How to fix a dent in your bike frame - Framebuilding 101 with Paul Brodie

SdĂ­let
VloĆŸit
  • čas pƙidĂĄn 22. 07. 2024
  • How do you make a top tube round again? Paul Brodie shares some tricks of the trade đŸ€“đŸ
    If you'd like to support our channel consider buying us a coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/framebui...
    â–șBuy Paul Brodie Merchandise! We have T-shirts, hoodies, and mugs: teespring.com/stores/paul-bro...
    â–ș Make a Custom Headtube Badge: ‱ Custom Headtube Badge ...
    Click here to subscribe to see more videos ➜ czcams.com/users/paulbrodie?s...
    ________________________________________________________________
    ➜ My book: www.amazon.ca/Paul-Brodie-Man...
    If you would like a signed copy please email me at fussyframebuilder@gmail.com (while supplies last)
    ➜ Follow me on Instagram: / brodie8191
    ➜ Find me on Facebook: / paul.brodie.902
    #dent #metal #custom #fussyframebuilder

Komentáƙe • 409

  • @pashakdescilly7517
    @pashakdescilly7517 Pƙed 2 lety +30

    Many years ago, I was given a classic frame (a 1948 or '49 Duckett) with hand cut lugs - and the down-tube had a deep crush in it, to half way through the tube. I took it to an old-time frame builder, and asked him if he could save the frame. When I went back a week later, he had used blocks just like yours to ease the dent out. He was left with a shallow dent the size of a pea, and he filled it with braze. Just as you did. I am well pleased with the repair.

  • @azizuladnan2389
    @azizuladnan2389 Pƙed 3 lety +37

    That this frame was repaired by Paul Brodie substantially increased its value.

  • @boma7437
    @boma7437 Pƙed 4 lety +22

    I really enjoy your videos, Paul. The content is always highly interesting and well cut. Thank you for sharing your Knowledge with us.

  • @Fra123
    @Fra123 Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci +1

    I’m impressed so much work to fix a dent! Well done

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci

      Thanks Francesco. Yes, building and repairing frames can be a Lot of work....

  • @mrexon
    @mrexon Pƙed 3 lety +6

    You just got a sub because you proved to me I was wrong about dented frames! Thank you

  • @SomeTechGuy666
    @SomeTechGuy666 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    Mind blown ! How did I not find this channel until now ? Subscribed.

  • @anderssoderlind90
    @anderssoderlind90 Pƙed 3 lety +3

    Yes! now I can repair my kona frame and use it again, every one thought I should scrap that frame. Once I was working in my uncles metal shop and learn almost everything how to work with metal. And I have learned something new today.

    • @saleemcarr9501
      @saleemcarr9501 Pƙed 3 lety

      Dont , your kona will still be a deathtrap just with a plug covering the damage. This isnt a structural repair only cosmetic.

    • @aryanraina1076
      @aryanraina1076 Pƙed 3 lety

      i spoke to a framebuilder about the same thing and he said it'd be ok but will reduce strength of the steel in the area. He told me it's better to keep a dent on it for strength. Small dents are okay in low stress areas of the frame apparently.

  • @ScrapWolf
    @ScrapWolf Pƙed 4 lety +2

    Thanks for this video. Learned a lot!

  • @4G42010
    @4G42010 Pƙed 5 měsĂ­ci +3

    Thanks a lot Paul for generously sharing your knowledge. Only great people do that!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 5 měsĂ­ci

      Thank you very much. I do enjoy sharing knowledge...

  • @mrmyorky5634
    @mrmyorky5634 Pƙed rokem +2

    I'm probably showing my age here, but many years ago a frame builder that I used replaced my entire top tube rather than attempt to repair a dent. He carefully sawed off the tube about 1/8" away from where it joined the seat tube and the same at the headstock end. He then filed away the remaining bits smooth before putting on a jig and brazing in a complete new tube. The frame was of course fillet brazed originally and although the repair and a respray cost me about half the cost of a new one I was very pleased with the finished result. The frame was built in Reynolds 531 butted tubing and I remember him saying that the heat of the brazing would always cause a slight loss of tube strength locally but because this was at a joint with another tube it was no detriment.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed rokem

      You are not showing your age. Replacing a tube (done properly) is perfectly acceptable. Repairing a dent is less labour and therefore less expensive. Thanks for watching and commenting!

