Wow this is eye opening. In Christianity women are not allowed to speak over a man or teach and are told to be quiet in church obviously this doesn’t happen anymore 🤷🏻♀️😆 something I struggle with is how the things we are told to do we don’t do it and why ? I don’t understand why Christianity only follows certain things . I respect Islam as it sticks to its teachings and doesn’t bend to cultures of societies etc .
@@jesussaveslives512 the muslim way of worship is not impress other people but to please and display complete submission to god. I understand why it might seem awkward to you. To each their own 🤷♀️
I as a female would be more comfortable praying in a separate space or behind men. This is because of the way we pray in Islam. This is not really an issue of men looking because the vast majority or all Muslim men would not look. This is more about what is comfortable.
@@arcane1282 then she can do that. In the time of the prophet he appointed a Woman ( i dont remember her name but i will get you the name if you insist) as an Imam of the masjid of her area. And hired a man to be her moazzan (the man who calls for prayer who is supposed to pray behind the imam).
Assalamualikum, many of people is being helpful to see this lecture like mine. Although i am a muslim but i don't know much knowledge about islam. It is really shame for me. but when i started to see thise lectures after from that i am being fully enriched the knowledge of Islam. Your selective topics are much beautiful in the context of era.
In Indonesia, men-women section in some mosque aren't front-behind row, but side by side with some barrier between two groups, and it's working. Maybe some Muslim community made a fuss about this because they lived in society which had strict separation between men and women (like many place in Middle East and South Asia), so looking another gender became such a big thing.
Although it doesn’t change how god sees us it does change how men see us as women, I think women are just as distracted by men as they are by us. The fact that women have to manoeuvre around the male gaze and not vice versa is absolutely ridiculous. Who’s to say that maybe a man prostrating in front of me won’t distract me? So yes I think we need to change the way women are seen in modern Islam.
As salam alaikum السلام عليكم. I can recall my early days of being a new Muslimah and feeling a bit "off" by being behind the men inside the Masjid for Salah, but I understood from an historical point, that the men would defend the Mosque if under attack. They would guard the women if something came up especially during the early Islamic times when armies or tribes would attack or try to run them out of cities etc. for me, 9ne day a couple of years ago truly made me appreciate the separations. for example: one year we had a drunk and "high" male enter our mosque from off the street just walking by..and was digging around in the books on the shelf, rambling, not responding to the brothers, and at that point, I truly appreciated that I was able to be behind the partition we have (which can be moved if sisters want to see to the front)- as the man who seemed lost, disoriented, confused and only said a few words about being homeless, did not have a chance to see me nor know I was there. All of the men that happened to be still in the mosque when that man came in, suddenly gathered near him asking if he was okay, gave him water, asked if he needed a ride, asked if he truly was interested in Islam as he was standing inside a mosque! And so they dealt with the man kindly and made sure we were protected just in case the person was there for other reasons. That same year, we had letters sent to our mosque from Christians/churches nearby blaming us Muslims for all sorts of problems from 9/11 to any other "terroristic threat" or headline in the news. So we were already a bit more aware and couscous that there could possible be a negative attacks to our mosque or partitioners. In my city, just within the last 2 years, we’ve had three different groups of teenagers or young adults smash in windows at two different mosques and caught in camera. Anyhow, although I felt a bit strange at first being in the back, coming from being a Baha’i Faith member of many years.. I know that in most cases, everyone no matter gender, are at the mosque to pray and study Quran etc, not bother anyone or us women. because I am disabled both visually and hearing, I am able to sit up front in order to be able to hear the Imam and this hasn’t been any issue before. We currently do not have hired sign language interpreters for the mosque. As far as men and women being separated in religious settings, that actually started way before Islam. Hinduism is the oldest major religion and they also separate the genders during yoga sessions, worship,and listening to the Sermon. Even synagogues have also kept this tradition as well as women wearing headscarfs during prayer, and at it’d most holiest site: The Wailing Wall in the Holy Land. Women must cover modestly and they have their own entrance with a dividing gate near the Wall itself. Everyone knows that’s just how traditional practices are done to this day. some churches still keep to this tradition also. The Catholic Church also had separation until the 80’s maybe a little earlier as several aspects of Mass was changed including the use of the language of the congregation rather then Latin only. But in Islam, outsiders tend to think we are "suppressed" and told what to do by men and that men "cannot control their sexual desires" and so we must be separated. I have never noticed any men try to walk towards the women’s area to chat with any of us nor speak directly with us as some of us are still praying, doing Zikr, reading Qur’an etc. men and women do socialize out front of the mosque after prayer and there hasn’t been any issues brought to the congregation’s attention regarding this topic. Many religious centers/churches/synagogues/mosques separated men and women still to this day and is common knowledge. Eid/celebrations or holidays are usually not separated though. Ramadan is s out to come up next month which I look forward too, Subhan Allah. Wa-llahu akbar. Peace be upon everyone no matter faith tradition or gender. As-Salamu-Alaikum! -Crystal/Sr. Najma.
صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم علیہ السلام سلام اللہ علیہا رضی اللہ تعالیٰ اجمعین رحمت اللہ thank you for this video very informative brother and sister keep up the good work mashAllah excellent explanation about the main point which after this video no need to raise question but unfortunately there are many individuals who will never understand and will ask the same question again and again after getting the best answer and we all can agree to disagree with each other ideology or may I say religion that is the reason why I always say that after ending my comment that now and always will be up to individual's to research by themselves without being biased towards any ideology or may I say religion like always all the best to Muslim and Atheism love from Pakistan 🇵🇰
Alhamdulillâhi Rabbil âlamiin. Allâhumma Salli alâ Seyyidinâ Mawlâna Muhammadin Wa Sallim. Thank you Dr ALLY for sharing your knowledge with us. May ALLÂH SWT Rewards You, your family and friends and all of your Team members. Amiin Amiin Amiin Amiin We love you.
