How BIG did SWORDS get?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 23. 12. 2022
  • Jason Kingsley, the Modern Knight, chooses three very different medieval swords and discusses what they are like to use and their advantages and disadvantages. #historyfacts #history #medieval
    Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @modernknight
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 913

  • @Tennouseijin
    @Tennouseijin Před rokem +149

    I imagine the greatsword would also be quite useful against windmills, should you choose to fight them on foot.

  • @YouTubalcaine
    @YouTubalcaine Před rokem +533

    The greatsword is an intimidating weapon all by itself, but it's absolutely terrifying when you're confronted by someone who knows how to use it. It's a lot faster than you'd think a blade that large would be. If you need to hold a lot of ground with few men, that's a pretty effective way to do it.

    • @NemeanLion-
      @NemeanLion- Před rokem +8

      Just looking at it’s unusually long handle, I wonder if it’s swung in a chopping motion like a long axe. I’d be curious to see a demonstration.

    • @sabotage9926
      @sabotage9926 Před rokem +19

      @@NemeanLion- in a lot of movements, the top hand is usually used as a sort-of hinge, thus adding to it's swiftness

    • @imperialus1
      @imperialus1 Před rokem +44

      @@NemeanLion- Not really axe like... Not really like any other weapon though... The greatsword is... weird. We don't have a ton of primary sources regarding their use, but there is one treatise by a Spaniard named Figueiredo that focus' on Spanish Montante (which was just the Spanish name) while Alfieri is one of the better Italian sources for Spadone (again Italian name). Both of them mostly focused around the sword's utility as a bodyguard weapon, which speaks to YouTubalcaine's point where he suggested holding ground against a group. Even the names of the forms given by Alfieri are phrases like "Guarding the Bridge" "Defending the Lady" ect. There is basically zero evidence that the sword ever saw use as a battlefield weapon in either of those regions though.
      That said, it's the Italians and Spaniards are only half the story, and probably the less well known one. In the German states of course it was popularized by the Landsknechts, which is where most of the mythology about the weapon seems to come from. Ideas about using it to chop up pike formations, or sever the heads of horses and all sorts of stuff like that, most of which is likely nonsense. What is particularly interesting, is that given its role as a battlefield weapon; and quite a prominent one at that (given its frequent depictions in period art) there are zero treatise's regarding its use as such. You certainly could not use it the way that any of the Italian or Spanish masters instructed, you'd be more of a hazard to your own formation than the enemy.
      Oh, and if you were interested in seeing a demonstration. These folks put on a pretty good one: czcams.com/video/vxHaNRO705k/video.html My one nitpick is that they call it Montante, but they are showing Alfieri's techniques so Spadone would be more accurate.

    • @felixlavulpe3506
      @felixlavulpe3506 Před rokem +7

      @@NemeanLion- Look up Montante on youtube, lots of wide horizontal sweeps.

    • @felixlavulpe3506
      @felixlavulpe3506 Před rokem +18

      I can't find anyone willing to spar against a steel one, but I've used a heavy foam flamberge for a few years at various Larps. Once you learn the patterns it's wickedly fast, makes a great deal of noise flying through the air, and everyone tends to give you a lot of space and are very hesitant to get close. I've been told it's unsettling seeing something that big move around like that, people expect it to be big and clunky like in the games and movies not constantly in motion and covering a lot of ground. Even with the foam one (which weighs 3 lbs, not even half the real ones) you still need to pull your swings at the end or you will bust fingers or beat people up pretty bad just due to the momentum and weight distribution. Getting hit with a sharp one at speed would do some absolutely horrific damage to someone. I'd assume the impact is comparable to a polearm, and considering the poleaxe and spear I've done through HEMA/SCA, I wouldn't want to face that without my plate on.

  • @jamesanderson6769
    @jamesanderson6769 Před rokem +490

    I always get excited when you post a new video, and this one didn't disappoint. That sword is a beast. It is borderline anime fantasy at that size.

    • @Darkdaej
      @Darkdaej Před rokem +23

      I was predicting that last sword would be a Zweihander and I wasn't disappointed :P

    • @joebauers3746
      @joebauers3746 Před rokem +7

      Who is the maker of that first sword?

    • @TirionLan
      @TirionLan Před rokem +7

      You can always see when people really love what they're doing

    • @MikeIsCannonFodder
      @MikeIsCannonFodder Před rokem +1

      All it's missing is a sheet of plywood!

  • @omegaflameZ
    @omegaflameZ Před rokem +69

    If designed for fending off street thugs or highwaymen I can imagine the whole 'pose and kick' thing would certainly make some folks think twice before trying their luck against an opponent wielding that beast, even if it does seem a little 'over the top' in a modern context.

