Correction eNCA, there is no "Mixed reactions". We are all behind what she said fully. She is right. And no she's not xenophobic. All countries have laws and enforcing laws can't be xenophobic only in SA.
We are 100% behind you honourable MEC. Us the poor citizens know how it feels to get to hospital and you can't be admitted because there are no beds...all occupied by illegal immigrants who found creative ways of jumping the border thanks to leaders who have access to private health care.
The constitution of South Africa should be adjusted to allow only legally documented foreigners access to its health system. I agree with the remarks of the MEC she is being honest.
The journalist is even blocking her when she starts speaking about the illegal collection of medication from hospitals and clinics to sell in their country.
Please make this lady the deputy president of South Africa with Aaron Motsoaledi as the presidents. The media will always try to twist the narrative to make good leaders look like xenophobic maniacs.
Why is it here in South Africa when you stand your ground and tell it as it is you being Xenophobic? The word Xenophobic is always on the tip of the tongue when the truth is being told.
Zimbabwe: They are failing us , no documentation, our system you must have passport, expired passport : not allowed in the system. You must have id, passport, etc.
@@davidmurutubarwe1432 these people they know what they are doing is very wrong but still they do it,professionals are now loosing their ethical codes just like your leaders not leading with their constitutional codes ,Hopewell Chino'no is protecting the constitution of Zim alone and he won't win alone when people like wants our ministers to keep a blind eye,hehe bathong No
When are we going to tiptoe around the issues of illegal foreigners in this country? I’m glad she said it. She frustrated about the little budget she has, that is meant for residents of Limpopo but not reaching them. Professionalism go out of the window when an employee doesn’t have resources.
Yes she was correct and it is good that she was said in full view and recorded, free education to Zimbos and all the illegal immigrant because no one wants to educate them. Very GOOD MEC, lesson learnt and the message has been sent through
Funny thing is that no one sees that and thinks to go back to Zimbabwe. ANC will do anything to look like they are against foreigners, if you are smart enough you can tell that all they do is ride the most trending wave. Cape Flats sent army Border employed guards Corruption, Commission cost 100s of millions. Step aside rule Pastors and Prophets chapter 9 institution. Marikana, fired Phiyega Unemployment, implementation of bbb-eee nonsense Nothing ever happens after people get bored with it.
Hands off our MEC, we need this kind of leadership, we need to also confront Department of Education, our schools are overflowing with illegal immigrants kids, those kids dont have documents and it becomes a problem after they completed Grd12. And some of them prefer good schools which makes our kids to not be accepted at those schools. Our country is in serious trouble.
Don't trust any member of ANC they have been quite all along. If they were doing their job correctly we could'nt be where we are today. Operation Dudula and other organizations who have been against illegal foreigners gave them a wake up call. I think it is too late they are now thinking of 2024 elections.
I love the Minister... Say it like it is. And by the way, we ae so sick and tired of news anchors using the same pickup line trying to always GUILT TRIP the truth told. "Are U xenophobic"... Do u feel smart after saying this ?, or it makes u feel great ?
Sunny Chizuva yes i understand you hence i disagree with the way mec handled it it was not done professional she need to just charge the patient in private according to human rights law she violated!!! violated a human beings she was wrong.in first world she wouldn't do that she would has to follow a right way to put things in place not this abusive way its wrong she is very luck its africa.
I'm happy that in a very long time, you were brave enough to tell the truth, health care workers are frustrated and overworked not to mention shortage of both material and human resources. We hope that our government will try and cotroll borders so that services can be rendered to relevant people. Thank you MEC. May you Continue to serve.
The media must stop to to ask nonsensical questions this doctor is not xenophobic at all she was just explaining the situation good for your doctor the real South Africans were supposed to get help they don’t because all this foreign people filled up the space
The good things is that she came with examples and reasons for her statement. This people running the media are useless. They are the once promoting this xenophobic sentiment.... The first thing the lady she be arrested for breaking the law for being in the country without being documented.
There is nothing wrong with what she said, she was just being vocal and honest. A problem is a problem and we cannot romanticise it. Big up my EMC. #handsofframathuba.