BJP IT Cell is now flocking these videos nowadays to cut and paste clips selectively to further their propaganda. Like the video about Daesh treating the women.. They edited it to further their propaganda.
actually praying in the back is more conveniant. The one who exist the mosque the first are those in the back. They can leave as quick as they want. If they have to suddenly leave, they dont need to cross trough a tiny pathway and having all eyes on them lol.
It's not from the sunnah, they believe their foreheads should touch the earth itself, when the sunnah makes it easier not to do that. I suggest you don't follow what they do.
Imagine standing shoulder to shoulder with a beautiful women. Is my mind going to be on God or on her. You go to mosque to pray not to intermingle with the opposite sex. As far as possible men and women should pray separately.
@@zuricon1925 Yes u are correct but I wonder which man would want his wife squeezed in between two men who are strangers. It is better for men and women to pray seperately, both sexes would feel more comfortable.
@@zuricon1925 A mosque is a place of worship and nothing should distract you from God. Women are not prohibited from going to a mosque where there is a seperate place for women to pray but in Islam there is more blessing and reward for her to pray at home. You insult me yet you do not know a single thing about me. Your IQ level really shines through.
Mohamed pbuh is the example of how we are to worship Allah, as the Quran says in 68:4, and 33:21. Thus, if this is how he arranged prayers, who are we to change it, when Allah is telling us that Mohamed is the example?
You need to visit the Imam of the local mosque in your area who would thoroughly guide you. Basically you need to take the shahada which is proclaiming or acknowledging that there is no god but allah and prophet muhammad is the messenger of allah.
So many people and mosques believe this is a law and set in stone. That women must be only behind men or on a separate floor which is ridiculous. I’m happy with side by side!
The answer is so that the men will be able to focus on their salah and not be distracted by the beauty of the woman. Like the example he gave of the beautiful woman praying behind the men. Also we follow the practice of the Prophet Sal how things were done back then.
Yes can do, woman has to stand behind, one,two three doesn’t matter,but when a man leads salaah a man, he should stand beside but not same line position a bit down from the imam or who leads the salaah. Jajakallah
We can't do something that prophete mohamed and his companions didn't do, it is an innovation if we do. It is sad that sometimes, our imams trying to please the non-muslims by not giving straight answers to some questions. Islam is a religion and it advocates peace, tolerance, equality amongst genders and human beings. In Islam, I believe men and women are equivalent and both have rights and duties; thinking that men and women are equal is pure hypocrisy. There is no such thing inferiority or superiority between men and women but equivalence. Muslims foukahah ( scholars) should tell what is Islam and not try to fit in in anywhere; Islam is already complete. jazaakum alfikher.
It is wholly illogical that men and women are both "equivalent" but not "equal". If you're saying that Islam is this way rather than a culture, then beware that you are opening the religion up to being imperfect. That's on you.
They women pray on diffrent areas like women upstairs and men up if women were infront or back it would make the women uncomftable instead of thinking about her prayer she would be thinking if any man is looking at her bottom while they are in sujud
We are to follow Muhammad. That was how He had the prayers, that is what we follow. Period! No doubts about His teachings. Is there anyone better than Him?????
That's true, the problem is, non-muslim doesn't agree with you. If I answer their question as simple as You, they'll think that muslim following Islam blindly, as I know atheist tend to think logically, if we can answer the question logically chance to make non-muslim to interested with Islam is better. Sorry for bad english
@@mlc1610 why must you worry when you follow Allah's teachings "blindly". Not all can get "hidayah". Look at Muhamnad uncles, they believe and trust him, but, they don't follow him.??? Muhamnad is Allah's loved one. Do you think that if Muhammad make a doa to Allah to give them Islam, wouldn't Allah grant him?? The whole meaning is to obey Allah, no questions ask, Allah is the One who will question us. Example;: Dont dig in to the consequences of eating pork ie, germs on the pork cant be killed by cooking and blah blah blah with other findings. Just take it like Allah"s command, dont eat pork because its unclean. No need to ask any further. Cause if you gonna come up with all kinds of science proven facts about how bad pork is, then, all those pork eaters would be dead by now or suffering from its disease.
Why do muslim care so much about all this peripheral things? The only thing that should matter is spirituality and the personal connection to God. How does it matter if a person is praying in front of someone or behind?
Brother imagine a woman is praying in front of you she bows down she kneels down ( to God ) do you know how some man will react upon this? They will forget the prayer and they will stare at the woman looking with sexually interest, this is dangerous brother
So it’s essentially to not distract the boys….. So we can’t pray in front of y’all cause y’all can’t control ur selves. U call ur selves muslim men, fully aware that allah commands you to lower your gaze and apparently it’s so hard for you to do that when it’s haram to think about ANYTHING else other than allah in prayer, and yet you’re still supposed to be somewhat of a leader. Wow.
in prayers Allah ( God ) ordered men & women should have separate rows but in circumambulation Allah does not want men & women separated ??? i couldn't understand what thoughts Allah has ??? there is another issue , Allah ordered women to cover their face so that their beauty should not be exposed but Allah wants women beauty to be exposed during worshipping Allah in Haj ( pilgrimage ) ?? again i couldn't understand Allah's thoughts ?????
No ... I wouldnt even let myself pray in front of the men. ... Its just... well we dont need really the answer, because we know it for ourself. A woman and a men behinde isnt good anyways....
Men being pervs shouldn't be normalized. If they intend to pray , then that's what they shall do , not be animals and make women feel uncomfortable. Also , why cant we pray besides each other ! WE NEED TO VIEW EACH OTHER AS HUMANS AND SHOW MUTUAL RESPECT; those who cant do that dont deserve praying , because they're not honest and only praying withouy purpose !