    • @eldorados_lost_searcher
      @eldorados_lost_searcher Před rokem +10

      I saw a guy going through the movements with a montante. I certainly wouldn't want to try my chances against that blender blade.

    • @cocodojo
      @cocodojo Před rokem +5

      The reach of such a monster blade compared to probably knives and shorter arming swords compared to that would give most highwaymen a lot of pause, they'd have to get close to the wielder to have any chance of hurting them, but the wielder's range is easily twice their own... yeah, nobody's going to want to be that first couple of fools to get cut down. Its just not worth it if you're trying to rob someone.

    • @johan8969
      @johan8969 Před rokem +9

      Thought the same. Its pure posturing to tell any street thug that they would risk their live for a few coins. And it probably worked 95% of the time.

    • @ori-yorudan
      @ori-yorudan Před rokem +1

      If I was a highwayman with a long knife, looking to hold someone up over a few small personal effects, and their personal guard pulled out a sword taller then me... I'd just fuck right off.

  • @sensuscommunis2526
    @sensuscommunis2526 Před rokem +40

    There's a nice scene in the Polish movie "Ogniem i mieczem" ("By/With fire and sword") where one the characters uses a great sword to hold off a bunch of Tatars. Despite being outnumbered one to couple dozens, his wide swings make them hesitant to even go closer, but they eventually kill him with bows & arrows.

    • @minerwaweasley1008
      @minerwaweasley1008 Před rokem +1

      Lord Longin Podbipieta has exactly such a sword.

    • @hartmutwrith3134
      @hartmutwrith3134 Před rokem +1

      it is a movie. Not proper research.

    • @sensuscommunis2526
      @sensuscommunis2526 Před rokem +15

      @@hartmutwrith3134 Sure, nobody said it's a historical source. But it's way better than modern Hollywood crap.

    • @danisyx5804
      @danisyx5804 Před rokem +1

      "you need a bow to kill a dragon"

    • @minerwaweasley1008
      @minerwaweasley1008 Před rokem +1

      @@danisyx5804 He was not a dragon, he was a human siege engine 😄 Big guy, incredible strength, and that huge sword...

  • @tomwhitehurst1333
    @tomwhitehurst1333 Před rokem +62

    I had read about the landsknecht in some of my history and weapon books and I always thought they looked just brilliant, such a cavalier attitude and a huge sword to go with it. I really did not expect you to bring that sword into this video. Thanks for the video and I hope you enjoy your christmas.

  • @derpy9306
    @derpy9306 Před rokem +80

    4:19 , I believe that the reasson some people didn't wear protection below their waist might be because they noticed and realized that attacks on their legs are very rare in an actual combat. As spanish and italian masters in later periods disovered and explained - you need to expose yourself quite a lot before you start to reach the opponents legs, due to trigonometry and geometry in general. Anyhow, a great video full of enthusiasm and pure enjoyement of history! Well done!

    • @lilgary9181
      @lilgary9181 Před rokem +2

      This is true to an extent. Jason is correct in the video, it is more situational. Understanding what your opponents had is huge in any battle through time. If you're opponents didn't have much longer weapons Spears and such then it made sense not to have armor on the lower extremities which would slow your units down and not be as mobile. They may have had a special unit of soldiers with more armor ready for longer reach weapons.

    • @mistersharpe4375
      @mistersharpe4375 Před rokem +9

      @@lilgary9181 I'd assume leg armour is more important to a horseman, as they would be exposed to any man on the ground. Outside of that context, armour made for the legs is almost non existent throughout history. The greek hoplites wore bronze greaves, but apparently even that wasn't universal.

    • @heygek2769
      @heygek2769 Před rokem +4

      @@mistersharpe4375 Achilles came to regret that.

    • @HUVideoer
      @HUVideoer Před rokem +1

      @@mistersharpe4375 the heavy leather boots of horsemen in the napoleonic wars did protect against saber cuts to some degree

    • @alexandreboureau6175
      @alexandreboureau6175 Před rokem +1

      It depends a lot on the other factors. I did some sword and (heater) shield fighting, and the legs get hit a lot. I doubt they get hit as often with the huge scutums of the Roman legions, though, but leg armor was also common among hoplites.

  • @renesauceda1885
    @renesauceda1885 Před rokem +140

    I admire your dedication, Jason. Keep up with this masterpiece of a channel. Have a merry Christmas.

  • @kooroshrostami27
    @kooroshrostami27 Před rokem +3

    Always a pleasure when our noble friends across the North Sea try to pronounce the word *Landsknecht* and it comes out as 'Landsschneckt' each an every time without failure. Sounds hilarious to the German ear, thanks for the giggles.

