Winston Peters DESTROYS Labour Party Wasteful Spending
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 12. 2023
- #shorts #newzealand #jacindaardern
#nzpol #newzealandparliament #primeminister
Jacinda Ardern, New Zealand, NZ, Ardern, NZ Convoy 2022, Ardern New Zealand News, prime minister Jacinda Ardern, Jacinda Ardern protest, NZ news, New Zealand News, Jacinda Ardern live, government protest New Zealand, New Zealand mandate protest, Jacinda Ardern New Zealand pm, pm Jacinda Ardern, New Zealand law, New Zealand protest, freedom, nzpoli, NZ Elections, New Zealand elections, Free Speech, Three Waters, Entrenchment, Nanaia Mahuta, Christopher Luxon, Chris Hipkins, David Seymour, Winston Peters, Grant Robertson, seanhernandez22, jacinda ardern debate, jacinda ardern youtube, christopher luxon elected, christopher luxon leadership, jacinda ardern vs christopher luxon, jacinda ardern vs david seymour, national party, labour party, shorts, youtube shorts
Labour have been a financial disaster for NZ!
Totally agree!
And Robertson tries to give advice to Willis...what a laugh... if it wasn't so dangerous it would be a joke!
Rubbish👎
Just take a look at the unruley rabble that walk the corridors now ,a disgrace to our forfathers that set the previous high standards that were once enforced by Lockwood Smith to name one of the last that enforced any order in that place .
@@trevorgarner5803 Bad choice of Speaker. He was a Labour Party stooge with no equality for his opposing party.
The government bureaucrats behind their massive losses are never named, never held to account
That could change. If it's in the public interest. Which it is.
That's what elections are.
Bravo this finance minister for having the guts to cut losses. Labour was so wasteful and were not watchful over the project.
Wow. 3bn. We could have been crossing the cook st on 3 Nimitz class carriers.
You'd first need a time machine to travel back to the 1970s to procure one at the price.
Grant Robertson has absolutely no self awareness as he has the audacity to still be sitting in Parliament after the last disastrous and unapologetic government. I hope the Labour party disappears completely from NZ.
They are heading that way, the halfwits
w dumb cluxon has already lost $300,000,000in the virgin airlne deal and now he gave himself huge tax cuts what a crook
No self awareness because he and the other Labour members who managed to get in to parliament still think they are the voice for the majority and they alone know how to run the world and lowly plebs are lucky to have them.
He literally defended a sunk cost fallacy.
Kiwi off the rails like everyone else were use to the Cindy gravy Train.
Labor is a financial disaster for Australia too 😂
There is always a sustainable cook st ferry. Its called Bluebridge. That labour guy is full of bs. I totally believe he wasted money.
Why is Cindy no where to be seen to take some accountability for this unbelievable mess that this new government has been left with? Did the rat jump off the sinking ship early?
She was the biggest fraud New Zealand politics has ever seen
Yep…..
She's still counting her 25 million!
Very good question, the rat was in Canada last I knew, and not sure where it is now. Just saying, did the rat buy any properties overseas to settle down or has any intention to return and face the questioning.😂Investigate the little chipee and he might spill the beans. I am on the brink of closing my small business.
John key lead by example 😂😂😂
Good job. Finally a responsible government.
New government actually talks like adults
Jacinda Ardern used to sound like a teenage at a high school debate
Such a big blowout😮. Good on the current government for exposing the woke labour party😂
WHERE did all the money GO? I Think we need to know that we have not been SWINDLED! A FULL INVESTIGATION IS NEEDED!
On design of the harbour works and construction of the ferries. There's no particular mystery here.
Leave it to the next Gov, costs blows out $5m+
Just seems like a lot of money and not much to show for it ?
@@theimaginationstation1899where are the ferries then
@@markmorrell7211They're not anywhere.
Grant is full of it. Said we need certainty, while not providing it himself. He literally admitted he left the decision until the government switched.
'Full of it' so true. He should remove his butt bung and let some of that hot air out.
Well done Nicola
If people really wanted to cross the cook strait, they should learn to swim. I as a tax payer I refuse to subsidise them. Time for the private sector to take over.
Would be interesting to see who has interests in the companies and consultants involved in building the new ferrys
It'd be more interesting to see who benefits by the refusal to buy rail capable ferries.
