The Alaska Purchase - debunking a myth

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 05. 2024
  • There is a common historical myth among Americans that the Alaska Purchase in 1867 was deeply unpopular -- that Americans didn't see any value in it and ridiculed it as "Seward's Folly" and "Seward's Icebox". But in reality there was widespread support for the purchase. Most of the newspaper reporting at the time was positive or at least neutral, and the treaty easily passed the Senate.
    There were three main reasons for American support for the Alaska Purchase:
    1. Americans and Russians did in fact know (contrary to the modern myth) that Alaska was rich in natural resources.
    2. Many Americans believed that control of Alaska would make it easier to trade with Asia. (Americans had been trading with Asia since colonial times.)
    3. Most Americans were in favor of annexing the British colonies north of the U.S. (what later became Canada), and they saw the acquisition of Alaska as furthering that goal.
    One point I didn't make in the video but is worth noting:
    The Senate passed the Alaska Purchase treaty 37-2. Some modern sources erroneously claim that the purchase "barely passed by one vote". Not true. The Constitution says the Senate ratifies a treaty with two-thirds of those voting, not two-thirds of all members. So the treaty got 95% of the Senate vote, well above the 67% necessary. The Alaska Purchase had bipartisan support during one of the most politically divided periods in American history.
    Support my work on Patreon at / premodernist

Komentáře • 1K

  • @fiddleriddlediddlediddle
    @fiddleriddlediddlediddle Před rokem +793

    If any country ever wants to sell you a part of its land, for geopolitical reasons, you always say yes if you can afford it. Honestly, the resources there are usually less important than having the land itself.

    • @Mockingbird_Taloa
      @Mockingbird_Taloa Před rokem +107

      @@stevej71393 Except that the US has been doing this for decades & still does it now in the form of military leases. There are plenty of US bases around the globe that are there because the host nation's government wants them for geopolitical reasons--even though the local population itself may not necessarily be happy to have the base there at all.

    • @Dutch_Uncle
      @Dutch_Uncle Před rokem +136

      A young man, on asking an old-timer what was the best investment, received this reply, "Buy land. They are not making it anymore."

    • @jimroscovius
      @jimroscovius Před rokem +6

      @Richard Garrison Yes, but land in Africa? Can you imagine trying to protect it?

    • @Dutch_Uncle
      @Dutch_Uncle Před rokem +13

      @@jimroscovius - As a result of the Spanish-American War the US acquired the Philippines, Cuba, and some small Pacific Islands. It did not go all the way and take Spanish possessions in Africa, such as Equatorial Guinea and Spanish Morocco.

    • @goksir5845
      @goksir5845 Před rokem +14

      This isn't universal. For example Kaliningrad was never annexed by any neighbouring country because of a fear of incorporating the major majority russian population. If you look at how Russia has wound up infiltrating other countries with Russian populations, I think it was justified to see as a mistake.

  • @tarstarkusz
    @tarstarkusz Před rokem +96

    4:32 My father always called the refrigerator "the icebox" out of pure habit because he had grown up with an icebox.

    • @robertewalt7789
      @robertewalt7789 Před měsícem +1

      Both my parents said “ice box.” Both grew up in Kentucky in the 1920’s.

    • @tarstarkusz
      @tarstarkusz Před měsícem +1

      @@robertewalt7789 Mine grew up in Philadelphia in the 30s and 40s.

    • @Name-ot3xw
      @Name-ot3xw Před 24 dny

      My grandmother's icebox is where we kept the paper plates, gloves, and potatoes. She was real big on refinishing her childhood furniture.

  • @mikepowell2776
    @mikepowell2776 Před rokem +178

    I studied American history for UK ‘A’ levels back in 1967 (and rather surprisingly passed.) I have never heard a clearer exposition of any aspect of it than this - and so pleasantly and professionally delivered. Thank you very much.

    • @premodernist_history
      @premodernist_history  Před rokem +18

      Thank you!