  • @james.d.8044
    @james.d.8044 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Such an awesome video, great channel that's a very cool trick to do with the wood blocks 😀 👌

  • @29roadie17
    @29roadie17 Pƙed 4 lety +2

    Excellent! Thanks for sharing.

  • @davidbraxton5110
    @davidbraxton5110 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Excellent craftsmanship, Thank you.

  • @rodrigozepeda3525
    @rodrigozepeda3525 Pƙed 2 lety

    super good video, thanks for sharing !

  • @lysdexsick
    @lysdexsick Pƙed 3 lety +1

    This is called, being a professional and knowledge throughout years of experience!!!

  • @petermarshall7775
    @petermarshall7775 Pƙed 3 lety +4

    I am an addict to your shows. The idea of frame building is beyond the capabilities of my eyesight. An old man can dream :).

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +4

      My oldest student in Framebuilding 101 was 75; his eyesight wasn't so great and his hands shook but he still finished his frame. Never give up!!

    • @phaedrussmith1949
      @phaedrussmith1949 Pƙed 3 lety

      Bifocals.

  • @johnnydeutschemark3620
    @johnnydeutschemark3620 Pƙed rokem +2

    Loved that fix. I have a dented frame, also on the top-tube and my local frame builder said, "Leave it." The tube is very thin and he felt like it might crack if it was forced 'back to round' or maybe he was just busy as hell and didn't want to get involved. So it remains...

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed rokem +1

      Yes, you do have to be careful with thin tubes. I would roll it round, and fill any low spot with a little bondo, then repaint. This is safer than using heat and braze on thin tubes.

  • @wtfftw24
    @wtfftw24 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    Always great handcrafting!👍👍

  • @shannons1886
    @shannons1886 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    First time one of your videos was suggested to me. Viewed and subbed. When your video views are that much greater than your subscribers, then you know your channel will grow quickly.

  • @kenmcdonald7793
    @kenmcdonald7793 Pƙed 3 lety +5

    Thought there where kids having fun in the background... they sound alot like Peacocks. Well, there they were in the backyard of your place. Thanks for the video.

  • @lihtan
    @lihtan Pƙed 4 lety +3

    Good job! It's nice to see you do some woodworking too!

  • @mymailforplaystore5496
    @mymailforplaystore5496 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Ingenious, amazing work...

  • @dariorodriguez7157
    @dariorodriguez7157 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Thanks a lot Paul...I learn a lot from you. From Buenos Aires, Argentina. Thanks.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      Dario, thanks for watching from Argentina!

  • @germancarfan
    @germancarfan Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Great work

  • @jayvee2081
    @jayvee2081 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci

    Such an amazing job đŸ‘đŸœ

  • @blockhead3654
    @blockhead3654 Pƙed 3 lety

    Great work Mitch.

  • @johnpartridge7623
    @johnpartridge7623 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    You have an easy teaching style Paul, thanks for the lesson 👍

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      John, thanks for watching and commenting.

  • @weldmachine
    @weldmachine Pƙed 3 lety

    Not disappointed.
    But i was hoping to see the dent come out of the frame.
    Glad to know this is how i would do the same repair.
    Thought there might be something new to learn, LOL.
    Thanks for bring us along.
    Peter.

  • @Tom-sp2xs
    @Tom-sp2xs Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Already thought you are a Super Man, seeing you file convinced me. Great Videos

  • @MrTiles
    @MrTiles Pƙed 4 lety +4

    You, sir, are a real pro. Thanks for sharing your time-tested knowledge with us neophytes.

  • @MADTherapist
    @MADTherapist Pƙed 7 měsĂ­ci +1

    Thank you for making this video and explaining it clearly, i have recently decided to build a couple of old bmx gems I've been holding onto for some time. One is a Redline RA340 and the other a dented up 99' Dave Mirra Haro. I will definitely use your method to knocking down a couple of those dents, I was starting to wonder if it would ever happen now I can get it prepared and ready to have it chrome dipped.
    Thanks and regards,
    Mike D.đŸ‘đŸŒ

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 6 měsĂ­ci

      Mike, thanks for watching. Now you can fix those dented BMX frames. Hope you have success!

  • @paulbuckles5353
    @paulbuckles5353 Pƙed 8 měsĂ­ci

    A wealth of information - I'd heard about the wood block method from a friend who wrenched for the USSR team in the mid 80's, but never seen it in practice.

  • @vanislandsteve
    @vanislandsteve Pƙed 2 lety

    Very nice work đŸ‘đŸ»đŸ‡šđŸ‡Š

  • @sidmarlin6497
    @sidmarlin6497 Pƙed 3 lety

    Beautiful shop!

