Its rather bias about state school, but I don't blame Mr Chan. He needs to look after his business. My daughters are in state school, her class has 22 pupils with 1 teacher and 1 TA. General speaking, there are 30 pupils in a class with 1 Teacher and 1 TA. There are plenty of after-school clubs. And many other affordable clubs (dance, drama, gymnastic etc) out there cost roughly £7-12 each lesson.
Hi, I am surprised to find there is so few Sixth Form / A-Level colleges in England. Is it true the ratio is 20 secondary schools to 1 Sixth Form? How can it be? I am confused. Secondary school graduates in England don't normally go to Sixth Form / A Level schools?
In London, people look at the league table. People will move house to a better catchment area to get their children into a better school. People do employ a private tutor for their children.
This question, you can ask the British Embassy in HK. I think this is the correct department to answer this query. And would not get it wrong, or to give their own personal opinion. It will be lawful and it will be correct.
as a huge fans of your channel, this guest is really....ma ma day., or....awful TBH ..好多野都講錯哂......conflict of interest obviously .....e.g,,,,how come BNO cannot study ar ? .....Compulsory education is rights to everyone living in UK including asylum seeker/ refugees status / exceptional leave to remain 既身份, 學校都唔可以reject their application lor...public school 好睇 school catchment , 即係校網.......and i suggest HK BNO holders' kids is more likely to fall into the category of exceptional leave to remain ...sigh.....advise him to do his research first and stop misleading ppl of HK
He also used the wrong choice of words as well... "sponsor"... This is not how the law is. Plus also, what he said that is also wrongly expressed. A lot of children, needs to have basic standard, before most private school is admitted. And even so... do not expect that your money, is going to be above another parent's money as well. Cos a lot of other parents DO mind this... And there is a lot of disputes in this kind of area as well. I also cannot believe that HK parents spend so much on actual "tutoring".... which is indeed a waste of money. Cos that amount of money can equal to a boarding school fee.
He does not know that, I think even with a BNO holder.. they can and should be also able to go to a state school as well... As far as I know. Cos he assumes that, the individual cannot. His implied meaning is wrong... Because it is obvious that, the newspaper stated clearly that BNO holder CAN study. A lot of people, even in my generation, went to colleges... to do their A levels, and then onto universities etc. It does not need to mean that you have to be under 16 etc. What he is speaking of, is his personal experience only. He does not know what the laws are surrounding the actual situation.... and cases. He is also behind in his knowledge as well. Fee-paying school = "Public" school, or grammar schools. (Trust-based) Non-fee paying /state supported = Comprehensives / Grammar Schools / Academies BNO holders should be able to go to non-fee paying schools...