    • @jerbear7952
      @jerbear7952 Před 3 měsíci +1

      I'm an enthusiastic but amateur historian of the USA (my home country) and Britain in its many forms to a lesser degree. In my opinion, all of the American topics I have seen him cover are air tight.

    • @kingeddiam2543
      @kingeddiam2543 Před 3 měsíci +1

      Woah you could do a specifically 'american' history a level back then? I never knew that. I'm doing my a levels now and we never had that choice

    • @ronmikebarnes2867
      @ronmikebarnes2867 Před 16 dny

      Professional lies. Is this paid propaganda? Who pays for this psychological nonsense? Google the following to know the truth about Alaska and Hawaii: “Alaska is an Apartheid State” and “Notice of Fraud to USA and the Holy See on the maladministration of Alaska and Hawaii Indigenous Nations” The deception of the racist regime United States of America and its racist political subdivisions Alaska and Hawaii are laid bare in truth about history. Why was Alaska and Hawaii listed for independence in the United Nations. They never belonged to the United States - Americans are easily brainwashed. Or naturally deceived?

  • @theclipclipper
    @theclipclipper Před rokem +1018

    That weird feeling when you realize Andrew Johnson did something right.

    • @person3070
      @person3070 Před rokem +144

      There were 2 other accomplishments during his presidency. The first was the Peonage Act of 1867, which as the name kind of insinuates, banned wage slavery, mostly in the New Mexico territory, where it was being heavily practiced. The other was the Metric Act of 1866, which facilitated trade with European nations, by allowing American businesses to use the metric system, making it easier to trade with those nations that used the metric system.

    • @STho205
      @STho205 Před rokem

      Johnson was an outsider to the one party system the Union had created during the war. He was a Democrat, that joined with the Republican president in 64 to form The Union Party...which was to encourage healing after the war. Lincoln got conveniently murdered, but the assassins missed Johnson and the Sec of State.
      Johnson then experienced JDS (Johnon Derangement Syndrome). Despite trying to fulfill post war plans that Lincoln had made publicly...Lincoln had been killed and turned into a nice dead saint of the Republic....The Party had other plans.

    • @roman111117
      @roman111117 Před rokem +66

      @@person3070 so you're saying, in the land of freedom, you needed explicit permission to use a different measurment system? 😂

    • @person3070
      @person3070 Před rokem +64

      @@roman111117
      The 19th century was a wacky time lol

    • @MrZombiekiller23
      @MrZombiekiller23 Před rokem +38

      @@person3070 America is a wacky place, time has nothing to do w it. We live in the most rich country in the world and have the the highest childhood malnourishment

  • @isstevetaken7722
    @isstevetaken7722 Před rokem +514

    This was great, hope you still get around to doing a video about why the Russians wanted to sell Alaska.

    • @premodernist_history
      @premodernist_history  Před rokem +141

      Thanks! I'm glad there's interest. I do plan to do it, but I've got some other videos coming down the pike first.

    • @AlaskaErik
      @AlaskaErik Před rokem +21

      Short answer...they needed the money.

    • @mathewfinch
      @mathewfinch Před rokem +81

      They needed the money to pay the war indemnity for the Crimean War. Also, the Crimean war showed them that they couldn't go toe-to-toe with the British Navy, and they would need to be able to do that to reasonably expect to defend Alaska. And they sold it to the US because they didn't want to sell it to the British (who at the time more directly controlled the regions that would later become Canada) because they had just finished fighting a war with the British.

    • @Rationalific
      @Rationalific Před rokem +13

      @@mathewfinch Very interesting summary. I didn't know that. Let's hope Alaska isn't the end of it and they leave Crimea as well.

    • @STho205
      @STho205 Před rokem

      In 1962 Lincoln and the Czar started making plans for a TransContinental RR and the TransSiberia RR to allow the US and Russia to supply the world without having to contend with the British and French. The British held choke points in the Mediterranean, North Sea and were acquiring choke points in China.
      If you look at the map and realize San Fran and Seattle were growing as ports at the same rate as the Kamchatka ports....with the Aleutians in-between with newly US forced open Tokyo at the bottom of that triangle...
      You'll see why decisions were made.

