... 노래 잘하지 춤 잘추지 성격 좋지 입담 좋지 끼도 많고 완전 요정... 천사페어리... 언니 이번 노래도 너무 좋아요 사랑해용
그러니까요 ❤❤
어릴때부터 봤던 가수라 항상 나보다 어른이라 생각했는데 다시 보니 태연도 누군가를 떠나보내기엔 익숙한 나이가 아닌걸 느끼게 됨
and now sulli who she adored so much passed away.
yepp I'm so worried about her
and her father passed away on her birthday :(
저렇게 크고 공적인 무대에서 숨 차오르게 라이브 하는 거 진짜 대단한 가수임...
I can feel her pain. I hope she get the happiness that she deserved.
She is true queen of KPOP.. Thank you Taeyeon unnie.. Our SONE leader..
@enn dorisn ?????
@enn dorisn hello? Anti stupid dumb ppl who keep on putting taeyeon down well, she's on top and thats her place.
@enn dorisn 🤮🤮🤮🤮🐵🐵🐵
@enn dorisn we all know Iu like taeyeon and she adore her.
You mean KING Taeyeon?
i can feel the emotion that she tried to convey in this song. it makes me so emotional everytime i watch this videos. and when the part "it's not fine" when she make an eye contact with the camera it really looks like she want to say that she is not fine :(
basyimoshi why is she sad???
AlexaBTS Sings cuz Jonghyun passed away
Shaoqi Liang oh.....
Shaoqi Liang he Didn’t
AlexaBTS Sings he Commited suicide
2:20 정말 혼신의 힘을 다해서, 모든 힘을 쥐어짜서라도 부르는 태연의 모습이 너무 멋있고 거대해보인다. 정말 프로같고 어른같다
it feels like she's addressing that "she's not fine"
태연 목소리가 하늘까지 닿았으면 좋겠다..
뒷부분으로 갈수록 눈물 고이는거같네
앞전에 이하이님 한숨 무대에 지금 저 무대까지 이하이님과 태연님한텐 너무 힘든 무대였다
She literally never sounds bad she’s a goddess sent from up above by actual angels
뭔가 이 당시에 노래 불렀을 때 자기 상황이랑 노래가 비슷하단 느낌이 들었는데 꼭 종현이한테 말하는 기분이랄까....
저땐 유난히 슬픔이라는 외침이 더 잘 느껴지는 라이브같음.. 태연선배😭😭
혹시 연습생이세요...??
She's not singing, she's telling her feelings 🥺💔
She’s not just singing, but she’s singing with her experience in love. The BaekYeon couple we failed to protect,& how she move on from that part of her life. I
How did we fail?I'm new
@@sbh6536 To protect Baek and Taeyong from the hate they receive so they broke up.
@@rosangelicasantana108 Taeyeon*
Taeyong is from NCT xD
@@imasaiko_ Thanks. 😩❤️
@@Attackontitanlover123 Baek and Taeyeon were a couple before but because of Toxic Fans they break up.
her eyes show everything 😭
She's so professional. She tried to supress her tears even though she was about to cry. "It's not fine." :(
After I heard this song in tiktok, I'm here to watch it again
same girl
Same me too
(2)
same💔
Same 😞💔
내가 너무 힘든 25살때 그 지옥 같던
돈 버는 곳에 가면서 매일 듣던 노래
그래서 난 지금 버틸수 있었지
참 좋은 노래
나였으면.....진짜 엉엉 울면서 불렀을텐데....진짜 프로다...ㅜㅠㅠ
가사가 너무 상황가 잘 맞아서 더 마음이 아프고 정말 그나마 밝게 불렀던 노래인데 이때 태연 표정은 그 누구보다도 눈물을 참으려 한 표정
주기적으로 보는 영상
온몸으로 노래하는게 이런거구나 울부짖고 애처로운 느낌이 너무 슬프고 생각남
몰랐는데 알고보니까... 가사때문에도 울컥한게 보인다.... 울음참는것도 보이고... 아이고....