  • @DavidRodriguez-eh8yd
    @DavidRodriguez-eh8yd Pƙed rokem +1

    Cool stuff, amazing workshop having the right tools to create sky’s the limit

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed rokem

      David, thanks for watching 😉

  • @Xavier_Ns
    @Xavier_Ns Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Dude your so smart this is very useful

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      I've been around for a while and I have some experience. Thanks for watching!

  • @dubmfg
    @dubmfg Pƙed 4 lety +4

    I look forward to watching these every week, thank you Paul!!!

  • @mtnbikeman85
    @mtnbikeman85 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    Hey, just found your channel. I rented a Brodie once on a trip to Sedona Arizona years ago, would have been 1999ish, I still remember it, a blue hardtail with a white logo and marzocchi bomber. It rode mint.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      And now, apparently, they have become collectible :)

    • @mtnbikeman85
      @mtnbikeman85 Pƙed 3 lety

      I'd probably buy one to keep if I saw it for sale....don't think too many made it to New Zealand where I live now.
      PS once this pandemic is over you should do a crossover episode with Allen Millyard.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@mtnbikeman85 Allen is about 8000 mies away, but I would definitely sit down and have a cup of tea with him :)

  • @janetmanzoblaz577
    @janetmanzoblaz577 Pƙed 2 lety

    Good work mr Paul newman !!!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety +1

      Interestingly, Paul Newman and I have birthdays on the same day January 26.

  • @petermarshall7775
    @petermarshall7775 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    Wow long time no-see, hope you are doing well in this COVID-19 situation. We are very envious of your workshop here in Havana

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      Hi Peter! I do remember you! Hope you are doing well :)

  • @SomeTechGuy666
    @SomeTechGuy666 Pƙed 3 lety +5

    I like the bike stand he uses. My consumer grade POS wobbles every time you touch the bike. His is rock solid. A poor carpenter blames his tools. A great carpenter always has great tools. Lesson learned.

  • @ppereztaylor
    @ppereztaylor Pƙed 4 lety +1

    Paul, I quite enjoy your videos. I have a question for you. I am restoring an old Norco Sports; it is a late 70's or early 80s japanese made frame. The seat stays were bent to the point where they were almost touching. I ended up using a rebar bending bar, but stopped because I noticed I put a couple dents in the seat stay tubes. How would you recommend I try to bend the stays so that they go back to being straight. Do you know if frame blocks are commercially available? Pedro (Edmonton Alberta)

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 4 lety

      Pedro, I would have to see the frame. I cannot offer an opinion otherwise, sorry.

  • @antn8387
    @antn8387 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci

    absolute legend

  • @michaelmeakin9674
    @michaelmeakin9674 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Cool! I just stumbled across you video. I have know your name for a long time. When I was a kid I worked for Norman Hill Bicycles at the time Derik Bailey was building frames him. I eventually went on to become a machinist. I still have my early nineties Rocky Mountain Blizzard. I wonder if you made that one.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      No, I only worked at Rocky from 84 to 86. Sorry!

  • @ronmatthews1738
    @ronmatthews1738 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    I have watched videos about an induction dent removal system for car bodywork and I wondered whether this would work on bicycle frame tubes.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Car bodies and bicycle frames might be a little like apples and oranges...

  • @hasletjoe5984
    @hasletjoe5984 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Paul, love the videos as I am a hobby machinist and motorcycle fixer upper wanna be! Curious, when you adjusted the boring head the .076, does the boring head work similar to the lathe and half the amount dialed in? On a side note, one of my friends (who suggested your channel) just pulled the trigger on a Triumph cub! Yep, he went off the deep end for sure!!!!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      Thank you Haslet Joe. On my boring head, when I dial in .050", it takes off .050". Not similar to a lathe. Your friend must be little crazy to buy Cub! At least there are Cub videos he can watch if he needs some inspiration :)

  • @lukadude7335
    @lukadude7335 Pƙed 4 lety +4

    love it! The tip for handling for low temp intake was really helpful!

  • @meboyotube
    @meboyotube Pƙed 3 lety +1

    I'm going to make a frame clamp just to enjoy that lovely sound it makes. Lol. 🙂

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      I'm told that my frame blocks are made from Eastern Maple. Any good hardwood will probably be just fine.