@@reno8494 i noticed you hypocrites love to use "being human" card to spread your immorality between the believers. we as humans have sexual attraction toward things. Especially in this era where everything have been sexualised fully, specially women.
I'm not sure If i agree with Dr Shabir Ally's stand here, I think if it can be done otherwise, prophet would have done it. For example just because it doesn't say anywhere in the Qur'an women shouldn't hit the men, it doesn't mean they can. We cannot change the standards just to please the society or people.
@Kam Skylight Muhammad hurt Aisha, and he laughed when Aisha and Hafsa were punched by their fathers in front of him. The Quran also tells men to hit their wives if they suspect any bad feeling in their wives. The same word for "hit" is used that is used for striking the neck and fingers off disbelievers.
@@toomanymarys7355 The Arabic word Dharaba doesn't mean to beat. Besides, Quran doesn't explicitly say to beat them senselessly like you people think and on the top of that, it is at the final resort. You think like that because you just need a reason to reject Islam. since your bible filled with brutality and violence not just against women, Infants, babies even animals are not left.
@@dreamdream963 so the standard is only not to beat senselessly? Why not 'don't beat at all'? Anyway, Old Testament is there to show the People of the Book as they were before. The New Testament allows no such thing and no violence of any kind, whether between man and wife, nor man against man. You would however have to read the New Testament to understand why it supersedes the Old Testament - and centrally, it's because Jesus says so. Jesus said, if a man beats your cheek, you turn the other way and offer up your other cheek. It is about tolerance, never reacting in anger. Ephesians 5:25-29 - Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ also loved the church and gave Himself up for her, so that He might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of water with the word, that He might present to Himself the church in all her glory, having no spot or wrinkle or any such thing; but that she would be holy and blameless. For a true Christian the "church" is both an equivalence to the ummah (in Islam), and a physical manifestation of faith itself. It is commanded to love and be tender with your one wife. All other verses in the NT all talk about spouses caring for one another, loving each other - although, yes, wives are supposed to obey their husbands. There are no verses on ever raising a hand toward her. There is no room to interpret that violence against your wife is at all permissible. So not sure where you get off thinking that violence (especially between spouses) is permissible under the Bible. Sorry I felt I needed to set that straight, no hatred toward you - but misconception about the Christian faith should not be a fuel for anyone validating their own Islamic faith.
@@blackdqen I don't know how to unpack this loaded comment. The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, did not strike a servant or a woman, and he never struck anything with his hand. Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2328, Grade: Sahih do not beat them, and do not revile them.(Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 11, Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Number 2139 Aisha reported that Allah's Messenger, may Allah bless him, never beat anyone with his hand, neither a woman nor a servant, but only, in the case when he had been fighting in the cause of Allah …” (Sahih Muslim, Hadith 4296) Tafsir Ibn Kathir, chapter 68: Imam Ahmad recorded that `A’ishah said, “The Messenger of Allah never struck a servant of his with his hand, nor did he ever hit a woman. He never hit anything with his hand, except for when he was fighting Jihad in the cause of Allah Narrated Mu'awiyah al-Qushayri: "I went to the Apostle of Allah (peace_be_upon_him) and asked him: What do you say (command) about our wives? He replied: Give them food what you have for yourself, and clothe them by which you clothe yourself, and do not beat them, and do not revile them. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 11, Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Number 2139)" I can quote more authetic ahadith and how companinons of Prophet(peace_be_upon_him) interpret that verse all said the same thing do not beat your wives. Coming to your Bible, offer the other cheek this has nothing to do wtih the married couple, its a general statement. What i said was 'misconception'? let's see. Your Bible specifically cruel to women from the very beginning, For example Eve, because of Eve, now all women are suffering in child bearing. Deut 22 if the woman proven not to be virgin, one must kill her. Psalsm 137 Dashed the babies against the rock. 1Sameul 3 Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy everything that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys. Now, i know what you gonna say this is all in old testament, not in the NT, but dude this is your God who wants to dash babies, even animals, what kind of God is He? You worship that God who at least once commanded to dash infants against the rock. Regardless whether its NT OR OT your God still the same. Now coming to Jesus, Your Jesus called Gentile Woman a dog. Paul used to believe that man who remained unmarried is more purer than one who was defiled by a woman or in other words got married. Even in the Revelation 14:4 you can find the same quote. Your Bible is degrading women from the Eve itself, i could go on like this, but this comment is already huge. ROFL!
@@zuricon1925 k go and verify that aya of knowledgeable ducaa but if you just want argue you can’t convince me that women should lead a prayer nor anything else.
its all about khusyu (concentration). men by nature attracted to woman. thus the arrangement is to help men more focus towards god during few minutes of prayer.
why is a man's problem a woman's responsibility? maybe men should check their iman if they're thinking of immoral things in a place of worship praying to their creator? lol ridiculous
Support and watch on Netflix or CZcams The Turkish TV series about "Diriliş: Ertuğrul: (Resurrection: Ertugrul) The series is based on the life and times of a 13th-century Muslim Turk Leader & Hero from the Kayi Tribe. Ertugrul was the father of Osman, the founder of the Ottoman dynasty, which ruled a large part of the world for 600 years. The series is a must see. It is number 1 in the world and has attracted 500 million viewers from 70 different countries. Al-hamdu lillah
How much in hadas how much temple ke simbol di finish dunia okey how much finish in body in dunia this one and the stand de answ dishwani body understand story bangun allah subhanahuwataala
This is why I’m thinking about leaving Islam, it seems like everything has to be sacrificed for a mans comfort as if he has some type of power over a woman. I don’t like this
Don't leave sister..the only power is ALLAH. Yet, Quran tells us most people don't believe, hate the truth and are not thankful. Study Quran more and ask Allah to show you the way..shaytan wants to trick you.
Respecting human nature isn't about a man's comfort. It is about protecting everyone from situations that lead to temptation and potentionally disasterous consequences. Any traditional religion will have some practices in place that do this. This is also practiced in the business world for example having two people sign checks.