Well done MEC, I wish all the leaders call out bad leadership in Zimbabwe. When Zimbabweans call them out they are called being unpatriotic. ED & ZANU LEADERSHIP THERE IS YOUR MESSAGE , LOUD AND CLEAR!!! HEAR IT!!!!! You have reduced your people to be laughing stock. Well done ED😇
Thank you. You are one intelligent guy who realises that the problem is not on civilians but the chief political groups that are after enriching themselves in the expenses of the citizens. Thank you once more. The other South Citizens only see the people on the flow as a problem. But they are missing the point. The real problem lies with the leadership of the ruling party. It doesn't matter whether there were correctly or incorrectly elected. They are a problem that has brought the nation of Zimbabwe into chaos and confusion as well as dead economically.
@@brnstubby6359 the people must vote them leaders out. We are not fighting our Zims brothers & sisters we just see lack of will power to fight for their country. SAns are going to vote 2024 watch & learn
@@mamokete2671 the zanu pf will not stop rigging the votes.we wish sadc cld do something regarding the votes in zim.coz people have voted these guys out many times but mmmm its just not working for us
Minister is right just leave her alone to carry out her job, she's doing her very best i applaud this brave women, minister u go ahead and do what you suppose to do thank u
Thats her Job, being controversial is actually very lucrative for media, but i still stand by the truth that Ramathuba said, these criminals must be stopped, we are done nursing their mighty feelings while they abuse our system.
Enca should get their facts straight and stop coughing xenophobic speech on the MEC ... We are way behind with quality health in South Africa because of the corrupt system
It doesn't make sense for the MEC to suddenly need to defend her stand on the matter and whether she's xenophobic which she's obviously NOT. Biased journalism crucifying an official for doing her job and wanting to ensure the wellbeing of the local citizens...I strongly doubt any well minded South African is against what the MEC did or her way of going about It, she was not rude, did not incite any violence at all. Personally I'd have been fuming to find individuals taking advantage of the constitution while backtracking my work
Like Motswaledi they are real patriots and sees how south Africans who are voters and citizens are sidelined in all departments with jobs and in hospitals!The only thing that can bring change is to vote ANC out in 2024!As for the EFF and DA they are beneficiaries of illegal foreigners together with ANC!How many times have the government bailed out Zimbabwe government since Mugabe days?
@@Vimbaiwacho she is telling g the right person. It's your job Zimbabweans to tell the right people your government ZanuPF. SAns can't do your job you are all supposedly smart and hardworking. When are you going to stop being lazy and face ZanuPF? Learn from Dudula and Soweto Parliament.
We have your back MEC. You are the man! More guts and bigger #*!@@ than these sissie male politicians. I call it taking the bull by its horns. You and minister Motsoaledi are true and straight forward facing hereos. You should lead this country. President and Deputy. IGAMA LA MAKOSIKAZI!!!!
Someone has to say it, your president is silent let them do the right thing, working citizens in SA are suffering huge tax sponsoring people who do not even contribute to the economy, power to MEC
It is only here in South Africa where if u talk about foreigners u are emmediately labelled as "Zenophobic" my god i hate this word so much. Well done MEC i support you 100% 😭😭😭
Dats true brother n it's very wrong,look at Dubai now,they have deported Nigerians but it's not called xenophobia,when we do that in south Africa it's xenophobia,I don't know what's wrong with this fu*n journalist who are always saying everything is xenophobia
@@emmanuelernest1187 South African media and some gvmt offials hate the truth, they prefer to be comforted by lies and bias news reporting while illigal immigration is killing this country in more ways than 1 its very sad.
