Javed Akhtar, Ruskin Bond, Swapan Dasgupta, Barkha Dutt at Kolkata Literary Meet 2016
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 02. 2016
- Let my Country Awake: Javed Akhtar, Ruskin Bond, Nandana Sen, Swapan Dasgupta and Barkha Dutt on where the country stands between the extreme positions on the intolerance debate. January 26, 2016, closing session at Tata Steel Kolkata Literary Meet 2016, at Victoria Memorial.
- Hudba
I met Ruskin Bond in Mussourie a few weeks after this debate and he told me that that was the first and the last time he took part in a debate loll😂
Wow 😂😂
No debate about that 🤣
Totally understand
Calcutta literary festival is my heart since 1990s .It is really imaging.
I enjoyed Calcutta literary festival as a student of Calcutta University English department in 1990s.
Swapan Dasgupta is truly a visionary... I love to hear him...
On the contrary he is opposite of visionary.
I survived this lockdown thanks to Swapan da
Ruskin Bond admits that he got calls to return the award for "intolerance". That is why we call the awardvapsi campaign was manufactured. Swapan Dasgupta is at his usual best. Javed Akhtar is also fine.
Ruskin Bond showed that a great intellect will always speak wise words... Wow!!!
Speak only when necessary - Sir Ruskin Bond proved this with ease and through his deep intellect. He remained calm, considerate and non-confrontational. A wise man speaks less and listens a lot more. No wonder Ruskin Bond is loved by all :)
Varun Prakash Dhanda i met Ruskin e few weeks after this in Mussourie. He said he was never ever gonna take part in a debate like that
Barkha moment Swapan is making a point to contradict your own views you interupt and bring Javed or Nandita to interupt and then you listen to Javed or Nandita without interruption. So here or at NDTV studio nothing has changed. This is no way trolling you or disrespectful language
Agree with you fully.
Its a simple journalist trick. These days the tv anchors lack the smartness and get exposed.
According to these current "panelists" like BD & JA, whatever they say is is LOGICAL, RATIONAL, & whatever else they say, but whatever they do not agree with is IRRATIONAL, ILLOGICAL, NON-SCIENTIFIC. They are audacious enough to claim that they are the only ones who are rational, sensible & wise & whatever. The=ir tone too is so condescending.
the simplicity and sensitivity with a warmth of true human is evident in Ruskins' expression. No extra pretension no extra intellectualism ... balance
After 1947 to 2013 in India no problems at all after 2014 Problems started as per this people's great . We know everything who is doing what
I like the video only for what Ruskin sir said in the last part. There is so much good n great in India to see, embrace them and write and notice them first.
Javed Akhtar Sir, Anupam Kher did not become good actor suddenly in 2016, he was there since 35-40 yrs and doing wonderfully well and most deserving. This is the height of intolerance and hypocrisy that why should Anupam Kher get Padma award because his opinion differs from mine.
Ruskin Ruskin Ruskin ! Such a beautiful person ♥️
Barkha seems to misinterpret the word liberal. Why should the liberal opinion mean that a person should be allowed to eat any meat he wants? On the contrary, the liberal should stand for the right of the animal to live not the right of the human to eat it. So the liberal should ban any kind of animal slaughter.... Is that not what is happening with PETA?
Dietary freedom does not exist in the USA for example... I do not believe one can eat Horses and Dogs in the US... or at least it is not socially acceptable..
but in India commies who are anti-majority and pro-minority have crept into media, education institutions. They make the maximum noise
Swapan is a sensible and intelligent guy with clarity of thought. It's a pleasure to listen to such people!!
Wow interesting progress., am here to show you love.
U can see how much Barkha let Raskin and Nandita speak??
On republic day why would you hold something at the Victoria Hall... ????
MrRk540 because it was built with Indian money
barkha is trying to be a psychologist here .....
Ruskin bond is love and he is not suited here ....
i will be horrfied by the laughfter at17.33. at night
venkatesh kannan
Indeed
I have listened to the early parts of the discourse. It seemed to me that Ms Barkha Dutt tried to convert the literary meet, a platform to take on her opponents especially Mr. Arnab Goswami, shamelessly indeed. But , Ms Dutt, please remember it would not work. He is unreachable by you.
Bharka is even more worst word then the bit€#. I am very very sorry to use such a word, please excuse me
This was literary meet??
Ohh really??
Barkha made it NDTV news room.
No question on book!!
Ruskin bond is Ruskin bond...
Javed said kher isn't a very fine actor..
Seriously??? Then who is fine actor shahrukh, Salman??
@Its Her Choice
How can i make you mine?
M here for ruskin bond The living legend❤
Power, feeling, use, weight balance, independent on a selfie value , compare with ?? If go outside of god circle.... ??
Nandana was better off acting.
Javed saheb your interpretation and narrative on current social nd political discourse makes sense, Mr.Dasgupta u r an eloquent articulator who embellish sentences nicely but occasionally being biased and need to have more patience,Barkha u r too good as always.It is a pleasure to listen to u.