This one understand this one hold this one of them makro islam you understand this one you understand quran this one understand hard diskunanda fokus in hd sin dunya rizwan makro haram rizwan body no everything
Understand low dunia okey hadis dunia quran imam umat indonesia how many connecting quran di sungai connecting quran connecting kromoszilharam di suami waktu ever this one you focus for anucariz on hadis siswan understanding haram understanding halisi volkswagen industry in body everything this one quran
Excuse me, why are we trying to reinvent the wheel Rather than making this an issue, make arrangements for women separately like in few Muslim countries. Build a separate small hall for women to pray in the same masjid
This one mgina beautiful di sunny beautiful my husband rosa indonesia how much do shahriz 19 dosa because something this one to say in something okey something this one beautiful my husband this one dosa how much syndrome dunia di suunda yang ke 4 air putin dosa dunia dianggo itu kak batu
Disappointing answer really, the fact that it was an established practice is the Prophet peace be upon him and his companions should have sufficed. He's left the door open for the practice of women praying at the front
Unfortunately i have heard that this is indeed practiced in one society (where women lead the prayer for men) May God guid us and keep us on the right path
It was a change instituted by Muhammad because some of his pervert companions kept staring in lust at a beautiful woman. Perverted companions for a perverted prophet.
They pray behind their men so that they can keep an eye on them! If they prayed on front, the eyes of the men would not concentrate on their Creator! Astaqfirrullah! 😂😂😂😂😂
This one mgina beautiful di sunny beautiful my husband rosa indonesia how much do shahriz 19 dosa because something this one to say in something okey something this one beautiful my husband this one dosa how much syndrome dunia di suunda yang ke 4 air putin dosa dunia dianggo itu kak batu
Dear friends, please follow us on instagram at instagram.com/quranspeaks.tv
I would love to hear his answer on why a mother or wife can't lead prayer in her home and the proofs for this.
Thank you very much!
Sometimes I long for a woman's beautiful voice reciting aprayer in my ear 👂
Please tell me if a non mehram male can lead prayer of women
Wow this is eye opening. In Christianity women are not allowed to speak over a man or teach and are told to be quiet in church obviously this doesn’t happen anymore 🤷🏻♀️😆 something I struggle with is how the things we are told to do we don’t do it and why ? I don’t understand why Christianity only follows certain things . I respect Islam as it sticks to its teachings and doesn’t bend to cultures of societies etc .
That's why you possess FREE WILL. Use it.
Musilms pray so awkward
Us Christians are more FREE
We can pray standing, Etc, We don't do rituals
@@jesussaveslives512 the muslim way of worship is not impress other people but to please and display complete submission to god.
I understand why it might seem awkward to you. To each their own 🤷♀️
@@shaphyshaphy
Christians are not here to please mankind neither but to worship God
@@jesussaveslives512 i simply wanted to show you the islamic viewpoint... didnt mean any disrespect to any other religion.
I'm really thankful for all these videos. Dr.Shabir is an inspiration.
I as a female would be more comfortable praying in a separate space or behind men. This is because of the way we pray in Islam. This is not really an issue of men looking because the vast majority or all Muslim men would not look. This is more about what is comfortable.
ohhh you would be surprised
What if a woman is comfortable to pray in front? what if she doesn’t want to be behind?
@@arcane1282 then she can do that. In the time of the prophet he appointed a Woman ( i dont remember her name but i will get you the name if you insist) as an Imam of the masjid of her area. And hired a man to be her moazzan (the man who calls for prayer who is supposed to pray behind the imam).
@@TheOriginalArgument Her name was Ummu Waraqa. But many ulama had different interpretation about that event.
Well Said Sister, Alhamdulillah
Assalamualikum, many of people is being helpful to see this lecture like mine. Although i am a muslim but i don't know much knowledge about islam. It is really shame for me. but when i started to see thise lectures after from that i am being fully enriched the knowledge of Islam. Your selective topics are much beautiful in the context of era.
I’d prefer side by side, we are equal that way.
No.
Men and Women are equal but not same.
I saw your comment about leaving Islam, why?
Sister, I hope Allah will guide you
Isn't your comment reason enough? A religion that has that attitude...
@@lxxsh2093 that's what she said. equal. she didn't say same
Yes but sometimes the mosque is narrow
In Indonesia, men-women section in some mosque aren't front-behind row, but side by side with some barrier between two groups, and it's working. Maybe some Muslim community made a fuss about this because they lived in society which had strict separation between men and women (like many place in Middle East and South Asia), so looking another gender became such a big thing.
The explain was very good thanks for the correction
Although it doesn’t change how god sees us it does change how men see us as women, I think women are just as distracted by men as they are by us. The fact that women have to manoeuvre around the male gaze and not vice versa is absolutely ridiculous. Who’s to say that maybe a man prostrating in front of me won’t distract me?
So yes I think we need to change the way women are seen in modern Islam.
very good point my sister!
Exactlyyy!! Well said!
Yes!
Yes distraction is there in that case a side by side arrangement and a curtain or something in between would work better .