Journalists start reporting on facts and stop sensationalising illegal behaviour by undocumented persons. MEC is correct. Countries must self correct Zimbabwe can refer their patients formally so that SA can recoup its costs. Simple. Zimbabwe must pay for its citizens loke all countries
You know am so disappointed about south Africans,when someone is standing up for their rights it's called xenophobia,when someone is confronting foreigners is xenophobic,we in south Africa have no leadership,for example, people get killed by foreigners it's ok but when south Africans react on that matter is xenophobic,the system in south Africa looks like it is built to serve foreign nationals
MEC she was right technically coz the foreigners should pay for their medical services they are not entitled for free medical or education neither social grants for that matter
In 1999 I went to the DRC Congo. I contracted malaria and was taken to a very dirty hospital next to a market. Before they could treat me the hospital demanded $350 because I was a foreigner. Was the clerk xenophobic no he was just following hospital policy to protect the Congolese. Stop calling everything xenophobic. The MEC was just frustrated because she has no budget to treat illegal immigrants. Xenophobic she isn't.
I support you Minister, media don't like to hear the truth. Influx control must come back. When America chase away illegal immigrants it's it's okay BUT when S.A. does the same it's wrong!!! I like the Minister you say it like it is!!!! We need more Minister's like you brave and bold.
The reporter is not seasoned. Probably she has a medical aid and does not appreciate what sa are going through. Middle class is becoming a problem and they do not realise that in no time, if things are left as they are- they will join everyone in government hospital. People must be patriotic and protect their infrastructure against abuse.
minister you were wrong just apologise , so what do you expect that vulnerable patient to do, is she to blame for Mnangagwa and Zanu pf 's failures , that was wrong timing to express your frustrations .
A medical doctor swear with the hyppocrate oath not to discriminate patients. It should not be the duty of a doctor to know where the patient comes from. The admin, home affairs, politicians should do their jobs. Where are the humanitarian NGOs so that they pay for the costs of treating foreigners who need care since their governments are ignoring their citizens?! If someone is paying for them, they will be no complaints.
When taking an Oath it means speaking the truth!We support Dr Ramothuba for speaking the truth like Dr Motswaledi!They are the only real patriots in the ANC!Others are hypocrites like the leader of the EFF!I'm sure voters are watching them for 2024!Their real concern are foreigners!
That patient was treated. Zimbabweans can't hold SA at ransom forever with emotional blackmail of; Thabo Mbeki,,, the oath of dealing with patients,,, SAns are xenophobic,,, inhuman treatment of ZEP holders if they are discontinued etc.. We are tired of all illegal immigrants, our government & some politicsl parties gets this except EFF which will be punished in 2024. It must end and it will end.
Then its simple, South Africans must recieve preferential treatment when it comes to our public Healthcare system that we citizens pay for with our taxes. It is unfortunate that we are being forced to care of citizens of another country who break our laws and take advantage of our good will
This lady she has what the most South Africans leaders do not have . If the sitting President was like her South Africa will be a better country. She is not intimidated, she stand by her words. Wow few of leaders like her within ANC ranks can pursue the voter's to vote ANC again.
MEC is not Xenophobic at all, I support her and do not see anything wrong with the statements she said on the viral video. Most of the foreign people are sick yooh. I took my son to Red Cross kids Hosp. And the most people who were there were foreign nationals, mostly Zimbabweans, Somalians and Nigerians. As I speak they couldn't operate my son, My first visit was on the 14 Dec, after that I had numerous appointments twice a month, after the diagnosis was complete in May I was given a 5th Jan 2023 appointment and I was told me and my son should patiently wait. They are killing the system really. When I complained the doctor also told be about the backlog of other ppl with serious issues who are also awaiting to be operated. There really should be tight rules when it comes to foreigners, all foreigners.
This is amateur journalism ... made the whole thing about xenophobia , meanwhile Public hospitals are overcrowded with illegals at our cost , We STAND BEHIND YOU MME RAMATHUBA
MEC is not Xenophobic... she is telling the truth... Who must take care of these foreigners... when there is a shortage of medication, staff, etc you blame department and nurses, Noooo call it whatever SA must come first.Munangwagwa must take his people
Yeah u support these crimimals going around stealling medications from our clinics and selling in Zimbabwe. Then u go to the clinic only to find out that the clinics do not have medications. Sometimes we need to just say the truth as it is and stop nursing the mighty feelings of these criminals.