  • @speed7exc
    @speed7exc Před rokem +476

    Big laugh at "The United States has never had a friend among the nations of Europe save Russia". How times change. Wish things could have been turned out better between the two continent spanning nation-empires, the world would have been much better for a friendship that never failed.
    Also, I was surprised to see you only have 4.5k subscribers - the quality of your presentation made me think you had at least ten times that amount. Great work.

    • @premodernist_history
      @premodernist_history  Před rokem +161

      I know, right? Imagine how different things would be if the US and Russia had stayed friends up to the present.
      Thank you for the kind words. Believe it or not, when I published this video the channel had 0 subscribers.

    • @-haclong2366
      @-haclong2366 Před rokem +45

      France, though.

    • @WagesOfDestruction
      @WagesOfDestruction Před rokem +8

      yeah i thought exactly the same

    • @premodernist_history
      @premodernist_history  Před rokem +89

      @@stevej71393 The author of the editorial was probably referring to the fact that Britain and France had been on friendly terms with the CSA, while Russia was always solidly pro-Union. That's at least what I recall reading when I was researching this video.

    • @alecblunden8615
      @alecblunden8615 Před rokem

      So it's fine to contemplate invading colonies that had no interest in being invaded because the British North America Act had not been passed yet ? And Americans wonder why they are not universally loved

  • @nothingelse1520
    @nothingelse1520 Před 5 měsíci +63

    As someone who was raised in Alaska, graduated college there, then left the state, I am always amazed the ridiculous questions I get about Alaska sometimes. One time someone asked me if I used "American money". Another person asked if I knew anyone with a pet penguin.

    • @E4439Qv5
      @E4439Qv5 Před 5 měsíci +1

      You got money from the oil fields tho, right?

    • @nothingelse1520
      @nothingelse1520 Před 5 měsíci

      @@E4439Qv5 yes, it varies but about $1,000 a year

    • @francisluglio6611
      @francisluglio6611 Před 5 měsíci +11

      Do you miss your dog driven sleigh?

    • @nothingelse1520
      @nothingelse1520 Před 5 měsíci +6

      @@francisluglio6611 yes, very much

    • @jerbear7952
      @jerbear7952 Před 3 měsíci +2

      And yet here you are still not answering the penguin question. Could it be perhaps that YOU are the real villain here? PS, i am sorry you had to trade in your dog team. That must have been really hard, especially with the depreciation on large breed dogs that require raw salmon.

  • @mrs.g7795
    @mrs.g7795 Před 5 měsíci +38

    THIS CHANNEL IS A GEM!! I never thought any of this would be facinating to a 38yr old mom but alas here I am; recommended by my younger sister! My 15 year pld daughter was listening along in the car ride. I thought she wasn’t paying attention then she said wait mom can you go back I missed what he just said 😂😂.

  • @herzogsbuick
    @herzogsbuick Před rokem +85

    Alaskan here, who enjoys Alaska history. I learned quite a lot in this video -- I always took for granted that $7,200,000 equaled the price per acre, multiplied by the (then surveyed) size of Alaska. Fantastic stuff. And -- great shirt!

    • @celiabrickell2500
      @celiabrickell2500 Před rokem +5

      That was the price for all of Alaska!

    • @herzogsbuick
      @herzogsbuick Před rokem +4

      @@celiabrickell2500 re-reading my post, it confused my a bit. I replaced "was" with "equaled" here: "$7,200,000 equaled the price per acre multiplied by the (then surveyed) size of Alaska"
      So I was saying, for some reason, I thought they decided on a price per acre, and multiplied to get the final number. I hadn't realized the offer was straight up for everything, and when we today say "39 cents" an acre today, that's not what they were thinking

