Bro. You can't dump on X/Y for being too easy, then let ORAS get away with shoving a legendary into your party halfway through the damn gym challenge lol.
ORAS definitely does fall to 6th gen curse of being easy , it still does have better side content and further detail in towns and routes when compared to XY I do agree that XY doesn't get enough attention even though game freak neglected it too
@@DootDoot93 Combat in Diamond and Pearl is notoriously slow, and the HP bar makes it even worse by depleting at a fixed rate, meaning you could literally be forced to wait for ten seconds watching a high-level Pokemon's HP go down after a strong attack.
@ColonelBragg except Pokémon literally means pocket monsters so pocket mon/man has always kinda been correct. He was simply hiding his intelligence through memes 😂
Genuine Response - While I love following the legend of BarDonJoe Shepard, I always look forward to hearing your version of the presidents talk about anything. Thank you!
Black and White 2 are S-Tier for the Black Tower and White Treehollow alone. Those are the best post-game facilities and actually made using legendaries viable. Not to mention the best alternative to leveling Pokemon to level 100 besides rechallenging the Elite Four over and over.
@@christiand1337 Bush says they were bad at the time. At the time, they were getting GOTY nominations , while being the single biggest media property on the planet.
@@kroganshepard6594 Hard to separate them out. The games were definitely the launchpad for Pokemania, and remain the best selling games in the history of the franchise.
@@christiand1337it’s really not bad. And games should be improving. If games aren’t getting better then we are screwing up big time. Pokémon established 90% of the gameplay.
So happy to see PrimeRadiancy branching out into new games. I love the Mass Effect videos, but I can imagine the well is running a bit dry for video ideas on those games, aside from the "Presidents Play" series. This is easily the best AI presidents channel, so I'm excited for the fresh content.
@@bassnoob8214 That's fair. I was thinking that there could also be videos on ranking enemy types and discussing things we want to see in ME4, but that's really just delaying the inevitable. At some point PrimeRadiancy was going to have to branch out more and I'm glad that he seems to be passionate enough about other games to make quality videos about them.
Gens 3-5 were the GOAT's. Golden era of pokemon. My first pokemon game was emerald. It's an amazing game that introduced double battles which is the official competitive format. Ev spreads were balanced to the 510 system. Without Emerald you don't have pokemon as it is today. The battle frontier is in my opinion the hardest and truest challenge in all of pokemon. Earning all golden badges is the final step in becoming a pokemon master.
Honestly solid tier list it's definitely has the same strength as the mass effect vids. Like if you're a pokemon fan you can tell the presidents actually know indepth knowledge of pokemon games.
Felt the vibes here. Love hearing the presidents talk about the other franchises you enjoy (especially the fact that I've been a fan of all of them so far)
Hell yeah man, you really strike the perfect balance between president banter and actually making a tier list. I also love the personalities of all the presidents. Keep up the great work!
We definitely need a Spin-off game tier list. The presidents' discussion on Pokémon Channel would be interesting since it's more known via the Creepypasta with BRVR.
Putting Legends Arceus so low is a tragedy, catching pokemon without having to enter battle was incredible, and it almost made me skip out on Scarlet and Violet because it didn't have that feature, for the first time in my life I had fun when catching pokemon, yes even in gen 3 it was a chore for me... Anyway awesome video as always, I'm pretty attached to these lines of codes talking sh** to each other over games lol
Yeah that’s my biggest gripe with S/V. PLA got the open world right and it just plays so smoothly in how you capture / encounter pokemon; not to mention that it feels so much more like an open world experience with how they do encounters. The agile / strong style was also a nice shakeup that didn’t feel too gimkcky. I’d put PLA in high A tier, maybe even S.
I really enjoyed this tier list, I'm looking forward to see more Pokémon related content and tierlists by the Presidents! Personally I would change the positions of RS with ORAS and BW witth B2W2. Also, despite the obvious technical problems that should be taken into consideration when ranking these games, SV are still atleast B-Tier in my opinion, since these games have an interesting and open-world region and two great DLCs that improve the games and their content substantially. Also building a competitive team is very easy nowadays, the only thing missing is a Rusty Bottlecap, which one could use to minimize IVs, e.g. the Attack stat for special attackers or the Speed stat for Trick Room teams. Furthermore I liked that these games had an actual epilogue that tied the main games and DLCs together nicely, also it is great that the newly released mythical Pokémon Pecharunt got its own little backstory and proper introduction in the story, instead of just being a random Mystery Gift with no backstory whatsoever (aside from the movies), that alone is a massive improvement over the treatment of Mythicals since Gen 6 up to Gen 8. One major problem for me that the presidents didn't mention is the insane power creep with the new Mons though, so I hope GF cools it down a bit in the future with Gen 10 onwards.
One of my biggest issues with S/V was how they replaced the gym puzzles with these often half-assed challenges. Like rolling a fucking olive??? REALLY???? What a meme challenge. The challenges included: - Roll a fucking inflatable olive - Find a bunch of flowers around town (not hard, but a little tedious) - Half-assed Where's Waldo - An auction??? - Culinary Detective Game (admittedly this one was kinda fun in its own way) - Literally no puzzle, just 3 battles in succession. For the first gym, this is passable, but for what's intended to be the 6th gym???? Seriously??? (Tbf the dancing Greavard was damned cute) - The world's slowest quick time event challenge that drags on for far too long - The world's easiest slalom minigame
The disrespect to Gen One is insane. Acting like the fact that it's barebones doesn't have to do with that it came out on the original Gameboy almost 30 years ago Just going to abandon the spark that caught the imagination of an entire generation to call it a "sub par RPG"
Seriousy, it created a blueprint where there wasn't one before. It was unique for its time, and the later games are obligated to improve on the original to justify existing. Really crazy take by the presidents, probably the worst I have ever seen.