  • @stanciualexandru3382
    @stanciualexandru3382 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Mr .Paul you is good work super video Thank for the video

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      You are welcome. Thanks for watching!

  • @garrisoncullen7476
    @garrisoncullen7476 Pƙed 4 lety +1

    can you do the same if the frame is not cylindrical like a mountain bike downtube? I dented mine pretty bad first day i got it but its not cylindrical.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 4 lety

      No, you can only roll a round tube.

  • @JulianMakes
    @JulianMakes Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Great video Paul thank you. Can I ask roughly what thickness of cardboard you use when you double it up in the mill? It looks like dense thin cardboard rather than the Amazon box stuff? Thanks!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      Thank you. I'm not in my shop to measure, but it's a dense file folder, maybe .030" thick. Best guess.

  • @theoriginalmungaman
    @theoriginalmungaman Pƙed 3 lety +2

    Assuming the frame is steel, you could use an auto body stud welder and weld a stud to the low spot then heat around the dent then pull it with the slide hammer.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +3

      Yes the frame is steel, but often the wall thickness is only 0.5mm and sometimes it is heat treated 4130 so that is not a very good solution, sorry.

  • @nickfrost7136
    @nickfrost7136 Pƙed 4 lety +5

    Thanks for making this. It is very timely for me. I made a lugged frame and used thin tubing for the top tube. Tange Prestige 7/4/7 in 31.8 I crashed yesterday and put a nice big dent in the top tube. I got most of the dent out with a tube block and I was planning to use cycle design system 48 silver brazing rod (what I have) to fill the remaining dimple since the tube is heat treated. Do you think that is this acceptable for heat treated tubing?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 4 lety +2

      Yes, you just have to be careful. The silver will melt at a lower temperature than bronze which will be good for your thin walled tube :)

    • @norberthofer5830
      @norberthofer5830 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@paulbrodie What if you use auto body shop lead, bondo or an epoxy filler to level out the dent. Once you have a majority of the dent out, you are cleaning up the cometics I assume.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@norberthofer5830 Yes, those are all good suggestions. I would choose bond over lead, it's much lighter!

    • @norberthofer5830
      @norberthofer5830 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@paulbrodie Thank you for response.

  • @tarabario
    @tarabario Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci +1

    love you, man

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci

      You are very kind.. Thank you!

  • @stoneyswolf
    @stoneyswolf Pƙed 3 lety +1

    I purchased a vintage bmx frame off eBay years ago really cheap because the head tube is dented. It's a chrome frame so it needs to be perfect . I used a pipe expander to get it mostly out but still needs work. I'm trying to get it perfect if possible without needing to be re chromed because it's in really good condition for a 40 yo frame any suggestions.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      It's not easy to make a head tube round. Keep pulling little by little. I think the key is patience.

  • @seanwilliams5053
    @seanwilliams5053 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Hello Mr. Brodie! I have a question - I have a Salsa Moto Rapido with a dent under the down tube. Since it's an aluminum/scandium alloy, is there anything I can do to repair or reinforce it? Any feedback is appreciated. Thank you, and fantastic channel!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety +1

      Hi Sean. Thanks for liking our channel! I have never worked with aluminum/scandium, so cannot say. If the dent has no sharp edges that might develop into a stress riser, I would just leave it.

  • @ratheskin58
    @ratheskin58 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    At last! Some competition for the calls of the peacocks!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety +1

      Peacocks are only noisy during mating season.

  • @tongalizia3175
    @tongalizia3175 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Greetings mr Paul
.. I have an aluminum Bottecchia road bike that has a dent on the down tube by the bottom bracket,,,, does this method work on aluminium,,,, once again great video you and mr Mitch
.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      Tony, it might work. But, I have almost zero experience with aluminum bicycle frames, so, if you do try, be very careful!!

  • @gweflj
    @gweflj Pƙed 3 lety +7

    Paul, What about a bit of beeswax or linseed oil on those clamp faces?

  • @DJFalkoHannover
    @DJFalkoHannover Pƙed 4 lety +5

    Excellent video! Great relaxxed teaching and explanations. I love to learn all about that stuff. All the best, Paul! Cheers from Germany

  • @BruceChastain
    @BruceChastain Pƙed 3 lety +2

    great video man! one general question, does this filling in job help with strength or is it more cosmetic?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Thanks Bruce. I would say it's mainly cosmetic. If you don't have a set of torches, you could use bondo (auto body filler..) It works well too.

