FNF': Vs Impostor V4 - Defeat (Old Vs New) (black impostor song old vs new comparison)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 20. 06. 2024
  • O, is this a comparison between the old and new version of Defeat Song with Black Impostor? Cool, I think you can watch this.
    --------------
    00:00 - Defeat Song (OLD)
    00:11 - Defeat Song (NEW)
    00:21 - Defeat Song (Old Vs New)
    --------------
    - MOD -
    Friday Night Funkin': VS IMPOSTOR (V4 Update) - gamebanana.com/mods/55652
    --------------
    - ALL PARTS OF COMPARISON -
    1. FNF': Vs Impostor V4 - Sussus Moogus, Sabotage, Meltdown (Old Vs New) (impostor full week v3 vs v4) - • FNF': Vs Impostor V4 -...
    2. FNF': Vs Impostor V4 - Sussus Toogus, Lights Down, Reactor, Ejected (Old Vs New) (green impostor full week old vs new comparison) - • FNF': Vs Impostor V4 -...
    3. FNF': Vs Impostor V4 - Sussy Bussy, Rivals, Chewmate (Old Vs New) (tomongus full week comparison) - • FNF': Vs Impostor V4 -...
    4. FNF': Vs Impostor V4 - Defeat (Old Vs New) (black impostor song old vs new comparison) - • FNF': Vs Impostor V4 -...
    4.5. FNF': Vs Impostor V5 - Defeated (V4 vs V5) (vs black impostor original and joke build comparison) - • FNF': Vs Impostor V5 -...
    5. FNF': Vs Impostor V5 - Double Trouble (Official Vs Fanmade) (fanmade restored vs impostor trouble) - • FNF': Vs Impostor V5 -...
    6. FNF': Vs Impostor - Oversight + Danger (V4 vs V5) (white impostor v4 vs yellow impostor v5 ft.black) - • FNF': Vs Impostor - Ov...
    ---
    [BONUS PARTS]
    1. FNF': Vs Impostor - Sussus Moogus (1.0 vs 2.0 vs 3.0 vs 4.0) (red imposter all versions comparison) - • FNF': Vs Impostor - Su...
    2. FNF': Vs Impostor - Sabotage + Meltdown (V2 vs V3 vs V4) (vs red imposter songs comparison) - • FNF': Vs Impostor - Sa...
    3. FNF' Vs Impostor: Loggo's Halloween DX - Christmas + Spookpostor (Old Vs New) (dx & dx+ comparison) - • FNF' Vs Impostor: Logg...
    --------------
    o _o
  • Hry

Komentáře • 434

  • @FrostBYEte
    @FrostBYEte Před rokem +50

    2:09 It's so funny that the OLD version black imposter in that part moves. LOL

    • @bruh4138
      @bruh4138 Před rokem +4

      He’s having a seizure

    • @zia3541
      @zia3541 Před rokem +2

      Also the new 😂😅

  • @loldude8783
    @loldude8783 Před rokem +157

    The return to the OG defeat for the new one at 1:29 is Amazing!!!

  • @terror_panther2687
    @terror_panther2687 Před rokem +43

    The improvement of everything about the song is amazing

  • @alexrousseau8505
    @alexrousseau8505 Před rokem +60

    Defeat is my favorite song of the mod!

    • @bendyfnaf2636
      @bendyfnaf2636 Před rokem +4

      Double kill is also great

    • @laudric51
      @laudric51 Před rokem +2

      Grey's week is banging

    • @1tz_v1
      @1tz_v1 Před rokem +3

      Boiling point is fire

    • @applesaretasty2.099
      @applesaretasty2.099 Před rokem

      *Identity crisis has left the chat*

    • @battery_acidd
      @battery_acidd Před rokem

      *Heartbeat has left the chat*
      *Delusion has left the chat*
      *Double Kill has left the chat*
      *Pretender has left the chat*
      *Finale has left the chat*