    • @ModernKnight
      @ModernKnight  Před rokem

      Us English have a long history of mispronouncing the words of others.

  • @shadowofhawk55
    @shadowofhawk55 Před rokem +25

    “A Light in the Darkness” I love that name so much.

    • @Immopimmo
      @Immopimmo Před rokem +6

      Same as Joshua Graham's custom 1911.

  • @Cinnder
    @Cinnder Před rokem +12

    I love the delight that shows in your demeanour when talking about these swords and look fwd to seeing what you are able to learn about using the greatsword. I have very rough versions of each of these varieties, but I don't know much about actual technique.

  • @fuferito
    @fuferito Před rokem +45

    Seeing -Elessar- Jason speak about swords was not only more entertaining than watching a _certain_ recent Amazon series, I watched this from beginning to end, instead of skipping it altogether.

  • @gaelan2393
    @gaelan2393 Před rokem +12

    I mean, if i saw somebody posing with a sword as long as i am tall and grinning i probably wouldn't fight him in the first place, so that has to have been an effective stance.

  • @Maverick87878
    @Maverick87878 Před rokem +54

    Sir, what a stunning set of garments. Its certainly pleasing to watch. Keep up the good work and being an example to others!

  • @JoseLuis-rj9kq
    @JoseLuis-rj9kq Před rokem +2

    The last one resembles the one Rutger Hauer uses in "Ladyhawke". A beauty, indeed.

  • @LynneFarr
    @LynneFarr Před rokem +10

    Just watched the video again. Facinating how different historical Medieval swords really are. Glad to have those differences explained.

  • @Sharon-bo2se
    @Sharon-bo2se Před rokem +17

    Love your enthusiasm and what you teach us. Happy Christmas to you, the horses, and everyone else.

  • @RichyJFilms
    @RichyJFilms Před rokem +10

    woohoo a sharp cut video today LOVE IT - merry christmas jason

  • @-PRPLEHZE-
    @-PRPLEHZE- Před rokem +6

    Ah thank you so much, you have made Christmas Eve so much better

  • @andakin117
    @andakin117 Před rokem +16

    I would really love to see more about great swords and their uses in the future. You have a very nice collection my friend.

  • @Crustdaddii
    @Crustdaddii Před rokem +9

    I love that you post videos about these topics and that you film these in a natural environment! It really puts your imagination into perspective when you do not live in those areas. Thank you!

  • @luxste
    @luxste Před rokem +10

    Your enthusiasm is contagious! You are a delightfully wonderful teacher. Thank you so much for making history so interesting and exciting!

  • @Silencyde
    @Silencyde Před rokem +4

    The sheer amount of knowledge Jason has of the Medieval era, I would kill for a medieval game from his company.

  • @DaraEhteshamzadeh
    @DaraEhteshamzadeh Před rokem +7

    You see European depictions of knights using swords and other weapons two-handed on horseback, and Chinese and Indo-Persian lance techniques include two handed lance use. It would be cool to see a demonstration of the pros and cons of such techniques.

  • @vivianevans8323
    @vivianevans8323 Před rokem +72

    Yay! An unexpected video - like an extra Christmas gift! Thank you, Sir Knight.
    As for using that breathtaking huge sword you showed last - might I suggest an invitation to Matt Easton who'd be happy, I'm sure, to give you some tips - perhaps in exchange you could give him some riding lessons?
    A Merry Christmas to you and yours - and to all your wonderful horses, especially Warlord, Tales, Gossamer, Ghost, Mr Dibbs and Bramble. And Muley!
    And a Merry Christmas to all comment posters here!

    • @nubzors
      @nubzors Před rokem +4

      A collab with Schola Gladiatoria (Matt Easton) is exactly what I was thinking too. I really hope Jason reaches out to him, since even though Easton is primarily a Sabre specialist, he has trained with all sorts of other weaponry (including the Zweihänder, which there are videos of him using), is well versed in all the medieval and renaissance fight manuals/techniques, and knows a lot of other UK based HEMA people too.

    • @vivianevans8323
      @vivianevans8323 Před rokem +4

      @@nubzors Exactly! And since Jason got Lindybeige to sit on a horse I'm sure he can do the same for Matt! (I would pay to see that ...)

    • @manatoa1
      @manatoa1 Před rokem +2

      I think the guy from London Longsword is a big montante fan.

    • @nutyyyy
      @nutyyyy Před rokem

      ​@@manatoa1Mr Rawlings would be a good guest.

  • @Doesnotexisttoyou
    @Doesnotexisttoyou Před rokem +28

    Who made your arming sword? She’s an absolute beauty.