Correction eNCA, there is no "Mixed reactions". We are all behind what she said fully. She is right. And no she's not xenophobic. All countries have laws and enforcing laws can't be xenophobic only in SA.
This eNCA women she must be from Zimbabwe too
Spot on. The MEC is spot on and we stand by her. eNCA has never been pro Soth Africa.
@@giventhatomahlangu9423 No she is asking such questions because this is wat is in the mind of many people
you can ask that again, what mixed reactions?
👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
We are 100% behind you honourable MEC. Us the poor citizens know how it feels to get to hospital and you can't be admitted because there are no beds...all occupied by illegal immigrants who found creative ways of jumping the border thanks to leaders who have access to private health care.
Mec Poppy is one of the best,if she can contest to be a President we will vote for her.She's fighting gor us and she's not xenophobic
MEC is right, shes not xenophobic.
She is definitely right
Amen mama we love you for advocating the truth...it's about time we get real leaders viva SA viva
The constitution of South Africa should be adjusted to allow only legally documented foreigners access to its health system. I agree with the remarks of the MEC she is being honest.
It's not just the health system. The education sector, the job market, housing sector... It's all flooded. We need change in all areas.
@@forevertheaii valid point
healrh care apartheid
The journalist is even blocking her when she starts speaking about the illegal collection of medication from hospitals and clinics to sell in their country.
Hypocrites labo
Always ENCA protects illegal foreigners. They make sure, I suspects most of these ENCA news presenters are foreigners.
She (journalist) lost the battle that's why she stopped the interview
There is no mixed reaction here, our main problem is media and journalists. Minister was right and we support her 100%
The south africa doctors association does not support her
She is telling the truth well said👍👍
She is a disgrace. She can shift to vet medicine
Truth be told. One country cannot cater for two countries hence SA systems have collapsed
All provinces should do that, this illegal foreigners should pay for the services they get. 100% behind you MEC.
Good minister you have to set an example and lead by example .
Please make this lady the deputy president of South Africa with Aaron Motsoaledi as the presidents. The media will always try to twist the narrative to make good leaders look like xenophobic maniacs.
Yes
Very True
Yes but she must first learn a minimum of diplomacy! She cannot go in hospital and address her frustration to patients!
@@davidmurutubarwe1432 Hayi suka! South Africans who vote don't care about diplomacy. Save that for UN, not for the South Africans she is serving.
Dr Phophi is unwell. her action and talk are irrational
Minister we are behind you, Thank you for your service, Luckily captured on Camera.
Why is it here in South Africa when you stand your ground and tell it as it is you being Xenophobic? The word Xenophobic is always on the tip of the tongue when the truth is being told.
You shall know them by their fruits. Dr phophi fruits are toxic, hatred, division, poison, vitriol,
Zimbabwe: They are failing us , no documentation, our system you must have passport, expired passport : not allowed in the system. You must have id, passport, etc.
Go to zimbabwe: You must have id , car documentation, passport and as a South African you can not enter zimbabwe if you don't have documentation.
They collect HIV treatment , Tb treatment and they are selling it.
She is doing her job and telling the truth, I back her 100%.
She’s correct. There’s nothing xenophobic about what she said.
But it's not professional to go directly to patient and address issues concerning government.
@@davidmurutubarwe1432 these people they know what they are doing is very wrong but still they do it,professionals are now loosing their ethical codes just like your leaders not leading with their constitutional codes ,Hopewell Chino'no is protecting the constitution of Zim alone and he won't win alone when people like wants our ministers to keep a blind eye,hehe bathong No
When are we going to tiptoe around the issues of illegal foreigners in this country? I’m glad she said it. She frustrated about the little budget she has, that is meant for residents of Limpopo but not reaching them. Professionalism go out of the window when an employee doesn’t have resources.
@@tebogo7066 I can see you don't understand what's ethics in medical system. You will learn by asking or getting some more information.
@@davidmurutubarwe1432 only if you knew what I do for a living. Lol
Yes she was correct and it is good that she was said in full view and recorded, free education to Zimbos and all the illegal immigrant because no one wants to educate them. Very GOOD MEC, lesson learnt and the message has been sent through
Funny thing is that no one sees that and thinks to go back to Zimbabwe.