    • @johnforrest9174
      @johnforrest9174 Před rokem

      Keep up the studies fellow Alaskan! It was offered for free for over ten years-IF the new State of Columbia was allowed entre to the United States, (54degrees by 40 or FIGHT was the slogan and battle cry, ), ignore "pig island" histories, it would have BLOCKED the brit Royals from access to the Pacific forever. And freed the poor colonials of Columbia, Canada.
      I ran a radio talk show in Fairbanks, 1990's and during 4 hours these real truth(s) came out as Alaskan Historian's called in and 'straightened" ME out on the real history. It was offered for FREE by our nations friends in Russia.
      Also, during the U.S. Civil war, The Russian had the only IRON Boat" Navy and they anchored their "Iron Boats" with 50,000 sailors in NYC and San Francisco, with ORDERS to turn over that Navy to President Abe Lincoln to attack ANY nation who recognized the 'Confederacy"."
      Confederate gold was sent to Canada to make confederate monies and bills.
      To this DAY the brits continue to demand 'civil wars' and divisions in the UNION, to break up the largest republic in the world.

    • @McWillis
      @McWillis Před rokem +6

      Was amazed he had a Strong Bad shirt. ❤❤

  • @liversuccess1420
    @liversuccess1420 Před rokem +80

    This was a great video. I'm glad you talked about the American interest in acquiring Canada. I've read in a book called "Future History of the Arctic" that Seward and other Americans had pretty intense interest in acquiring British Columbia, perhaps more so than Alaska. But John MacDonald maneuvered to prevent that as he wanted Canada to have a Pacific outlet and was very concerned about Canada being absorbed by the U.S.

    • @CuyanaTGen
      @CuyanaTGen Před rokem

      You may already be aware of this, but, at the outset of the American Revolutionary War [June 1775], the 2nd Continental Congress INITIATED an INVASION OF CANADA. They wanted to drive the British out of CANADA and get the French to join the American effort for independence. This invasion, right after the skirmishes at Lexington and Concord [April 1775], was the first large-scale military action by the newly formed Continental Army. Before betraying the USA, Benedict Arnold played a significant role in this invasion.

    • @kakyoin9688
      @kakyoin9688 Před 6 měsíci

      Canada will fall to America

  • @geoffreydesena587
    @geoffreydesena587 Před rokem +36

    Fascinating. I’ve been through a few American history courses, and they’ve all glossed over this bit, which is a shame. This really helps wrap my head around how Americans saw manifest destiny in the 19th century.

  • @vanrozay8871
    @vanrozay8871 Před rokem +11

    In Manhattan, in the late 40s and early 50s, my mom's Aunt Louise, in a small apartment, had an icebox and bought a "refill" from an iceman weekly.

  • @kcaleb
    @kcaleb Před rokem +32

    I'm from BC, I've always found it interesting when I read histories and important documents from the 1880's when British Columbia had to decide whether it would remain British, become independent, join the US, or join Canada.
    Apparently joining either the US or Canada were the two most popular options. We went with Canada because Canada offered a railway to join, and because many British Columbians had a bad impression of Americans do to some rowdy prospectors coming north during a gold rush.

    • @francus7227
      @francus7227 Před rokem +7

      Let me tell ya.... We Americans only got MORE rowdy. Ever see the cartoon Yosemite Sam? Based on truth.... The ruffest, tuffest, rootenest, tootenest, gunslingest, rowdiest outlaw cowboy in da west...

    • @hotdogguy273
      @hotdogguy273 Před rokem +6

      I'm actually kinda glad we didn't get BC. Would have been kinda mean cutting Canada off from the Pacific. But more importantly, it would have made our border look weird

    • @Pyrolonn
      @Pyrolonn Před rokem +1

      @@hotdogguy273 Really is is good that the U.S. didn't get BC and the rest of the N.A. territory north of 49°N, for the simple reason that Canadians actually live and work there, but if it wasn't the southern extent, it would just be unsettled wasteland.

    • @eastvandb
      @eastvandb Před rokem +4

      @@Pyrolonn
      Don't think so. The areas the Coast Salish nations lived on (Which is much of Vancouver Island and Greater Vancouver) were abundant with fish and game. They lived a beautiful life before we stole their land. It was rich country with tons of waterways; it was going to be heavily populated no matter which colonists ended up there.

