Deadly illness from THIS SUPPLEMENT: Medical Mystery

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 10. 2023
  • Emma is a 31-year-old woman who took this health supplement without telling her doctor, and it landed her in hospital. Doctors didn’t know what was causing her symptoms, until all the pieces of the puzzle came together.
    Join me in solving this medical mystery as we discuss medical conditions like iron deficiency anemia, endometriosis and porphyria along the way to discovering the underlying diagnosis.
    #medicaleducation #premed #doctorexplains #medicalmysteries #ayurveda #ayurvedic #irondeficiency #violinmd #meded #didyouknow #science #healtheducation #healthsupplements
    This video was adapted from a medical case report published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal. Click to read the original case! www.cmaj.ca/content/195/30/E1...
    Thank you to hematologist Dr. Sarah Patterson for peer reviewing this video!
    This video is made for educational purposes only and should not be viewed as medical advice. Speak to your doctor if you have any concerns about your health.
    SUBSCRIBE so you never miss a video
    COMMENT with any questions or just to say hi
    LIKE if you want to see more like this!
    🙋‍♀️ Let’s stay connected!
    Instagram: Violin.MD
    Facebook: @realviolinmd
    Twitter: Violin_MD
    Mail: PO Box 1, 119 Spadina Ave, Toronto ON, Canada, M5T2T2
    See you in the next video!
    ~ Siobhan (Violin MD) ~
    ----------------------
    ❤ YOU MAY ALSO ENJOY WATCHING... ❤
    21 year old ate THIS DIET and it caused BRAIN DAMAGE: Medical Case Report
    • 21 year old ate THIS D...
    One Simple Dietary Mistake Sent her to the Emergency Department: Medical Mystery Case SOLVED!
    • One Simple Dietary Mis...
    What your HAND says about your HEALTH
    • What your HANDS say ab...
    ----------------------
    📚 References:
    - CBC article: www.cbc.ca/news/health/ayurve...
    - Health Canada Recall: recalls-rappels.canada.ca/en/...
    - FDA dietary supplements info: www.fda.gov/food/dietary-supp...
    - About Natural Health Product Regulation in Canada: www.canada.ca/en/health-canad...
    - Ayurvedic Medicine: www.nccih.nih.gov/health/ayur...
    ----------------------
    📸 Image Credits:
    - By BruceBlaus. When using this image in external sources it can be cited as:Blausen.com staff (2014). "Medical gallery of Blausen Medical 2014". WikiJournal of Medicine 1 (2). DOI:10.15347/wjm/2014.010. ISSN 2002-4436. - Own work, CC BY 3.0, commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=31118602

Komentáře • 2,2K

  • @ViolinMD
    @ViolinMD  Před 8 měsíci +194

    What was YOUR diagnosis? Did you get it right before I revealed the answer?

    • @shorty38
      @shorty38 Před 8 měsíci +10

      Happy thanks giving

    • @appalachiancat
      @appalachiancat Před 8 měsíci +12

      You told us a bit in the title but I didn't suspect lead. The US doesn't regulate our supplements.

    • @ceeq3997
      @ceeq3997 Před 8 měsíci +9

      gosh, not a chance....haha...i didn't even try. but was totally riveted to all the steps in solving this mystery!!

    • @YukiLuvsJesus
      @YukiLuvsJesus Před 8 měsíci +13

      YES, MEDICAL MYSTERIES ARE BACK

    • @squarz
      @squarz Před 8 měsíci +11

      Your preview are always too spolery :D When I saw the bones I immediately thought about lead poisoning and 'she did to herself' I knew they were some sort of supplements.

  • @michellebobier4471
    @michellebobier4471 Před 8 měsíci +781

    My cardiologist reacted to learning that my chiropractor had been helpful to me with my attacks of tachycardia by blurting "Your CHIROPRACTOR!!" -- as if I had just told him I had consulted a witch doctor. So I totally understand this patient's reluctance to mention her Ayurvedic regimen to the hospital staff, given that a previous doctor had belittled her about it. Doctors really need to learn to be less arrogant and judgmental and stop shaming patients. A friend of mine who was overweight was fat-shamed by an OB/GYN, and the experience was so humiliating for her that, even though she was diligent about other kinds of checkups, she went many years without a gyny exam. She eventually developed ovarian cancer that, thanks to her humiliation-derived avoidance, wasn't diagnosed until she was having significant symptoms. Successful surgery saved her life, but she could've died because of the aversive conditioning she had endured. Shaming patients can result in disastrous consequences. Stop it, docs!

    • @Aochic
      @Aochic Před 4 měsíci +66

      Thank you for this HONEST post. I am a chiropractor and I see patients that felt dismissed by MDs regularly. And If I suggest a supplement, I ALWAYS tell them to check with their pharmacist first.

    • @incognito595
      @incognito595 Před 4 měsíci +56

      Yes. Rude, judgemental, unkind behavior causes patients many harms. I could tell you nightmare stories. I know I am not alone in being badly treated by these people. I'm sick of it.( no pun intended)..The internet is Full of Stories of mistreatment by medical people..

    • @joanndaprile9076
      @joanndaprile9076 Před 3 měsíci +11

      @@Aochic That is very good. But I think it's better to tell them to check with their physician (or PCP) first since a pharmacy may not have all the pt's pertinent medical information. Although, as this video brings out, the PCP may not have it either.

    • @christinag.2137
      @christinag.2137 Před 3 měsíci +23

      Does it mean anything to our healthcare system and providers amour current system is not looked at favorably and in fact causes many iatrogenic deaths each year? This woman went through multiple dangerous and invasive procedures that could have been solved by a blood test. I’m pretty sure an AI would have done a better job diagnosing her condition without subjecting the patient to unproductive and dangerous medical testing and expense!

    • @winebox
      @winebox Před 3 měsíci

      ⁠@@joanndaprile9076Good luck finding a “regular” doctor who knows anything about supplements. Had one not even know what a probiotic was.

  • @Emily-hd9sm
    @Emily-hd9sm Před 8 měsíci +195

    "stress from the new job" ugh I low key hate being told my symptoms are from stress when I wasn't stressed until my symptoms started 🙃

    • @peaceofmyhearthomestead4611
      @peaceofmyhearthomestead4611 Před 29 dny +9

      I get told its just anxiety. anxiety didn’t cause the symptoms the symptoms caused the anxiety.

    • @davidsalvador8989
      @davidsalvador8989 Před 17 dny

      @@peaceofmyhearthomestead4611 I had stomach issues about 2 years ago and 3 seperate doctors prescribed anti anxiety meds. I refused to take them and found out later I was seriously anemic. B12 and Iron helped tons.

  • @gullybull-rx2ng
    @gullybull-rx2ng Před měsícem +77

    AS SOON AS YOU SAID SAFE AND EFFECTIVE ALARM BELLS STARTED RINGING IN MY HEAD

    • @VM-123
      @VM-123 Před měsícem +14

      And pregnant people.

    • @thelightstillshines2476
      @thelightstillshines2476 Před měsícem +2

      ​@@VM-123I thought lead poisoning only infected children because the people in Flint Michigan with the Flint Water Crisis they are saying that it only affects children and not adults am I missing something🤔

    • @gsssprocket
      @gsssprocket Před měsícem +1

      @@thelightstillshines2476 yes

    • @robmcguckin7605
      @robmcguckin7605 Před měsícem

      @@thelightstillshines2476 YES! Lead is toxic to everyone of any age but children especially.

    • @ShamelessFNGRL
      @ShamelessFNGRL Před 18 dny

      ​@@thelightstillshines2476 that's them lying to make themselves look less bad. Ingesting lead is bad for everyone, there are no safe levels.
      The water in Flint is still not useable.

  • @Bhatmann
    @Bhatmann Před 2 měsíci +128

    It would be interesting to hear about people that died taking prescription medication’s as directed because I heard an MD say it was like 140,000/year.

    • @MeowNow494
      @MeowNow494 Před měsícem +27

      My mom was one. The medicine had a black box warning and when my mom experienced that she went to the hospital like you’re supposed to when experiencing serious side effects. They told her she was imagining it & they gave her a double dose and sent her home. She died a couple days later just like she told them.

    • @christinakuczora4862
      @christinakuczora4862 Před měsícem +8

      I’m so sorry. It sounds exactly right, tho!

    • @nolajacob5306
      @nolajacob5306 Před měsícem +10

      @@MeowNow494 The doctor wrote the wrong amount of the drug he prescribed and it was only when my brother had a near fatal reaction that he realised the doctor put an extra zero on the amount he should have been taking. It has been observed that when doctors go 'on strike' far fewer patients die!!! They are in a rush, so it's easy for them to make a mistake.

    • @docmcquack7252
      @docmcquack7252 Před měsícem +15

      I took a statin for 4 days and nearly died.

    • @2lorishep
      @2lorishep Před měsícem

      @@nolajacob5306 Wow! Usually a pharmacist would have picked that up. That's their job too.