ANC will do anything to look like they are against foreigners, if you are smart enough you can tell that all they do is ride the most trending wave.
Cape Flats sent army
Border employed guards
Corruption, Commission cost 100s of millions.
Step aside rule
Pastors and Prophets chapter 9 institution.
Marikana, fired Phiyega
Unemployment, implementation of bbb-eee nonsense
Nothing ever happens after people get bored with it.
Hands off our MEC, we need this kind of leadership, we need to also confront Department of Education, our schools are overflowing with illegal immigrants kids, those kids dont have documents and it becomes a problem after they completed Grd12. And some of them prefer good schools which makes our kids to not be accepted at those schools. Our country is in serious trouble.
she is mentally unwell, any psychologist can tell, she needs help
For once we have someone who is speaking sense and who cares about South Africans. 100% Support, she should be the Minister of Health
Don't trust any member of ANC they have been quite all along. If they were doing their job correctly we could'nt be where we are today. Operation Dudula and other organizations who have been against illegal foreigners gave them a wake up call. I think it is too late they are now thinking of 2024 elections.
where are new hospitals built by ANC and you shall continue relying on those build by apartheid government for ever,
I fully support the MEC .
The most active MEC in Limpopo. Re ema le wena ✊
The MEC...she was telling the truth. Viva MEC Viva👌👌👌
10000000% behind u!
There has not been mixed reactions. The overwhelming majority of South Africans share the MEC sentiments, read the comments.
The sad part is that the Zim President saw this clip and he won't even respond because he simply doesn't care about his people.
The devil has a special room for him don't worry.
So true
Calling his people back to Zim should be his only response.
Saluut to this woman. She is 100% write. She works with budget and there is people illegal she is 100% write.
Truth to be told sometimes even though it hurts...
I love the Minister... Say it like it is. And by the way, we ae so sick and tired of news anchors using the same pickup line trying to always GUILT TRIP the truth told. "Are U xenophobic"... Do u feel smart after saying this ?, or it makes u feel great ?
Truth is the truth always you are complening if someone she tell the truth plz guys be on next
I’m a Zimbabwean and I support the mec and I’m so ashamed of this situation,our country has failed us
Sunny Chizuva yes i understand you hence i disagree with the way mec handled it it was not done professional she need to just charge the patient in private according to human rights law she violated!!! violated a human beings she was wrong.in first world she wouldn't do that she would has to follow a right way to put things in place not this abusive way its wrong she is very luck its africa.
Is time to vote for the right people in🇿🇼
She's not xenophobic
Every time when issues raised about illegal coacroches, you will be labeled xenophobic
I'm happy that in a very long time, you were brave enough to tell the truth, health care workers are frustrated and overworked not to mention shortage of both material and human resources. We hope that our government will try and cotroll borders so that services can be rendered to relevant people.
Thank you MEC. May you Continue to serve.
We support u 100% Doctor
The media must stop to to ask nonsensical questions this doctor is not xenophobic at all she was just explaining the situation good for your doctor the real South Africans were supposed to get help they don’t because all this foreign people filled up the space
The good things is that she came with examples and reasons for her statement. This people running the media are useless. They are the once promoting this xenophobic sentiment.... The first thing the lady she be arrested for breaking the law for being in the country without being documented.
Great work MEC.
This journalist is crazy.
MEC you are right.You dont have to explanin yourself.zimbabwe,Mozambique,Lesotho,Swaziland are taking advantage of SA.
Ernest tebogo mere ,well said bhuti 100%
Their government's must take charge and ownership & start paying SA for these services
There is nothing wrong with what she said, she was just being vocal and honest. A problem is a problem and we cannot romanticise it. Big up my EMC.
#handsofframathuba.
Venting at the wrong person
@@Tastylunchhanley the point is it is a bitter truth and this people are been told truth like this but not recorded for a long time
Mixed reaction my foot,, only from Zimbabwean journalists and their handlers. The MEC is 100% correct and she's going nowhere!! Hands off DR.PHOPHI.!!