    • @johnforrest9174
      @johnforrest9174 Před rokem

      "decide" hahahaha the KING STOLE that land and oppressed the Canadian's ever since with Hudson's Bay. (and now Locked up at home in the royal censoring masks, for over two years!

  • @danielbabb4776
    @danielbabb4776 Před 2 lety +58

    I am researching this topic right now for a presentation tomorrow and yours has been one of the most organized and informative sources I have seen! Your video deserves so many more views!

  • @BoerChris
    @BoerChris Před rokem +22

    Thanks for a fascinating video. I am British (despite the CZcams handle), and I had never devoted much thought to the Alaska Purchase before. Above all, you show how important it is, when studying history, to look closely at the perceptions of the time rather than view things in retrospect.

  • @PhoenixDQ
    @PhoenixDQ Před rokem +22

    I was quietly enjoying listening to this while working... then... STRONGBAD SHIRT. Mr. History Prof Guy just got a hell of a lot cooler.

    • @nicolasvidal92
      @nicolasvidal92 Před 2 měsíci

      A Strongbad shirt in 2021 in such good condition too! Mine are all ratty now from when I got them in the 2010's

  • @zombienectar
    @zombienectar Před rokem +5

    Louis Lamour novel Sitka was about the Alaska purchase. An excellent read.

  • @JumpydeerbobHD
    @JumpydeerbobHD Před rokem +26

    What a lucky find your channel is! The videos are extremely well made, and hosted by someone who appears to absolutely love history. Thanks for making these!

  • @punishedbarca761
    @punishedbarca761 Před rokem +9

    The way you present everything so concisely and conversationally is amazing. Thanks for the videos!

  • @mrgreenweaver
    @mrgreenweaver Před 5 měsíci +5

    I learned in school (in Alaska) that it was like the best deal for us ever, but never heard of anyone thinking it was a bad deal. Some cities like Fairbanks formed because of a gold rush

  • @normaaliihminen722
    @normaaliihminen722 Před rokem +31

    As Finnish guy who is interested about knowing history of USA I think I have found my golden channel for consuming it, Thank you!

    • @YOYO-xy3yg
      @YOYO-xy3yg Před rokem +3

      if you dont mind telling me, what makes you interested in the history of the usa? i always see finns doing this

    • @normaaliihminen722
      @normaaliihminen722 Před rokem +15

      @@YOYO-xy3yg Its a birth story (biography if you will) to most influential country in modern age.

  • @endokrin7897
    @endokrin7897 Před rokem +6

    What's more interesting than the Alaska Purchase, in my opinion, is the extra information about the colony of British Columbia and other 'Canadian' colonies North of the United States.
    I had no idea there were more Colonies that 'could have' been part of the U.S. 🤯
    If B.C. had joined, and a couple colonies in the Northeast, wow, the map would look completely different! How would that have changed geopolitics?
    Why don't they teach this in school? Everything in history class seems to start from the present day looking backwards, through the lens of modern-day America, instead of 'starting at the beginning' and showing how things moved forward in time.

  • @dragonfurry69
    @dragonfurry69 Před rokem +28

    I'm a simple man. I see a fellow academic wearing a Strong Bad T-shirt, I hit the like button.

  • @traildoggy
    @traildoggy Před rokem +80

    Crazy to think how different things would be if instead Russia maintained land and a political boundary in North America, or even just the same cultural influence as the French in Canada. There's so many moving parts it's hard to even imagine what might have happened.

    • @andrewsuryali8540
      @andrewsuryali8540 Před rokem +17

      The problem with Russian colonialism was that they had expanded into areas that were already full of people, had a bustling economy and plenty of culture, long before they even got into Siberia. It was a heck of a lot easier to convince Russians to move to cozy Samarkand, the capital of ancient empires, than to start up a colony in Alaska. There's a reason Russian regimes had to exile people to Siberia. By the time Russians got Alaska, they had basically run out of people willing to go there. By contrast, Americans had been expanding into depopulated lands for over two centuries. Even if the Alaska purchase had not happened, demographics pressure would have kicked the Russians out of the region anyway.