    • @ModernKnight
      @ModernKnight  Před rokem +25

      St George Armouries

    • @deejayk5939
      @deejayk5939 Před rokem +1

      Don’t chop your head off! Be careful and have a Happy New Year!

  • @vukjovanovicofficial
    @vukjovanovicofficial Před rokem +20

    Absolutely fantastic video Jason! Those swords all look absolutely stunning! Amazing channel!

  • @Helxas
    @Helxas Před rokem +6

    8:00 Funny that you brought that up - There's a passage from Froissart that describes a sword being used as a lance!
    "It happend in the midst of the general pursuit, that a squire from Picardy, named Jean de Helennes, had quitted the king's division and meeting his page with a fresh horse, had mounted and made off as fast as he could. There was near him at the time the Lord of Berkeley, a young knight who had that day for the first time displayed his banner, and he immediately set off in pursuit of him. *When the Lord of Berkley had followed for some time Jean de Helennes turned about, put his sword under his arm in the manner of a lance and thus advanced upon his adversary.* "
    Certainly an unorthodox thing to do, but not outside the realms of history.

    • @Your-Least-Favorite-Stranger
      @Your-Least-Favorite-Stranger Před rokem

      Laziness is the mother of invention, but necessity is the mother of innovation.
      If you find yourself need: adapt, innovate, and make due.

  • @svan4748
    @svan4748 Před rokem +10

    It's mind-blowing how well made these videos are. You give us so many insights and perspectives. Much love!

  • @DigitallyTwistedOutlaws1178

    Got to love those massive swords! Awesome explanation and thank you for the extra bit about the men who wielded the Zweihander!

  • @kalgrave497
    @kalgrave497 Před rokem +8

    out of all weapons in history, i think the Great sword is probably my favorite. The Sheer size and power of the thing is just memorizing. I have a cold steel Zweihander that is fun to hack at stuff, yours is truly gorgeous i look forward to more videos of it !

  • @Grace-bx1eg
    @Grace-bx1eg Před rokem +3

    The absolute glee on your face when talking about the greatsword is brighter than the evening sun! You picked a lovely place to film for this, with the woods and sunset behind you. Thank you for such a fun video, I hope your fields are dry and horses happy over the next few months of wet weather.

    • @ModernKnight
      @ModernKnight  Před rokem +2

      Thanks, the fields are very muddy, the sky grey and dull, drizzle is falling, but there are still adventures to be had if you try!

  • @navneetchahal6928
    @navneetchahal6928 Před rokem +41

    Remember to have lots of strength, vitality, and endurance before handling. Furthermore having rings/talismans that increase your equip load also help make the weapon more manageable, also don't be afraid to use something that increases your stats but causes you to take more damage, if you do more damage it doesn't matter if you take a little more.

  • @WATCH0YOUR0MUMMER
    @WATCH0YOUR0MUMMER Před rokem +4

    I always find your videos informative but also very comforting,
    Have a wonderful Christmas

  • @LeannanSC
    @LeannanSC Před rokem +2

    Now this is the content I want in my stocking for Christmas morning! Merry Christmas from New Zealand, love watching your videos

  • @maylisthevenot4518
    @maylisthevenot4518 Před rokem +1

    I love your smile, when you come in front of the camera with the last sword 😁 Just like a little boy showing his favorite toy on Christmas day ! And what a toy !!

  • @ionacjohnj.59
    @ionacjohnj.59 Před rokem +3

    I really like your channel. Because it says not just weapons. Not just technics. Not just life style. Not just history. It says everything! Well done 👍 Thanks for sharing your experience and knowledge with us!

  • @caniconcananas7687
    @caniconcananas7687 Před rokem +23

    Merry Christmas to all Christian knights, squires, friars, peasants, foresters, smiths and millers.
    Time ago I saw on some book an example of the first sword in a painting from the Renaissance. I thought that the painter was not realist because of the triangular shape of the blade, with such a broad start and such a pointy end. But after watching this one I have changed my mind. ⚠▶🔺

    • @janetmackinnon3411
      @janetmackinnon3411 Před rokem

      And the invisible women...