Hounarable mec, you are not xenophobic but truthful. We are 100% behind you
Individual A NC leaders like this one may confuse me to vote them again.Good work M E C forget about this bias journalist
😄✊✊✊
Me too shlobo sam
I hear you, I think E*F must quickly go and adopt this one🤣, she is pushing for change❤
Well done MEC, I wish all the leaders call out bad leadership in Zimbabwe. When Zimbabweans call them out they are called being unpatriotic. ED & ZANU LEADERSHIP THERE IS YOUR MESSAGE , LOUD AND CLEAR!!! HEAR IT!!!!! You have reduced your people to be laughing stock. Well done ED😇
Thank you. You are one intelligent guy who realises that the problem is not on civilians but the chief political groups that are after enriching themselves in the expenses of the citizens.
Thank you once more. The other South Citizens only see the people on the flow as a problem. But they are missing the point. The real problem lies with the leadership of the ruling party. It doesn't matter whether there were correctly or incorrectly elected. They are a problem that has brought the nation of Zimbabwe into chaos and confusion as well as dead economically.
@@brnstubby6359 the people must vote them leaders out. We are not fighting our Zims brothers & sisters we just see lack of will power to fight for their country. SAns are going to vote 2024 watch & learn
@@mamokete2671 the zanu pf will not stop rigging the votes.we wish sadc cld do something regarding the votes in zim.coz people have voted these guys out many times but mmmm its just not working for us
Minister is right just leave her alone to carry out her job, she's doing her very best i applaud this brave women, minister u go ahead and do what you suppose to do thank u
The hell is the opening question from the anchor! I'm shocked
Propaganda of the media
I'm shocked too it's like this anchor has an agenda
Thats her Job, being controversial is actually very lucrative for media, but i still stand by the truth that Ramathuba said, these criminals must be stopped, we are done nursing their mighty feelings while they abuse our system.
Enca should get their facts straight and stop coughing xenophobic speech on the MEC ... We are way behind with quality health in South Africa because of the corrupt system
It doesn't make sense for the MEC to suddenly need to defend her stand on the matter and whether she's xenophobic which she's obviously NOT. Biased journalism crucifying an official for doing her job and wanting to ensure the wellbeing of the local citizens...I strongly doubt any well minded South African is against what the MEC did or her way of going about It, she was not rude, did not incite any violence at all. Personally I'd have been fuming to find individuals taking advantage of the constitution while backtracking my work
Like Motswaledi they are real patriots and sees how south Africans who are voters and citizens are sidelined in all departments with jobs and in hospitals!The only thing that can bring change is to vote ANC out in 2024!As for the EFF and DA they are beneficiaries of illegal foreigners together with ANC!How many times have the government bailed out Zimbabwe government since Mugabe days?
Well said MEC. Tired of these foreigners using our resources at the expense of South Africans.
She’s 100% correct
But she is telling the wrong person
@@Vimbaiwacho who is the wrong person?
@@MG-kx1bb the media
@@Vimbaiwacho she is telling g the right person. It's your job Zimbabweans to tell the right people your government ZanuPF. SAns can't do your job you are all supposedly smart and hardworking. When are you going to stop being lazy and face ZanuPF? Learn from Dudula and Soweto Parliament.
@@hopes9451 ok
We have your back MEC. You are the man! More guts and bigger #*!@@ than these sissie male politicians. I call it taking the bull by its horns. You and minister Motsoaledi are true and straight forward facing hereos. You should lead this country. President and Deputy. IGAMA LA MAKOSIKAZI!!!!
South Africans are on your side MEC, that journalist was talking nonsense.
That Journalist must be an EFF member since they are good on putting foreigners first than us South Africans.
journalists always talk nonsense
you don't talk to a patient like that it's inhuman
If they have nice treatment in they contury why they here
She talk to her nicely...
She is not a patient she's criminal...if u come to others country illigal..ur a criminal...