  • @gruntification4749
    @gruntification4749 Před rokem +24

    For the new one, I like how the that red light effects actually effects character’s sprite colors

  • @efen0269
    @efen0269 Před rokem +112

    The mixing of the new version makes the atmosphere even more tense, i fucking love it

    • @eljugasodemanzana8390
      @eljugasodemanzana8390 Před rokem +4

      A blast from the past

    • @Krakyy
      @Krakyy Před rokem +4

      ikr, the crispiness in the new one makes the old one sound muffled lol

    • @efen0269
      @efen0269 Před rokem

      @@Krakyy LMAO yeah

  • @sabihabagum8122
    @sabihabagum8122 Před rokem +14

    In V3, he used to be a secret character but,in v4 he is officially a main character

  • @Random_Limo8051
    @Random_Limo8051 Před rokem +193

    I like the new one better in all aspects except the charting, I adore the "stairs" at the end of the old one a whole lot and was mildly disappointed to see it not exist in the final product

    • @bup_up
      @bup_up Před rokem +2

      The real long chain at the end of the old one?

    • @LSM2_Official
      @LSM2_Official Před rokem +16

      probably removed because of the miss limit mechanic
      would've been near impossible unless you're good at that type of stuff
      i know i'd always die there

    • @Funiman1
      @Funiman1 Před rokem +1

      @@LSM2_Official if you miss 5/3/2 times in the new one you die

    • @LSM2_Official
      @LSM2_Official Před rokem +2

      @@Funiman1 you choose how many misses you want to have
      maximum 5 minimum 0

    • @Funiman1
      @Funiman1 Před rokem +1

      @@LSM2_Official oh that is so cool!

  • @Hithalo
    @Hithalo Před rokem +26

    I just noticed that Black Impostor's voice sounds more muffled in the old version, and in the new version his voice sounds better and louder.

    • @Uparrowmate
      @Uparrowmate Před rokem +4

      well i remembered black imposter in v3 sounding like v4 black but thats not the case

    • @n0t_br33zy
      @n0t_br33zy Před rokem +4

      The difference is that the v4 version is have an louder sounds,echo and a little bitcrush if you can hear it

    • @ds2561
      @ds2561 Před rokem +3

      I'm not a big fan of v4's voice it's very disorienting and headache inducing

    • @Caleb-bz6kc
      @Caleb-bz6kc Před rokem +3

      The entirety of The Old Version is kinda muffled and quiet.

    • @lynnigncacio9276
      @lynnigncacio9276 Před rokem +2

      The voice of v4 came from black betrayal

  • @klgamer_135
    @klgamer_135 Před rokem +42

    New defeat is so goodddd

  • @Lunarcreeper
    @Lunarcreeper Před rokem +30

    it's kinda hard to believe that we thought the original was menacing. or at least, i was surprised, because i remembered it being way better

  • @dynamite_animator
    @dynamite_animator Před rokem +10

    Bro the buildup from v4 at 0:20 made v3's defeat feel so anticlimactic

  • @X-DUMO
    @X-DUMO Před rokem +17

    To say a few things that have changed, the emotional emotes are "more or less the same", but now they are updated, and the tone of black's voice and the tension of Bgum are included to some extent, and the black has become more shiny (?) And the biggest difference is that the voice resonates. It's yes or no. Because we seem to be more tense when we listen to songs or beats with "echo" in particular (the rest are comments)

    • @X-DUMO
      @X-DUMO Před rokem +1

      It seems that among us creators here also wanted to express this.they kept everyone waiting But they gave birth to black again He is now black and stands before our eyes. And this update seems to be a big gift in a way That's why I like black the best🎉🎉

  • @nguyengiatrieu8269
    @nguyengiatrieu8269 Před rokem +263

    Fan Made Week 3 vs Official Week 3 Impostor.