@@daqueda1577okay but you said it yourself, the later games improved on it. Go back and actually play pokemon red and compare that to B/W or platinum. It’s not contest other than the kanto pokemon are by far the most iconic.
@@digitaldarmanitan3072 Read my comment again. The sequels had to improve on the originals to JUSTIFY EXISTING. Some of them are not improvements, and should not exist. The originals are top 3, because its way harder to design an entire genre then be one of a dozen incremental updates.
Love to see some Pokemon content! Most of it was spot on for the placements, though I'd say that Area Zero was a peak area for Scarlet and Violet, so I was surprised to not see it mentioned. Seeing this new video gives me some motivation to finish my own tier list. I need to pick up my pace :)!
Wow. I just learned Ash became a Pokémon master. I had given up. It’s been so long. I was a baby when he started and now I have patches of grey hair. I’m so proud 🥹
Love seeing our Man George coming in. I am going to attempt to building a AI video myself for different characters. If you have any advice, i’ll gladly take it, because you are GOATED at this. Take care man, and hope you are well!
I think the thing I've seen people appreciate the most in my videos is the genuine analysis mixed with jokes. Try to find the balance. Don't get too caught up making things as edgy and having the characters, whoever you're using, insult each other back and forth distracting from the content. Thank you for the super thanks and good luck. 👍
You can absolutely catch Growlithe in the wild in Crystal. They even made it available earlier (grass west of Violet) so you can use it against Bugsy. Vulpix was kept Silver exclusive tho
same here, too bad that the 4th storyline with area zero wasnt included in the discussion. still its true that their problems are hard to ignore. im sooo torn when it comes to SV
My zigga I was just binge watching the presidents nuzlocke sapphire playthrough when the algorithm gods decided to hit me with another banger. Let's gooooo! Diamond and Pearl gang represent.
Honestly, I think Scarlet and Violet got waaaaay too much hate here. I might be biased, but it's the most fun i had playing a Pokemon in YEARS. Area Zero, while only an hour or two at the end, is probably the best bit of story we've ever gotten in a Pokemon Game. Nemona is the friendly rival archetype done right. Penny and Arven are fun and likeable characters. I feel like it really should be an S-Tier, but the technical issues drag it down to B for me. Fun as it is, and as cool as many of the ideas and concepts were, they sadly dropped the ball in several areas technologically. Scarlet and Violet is, hopefully, a step in the right direction from a narrative and character perspective. But they need to fix the technical issues and introduce more of a challenge to the game. Side note: I'd love if you ranked some of the spin-off titles at some point. I'd LOVE to see the takes given to the Mystery Dungeon titles.
You're videos are too good, you are the best that made this videos of the president. By the way do you play Persona? because i would love a video about the president about Persona
Insane take on X/Y. Mega Evolution was a legitimately amazing mechanic with serious depth that they should hae continued throughout the series rather than invent new gimicks. Not to mention the beautiful 3D model work, new fairy typing, the addition of player customization beyond starting gender, a bonus starter pokemon in the Gen 1 starters, XP share that doesn't suck, a way to boost EVs without grinding wild pokemon, etc. Yeah the game is easy, and that's unfortunate, but it's useful for there to be a couple easy games in the series to appeal to players of all skill level. X/Y is the perfect game for players to get into Nuzlocking. The only bad thing about X/Y is boring Team Flare. Everything else is goated. Easy A tier or S tier. Edit: because everyone always says that everyone's favorite pokemon game is the one they started with, I feel the need to make it clear that my first pokemon game was Sapphire.
100% agreed, X and Y are what got me into pokemon games in general, and its still by far my favorite of the series. Really wish they kept up the mega evolution mechanics rather than the lazy gimmicks they keep going for like 'make pokemon huge'
agree for mega evolution, but the game doesn't even use them until the champion and it's an easy sweep, not to mention some clear balancing issues they never addressed. It's still by far the best gimmick and clears all the others but it's not perfect either. the """"""beautiful"""""" 3d models look like lifeless husks that got their souls sucked up from them at the same time as their bright and beautiful colors when going into the washing machine, and the fact that they're still using those ass models in 2024 makes me hate them even more. Fairy typing is great but new types have been introduced before and we'll probably get new ones in the future, it wasn't an arguments for the other games so it's not here either. Player customisation is great and it was taken into consideration in the tier list, but it's the sidest side content if the customisation is the ultimate greatest addition might as well play movie star planet instead. More useless gen 1 pandering making the easy game even easier isn't an argument for S tier. While XP share not being mandatory was better than having forced on the player it's still the reason we have it now, exp share that didn't suck was back when it was an item, If they wanted it to be easier to access for the whole team they could've easilly handed multiple copies of it throuhought the game with side quests or main quest story bits, way more apealling that having the easy way out ready from the get go. And i agree with the last point. The game isn't deserving D tier or lower for sure but it's far from an A tier S even less. Maybe if it had gotten the 3rd Z version everyone was waiting for to fix some of the issues and lack of postgame, maybe then the game could've gotten this high. But as it is now it's fine in mid C or B tier
I liked it at the time, but you only ever fight two mega pokemon in the whole game, which speaks to larger problem in the game being way too easy. E4 members having 4 pokemon each? To go from B/W difficulty to X/Y difficulty was such a let down despite how cool megas are.
The one good thing sword and shield that was expanded upon was the character customization plus that banger gym music. Dynamax adventures was great cause i got my shiny lunala after 100 tries. Other than technical issues gen 9 was great, school was underutilized sure but then we got area zero and its beautiful music. Gen 2 and 3 are still my favorite, secret bases are awesome.