    • @caniconcananas7687
      @caniconcananas7687 Před rokem

      @@janetmackinnon3411 Peasants include men and women alike, all of them equally anonymous. Although I don't know about England, in other European kingdoms (in current Germany and Spain) there were millers that happened to be women.
      Also there were women well known in their time and still now. They were persons with power. Some of them were queens like Eleanor of Aquitaine, Caterina di Medici or Isabel of Castile, some of them were religious leaders founding orders and ruling over monasteries who were feudal grants. And a handful were not men of arms, but women of arms, from Jeanne d'Arc to Catalina de Erauso.
      But, believe me, the best thing to do if you were the daughter or wife of a small landowner was to be very very very invisible. Because a single or widow woman with some plot of cultivable land was the target of every unmarried man in her village. But...
      What if she didn't want to marry?
      SHE IS A WITCH !!! BURN (OR HANG) THE WITCH !!!
      (and let's seize her properties anyway).
      It happened thru all Europe and in New England until the 30 Years War. Except in Spain, where the Inquisition monopolized the religious violence and had no interest in the tiny lands of small landowners, as the Orders (Templars, Hospitallers, etc) and the monasteries and bishoprics had huge extensions of land.
      After the first "popular" witch hunting at Zugarramurdi, the Inquisition sent an enquirer that concluded that those poor women (and men) were not sorcerers, witches or even pagans at all. And it was the end in Spain of this kind of use of religion as a excuse to steal. Until the last civil war, when people killed their neighbours accusing them of being fascists or communists and stole their properties.
      Being poor is hard, but much more safe. 😉

    • @ozzy194870
      @ozzy194870 Před rokem

      Don't forget us heathens!

  • @coleshinkle3744
    @coleshinkle3744 Před rokem +1

    Every time a see a video pop up with you in the thumbnail it makes my day a little better. Great video as always, I love the decorated mail.

  • @nicknickson3650
    @nicknickson3650 Před rokem +10

    That arming sword is niiiiice. Really beautiful piece.

  • @robingray5037
    @robingray5037 Před rokem +3

    Thanks for the new video, Sir Knight. One of my favorite swords I had, as it was handy a couple of times for home defence, was an antenna palmal short sword.
    I miss the sword, but happy I live in what seems to be so far a much safer place.
    Whatever holiday you all celebrate(d) I hope it's (was) happy and may your new year be joyous and productive.

  • @antoinettehatchell2052
    @antoinettehatchell2052 Před rokem +4

    Merry Christmas !
    Wonderful video Jason! Hope see more videos soon. ❤

  • @Pewling
    @Pewling Před rokem +1

    Hope you had a lovely Christmas, Kingsley! Always entertained by your videos on this channel and excited to see a new one!

  • @Ser-Smiley
    @Ser-Smiley Před rokem +15

    New video yaay!
    Swords. I love swords!😋

  • @colmortimer1066
    @colmortimer1066 Před rokem +5

    I often think of great swords as more of polearms, since many of the techniques are more spear, or even bill/halberd like, but when swinging it around it is much more agile than most bladed polearms. Swords be them, arming, long sword, rapiers, sabers all have similar ways to use them. Cutting with a single edged sword is pretty much the same as a double edged sword, and if the blade is curved it will be easier but it does not take a lot to get used to. Thrusting is almost the same with any style. But a greatsword just seems to not fit the other classes of sword. It looks like a sword but using it is quite a bit different, compared to switching between other sword types.

  • @kathleenorr9237
    @kathleenorr9237 Před rokem +7

    Fantastic video! Greatsword was immense..know I’d hurt myself in 5 minutes near it!

  • @call_sign_Nomad
    @call_sign_Nomad Před rokem +1

    Thanks as always Jason, Sir. I'd love to see a video on different Warlances and how they were used on the battlefield.

  • @Frurin
    @Frurin Před rokem +1

    That is a great Christmas present from Sir Jason :).
    I love how merry he is holding his swords, like a kid who is showing his toys, but in earnest, not in spite.

  • @RevanR
    @RevanR Před rokem +11

    I like sword

  • @andrewblair8725
    @andrewblair8725 Před rokem +8

    Jason is living the dream of every man in England

  • @Knirtsgafasl
    @Knirtsgafasl Před rokem +10

    The greatsword has several different names in german, one of them is "Gassenhauer" wich loosely transaltes to "ally chopper" since it only takes one skilled Doppelsöldner wielding such a huge sword to completely cover a whole narrow street.

    • @hartmutwrith3134
      @hartmutwrith3134 Před rokem

      That Gassenhauer term descent from 16th. cent. music only. ("Laut durch die Gassen musizieren/rumgröhlen")It was connectet to swords by the 1850ies to 189oies. when Landsknecht stories where a fashion. The big battle sword after medival times was used against unarmed soldiers to block a road or a ship against may for a short time.

    • @OvermasterJ
      @OvermasterJ Před rokem

      Gassenhauer is a modern name and not rly historical. There are 3 Types of Greatswords. Spada a due mani (Spadone), Montante and in german: Schlachtschwert.

  • @MartinPurvis
    @MartinPurvis Před rokem +1

    Great video Jason! Always a bunch of work that goes into your videos

  • @tacticalchunder1207
    @tacticalchunder1207 Před rokem +6

    That arming sword is absolutely beautiful!