    • @BruceChastain
      @BruceChastain Pƙed 3 lety

      @@paulbrodie thank you Paul! I have a set of torches, well my dad does anyway. I’m planning on powder coating this frame so I suppose I’ll need to braze it.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@BruceChastain You can powder coat over Tig, braze, nickel silver, and silver solder.

  • @spongesurf12
    @spongesurf12 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    3:45 Peacocks! Interesting video. Always thought the Brodie bikes were sweet.

  • @jonasmeier417
    @jonasmeier417 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Hello Paul: Very interesting! I didn't know how dents are fixed. What would happen without fixing? Bending? Breaking? Does a frame lose static and stability with a dent or is it more an optical thing? Does it work only with bronze on a steel frame or would silver also do the job? Is it possible to repair also dents on aluminum frames? Thank you for replying.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +2

      Hello Jonas, If you didn't fix a small dent, as long as there was no sharp crease (to start a crack..), it would probably last a very long time. You could say most "small dents" could be considered cosmetic. As dents get bigger, a framebuilder has to decide when to fix and when to replace the tube. You can also use silver solder, lead, and bondo to fill the dent. I have never repaired a dent on an aluminum frame so no expert here. Thanks for watching!

  • @wrknclass1
    @wrknclass1 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Gangster! Thanks for your time!

  • @raibt6093
    @raibt6093 Pƙed 4 lety +4

    Dear Mr. Brodie,
    I've got the same frame, a RM Ă©quipe from 1993 with a dent at nearly the same position, but it was a little bit smaler. After I've seen your video I tried to roll out the dent with selfmade tube-blocks like you declared and it worked very well. Many thanks for your video. Finally I put grease between tubeblock and framedent so I could press it harder by rolling out the dent. At least there was nearly no high spot and no dent left. For heating up I unfortunately don't have the right workshop so I was contented with the little leaving dent. Many thanks for giving your idea. I don't dare to file the frame because the tange ultimate ultralight tubewall should have a thickness of 0.6 mm. Is it really without problem to file the frame?
    Yours sincerely Rainer

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 4 lety

      You don't have to file the frame. It sounds like you were careful and made it better. Congrats!

    • @raibt6093
      @raibt6093 Pƙed 4 lety

      @@paulbrodie Many thanks.

  • @MrLethal1986
    @MrLethal1986 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Hi Paul any tips for removing a dent from a curved tube on a cruiser type frame. Any ideas how I could go about doing it would be much appreciated. Great content thanks for sharing.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      I would use bondo. Scratch and sand it with 80 grit emery cloth, then fill and sand. Paint. Thanks for watching!

    • @MrLethal1986
      @MrLethal1986 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@paulbrodie I've found some other information on dent removal using compressed air and heat. It's normally used on exhausts and tanks but I've seen one guy do it on a bike frame and worked really well. Just in the process of making a attachment to connect the air line to my frame. Thanks for the reply.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      @@MrLethal1986 Yes, that process has been used to take dents out of 2 stroke expansion chambers. I think you have to be very careful with how much air pressure and the amount of heat. Good luck!

  • @pepekrozinek
    @pepekrozinek Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Paul, what is the deal with the custom dynafile? Does the twist in the belt help?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Just found your comment! I made the custom dynafile in 1985 and saved myself $400. The belt follows the same twist and bend as the original dynafile.

  • @moon-unitwoof670
    @moon-unitwoof670 Pƙed 4 lety +1

    What's the functional difference between the aluminium and wooden tubing blocks? Could you hold tubes in the mill for cutting using wooden ones? What are the advantages of the metal ones? The machined alu tubing blocks arlways seemto be machine to hightolerance. Does the parallelism of the sides actually matter when building a bike frame?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 4 lety

      They can both work well. Wood is better for a bench vice, and aluminum in the mill vice. They can both be parallel if they are made well and not abused.

  • @andrewut7ya511
    @andrewut7ya511 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    I would have filled the tube with water and freeze it while carefully observing, the ice will push the dent out. Its cold work and takes many hours in the cold watching for just the right moment to stop the cold treatment, but the results are spectacular.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +2

      I don't think I have that much time or a freezer that big!

  • @allcapitols1554
    @allcapitols1554 Pƙed rokem +1

    I meant to ad that that dent looks like a garage-dent, not something that was a ride gone bad. They're harder to fix than when a handlebar swings around.