0:00 intro 0:47 Pokémon Red and blue 3:04 Pokémon Yellow 4:24 Pokémon Gold and silver 6:20 Pokémon Crystal 7:07 Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire 8:32 Pokémon Emerald 10:24 Pokémon fire red and leaf green 12:00 Pokémon diamond and pearl 14:45 Pokémon platinum 15:35 Pokémon heart gold and soul silver 16:51 Pokémon Black and White 19:15 Pokémon black 2 and white 2 20:40 Pokémon X and Y 22:45 Pokémon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire 24:40 Pokémon Sun and moon 26:24 Pokémon ultra sun and ultra moon 27:34 Pokémon let's go Pikachu and let's go Eevee 29:09 Pokémon sword and shield 31:24 Pokémon brilliant diamond and shining pearl 32:28 Pokémon legends Arceus 35:58 Pokémon scarlet and violet 36:57 Outro
Playing through Arceus currently probably my favorite way to go through gen 4 hisui is great and it’s just a different type of game in a l lot of respects
Pretty insightful. I always thought the later gen games were pretty easy. No need for dark souls hard but maybe a level below that? Curious about what gen 10 will be like.
The craziest thing about Pokemon is that any video covering the series will require at least eight minutes of watchtime before you discover that the author is a gen 3 fanboy
Here's my take on Sun & Moon and USUM; mainly the villains: Lusamine & Guzma were easily one of the best evil team leaders at that point in time of their debut. Lusamine had lost her husband when they traveled in Ultra Space, got her mind infected by Nihilego which made her so obsessed that she even tried forcibly dressing up Lillie like Nihilego itself, and even abused her own children so badly (namely Lillie), that they abandoned her to loneliness. She even cryogenically froze Pokemon that she once told in stories to her children while also trying to get even closer to Nihilego. She effectively gave me every reason to wanna beat her considering that Ultra Wormholes were also appearing all over Alola. And then when the Ultra games came along, they sorta kinda make her look like a good guy despite having still abused her own kids in the past and just got away with it. Not only does this make no sense, but it also ruins Lillie and Gladion's character growth. They pretty much go from "I'm gonna stop my psychotic mother from destroying the region" to "I want to stop my mom from saving the region because I don't want to lose my Pokemon." Lusamine also ended up being a background character once the main conflict was over. This is why the Rainbow Rocket Episode should've been the main story of the whole games (considering Game Freak clearly had a massive hard-on for Kanto throughout the story). Considering Giovanni mentioned using Nihilego's poison to mind-control Lusamine, they could've made it where she was their puppet and that she is a sweet/loving mother, which would then tips Lillie and Gladion off to something not feeling right. Team Skull could be used as their front to stop you while the Ultra Recon Squad is trying to warn you to the problems as Rainbow Rocket is after Necrozma and are trying to use it for their own gain, but Team Skull would interrupt conversations to prevent you from knowing the truth. ...Or something like this.
Bruh, they ignored the fact that Scarlet/ Violet's music is one of the best things about the games, they were composed by Toby Fox, plus they were playing Penny's theme in the background, an incredibly catchy song, my favorites are definitely the Tera Raid theme, Penny, and Turo/ Sada
I've seen some other President's Pokémon tier lists, and this is definitely one of the better ones. Easily the most well-articulated. I'd personally put BW and FRLG in A tier and I thought putting Yellow and Crystal in F was a bit harsh despite your valid criticisms, but since Emerald, Platinum, and HGSS were put in S where they belong, I'm okay with it.
It's not wrong though lol. Everytime i hear someone say gen 1 was the best generation, i know that person is either a liar, or havent played those games in 20 years. Those games aged like sour fucking milk lol
Surprised you didn’t include the DLC expansions for the Switch games as a “third” game and separate on the tier lists. They’re pretty big and are a nice improvement by replacing the third game.
In terms of Fun Gen 1 is undefeated there are so many cool glitches in that game to do like, missingno, Beating the game in 0 seconds, Battling Professor Oak and finding all sorts of Scrapped glitched Gen 2 pokemon, the mew glitch, getting any pokemon in the game before the second gym etc
People always talk about how Cythia was so difficult. Young me played Ruby first and did not know what he was doing. Killed Groudon because he figured he would catch one later. Best mon was a Vulpix (didn't have a fire stone) and it used fire spin, will o wisp, iron tail, and flamethrower. After the forge that was beating the Elite 4 under those conditions, Diamond was a breeze as was everything since.
I can't argue with the rankings. In fact, the points the boys touched on simply reminded me that the most fun I had with the games was Pokemon Stadium back on the N64. I do like the later gen version on the xo share since one of my biggest gripes with the older games was the grind. I'd catch a new pokemon that felt interesting but I couldn't use them because their lvl was way too low.
The thing I don't understand is this: if something ceases to appeal to you, why do you continue to check out every new iteration when nothing changes? I was a massive Pokémon fan as a youngster but I steadily began to lose interest following Gen IV. Eventually after X and Y I just stopped buying the games because I understood they weren't really "for me" anymore. I picked up Sun and Moon years later for something like 5 dollars and like Trump, couldn't get past the long-ass tutorial. Then I tried Arceus, and while yeah it's nice to see them finally do something new after 30 years, the bland openworld, AI-generated story and lack of personally interesting 'Mons solidified to me that I'm just not a fan of Pokémon anymore, and that's okay. I go back and play romhacks of the good games, I've played through GSC/RSE/DPPt more times than I can count, and I have two originally-issued massive Pokémon: The Movie and The Movie: 2000 posters in my apartment. But all that stuff will always be there. This is the most financially successful video game IP of all time but no one seems to be happy lol. If Trump's little spiel at the end was cathartic for you, I'd bring that same energy for the next game GF releases, and either don't buy it or just pirate it.