💯
As salam alaikum السلام عليكم. I can recall my early days of being a new Muslimah and feeling a bit "off" by being behind the men inside the Masjid for Salah, but I understood from an historical point, that the men would defend the Mosque if under attack. They would guard the women if something came up especially during the early Islamic times when armies or tribes would attack or try to run them out of cities etc. for me, 9ne day a couple of years ago truly made me appreciate the separations.
for example: one year we had a drunk and "high" male enter our mosque from off the street just walking by..and was digging around in the books on the shelf, rambling, not responding to the brothers, and at that point, I truly appreciated that I was able to be behind the partition we have (which can be moved if sisters want to see to the front)- as the man who seemed lost, disoriented, confused and only said a few words about being homeless, did not have a chance to see me nor know I was there. All of the men that happened to be still in the mosque when that man came in, suddenly gathered near him asking if he was okay, gave him water, asked if he needed a ride, asked if he truly was interested in Islam as he was standing inside a mosque! And so they dealt with the man kindly and made sure we were protected just in case the person was there for other reasons. That same year, we had letters sent to our mosque from Christians/churches nearby blaming us Muslims for all sorts of problems from 9/11 to any other "terroristic threat" or headline in the news. So we were already a bit more aware and couscous that there could possible be a negative attacks to our mosque or partitioners. In my city, just within the last 2 years, we’ve had three different groups of teenagers or young adults smash in windows at two different mosques and caught in camera. Anyhow, although I felt a bit strange at first being in the back, coming from being a Baha’i Faith member of many years.. I know that in most cases, everyone no matter gender, are at the mosque to pray and study Quran etc, not bother anyone or us women. because I am disabled both visually and hearing, I am able to sit up front in order to be able to hear the Imam and this hasn’t been any issue before. We currently do not have hired sign language interpreters for the mosque.
As far as men and women being separated in religious settings, that actually started way before Islam. Hinduism is the oldest major religion and they also separate the genders during yoga sessions, worship,and listening to the Sermon. Even synagogues have also kept this tradition as well as women wearing headscarfs during prayer, and at it’d most holiest site: The Wailing Wall in the Holy Land. Women must cover modestly and they have their own entrance with a dividing gate near the Wall itself. Everyone knows that’s just how traditional practices are done to this day. some churches still keep to this tradition also. The Catholic Church also had separation until the 80’s maybe a little earlier as several aspects of Mass was changed including the use of the language of the congregation rather then Latin only. But in Islam, outsiders tend to think we are "suppressed" and told what to do by men and that men "cannot control their sexual desires" and so we must be separated. I have never noticed any men try to walk towards the women’s area to chat with any of us nor speak directly with us as some of us are still praying, doing Zikr, reading Qur’an etc. men and women do socialize out front of the mosque after prayer and there hasn’t been any issues brought to the congregation’s attention regarding this topic. Many religious centers/churches/synagogues/mosques separated men and women still to this day and is common knowledge. Eid/celebrations or holidays are usually not separated though. Ramadan is s out to come up next month which I look forward too, Subhan Allah. Wa-llahu akbar. Peace be upon everyone no matter faith tradition or gender. As-Salamu-Alaikum! -Crystal/Sr. Najma.
What if the mosque got attacked from behind? Then the women are defending the men? lol
Makes sense and, as ever, a logical and informative upload - thanks.
Brilliant wise Man. Pleasure to listen and learn . Best wishes from Lithuania.
May Allah bless you Dr. Shabir and Dr. Safia😊
صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم علیہ السلام سلام اللہ علیہا رضی اللہ تعالیٰ اجمعین رحمت اللہ thank you for this video very informative brother and sister keep up the good work mashAllah excellent explanation about the main point which after this video no need to raise question but unfortunately there are many individuals who will never understand and will ask the same question again and again after getting the best answer and we all can agree to disagree with each other ideology or may I say religion that is the reason why I always say that after ending my comment that now and always will be up to individual's to research by themselves without being biased towards any ideology or may I say religion like always all the best to Muslim and Atheism love from Pakistan 🇵🇰
Dr. Shabir is a blessing for ummah.
Masha Allah Doctor great lecture
Alhamdulillâhi Rabbil âlamiin.
Allâhumma Salli alâ Seyyidinâ Mawlâna Muhammadin Wa Sallim.
Thank you Dr ALLY for sharing your knowledge with us. May ALLÂH SWT Rewards You, your family and friends and all of your Team members. Amiin Amiin Amiin Amiin
We love you.
how could you not like and subscribe when dr Shabeer asks for it at the end of the video? 08:36
BJP IT Cell is now flocking these videos nowadays to cut and paste clips selectively to further their propaganda. Like the video about Daesh treating the women.. They edited it to further their propaganda.
There’s really no end to RSS’s venomous ways. The earlier the world realizes we need to collectively put an end to RSS, the better for world peace.
actually praying in the back is more conveniant. The one who exist the mosque the first are those in the back. They can leave as quick as they want. If they have to suddenly leave, they dont need to cross trough a tiny pathway and having all eyes on them lol.
thanks. another great video
no
Why we can't just pray abreast rather than in the back / front?
Dr shabir...... alhamdulillah
Question from Philippines. Why Shia believers put clay soil in front of his place of sujude. What is the purpose or wisdom of this prayer methods?
It's not from the sunnah, they believe their foreheads should touch the earth itself, when the sunnah makes it easier not to do that. I suggest you don't follow what they do.
Imagine standing shoulder to shoulder with a beautiful women. Is my mind going to be on God or on her. You go to mosque to pray not to intermingle with the opposite sex. As far as possible men and women should pray separately.
men should learn to control themselves.
@@zuricon1925 Yes u are correct but I wonder which man would want his wife squeezed in between two men who are strangers. It is better for men and women to pray seperately, both sexes would feel more comfortable.
@@sahirebrahim6412 how is it better? it’s men like you who can’t control themselves and don’t know how to lower their gaze, grow up and mature...
@@sahirebrahim6412 if you lower your gaze their would be no issue, you sound like a pervert
@@zuricon1925 A mosque is a place of worship and nothing should distract you from God. Women are not prohibited from going to a mosque where there is a seperate place for women to pray but in Islam there is more blessing and reward for her to pray at home.
You insult me yet you do not know a single thing about me. Your IQ level really shines through.
Mohamed pbuh is the example of how we are to worship Allah, as the Quran says in 68:4, and 33:21. Thus, if this is how he arranged prayers, who are we to change it, when Allah is telling us that Mohamed is the example?
Love The Showwwwwwwwwwwww.