  • @AbrahamBarberi
    @AbrahamBarberi Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Great video with great information. Question. I just purchase an 853 Reynolds MTB frame. The brand is Cotic, and was made in England. The frame has a much smaller dent that the one on the video. This is the question, since Im going to use this frame for MTB, do you think is still safe to use or should I get it fixed? Thank you!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Thank you Abraham. If it is a small dent, with no sharp edges, it should be fine to use. A sharp edge could cause a stress riser. A small dent is basically cosmetic. Thanks for watching!

    • @AbrahamBarberi
      @AbrahamBarberi Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@paulbrodie thank for the quick and good answer. Great channel!

  • @lukealexander3639
    @lukealexander3639 Pƙed rokem +1

    I just purchased a vanni losa frameset, has a very minor dent on the top tube, might have to try filling it with braze. Too bad i cant save the paintwork, in the end im a good painter so i should be able to recreate the finish. The finish is a white pearl base with candy red transitioning to orange, yellow till it reaches the seat tube.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed rokem

      Bondo is another way of repairing a dent, and there will be less paint lost with no heat. Sounds like a sophisticated paint job. Good luck!

  • @pedrojosemorenoferrer2836

    I have quite a larger an spreaded dent in an aluminium frame, is this method suitable?

  • @Vip-db2mq
    @Vip-db2mq Pƙed 4 lety +1

    nota 10 ta de parabéns..

  • @stevenmorris1153
    @stevenmorris1153 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    would that brazing technique and the flame temperature be the same if I did that with a 7005 aluminium frame and 5356 filler instead of bronze filler? and would bronze filler work as good as 5356 filler for brazing 7005 aluminium? Thanks for the video.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +2

      I can really offer no opinion on aluminum frames, because I am no expert there. Any heat applied to an aluminum frame would mean softening of the material and the necessity to re-heat treat. That's one reason why aluminum frames don't get fixed or repaired as often as steel frames..

    • @stevenmorris1153
      @stevenmorris1153 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@paulbrodie Thanks a lot for answering me

  • @teunluijbregts2533
    @teunluijbregts2533 Pƙed 4 lety +1

    OMG - you've got a Whippet safety? Beautiful machine 😍.

  • @danskustomairbrushin
    @danskustomairbrushin Pƙed 2 lety +1

    solid work ,enjoy the channel. id be interested to know if any pdr (paintless dent repair) techs have had any sucsess in doing a pdr on a dent like this. i did paint for a few local fame builders and a few large bike manufactures and have alot of experance working on this stuff but the idea of pdr a bike never crossed my mind untell watching this for some reason. if anyone reading this knows of someone who has let me know.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      I do not have any experience with pdr, sorry.

  • @621ELECTRONICS
    @621ELECTRONICS Pƙed 3 lety

    I've used regular plumbing solder / flux and a propane torch to fill some dents. Easy to file / sand to shape, and couldn't even tell it was dented. Not that it is better than real brazing, just an easier solution with very basic relatively cheap tools and what I had on hand. I did try a stud welder (welds the little pins on) and a slide hammer as I see mentioned in the comments, however, I couldn't get enough force to even budge the dent before the pins snapped (the dent wasn't even as bad the one one in the video here). Perhaps there are stronger pins available, never looked into it, was my dads stud welder from when he did autobody repair. I still have it and have another dented frame, perhaps I'll look into it again sometime. I'll say it was a cheaper BMX frame, chromoly tubing, so not sure the wall thickness compared to road / mountain bike frames, so I suppose results may vary with the stud welder. At any rate, nice video, makes me feel a little better about filling the dent on my frame, felt a bit guilty "hiding" the damage (I still own the frame, so not like I did it to sell, just to make it look better).

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Yes, the autobody folks often use lead to fill low spots or dents on restorations. It is a perfectly valid way of doing things. There's always more than one way to do things. Thanks for watching!

  • @RICHARD.WRIGHT1
    @RICHARD.WRIGHT1 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Is that JOHN TOMAC in the photo on the wall next to that column drill in the background?

  • @birthaappleshirt7404
    @birthaappleshirt7404 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    So interesting. Does the brass act as a filler or does it add some strength?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      The bronze is a filler and might add to the strength a little bit. Thanks for watching!

  • @KondoriRamin
    @KondoriRamin Pƙed 3 lety +1

    You could use air pressure (inside the tube) to pop it up...
    That's the most efficient way to do it. You could also apply a little bit of heat to soften it up...