![英國買樓升學須留意周邊 近河多為窮區；投資物業收租 不宜租予大學生；英國幼教寄宿文化優良 大學理科商科遠遜美國 ｜張寶華 #會客室 - 英國升學顧問 陳思銘 訪問 [下]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oeWFd5a32eQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![香港人移民英國最愁就業 人工預降一兩級 生活費點辦？英鎊兌港元跌穿十算 買樓是否划算？| 張寶華 #會客室 - Goodbye HK, Hello UK 香港代表 Billy Wong 訪問 [下]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3HITIdQjvqk/mqdefault.jpg)
Samuel 於 2020 年 6 月 30 日下午受訪，及後 BNO 平權有所進展。英國政府於 2020 年 7 月 1 日表示，BNO 持有人不受目前居留 6 個月限制，將獲得在英國工作和學習的 5 年「有限居留許可」(limited leave to remain)，之後可申請定居 (settled status)，12 個月後可申請英國公民身份。
詳情：www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-to-extend-residence-rights-for-british-nationals-overseas-citizens-in-hong-kong
張寶華 找這個升學顧問 做訪問， 係絕對錯誤，呢個顧問所提供的資料非常bias。 我有三個孩子，全部在英國state school 由 year 9 (即係香港中一中二嘅程度) 開始讀到上大學， 他們讀的3間state schools 都提供寄宿與不寄宿部分， 即係學生部分是寄宿生，另外亦有day students。 我嘅經驗可以話畀你哋聽，英國絕對係有不少有質素嘅 state schools 提供寄宿學位，並不是這個顧問所說，只有private schools 才是好學校， 實際上 很多private schools都會有良莠不齊的情況。我三個孩子考 gcse嘅成績都不錯，我一個女兒去年才考入了 University of Edinburgh ，大家可以上綱查一查這間大學 嘅排名，係比香港任何一間大學都要高。 我幫孩子找學校的過程中， 並沒有聘用任何升學顧問 ，我是自己上網找資料申請， 然後替孩子向香港學校請假， 專登飛到英國不同學校interview， 還可以親身視察學校及宿舍環境， 與教職員傾談， 可以親身見到該校學生， 感受一下學生品格、禮貌。 有時升學顧問 因為生意理由，只會向顧客提供對他們公司有利的資料。
dick lo 很多outstanding schools ， 佢知道嘅事太少
咪打爛人飯碗啦🤣
講者做中介有佣的當然讚好boarding, 聽吓無所謂，但貨比三家不能盡信，孩子在身邊每日照顧住，讀state schools ok
dicklo, 求教，請問如果小朋友鍾意藝術，想搵間著重藝術既state school Year 4，可以點樣搵到呢啲資料？
無錯，想細路成績好唯一同最有效方法就係自己跟，而且可以成本極低。
本來都呢個Samuel 都有啲好印象，但一講到BNO既子女可唔可以係英國讀到共立學校就咁有保留，支吾矣對。始終都係要顧住自己檔生意，比既意見都是十分商業考量！
State school /政府學校:任何國籍嘅人都讀得，呢d係人權。當然你問一個sell私校嘅人關於state school就梗係依依哦哦啦
本來也對Samuel chan印象唔錯，但經過佢今次分享，對佢有保留，感覺佢想保住自己D生意
呢D"嘉賓"又係有利益衝突, 點會講真野比你聽
人地sell私校，張小姐就問佢政府學校，陳生唔通倒自己米咩，咪依依哦哦囉
咪係囉，我仔喺英國讀緊政府學校，3點放學後有好多課外活動俾你選擇，最遲的活動係到6點。點會4點鐘就無曬嘢做？亂講！
真心希望寳華吾好再叫升學顧問,移民律師接受訪問,有冇理由叫人比二十皮一年去讀private school,吾通個個都要做最top個7%!
點計數？20a一年？我六年前係英國學費加洗用起碼都要50萬港紙一年？仲要係homestay，而且我係果邊都有fd.融得入啲生活，我見過太多華人融入唔到。有時候真係要惗清楚先移民。譬如工作，穩份工打很容易。你想做大？自己惗啦
而且我俾啲個人意見同路人，真係要惗清楚，英國唔單只人權，難民法，女權，生活習慣。華人係咪平等自己去了解清楚。我覺得你地將移民講得太簡單😂
18歲前免費教育，硬要比錢私校阻唔到，未住滿3年，讀緊大學個D就食自己，如果覺得自己福大命大繼續留香港也是個人選擇
@@nearchan7849 冇人話簡單
@@nearchan7849 你讀大學並係中學,佢講中小學學費喎。
Its rather bias about state school, but I don't blame Mr Chan. He needs to look after his business.
My daughters are in state school, her class has 22 pupils with 1 teacher and 1 TA. General speaking, there are 30 pupils in a class with 1 Teacher and 1 TA. There are plenty of after-school clubs. And many other affordable clubs (dance, drama, gymnastic etc) out there cost roughly £7-12 each lesson.
