During season one i thought it was ok, but season two really solidified the greatness of the show for me. I struggle to understand how divisive the show is with fans. My only conclusion is that there is a large segment of Gundam fans who only want a power fantasy and war drama and miss the core of the show. War is hell, power corrupts, and only cooperation leads to a better world. I actually believe IBO is probably the best executed and realized version of those core Gundam principles intended all those decades ago. That said it is a tough, sad pill to swallow.
The main reason a lot of fans dislike season 2, is cause it feels Hella rushed, and also cause of juilleta. Her character felt like she had all the plot armor, while tekkadon members were killed off for no reason a lot of the time.
@@lordgaroroironically this is discussed in another YT’s video, but it’s because Tekkadan is no longer right. They were the Villains in Szn2, just OUR protagonists
@@EastsideBodega_ it was actually cause of writing differences between the creators, one wanted to kill off all of tekkadon while one wanted em to live, hence we got this wierd middle ground. the final battle still dope tho
the Imperial Japanese Army mobilized 1,780 schoolboys aged 14-17 years into front line service as an Iron and Blood Imperial Corps. during the battle of Okinawa. feel like there’s some kind a ties to that.
It was one of the finest Gundam series ever made hands down. I wish they would make a game based on it where you can make your own merc unit and the like.
Good video. Honestly probably the realest Gundam show. Most Gundam shows will have you forget two episodes in that the main character and some other people around them are children and they just fade into being soldiers like everyone else. This one though, the entire time, I would constantly be like fuck....these are really just children fighting a war. Every death, even the most minuscule characters, just felt so much more impactful.
I loved it, theres a lot of ways IBO can be analysed, be it by its importance alongside other stories, its own tale in the context of the show or our world. How as time has gone by, the series seems to gain more importance with the issues we are dealing with.
If ever there was someone trying to convince someone else that Gundam anime is cool and can be watched and enjoyed by older adults (that's my Mom), this is the video to show them. This has to be the best summary of my favorite TV show ever. Keep up the great work!
Edgerunners definitely hits on some of the same notes. It is also one of my favorite shows. I'd say edgerunners is missing the political and generation aspect which I find the most impactful in IBO.
I just stumbled onto this video. I have to say, this is a very Good Vid. Especially as an IBO fan, this is dope I sure hope your channel grows big soon. Good Luck
Well I think it was implied well enough that the Teiwaz higher ups other than McMurdo didn’t really like them or naze Turbine Who stated that no one likes young upstarts.
They might not have liked them, but they were happy to allow them in and work with them until it reached a point that they had surpassed them. That was when parts of Teiwaz turned against them enough to try to actually kill them.
Even though I disagree on some points, and I personally see IBO as the most disappointing Gundam series that I have ever watched for all it's narrative faults on both an objective level and from my own subjective perspective, I deeply enjoyed and appreciate this analysis. I honestly never really had that much insight on the characters and the conclusions they come to by the end of series the same way you did. And I really appreciate your perspectives and the articulate analysis you give. I also INCREDIBALLY (you have no idea) appreciate how much you don't paint Tekkaden or even McGillis as the "villains" of the series like I see nearly every other video analyst do in the videos they make when it comes to series. Doing it by looking at it from an idiotic meta perspective. Instead of looking at it with meta-tinted glasses you actually look at the series for what it itself says. Seeing them as nothing more than tragic, and victims of both their own flaws and the cruel circumstances forced onto them. And that I cannot appreciate enough.
There were a lot of sad deaths I felt the rage of shino being mad he couldn't destroy galihorn's ship then dying for nothing and biscuit died trying to hold on to life then orga and tawa'z and lafter even though tekkaden didn't really win completely galihorn was reformed
For your first video, this is really good. You speak into the mic well, the script is well-written, the editing is great, and the use of music is nice. Hope to see more.
this was amazing.ibo is my favourite gundam series.I was thinking about how would i write a sequel to it but your review made me realize it would lack what made ibo ibo
Had this in my Watch Later list for a couple of months and just got around to watching it. I'm thankful that I did, as your analysis was on point, well constructed, and beautiful. IBO is my favorite of the Gundam franchise and it's disappointing to me that Witch From Mercury couldn't live up to this as a "Next Entry" in the franchise.
The show is great, probably the best gundam. But I do feel that Rustal (Moon Commander guy) being assassinated at the end rather than Nobliss (Kudelia's former benefactor) would've left a better taste in the mouth of the audience. The whole idea was that everyone would get the comeuppance in the end for the sins they committed, but With Rustal and co still alive I felt it kinda fell flat. Rustal through out his humanity in pursuit of his ideal Gallahorn just as the other characters did in essentially executing a bunch of children to use as a scape goat, but he never really had to pay for it. Sure you could argue that his being forced to compromise with Kudelia as well as the very fact that Nobliss was assassinated could be extrapolated to mean he would eventually be forced to pay, but I do think it'd have been better if Rustal had ended up being assassinated instead. Then everyone on both sides would've been forced to lose someone balancing the proverbial ledger and having Julieta (monkey girl) succeed him with her realization that Tekaden was ultimately a product of circumstance.
