Friends build each other up and support them. However there are times where being a friend means being truthful even if it's something they don't want to hear.
They all handled it wrong. Barney told her the truth but did it way too harshly. I love the quote "honesty without tact is cruelty." But they lied. They didn't like it but didn't want her to feel bad. I think maybe dont say anything unless she asks you how you felt about it. And then when it's done just say "hey I'm really proud of you for accomplishing this. It must have been cool to be apart of a theatrical show." Then you're not lying and you acknowledge them and you dont have to tell them how crappy it is unless they ask.
@@alexisd6106 The truth isn't about being nice or harsh it is just the truth which people will have to accept no matter how much it hurt peoples feelings. The problem is not the truth being harsh, but that people are not able to handle it when it's harsh even though they keep saying that they want the truth.
@@lionkingflo6355 Yeah I see what you mean but as Alexis pointed out if they didn't ask for it there's no need to point it out. In this situation Barney could've used constructive criticism instead of just saying it sucked
@@thekat2784 nah she would have asked for, because that's what's the point about if they saw it. But that shows about people not being able to face the reality even though they say that they want to hear the truth.
As someone who watch a theater play where the actors are not well preapred it's cringe believe me or not. It's funny on our pov but if you are the audience you will find it cringey
It would be hilarious for the first hour, sure! Then by the second hour, I'd maybe get a little bored. Two and a half hours in, the pain would be steadily mounting. By the time it became a play within a play, I'd be praying for death's sweet embrace
I liked how the episode ultimately ended with both of them being right. Lily did stay to support Barney’s play but eventually she broke and was honest about it being bad. But then she still stayed to let him finish the second act because it was important to him.
I have learn the hard way that being honest about everything actually sucks ... Unless this directly affects you and there is no another way, you should let your friends realize by themselves ... Bceause your opinion may be not correct and even this is true, people are terrible when having to face reaility unwillingly... Most of the time they will interept your honest advice as negative things like you don't understand what they are doing or you are cruel, not supportive as a real friend .... So helping your friend as much as you can, being positive and keeping your mouth shut is always the best way to go :))
@@llarmstrong783 lily should have been consumerism considering she’d racked up thousands of dollars of credit card debt just a few months prior due to her buying lavish clothes
Narrator (voice of Bob Saget): There's Broadway, off Broadway, off-off Broadway, homeless people screaming in the park, and beneath that...the play Aunt Lily was in.
"Oh my god, Ted's part of the play!" XDDDD!!!! Marshall is just so shocked, it's hilarious. Love his awed smile when Ted is called Consumerism again! Lmao at Barney running through the seats at the end.
I just wanted to say that after this scene I joined a theater like that. The show was in a basement, we were wearing all black, and it was a very strange performance. My friends were very confused, buy I was living my moment of HIMYM and that made me so happy!
If I am having a bad day, I just watch this episode again. This series has just became a part of my life now, missing it badly!! Wish it had continued for more years.
Reminds me of that one time in college i took a dance class and the entire class decided to do art house metaphorical dances and have them go on for far too long. While I just did a nice jazz number
I loved it back then, to see Barney being honest about something he didn't like in his female friend. And it didnt break their friendship. About American rage, greed, envy, consumerism, I wasnt old enough to understand such things and take it to heart. Enjoyed it thoroughly. One time I danced even though I didnt know how to dance, and it became the most embarassing moment of my entire adult life. I wished for that video to be destroyed. And I think it did. None of my friends told how horrible I looked when dancing. They simply laughed. I dont know how anyone convinced me to dance but it still embarasses to remember the day I danced. And no one was honest with me. It hurt me even more.
The joke is that Barney's deliberately dreadful play was only on the level of how bad Lily's was. But Marshall forces him to stay and endure it and then they all lie rather than fess up that it sucked (not that you do it right to your friend's face but you get my point, they all turn a blind eye to how bad Lily's is but are open to how bad Barney's is when they're barely any different). Barney heaving into a bag is honestly hysterical and exactly how you'd feel watching this dreck.
I am brutally honest when people ask for my opinion. My sister once got upset when I told her that her cooking was subpar and needed more seasoning after she asked me what I thought about it. I wasn't mean about it, just honest.
U cud have said it was not something that suited your taste than saying it was subpar. She was hurt obviously because she liked eating that kind of food that was why she was cooking it. Unless impressing others with her culinary skills was her goal.
4 actors 1 technician and 8 audience members and 4 of them were Lily’s invitees…. Didnt the other 3 have anyone they wanted to torture? Or give brain lesions to? Cuz that’s how at least Barney seemed …. Brain damaged …. Especially when director announced QnA
Barney running out is honestly the best part.
Makes me giggle every time.
It kills me every time. 🤣
Yep
for real hahahahahahahahahahaha
2:47
Friends build each other up and support them.
However there are times where being a friend means being truthful even if it's something they don't want to hear.