  • @unclevampy
    @unclevampy Před 8 měsíci +803

    This definitely shows the need for complete transparency with your doctors. As well as the need for healthcare professionals to be mindful of how they talk to their patients. It has to be a team effort to succeed. Great video, as always, Siobhan.

    • @maxim9376
      @maxim9376 Před 8 měsíci +13

      No, it only shows one thing: Patients should have to pay 100% of their treatment cost when lying to their doctors so this nonsense finally stops.

    • @janetslater129
      @janetslater129 Před 8 měsíci +77

      @@maxim9376 No. It really does go both ways. Doctors are so quick to judge and push patients aside, without really listening to them. So, it makes sense that the patient may not want to share other information.

    • @Odo55
      @Odo55 Před 8 měsíci +24

      ​@@janetslater129 That's just cowardly on Emma's part. It's up to the patient to be responsible and advocate for themselves. Not giving full details of what you're ingesting is your fault, not the doctors. She finally revealed the most important bit. So the doctors did listen to her and saved her life. If she ever has kids she better be honest about what she's giving them.

    • @janetslater129
      @janetslater129 Před 8 měsíci +57

      @@Odo55 But doctors also need to do better with their patients and not make the patients feel intimidated. It's a two way street.

    • @spulwasser
      @spulwasser Před 8 měsíci +46

      ​@@janetslater129exactly, especially since a lot of people start with alternative medicines from not feeling taken care of by the actual health system in the first place

  • @jasonwarbird
    @jasonwarbird Před 8 měsíci +647

    Geez, this was like a real-life House MD episode, except that no-one broke into her house and found the supplements and then accused her of being an addict.

    • @BasketCells23
      @BasketCells23 Před 8 měsíci +17

      😂😂😂

    • @newlinebraces2872
      @newlinebraces2872 Před 8 měsíci +31

      Or cheat on her boyfriend with first cello, I'm in the middle of rewatching House right now xD

    • @soldier-gaming321
      @soldier-gaming321 Před 8 měsíci +8

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @olgakoksharova5042
      @olgakoksharova5042 Před 8 měsíci +20

      actually, if someone broke into her house and found the supplements earlier the story was shorter))

    • @DoggieFosters
      @DoggieFosters Před 5 měsíci +34

      And House was right: "everybody lies."

  • @conniecrowley9756
    @conniecrowley9756 Před 3 měsíci +357

    The problem is FDA approves actual poison while harassing raw and natural non gmo supplements

    • @lindadurand247
      @lindadurand247 Před 3 měsíci +20

      Exactly!

    • @MarieAnne.
      @MarieAnne. Před 3 měsíci

      What? Are you saying the supplements that came in plastic baggies were FDA approved? Wth is going on?

    • @Random_847
      @Random_847 Před 3 měsíci

      For the US yeah, she referenced a number on the bottle for Canadians. Wouldn’t it be nice if we could trust a number on a bottle!! FDA actually stands for Free De☠️th Assistance… to me anyway. I love the country but the G o v doesn’t give a flying flip about us. Food and Drugs shouldn’t even be in the same sentence, here they’re all under the same money making umbrella so whatever is approved is meant to make us sick so we can then take approved drugs that will make us sick in other ways so more meds… UGH 😤 it’s infuriating!! That’s why we don’t have free health care… they’d lose too much money! That’s why g o v s that have free healthcare also ban tons of crap they sell to us here in the US OR! The ingredients list is totally different!!! Facts and it’s disgusting!!!!ok have to stop ranting. Sorry

    • @c.m.303
      @c.m.303 Před 3 měsíci +1

      This whole video was a joke...on a youtube search enter Dr. Berg and your main symptom and he will teach you how it works and what to do about it.

    • @nadiamccall4311
      @nadiamccall4311 Před 3 měsíci +17

      kind of the opposite issue here though. Lead and other heavy metals are natural and can be found more often in supplements as well as groundwater. Supplement industry is highly unregulated in the US, it's really scary to look at what is sold and how little we are able to know what's really in any product. This has nothing to do with it being natural or raw, bc anything sold is fair game.

  • @kimjay2697
    @kimjay2697 Před 3 měsíci +40

    While being seen by my internist for something, upon telling him my vitamin regimen, he cut me off halfway through spitting venomously at me "Voodoo Vitamins"!...shaking his head disappointedly making me feel like I had just been caught with my hand in the cookie jar by Mom. I never went back to him. I would have liked a grown up conversation with him instead of being demeaned/belittled. I was infuriated and don't even remember the rest of the visit!

    • @visam28
      @visam28 Před 27 dny

      Which is funny because pharmakia is actually the real voodoo

    • @charleeghee7195
      @charleeghee7195 Před 9 dny

      Something similar happened to me also but worse is that she placed her bias opinion of me in a medical portal for all medical professional in my future to view and influence their opinion of me before even meeting me. I detest how the conventional medical industry discourages people from taking their own health in their own hands and to the point of ridiculing them is pathetic.

  • @searaph
    @searaph Před 8 měsíci +380

    Sounds like there are 2 morals in the story. 1. Health care practitioners: never belittle your patients! 2. Patients: always inform your doctors of anything you're taking.

    • @ViolinMD
      @ViolinMD  Před 8 měsíci +31

      Totally agree! 👌

    • @maddys6
      @maddys6 Před 8 měsíci +2

      ​@@ViolinMDin agreement 😀🤝

    • @carolcole570
      @carolcole570 Před 4 měsíci +33

      Let’s add a third moral to the story. That students studying to become doctors are required to take MANY courses in vitamins and supplements before graduation. Then, they will be totally prepared to understand each supplement and can converse with their patients without immediately hanging from a chandelier screeching at them. Bottom line……physicians do not truly CARE about helping patients. Their goal is…..exactly what they tell us : to lower the population. No wonder we are all terrified of them and hide our supplements. Two of my doctors actually look down their noses at me and sneer. My stomach gets tied up in knots about a week before my upcoming appointment.

    • @donnahilton471
      @donnahilton471 Před 4 měsíci +4

      She should have LISTENED to the first doctor!

    • @carolcole570
      @carolcole570 Před 4 měsíci +2

      @@donnahilton471 In this day and time, Donna ? Oh well…….each to his own, as they say.😳

  • @wallychambe1587
    @wallychambe1587 Před 3 měsíci +83

    I brought my 89 year old friend to his doctor check up showed every thing he was taking including some supplements. The doctor made a snide remark "Well you just need to take a multivitamin, those other supplements you are just wasting your money on them" ! My friend told the Doctor "I didn't get to be 89 taking all that prescription crap!" He is only on two prescription meds, blood pressure and prostate! No diabetes and perfect cholesterol!😲😲

    • @williamwaters4506
      @williamwaters4506 Před měsícem +5

      Sounds like she saw my doctor.

    • @portagepete1
      @portagepete1 Před měsícem

      That's 2 too many, prostate drug now found to cause dementia. and high blood pressure is not enough exercise.

    • @lindabirmingham603
      @lindabirmingham603 Před měsícem +13

      Cholesterol is whatever the body needs it to be and shouldn't be micromanaged. It was never the cause of heart disease; it is a scapegoat. Heart disease is caused by various factors that damage the lining of the arteries(glycocalyx) causing clotting which leads to plaque formation and calcification over time. A prime offender is high blood sugar which causes the red blood cells to get coated ( glycated), changing the smooth surface of the cells. This is what the Hemoglobin A1c test measures. Other causes of damage of the glycocalyx is smoking, high blood pressure, certain common medications, and sickle cell anemia.
      What cardiologists do not realize is that when the arteries in the heart are full of plaque, so is the main artery of the body: the aorta. When the aorta is examined at autopsy, there are many holes where the blood leaves the aorta to feed various organs. The opening of these holes have thick rings of calcified plaque from the increased pressure of damaged blood cells being forced through. Also, at autopsy there is no plaque in veins. The same blood flows through the entire system. If dietary cholesterol was the cause, the veins would clog up first as the blood moves more slowly with less pressure. Veins do not clog up unless you graft them into a high pressure area such as the heart.
      The cholesterol in plaques comes from the disintegrated red blood cell membranes in the blood clots which are 40% pure cholesterol. LDL is not a kind of bad cholesterol either. It is like a submarine carrying fat based cargo through the bloodstream. You wouldn't call a car a human because it carries people. LDL carries cholesterol, hormones, vitamins and triglycerides, delivering the cargo wherever needed.
      There is also a type of LDL that immediately goes to the scene of damage in an artery stabilizing the newly formed clot so we don't bleed to death. It is a fireman, not an arsonist.
      All of our cell membranes are rich in cholesterol. Cholesterol is also needed to make vitamin D, fat soluble vitamins, hormones. Over 40% of our brain tissue is made of cholesterol. It is not a critical building block for our body.

    • @VernCrisler
      @VernCrisler Před 17 dny

      Hey, nothing like anecdotal medical advice.

    • @bytejuggler
      @bytejuggler Před 15 dny +2

      @@lindabirmingham603 Spot on. 👋from someone else that's been down this rabbit quite a bit. To add to your comment if I may: A lot of the damage caused by persistently high blood sugar will be arrested and eventually start healing and reverse if the body is given time to heal during a period of sustained lower, healthier blood sugar and periods of fasting to encourage autophagy and renewal. A low carb diet and/or Intermittent Fasting protocol will over time help in this regard.