  • @neonerf3203
    @neonerf3203 Před rokem +3

    The new ones animations are phenomenal, the old ones music just has the certain feeling

  • @guacotaco4349
    @guacotaco4349 Před rokem +5

    It'd been a while since I'd seen the original defeat, so when I saw a genocide cover of red and green vs black (all v3) I realized just how large the difference of they're vocals are, at first I thought they were just echo'd, rewatching though I'm just now noticing that they both have entirely different voices

  • @Dark_Ron
    @Dark_Ron Před rokem +24

    New one has better visual effects but old is fire on the instrumental part

  • @flaregamer64
    @flaregamer64 Před rokem +36

    I like the old idle more (with how the knife is facing backward and how the arms are practically moving Black's body) but the new singing animations are really badass. V4 is better overall.

    • @i_am_mr_cheese_12345
      @i_am_mr_cheese_12345 Před rokem

      Same bro👍

    • @Clover33288
      @Clover33288 Před rokem +4

      They should make it where in the first part, black will have no weapons and his eye won't glow, but after the beat drops, Black's eye will flash and he will pull out a knife spin it and makes the knife turn backwards and the true fight starts

    • @i_am_mr_cheese_12345
      @i_am_mr_cheese_12345 Před rokem

      @@Clover33288 yeah you r right

    • @mine_cool
      @mine_cool Před rokem

      Full same

  • @AmongUs567
    @AmongUs567 Před rokem +18

    Only complaint is the sprites in the new one. I loved how smooth the idle was. And how the animations fit together soo well.

    • @shitanotosaurus
      @shitanotosaurus Před rokem +12

      New ones are still very smooth, and imo the old ones were much more generic and tame. They were all just imposter animations, vs now each pose ties into blacks character.. But that's just my take, its perfectly fine if u disagree!

    • @AmongUs567
      @AmongUs567 Před rokem +3

      @@shitanotosaurus To me because the old animations were just slight movements it was more smooth. The new old he moves a bit too much and when he’s spamming it looks like a mess.

    • @HArthurV
      @HArthurV Před rokem +8

      @@AmongUs567 man, the same thing happen' in the old one.. so I think your complaint doesn't make sense in my opinion, but if u think it does so whatever🧍

  • @iok1617
    @iok1617 Před rokem +2

    A few things i like about old imposter is that hes holding his knife in reverse grip and also has that bobbly cartoony feeling

  • @fabfest576_
    @fabfest576_ Před rokem +8

    i honestly like the fact that black v3 and black v4 are similar, just the detail, the vocals, and the animation are different and have more effects, making the vocals more clear.

  • @sonicelchorizoconuntoquede4871

    Let's ignore how the black impostor holds the knife differently in v3 and v4.

  • @tinyaochang4534
    @tinyaochang4534 Před 11 měsíci +1

    The improvement of everything about the song si amazing

  • @badguy3602
    @badguy3602 Před rokem +3

    I like how black have very smooth animations and it became his thing

  • @AmbushedAmbusher
    @AmbushedAmbusher Před rokem +11

    the fact that they added the old version but with different vocals and charting
    awsom e

  • @TAKLI-TAKLI
    @TAKLI-TAKLI Před rokem

    Снова я тут. Но это прекрасно...
    Я сам ждал почти 2 года это. И это очень эпично.
    Там прекрасно всё.

  • @markc6454
    @markc6454 Před rokem +21

    1:29 , old one is better in the instrumental , for sure

    • @m.d7167
      @m.d7167 Před rokem +4

      how
      seriously, how. old instrumental was empty and sounds lazy compared to V2

    • @MrArreaga
      @MrArreaga Před rokem +1

      @@m.d7167 1:21 but it's pretty sad that in this special part , hits different , i loved this and they got rid of it

    • @kostyaodnokonnyy4439
      @kostyaodnokonnyy4439 Před rokem +1

      What are you doing here? Wasnt expecting you.

    • @markc6454
      @markc6454 Před rokem

      @@kostyaodnokonnyy4439 What’s up?

    • @kostyaodnokonnyy4439
      @kostyaodnokonnyy4439 Před rokem +1

      @@markc6454 My life is fine. Everything is "fine"
      Also do you know me?