To be fair, Cynthia was scariest in Pokemon Black/White when you wandered into the wrong house on the wrong season and she refuses to let you leave without a thorough spanking. Her team was bordering lvl 80
Gen 1 paved the way for all the others. All 3 are absolute S tier. They built a formula where there wasn't one. Of course the others should be improvements, there's no excuse not to be, yet some of them still failed.
Megas should have been limited to two stage evolutions. There should also only have been one mega stone. Make it so you had to be really careful with who gets the mega. Takes up a slot and its held item
i wouldnt touch any old game that was considered a masterpiece cause nothing old ages well for me, but ya gotta rate them as how great they were back then at the time. gen 1 was like S tier shit back then i loved it
The disrespect to Kanto is insane Gen 1 remake is good and deserves A everything doesn't need to be more sometimes simple and little things are better like how Daredevil show isn't about saving the world and the stakes are low yet it's far better than anything in MCU.
Gen 1 deserves our respect, and Yellow allows the opportunity to not only start out with Pikachu, but to get the original 3 starters as well, just like Ash did! Are there improvements that could/would be made? Of course, but much of it was already perfection. We don't need 1,025 Pokemon. How many generic birds/fish do I have to try and memorize now? How many beauty contests do I have to enter before I can just play the core game? It was a simpler time; We played RBY and then pushed a hoop with a stick down a dirt road.
Hey, I know most people don't consider them mainline but I really think you missed out on ranking Pokemon Colosseum and XD gale of darkness, personally I believe they Didi 3D right and had a lot of good and fresh stuff to bring to the table, and are worthy pokemon games, it's really a shame most people don't know about them
George: "Cynthia made these games iconic. If you don't fear her, then you're just too young to understand what we went through back in 2006." *Me who absolutely smoked Cynthia on the very first try back in 2006 on Pokemon Pearl, then did it again on Platinum.* Yeah, that sounds like a skill issue homie.
It’s a universal truth in every presidentsverse; Joe is a gen oner lol
And nearly all have him hate gen 5 despite an ice cream pokemon existing. Bet he’s so upset it’s not chocolate chip lol
Since he is the oldest of the bunch, it makes sense that he'd be the Gen-Wunner
@@Reagan1984 I'd assume he'd like gen 5 cus he loves ice cream but Biden gotta be controversial
@@JoeMamaLlama1234
Even the love of ice cream can't win over his nostalgia.
... Except Jaydoff apparently.
Bro. You can't dump on X/Y for being too easy, then let ORAS get away with shoving a legendary into your party halfway through the damn gym challenge lol.
I love X/Y, it’s what got me back into Pokémon, I know it’s to easy but I’m not playing these games for a challenge tbh lol
Mega Evolution has to be my favorite gimmick, that hasnt been topped.
ORAS definitely does fall to 6th gen curse of being easy , it still does have better side content and further detail in towns and routes when compared to XY
I do agree that XY doesn't get enough attention even though game freak neglected it too
@@r.e.z9428Facts. I hope when Kalos gets another remake or sequel we can use mega evolution again.
Really wish it would come back outside of it.
@@thelordoftheweebs9501 Except I dont want another Scarlet and Violet or Sword and Shield.
Bush: "I would like to rate these games, but I haven't finished them. Still waiting for one of my pokemon's health bar to reach 0."
Holy shit 💀💀
I don’t get it. What does that mean? Is he doing a Nuzlocke or something?
@@DootDoot93 Combat in Diamond and Pearl is notoriously slow, and the HP bar makes it even worse by depleting at a fixed rate, meaning you could literally be forced to wait for ten seconds watching a high-level Pokemon's HP go down after a strong attack.
I like how Bush calls it "Pocket man" at first then turns into a hentai man and lore master right after
@ColonelBragg except Pokémon literally means pocket monsters so pocket mon/man has always kinda been correct. He was simply hiding his intelligence through memes 😂
Ain't no way joe doesn't like the ice cream pokemon.
So fucking true dude
Ain't chocolate chocolate chip flavored
pokemon gen 3 was awsome it infold five main games and two spin off
Genuine Response - While I love following the legend of BarDonJoe Shepard, I always look forward to hearing your version of the presidents talk about anything. Thank you!
Black and White 2 are S-Tier for the Black Tower and White Treehollow alone. Those are the best post-game facilities and actually made using legendaries viable. Not to mention the best alternative to leveling Pokemon to level 100 besides rechallenging the Elite Four over and over.
Pokemon Red, Blue, and Yellow were beloved sensations. Is only Sleepy Joe old enough to remember what actual Pokemania was?
No, it’s hindsight that shows how bad RBY were. The tiers lists aren’t how about popular they were on release but how they hold up today.
@@christiand1337 Bush says they were bad at the time. At the time, they were getting GOTY nominations , while being the single biggest media property on the planet.
I'd argue that the anime and TCG had more to do with PokeMania than the Gen 1 games themselves.
@@kroganshepard6594 Hard to separate them out. The games were definitely the launchpad for Pokemania, and remain the best selling games in the history of the franchise.
@@christiand1337it’s really not bad. And games should be improving. If games aren’t getting better then we are screwing up big time.
Pokémon established 90% of the gameplay.
So happy to see PrimeRadiancy branching out into new games. I love the Mass Effect videos, but I can imagine the well is running a bit dry for video ideas on those games, aside from the "Presidents Play" series. This is easily the best AI presidents channel, so I'm excited for the fresh content.
I mean there can be a ship ranking, planet ranking, ranking Andromeda planets, talking about Andromedas flaws
@@bassnoob8214 That's fair. I was thinking that there could also be videos on ranking enemy types and discussing things we want to see in ME4, but that's really just delaying the inevitable. At some point PrimeRadiancy was going to have to branch out more and I'm glad that he seems to be passionate enough about other games to make quality videos about them.