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Yes I did watch a CZcams video where someone did that. I know that's what they do with motorcycle expansion chambers to get the dents out. Some bicycle tubes are sealed, others aren't. Downtubes, for example, usually have a big airhole going into the BB. How to seal that? I don't know.

    • @KondoriRamin
      @KondoriRamin Pƙed 3 lety

      @@paulbrodie
      With a plug...
      Or you can even seal the end with a plate and then remove it. You do not need much pressure for that, especially if you heat the metal...

  • @amc_sounds
    @amc_sounds Pƙed 4 lety +2

    So, how'd you do it with ovalised tubing like Columbus Max (the clamp)? That'd be cool to see :-)

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      this only works on tubing that is round...

    • @amc_sounds
      @amc_sounds Pƙed 3 lety

      @@paulbrodie I wondered if you'd figured out a way to defy the oval 😉

  • @tomanycooks
    @tomanycooks Pƙed 3 lety +1

    very interesting. does the braising strengthen the frame or is it for looks?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      It might strengthen it a tad, mostly cosmetic.

    • @saleemcarr9501
      @saleemcarr9501 Pƙed 3 lety

      100% cosmetic, this is not how to structural repair. One big bump or curb and the bike will fold in half

  • @lucretius123
    @lucretius123 Pƙed 2 lety

    Hi, I have a much smaller dent In my steel frame. Maybe the size of a pea. I was wondering if it would be possible to cut a piece of chromoly length wise and braze it on as a sheath. I don’t think my frame needs a repair, just wondering.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      If your frame doesn't really need a repair just fill it in with bondo. No heat, no warpage, just a little sanding and a little touch up paint.

  • @Aubreykun
    @Aubreykun Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Is this doable on chainstays? I noticed all your blocks shown were larger diameters.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      Probably not. Chainstays are often ovailzed, tapered and bent.

  • @jsdhesmith2011
    @jsdhesmith2011 Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci +1

    Just picked up a Gary Fisher Hoo koo e koo that has about a 1/4” deep dent in the top tube like this frame had. I traded an old squier electric guitar for it, I didn’t notice the dent till I got home. The guy who traded with me only had pictures of one side of the bike, so I didn’t get to see it in pictures. Anyways, I’m thinking my dent is not so bad compared to this one but I’d hate to have the frame fail on me while riding. My question is, if I just ride around the city and some light trails (mostly gravel, no jumping) do you think I’d be fine to leave it alone? I would love to fix it but I don’t have a setup like yours. Thanks.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci +1

      Josh, the top tube is not highly stressed so it should be fine. If it is going to crack, it will probably happen over time, not suddenly, so just keep an eye on it. Thanks for watching...

    • @jsdhesmith2011
      @jsdhesmith2011 Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci

      @@paulbrodie Thanks for your input. I subbed

  • @yurib5089
    @yurib5089 Pƙed 3 lety +4

    I like mitch, because he said you needed to do the little dent as well. I like how he kept detail & principles to your work.

  • @BinhNguyen-ex4zn
    @BinhNguyen-ex4zn Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +1

    can you do the same for aluminum bike frames? what would be different?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci

      No, aluminum bicycle frames cannot be economically fixed. They just get re-cycled...

  • @richardcarew4708
    @richardcarew4708 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    love watching you work... thanks for sharing your amazing knowledge... 👏
    once upon a time I taught autoshop.. richest town in the Bay Area... my kids drove Mercedes and Jaguars... which is why they hired me ;;☆》.. of many jobs... it remains my all time favorite... my biggest problem was getting them to go home... big fun... an honor
    question: I usually use brazing rod with the flux on the outside... is the separate flux better?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Flux is flux. If you don't have an automatic fluxer a coated rod will work.

    • @richardcarew4708
      @richardcarew4708 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@paulbrodie back when I learned how to braze... I recall the guy mentioning that issue.. but I was in a hurry and didn't pay attention to the details... I figured I would figure it out... I use the coated kind simply because it is easier in the small applications I have had... times are changing... thanks Mr Brodie... it's been a pleasure, sir

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      @@richardcarew4708 I don't think flux coated rods are the very best solution, but much better than no flux at all.

  • @michaelhallas6450
    @michaelhallas6450 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Theirs anyway you can pull the dent out with a unispotter (pinwelder) then fill it ?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      You have to understand that not all bicycle frames are created equal. The cheap ones use heavier wall tubing, not much better than mild steel. The expensive frames use thin wall 4130 tubing that might be heat treated too. There is a world of difference between the two. What might work on one might not work on the other. Make sense?