Are patients not supposed to be told the truth?why are they supposed to be given special treatment cz they are illegal in our country?
Some south africans are stupid yaz, The law has no emotions she shud be arrested for being here illegal
Even thou said go back to Mnanangwa she's right.....go back
She is 💯 correct 💯
She is telling the truth. 100
I was in Istanbul 3 years back. I happened to get sick and I didn't enough money. So they couldn't help me for free. I had to use my last money
Someone has to say it, your president is silent let them do the right thing, working citizens in SA are suffering huge tax sponsoring people who do not even contribute to the economy, power to MEC
journalist is out of line...OPEN your mind wide and never take sides lady..what a TONE YOU HAVE !
100%we stand with you MEC...hope this presenter also foreigner
It is only here in South Africa where if u talk about foreigners u are emmediately labelled as "Zenophobic" my god i hate this word so much. Well done MEC i support you 100% 😭😭😭
Dats true brother n it's very wrong,look at Dubai now,they have deported Nigerians but it's not called xenophobia,when we do that in south Africa it's xenophobia,I don't know what's wrong with this fu*n journalist who are always saying everything is xenophobia
@@emmanuelernest1187 South African media and some gvmt offials hate the truth, they prefer to be comforted by lies and bias news reporting while illigal immigration is killing this country in more ways than 1 its very sad.
Journalists start reporting on facts and stop sensationalising illegal behaviour by undocumented persons.
MEC is correct.
Countries must self correct
Zimbabwe can refer their patients formally so that SA can recoup its costs. Simple.
Zimbabwe must pay for its citizens loke all countries
hands off our MEC
You know am so disappointed about south Africans,when someone is standing up for their rights it's called xenophobia,when someone is confronting foreigners is xenophobic,we in south Africa have no leadership,for example, people get killed by foreigners it's ok but when south Africans react on that matter is xenophobic,the system in south Africa looks like it is built to serve foreign nationals
It doesn't look like it is built to serve foreign nationals, it is built to serve foreign nationals
This fake freedom was for them, not for black SANS!!!! They will one day take this country over together namabhulu....
We are behind you MEC. She is not xenophobic. Foolish journalist.
Behind u 100% Dr.....well said🙌🙌🙌😘media is full of nonsense xem
MEC she was right technically coz the foreigners should pay for their medical services they are not entitled for free medical or education neither social grants for that matter
In 1999 I went to the DRC Congo. I contracted malaria and was taken to a very dirty hospital next to a market. Before they could treat me the hospital demanded $350 because I was a foreigner. Was the clerk xenophobic no he was just following hospital policy to protect the Congolese. Stop calling everything xenophobic. The MEC was just frustrated because she has no budget to treat illegal immigrants. Xenophobic she isn't.
I support you Minister, media don't like to hear the truth.
Influx control must come back.
When America chase away illegal immigrants it's it's okay BUT when S.A. does the same it's wrong!!!
I like the Minister you say it like it is!!!!
We need more Minister's like you brave and bold.
Great job mam
The reporter is not seasoned. Probably she has a medical aid and does not appreciate what sa are going through. Middle class is becoming a problem and they do not realise that in no time, if things are left as they are- they will join everyone in government hospital. People must be patriotic and protect their infrastructure against abuse.
Yes, she is xenophobic ! Why not? She mustn't address directly to patients!!!
Truth is to be told. Trillion % right
You were telling the truth Minister
To the wrong person though
MEC YOU ARE RIGHT,SO RIGHT.
She was right this mec I support her 100%. They ran away from Zimbabwe and come here to umthwalo we south Africa
That is true
She is 100% correct and we are 1000% behind her
minister you were wrong just apologise , so what do you expect that vulnerable patient to do, is she to blame for Mnangagwa and Zanu pf 's failures , that was wrong timing to express your frustrations .
This eNCA women she must be from Zimbabwe too
She might be correct but she is telling the wrong person though.
She wás one who there
Who is the right patient? Who has been operated?
@@thulimahlazitha9858 the people who can do something about it
@@Vimbaiwacho like who?