@@theimaginationstation1899 maybe a reasonable person would think that both are equally value?
@@nowhereman6540 Not really. New Zealand politics has never been impacted upon by the ship and harbour design lobby - seeing as neither has a particular presence in New Zealand. NZ road transport however has invested significantly into NZ politics. So a reasonable person would probably regard it as a false equivalence for the purposes of obfuscation to class the two as being of equal import.
@@theimaginationstation1899 Keep doubling down. Labour type stalwarts like you have no shame. Such ignorant delusion without bounds. You people have destroyed NZ.
Finally the adults are in the room again
The kids have had a slap and they’re NOT happy.
Let's see what this new lot can do.
Only been in office 5mins. Talk big, already ppl marching in protest.
@@myrabateman1790Only the straggling few who don't do democracy. The majority voted for much needed change.
What about the 129k migrants granted by labour mostly unskilled ....... where are the houses ???
A very good and important question. I looked up NZ Stats on immigration 2023. No mention of ANY Middle Eastern (Muslim) people's coming here and yet here in Dunedin there seems to be quite a few more around. NIWA is the same. Tell us Cyclone Gabrielle was the worst yet history shows we've had several worse before. Both worth looking at for political bullsh*t.
My way of looking at it is, they were granted to only boost up the votes for lefty, liberal, labour a****les.
@@GaryPeters-nv8pjAnd looking at Europe and the UK experience with large numbers of that type of people it's not good. Trucks of peace and all that.
its funny Labour is talking about finding certainty for New Zealander's. Labour is a joke
They are worse than a joke. They are communists.
Why were we also not told about the country wide Marae upgrade that cost the taxpayer billions, of course the media kept quite about it as well, as per bribed by the government.
It's a pity the current government wasn't in power when the Auckland CRl was approved, the cost blow outs are eye watering.
Take any infrastructure project budget estimate then double it, then times it by 2 and add half again. That will be closer to the true final cost. Lots of creative accounting is used when trying to get a project over the line. This is particularly true of infrastructure projects of national significance.
It was a project of the National Government of John Key.
Labour was a wasteful govt, we need to puts taxpayer's money into more practical sense.
Like a reliable, efficient, enduring, safe link between the North and South Island?
@@theimaginationstation1899that can happen if you take the blue bridge ferry, a non govt funded ferry that is a lot more reliable 🤷🏻♂️
Public transparency, who’s Auditing the auditor s
@@deanostevenson9238 The Auditor General.
@@PeacefulMeteorShower-th8fk Not at all.
The Finance Minister has not refered to the board of governace of Kiwirail who have more direct role in decisions.
I hope head's are going to roll for this incompetence. Shouldn't need to hear from any of the previous government they are clearly all hui no doey.
"when the handbag left the room" Priceless.
At last NZ'ers have seen sense and have elected a proper government, good riddance Labour and Adhern
Try telling that to diminish labour caucus they still believe they won and want to run the country.
Great job! It is wonderful to have adults in charge again. The wokesters need to get back in their boxes.
Totally, every dollar spent on infrastructure is a wasted dollar.
There's nothing more woke than shipping. Except possibly harbour works.
wow, a responsible government
Thank goodness the grown ups are now in charge.
No more irresponsible, short term cuts like Bill English slashing rail and road maintenance expenditure in 2014:to finance Tax cuts. Maybe these large rail passenger ferries should have been transferred to a restored Lyttelton Wellington overnight ferry service or even the RNZN as a transport to replace HMNZS. I am just suggesting the possibility of the longer coastal or naval use should have been examined as these large new ships had been fully designed for rough cold water conditions around NZ and were probably capable of global operation. Hyundai was about to start cutting steel and these civilian ships would not have been difficult to build . They would have been delivered for some sort of inter island service in 2016 and it remains to be seen if a better or safer alternative will be found this decade. I doubt if the Topp twins Wills and Bish could run a branch of Farmers or Hallensteins.
@@frederickmiles327Not.
We need to get inter island rail
Thank god NZ Labour is out of power and hopefully will NEVER return to power in my lifetime!
Oh well, you've had a good run I suppose.