    • @normaaliihminen722
      @normaaliihminen722 Před rokem +5

      @@andrewsuryali8540 Not to mention Russia has resource curse just like some African countries.

    • @johnrigler8858
      @johnrigler8858 Před rokem +5

      It is probable that GB would have annexed Alaska and added it to Canada had the USA not purchased it in 1867!

    • @Ray-fk4vh
      @Ray-fk4vh Před rokem +1

      @@normaaliihminen722 not true

    • @jasonhaven7170
      @jasonhaven7170 Před rokem

      @@andrewsuryali8540 "depopulated" They literally genocided Native Americans through scalp bounties

  • @christianwestling2019
    @christianwestling2019 Před rokem +6

    This reminds me that during the Civil War, russian naval ships patrolled New York Harbour to keep it safe when the US Navy was down south fighting the war.
    And a couple of years later the US could negotiate to buy Alaska.
    So odd that there were such warm relations between the US and Russia, considering later history and today.

    • @giantgeoff
      @giantgeoff Před 6 měsíci +3

      Not as odd as you might think. There are many instances where Russian people and American people have gotten along famously. In WW2 the Soldiers not only appreciated our lend lease aid but also remembered the Famine Relief aid that was sent in the '20's and '30's from America (by NGO's I believe) They may not have not known anything else about America but the saw the printing on the outside of the sacks of food that saved their lives.

  • @timlecount8690
    @timlecount8690 Před rokem +10

    Just discovered your video and channel. Thank you so much, this was really well-done and captivating. I teach AK history at a high school in Palmer, and was pleased that you touched on so many points that I teach in my class. AND I learned something new about the .2 added on to the 7 million. Thanks again!

  • @kelly2558
    @kelly2558 Před rokem +5

    Nice to encounter someone who is well spoken and has a quiet passion and deep respect for history. A person who dispenses with sensationalism, talks in measured tones and not in love with the sound of their own voice or amazed with their own incites. Someone whose priority is to teach and clarify above being entertaining. Puts me in mind of one of my countries most revered historical researcher/lecturers, the late great Pierre Berton.

  • @mikeworksatharkins
    @mikeworksatharkins Před rokem +15

    I recently found this channel and love all your videos! Mad props for the Strong Bad shirt too!!!

  • @ScabbyBoi
    @ScabbyBoi Před 5 měsíci +3

    Fantastic video. As a fan of history educated in the U.S. you always manage to find topics that it seems we know just a ~little bit~ about, but never enough that we were taught all of the nuance and interesting details in school. The fact that you cover seem to cover whatever subjects strike your interest whenever you catch a wave of motivation to make a video makes the material that much better. Please continue to deliver content on interesting points in pre-modern and early modern history, and please continue to deliver them at a pace that feels comfortable and allows you to do your best. THANKYOU :)

  • @iakona23
    @iakona23 Před rokem +5

    The U.S. Ambassador to Russia, Cassius Clay, never gets the credit that he deserves for his personal relationship with the Czar and for his efforts to persuade the Czar to sell Alaska to the USA.

  • @nedmerrill5705
    @nedmerrill5705 Před 3 měsíci +1

    My wife and I visited William Seward's home (now a museum) in Auburn, NY and saw Seward's icebox.

  • @KristianWontroba
    @KristianWontroba Před rokem +10

    Great historical content! And great Strong Bad T-shirt!

  • @BostonsF1nest
    @BostonsF1nest Před 7 měsíci +6

    I remember reading once that ice was actually one of the most valuable commodities on the Oregon Trail

  • @Mockingbird_Taloa
    @Mockingbird_Taloa Před rokem +5

    This filled in some details about things I knew or guessed in part, many thanks! Style and use of graphics is spot-on.
    I'd love to see videos on the Russian interest in selling Alaska and the underhanded acquisition and quasi-forced statehood of Hawai'i.