Me too
As Salaam Alaakum. The Prophet pbuh said Pray the way you see him Pray.
It maybe happened all the time still the same today
Most mosques in algeria have two floors, one for men and the other for women.
Love the showwwwwwwwwwwww.
Do you have to be re-baptized and speak in tongues is the Oneness group teaches to be joined to the Muslim religion?
You need to visit the Imam of the local mosque in your area who would thoroughly guide you. Basically you need to take the shahada which is proclaiming or acknowledging that there is no god but allah and prophet muhammad is the messenger of allah.
So can man and woman ( husband and wife ) can pray together
If you mean side by side. Yes.
I like to pray in the back. I feel more comfortable that way when I'm out of the sight of men. I also like to pray according to the Sunnah.
why not in front
@@napoleonlaguerre5587 Literally gave the reason in the comment dude
Even in their prayers men cannot maintain their focus and composure....probably the main reason.
So many people and mosques believe this is a law and set in stone. That women must be only behind men or on a separate floor which is ridiculous. I’m happy with side by side!
He told us everything ..except the answer
The answer is so that the men will be able to focus on their salah and not be distracted by the beauty of the woman.
Like the example he gave of the beautiful woman praying behind the men.
Also we follow the practice of the Prophet Sal how things were done back then.
@@Jameelah147 but its not haram if sisters and us pray together😊
@@arasmirvani9400 yes it's your muhrim
@@arasmirvani9400 we cant change what our prophet has ordered uis to do
I don’t mean to be rude but I want ask dr shabir why do we have separate rest rooms for men and women?
privacy
Men tal u r
كلامك غريب
I do not think Dr ally give an historical reason of why
Dr. Shabir Ally is brilliant, may Allah preserve him, ameen
I do not think DAr ally give an historical reason of why
If Nothing like that never mentioned in the Quran then we should stick to the sunnah and forget about the possibilities. Allah knows best
Praying behind men is Sunnah, but praying in a separate room is just something people invented after the death of the prophet, pbuh
This explanation does not make any sense.
Why? What doesn't make sense?
Can a man (non mahram) led a salah ,while a woman prays behind him? Can he led the salah? Is the ques clear?
Yes can do, woman has to stand behind, one,two three doesn’t matter,but when a man leads salaah a man, he should stand beside but not same line position a bit down from the imam or who leads the salaah. Jajakallah
We can't do something that prophete mohamed and his companions didn't do, it is an innovation if we do. It is sad that sometimes, our imams trying to please the non-muslims by not giving straight answers to some questions. Islam is a religion and it advocates peace, tolerance, equality amongst genders and human beings. In Islam, I believe men and women are equivalent and both have rights and duties; thinking that men and women are equal is pure hypocrisy. There is no such thing inferiority or superiority between men and women but equivalence. Muslims foukahah ( scholars) should tell what is Islam and not try to fit in in anywhere; Islam is already complete. jazaakum alfikher.
It is wholly illogical that men and women are both "equivalent" but not "equal". If you're saying that Islam is this way rather than a culture, then beware that you are opening the religion up to being imperfect. That's on you.
@@blackdqen what do you understand by men and women are equal? Equal in what sense ?
Why doesn't God get the (pbuh)?
Because pbuh means peace be upon him and One of 99 God names is al salam means the peace ..you can’t send peace to God when God himself is peace
Even if I was of Christian faith I would not feel comfortable with men being behind me looking at my behind!
Just my opinion folks!
They women pray on diffrent areas like women upstairs and men up if women were infront or back it would make the women uncomftable instead of thinking about her prayer she would be thinking if any man is looking at her bottom while they are in sujud
We are to follow Muhammad. That was how He had the prayers, that is what we follow. Period!
No doubts about His teachings. Is there anyone better than Him?????
what an arrogant comment, makes a statement and offers no help or insight. It would've been better if you just skipped commenting at all.
@@lusiiiman not arrogant, it"s a straight foward, no twists and turns.
That's true, the problem is, non-muslim doesn't agree with you. If I answer their question as simple as You, they'll think that muslim following Islam blindly, as I know atheist tend to think logically, if we can answer the question logically chance to make non-muslim to interested with Islam is better. Sorry for bad english
But yeah, you're true. No doubts about His teachings
@@mlc1610 why must you worry when you follow Allah's teachings "blindly". Not all can get "hidayah". Look at Muhamnad uncles, they believe and trust him, but, they don't follow him.???
Muhamnad is Allah's loved one. Do you think that if Muhammad make a doa to Allah to give them Islam, wouldn't Allah grant him??
The whole meaning is to obey Allah, no questions ask, Allah is the One who will question us. Example;:
Dont dig in to the consequences of eating pork ie, germs on the pork cant be killed by cooking and blah blah blah with other findings. Just take it like Allah"s command, dont eat pork because its unclean. No need to ask any further. Cause if you gonna come up with all kinds of science proven facts about how bad pork is, then, all those pork eaters would be dead by now or suffering from its disease.
You will still find men and women on different sides of the church in some anabaptist churches.
He is opening the door for different arrangements? It is bad 👎.
Why do muslim care so much about all this peripheral things? The only thing that should matter is spirituality and the personal connection to God. How does it matter if a person is praying in front of someone or behind?
Brother imagine a woman is praying in front of you she bows down she kneels down ( to God ) do you know how some man will react upon this? They will forget the prayer and they will stare at the woman looking with sexually interest, this is dangerous brother
@@yargi5811 why can't they control themselves
Why does it bother u ?
So it’s essentially to not distract the boys…..
So we can’t pray in front of y’all cause y’all can’t control ur selves. U call ur selves muslim men, fully aware that allah commands you to lower your gaze and apparently it’s so hard for you to do that when it’s haram to think about ANYTHING else other than allah in prayer, and yet you’re still supposed to be somewhat of a leader.
Wow.