@@SkyRanger343 honestly I hope he makes some star wars content covering kotor
Tbh, I want to see an Andromeda mission ranking list. I just finished a trilogy run now I'm playing Andromeda.
A tier list for Andromeda's flaws even??@@bassnoob8214
You know I never got passionate about tier lists, but I think this is the first one I can't help but actively hate.
Platinum, HGSS, BW & B2W2 all came out withing 5 years. The DS Era is simply unmatched
I will do everything in my power to get Primeradiancy into larger YT recognition.
And by everything, I mean liking and commenting.
Gens 3-5 were the GOAT's. Golden era of pokemon. My first pokemon game was emerald. It's an amazing game that introduced double battles which is the official competitive format. Ev spreads were balanced to the 510 system. Without Emerald you don't have pokemon as it is today. The battle frontier is in my opinion the hardest and truest challenge in all of pokemon. Earning all golden badges is the final step in becoming a pokemon master.
"My first pokemon game was emerald."
That explains it
Emerald is good but not perfect. No physical/special spilt and certain types were broken.
Honestly solid tier list it's definitely has the same strength as the mass effect vids. Like if you're a pokemon fan you can tell the presidents actually know indepth knowledge of pokemon games.
I love all of these. You have really made them into characters of their own
16:40 You can also take pictures with your favorite gym leader in HG/SS. I loved taking a picture with Sabrina.
Felt the vibes here. Love hearing the presidents talk about the other franchises you enjoy (especially the fact that I've been a fan of all of them so far)
Hell yeah man, you really strike the perfect balance between president banter and actually making a tier list. I also love the personalities of all the presidents. Keep up the great work!
I knew right off the bat that Driftveil city would play when they talked about Black and White
We definitely need a Spin-off game tier list. The presidents' discussion on Pokémon Channel would be interesting since it's more known via the Creepypasta with BRVR.
Lugia is goated. Always will be.
Putting Legends Arceus so low is a tragedy, catching pokemon without having to enter battle was incredible, and it almost made me skip out on Scarlet and Violet because it didn't have that feature, for the first time in my life I had fun when catching pokemon, yes even in gen 3 it was a chore for me...
Anyway awesome video as always, I'm pretty attached to these lines of codes talking sh** to each other over games lol
Yeah that’s my biggest gripe with S/V. PLA got the open world right and it just plays so smoothly in how you capture / encounter pokemon; not to mention that it feels so much more like an open world experience with how they do encounters.
The agile / strong style was also a nice shakeup that didn’t feel too gimkcky.
I’d put PLA in high A tier, maybe even S.
Gen 2 gives us Wooper and quagsire it's S+ tier
Woopy boi
And Gen1 gives us Praise Helix ❤
Crystal F tier!? No wonder I didn't vote for any of these guys.
Oh boy. This is going to be a long series
glad to see HG and SS up in S tier where it belongs but kinda sad the GOAT pokewalker wasnt mentioned
They never fixed the level curve though. They could’ve really flushed out the kanto region too. The fight against red is always really cool though.
GEN ONE IS BEST ONE
DIS WHY COZY DOESNT VOTE
'Puts SV in F/D tier'
Well none of these guys were known for their intelligence.
Youre right it should be F- tier
@@mreevee7785 But where would we put Gen 3 then? H tier?
@KnightofChaosDeck no it would go in 7.8/10 too much water tier
@@mreevee7785 it isn't lmfao
I really enjoyed this tier list, I'm looking forward to see more Pokémon related content and tierlists by the Presidents!
Personally I would change the positions of RS with ORAS and BW witth B2W2. Also, despite the obvious technical problems that should be taken into consideration when ranking these games, SV are still atleast B-Tier in my opinion, since these games have an interesting and open-world region and two great DLCs that improve the games and their content substantially. Also building a competitive team is very easy nowadays, the only thing missing is a Rusty Bottlecap, which one could use to minimize IVs, e.g. the Attack stat for special attackers or the Speed stat for Trick Room teams. Furthermore I liked that these games had an actual epilogue that tied the main games and DLCs together nicely, also it is great that the newly released mythical Pokémon Pecharunt got its own little backstory and proper introduction in the story, instead of just being a random Mystery Gift with no backstory whatsoever (aside from the movies), that alone is a massive improvement over the treatment of Mythicals since Gen 6 up to Gen 8. One major problem for me that the presidents didn't mention is the insane power creep with the new Mons though, so I hope GF cools it down a bit in the future with Gen 10 onwards.
One of my biggest issues with S/V was how they replaced the gym puzzles with these often half-assed challenges. Like rolling a fucking olive??? REALLY???? What a meme challenge. The challenges included:
- Roll a fucking inflatable olive
- Find a bunch of flowers around town (not hard, but a little tedious)
- Half-assed Where's Waldo
- An auction???
- Culinary Detective Game (admittedly this one was kinda fun in its own way)
- Literally no puzzle, just 3 battles in succession. For the first gym, this is passable, but for what's intended to be the 6th gym???? Seriously??? (Tbf the dancing Greavard was damned cute)
- The world's slowest quick time event challenge that drags on for far too long
- The world's easiest slalom minigame
The disrespect to Gen One is insane. Acting like the fact that it's barebones doesn't have to do with that it came out on the original Gameboy almost 30 years ago
Just going to abandon the spark that caught the imagination of an entire generation to call it a "sub par RPG"
Seriousy, it created a blueprint where there wasn't one before. It was unique for its time, and the later games are obligated to improve on the original to justify existing. Really crazy take by the presidents, probably the worst I have ever seen.
Facts
@@daqueda1577okay but you said it yourself, the later games improved on it. Go back and actually play pokemon red and compare that to B/W or platinum. It’s not contest other than the kanto pokemon are by far the most iconic.