They all handled it wrong. Barney told her the truth but did it way too harshly. I love the quote "honesty without tact is cruelty." But they lied. They didn't like it but didn't want her to feel bad. I think maybe dont say anything unless she asks you how you felt about it. And then when it's done just say "hey I'm really proud of you for accomplishing this. It must have been cool to be apart of a theatrical show." Then you're not lying and you acknowledge them and you dont have to tell them how crappy it is unless they ask.
@@alexisd6106 The truth isn't about being nice or harsh it is just the truth which people will have to accept no matter how much it hurt peoples feelings. The problem is not the truth being harsh, but that people are not able to handle it when it's harsh even though they keep saying that they want the truth.
@@lionkingflo6355 Yeah I see what you mean but as Alexis pointed out if they didn't ask for it there's no need to point it out. In this situation Barney could've used constructive criticism instead of just saying it sucked
@@thekat2784 nah she would have asked for, because that's what's the point about if they saw it. But that shows about people not being able to face the reality even though they say that they want to hear the truth.
@@lionkingflo6355 In that case you're completely right
Honestly, its unrealistic that they didn't enjoy the play due to how incredibly unintentionally funny it was.
No it wasn't
@@tokachan6345 it was. It’s like The Room by Tommy Wiseau.
As someone who watch a theater play where the actors are not well preapred it's cringe believe me or not. It's funny on our pov but if you are the audience you will find it cringey
That’s something you joke about later, but that play lasted 3 hours. At that point it’s just torture.
It would be hilarious for the first hour, sure!
Then by the second hour, I'd maybe get a little bored.
Two and a half hours in, the pain would be steadily mounting.
By the time it became a play within a play, I'd be praying for death's sweet embrace
“Ya if you’re a smurf”….. then I remembered Barney is in Smurfs lol
Ikrr 💀
I agree with both Barney and Lily, friends need to comfort each other but they also need to be honest
butter up things though, don'y be brutally honest.
I liked how the episode ultimately ended with both of them being right. Lily did stay to support Barney’s play but eventually she broke and was honest about it being bad. But then she still stayed to let him finish the second act because it was important to him.
I have learn the hard way that being honest about everything actually sucks ... Unless this directly affects you and there is no another way, you should let your friends realize by themselves ... Bceause your opinion may be not correct and even this is true, people are terrible when having to face reaility unwillingly... Most of the time they will interept your honest advice as negative things like you don't understand what they are doing or you are cruel, not supportive as a real friend .... So helping your friend as much as you can, being positive and keeping your mouth shut is always the best way to go :))
Right
Moist
Guy: I am rage
Girl: I am greed
Lilly: I am rage, no envy
Barney: I am out of here
The best part was "I am your father, America" lol
Barney should have been consumerism
@@llarmstrong783 lily should have been consumerism considering she’d racked up thousands of dollars of credit card debt just a few months prior due to her buying lavish clothes
@@noahlibra good point
Narrator (voice of Bob Saget): There's Broadway, off Broadway, off-off Broadway, homeless people screaming in the park, and beneath that...the play Aunt Lily was in.
"Oh my god, Ted's part of the play!" XDDDD!!!! Marshall is just so shocked, it's hilarious. Love his awed smile when Ted is called Consumerism again! Lmao at Barney running through the seats at the end.
marshall says why do i never get picked for audience participation too in barney’s play
@@chrispycreme9545 Every time I go to a show with audience participation, I think of these 😂
The guy playing America was actually a pretty good actor
He's also the security guard from The Amanda Show, Barney lol
Bob Rooney from Married with Children :-)
He looked like many a men we have here where I live with that stereotype vest and unkempt looks and pronouncing America. Where I live is not America.
I just wanted to say that after this scene I joined a theater like that. The show was in a basement, we were wearing all black, and it was a very strange performance. My friends were very confused, buy I was living my moment of HIMYM and that made me so happy!
If I am having a bad day, I just watch this episode again. This series has just became a part of my life now, missing it badly!! Wish it had continued for more years.
Right now, this scene and the one from Monk when he’s trying to laugh have been my go to’s for an immediate pick me up.
I was in a student play at Uni and all my friends left halfway through.
Honestly couldn't blame them 🤣
‘Wow Lilly! That sucked’ incredible
The funniest thing is, this kind of play really exist. And people pay money for it…
I mean the last Jedi exists
And some folks actually like it
@1:10 oh my god Ted's part of the play always gets me
Reminds me a little bit of FRIENDS' "Why don't you like me" - one woman show! 😆
2:46 gets me everytime😂
Me too haha i need a gif of this
I had a friend who used to do awful pantomimes, so I can relate to the gang here
The best moment in the series when Lily was put in her place.
Envy wanted to be rage.
Beautifully written.