Grant Robertson nd Jacinda Ardern need to be investigated by the SFO and Auditor General and tried by the SFO and sent to Jail
SFO doesn't do trials or sentencing.
At last! A responsible government. I'm impressed.
The Spirit of Tasmania vessels are being replaced next year. 2 good ferries there.
Put a tie on Robertson, you're in the House
The govt dropped the ball on this issue, they’ve just dropped it and that’s their signature move but they don’t consider the outfall, or the loss, or the actual cost in the long term will cost nz more in the long run, and their doing it across policies
Not so sure you're right here. Nobody else in the world is using the solution that was going to be put in place. Need to see what is done, but I suspect cost savings.
I thought ship building was a competitive globalised industry, why are the ferries so expensive?
I remember seeing a statistic that NZ has the worst percentage of public infrastructure funding actually going to on the ground (or sea in this case) work within OECD countries. No doubt Iwi came in demanding a few handouts, knowing the way the last Labour government worked.
They did exactly the same in connection with Auckland Light Rail and Let’s Get Wellington Moving
Speaker.,tell the wannabe cowboy to remove his hat in parliament.
Well said. Totally reckless. At least Bluebridge is still running. Grant Robertson is all talk not good enough.
Why? Because theres no room its full of crims already
Grant R allowed KiwiRail to waste 45 mil in the last year following me uncovering this disaster. The 45 mil was wasted on a JV Contractor who achieved absolutely nothing
Labour wasted 400 mil on this Project and have achieved nothing!
No they didn’t ? You’re not listening to the debate.
They did achieve something, votes of many idiots to still sit in the opposition and show their faces.
Look at the body language. The govt body language is divided. Then contrast that with the opposition.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 dream on
@@paton57 is reality getting to you?
Yeah. The new government looks fit and healthy. The other side look like a bunch of overweight fried animals.
How about axing tax cuts for landlords
The evidence speaks for itself
show us
KiwiRail knew well before Feb. I told them a year before that but was ignored. I have all of the evidence
I THINK THE LABOUR GOV HAS EATEN ALL THE MONEY LOOK AT THE SIZE OF THE LONG STANDING IT SHOWS THAT NOT ALL KIWIS ARE EATING THAT GOOD
Why is the te pati Maori fella still wearing his hat bloody disrespectful to the house and the nz public,he’s like the annoying kid in school always trying to do something different to impress 5he other kids
The problem with the quadtrippled 3bn funding is that there is still no guarantee from Kiwirail that it would be the end of the funding requests. What if it balloons again to 6bn? To 12bn? where is the 2bn light rail to airport promised by Jacinda?
The bottom line is that this is a major stuff up and someone if not multiple people need to be held accountable, Grant Robinson being one of them.
Typical Robertson, spend spend spend tax payers money with little to show for it.
The. Houses. Still. Fixing. The. Earth. Moving around. By. Heavy. Rain. And. Earthquake . Around. The. Country. And. Road. Damage. We. Cant. Hold. It
Feel ya. Why dont they at least put a hold on any monies t other countries till our own infrastructure is on a level deserved by its tax paying citizens.
They cannot even maintain their own assets - read the reports. Let alone build capital works programmes
LabourGovt - Finance Minister Grant Robertson for 6years spent $120BILLION how the fart the nxt Govt gonna pay that debt (New Zealand Citizens 2123)
It's simple, by increasing taxes to a whole lot of sh** to repair the punctures that the hopeless previous government has left us with. In fact I was worried about my own kid, explaining what kind of a mess they are going to be in soon. The voters are the idiots who chose such parties as labour, specially the tax paying ones.
Was that te pati Maori coming in late and with no cultural fanfare and theatrics? Is this the actual chamber or an alternate reality?
Anyone notice the change of hat for Rawiri after Winston called him out on it? Maybe Rawiri finally decided to do some research on where the cowboy hat design came from and what those who wore them - colonials - did to native Americans.. What a hua.
Thank goodness for the adults who have returned to our parliament
Show me a huge civil infrastructure project that hasn’t blown out .
Contractors price gouging and inflating prices got a lot to do with it.
Paul Goldsmith can’t count without taking off his socks can he .