@@digitaldarmanitan3072 Read my comment again. The sequels had to improve on the originals to JUSTIFY EXISTING. Some of them are not improvements, and should not exist. The originals are top 3, because its way harder to design an entire genre then be one of a dozen incremental updates.
Despite starting it all the original games are awful now. Nobody is emulating that shit
Love to see some Pokemon content! Most of it was spot on for the placements, though I'd say that Area Zero was a peak area for Scarlet and Violet, so I was surprised to not see it mentioned.
Seeing this new video gives me some motivation to finish my own tier list. I need to pick up my pace :)!
Wow. I just learned Ash became a Pokémon master. I had given up. It’s been so long. I was a baby when he started and now I have patches of grey hair. I’m so proud 🥹
These are getting so good. I could honestly listen to them talk about anything at this point.
I'll be honest I personally don't mind how the EXP Share worked in X/Y mainly cause it made grinding less annoying
True and super training made it so EV training wouldn't be so much of a chore instead of farming 100s of low level mons
Love seeing our Man George coming in. I am going to attempt to building a AI video myself for different characters. If you have any advice, i’ll gladly take it, because you are GOATED at this. Take care man, and hope you are well!
I think the thing I've seen people appreciate the most in my videos is the genuine analysis mixed with jokes. Try to find the balance.
Don't get too caught up making things as edgy and having the characters, whoever you're using, insult each other back and forth distracting from the content.
Thank you for the super thanks and good luck. 👍
No Pokémon Colosseum or XD?! These presidents have surely failed this country.
Happy to see Discord be integrated into the videos some more and I'd love to see more videos about different games you like.
You can absolutely catch Growlithe in the wild in Crystal. They even made it available earlier (grass west of Violet) so you can use it against Bugsy. Vulpix was kept Silver exclusive tho
That's my B
@@primeradiancyi look forward to ju on the grudge films and game rank list 👍👍
No prob thanks for the entertaining vids dude 🤙
Yeah im honestly surpriseed how easily it was damned to F teir like what about the other stuff it improved from gold and silver?
I actually had tons of fun with scarlet and violet. The most fun I’ve had with pokemon since probably gen 5
same here, too bad that the 4th storyline with area zero wasnt included in the discussion. still its true that their problems are hard to ignore. im sooo torn when it comes to SV
I did too, but the games are still way way too easy and that’s a problem.
My zigga I was just binge watching the presidents nuzlocke sapphire playthrough when the algorithm gods decided to hit me with another banger. Let's gooooo! Diamond and Pearl gang represent.
Please more Mass Effect! And the lets play doesnt have to be longform im okay with plenty of cuts to get to the good stuff
Honestly, I think Scarlet and Violet got waaaaay too much hate here. I might be biased, but it's the most fun i had playing a Pokemon in YEARS. Area Zero, while only an hour or two at the end, is probably the best bit of story we've ever gotten in a Pokemon Game. Nemona is the friendly rival archetype done right. Penny and Arven are fun and likeable characters.
I feel like it really should be an S-Tier, but the technical issues drag it down to B for me. Fun as it is, and as cool as many of the ideas and concepts were, they sadly dropped the ball in several areas technologically. Scarlet and Violet is, hopefully, a step in the right direction from a narrative and character perspective. But they need to fix the technical issues and introduce more of a challenge to the game.
Side note: I'd love if you ranked some of the spin-off titles at some point. I'd LOVE to see the takes given to the Mystery Dungeon titles.
You're videos are too good, you are the best that made this videos of the president. By the way do you play Persona? because i would love a video about the president about Persona
Love the mass effect content but would love to see more video game franchise tier lists with the boys in the future!
A like and a comment for the algorithm. All the best for the best AI president youtube videos!
idk why these videos help me a lot getting away from all the crazyness. thank you
Insane take on X/Y. Mega Evolution was a legitimately amazing mechanic with serious depth that they should hae continued throughout the series rather than invent new gimicks. Not to mention the beautiful 3D model work, new fairy typing, the addition of player customization beyond starting gender, a bonus starter pokemon in the Gen 1 starters, XP share that doesn't suck, a way to boost EVs without grinding wild pokemon, etc.
Yeah the game is easy, and that's unfortunate, but it's useful for there to be a couple easy games in the series to appeal to players of all skill level. X/Y is the perfect game for players to get into Nuzlocking.
The only bad thing about X/Y is boring Team Flare. Everything else is goated. Easy A tier or S tier.
Edit: because everyone always says that everyone's favorite pokemon game is the one they started with, I feel the need to make it clear that my first pokemon game was Sapphire.
100% agreed, X and Y are what got me into pokemon games in general, and its still by far my favorite of the series. Really wish they kept up the mega evolution mechanics rather than the lazy gimmicks they keep going for like 'make pokemon huge'
Then you have no excuse being this wrong
I completely disagree. X and Y had absolutely zero depth or content. Megas were great and I liked some of the lore.
agree for mega evolution, but the game doesn't even use them until the champion and it's an easy sweep, not to mention some clear balancing issues they never addressed. It's still by far the best gimmick and clears all the others but it's not perfect either. the """"""beautiful"""""" 3d models look like lifeless husks that got their souls sucked up from them at the same time as their bright and beautiful colors when going into the washing machine, and the fact that they're still using those ass models in 2024 makes me hate them even more. Fairy typing is great but new types have been introduced before and we'll probably get new ones in the future, it wasn't an arguments for the other games so it's not here either. Player customisation is great and it was taken into consideration in the tier list, but it's the sidest side content if the customisation is the ultimate greatest addition might as well play movie star planet instead. More useless gen 1 pandering making the easy game even easier isn't an argument for S tier. While XP share not being mandatory was better than having forced on the player it's still the reason we have it now, exp share that didn't suck was back when it was an item, If they wanted it to be easier to access for the whole team they could've easilly handed multiple copies of it throuhought the game with side quests or main quest story bits, way more apealling that having the easy way out ready from the get go. And i agree with the last point. The game isn't deserving D tier or lower for sure but it's far from an A tier S even less. Maybe if it had gotten the 3rd Z version everyone was waiting for to fix some of the issues and lack of postgame, maybe then the game could've gotten this high. But as it is now it's fine in mid C or B tier
I liked it at the time, but you only ever fight two mega pokemon in the whole game, which speaks to larger problem in the game being way too easy. E4 members having 4 pokemon each? To go from B/W difficulty to X/Y difficulty was such a let down despite how cool megas are.