  • @cheetos_lol
    @cheetos_lol Před rokem +3

    I like how they gave a little flashback of black from v3

  • @Meartistthegodofdarkness
    @Meartistthegodofdarkness Před 9 měsíci +1

    i love the fact that black impostor has an extraordinary voice unlike the others and this tells us that he is much different than the other impostors

  • @jonaaasssj
    @jonaaasssj Před rokem +2

    I loved the way black impostor had 3D effects tho

  • @scared-pancake7811
    @scared-pancake7811 Před rokem +23

    I like the old one better but the visuals for the new one are heat

  • @user-ig9yt3wh2n
    @user-ig9yt3wh2n Před rokem

    Excellentrapbattle!

  • @ZER0LEGEND
    @ZER0LEGEND Před rokem +3

    Damn someone in your other video asked for this like 3 minutes ago

  • @eeeeee6993
    @eeeeee6993 Před rokem

    This is an absolute banger

  • @justyoureverydayidiot4523

    bf in old: kalm.
    bf in new: P A N I K

  • @greentoesbstatus4325
    @greentoesbstatus4325 Před rokem

    I really like mods that give bf more emotion and also, HOLY CRAP V4 LOOKS LIKE AN F-ING MOVIE!

  • @elprisas358
    @elprisas358 Před rokem +2

    I love the art in the new one but i prefer the old vocals and chart and idle pose for Black

  • @Kazou_Yashiki
    @Kazou_Yashiki Před rokem +2

    ok, i’m typing this as i wake up, but i literally just had a dream about the defeat song while sleeping.

  • @stormchasermary7593
    @stormchasermary7593 Před rokem +4

    New Black has a higher pitched voice.
    Old Black has lower but is kinda high.
    In the new defeat when referencing Old Defeat, Black has a sort of different voice from his original.
    And of course, New Black has a larger visor

  • @RydenTseng
    @RydenTseng Před 11 měsíci +1

    Personally, I'd prefer the old animations since they are smoother, meanwhile, the new one is just Black having a seizure.
    Still, the new background is still really good.

  • @Damp_Future
    @Damp_Future Před rokem

    The black imposter never gets old with his animation so smooth even the new version 😆😆👍

  • @leolee2769
    @leolee2769 Před 2 měsíci +1

    The notes are also different,wick makes the new a "remix" of the old one

  • @sonicelchorizoconuntoquede4871

    we are going to ignore how holds the knife differently in v3 and v4

  • @ImCookieTho
    @ImCookieTho Před rokem

    the new one has alot more energy and i love that!!

  • @OXIMrGreen
    @OXIMrGreen Před rokem

    I absolutelly LOVE the new chart, literally i can pfc but the old one no

  • @ZephyrEditsOffical
    @ZephyrEditsOffical Před rokem

    The new animation look cooler express his feeling he's going through rn and its more different than the old one

  • @r3g1s35
    @r3g1s35 Před rokem +5

    1:30 bruh

  • @Solar_Glass
    @Solar_Glass Před rokem

    Ty I've made v4 of black in obby creator

  • @Ursu00
    @Ursu00 Před rokem

    brother I love the part of defeat v4 when it refers to the old sussy black

  • @DripLolz
    @DripLolz Před rokem +1

    the amount of effort put in v4 gah dam

    • @Ho_Tuyen
      @Ho_Tuyen Před rokem

      No wonder it took a long time for v4 to release

  • @Unexperiencedguy
    @Unexperiencedguy Před rokem +4

    Blacks old version is alot less aggresive.
    His voice is muffled.
    His sprites dont show as much emotion
    The song is a little less crazy (except for the charting. The stairs are impossible.)
    Blacks new version is crazy.
    He is louder.
    He is Angry (very)
    He seems like he actually wants to kill bf instead of just pointing a knife at him and saying “hey bro can you die for me?”
    His sprites show more emotion
    And the song is crazier.
    The only thing that does not make sense here is the fact that the v3 defeat chart is harder tho. Cuz they removed the stairs. Thats very strange. 😅