  • @samsonsoturian6013
    @samsonsoturian6013 Před 3 měsíci +2

    I've seen people keep refusing to believe it was worth the money despite the amount of oil per year alone exceeded the purchase price

  • @michaelinminn
    @michaelinminn Před rokem +4

    I am a history aficionado.
    Thanks for this post - nicely written - and debunking the Seward's Folly myth.

  • @BS-vx8dg
    @BS-vx8dg Před rokem +14

    This is my second video of yours I have watched, having watched the 1789 Presidential election immediately before this. I think you have a great voice and a great style with great pacing. You include details that 99.9% of us don't know, but they are actually *interesting* details. I don't know how much you produce, but you've just gotten a new subscriber.

  • @gerryreihsen5084
    @gerryreihsen5084 Před rokem +7

    I'd also love a video about the Colonies beyond the 13 that originally came together to oppose and free themselves from British rule and why the other colonies did not join them.

  • @vlogbrotherdave
    @vlogbrotherdave Před rokem +1

    FASCINATING! Thank you for this in-depth content; I'm currently binge-watching your channel.

  • @picklikeapro6952
    @picklikeapro6952 Před rokem +1

    Please make more videos. You mention so many details I’ve never heard before in any videos and they’re important things. I’m learning a lot on your few videos you have.

  • @Chris-ut6eq
    @Chris-ut6eq Před rokem +15

    Came for the content and stayed for the strongbad shirt :)

  • @thesodaman1132
    @thesodaman1132 Před rokem +5

    Pretty great video. Seward lived in my hometown but I never learned too much about him besides being able to visit his house a few times. This was really informative and interesting. Thanks!

  • @karyldavidkidd7111
    @karyldavidkidd7111 Před rokem +1

    I adore the amount of information delivered here. Bloody brilliant!
    Thank you bud

  • @DeathclawJedi
    @DeathclawJedi Před rokem +3

    Good presentation.... And love the Strongbad shirt dude!
    I just kinda stumbled onto this video. Watched in full and had already subscribed by the 1/2 way point. Looking forward to watching more!

  • @kevincrowley6561
    @kevincrowley6561 Před 9 měsíci +3

    You are one of the best CZcams historians! Keep it up!

  • @bing0bongo
    @bing0bongo Před rokem +8

    This was very interesting! I had no idea that the US purchasing Alaska and making moves to potentially acquire British Columbia was one of the largest motivating factors for the creation of Canada as a country!

    • @matthewsmith5104
      @matthewsmith5104 Před rokem

      It was one of the factors, yeah, although the process of Confederation was already underway by then, for example: The Charlottetown Conference and then the Quebec Conference, both in 1864, and then the London Conference in 1866, so Confederation was a years-long process that was already in motion by then. The British North America Act of 1867, while it went into effect on July 1 (Dominon Day, later Canada Day), it received Royal Assent in March. The American purchase of Alaska probably had a larger effect on British Columbia joining Canada 4 years later in 1871 and the construction of the transcontinental railroad linking it to the rest of Canada.

  • @stingfan16ify
    @stingfan16ify Před rokem +1

    Great job in filling in many missing details of historical significance that I wasn't aware of!

  • @nehemiahjandroep4568
    @nehemiahjandroep4568 Před 4 měsíci +2

    Stumbled upon your channel about a week ago. Love your content! Keep posting!

  • @robertortiz-wilson1588
    @robertortiz-wilson1588 Před rokem +7

    I genuinely do enjoy learning about this, thank you so much!

  • @StephenGillie
    @StephenGillie Před rokem +3

    14:47 Thank you for putting Longitudinal History at the bottom of the timeline. Seeing worldwide events really makes history feel real.

  • @dudeskeela
    @dudeskeela Před rokem +2

    i could listen to you discuss 19th century american history for hours. great video!!

  • @ajjake3135
    @ajjake3135 Před rokem +2

    You're good. I like the way you put yourself in those time periods, like you are actually there, and explain how other things were going on and how they relate to the topic. Makes "History" more believable and interesting. Can you do something, in your style, covering the history of Native Americans? Anything. Thank you.