Watched all your vids so far on ai content, finslly subbed lol
The one good thing sword and shield that was expanded upon was the character customization plus that banger gym music. Dynamax adventures was great cause i got my shiny lunala after 100 tries.
Other than technical issues gen 9 was great, school was underutilized sure but then we got area zero and its beautiful music.
Gen 2 and 3 are still my favorite, secret bases are awesome.
Damn, how’d they forget about coliseum and XD gale of darkness
0:00 intro
0:47 Pokémon Red and blue
3:04 Pokémon Yellow
4:24 Pokémon Gold and silver
6:20 Pokémon Crystal
7:07 Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire
8:32 Pokémon Emerald
10:24 Pokémon fire red and leaf green
12:00 Pokémon diamond and pearl
14:45 Pokémon platinum
15:35 Pokémon heart gold and soul silver
16:51 Pokémon Black and White
19:15 Pokémon black 2 and white 2
20:40 Pokémon X and Y
22:45 Pokémon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire
24:40 Pokémon Sun and moon
26:24 Pokémon ultra sun and ultra moon
27:34 Pokémon let's go Pikachu and let's go Eevee
29:09 Pokémon sword and shield
31:24 Pokémon brilliant diamond and shining pearl
32:28 Pokémon legends Arceus
35:58 Pokémon scarlet and violet
36:57 Outro
Playing through Arceus currently probably my favorite way to go through gen 4 hisui is great and it’s just a different type of game in a l lot of respects
Pretty insightful. I always thought the later gen games were pretty easy. No need for dark souls hard but maybe a level below that? Curious about what gen 10 will be like.
Pokémon spin-offs or starter tier list next?
never mind just got to the end lol
Please post a tier list about the Pokemon starters next.
That's actually fully scripted already, you can expect it within the month.
Not even gonna mention the GOATed Pokemon Colosseum?
The craziest thing about Pokemon is that any video covering the series will require at least eight minutes of watchtime before you discover that the author is a gen 3 fanboy
Here's my take on Sun & Moon and USUM; mainly the villains:
Lusamine & Guzma were easily one of the best evil team leaders at that point in time of their debut.
Lusamine had lost her husband when they traveled in Ultra Space, got her mind infected by Nihilego which made her so obsessed that she even tried forcibly dressing up Lillie like Nihilego itself, and even abused her own children so badly (namely Lillie), that they abandoned her to loneliness. She even cryogenically froze Pokemon that she once told in stories to her children while also trying to get even closer to Nihilego. She effectively gave me every reason to wanna beat her considering that Ultra Wormholes were also appearing all over Alola.
And then when the Ultra games came along, they sorta kinda make her look like a good guy despite having still abused her own kids in the past and just got away with it. Not only does this make no sense, but it also ruins Lillie and Gladion's character growth. They pretty much go from "I'm gonna stop my psychotic mother from destroying the region" to "I want to stop my mom from saving the region because I don't want to lose my Pokemon." Lusamine also ended up being a background character once the main conflict was over.
This is why the Rainbow Rocket Episode should've been the main story of the whole games (considering Game Freak clearly had a massive hard-on for Kanto throughout the story).
Considering Giovanni mentioned using Nihilego's poison to mind-control Lusamine, they could've made it where she was their puppet and that she is a sweet/loving mother, which would then tips Lillie and Gladion off to something not feeling right. Team Skull could be used as their front to stop you while the Ultra Recon Squad is trying to warn you to the problems as Rainbow Rocket is after Necrozma and are trying to use it for their own gain, but Team Skull would interrupt conversations to prevent you from knowing the truth.
...Or something like this.
I feel like USUM also did some good with Ultra Necrozma, if you weren’t prepared for it you were F U C K E D
All those comments about X and Y and then they decide to have fun at the pokemon direct today. What great timing boys.
Bruh, they ignored the fact that Scarlet/ Violet's music is one of the best things about the games, they were composed by Toby Fox, plus they were playing Penny's theme in the background, an incredibly catchy song, my favorites are definitely the Tera Raid theme, Penny, and Turo/ Sada
Also the goated characters in the goddamn Game holy hell
Frankly I appreciate having W. in the chat, just because 4 seems like a better number than 3
I've seen some other President's Pokémon tier lists, and this is definitely one of the better ones. Easily the most well-articulated. I'd personally put BW and FRLG in A tier and I thought putting Yellow and Crystal in F was a bit harsh despite your valid criticisms, but since Emerald, Platinum, and HGSS were put in S where they belong, I'm okay with it.
The utter disrepect of gen 1 is dosheartening
It's not wrong though lol. Everytime i hear someone say gen 1 was the best generation, i know that person is either a liar, or havent played those games in 20 years. Those games aged like sour fucking milk lol
@clouds2589 hey that's the best sour milk ever I love that generation best starters period
@@garycannon4644 You can like the starters and still recognize how horribly buggy and shit the game was.