  • @AkademietHistorie
    @AkademietHistorie Před rokem +28

    One thing of note is how much pointier these real swords are compared to a typical Hollywood prop sword. It's for safety reasons; they don't want the actors to wave around something really deadly, so you can't really blame the movie producers too much. They also can't very easily swap out props with "real" swords like they can do with guns, because while you can make a prop gun look real, it's very difficult to hide the fact that the prop sword actually has a very different tip compared to the real thing.

  • @Archangel144
    @Archangel144 Před rokem +2

    Merry Christmas! The most jarring thing for me when I first picked up a claymore was how much wobble you can get in that enormous blade. The examples I've held have tended to flex under their own weight when held horizontally with the flat down.

  • @Vurti0
    @Vurti0 Před rokem +1

    His enthusiasm is really contagious!

  • @knightshousegames
    @knightshousegames Před rokem +5

    You know, it's funny, when I was younger, when I'd see a sword like that greatsword and I'd be like "YEAH, gimmie that thing!"
    But I've noticed as I've gotten older, and actually gotten to hold and own real swords, that I've become more and more inclined to think if I could pick a sword for a battle, I'd rather just take an arming sword or a side sword and a buckler over a long sword or even a bastard sword, let alone a greatsword
    I've noticed that feels like the case with a lot of people I see online too, like graduating to the arming sword is almost like a right of passage, a perhaps a sign of maturity

  • @susiesturman8180
    @susiesturman8180 Před rokem +8

    I would enjoy knowing more about the Scottish claymore, which might have been used by some of my ancestors. Like the great sword, the claymore was huge.

  • @skylarkarchaeologicalsolut9852

    I really enjoy your content. Your horsemanship makes me envious. Please keep it up. Thank you.

  • @chimilla868
    @chimilla868 Před rokem +1

    I love love coming back to your channel!!

  • @danielduncan6806
    @danielduncan6806 Před rokem +3

    There was a spear fight in the movie 'Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon' that really opened up my eyes to just how effective a spear could be in the hands of someone skilled enough. When I see swords like the "great sword" I like to imagine it being used in the same fashion as that, because not only could the motions be beautiful, they would also be quite deadly. I like to picture someone swinging that sword in such a frenzy that their hands are actually positioned at the very bottom of the handle, swinging it in the widest arc possible, around and around, and at various heights, from head to toe, to fend off any would be attackers in a spectacular display of intimidation. Then quickly changing it up, moving the hands back to the hilt to actually attack those foolish enough to try to get close.

  • @APinchOfHistory
    @APinchOfHistory Před rokem +6

    I have to get some swords on my channel. Thanks! Merry Christmas Jason!

  • @mikemarthaller8789
    @mikemarthaller8789 Před rokem +1

    During my military time in Germany 1959-61. (Yes the time the wall went up) I often visited castles/Museums
    I was amazed by the variety of weaponry and reflected on its use. tactics and the evolution.
    Sitting in a German "Tavern" hundreds of years old, walls covered in old human skulls. Drinking wine or cognac makes for a reflective experience on humanity, wars and politics.
    This site does a great service in our attempts to understand the subtibly and nuances of history.
    I appreciate your willingness to reflect, and put things into a context of the time period in which they were used partly based on you own experiences using the tools and weapons.
    Peace and prosperity Through responsibilities

  • @manonanisland88
    @manonanisland88 Před rokem

    Definitely looking forward to seeing you rock that zweihander in future videos !

  • @LDub01031994
    @LDub01031994 Před rokem +14

    I can definitely see a big German fella from the Medieval period wielding that third sword haha. It's funny how the fight book has you taking a stance with some flair. It kind of reminds me of when you come across a boss in a video game!

    • @Vespuchian
      @Vespuchian Před rokem +5

      I recall reading somewhere that one of their common uses was by senior gate guards, so in addition to a couple of fellas with halberds or spears you had _that guy_ with his big hat, gleaming breastplate, and this stonking great sword _POSING_ at you unless you got past the other guards.
      Boss character indeed!

    • @triela420
      @triela420 Před rokem +3

      @@Vespuchian Yeah. I'd imagine it would be good for intimidation and I believe the techniques are somewhat geared towards "crowd control" against unarmored opponents.

    • @Kidneyjoe42
      @Kidneyjoe42 Před rokem +3

      @@triela420 I suspect the use by gate/bodyguards might also be a matter of versatility. It's got the reach of a short spear while still being threatening on its own in a tight scramble. Sort of like the secret service using P90s as a compromise between the power of a full size rifle and the compact handiness of a pistol.

    • @winifredryan8223
      @winifredryan8223 Před rokem

      Considering the dimensions of some urban streets, I could see hitting the adjacent walls and doing more damage to the blade than much else. I think I’m more in line with its use as a modified spear. Seems like a lot of use of metal to create more weapon for looking intimidating than functionality, but of course lots gets lost in time.