今集音質又如何呢？
Perfect, love it👌
你發言時仲有些虛音
稻花香里说丰年，听取人生经验～
Hi, I am surprised to find there is so few Sixth Form / A-Level colleges in England. Is it true the ratio is 20 secondary schools to 1 Sixth Form? How can it be? I am confused. Secondary school graduates in England don't normally go to Sixth Form / A Level schools?
thank you
👏👏👏
Like 睇廣告，留言支持
👍👍👍
有小朋友的家庭去英國定居，如小朋友讀中二year8，理論上6年後申請到入籍BC，那麼他上大學時就可作為本土生，£9000對£2萬國際生學費，乘3年就慳好多錢。中學讀boarding school 有很多款收費，寄宿週一至五星期六日回家會平D，day pupils不用宿費又平D。
呢位嘉賓一係唔識BNO, 一係刻意隱瞞.
Samuel 於 2020 年 6 月 30 日下午受訪，之後及BNO 平權再有所進展。英國政府於 2020 年 7 月 1 日表示，BNO 持有人不受目前居留 6 個月限制，將獲得在英國工作和學習的 5 年「有限居留許可」(limited leave to remain)，之後可申請定居 (settled status)，12 個月後可申請英國公民身份。
詳情：www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-to-extend-residence-rights-for-british-nationals-overseas-citizens-in-hong-kong
多謝妳嘅補充
就算係咁 都同呢位嘉賓本身biased既評論態度係無衝突既
叫你讀免費嘅state school，佢點樣賺你錢呀？🤪
原來佢真係唔知架
Glasgow is good. I lived for 11 years.
👍🏻👍🏻
真係唔好再搵移民同升學顧問訪問啦
佢地有自己嘅私心
個個都可以自己移民，自己升學佢哋無飯食
當睇廣告
合法居留就可以了, 16歲以下, 睇下education act
如果唔係有必要既嘉賓，我鐘意聽你solo your own option, 分享下英國考試, 讀書經驗, 點睇英國人。
而唔係做問果個law
訂閱得就係睇你台戲。
人哋sell私校，你問佢公立學校，扮聽唔明，答都唔想答
In London, people look at the league table. People will move house to a better catchment area to get their children into a better school. People do employ a private tutor for their children.
這嘉賓對BNO現况完全不懂
Samuel 於 2020 年 6 月 30 日下午受訪，之後及BNO 平權才有所進展。英國政府於 2020 年 7 月 1 日表示，BNO 持有人不受目前居留 6 個月限制，將獲得在英國工作和學習的 5 年「有限居留許可」(limited leave to remain)，之後可申請定居 (settled status)，12 個月後可申請英國公民身份。
詳情：www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-to-extend-residence-rights-for-british-nationals-overseas-citizens-in-hong-kong
@@TooSimpleSometimesNaive 11:58 他正正就是在回應上個月提出的「六個月變十二個月」這個建議時的安排。而那時(七月一日前),內政大人、外相、首相都已經多次提及able to work or STUDY. 並不是只能「揾工」
如果你請個新盤地產代理/發展商訪問，人地會唔會話︰我睇跌足十年，大家唔好買呀！
如果張小姐呢兩集無收到錢，咁就仲唔值啦。
比左airtime，仲要貼埋自己名聲。咩生意黎。
間房有回音，可能用clip-mic好啲。
state school in uk must check and make sure you have a British passport for admission.
your outfit and make up make you looks 5 years younger today
Alvin Soon 😚😚😚
Hello
不太欣賞這嘉賓的分享~
用earphone聽較佳。
看起来挺漂亮且面善的一个女孩，多做点客观公正的节目，尽量别带立场。世界上本无正邪之分，97之前，大量港人怀疑香港的将来离开了，后来不是又有不少人回来了么？世界到哪里都一样，自己有学历有能力才能享受真正的财务自由、政治自由。倘若你就一个普通大学专科学历甚至没读过大学，即便到了英国美国，如何生存？我一直很迷茫，共产党走的是社会主义路线，也就是杀富济贫，他是站在无产阶级立场上的，想不通香港人为什么抵制？......香港董建华的八万五计划，香港人反对、大屿山填海计划，香港人又反对.....这些可都是为了底层人们设计的福利政策。被政治冲昏了头脑的人是真可怕！
13歲去英國留學使唔使考IELTS?