I mean the whole point of my essay and the show IMO was that these things aren't fair and balanced. For all his flaws Rustal was the person Gjallarhorn needed to steady themselves and become a more responsible organization and even with his tarnished past, he led to a better future. As I said at the end, even as broken people they could leave behind something whole. The world isn't a game of balanced and fair compensation in conflict and what made this show good is that it represented that.
Season one was good, it ended on a bittersweet note but things looked promising. Season two is what happens, when you take the needless sociopathy and sadism of evil characters, turn the nob on that up to 11 and break it off. All for no other reason than, 'well we've got a second season to fill and no other ideas'.
S1 wasnt bittersweet and Im unable to know what wasnt just the consequence of the things done in S1. I think you may want to learn the use of narratives.
@@Jaeger_Bishop Damn, not like it matters since its getting a new anime spin off, kind of sounds like you are going to be hitting your head in the near future.
@@tutumazibuko2510 No. I watched the 2nd season and was just aggravated by is as it went along. Heaven forbid someone doesn't see the end result the way you do.
Literally a small segment teased in S1 which had a glimpse in S2 while the narrative took place. If it comes down to just not following thw story then it sucks to be you, so much so people do enjoy it so its getting a spin off.
I like the design of the gundams and some of the fight scenes but the one thing i didnt like is the ending of this series this is the most dissapointment gundam series that i have watched.
During season one i thought it was ok, but season two really solidified the greatness of the show for me. I struggle to understand how divisive the show is with fans. My only conclusion is that there is a large segment of Gundam fans who only want a power fantasy and war drama and miss the core of the show. War is hell, power corrupts, and only cooperation leads to a better world. I actually believe IBO is probably the best executed and realized version of those core Gundam principles intended all those decades ago. That said it is a tough, sad pill to swallow.
I agree with you there. Especially with trying to understand why so many were divided over it.
Agreed.
The main reason a lot of fans dislike season 2, is cause it feels Hella rushed, and also cause of juilleta. Her character felt like she had all the plot armor, while tekkadon members were killed off for no reason a lot of the time.
@@lordgaroroironically this is discussed in another YT’s video, but it’s because Tekkadan is no longer right. They were the Villains in Szn2, just OUR protagonists
@@EastsideBodega_ it was actually cause of writing differences between the creators, one wanted to kill off all of tekkadon while one wanted em to live, hence we got this wierd middle ground. the final battle still dope tho
IBO is, to this day, the best gundam I ever saw. The level of tragedy and fall is amazing
the Imperial Japanese Army mobilized 1,780 schoolboys aged 14-17 years into front line service as an Iron and Blood Imperial Corps. during the battle of Okinawa. feel like there’s some kind a ties to that.
It was one of the finest Gundam series ever made hands down. I wish they would make a game based on it where you can make your own merc unit and the like.
This show, the OST.. probs one of the best scores of all ANIME in my opinion. You fucking feel everything. But the goul
But the gou
Bro made one video then left
Good video. Honestly probably the realest Gundam show. Most Gundam shows will have you forget two episodes in that the main character and some other people around them are children and they just fade into being soldiers like everyone else. This one though, the entire time, I would constantly be like fuck....these are really just children fighting a war. Every death, even the most minuscule characters, just felt so much more impactful.
have u seen gundam ms08th team or stardust memory ?
I'm not even a gundam fan, but this was such an interesting watch
I loved it, theres a lot of ways IBO can be analysed, be it by its importance alongside other stories, its own tale in the context of the show or our world.
How as time has gone by, the series seems to gain more importance with the issues we are dealing with.
By far the best analysis i've seen and heard about this show!!! i just bought the whole soundtrack collection.
Brilliant! Loved the show and this, thank you!
If ever there was someone trying to convince someone else that Gundam anime is cool and can be watched and enjoyed by older adults (that's my Mom), this is the video to show them. This has to be the best summary of my favorite TV show ever. Keep up the great work!
Holy cow, man, this is your first video. This is very well done! I'm looking forward to more. Especially if it's more gundam.
cyberpunk edgerunner is basically an abridged version of this
Edgerunners definitely hits on some of the same notes. It is also one of my favorite shows. I'd say edgerunners is missing the political and generation aspect which I find the most impactful in IBO.
@@taez_ ya could only do so much 10 epd
I just stumbled onto this video. I have to say, this is a very Good Vid. Especially as an IBO fan, this is dope
I sure hope your channel grows big soon. Good Luck
Dude, thanks for express really beautiful what this series made me feel. From the beginning it was a history about atrocities 😢
“What’s going on” New watcher, 17 year worker “War! We’re going to war!
Great content, keep it up
I love IBO so much, easily in my top 10 list.
Very well-made video, you've got a good eye for literary analysis and a helluva way with words!
This is the type of video people named Tanner would enjoy.
Fellow dota enjoyer i see
What does this even mean 😭
@@thesomalistrawhat Inside joke
Tanner might not enjoy this tbh
Well I think it was implied well enough that the Teiwaz higher ups other than McMurdo didn’t really like them or naze Turbine Who stated that no one likes young upstarts.