@Rockshy “cause I said so” is not an answer honey lmao
in prayers Allah ( God ) ordered men & women should have separate rows but in circumambulation Allah does not want men & women separated ??? i couldn't understand what thoughts Allah has ??? there is another issue , Allah ordered women to cover their face so that their beauty should not be exposed but Allah wants women beauty to be exposed during worshipping Allah in Haj ( pilgrimage ) ?? again i couldn't understand Allah's thoughts ?????
No ... I wouldnt even let myself pray in front of the men.
...
Its just... well we dont need really the answer, because we know it for ourself.
A woman and a men behinde isnt good anyways....
I don’t think you watched the whole video, he said we can pray side by side
@@shukrat5293 .... that doenst even matter with side to side. I'm only speaking about behinde. Don't tell things you dont know from others.
Men being pervs shouldn't be normalized. If they intend to pray , then that's what they shall do , not be animals and make women feel uncomfortable. Also , why cant we pray besides each other ! WE NEED TO VIEW EACH OTHER AS HUMANS AND SHOW MUTUAL RESPECT; those who cant do that dont deserve praying , because they're not honest and only praying withouy purpose !
@@reno8494 very true
@@reno8494 i noticed you hypocrites love to use "being human" card to spread your immorality between the believers. we as humans have sexual attraction toward things. Especially in this era where everything have been sexualised fully, specially women.
Pronounce correctly..circumNambulation..The creator called Himself ALLAH
I see photos in different local mosques that have the women literally roped off in the back corner, like cows 🐄…. A very gross display
I'm not sure If i agree with Dr Shabir Ally's stand here, I think if it can be done otherwise, prophet would have done it. For example just because it doesn't say anywhere in the Qur'an women shouldn't hit the men, it doesn't mean they can. We cannot change the standards just to please the society or people.
It says that husbands should hit wives. Do you think that's necessary? Or do you think that's something that a corrupt man would want in a fake book?
@Kam Skylight Muhammad hurt Aisha, and he laughed when Aisha and Hafsa were punched by their fathers in front of him. The Quran also tells men to hit their wives if they suspect any bad feeling in their wives. The same word for "hit" is used that is used for striking the neck and fingers off disbelievers.
@@toomanymarys7355 The Arabic word Dharaba doesn't mean to beat. Besides, Quran doesn't explicitly say to beat them senselessly like you people think and on the top of that, it is at the final resort. You think like that because you just need a reason to reject Islam. since your bible filled with brutality and violence not just against women, Infants, babies even animals are not left.
@@dreamdream963 so the standard is only not to beat senselessly? Why not 'don't beat at all'? Anyway, Old Testament is there to show the People of the Book as they were before. The New Testament allows no such thing and no violence of any kind, whether between man and wife, nor man against man. You would however have to read the New Testament to understand why it supersedes the Old Testament - and centrally, it's because Jesus says so.
Jesus said, if a man beats your cheek, you turn the other way and offer up your other cheek. It is about tolerance, never reacting in anger. Ephesians 5:25-29 - Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ also loved the church and gave Himself up for her, so that He might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of water with the word, that He might present to Himself the church in all her glory, having no spot or wrinkle or any such thing; but that she would be holy and blameless.
For a true Christian the "church" is both an equivalence to the ummah (in Islam), and a physical manifestation of faith itself. It is commanded to love and be tender with your one wife. All other verses in the NT all talk about spouses caring for one another, loving each other - although, yes, wives are supposed to obey their husbands. There are no verses on ever raising a hand toward her. There is no room to interpret that violence against your wife is at all permissible. So not sure where you get off thinking that violence (especially between spouses) is permissible under the Bible. Sorry I felt I needed to set that straight, no hatred toward you - but misconception about the Christian faith should not be a fuel for anyone validating their own Islamic faith.
@@blackdqen I don't know how to unpack this loaded comment.
The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, did not strike a servant or a woman, and he never struck anything with his hand.
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2328, Grade: Sahih do not beat them, and do not revile them.(Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 11, Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Number 2139
Aisha reported that Allah's Messenger, may Allah bless him, never beat anyone with his hand, neither a woman nor a servant, but only, in the case when he had been fighting in the cause of Allah …” (Sahih Muslim, Hadith 4296)
Tafsir Ibn Kathir, chapter 68:
Imam Ahmad recorded that `A’ishah said, “The Messenger of Allah never struck a servant of his with his hand, nor did he ever hit a woman. He never hit anything with his hand, except for when he was fighting Jihad in the cause of Allah
Narrated Mu'awiyah al-Qushayri: "I went to the Apostle of Allah (peace_be_upon_him) and asked him: What do you say (command) about our wives? He replied: Give them food what you have for yourself, and clothe them by which you clothe yourself, and do not beat them, and do not revile them. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 11, Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Number 2139)"
I can quote more authetic ahadith and how companinons of Prophet(peace_be_upon_him) interpret that verse all said the same thing do not beat your wives.
Coming to your Bible, offer the other cheek this has nothing to do wtih the married couple, its a general statement. What i said was 'misconception'? let's see. Your Bible specifically cruel to women from the very beginning, For example Eve, because of Eve, now all women are suffering in child bearing. Deut 22 if the woman proven not to be virgin, one must kill her. Psalsm 137 Dashed the babies against the rock. 1Sameul 3 Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy everything that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys. Now, i know what you gonna say this is all in old testament, not in the NT, but dude this is your God who wants to dash babies, even animals, what kind of God is He? You worship that God who at least once commanded to dash infants against the rock. Regardless whether its NT OR OT your God still the same. Now coming to Jesus, Your Jesus called Gentile Woman a dog. Paul used to believe that man who remained unmarried is more purer than one who was defiled by a woman or in other words got married. Even in the Revelation 14:4 you can find the same quote. Your Bible is degrading women from the Eve itself, i could go on like this, but this comment is already huge. ROFL!