is kids eligible to have free education in UK once arrive UK or have to wait after 5+1
This question, you can ask the British Embassy in HK. I think this is the correct department to answer this query. And would not get it wrong, or to give their own personal opinion. It will be lawful and it will be correct.
as a huge fans of your channel, this guest is really....ma ma day., or....awful TBH ..好多野都講錯哂......conflict of interest obviously .....e.g,,,,how come BNO cannot study ar ? .....Compulsory education is rights to everyone living in UK including asylum seeker/ refugees status / exceptional leave to remain 既身份, 學校都唔可以reject their application lor...public school 好睇 school catchment , 即係校網.......and i suggest HK BNO holders' kids is more likely to fall into the category of exceptional leave to remain ...sigh.....advise him to do his research first and stop misleading ppl of HK
🤣
Jeff Kwan very well said
He also used the wrong choice of words as well... "sponsor"... This is not how the law is. Plus also, what he said that is also wrongly expressed. A lot of children, needs to have basic standard, before most private school is admitted. And even so... do not expect that your money, is going to be above another parent's money as well. Cos a lot of other parents DO mind this... And there is a lot of disputes in this kind of area as well. I also cannot believe that HK parents spend so much on actual "tutoring".... which is indeed a waste of money. Cos that amount of money can equal to a boarding school fee.
He does not know that, I think even with a BNO holder.. they can and should be also able to go to a state school as well... As far as I know. Cos he assumes that, the individual cannot. His implied meaning is wrong... Because it is obvious that, the newspaper stated clearly that BNO holder CAN study. A lot of people, even in my generation, went to colleges... to do their A levels, and then onto universities etc. It does not need to mean that you have to be under 16 etc. What he is speaking of, is his personal experience only. He does not know what the laws are surrounding the actual situation.... and cases.
He is also behind in his knowledge as well.
Fee-paying school = "Public" school, or grammar schools. (Trust-based)
Non-fee paying /state supported = Comprehensives / Grammar Schools / Academies
BNO holders should be able to go to non-fee paying schools...
張寶華、請問可否給我Sammuel 的公司contact ？我正需要一些升學諮詢。可否
幫忙一下？🙏🏻
Yes ! U pm my fb page
請攞番個平衡
收費嘉賓節目 同片既內容質素之間有無共存空間
無睇一排 睇番近幾條片都真係好失望
明既 妳同嘉賓都要搵食
但作為觀眾 真係好難唔unsub
年青人一定要走，捱苦都要去外國闖一闖，數年後思想和世界觀念，會和現在完全唔同，學有所成，世界這麼大不需要再回香港。2046年後香港有可能，只得三成人識講廣東話。
唔好咁悲觀。Jessica adams 話，2028香港歸英。或者預言成真呢！
加拿大移民现在这么容易 为啥不去加拿大 我觉得加拿大的福利和就业都远远好于英国
張小姐，陳先生的意見是錯的，首先他說現在的BNO是工作或讀書，所以那些小朋友是不可以申請讀state school是錯的。Boris Johnson的政策是BNO的持有人和他們的dependents都可以到英國生活，因此持有的BNO人士他們的子女是可以申請讀state school, 等於如果一個家庭經過投資移民到英國，他們的子女都可以申請政府學位。
講到卡吓卡吓。係都唔肯講。而家2021，BNO子女有得免費讀state school，呢位嘉賓檔野執左未，自己返咗英國未？🤣🤣
噪音比較大，錄音地方大感覺空擴。
請以後要請嘉賓小心點
Otherwise it will just ruin your channel😒
呢個嘉賓好唔掂!
真心 講者睇清楚先講啦
Bno 父母 過到去讀local school 中 小學仲要錢？ 人地讀書係 小朋友權利呀
hence free education for public school ?
@@alvinsoon8184，真係未 sure，因為仲未公佈各種 details！
中介一名...sell 屎💩⋯⋯sales