Winston has to remember he was there with labour 2017
Bring back the Lyttleton ferry and move the port to Grassmere and make Picton a destinston not a coffee syop
Kiwirail is and SOE. If read more than what they refering to CentePort Wellington is involved in project. So the detailed activity is happen at lower level. The government of day is the shareholder. The port company is owned by the local authority.
Grant Robinson should be in jail
We to Rebuild a proper infrastructure both Rail.& Sea
Open up more of New Zealand and increase tourism opportunities
Man this is just ministerial corruption = Follow the money , Waste in the Picton side is eyewatering , 100+ million loaned from the caunsall AT what cost to the rate payers ??
Politicians are pathetic. Wasting tax payers money whinging about points of order and comments made. No one taking blame for the Mammoth in the room.
Lol someone else's getting ripped a new one an they aint liking it one bit 😅
Free markets = freedom... God Bless NZ
Winston is losing it lol!
Safeguard the sunk costs? So in poker terms, Labour decided to go full tilt. Nice one, Grant.
So pleased we have got rid of the woke Labour/Green government. The Maori party don’t speak for all Maori either but are a joke
Never seen it before now...... Megan woods, looks like chukys wife lol😂
Thank you Nicola and thank you National for doing this, one of your decisions that made me not leave the country. The previous jokers had no clue about spending money, since it was not theirs😂😂 In fact I would request you to start an investigation into the assets of Jacinda, Grant, Hipkins, Ayesha, and that bubble gum next to grant to check where such spending has gone.
I have always been interested what makes a right wing person, go right. As someone with left-wing views, I appreciate the focus on social justice, equality, and environmental sustainability. I believe in creating a fair and inclusive society, supporting workers' rights, and advocating for universal access to healthcare and education. Embracing progressive social policies and wealth redistribution aligns with my values, contributing to a more compassionate and equitable world. I feel that my left-wing ideologies offer a holistic approach to societal progress, fostering innovation and promoting diplomacy for a harmonious international community.
Nicola talking she-art.
The development of NZ Railways was always delayed, stop start affair. Vogel decided to build fast, light and cheap and the core of the South Island system was built in the 1870s and 1880s as was Palmerston North- New Plymouth. After several cost blowouts the NIMT was finally completed in 1909, 20 years late and on the wrong route. The first thru trains on the NIMT arrived in Auckland just a week before Theodore Roosevelt fleet arrived in NZ . The Great White Fleet was cover for the prospective and planned incorporation of a dangerously misguided socialist NZ into the United States. So in a sense in 1909 the planned US invasion of Auckland occurred, but after a week the USN decided NZ socialism was largely talk and the country was okay and the fleet sailed on. The NIMT however was steep,slow and difficult to maintain, NZ Railways construction allowing 1/35 grades which still stop efficient operation of the Taranaki and Picton lines. The Union Steam ship an alternative Onehunga to New Plymouth overnight passenger ferry continued to run till 1930 linking with the New Plymouth - Wellington express.
Do you have sources for this?...
I've watched Drachinifel's video on the great white fleet and have considerable interest in history.
An Australian naval History
Southern Trident and secondly an University of Auckland PhD thesis in politics see
In Political Science by a USN rating later commissioned as a USN officer who later taught at a minor Texas Uni, at Lubock ( about 200 miles south of Armarillo)Thomas Reinker would approximate his name and the thesis was published
@@kieranh2005It's largely made up re the great white fleet.
The Americans were not interested in taking on the British Empire in the Pacific in 1908.
It was more an announcement of the end of US isolationism.
His history of railway construction is o.k.
But the NIMT route was the most practical route in terms of what the line was intended to achieve.
Time to replace the ferries with galleys, rowed by the unemployed. And we can spend the $3 billion dollars saved on tax cuts for the wealthy/property speculators. This is the official advice of the reserve bank, the cook strait is a dead duck, and have advised to sell the south island. It's just dead weight.
🤣
Peters knew exactly what the KiwiRail ferry project was and it's scope. Robertson read out in the House Winston's press release of 22 May 2020 to Willis, which stated the scope of the project included significant wharf and shore infrastructure for rail and vehicles. So Willis is either lying or just incompetent in not knowing scope of works. Robertson also asked Willis to table her press release of the previous day that noted that Kiwi Rail had in October 2022 written to the Minister that a tagged cost contingency needed to be increases by 280 million for the ferry project. So Willis is lying again or just incompetent about not knowing of cost over runs? Also KiwiRail fronted Robertson for funding of 2.6 billion which was rejected. So much for Willis's claim the the Labour government throwing good money after bad or was this just another convenient lie on her part?.