    • @CynicalOldDwarf
      @CynicalOldDwarf Před rokem +2

      @@Vespuchian And don't forget, the guy probably had a moustache and beard of epic proportions

  • @yellowdevil9650
    @yellowdevil9650 Před rokem +5

    Happy Holidays

  • @CesarIsaacPerez
    @CesarIsaacPerez Před rokem

    Love it. Can't wait to see what you show us next!

  • @MisterKisk
    @MisterKisk Před rokem +2

    You probably already know of him, but David Rawlings of the London Longsword Academy has some great stuff regarding swords like that montante.

  • @arnoldkotlyarevsky383
    @arnoldkotlyarevsky383 Před rokem +3

    One thing that strikes me about that greatsword, having handled something like it a number of years ago, is that you dont need to hold it just under the main quillions the way you would a normal sword. There is a lot of real estate on that handle and moving your hands around on it would help a ton with extending its already notable range and give you more spear like performance. Similarly, when approaching a nest of pikes, choking down on the handle and swinging wide can cut an enormous swath - knocking down or back the pikes. Very cool weapon.

  • @D0G5Coolpat11
    @D0G5Coolpat11 Před rokem +6

    I've learnt a lot from your videos, I'm glad I stumbled upon you over two years ago. Mid 2022 I showed my mother your channel and we watched you for hours. Thank you for your help in bringing me closer to my family :)

  • @MotivateYourMindOriginal

    I get so giddy when I get a pop-up notification for your videos! I love this kind of sword since I heard from Age of Empires that William Wallace had a sword like this. The Wallace Sword. Not sure how 100% accurate that is

  • @michaelwhite8031
    @michaelwhite8031 Před rokem +1

    Thank you for all the great info. Happy Christmas and new year to you and your family.

  • @LaneLibra
    @LaneLibra Před rokem +3

    Wonderful video as always! Merry Christmas! 🌲🎄

  • @100dfrost
    @100dfrost Před rokem +3

    Excellent video as always, thank-you.

  • @TheHardTake
    @TheHardTake Před rokem +1

    This is great. This is where I started watching you long ago. Really nice video.

  • @raphlvlogs271
    @raphlvlogs271 Před rokem +2

    the great sword can be a very handy weapon to use against bayonets if it stayed in used in to later periods where the soldiers using them can also carry pistols or other small firearms as secondary weapons

  • @troelsdc
    @troelsdc Před rokem +3

    Seeing the look of pure joy on your face when trying to describe the greatsword as something other than enormous is really telling. You really like swords, don't you? It's contagious. I love your videos!

  • @lingling5278
    @lingling5278 Před rokem +16

    Merry Christmas to you all 😊❄️🎄

  • @donnastewart-vega1673
    @donnastewart-vega1673 Před rokem +1

    Would love to see you trying it as a short lance.
    As always enjoyed your video. Thank you

  • @Papa_rossii
    @Papa_rossii Před rokem +1

    The excitement when a post from you comes is incredible. As said prior this didn't upset at all. Incredible that it doesn't weigh as much as it looks, when will we get a full LARP video? ;)

  • @belladonnabaggins3996
    @belladonnabaggins3996 Před rokem +3

    What a fun video on this festive eve 😊😊 Happy Holidays!

  • @DW-dd4iw
    @DW-dd4iw Před 11 měsíci +3

    Knight: "I see a tiny little swordsman on the battlefield to attack!"
    Squire: "Are you sure that's not a normal guy with a great sword?"

  • @OmegaPaladin144
    @OmegaPaladin144 Před rokem +1

    Happy Christmas to you, Sir Kingsley!

  • @JoshHCK
    @JoshHCK Před rokem

    wow I love the subtle gold ends to your mail, looks great!

  • @_ninthRing_
    @_ninthRing_ Před rokem +3

    From the limited reading I've done of the greatsword, they were incredibly useful in breaking the detente which often occured between fairly evenly matched groups of pikemen. An amazing, if less versatile, weapon which could be used to devastating effect.
    I suspect that the other two swords saw far more use over the years, but I can't help but wish to see how such a remarkable weapon would have been used by an expert swordsman.

  • @LynneFarr
    @LynneFarr Před rokem +20

    Really interesting comparison of swords. I suspect one additional aspect of your new Monster Sword is psychology. It must have been pretty scary for an enemy or a perp to see an opponent advancing swinging that weapon. Good video!

  • @professormetal4411
    @professormetal4411 Před rokem +1

    Montante Niño has a few great videos on greatswords and their use that I highly recommend to better understand them. One of them is called, "Cutting with large swords" and it's about 35 minutes long.
    Great video as always, fun to see you mess around with the greatsword!