  • @erictaylor5462
    @erictaylor5462 Před 8 měsíci +88

    My dad worked in an oil refinery from 1968 to 2008 and as they were still making leaded gasoline he had to have regular lead testing.
    My dad was also a GA pilot and owned an airplane with 3 other guys.
    We had some friends of the family who had a son (who was under 18) who was serving time in the juvenal prison system. The prison the boy was serving his time in was in Southern Ca and so once a month my dad would fly the man and his wife down to visit their son.
    On this particular day he noticed the belly of the plane was covered in oil, so he took a rag, got some gasoline on it from the plane and used it to clean the oil off. Aviation fuel is 100 octane and is called "high lead" because it contains a large amount of tetraethyl lead.
    On his next work day he was tested for lead levels and the test came back "alarmingly high" just from cleaning the plane with a rag with av-gas.

    • @diablominero
      @diablominero Před 7 měsíci +5

      These days, avgas 100 has been mostly replaced by avgas 100LL, which has less tetraethyl lead in it.

    • @marymotherofgod4861
      @marymotherofgod4861 Před 3 měsíci +6

      Thk u for ur comment and ur dad is a awesome man to fly this family down to c their son 🙏💜

    • @oldandintheway9805
      @oldandintheway9805 Před 2 měsíci +7

      From an aircraft mechanic and flight instructor; Aviation fuel is not called high lead fuel. It's actually called LOW LEAD fuel. Even thought it contains 17 times the lead that used to be standard in auto gas. The industry knows this and has been looking for a reliable no lead alternative, with no luck. So low lead continues to be used by general aviation aircraft.

    • @sincerely-b
      @sincerely-b Před 5 dny

      "Juvenile" I don't mean to be an ass, just helping. As for your dad, why was he tested? Is it protocol of was it because he had symptoms?

  • @northernpianotuner3319
    @northernpianotuner3319 Před 5 měsíci +95

    As a (retired) EMT we have to take a medical history (as best we can in the circumstances); actually having the medication bottles is a huge help. I learned to ask the patient about meds in categories: prescription meds, over the counter meds, street drugs, and herbal or alternative treatments (can include supplements, oils, treatments such as acupuncture). Asking by CATEGORY made it a little more likely to find something, & gave us a chance to reassure the patient that they would not get arrested or charged over things they had ingested.

    • @deborahsacco186
      @deborahsacco186 Před 3 měsíci

      You fell for this gas lighting propaganda too? Yikes society is in for a rude awakening if they live through this kind of propaganda war. Can't see she is reading a script and not once goes to memory in body language. Suppose you are vaxxed to the hilt and if so you gave away your brain power to think outside the box or for yourself!

    • @lillieberger2883
      @lillieberger2883 Před 2 měsíci +3

      Yep. I had someone in hepatic failure , from supplements from the health food store.

    • @deborahsacco186
      @deborahsacco186 Před 2 měsíci

      @@lillieberger2883 And that can be fixed within 24 hours using correct natural remedies especially homeopathic. Which means no side effects.

    • @tammyf8326
      @tammyf8326 Před měsícem +2

      When I was 18 years old I required surgery to repair a snow ski injury. I met with someone on the staff in advance that asked me about of questions prior to the surgery and one of the questions was “have you taken any drugs of any kind” and I answered no because I thought they would document it and share with my parents. I actually had smoked some weed the day or two before surgery and had no idea that the reason they were asking was because it could react negatively with general anesthesia. I vividly remember to this day (40+ years later!) being in a coma for what my mom said was 6 hours in the recovery room. I could hear everybody speaking around me and knew my mom was there and they kept checking on me but I couldn’t move or speak. It was the scariest experience of my life. I wish whoever had asked me if I’d taken any drugs had let me know that it wouldn’t be completely confidential and that it was a safety concern. I didn’t know why he asked the question at the time.

    • @gsssprocket
      @gsssprocket Před měsícem +1

      EXCELLENT

  • @paulbieber7103
    @paulbieber7103 Před 8 měsíci +237

    Please, more medical , mystery cases. I’m a U.S. paramedic and have enjoyed and benefited from all your videos, but the unique nature of the medical mysteries is especially interesting and helpful. Thank you for everything. Paul

    • @SaraMorgan-ym6ue
      @SaraMorgan-ym6ue Před 7 měsíci +2

      this goes to show how safe is not safe if you take to much

    • @stevemitz4740
      @stevemitz4740 Před 3 měsíci +10

      My wife was killed by an EMT who wouldn't listen to her Doctors & my O2 warnings! "WE know what we're doing." he said, and O.D. ed my type 2 COPD wife with massive amounts of O2, pushing her carbon dioxide level to 700+ mEq/L. [60 being normal for her] Elevating her acidosis into the 6.30's range! Saturating more O2, preparing for the more lucrative intubation, [as opposed to Bi-pap therapy] she died for 9 min. then the ER quack administered Bi-carb [instead of first] and got her heart going again, [with all her organs noe wiped out!] She died the next day, and joined the 2191 iatrogenic victims who also died that day & every day! (See Dr. Null’s book, Death by Medicine, for facts & details, interesting stuff, one should know! (I wish I knew at the time!)

    • @stevezarbock8733
      @stevezarbock8733 Před 3 měsíci

      P​@@stevemitz4740

    • @candyrosefreeman7232
      @candyrosefreeman7232 Před 3 měsíci +4

      ​@@stevemitz4740fellow human I am so sorry that your wife and you endured such tragedy preventable tragedy at that I'm so sorry blessings for you and yours May her memories bring you comfort.

    • @stevemitz4740
      @stevemitz4740 Před 3 měsíci

      @@candyrosefreeman7232 Thank you for your kind thoughts and blessings! Blessings and good luck is what my wife Janice brought me! She was very intuitive, in fact predicting her own death a few years beforehand [without any doctors or medical reason] I would always chide her on her “silly” predictions] now as she was lying sedated & intubated on her [EMT and doctor induced death bed,] I now knowing her death was near I was in a quandary, do I tell her, she was right and I was wrong? All reminding me of the silly story of two men camping in a remote cabin, one of them came in screaming hysterically, “I’m gunna die, I gunna die, a poisonous rattle snake bit me when I was in the out-house! Calm down I’ll call and get advice on what to do, finding out he needed to cut x’s and suck out the poison with his mouth, he ask where did the snake bit you? When Mr. Victim told him where, he responder, Yep your gunna die all right! Now that silly story was running through my silly head, Do I tell her, admitting I was wrong & she was right? So I told her as gently as I could, that extreme sad expression on her face was something I never seen before! [We’d been through a lot of sadness together] Then I told her [she as I believing in God Jesus and what he told us,] "just think you soon will be seeing your God sister Joan, and Esther" [who was also killed by iatrogenics] Then [no exaggeration] her sad face lit up like she just hit the lottery, knowing where she was soon going to! And I thanked God for giving me her, and her wisdom, for 39 years! Knowing we’ll soon be together again in glorious, God Jesus’s Heaven! Makes saying good bye, more easy, knowing where your going!

  • @FireCracker3240
    @FireCracker3240 Před 8 měsíci +325

    This is why you never, ever hide anything you're ingesting from your doctor. It's better to be embarrassed than sick or worse. It's just not worth the risk to your health and your life.

    • @zunedog31
      @zunedog31 Před 8 měsíci +31

      Also say no to traditional medicine. It's never worth the risk.

    • @josephdahdouh2725
      @josephdahdouh2725 Před 8 měsíci +4

      I do understand the fear. But, people pay their livelihood to get checked out and treated for an illness that may cause them everlasting suffering. So, how can one accept themselves to hide the truth when they're seeking the gull truth back. It really is weird to me how humans think and behave in regard to that. Similarly, people pay huge tuition fees in colleges just to end up homeless with a barely passing degree. Humans are reckless and doctors should know this without judging it in a manner that causes further fear. But, still, it is in our nature to be reckless and hide what's embarrassing as we have done so our entire lives(for example keeping secrets...). If people were more open to each other, and there was less judgment in this world, then people wouldn't fear and lie dead/morbidly affected because of a silly root that involves hiding the supplements one has taken.

    • @rexrobo2512
      @rexrobo2512 Před 8 měsíci +17

      @FireCracker3240 I used to have the same opinion about not hiding (failure to disclose ≠ hiding) things from your doctor. Until I realize that while answering their questions about pills and medication I started hearing, from the medical questioner, audible sighs, and noticing eye rolls, and other signs of discontent.
      I finally decided to start giving them what I think they want and not what they're asking for. Problem solved.

    • @rexrobo2512
      @rexrobo2512 Před 8 měsíci +12

      @FireCracker3240 either I follow that method of alleviating the medical professionals discontent, or I'm constantly asking them what the f is their problem (without the colorful language of course) my way is simpler and doesn't get me listed as a problematic patient.
      One complaint from a doctor or nurse about a patient can forever change how that facility will relate to and deal with that patient. On the flip side it takes hundreds of complaints against the medical professional before anything is done. Something to remember before virtue signaling about hiding things from doctors.