  • @shafhamid83
    @shafhamid83 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    I'm just wondering whether the same can be done on a non circular tube frame? I've got a couple of dents on my top tube which has a non uniform profile along its length

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      Well, if you think about it, a wooden frame block (with a round hole..) used on a tube with a "non circular" shape, is going to want to make that tube round. So, no, I do not think that is going to work very well at all.

    • @shafhamid83
      @shafhamid83 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@paulbrodie yeah I thought that would be the case. Perhaps if the hole in the wooden block could be shaped to match my top tube's profile, then maybe it could work. But I'm sure that's no easy task to do

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@shafhamid83 No, matching the inner shape of the wooden blocks to match the profile of the bicycle tube will mean that you cannot rotate the tube in the block, so it will not work.

  • @jockiron
    @jockiron Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Would brass be a suitable material for a frame block?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      Brass would work, but expensive and heavy...

  • @unclefester610
    @unclefester610 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    When I got a dent in my trombone slide I took it to a repairman and he had a series of steel balls on a cable. He'd tap one small ball through the dent, then the next size up, and so on until the dent was gone. He did a really good job.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      Sounds like a well done repair.

    • @roscoeschieler7752
      @roscoeschieler7752 Pƙed 2 lety +1

      I've seen a bit of trombone repair and always found it fascinating. I good instrument tech I know was straightening a slide by hand by just bending it over his bench. It scared me watching with the size of the deflection, but he pulled it quite true in a few bends.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      @@roscoeschieler7752 Sounds like he did a good job!

    • @unclefester610
      @unclefester610 Pƙed 2 lety

      @@roscoeschieler7752 TY

  • @dfreeze666
    @dfreeze666 Pƙed měsĂ­cem +1

    Im not educated, is adding the bronze actually structurally helping the frame in the long run? Isnt that now a weak point? Or does the fill make it stronger like bone? I have Monáșœ bars so i trust brazing, just new!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed měsĂ­cem

      I don't think it's a weak point. Is it stronger? Probably not. It just "is"... I have never seen a frame fail at that point after being filled with bronze. The danger is Overheating the tube, so you do have to be careful.. Thanks for watching...

  • @ardytjahjono9307
    @ardytjahjono9307 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Hi Paul. Great video btw đŸ‘đŸ». Can you do same approach to fix aluminum frame ?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +2

      Using frame blocks yes. Be very careful with heat. Too hot and the aluminum will lose its' heat treating..

    • @ardytjahjono9307
      @ardytjahjono9307 Pƙed 3 lety

      Do you accept dent and paint repairs? If yes what would be the best way to contact you for quick inquiry?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety

      @@ardytjahjono9307 Sorry Ardy, I'm retired with a youtube channel...

    • @ardytjahjono9307
      @ardytjahjono9307 Pƙed 3 lety

      @@paulbrodie ah okok. Good for you. I think I might suggest my dad to also start a youtube channel, as he is a really good cook. Thank you Paul and GBU

  • @kenneely7899
    @kenneely7899 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    Could a stud be brazed on. Knock the dent out with a slide hammer? Great looking repair!

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 2 lety

      If it was a cheap frame with thicker hi tensile steel, yes. But thin wall heat treated 4130 steel, no. It would most likely crack.

  • @jack002tuber
    @jack002tuber Pƙed 3 lety +1

    You ever try an automotive dent puller? The kind that welds a small stud on

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      Have not. Bicycle tubing is very thin (often 0.5mm) and heat treated so I'm unsure how well that method would work...

    • @jack002tuber
      @jack002tuber Pƙed 3 lety +1

      I just wondered. I stumbled onto your channel yesterday and have seen many videos. So impressive. Love your work.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@jack002tuber Thank you for stumbling :)

  • @kokadedru5157
    @kokadedru5157 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    why dont you use silver solder for this job to profit from the way lower heat? is it a price thing?

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      You could use silver solder. It has different flow characteristics than bronze, and might be trickier to build up. I've just always used bronze so that's what I'm used to. And bronze is less expensive..

  • @londonpickering8675
    @londonpickering8675 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    That was simply therapeutic.......All is right in the world for 15:27.

  • @semidemiurge
    @semidemiurge Pƙed 3 lety +6

    I would think the heat from the brazing would seriously affect the strength of the heat-treated tubing.

    • @paulbrodie
      @paulbrodie  Pƙed 3 lety +3

      If you're careful not to overheat, it is not a problem..