A medical doctor swear with the hyppocrate oath not to discriminate patients. It should not be the duty of a doctor to know where the patient comes from. The admin, home affairs, politicians should do their jobs. Where are the humanitarian NGOs so that they pay for the costs of treating foreigners who need care since their governments are ignoring their citizens?! If someone is paying for them, they will be no complaints.
When taking an Oath it means speaking the truth!We support Dr Ramothuba for speaking the truth like Dr Motswaledi!They are the only real patriots in the ANC!Others are hypocrites like the leader of the EFF!I'm sure voters are watching them for 2024!Their real concern are foreigners!
That patient was treated. Zimbabweans can't hold SA at ransom forever with emotional blackmail of; Thabo Mbeki,,, the oath of dealing with patients,,, SAns are xenophobic,,, inhuman treatment of ZEP holders if they are discontinued etc.. We are tired of all illegal immigrants, our government & some politicsl parties gets this except EFF which will be punished in 2024. It must end and it will end.
Then its simple, South Africans must recieve preferential treatment when it comes to our public Healthcare system that we citizens pay for with our taxes. It is unfortunate that we are being forced to care of citizens of another country who break our laws and take advantage of our good will
Remember, She is not just a Dr but also an MEC who must be accountable.
This lady she has what the most South Africans leaders do not have . If the sitting President was like her South Africa will be a better country. She is not intimidated, she stand by her words. Wow few of leaders like her within ANC ranks can pursue the voter's to vote ANC again.
We don’t care about the tone, get it eNCA apologists? The MEC is correct and should be supported. Period.
Thanks Dr this is true. Leave all the diplomacy away and talk reality.
shame on the presenter who has money and medical aid, unpatriotic narrative
I support you Minister I have been sent a bail from polokwane hospital if you're illegal here were do they send the bill to 🤔
Why don't you send the message to Zimbabwean gouvernement
They do not spark at all 100% behind you doctor phophi it's time for 🇿🇼 to be responsible for their people thank you 🤝
We agree with MEC
im with MEC on this point
This journalist has been paid.the MES was not rude at all . U are driving yr own agenda period.
She is very unprofessional MES.
MEC is not Xenophobic at all, I support her and do not see anything wrong with the statements she said on the viral video. Most of the foreign people are sick yooh. I took my son to Red Cross kids Hosp. And the most people who were there were foreign nationals, mostly Zimbabweans, Somalians and Nigerians. As I speak they couldn't operate my son, My first visit was on the 14 Dec, after that I had numerous appointments twice a month, after the diagnosis was complete in May I was given a 5th Jan 2023 appointment and I was told me and my son should patiently wait. They are killing the system really. When I complained the doctor also told be about the backlog of other ppl with serious issues who are also awaiting to be operated.
There really should be tight rules when it comes to foreigners, all foreigners.
This is amateur journalism ... made the whole thing about xenophobia , meanwhile Public hospitals are overcrowded with illegals at our cost , We STAND BEHIND YOU MME RAMATHUBA
PLEASE PROMOTE THIS MEC IN JESUS NAME.
Thank you MEC..they say we are xenophobic in order to keep us quit..SA journalism does not benefit citizens
MEC is not Xenophobic... she is telling the truth... Who must take care of these foreigners... when there is a shortage of medication, staff, etc you blame department and nurses, Noooo call it whatever SA must come first.Munangwagwa must take his people
Yess how is it over there in your kauntry
Viva MEC viva🇿🇦💪✊✊✊✊✊
The start of this interview reminds me of that "why are you geh?" Interview 🤣
She is suitable for presidency.
Xenophobic or not she was correct in addressing the issue she's facing we are boombaded by foreigners and us as citizens we are suffering...
She is 100% correct..Media politiks about every nonsense and rubbish!
You can't mock a patient this way ,either illegal or whatever, I don't support nonsense as citizen of this country
Yeah u support these crimimals going around stealling medications from our clinics and selling in Zimbabwe. Then u go to the clinic only to find out that the clinics do not have medications. Sometimes we need to just say the truth as it is and stop nursing the mighty feelings of these criminals.