    • @rexrobo2512
      @rexrobo2512 Před 8 měsíci +3

      @FireCracker3240 no offense intended mate. I probably could have said that to more than a couple dozen different people who are commenting on this video. You just happen to be the first one I saw.
      God bless!

  • @r.d.7248
    @r.d.7248 Před 3 měsíci +85

    From a fellow Canadian. We need more doctors like you- humble, kind and putting people first. Keep up your wonderful work and God bless you!

    • @deborahsacco186
      @deborahsacco186 Před 3 měsíci

      She was reading a script. Did you check her credentials, really? This reeks of propaganda and gives you fear and the only solution is their nefarious solutions. Get educated please!

    • @gsssprocket
      @gsssprocket Před měsícem

      agreed

  • @juliekongs4856
    @juliekongs4856 Před 3 měsíci +54

    If doctors were educated about supplements and less judgmental, people would be more forthcoming with info about supplements.

    • @janwhite1361
      @janwhite1361 Před měsícem +3

      I believe that if doctors lack interest and respect for the supplement industry, it's because they know better

    • @lj8945
      @lj8945 Před měsícem

      @@janwhite1361 No, doctors lack interest and respect for the supplement industry because they DON'T know better. They are not taught anything about supplements or natural healing in medical school. They're indoctrinated to believe supplements and natural treatments are bad or ineffective. They get 1/2 day of nutrition in their many years of medical training, if that (not an exaggeration). Pharmaceutical companies write the medical textbooks. There's no money to be made in supplements because they're natural and cannot be patented like pharma meds. That's also why you don't see big studies on supplements, because that requires massive funding (usually government grants) and there's no big money to be made from them. It's a sad, vicious circle. The medical system, for all the miracles it can perform, is grossly lacking in using natural modalities as part of their patients' treatment plans. But I'm afraid there will be no change until there is a massive shift in the system and a huge incentive for them change.

    • @sblijheid
      @sblijheid Před měsícem +3

      @janwhite1361
      No they don't. They are ignorant about it. Medical school didn't teach them that and they refuse to bother to look into it.

    • @janwhite1361
      @janwhite1361 Před měsícem

      @@sblijheid
      Mabey...

    • @user-fn1cd6mo9z
      @user-fn1cd6mo9z Před měsícem

      @@janwhite1361 Yes and no...there's definitely quackery out there in the supplement industry, but your GP can be puzzled by health supplements that a Dietitian will understand and agree with. I've supplemented NAC, SAM-e, DIM, and resveratrol for years, but when I included then on my med list one time, it turned into a long discussion with my GP about what they were and why I was taking them. My Dietitian, on the other hand, knew what they were and had no issues.

  • @sheelaghhalstead4549
    @sheelaghhalstead4549 Před 8 měsíci +138

    I wish i could upvote this video several times: For the interesting "detective story"; For the advice on supplements; For the advice for doctors to be nonjudgmental; and finally that Emma finally had a good outcome.

    • @ViolinMD
      @ViolinMD  Před 8 měsíci +17

      Aw thank you!

    • @cgttc0441
      @cgttc0441 Před 4 měsíci

      It’s funny I have friends that will take “supplements “ by the handfuls. Never know what’s in them and if there are any verified studies showing safety and efficacy. At the same time they won’t take the meds their doctors recommended because of the known risks BECAUSE of studies.

    • @deborahsacco186
      @deborahsacco186 Před 3 měsíci +2

      Guess you never thought about what she didn't tell you, the script was so well conspired!

  • @jeanetteraichel8299
    @jeanetteraichel8299 Před 8 měsíci +120

    No matter what specialty or how long you've been practicing, you want to be kind, caring, compassionate and non-judgmental to all of your patients. You never want to gaslight or trigger a patient. They'll not be open to their doctor.

    • @puclopuclik4108
      @puclopuclik4108 Před 3 měsíci +1

      This goes to individual personality. We will never know how many people died because they had bad experience with doctors and therefore weren't honest about their supplements, diet, or lifestyle.

    • @sblijheid
      @sblijheid Před měsícem

      Most doctors and nurses are arrogant Aholes.

    • @jackiem9460
      @jackiem9460 Před měsícem

      Also, uncaring doctors will lose patients. I was referred to a cardiologist for fatigue, dizziness, and shortness of breath (I was 36yrs old). He said my blood pressure was fine and brushed off my concerns. I will never see him again.

  • @leonardgibney2997
    @leonardgibney2997 Před 3 měsíci +71

    Replacing mercury containing dental fillings was the greatest thing ever for my general health. They caused twenty plus illnesses some life-threatening.

    • @denisern55
      @denisern55 Před 3 měsíci +6

      What symptoms reversed by doing this? I just read an article by Cleveland Clinic saying not necessary to remove if no issues. However if opportunity arrives then do it. Same thing from my dentist

    • @alexstone7594
      @alexstone7594 Před 3 měsíci +6

      What illnesses can the mercury filling cause. Thanks.

    • @mikestanly749
      @mikestanly749 Před 3 měsíci +3

      like ????????????????????????????? what ?

    • @alexstone7594
      @alexstone7594 Před 3 měsíci

      @@mikestanly749 Back in the 1940 or way back then dentis filled cavities with the metal lead and mercury to "dumb down the people".

    • @bluewaters3100
      @bluewaters3100 Před 3 měsíci +9

      i took out my amalgams and root canal teeth i was trying to get rid of severe joint and muscle pain. I ended up with severe mercury poisoning and needed DMPS IV's to clear it out. It was not pleasant and very expensive. Finally got a diagnosis...Lyme disease from a tick bite gotten in 1989. I ended up getting a good doctor who gave me 6 weeks of
      IV daily antibiotics for six weeks. had good insurance in 1996 so my bill of almost $10,000. I was also traveling 300 miles to get UBI treatments which I believe helped me get over the Lyme disease too. I was also taking alot of probiotics and other things. I am lucky to have gotten a clean bill of health. I am 71 now and just spent 5 weeks helping my daughter with her newborn. Life can be good...

  • @ineedvyvanse3493
    @ineedvyvanse3493 Před 5 měsíci +40

    As a nurse, I can really really appreciate your nice neat handwriting.

  • @spelldaddy5386
    @spelldaddy5386 Před 8 měsíci +122

    I appreciate your outro, that you not only based the video on a published work, but you had your own video peer reviewed. There are thousands of papers, journals, and books out there that get peer reviewed, but often, CZcams videos are neglected and seen as less reliable. I wish more people like you would have their videos peer reviewed before publishing, so that we can have better transparency in the medical community

    • @fusionfan6883
      @fusionfan6883 Před 3 měsíci

      Do you understand how impractical that is???

    • @peterson6824
      @peterson6824 Před 3 měsíci

      @@fusionfan6883 he didn't suggest every video get peer reviewed...he just wished more people like her would have their vids PR'd

  • @ericboyer6464
    @ericboyer6464 Před 8 měsíci +54

    If all doctors were as compassionate and diligent as you! 💜

  • @theworldofjuniperthecat1307
    @theworldofjuniperthecat1307 Před 4 měsíci +57

    Exactly what my sister went through. She used paint with lead in it to paint her jewelry gold.

  • @incognito595
    @incognito595 Před 4 měsíci +24

    Nightmare stories result from not being kind, and treating patients badly. Medicine is not what it used to be.

    • @gsssprocket
      @gsssprocket Před měsícem +2

      ALSO, INDIVIDUALS CHOOSE LAZINESS, AND NOT TAKING RESPONSIBILE ACTIONS TOWARD THEIR OWN HEALTH!! TOTAL NEGLIGENCE TO TAKE ANY DRUGS,,AKA PILLS, FROM HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS IN A BAGGIE, NO INGREDIENTS, !!1 THERE WAS SOMETING BACK HANDED ABOUT THAT ENTIRE EXPERIENCE, LIKE FINDING QUESTIONABLE FACILITES ON THE CHEAP!!! TOTALLY RIDICULOUS!!!!!

    • @sincerely-b
      @sincerely-b Před 4 dny

      My father just spent two months in the hospital. I was absolutely appalled by the staff, the docs, the nurses. Some passed remarkably well, but many should change careers IMHO...

  • @squidleyskidley
    @squidleyskidley Před 8 měsíci +314

    This is why it’s important for doctors and healthcare staff to create a nonjudgmental environment and be culturally sensitive, so patients will share their whole picture of what they’re doing.

    • @Skatejock21
      @Skatejock21 Před 8 měsíci +15

      but many places do. Doctors can do all things to not be judgemental but people still fear it. It still falls on the persons lap whether they feel judged or not. Its not a fun place to be in the first place and doctors know that. You cant make a "non judgmental" environment by definition. Patients wont share things for all kinds of reasons. Some people dont even think they need to tell a doctor their medications. They think surgeries from 20 years ago dont matter. The doctor already knows you dont want to be there. People put too much focus on judgement that sometimes the doctor needs to do some judgement in order to tell a patient to change their choices and behavior. Even the staff can do all things and people will still tell them that they dont want to be there. They will tell the staff they feel judged. When really people dont realize that when you associate judgement with bad judgement. You may not get the kind of care you want because you went in there already telling the staff that you feel judged. Doctors and staff have to become numb to the unkindness people bring to medical offices. You can have the nicest staff in the world and people still treat them unkindly.