    • @greatheavy1527
      @greatheavy1527 Před rokem

      You can also miss 4 notes before dying on v4 (below the hp the combo breaket is x/5)

    • @Uparrowmate
      @Uparrowmate Před rokem

      the thing about the emotion:they made it like that so he looked menacing or mysterious

    • @Gito--VR
      @Gito--VR Před rokem

      Honestly V3 black imp song is a bit more harder

    • @n0t_br33zy
      @n0t_br33zy Před rokem

      The new one haves an loud and a little bitcrush or 8 bit style a little bit

    • @suspiciousamogus
      @suspiciousamogus Před rokem

      The only downgrade was his idle
      It was so much better

  • @Rainbow98594
    @Rainbow98594 Před rokem +2

    Nice song new black lmposter and old black lmposter I like this

  • @eldaniel2676
    @eldaniel2676 Před rokem +2

    Mano, essa entrada de video fico FENOMENAL!

  • @solaris7614
    @solaris7614 Před rokem +1

    my only complaint is the start and the minute 1:29 instrumental, because that orchestra thing makes the song feel REALLY MENACING HOLY SHIT but in the new version there isn't nothing of that, the rest of the song still a banger

  • @Mechagodzilla170
    @Mechagodzilla170 Před rokem

    The old version just sound like their underwater while new version sound like their in a stadium

  • @marinfirebrawl
    @marinfirebrawl Před rokem

    IN V3, at first balck was holding his dagger in reverse, But coming to V4, He is holding the dagger forward.

  • @darrenneil2778
    @darrenneil2778 Před rokem

    Nostalgic moment

  • @SRNSonic_somefnfmodsreator
    @SRNSonic_somefnfmodsreator Před 6 měsíci

    I just realize if the chromatic old black actually different in v3 and v4

  • @mijicandjela
    @mijicandjela Před rokem +13

    I personally find the New Defeat better because of the music and art

  • @fnfandbfbyt4390
    @fnfandbfbyt4390 Před rokem

    I like the new design because he looks more intimidating and in the old design he doesn’t look as scary and intimidating.

  • @SonicTasticCraftYT
    @SonicTasticCraftYT Před rokem

    in the new defeat song when they showed V3 black the note were wrong.

  • @jorgemoreno1651
    @jorgemoreno1651 Před 8 měsíci

    Desde que salió la segunda parte bueno la segunda voz del del negro me sorprendió de verdad y apenas que la jugué Me encantó

  • @salmanmalambut3999
    @salmanmalambut3999 Před rokem

    V2 mickey and hypno: now we can update our song!!!

  • @Gamerx-ow2hr
    @Gamerx-ow2hr Před rokem

    damn this slaps

  • @Your_bloxy767
    @Your_bloxy767 Před rokem

    Tbh v4 sounds like a fight of survival(even the flashback doesn’t even sound like the old characters) and the old one sounded like the rest of the old character voices

  • @WEARESPECIALZ
    @WEARESPECIALZ Před rokem +11

    Meltdown old vs new

    • @lasernick
      @lasernick  Před rokem +6

      already done ---> czcams.com/video/iv8WQkSz8Q4/video.html :)

    • @WEARESPECIALZ
      @WEARESPECIALZ Před rokem +1

      @@lasernick oh. Guess i forgor 💀

    • @lasernick
      @lasernick  Před rokem +1

      @@WEARESPECIALZ it's ok

  • @VeryVeryNormalOhioMan
    @VeryVeryNormalOhioMan Před rokem +2

    a normal visor black vs a ice brick "visor" black

  • @benbradley4148
    @benbradley4148 Před rokem

    I like how black is more like flexible than the old one he's like keeping his body still🤨

  • @LoriRamsey-bp5dg
    @LoriRamsey-bp5dg Před rokem

    i didn't really see that big difference between the old and new XD

  • @Player1Orang
    @Player1Orang Před rokem

    I've just noticed New Black looks more....
    *Cube-like?*
    (I mean this as in the back part and Visor)

  • @markuswoolums5580
    @markuswoolums5580 Před rokem

    ngl the old one just sounds the exact same but its just underwater

  • @leolee2769
    @leolee2769 Před 2 měsíci +1

    1:31 left:old
    Right:also old

  • @Conradnimations
    @Conradnimations Před rokem +8

    how did hes visor change into a block?