슬프면 배에 힘도 안들어감. 저걸 어떻게 불렀는지 상상도 안가
fine 무대 자체가 이하이 - 한숨으로 태연이 운 뒤고 저 무대 바로 앞 순서가 종현 추모라 저정도로 부른것도 대단한거임
이거 고정 각
Only second gen SM artist can sing this beautifully, that too live..tbh SHINee does lives the best, and after them its just Taeyeon no one is doing it like them, because they can't..these are the idols that song live on their debut stage and there are idols nowadays who can't help just lipsync
"Its not fiiiine" line hits me so hard
Its not fine without you Jonghyunnie😢
노래는 혼자 부르는데 저 넓은 무대가 꽉 채워진 듯한 느낌
금방이라도 울것같은 표정이네... 눈물을 참는게 보여
I felt that "It's not fine".
This song is not about them after they broke up, but this song is Jonghyun's story, moreover, this song came out after Jonghyun was gone, so this song has nothing to do with Baekhyun or Taeyeon..mv release after jonghyun is gone,,okey
this song came out early 2017, way before jonghyun’s death, so it has nothing to do with him. the song is about the suffering taeyeon had to endure after losing a loved one, baekhyun, even if they didn’t want to let go of each other. can we please focus on taeyeon and her talent and not always make it about jonghyun, hara, sulli or someone else¿
@@larisastancu4012 A. This performance is literally a tribute to Jonghyun so of course people will acknowledge that. B. while it's true that the song came out early 2017 it doesn't mean that it's about a relationship that ended 3 years prior. That's the only public releationship people know of that's why y'all are so fixated on the fact that many of her songs about ending things is about him. D. She didn't even write the song. She may relate to it but it's not written by her which doesn't even matter since she's one of the strongest singers out there. D. People always praise her for her talent and tell her that all the time. The reason people mention her friends in the industry that died is because they all have something in common. Depression and them taking their lives. Since Taeyeon has stated that she also suffers with depression. Sulli and Hara got treated so terribly by the public even tho they didn't do anything. Lastly people need to let go of this Baekhyun shipping shit.
@@larisastancu4012 ironic how 'can we focus on Taeyeon?' when you're the one who mentioned Baekhyun lmao. Not every song she sings related to Baekhyun. 🤷🏻♀️
가끔씩 아주 가끔씩은 떠올려봅니다.
각자 개인의 삶으로 바쁘지만,
저는 한달에 한번씩은 생각하며 말걸어줬던거 같아요.
종현아 거기서도 잘 지내니
들리는 대답은 없지만 어렴풋이 알 것 같습니다
3:03 the way she looks at the camera saying its not fine and looking away hiding the tears that are on the edge of her eyes
No one can sing this like her ... i bet...No one
2:31 무딘 척 웃음을 지어 보이며
너란 그늘을 애써 외면해보지만
우리 마지막 그 순간이 자꾸 떠올라
잘 지내란 말이 전부였던 담담한 이별
여기 가사 진짜.....감정이입 대박임 너무 슬퍼 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
솔직히 태연이 노래 부를 때마다 얼굴 찡그리는 거 너무 멋지다.....
Fine 이란 노래를 부르지만 전혀 Fine하지 않았던 무대..
You can literally feel her sadness in her singing
fine 이 곡이 종현님이랑 태연님의 과거 이야기와 저 때 태연님의 마음을 담아낸 노래 같은 느낌인 것 같아요. 뭔가 상황 매치가 되네요.
이 노래 엄청난 고음에 숨실틈 없는 힘든 곡입니다.
태연..이 노래를 통해 자신의 힘듬을 애써 감추려 하는거 같다.정말 프로답다.
Baekhyun! Is it fine?🥺 BaekYeon fan here👋💞
Non sones think she’s struggling with singing but real sones know she just held back from crying
She is trying to hold her tears but I'm sobbing after seeing her like this 😭💔
This song was very relatable to there love s story, say's its fine but its not.
I am watching this 2 yrs later on the same day this was posted
Omg glad I found ur comment lol
Even though SM Ent is very harsh with their vocal training, this is the result, basically Vocal angels 💜💜