    • @Adam1984_
      @Adam1984_ Před 8 měsíci +23

      @@Skatejock21 Did you miss the part where the patient clearly stated that the reason she didn't mention the supplements was because a previous doctor had been judgmental and belittling toward her when she did mention them? That IS the fault of the doctor, not the patient for "feeling judged".

    • @whimsy-chan1188
      @whimsy-chan1188 Před 8 měsíci

      ​@@Adam1984_ its pretty hard not to come across as judgmental when discussing traditional medicine as its so hard to find a polite way to explain they're wasting money and potentially doing more harm. Its unfortunate there are charlatans that continue to take advantage of the desperate to peddle voodoo tonics for profit.

    • @yasminbarry7941
      @yasminbarry7941 Před 8 měsíci +8

      YEAAH..... But I thought everybody knew how dangerous it can be if you fail to tell your doctor about everything else you are taking for your condition.

    • @Urza9814
      @Urza9814 Před 8 měsíci

      Sure, the woman was downing homemade pills full of lead, but the REAL problem is the doctor who made it clear that he didn't think that was a good idea...lmao

  • @kmjc1213
    @kmjc1213 Před 8 měsíci +97

    Like other people are saying in the comments, it's SO important to tell your doctors about every single drug or supplement you put into your body. Even if it's a taboo drug. Even if it's an illegal drug. It could make or break your diagnosis and treatment (or lead to dangerous drug interactions). And I agree that doctors need to be better about taking all patient info for what it is, even if it doesn't match their personal morals or beliefs.

  • @stefanieritter5801
    @stefanieritter5801 Před 4 měsíci +37

    I’m a pharmacy technician in the US. I love watching your videos. So very interesting!

    • @deborahsacco186
      @deborahsacco186 Před 3 měsíci

      Love the propaganda hype, do ya??? maybe you took too many vaccines (gene therapy &/or bioweapon) and will have prion or other neurological disease soon. This is completely scripted !!!

  • @kthybrown007
    @kthybrown007 Před 7 měsíci +46

    I love your enthusiasm! I am a retired doctor, having trained in both FP and Ob/ Gyn ... and play double reeds in several community groups. You would be the BEST Chief Res and/or IM Attending! AND a musician.... no matter what, don't let that go!

  • @evangelinegrace8402
    @evangelinegrace8402 Před 8 měsíci +62

    Hey Dr. Siobhan,
    Thank you for posting this video. I’m a medical student. Seeing this video after studying about Heme synthesis and Porphyrias educated me a lot. You’re such a great teacher! Keep sharing mystery cases like these 😊

  • @britneynicole8903
    @britneynicole8903 Před 8 měsíci +33

    I am so proud of how far you have come. I have been watching you for six years now and it has been so amazing seeing you go through residency, fellowship, and become an attending physician. I cannot wait to continue watching and going along with you on this amazing journey.

  • @MeowMeow-sy2mi
    @MeowMeow-sy2mi Před 8 měsíci +22

    I am not a medical student or healthcare worker. Just a stay at home mom whos disabled and has medicine as a special interest. I find medicine fascinating.
    This was a great case to cover. I am so glad Emma was okay and was able to have a baby ❤

  • @user-mp9rd4hg8b
    @user-mp9rd4hg8b Před 3 měsíci +12

    I wish all doctors worked this hard to get to the root cause of severe, unusual symptoms. I'm going through this myself.

    • @sincerely-b
      @sincerely-b Před 4 dny

      Have they figured it out? Are you doing well?

  • @charityloar7287
    @charityloar7287 Před 8 měsíci +13

    I absolutely love your medical mystery cases! Your enthusiasm, breakdowns of complex topics, and the interesting cases you choose are so engaging!

  • @tonics7121
    @tonics7121 Před 4 měsíci +12

    O my gosh. That is totally scary, and actually very interesting. Well done. You have a gift for storytelling, making points stack up beautifully.

  • @bradcampbell5766
    @bradcampbell5766 Před 3 měsíci +45

    I had a dentist when I was a kid. One appointment he seemed to go into a rage while he was trying to use a chisel to remove a tooth. It was a bit traumatic for me. I believe now that he had mercury toxicity, and he was triggered. Mad Hatters syndrome is what is described based on employees at a Hat manufacturing place in the early 20th century where they were exposed to toxic levels of mercury. I'm sure many dentists have suffered from mercury toxicity. Someday people will wonder how they thought it was a good idea to put a known toxin in our mouths as filling material.

    • @oldandintheway9805
      @oldandintheway9805 Před 2 měsíci +4

      You could afford a dentist? Wow, we were so poor when I was a kid that we couldn't afford teeth!

    • @sumralltt
      @sumralltt Před měsícem +1

      @@oldandintheway9805 My dad took a second job so I could get braces!

    • @_Wake_Up_If_U_Can
      @_Wake_Up_If_U_Can Před měsícem

      They also use it to keep multi dose medicine germ free, then they inject the multi dose "medicine" into babies. Cue the bots/online paid astro-turfers below my comment...in 3, 2, 1...

  • @danieeccc
    @danieeccc Před 8 měsíci +51

    Thanks for explaining endometriosis! 😊😊 Took 9 years to diagnose me and unfortunately it's so common

    • @KBB-nf1dr
      @KBB-nf1dr Před 4 měsíci

      It’s common, and it’s only gonna get more common. The more people were safe vaccines. Endometriosis is caused by streptococcus bacteria that feeds on heavy metals.
      Your womb needs to be clean in order to grow life, and your uterus will push all of the toxins and heavy metals out through the uterine wall. We’re streptococcus feeds on it. That is, what causes all that sticky muck and glues your bowels together. Streptococcus bacteria is grown in laboratory on eggs and injected into humanity via vaccines, along with the heavy metals that feed it.

    • @kiradelarochefoucauld7499
      @kiradelarochefoucauld7499 Před 3 měsíci +1

      I had that for a few months in 1978. (horrible). My GYN, did a D&C and completely cured it. Went on to have 3 easy baby deliveries. granny now. WHY is this issue SO MYSTERIOUS?

    • @KBB-nf1dr
      @KBB-nf1dr Před 3 měsíci

      @@kiradelarochefoucauld7499 all disease and illness is mysterious, because all medical research and training is funded and manipulated and controlled by the pharmaceutical industry, it is the pharmaceutical industry that causes all disease and illness, throw vaccinations, and they keep the medical professionals ignorant to that reality, because they can’t make $1 trillion profit when people are healthy. Medical professionals are essentially legal drug dealers. They’re not taught the course or cure of anything, because the Medical industry is the cause of everything.

  • @jamessharier7529
    @jamessharier7529 Před 8 měsíci +14

    I always love your story telling, they’re so compassionate and engaging 🤗🤗🤗

  • @AudioTruyenLangQue
    @AudioTruyenLangQue Před 7 měsíci +5

    I love how all of these medical mysteries have something to do with food! Thank you so much for sharing these with us

  • @rajahua6268
    @rajahua6268 Před 8 měsíci +3

    The kind of investigative report I like. Thanks for bringing it up!

  • @debribbe3502
    @debribbe3502 Před 8 měsíci +6

    You are the best at explaining medical issues and I look forward to everyone of your videos. Thank you, thank you for what you do.

  • @thundercactus
    @thundercactus Před 8 měsíci +26

    I can really sympathize with how difficult it is to get the right diagnosis when a patient doesn't remember or won't tell you what they've been exposed to recently, and that some symptoms are so incredibly common among other conditions that it could be "anything". "Vomiting and fever" doesn't narrow it down all that much.
    Also, this is a supplement poisoning case, I was fully expecting you to say "bringing us to the emergency room, where we are now" lol

  • @katherinekelly5380
    @katherinekelly5380 Před 7 měsíci +26

    When I went into the hospital for appendicitis (I was throwing up and couldn’t uncurl from the fetal position until they gave me Demerol for the pain) When I was asked about medications, I listed the prescription meds and then I was specifically asked about any vitamins or supplements I was taking. The nurse was so nice and she mentioned how important it is to include any and all supplements, any herbal remedies pills or teas etc
    She mentioned she had known of a few medical mysteries that had been solved once the medical team was aware of everything the patient was taking
    My appendix did turn out to be the problem and it was removed but I’ll never forget this talk with the nurse while I was under the influence of Demerol!
    So now, whenever I have to fill in this type of medication I take a snapshot of my medicine cabinet so I can provide exacted amounts and even brand names

    • @deborahsacco186
      @deborahsacco186 Před 3 měsíci

      You were played!! They are all in on helping Pfizer gas light the natural God's pharmacy into oblivion. While there are cures for everything if you do your research. Quit being fooled by propaganda.