Good debate
I haf watched something of Barkha, and that liking again dropped out after this interview
A society which is still struggling with BEEF POLITICS, I find no ray of hope for it...
What politics do you want?
You can have beef then and don't vote...lol and do whatever?
Why bond was called here?
Intolerance means not tolerating. It is unacceptable only when a crime results from such intolerance.
Only came here, for Ruskin sir
Rest is noises
That's not..
Nope.
The discord is goal of Barkha Dutta as she alway try to focus on discord and distrubances in imagination /actuals !
She always tries to put her opinion on others mouth....pathetic.
1984 & 1991 incidents was constitutional not intolerant act ? Ask Javed Akhtar Nandita
Swapan Dasgupta is just amazing
Try eating horse or dog meat in US.. Or allow north eastern Indians to have dog meat in rest of India.. U Ll forget issues with cow..
Why no one in media felt India became intolerant when 6 Lakhs Hindus were thrown out of Kashmir ?
Aur a "yogi adityanath" 😂😂😂 hez a CM now..
As is Kamal Nath the CM of MP
Ruskin sir👏🤠
13:58
@12:50, Javed Aktar said is true, 🌹👌👌
There can exist more perfect laws, but
the law of the system is the base, which has to be abid. As long as it's incompatible, it has to be taken to consideration.
Swapan Dasgupta is absolutely right India is all about of indianness , you may
have different ideas about indianness ,but your core values of indianness is all about india. Constitution is a
Holly books of indianness ,
There are Javed Akhtar & Nandita ji belongs to liberal
Who r trying to making a Narratives of in- tolerance , reflecting their Insecurities
& so called elitism& monopoly intellactualism under threat . & It is evident after Modi ji , Mass is now more important than such psedue secular & liberals .
Here is the Insecurities Started for all Idiotic Corrupt parasites of Society
Barakha Dutt does not belong to such panel even as host
Ruskin bond ❤️❤️
Only clicked on the video because of Swapan Das Gupta
Indian multi national companies are not having much moral responsibilities, that's why they have given chance to the anti nationalist journalists like this bit€#
Who is she?
I wonder what Ruskin bond is doing here 😂
If you agree with her she allows them to speak,otherwise she interept
Javed Akhtar is the dambaldor of all debates🔥🔥
Haha
javed is a real crook and sort of trying to pontificate on social issues masquerade ing as an intellectual when he is really and old pudding head. To make himself look fair and square he will criticise muslims only to legitimise his criticising the Hindus. Intelligent and honest people like Ruskin and Swapan will not be able to confront his gameplan. So Ruskin just kept to himself and spoke very less but whenever he spoke one could see his honesty.
Name of the city of joy is Kolkata not Calcutta.
Two names tellable..
Kolkata from here..
@@Arunava_Sar no, only one name can be telltale and that is Kolkata. After divorce the divorced lady can't being wife.
Charkha Dutt.. She irritates
Kahan se aate hain ye log, constitutional patriotism? Aadmi ke sar pe hathi ka head lagane ki aadat gayi nhi inki
The intolerant man at its best...javed ...
Kya bakwaas bol rahale hai ye teen-javed akhtar barkha and the ither one. Total bs...
Would Javed Akhtar have written a scene in a mosque? Its easy to do a Hindu, cause we are tolerant.
I don’t know why Javed is called in intellectual debates. Javed doesn’t have sense of sitting on chair. Nikal pehli phursat me nikal
Your sense of humour in the last line proved how much intellectual you are.
sayan roy And what about your intellectual capability🤣🤣🤣🤣.
Why that hypocrite javed akhtar is given all the time
Ruskin bond really doesn't stand up to barkhas propaganda hold
Can't burkha dutt stay shut for somewhile why she has to be omnipresent
Why aren't you tolerant to Britishers then??
Burqa dutt you have blood in your hands two times, kargil and munbai
Swapan Dasgupta 👌👌👌👌👌
Ruskin bond is bat man
if javed akhtar wouldn't be there , this debate would have been illogical
Mulla mulla mullla.. yeh mullom ki baatein
I hate javed akhtar but I absolutely avenge burkha dutt
Only for jawed Saab 💖
India should know one truth is that while Congress in power, it used to give almost 750 crores to 1000 crores for award functions of Bollywood. In that only around hundred crores used to spent on function ,remaining amount will be shared by Bollywood people and one more thing is that ,whenever prime minister of India when Congress is in power visiting foreign countries, it used to take journalists particularly who anti India and anti Hindus like Rajdeep sardesai, Barkha Dutt, Ravish Kumar and from Hindustan Times and from Times now, to foreign countries with lavish facilities.
After BJP in power they are not enjoying these facilities, that's why they are spraying venom on India and BJP.
This is new India ,stop your drama award wapasi
Ruskin bond is love and he is not suited here ....