Barney rushing out of the place when the director talks about the q&a always makes me laugh 😂
Barney mentioning smurfs is funny especially because NPH would later star in a smurf movie
Always hated Lily, sanctimonious Grinch
Barney's revenge in a later scene is one of the funniest things I've ever seen in my life.😂
Reminds me of that one time in college i took a dance class and the entire class decided to do art house metaphorical dances and have them go on for far too long.
While I just did a nice jazz number
I love how marshall supported lily
Fullmetal Alchemist looks different
I wanna see a real play based off of this just to see how terrible the play really is 😂
Me too. Kind of like Sheldon's roommate agreement.
Right! I’m curious about the play with in a play part 😂
The last scene would be me after every play.
especially assemblies
I do get barney tho, they are close friends, it's kind of Ok that he's been honest instead of fulling her with crap.
I loved it back then, to see Barney being honest about something he didn't like in his female friend. And it didnt break their friendship. About American rage, greed, envy, consumerism, I wasnt old enough to understand such things and take it to heart. Enjoyed it thoroughly. One time I danced even though I didnt know how to dance, and it became the most embarassing moment of my entire adult life. I wished for that video to be destroyed. And I think it did. None of my friends told how horrible I looked when dancing. They simply laughed. I dont know how anyone convinced me to dance but it still embarasses to remember the day I danced. And no one was honest with me. It hurt me even more.
It’s 2am in here and im bursting out of laugh because of barney running out😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
AS WE SHOULD !! 🤣🤣🤣
I think Barney is kinda right. You should always try to be honest with your friends but you shouldn't be so harsh about it.
The joke is that Barney's deliberately dreadful play was only on the level of how bad Lily's was. But Marshall forces him to stay and endure it and then they all lie rather than fess up that it sucked (not that you do it right to your friend's face but you get my point, they all turn a blind eye to how bad Lily's is but are open to how bad Barney's is when they're barely any different). Barney heaving into a bag is honestly hysterical and exactly how you'd feel watching this dreck.
moist
The truly funny thing is that this is how most theatres do productions today and apparently it is hip and cool 🙄😅
So Barney only brought ONE puke bag!?
"Wow Lily, that sucked"
Idc what anyone says Lily put in her place is well deserved. She is a grinch
Barney was right. The play she was in was crap.
I badly miss these people
This isn't how I remembered Fullmetal Alchemist
Am I the only one who wants to see this terrible play. It's so bad to the point that I would laugh
So bad, it’s good, eh? 😉😎
barney almost got tears 😂😂😂
The girl doing the "I am Greed" line slightly out of sync is underrated
Barney's one man show is my favourite scene of HIMYM.
The director was "Bob Rooney"
Barney gagging 😂😂😂
Ted's emotions 😂😂😂
"I am rage envy!" Hah
I mean this is at least one group in drama class 😂
I love that seen, u can't expect someone to tell u , you were good when you're not.
Even if someone do it ,it's fake, n make feel so bad.
I am brutally honest when people ask for my opinion. My sister once got upset when I told her that her cooking was subpar and needed more seasoning after she asked me what I thought about it. I wasn't mean about it, just honest.
U cud have said it was not something that suited your taste than saying it was subpar. She was hurt obviously because she liked eating that kind of food that was why she was cooking it. Unless impressing others with her culinary skills was her goal.
It’s not the worst concept but the revelation of who each of the characters are should have been left till the end
Hey, is a nice play, I would watch
2:28 Challenge Accepted!
The weird thing about watching HIMYM is that Ted both looks and acts like my brother.
Classic!! 😂
I like this episode the best. hahaha~
I kinda like Barney's play more than this.
Moist… moist… moist…
Moist!
@0:15 guys 4 together 🤣🤣🤣
Lily is woke
What is the episode?
Season 2 episode 16
You had one job
This is actually a surprisingly accurate commentary on the current state of capitalism.
2:46 😂
Thats Bob Roony 😂😂😂😂😂😂
if you'd want to make a dvd collection of the scenes and plots from HIMYM copied from Friends it would take like 20 boxsets
Something like this lasted 3 hours?????😂
Because that was how they showed the torture Barnie felt. Later he did torture Lily back equally with his drama and took full revenge.
@@Flawed-Awed-Gawed that's what made Barney Legendary
Bro it's Hugh Mungus
4 actors 1 technician and 8 audience members and 4 of them were Lily’s invitees…. Didnt the other 3 have anyone they wanted to torture? Or give brain lesions to? Cuz that’s how at least Barney seemed …. Brain damaged …. Especially when director announced QnA
1:41 I laughed so hard it hurts
🤣🤣
Episode
I thinks it’s season 2 when robin and ted argue over if they should keep stuff from exes.
@@stephenreilly2334 it's not season 2, idiot
The director is Bob Rooney ftom married with children
2:05
I am out of here.
Im last comment here
MOIST
Didn’t know lily was such an extreme leftist. I’m with Barney 1000%
WTF