  • @flagmichael
    @flagmichael Před 7 měsíci +16

    The Natural Product Number sounds like a great idea. In a field where all sorts of things are sold with little information (at least in the US) the standardization with NPNs means problems can be addressed without a long list of brands and labels.

    • @CarolynStOnge
      @CarolynStOnge Před 3 měsíci

      In Canada, we have a DIN number already

  • @bethenielaurentwist4818
    @bethenielaurentwist4818 Před 8 měsíci +27

    Love your videos! Please don’t take this the wrong way, with someone who suffer with tinnitus, if you use noises to explain it, using a warning would be really helpful, especially for someone who has reactive tinnitus like me! Hope that makes sense ❤

    • @AlphaGeekgirl
      @AlphaGeekgirl Před 4 měsíci +4

      Thanks for posting this comment. I thought I was the only one. I thought my head was going to explode. Oh, the pain!

    • @nikkijack911
      @nikkijack911 Před 3 měsíci +4

      That's a thing? I'm guna have to read up on that. Seems like that may be why certain videos make my tinnitus worse. I just assumed it just happens when it happens and I have to deal. Wasn't aware of the reactive part, but makes total sense.

  • @laratheplanespotter
    @laratheplanespotter Před 8 měsíci +28

    I’m actually training to be a forensic scientist so this was a great video for my toxicology class thank you!

    • @casperinsight3524
      @casperinsight3524 Před 4 měsíci +1

      Forensic scientist sounds like an interesting profession. What an interesting and much needed career choice 😎

  • @jennyhammond9261
    @jennyhammond9261 Před 5 měsíci +1

    You are a great storyteller and make the medical jargon easy to follow!

  • @katego370
    @katego370 Před měsícem +5

    Two of my grandparents were pharmacists. Although I don't remember them because they died when I was very young, they packed my father with a wealth of knowledge. I still hear stories of "grandpa always said that..."
    One of the things they taught me by proxy was to trust science and doubt natural "medicine", not for its possible efficacy, but for the wonky trash that may be in it. My grandfather used to say: "Natural medicine is still medicine. It's the water you drink and the salt you eat, even the fluids you get in an IV. But if an independent pharmacist isn't willing to sell it or recommend it, there's usually a very good reason." That's because they simply cannot _afford_ to sell snake oil.
    If a pharmacist educated in the 50s can be open yet critical of natural solutions, then so should doctors in the 2020s. This would steer desperate people away from the woowoo gurus without degrees and back to actual medicine, including natural medicine that actually works.

    • @user-fn1cd6mo9z
      @user-fn1cd6mo9z Před měsícem +2

      That brings up a very good point, too, about supplement contamination. Sometimes even reasonable supplements can have unreasonable things in there by accident. Nowadays, I won't buy any supplement that isn't both made in a GMP facility and 3rd-party lab tested.

  • @KeishaAbbott
    @KeishaAbbott Před 8 měsíci +23

    Going through my own journey for an endo diagnosis at the moment! Hearing you talk about hemoglobin and iron deficiency in relation to Endo would explain my chronic anemia for the last 10 ish years!

    • @tracy3418
      @tracy3418 Před 8 měsíci +2

      I have iron deficiency anemia from my endometriosis

    • @KeishaAbbott
      @KeishaAbbott Před 8 měsíci +2

      @@tracy3418 in hindsight, it would make so much sense! I hope you're doing okay with it;

    • @MeowNow494
      @MeowNow494 Před měsícem

      That procedure she was talking about poking the holes and pumping the air is also how they do tubal ligations, and that’s how I was diagnosed with Endo. She saw it all inside my abdomen when it was full of air.

  • @mujkocka
    @mujkocka Před 8 měsíci +5

    These are your best kind of videos! Thanks for the medical mysteries 😊

  • @dr.stevenpennym.d.3241
    @dr.stevenpennym.d.3241 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Great video. Great case. Always tell your doctor what you are taking. As soon as you stated that she was taking a supplement for fertility reasons, I immediately knew it was heavy metal poisoning. She went through a lot of unnecessary testing in surgeries.

  • @larissacaye
    @larissacaye Před 8 měsíci +1

    please keep making your amazing videos!! i love watching them!! ❤

  • @LaraA55
    @LaraA55 Před 8 měsíci +3

    @Violin MD I absolutely and loved this video. The last part of your video was so important for everyone to hear for the patient and health professional.🤗

  • @josephdahdouh2725
    @josephdahdouh2725 Před 8 měsíci +16

    It's actually insane to me how easy some cases are to solve, but how many routes it can go so much to the extreme that it takes longer than expected to solve a case. I already studied hematology as a premed, but it's difficult to figure it out without your guidance. I think you're videos are super educational especially those of this format, so keep it up! Now I know what I need to look out for even more than I did before if ever I encounter a similar case. It is very important for doctors and patients to communicate empathetically and truthfully with each other. I have seen many cases online on many misdiagnoses or later diagnoses with repercussions on the patient due to hiding the truth in shame. I feel sorry she got belittled for her negligence instead of being taught what to do without giving crazed judgments. I do understand her fears, but I do believe that doctors should pressure the patient more on what they're taking ensuring that any medication or supplement taken may be the cause. Also, I bet a well-informed well-rounded doctor would know to explain the fact that certain supplements if bought illegally could contain harmful material such as lead, and this I believe should be mentioned to every patient alongside other facts to make it easier for patients to deliver the entire truth. Maybe the issue is the system that doesn't allow such thorough investigations, but I do believe that they're necessary and that many of the tests she had to do are wasteful if, in fact, they did uncover the truth from her via the technique I've already discussed, which ironically would give doctors more time to deal with other patients.... In my opinion, it is BS that the hospital sends back the patient with diagnoses such as anemia of an unknown reason, and unsurprisingly, the patient returns with worse symptoms and outcomes than if they did a more involved investigation in the first place... Anyhow, I still do love how well the government handled this case and took down the illegal company that probably poisoned hundreds if not thousands of Canadians. My uncle has a Canadian university degree in traditional and herbal medicine. Now I worry that such a degree only causes more mishandling of patients than good.

    • @rebekahjimenez2808
      @rebekahjimenez2808 Před 8 měsíci +2

      Herbs and supplements have been used quite successfully for thousands of years. The herbs are not dangerous when administered by someone like your uncle and produced by a reputable company.

  • @ssjb7542
    @ssjb7542 Před 7 měsíci +2

    I JUST FOUND YOU! TY, V MD, YOU are a brilliant story teller~ &DOC! XO

  • @Christynmaine
    @Christynmaine Před 3 měsíci +4

    So glad I found this video. Thank you! I’ve just started working with a hematologist for my anemia and g.i. problems. yesterday they drew eight tubes of blood for testing. We talked about a bone marrow biopsy and transfusion. I’ve also just bought an 1880s house and am doing a lot of refinishing inside. I did not think to let this doctor know about that. It didn’t occur to me that the mask I wear may not be sufficiently protective. Will make sure I’m screened for heavy metal poisoning before I have any more invasive tests.

  • @make725daily1
    @make725daily1 Před 8 měsíci +9

    This video sets an exemplary benchmark! - "Appreciate the path, as it molds your journey towards greatness."

  • @hle1606
    @hle1606 Před 8 měsíci +4

    You are such a good story teller this is such an informative video!

  • @sheriboston706
    @sheriboston706 Před 3 měsíci +5

    Good information.. Dr. Side & Patient Side need to do their part! So glad Emma now getting well.❤🕊️ Lord's Blessings All

  • @leannabedore
    @leannabedore Před 3 měsíci +3

    I just came across your video and I just have to say wow! Fascinating. My gma has porphyria and I just had blood wrk done and sent out to test for it. It is VERY hard to detect. When you said it is a lot to unpack that we don't have time for I COMPLETELY understood. Lol
    You are extremely knowledgeable and thank you for sharing your education with us! Btw you are beautiful❤
    This was extremely frustrating to watch, all this investigative work up all while she hid her supplements. She should have been 100% been truthful. It makes me wonder if she knew or semi-knew this company wasn't entirely legitimate. So glad Canada got on top of this and the federal level. 👏👏

  • @maddygardner4641
    @maddygardner4641 Před 8 měsíci +83

    I’m in medical school and we just finished our hematology block! Before finishing the video, I guess lead poisoning! Causes hypochromic microcytic anemia and the build up of ALA makes sense because lead inhibits ALA dehydratase! Wondering why they went straight for an invasive bone marrow biopsy before testing her for all the possible causes of microcytic anemia?

    • @reannarichardson3978
      @reannarichardson3978 Před 8 měsíci +11

      Yeah I guessed lead poisoning as well. I also wonder why they took so long to do a peripheral blood film. My haem lecturer goes on and on about how important it is as an investigation.