I developed multiple options which were far more conducive to value for money
i think the truth should be if labour wanted everyone to see "how hard they worked" they would have put that shit in the media. what he is really meaning is he wants to try prove to everyone they did better then the new government. Now all they want to do is is throw it out in the media and just prove they are better by the stance each side has.
If you need all of the details, I can provide them to you
Ask Elon to dig us a tunnel.
Sean can’t be that serious. He needs to get honest and understanding in his comments.I wonder if he finds it hard to live with himself.The thing is educate yourself more and don’t dig a hole for yourself otherwise you may get buried
So Grant can say whatever he likes now because he has been kicked out of office. Meanwhile, Labour continued to throw money at the project. One of many cancelled projects, where experts were paid, even while still in office.
Who is Tex in the front row?
Yawn 🥱
Down. I. Means
National added 6 more cabinet ministers
5+ million more tax payer dollars. Each salary is $296,007. Luxon preaching about wasteful spending 🧐
😅
How the hell do these videos keep coming to me, I dont give two hoots what all the clowns in this comment thread are saying - right, left are both as bad as each other. I just dont want to see these comments that are full of separatist ideals ... have a good time watching our country disintergrate into separation as we fall divided more and more - and I speak to both sides of this argument
Robo😂
Coalition talks held in Auckland hotel meeting room costing $1000 per day while govt rooms were available. Luxon preaching about wasteful spending 🧐
For your kind info' coalition talks cannot be held in govt rooms since they haven't formed a govt yet. Labour was still the caretaker govt till the announcement was made. And I am sure it was not the tax payers money. Thanks 😂
@@speaksense4605 🙄for your information your statement is a bull$hit. The gaslighting is strong in this one 🥱.
Really? You compare a few thousand dollars to hire rooms to form a government to Labours wasting of billions.
Labour giving NZs most well known violent, meth dealing gang 2.75 million to treat crackheads the mob created, let's talk about more wastefull spending like also paying the mob $9000 to fill in their census forms & here I was thinking if you don't fill it out you get fined $2500 🤔 I put money on it the mob were also paid for labour votes,.. want to talk some more about Labours wastefull spending?
@@Mark-ou6fv it’s the hypocrisy 😳, hypocrisy, hypocrisy!
In 2020 were you one of the 69% of employed men or 1 of the 54% women who received a wage subsidy durin Covid pandemic? Did the govt help you and your family? Labour bashes conveniently forget the world went through a pandemic 🧐😳
23 billion in wage subsidies which helped keep the economy afloat during covid. Overall 47% of nz jobs received @ least 1 the 2021 wage subsidies
But your kiwisaver got nailed for it.
Putting aside who's wrong or who's right, the money saved by not spending, cutting costs etc: where does the govt intend to use it? It's not like we can bank it and leave it to dissappear via inflation. Our credit rating is still in the top 3 worldwide so there's no panic about overseas debt. So where's it going to go?
Tax payer handouts for people with seven houses
New Zealand is in debt. There is no spare money. All they are trying to do is keep spending down.
The ignorance of your question begs belief.
Clearly a question only labour voter could ask.
@@GerryAustin1978 it appears that faux virtue and economic ignorance go trotter in trotter.
I would prefer not to have Winston Peters remark on any wasteful costs within this country due to the staggering costs to date of various failed Court cases that cost the tax payers millions.
Flooding. I. Means
Let me guess which side of politics you're on. Try a bit less bias.
What aload of rubbish iF IT WASN'T FOR THE FORMER LABOUR GOVERNMENT AND THE ACTION THAT WAS TAKEN DURING THE COVID PANDEMIC WE WOULD OF HAD MORE DEATHS FROM COVID
Bollocks, anyone can close an island down in the middle of nowhere. Many thousands died due to not getting healthvtreatments during covid. Keep drinking the kool aid
🤣🤣 someone has been brainwashed by Labour
Nicola (what is one and one) Willis, the most incompetent finance minister ever!
No, that's Grant Robertson