  • @ft_killanimz2579
    @ft_killanimz2579 Před rokem

    I like the old one better cause it's unbreakable from it's combo breaks miss

  • @The_unknown595
    @The_unknown595 Před měsícem

    i like the old one cuz the notes are more recognizable

  • @keishaboatswain
    @keishaboatswain Před rokem +1

    If Black imposter v4 than v3 why dose v3 dose not has a background at the beginning but I like it still

  • @linthantheinzaw9975
    @linthantheinzaw9975 Před rokem

    The new version of Black Impostor is way more detailed and more animation clean! 😉👍

  • @dynamitepeter8337
    @dynamitepeter8337 Před rokem

    Why the rhythm of song at last seem similar to the old "Lullaby Left unchecked" last part rhythm

  • @Gito--VR
    @Gito--VR Před rokem

    Honestly I barely think V3 is better than V4 because of
    *Nostalgia*

  • @mariogamer6838
    @mariogamer6838 Před rokem

    I think it was better if you made the old and the new impostor sing against eachother

  • @Uparrowmate
    @Uparrowmate Před rokem

    am i tripping or didnt v3 deffeat have black imposter have a sorted of distorted voice(like v4 black)

  • @FYTlissiz
    @FYTlissiz Před rokem +1

    My favorite song in this mod is blackout

  • @batthewtheheroanewstar.6718

    Man! I love the… like, the 𝘯𝘦𝘸 FNF mod

  • @TheUnEpicGamer321
    @TheUnEpicGamer321 Před rokem +1

    arent those called thrills

  • @user-xz1tj7xr1g
    @user-xz1tj7xr1g Před rokem

    確かに新しい方のクオリティ高いけど昔の方が好きなのは俺だけじゃないはず

  • @Arman_Safin108
    @Arman_Safin108 Před rokem

    Defeat song is amazing!

  • @DENRUI10
    @DENRUI10 Před rokem

    dam bro old one sounds inside water and slight boring but new one is rlly funky and vibing when listening to both lol

  • @ss-ky8dl
    @ss-ky8dl Před rokem

    Mi favorito es los dos el new tiene tremenda animación

  • @red_imposter9777
    @red_imposter9777 Před rokem +1

    I like the old one better. Idle is better plus I think it has a better look

  • @castorbzxd
    @castorbzxd Před rokem

    After hearing the new one, the old one feels so empty

  • @fernandodeleon2406
    @fernandodeleon2406 Před 6 měsíci

    This My favorite music🎵

  • @Karl62777
    @Karl62777 Před rokem

    at 1:59 that part was amazing

  • @Salvo_Z_Mix
    @Salvo_Z_Mix Před rokem +1

    Why is the old one so muffled???/? .-.

  • @ricardobr1493
    @ricardobr1493 Před rokem

    I miss the old idle tho

  • @Monod_chocolate
    @Monod_chocolate Před rokem +1

    Мне нравится больше Old версия

  • @Fatalerror4367
    @Fatalerror4367 Před rokem

    V4 is really good!

  • @mightyyy_triston
    @mightyyy_triston Před rokem

    the old one sounds muffled and the new one sounds louder and better

  • @TJ100XBOI
    @TJ100XBOI Před rokem +1

    I prefer the notes for the old version but the animation for the new is better. Old version is easier tho

  • @Bobmanofsteal
    @Bobmanofsteal Před rokem

    Mi favorito es el old es muy divertido

  • @spookyred1338
    @spookyred1338 Před rokem

    New black is pretty crazy