    • @josephdahdouh2725
      @josephdahdouh2725 Před 8 měsíci +4

      I think because of how rare it was for a person in Canada to be lead poisoned. Apparently, the musician lives in an env. with lead not being exposed to her. So, since there was no reason to think the patient was coming in contact and not at all exposed to lead, why would one think of lead poisoning as the issue? They did investigate the easiest cause of such an anemia(i.e. iron deficiency and found evidence of that in that the ferritin was low). So, they went on to investigate why and what the reason behind the Fe-deficiency. Here, instead of looking for the possibility of lead poisoning which they wrongly probably crossed out the fact that they trusted the patient to not have been exposed to lead was what lead them to her return home undiagnosed. The bone biopsy is important to figure out if there is an anomaly with the hematopoietic stem cells? To be honest, I would have also thought that erythropoietin production or bone marrow failure would be probable causes. So, maybe they started by testing the bone marrow 1st. I disagree with the fact that they may not have done a thorough examination of the peripheral blood smear since as we know a basophilic stippled cell is a big indicator of lead poisoning. Tbh, I never learned about the elaborate hematology concerning the porphyria screen. But, if absolutely necessary, in this case since the options were running low, then I too would have come to order this test for her. But, tbh, if I were her doctor, I would think of the route of action and what I'd do for every possible result, and then check if I could ask questions or make shortcuts rather than do the entire pannel of testing(e.g. endoscopy...). Tbh, endoscopy, and colonoscopy could have also been helpful in diagnosing helminth that could have absorbed the iron before making it to the blood stream, so maybe the doctors considered that. Anyway, returning to my point, I think with greater attention to the supplements and medications, I would have asked the patient to tell me of any embarrassing extra medication or supplement she may be taking, and explain to her that for example anything could be the answer to her issue, and that there will be no judgment if she tells the complete truth. Despite this making it feel like a trust issue that the doctor has with his patient, it is absolutely necessary to do this in order to diagnose the patient quickly and effectively rather than to waste endless resources on possibilities. Tbh, this case, and any other case could be solved in years rather than quickly if doctors decide to take a certain route had the patient never disclosed to them the truth and had they not thought of the rare instance that involves the screening pannel they ordered. So, I'd say despite the case being lengthened. I bet there are worse cases, and this case did close up quickly relatively to many undiagnosed patients who also probably have "easy" cases...

    • @josephdahdouh2725
      @josephdahdouh2725 Před 8 měsíci +1

      @@reannarichardson3978 I am a premed btw but my major is really interrelated with the medical domain.

    • @reannarichardson3978
      @reannarichardson3978 Před 8 měsíci

      @@josephdahdouh2725 my haem lecturer would still suggest a peripheral blood film especially in a case for suspected anemia. It's not enough to just look at the numbers but physically look at the blood with your eyes. I kind of agree with original poster about why would they jump to such an invasive test like a bone biopsy. It's very very painful and most times you try other investigations first before you go with such an invasive test.

    • @holly.earendil5187
      @holly.earendil5187 Před 8 měsíci +1

      I’m a med student too and wondering why they didn’t see it on the blood smear? We get them done with the FBP (full blood picture) in Australia. If it was causing a sideroblastic anaemia, surely you’d see the rings?

  • @Angel-zn1xh
    @Angel-zn1xh Před 8 měsíci +17

    I love this! This was like a real "House" episode. Is there otc testing kit available to home test for lead toxicity in the body?

  • @erilynnparas1787
    @erilynnparas1787 Před 2 měsíci +5

    Had a similar experience…except not only was i anemic, my CA-125 lvls were elevated…(laparoscopic ovarian cystic removed-size of grapefruit) and the doc found I was “riddled” with endometriosis…i was 26…I luckily had had 2 kids back to back @ 19 & 20.

  • @dariusdadurkevicius9090
    @dariusdadurkevicius9090 Před 8 měsíci

    You are amazing!, you know so much and your videos are very interesting.

  • @mariaioannou7770
    @mariaioannou7770 Před 8 měsíci +6

    Your spirit is admirable! I hope you live a happy fulfilling life with health and love ! Great videos, love from European viewers

  • @lauriebrin4365
    @lauriebrin4365 Před 8 měsíci +7

    I love your videos,they are very informative and educational.❤❤❤

  • @ktm7519
    @ktm7519 Před 3 měsíci

    Thank you for this very informative episode. You brought us such valuable information, so grateful for your efforts!! This is what social media should be reflecting. Knowledge doesn’t serve anyone unless it’s shared ❤

  • @joneenurse9616
    @joneenurse9616 Před 8 měsíci

    Thank you for your all videos so helpful.

  • @LindseyObrooke
    @LindseyObrooke Před 8 měsíci +23

    I have to remind myself that not everyone is mindful, but sheesh, there's gotta be a moment of logic somewhere and connecting some dots. What is new? Supplements. Derp. Not telling your doctor, or even multiple doctors...truly just, mind-blowing.

    • @giftofthewild6665
      @giftofthewild6665 Před 3 měsíci +5

      Doctors and medical professionals are guilty of not connecting dots too. They're all doing it right now.

    • @TheBaumcm
      @TheBaumcm Před 3 měsíci

      @@giftofthewild6665yep, it took the docs 6 months to connect headaches and body aches to bone for my aunt, and multiple myeloma. Her specialist said they should’ve known something was wrong with how out of whack her white blood cells are. If they have convinced themselves you are suffering from X it can be really difficult to get them to pursue all avenues, especially when insurance actively tries not to pay for anything.

  • @ceeq3997
    @ceeq3997 Před 8 měsíci +5

    possibly one of the best videos you have made -and there have been sooo many great ones. absolutely fascinating...and exciting....and highly addictive‼. plus super informative, non-judgemental, and with advice on realistic steps we can take to avoid this kind of harrowing illness 😍5/5⭐

  • @mmmmlllljohn
    @mmmmlllljohn Před 4 měsíci +3

    You are a gifted teacher - great info! TFS. ❤️🇨🇦

  • @katisugarbaker7349
    @katisugarbaker7349 Před 4 měsíci +42

    The problem wasn’t Ayurvedic remedies; the problem was a low quality supplier and dispenser.

    • @glenncordova4027
      @glenncordova4027 Před 3 měsíci

      Lead, mercury and other toxins are a part of Ayurvedic medicine. Ayurvedic remedies was the problem in this case

    • @puclopuclik4108
      @puclopuclik4108 Před 3 měsíci +4

      I would disagree. Although some ayurvedic practices like meditation, yoga, and herbs have a positive impact on health, the metal ingestion is the problem.

    • @glenncordova4027
      @glenncordova4027 Před 3 měsíci

      Metal ingestion is part of Ayurvedic medicine.

  • @flame-on-3
    @flame-on-3 Před 8 měsíci +4

    Wow great episode. I love the in depth passion you provide. Wouldn't it be great from admittance to have a body scanner to pick up all the pathology parameters in one go but also spit out an accurate diagnostic. Just the interface with the body is missing in the technology. I love to hear and celebrate these teased out diagnoses and the professional doctors that do it. Unfortunately It is a rarity, In most situations the patient bares the symptoms after being released and if the symptoms continue they go to doctor google (thank the good universe) and hopefully after many hrs of research and rational thinking and with the help of Doctors they start to work out the puzzle, you have to take responsibility for your health. I find it amazing that the fear of just one Doctor dressing down would have that effect on her logic to that degree where she didn't mention the alternative meds, but also she didn't pick up on the association of sickness and taking the tables given the symptoms. but there you go.

  • @althomas8672
    @althomas8672 Před 8 měsíci +18

    Lead line in gums might have been present but missed in work up. I was leaning toward porphyria. Didn’t realize heavy metals might be in Ayurvedic meds.

    • @sbocaj22
      @sbocaj22 Před 8 měsíci +7

      It’s not surprising tho considering that a lot of those meds are made from herbs and stuff gathered from soil that could easily have high heavy metal levels.
      I smoke weed medically (my liver won’t process edibles) but because there’s so much heavy metal contamination in the soil that rolling papers and stuff come from I only smoke out of bongs. It’s super disappointing to realizing how much of our various agricultural supplies are lethally contaminated.

  • @sitara7084
    @sitara7084 Před 8 měsíci

    this is such a great informational video! I usually order supplements from amazon all the time, I never knew about the NPN.

  • @CLaRITaBONITa12345
    @CLaRITaBONITa12345 Před 5 měsíci +1

    These kinds of case studies I'd love to hear in a podcast type of format! I wish I can just listen to these on drives without having youtube open.

  • @eternalsunshineofthespotlessme
    @eternalsunshineofthespotlessme Před 8 měsíci +9

    I love these case reviews! 😊

  • @jeremiahbaker6396
    @jeremiahbaker6396 Před 8 měsíci +5

    Thank youu!
    Mnemonic for microcytic aneamia = TAILS - Thalasemia, Anemia of Chronic Disease, Iron deficiency anemia, Lead toxicity, Sideroblastic anemia

  • @CK-yh9mi
    @CK-yh9mi Před 3 měsíci +1

    Through testing, discovery and rapid response helps save many lives. Bravo for not giving up!