Can a muslim women wear pant??
Loose pants
@@phewphew402 same goes for men btw
Didn’t god said men are leaders over women yaa sheeq modern? And praying needs leadership read between lines.
Um please cite where it says that in the quran because that is completely false
where do you see that in the Quran?
@@zuricon1925 arijaalu qawaamiina linisaai if you didn’t see that aya don’t reply
@@abdisalamdirir5904 can you tell me what verse it is so i can go look at it?
@@zuricon1925 k go and verify that aya of knowledgeable ducaa but if you just want argue you can’t convince me that women should lead a prayer nor anything else.
its all about khusyu (concentration). men by nature attracted to woman. thus the arrangement is to help men more focus towards god during few minutes of prayer.
so a woman has to sacrifice her comfort to make sure a man is comfortable in his prayer? what about her prayer?
Aren't women attracted to men too? What about their concentration and how it affects them in their prayer?
why is a man's problem a woman's responsibility? maybe men should check their iman if they're thinking of immoral things in a place of worship praying to their creator? lol ridiculous
Are men prayer more important than women’s?
@@arcane1282 no one said she will not pray the prophet said her to pray behind why are uh so pressed
This one understand this one how much in korupsi animal reboot haram no jackie destiny my zakat iswan halal
Why do people pray at all? Does god listen to prayers or is he too busy? Does god answer prayers?
Yes He does
Support and watch on Netflix or CZcams
The Turkish TV series about "Diriliş: Ertuğrul: (Resurrection: Ertugrul)
The series is based on the life and times of a 13th-century Muslim Turk Leader & Hero from the Kayi Tribe. Ertugrul was the father of Osman, the founder of the Ottoman dynasty, which ruled a large part of the world for 600 years.
The series is a must see. It is number 1 in the world and has attracted 500 million viewers from 70 different countries. Al-hamdu lillah
What’s this got to do with anything?
How much in hadas how much temple ke simbol di finish dunia okey how much finish in body in dunia this one and the stand de answ dishwani body understand story bangun allah subhanahuwataala
☝️🤲🏿🤲🏿🤲🏿
This is why I’m thinking about leaving Islam, it seems like everything has to be sacrificed for a mans comfort as if he has some type of power over a woman. I don’t like this
Don't leave sister..the only power is ALLAH. Yet, Quran tells us most people don't believe, hate the truth and are not thankful.
Study Quran more and ask Allah to show you the way..shaytan wants to trick you.
Respecting human nature isn't about a man's comfort. It is about protecting everyone from situations that lead to temptation and potentionally disasterous consequences. Any traditional religion will have some practices in place that do this. This is also practiced in the business world for example having two people sign checks.
This one understand this one hold this one of them makro islam you understand this one you understand quran this one understand hard diskunanda fokus in hd sin dunya rizwan makro haram rizwan body no everything
The Sunnah is also binding upon all muslims men and women. Beware of the people who open the doors of innovation.
What doesn't bend shall break.
I make my dog walk behind me and be obedient or else
Understand low dunia okey hadis dunia quran imam umat indonesia how many connecting quran di sungai connecting quran connecting kromoszilharam di suami waktu ever this one you focus for anucariz on hadis siswan understanding haram understanding halisi volkswagen industry in body everything this one quran
Excuse me, why are we trying to reinvent the wheel
Rather than making this an issue, make arrangements for women separately like in few Muslim countries.
Build a separate small hall for women to pray in the same masjid
How come you never Talk about Quran? You answer questions which only Allah knows best.
You can visit our website quranspeaks.com to learn about our mission.
5:30
This one mgina beautiful di sunny beautiful my husband rosa indonesia how much do shahriz 19 dosa because something this one to say in something okey something this one beautiful my husband this one dosa how much syndrome dunia di suunda yang ke 4 air putin dosa dunia dianggo itu kak batu
Disappointing answer really, the fact that it was an established practice is the Prophet peace be upon him and his companions should have sufficed. He's left the door open for the practice of women praying at the front
Unfortunately i have heard that this is indeed practiced in one society (where women lead the prayer for men)
May God guid us and keep us on the right path
It was a change instituted by Muhammad because some of his pervert companions kept staring in lust at a beautiful woman. Perverted companions for a perverted prophet.
@@toomanymarys7355 hello why call the prophet perverted? May your needs be met inshallah
this is what happens when you dont learn islam through sanad
This guy talks so much
The ads are poison Like oppinions
Try knowing how to spell before forming an opinion
I usually get Islamic adds that ask for donations and it breaks my heart knowing that I dont have money to give
@@isxaaqibnabdulaziiz4219 the Prophet SAAWS was No beggar
@@isxaaqibnabdulaziiz4219 Same. Especially adds about Yemen. It breaks my heart
Religion of lust
Foolishness
Imagine writing hate comments, man get a life.
@@bngmln5326 I know what you really meant, I saw your other comments, dont muck arround dude.
They pray behind their men so that they can keep an eye on them!
If they prayed on front, the eyes of the men would not concentrate on their Creator!
Astaqfirrullah!
😂😂😂😂😂
Because the men go first in the wars
And how about when woman carries that particular man in her belly for 9 months. Ur argument is weak. Watch till end and then comment
@James C, sorry, but your argument makes no sense. Maybe watch the video before commenting?
@@QuranSpeaks are you saying it is by accident? Are you ashamed of such a practice?
@@jamesc9853 ashamed of what? That prayer is related to war, which seems to be the ridiculous argument you are making?
@@khaledhd2055 so you would be fine with the men watching over children and the women being scholars?
This one mgina beautiful di sunny beautiful my husband rosa indonesia how much do shahriz 19 dosa because something this one to say in something okey something this one beautiful my husband this one dosa how much syndrome dunia di suunda yang ke 4 air putin dosa dunia dianggo itu kak batu