@clouds2589 those bugs made it better lol
@@clouds2589 just so you know I will die on this hill lol
Surprised you didn’t include the DLC expansions for the Switch games as a “third” game and separate on the tier lists. They’re pretty big and are a nice improvement by replacing the third game.
Scarlet and Violet DLC is really good lol
We definitely wanna see a president pokemon battle
In terms of Fun Gen 1 is undefeated there are so many cool glitches in that game to do like, missingno, Beating the game in 0 seconds, Battling Professor Oak and finding all sorts of Scrapped glitched Gen 2 pokemon, the mew glitch, getting any pokemon in the game before the second gym etc
I see you with the Driftveil City
People always talk about how Cythia was so difficult.
Young me played Ruby first and did not know what he was doing. Killed Groudon because he figured he would catch one later. Best mon was a Vulpix (didn't have a fire stone) and it used fire spin, will o wisp, iron tail, and flamethrower. After the forge that was beating the Elite 4 under those conditions, Diamond was a breeze as was everything since.
Fire Red is my personal favorite. It was my first and funnily enough i played it on an emulator.
Best part of my day just hit
I can't argue with the rankings. In fact, the points the boys touched on simply reminded me that the most fun I had with the games was Pokemon Stadium back on the N64.
I do like the later gen version on the xo share since one of my biggest gripes with the older games was the grind. I'd catch a new pokemon that felt interesting but I couldn't use them because their lvl was way too low.
I can Holly hell one of reasons I hate old gen lovers are cuz they are so annoying
The thing I don't understand is this: if something ceases to appeal to you, why do you continue to check out every new iteration when nothing changes? I was a massive Pokémon fan as a youngster but I steadily began to lose interest following Gen IV. Eventually after X and Y I just stopped buying the games because I understood they weren't really "for me" anymore. I picked up Sun and Moon years later for something like 5 dollars and like Trump, couldn't get past the long-ass tutorial. Then I tried Arceus, and while yeah it's nice to see them finally do something new after 30 years, the bland openworld, AI-generated story and lack of personally interesting 'Mons solidified to me that I'm just not a fan of Pokémon anymore, and that's okay. I go back and play romhacks of the good games, I've played through GSC/RSE/DPPt more times than I can count, and I have two originally-issued massive Pokémon: The Movie and The Movie: 2000 posters in my apartment. But all that stuff will always be there. This is the most financially successful video game IP of all time but no one seems to be happy lol. If Trump's little spiel at the end was cathartic for you, I'd bring that same energy for the next game GF releases, and either don't buy it or just pirate it.
In the old games that they played I tried to distribute the HMS equally
To be fair, Cynthia was scariest in Pokemon Black/White when you wandered into the wrong house on the wrong season and she refuses to let you leave without a thorough spanking. Her team was bordering lvl 80
This channel gets better and better.
Gen 1 paved the way for all the others. All 3 are absolute S tier. They built a formula where there wasn't one. Of course the others should be improvements, there's no excuse not to be, yet some of them still failed.
Curious will you rank the pmd games as well?
Video dropped 1 hour ago and it's automatically goated
Megas should have been limited to two stage evolutions. There should also only have been one mega stone. Make it so you had to be really careful with who gets the mega. Takes up a slot and its held item
So this is the video that Donald and Joe switched with Smash and Pass tier list?
i wouldnt touch any old game that was considered a masterpiece cause nothing old ages well for me, but ya gotta rate them as how great they were back then at the time. gen 1 was like S tier shit back then i loved it
Idk man, playign them today, Emerald is still good, hell it's still better than most modern games.
Gens 1 and 2 not so much.
Don gets a standing ovation for that SV rant 👏
This is sooo well done.
It made me so happy hearing them all agree that Pokemon Emerald is S Tier.
Truth! I still play it to this day and I have a smile on my face the entire game.
I victory-punched my damned cabinet while washing dishes
The disrespect to Kanto is insane Gen 1 remake is good and deserves A everything doesn't need to be more sometimes simple and little things are better like how Daredevil show isn't about saving the world and the stakes are low yet it's far better than anything in MCU.
Gotta say, it's a perfect tier list ranking. 👍
Champions and rivals teir list next for Pokémon?
Now we're talking
Idea: tierlist for the different Mass Effect soundtracks
“ How is that the two game stat needed it most didn’t get a third version” heh wonder if we’ll get a ZA play though.
Rank gyms next after starters. Please
Not a minute in and bush being sus. I thought that would be joe.
Fun video.
Ghetsis’s Hydreigon is Level 54, not 62
Gen 6 is my favorite generation but it dropped the ball on a great concept and evil team.
The fact I watched this in its entirety is wild
Gen 1 deserves our respect, and Yellow allows the opportunity to not only start out with Pikachu, but to get the original 3 starters as well, just like Ash did! Are there improvements that could/would be made? Of course, but much of it was already perfection. We don't need 1,025 Pokemon. How many generic birds/fish do I have to try and memorize now? How many beauty contests do I have to enter before I can just play the core game? It was a simpler time; We played RBY and then pushed a hoop with a stick down a dirt road.
Hey, I know most people don't consider them mainline but I really think you missed out on ranking Pokemon Colosseum and XD gale of darkness, personally I believe they Didi 3D right and had a lot of good and fresh stuff to bring to the table, and are worthy pokemon games, it's really a shame most people don't know about them
The boys come back with a slammer
I can’t believe of all people, Joe Biden Hates the ice cream Pokemon
George: "Cynthia made these games iconic. If you don't fear her, then you're just too young to understand what we went through back in 2006."
*Me who absolutely smoked Cynthia on the very first try back in 2006 on Pokemon Pearl, then did it again on Platinum.*
Yeah, that sounds like a skill issue homie.
This is going to be interesting.