They might not have liked them, but they were happy to allow them in and work with them until it reached a point that they had surpassed them. That was when parts of Teiwaz turned against them enough to try to actually kill them.
Excellent analysis!
Even though I disagree on some points, and I personally see IBO as the most disappointing Gundam series that I have ever watched for all it's narrative faults on both an objective level and from my own subjective perspective, I deeply enjoyed and appreciate this analysis. I honestly never really had that much insight on the characters and the conclusions they come to by the end of series the same way you did. And I really appreciate your perspectives and the articulate analysis you give. I also INCREDIBALLY (you have no idea) appreciate how much you don't paint Tekkaden or even McGillis as the "villains" of the series like I see nearly every other video analyst do in the videos they make when it comes to series. Doing it by looking at it from an idiotic meta perspective. Instead of looking at it with meta-tinted glasses you actually look at the series for what it itself says. Seeing them as nothing more than tragic, and victims of both their own flaws and the cruel circumstances forced onto them. And that I cannot appreciate enough.
Cool story bro, tell it again.
There were a lot of sad deaths I felt the rage of shino being mad he couldn't destroy galihorn's ship then dying for nothing and biscuit died trying to hold on to life then orga and tawa'z and lafter even though tekkaden didn't really win completely galihorn was reformed
This is very good
Comment for the comment gods
For your first video, this is really good. You speak into the mic well, the script is well-written, the editing is great, and the use of music is nice. Hope to see more.
Poggers content
we really need another season of this masterpiece
Such an great video.
Man this video just made me notice that they used shinos eye logo for a factory :’)
this was amazing.ibo is my favourite gundam series.I was thinking about how would i write a sequel to it but your review made me realize it would lack what made ibo ibo
Excellence!
Had this in my Watch Later list for a couple of months and just got around to watching it. I'm thankful that I did, as your analysis was on point, well constructed, and beautiful. IBO is my favorite of the Gundam franchise and it's disappointing to me that Witch From Mercury couldn't live up to this as a "Next Entry" in the franchise.
Nice vid
Joint was Ight S1 I was dragging myself to finish but S2 and I was like “ok ok not bad not bad” solid 6-7 for sure
Do you know what the name of the song used in the background of the beginning of the video is
It's part of the shows OST, called "Our Home"
Thank you so much bro
The show is great, probably the best gundam. But I do feel that Rustal (Moon Commander guy) being assassinated at the end rather than Nobliss (Kudelia's former benefactor) would've left a better taste in the mouth of the audience. The whole idea was that everyone would get the comeuppance in the end for the sins they committed, but With Rustal and co still alive I felt it kinda fell flat. Rustal through out his humanity in pursuit of his ideal Gallahorn just as the other characters did in essentially executing a bunch of children to use as a scape goat, but he never really had to pay for it. Sure you could argue that his being forced to compromise with Kudelia as well as the very fact that Nobliss was assassinated could be extrapolated to mean he would eventually be forced to pay, but I do think it'd have been better if Rustal had ended up being assassinated instead. Then everyone on both sides would've been forced to lose someone balancing the proverbial ledger and having Julieta (monkey girl) succeed him with her realization that Tekaden was ultimately a product of circumstance.
I mean the whole point of my essay and the show IMO was that these things aren't fair and balanced. For all his flaws Rustal was the person Gjallarhorn needed to steady themselves and become a more responsible organization and even with his tarnished past, he led to a better future. As I said at the end, even as broken people they could leave behind something whole. The world isn't a game of balanced and fair compensation in conflict and what made this show good is that it represented that.
Season one was good, it ended on a bittersweet note but things looked promising.
Season two is what happens, when you take the needless sociopathy and sadism of evil characters, turn the nob on that up to 11 and break it off. All for no other reason than, 'well we've got a second season to fill and no other ideas'.
S1 wasnt bittersweet and Im unable to know what wasnt just the consequence of the things done in S1.
I think you may want to learn the use of narratives.
@@ParagonGoetia I don't care what you think.
@@Jaeger_Bishop Damn, not like it matters since its getting a new anime spin off, kind of sounds like you are going to be hitting your head in the near future.
Nice to know you didn't watch the second season based on the nonsense you just said
@@tutumazibuko2510 No. I watched the 2nd season and was just aggravated by is as it went along. Heaven forbid someone doesn't see the end result the way you do.
Show had alot of potential and fell short with the "ancient AI" bait-and-switch.
Literally a small segment teased in S1 which had a glimpse in S2 while the narrative took place.
If it comes down to just not following thw story then it sucks to be you, so much so people do enjoy it so its getting a spin off.
65 subs? i got you bro. 66.
Rather waxing poetic, and could stand to be 10mins or so shorter, but this was an excellent breakdown.
I like the design of the gundams and some of the fight scenes but the one thing i didnt like is the ending of this series this is the most dissapointment gundam series that i have watched.
You wanted a W, but this world building was far away of that. You can feel that along the series 😢