  • @exploringallgenres
    @exploringallgenres Před rokem +1

    Love seeing the different types of weaponry used and some of your favorites. That last one is huge but I can certainly see it's potential in certain situations. I'm wondering if you have any recommendations for books about medieval weapons and armor, I'd love to read more about it all.

  • @user-eq8ww1gr6v
    @user-eq8ww1gr6v Před rokem +5

    I heard the magic word, "context, used in relation to swords and I'm suddenly looking to see if Captain Context, Scholagladitria is going to pop out from the brush behind you.🤣

    • @ModernKnight
      @ModernKnight  Před rokem +2

      lol

    • @user-eq8ww1gr6v
      @user-eq8ww1gr6v Před rokem

      @@ModernKnight ps what a great video to watch out enjoying the snowless landscape,meanwhile on the other side of the pond (Wisconsin, USA) we are in a blizzard.
      Cheers to you and yours this holiday weekend!!!

  • @minerwaweasley1008
    @minerwaweasley1008 Před rokem +6

    Excellent! Both the movie and the sword. The last one is really a monster, I remembered your Soul Calibur 2020 tournament, there were such gigantic weapons in action :) One of the Polish literary heroes Longin Podbipieta cut off three heads of enemies with such a sword with one swing.
    I strongly support the idea of collaborating with Matt Easton.
    Thanks for the Christmas gift and traditionally happy birthday - you keep the exact date a secret, but it is publicly known that they are somewhere in December :)

    • @sensuscommunis2526
      @sensuscommunis2526 Před rokem +1

      Seeing the great sword, I immediately thought of him and the scene from the movie where he holds off a bunch of Tatars with wide swings of his Zerwikaptur.

    • @minerwaweasley1008
      @minerwaweasley1008 Před rokem

      @@sensuscommunis2526 Yes, Lord Longin's Zerwikaptur was just such a two-handed sword. People laughed at it because it was a bit outdated in the 17th century - but it did a great job when needed.

  • @EmeraldVideosNL
    @EmeraldVideosNL Před rokem

    Shout-out for a video dedicated to the beautiful workmanship on that chainmail and belt with golden/brass(?) details. I might have missed it, but I don't recall Jason wearing a full chainmail shirt before, these items deserve being looked at in detail. Amazing!

  • @harrisonmcguire4235
    @harrisonmcguire4235 Před rokem +1

    This video is what I needed today! Thanks all

  • @magister.mortran
    @magister.mortran Před rokem +4

    I guess this last sword could do quite some damage to the horse of a mounted opponent. I think I saw pictures with that kind of sword used by Landsknechts during the 30-Years War.

  • @martialme84
    @martialme84 Před rokem +3

    I would absolutely love it if you could learn from the fight books and then make a video demonstrating what you learned. That should be fantastic, surely.
    Maybe Matt Easton could share in the workload so the task would be less daunting.

  • @llamabing5215
    @llamabing5215 Před rokem +1

    Sir, even without the tassels and the bat you do look fabulous with that pose at the end

  • @TalosBjorn
    @TalosBjorn Před rokem +2

    Love seeing the Zweihander get some recognition. That sword was both a go-to dueling weapon and a weapon used to shatter pike formations, cutting the pike heads off and striking the pikemen behind. Beautiful weapon

    • @Bubben246
      @Bubben246 Před rokem +1

      I doubt that you'd get a good enough hit to chop pike heads off, but you could sweep the points up and away from you, getting inside their guard just the same.

  • @ViktorBrech
    @ViktorBrech Před rokem +3

    They are so beautiful, and your passion shines through so clearly. Cannot believe you are also running Warlord Games -- what a hero! Merry Christmas, Sir!

    • @harag9
      @harag9 Před rokem

      Really? wasn't aware he ran that as well. I thought it was just Rabellion and sniper elite he was involved in.

  • @Beryllahawk
    @Beryllahawk Před rokem +8

    A monster but what a gorgeous monster! Absolutely love the notion of an Italian mercenary guard just standing in the street, posing as you say, and likely throwing out top-tier insults as well to bully and shame the bravos away. "Colorfully violent" indeed! It's such a pleasure to see another video from you, and the timing is so nice, a Christmas gift for us fans! Thank you for all the work you do to bring us these videos - and thank you for sharing your passion for history with us! Merry Christmas and a wonderful New Year to you!

  • @paul72002
    @paul72002 Před rokem +1

    very nice. looking forward to seeing your learning. merry christmas

  • @KURO_ame
    @KURO_ame Před rokem +1

    Epic video by Sir Jason again. Thank you.