  • @averymarie7057
    @averymarie7057 Před 3 měsíci

    you made this complicated subject sound so interesting. Thanks 🙂

  • @martinamasala8070
    @martinamasala8070 Před 8 měsíci +48

    I love these videos! Do you think you and your husband will start a podcast on Spotify where you talk about medical cases as well? That would be fantastic!

    • @laurend8140
      @laurend8140 Před 8 měsíci +1

      Yes, she is a natural at telling these stories! I'd love a podcast!

  • @wmdkitty
    @wmdkitty Před 8 měsíci +46

    Yep. Tell your doctors/nurses/EMTs EVERYTHING, even if it's silly, illegal, or feels irrelevant. It's super important, and remember: Your doctor (the ER nurse, the EMT, etc.) is not going to call the cops on you for ingesting illegal substances. Their main goal is getting you back to healthy.

    • @kakefyll
      @kakefyll Před 8 měsíci +4

      If you're a parent they might contact cps tho

    • @BetwixtDandD
      @BetwixtDandD Před 7 měsíci +3

      Are you sure? There are many instances when doctors are required to inform authorities.

    • @sandy239b6
      @sandy239b6 Před 4 měsíci +4

      Like they care...remember the recent plandemic?!

    • @stevemitz4740
      @stevemitz4740 Před 3 měsíci

      And you think that will bring down the 800,000 annual,/ 2191 per day iatrogenic death toll?

    • @DianneRay-pj3wu
      @DianneRay-pj3wu Před měsícem

      They may be so threatened they attack...

  • @jenniferutasy8641
    @jenniferutasy8641 Před 2 měsíci +1

    ❤Thank you so much Dr.for sharing this insightful analysis.
    Dr. Jen.

  • @dr.kamtavatsalam
    @dr.kamtavatsalam Před 3 měsíci

    Great channel. Mult millionfold thanks for sharing with so much zest and professionalism.

  • @StefBarber
    @StefBarber Před 8 měsíci +7

    Happy Thanksgiving Dr Siobhan and Dr Mark!

    • @ViolinMD
      @ViolinMD  Před 8 měsíci +2

      Thanks Stef - happy thanksgiving to you too!

  • @NicHklas9Nevermind
    @NicHklas9Nevermind Před 8 měsíci +11

    Fantastic video! This is why supplements should be well researched before you start taking them, the industry is very unregulated and people assume they are all beneficial, but many daily supplements provide more up to 100x the recommended daily dose of a vitamin/ minerals which isn't necessarily a good thing.

  • @FourthMatrix
    @FourthMatrix Před 3 měsíci +79

    14:26 and pregnant people? You can't say "a pregnant woman" anymore?

    • @maggierags8328
      @maggierags8328 Před 3 měsíci +7

      Women are people, too.

    • @FourthMatrix
      @FourthMatrix Před 3 měsíci +9

      @@maggierags8328 I agree with you 100%. But that still doesn't give a man any license to compete unfairly against women or to say they can menstruate or give birth. Honestly the thing that is very wrong with modern culture is that we don't celebrate all the things that are special and beautiful about women, or the things that are special about men - which are different. We just need real love in the world.

    • @lindamorgan2678
      @lindamorgan2678 Před měsícem

      Freaking Leftist idiot talk ..I do not trust them

    • @abyfuller
      @abyfuller Před měsícem +19

      @@maggierags8328but pregnancy is specific to women

    • @GinaR21212
      @GinaR21212 Před měsícem

      Women are obviously the only people that can get pregnant!

  • @AlEndo01
    @AlEndo01 Před měsícem +1

    Wonderful discussion. I'm a recently-retired endocrinologist (hybrid private practice & academics) otherwise known as a "bonehead" (metabolic bone disease). I guessed the Dx early. But note that lead poisons an enxyme called ferrochelatase that puts iron into protoporphyrin-IX to make heme(oglobin). Protoporphyrin does not go out in the urine; it would have been detected easily by measuring serum! I recently stumbled across your talks, and am using them to keep both brain cells working hard. You should have a homepage listing all your presentations! Best regards. I'll bet you're accumulating your share of Teacher of the Year awards at your institution.

  • @kmmusic8
    @kmmusic8 Před 8 měsíci +70

    Dear ViolinMD, thank you for your compassion towards patients who are mislead by these untested treatments and your efforts to include trans and non-binary people. We need more medical professionals who are kind and nonjudgmental so that people don’t suffer the way the woman in this case report did because they don’t feel understood by their healthcare team.

  • @WhoseLineVideos101
    @WhoseLineVideos101 Před 8 měsíci +4

    Another amazing video, Siobhan!

    • @ViolinMD
      @ViolinMD  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Thank you, so glad you enjoyed it!

  • @ParadoxxedMedia
    @ParadoxxedMedia Před 3 měsíci +1

    Sigh... thanks for sharing this story. It's unbelievable how corrupt companies can be nowadays with total disregard for public safety!

  • @robotaholic
    @robotaholic Před 8 měsíci

    This is the third video of yours Ive seen and I love these. You are great...and beautiful and smart 🤩🤘

  • @sydneybarnett6806
    @sydneybarnett6806 Před 8 měsíci +4

    thank you so much for talking about endometriosis! it is so often overlooked as a diagnosis and takes SUCH a toll on the lives of those suffering.

    • @user-kd2hz4mc3f
      @user-kd2hz4mc3f Před 3 měsíci

      I suffered most of my life when I became 43 years old doctors found out that I have endometriosis. Folks thought that I was faking the pain when I got my monthly. I was able to have my son at 45 years old.

  • @MsStina84
    @MsStina84 Před 8 měsíci +21

    I listened extra carefully to the iron deficiency subject. My puberty came early and at least 3 generations in my family have bled a lot during long periods. So I've often had iron deficiency. And as someone with spina bifida I can't take iron pills unless it's really really necessary, 'cause they cause my already existing bowel movement problems to worsen a lot.

    • @susancarr8998
      @susancarr8998 Před 8 měsíci +2

      Why not drink spa tone? It's natural spring water high in iron. But TELL your doctor.

    • @kylieharrison3782
      @kylieharrison3782 Před 8 měsíci +3

      Dried fruit, dark fruit cake, molasses,dark brown sugar are all great sources of iron.

    • @Jane-dr2wg
      @Jane-dr2wg Před 8 měsíci +3

      A long and heavy period definitely warrants a checkup with an obgyn! Even if it’s something that runs in the family, there are lots of things that can cause this and many can be managed :)

    • @blueseptember2174
      @blueseptember2174 Před 7 měsíci +1

      I've lost life threatening amounts of blood before and alos have extremely heavy periods. Something that's helped me was during recovery from surgery and also right before my period, I sometimes eat dates, molasses muffins or milk, prune juice, healthy veggies like broccoli and vitamin C. I also stay away from added sugar but keep my fruits. I actually made a quick recovery from a hemoglobin of 2! Crazy! It went back up at an amazing rate ❤ to normal levels.

    • @gloriakummer5357
      @gloriakummer5357 Před 4 měsíci +1

      If your family has a history of heavy periods make an appointment with a hematologist. I have a bleeding disorder called VWD. My hematologist prescribes iron infusions, as I don’t absorb iron pills. Infusions don’t cause constipation. I’m sure your doctor could get approved iron infusions with your underlying condition of spina difida.

  • @randiley
    @randiley Před 8 měsíci

    Love your channel!!

  • @Em1n3mka
    @Em1n3mka Před 3 měsíci

    Very interesting to listen to this story. Also, eye opening. Especially as my mom has low levels of hemoglobin and iron. Thanks for sharing, Violin and I am sure more interesting cases are to be seen in your channel.

  • @LWilkes
    @LWilkes Před měsícem +73

    It's "pregnant WOMEN" not "pregnant people." Please do not erase women from our language.

    • @msaijay1153
      @msaijay1153 Před 15 dny +2

      How does this erase women?

    • @kevlahead7278
      @kevlahead7278 Před 15 dny +1

      @@msaijay1153 It's more about the nonsense of succumbing to the Libtard narrative such as the new phrase 'chest feeding'

    • @way_truth_life_of_love
      @way_truth_life_of_love Před 12 dny +6

      Because only women can menstruate, get pregnant, carry a life inside her for nine months, go through labor and delivery, and breastfeed. It is a great responsibility and gift, but so is fatherhood!❤

    • @_Solaris
      @_Solaris Před 8 dny +1

      Yes.

  • @noellundstrom7447
    @noellundstrom7447 Před 8 měsíci +3

    great video! never would have guessed lead poisoning, didn't think someone would ever put lead in a supplement...

    • @joanhoffman3702
      @joanhoffman3702 Před 8 měsíci +4

      Often the ingredients contain lead, and no one needs to add any. For example, matcha tea contains lead because the whole leaf is used, and lead is absorbed from the soil.

  • @jaimeizreal8810
    @jaimeizreal8810 Před 3 měsíci

    Wow! Thanks @Violin MD. Appreciate it.

  • @bonniemahrenholz6972
    @bonniemahrenholz6972 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Your video is so beneficial on so many levels, thank you. The one thing that stands out to me is the gaslighting patients are experiencing by medical profesdionals. It needs to stop.
    Thank you for your informative videos.