  • @tommybreeze5476
    @tommybreeze5476 Před rokem +3

    I do enjoy this stuff a ton, and thanks so much for making these videos! I just found them and I'm sure I'll be watching more. Any future videos planned about other American expansions in the west?

  • @Jeremy-sj8xv
    @Jeremy-sj8xv Před rokem +6

    Great video, my undergrad thesis was about the tension between Russia and Britain and Russia had a lot of geopolitical incentives to sell to the US

  • @ZZ-sb8os
    @ZZ-sb8os Před rokem +1

    Just stumbled onto this channel, loving it so far!

  • @parkependleton6453
    @parkependleton6453 Před rokem +1

    I just discovered your CZcams channel in the last hour. Fantastic!

  • @DeepStateCrisisActor
    @DeepStateCrisisActor Před rokem +3

    Your T-shirt reminded me of some early internet days I had totally forgotten about. Strong bad or whatever its called lol. Homestar runner. Wow, just took a direct hit of nostalgia.

  • @-haclong2366
    @-haclong2366 Před rokem +8

    13:57 I just like how dry and direct that message is "British America and Mexico clearly belong to us".
    Edit: grammar

  • @bradleyneufeld6127
    @bradleyneufeld6127 Před rokem +2

    Amazing videos. It's lovely having a presenter more interested in the content than the monetization

  • @_Westory
    @_Westory Před rokem +1

    this channel is really well done! I hope you reach 50k soon!

  • @bamuz
    @bamuz Před rokem +3

    Just discovered your channel, and I must say I enjoy how you present the information-subbed and look forward to more content!

  • @ruslanreyisov6227
    @ruslanreyisov6227 Před rokem +3

    Hello from Uzbekistan. This channel is so useful for a lot of information...
    Thanks for all of them

  • @jonathanlong6987
    @jonathanlong6987 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Shreveport, LA bred & reared. Delighted a (defunct) local newspaper was cited. And, I learned the AK purchase was less controversial than I thot. Thank you for “edumakating” me.

  • @Norsilca
    @Norsilca Před rokem +5

    Just wanted to say,
    ♥️ the Strong Bad shirt

  • @TechedCanvas
    @TechedCanvas Před rokem +6

    Can you make a video about the history of Hawai’i? Love your videos! Fantastic stuff man

  • @williamburroughs9686
    @williamburroughs9686 Před 11 měsíci +3

    Wow! Reading this article about what/how Russia like back then with the United states is amazing.
    4:37 Wooden iceboxes? Now that painting of fruit in the cabinet makes since. It was an icebox.
    5:00 lol. Now that is a long trip just so you can get ice.

  • @jefffinlayson3002
    @jefffinlayson3002 Před rokem +2

    Your video provided a lot of good background and details, thanks!

  • @ipolygon1
    @ipolygon1 Před 3 měsíci

    Man great video. I love your voice and how confident you are.

  • @johnnyrocketed2225
    @johnnyrocketed2225 Před rokem +14

    Had no idea that there were more than 13 colonies. I guess I knew there were other colonies but I didn’t know they could have joined the rebellion. Also always thought Florida was a Spanish colony during the revolution. Thanks! 👍😊

    • @curtiskretzer8898
      @curtiskretzer8898 Před rokem +1

      1704 Gibraltar was traded from Spain to Btitain for Florida. During revolution
      '79-'83,🇬🇧controlled
      🇬🇮was under seige from imperial France & Spain!

  • @AndrewVelonis
    @AndrewVelonis Před rokem +5

    Ice production was a substantial industry in the northeast from about 1870 - 1920. Maybe you could do a segment on that.

  • @casinozx
    @casinozx Před měsícem +1

    A little late to the party but wow this video is fantastic! I love the way you put it together. Thanks!

  • @1948DavidB
    @1948DavidB Před rokem +2

    Please make more presentations like this on any subject, no less. You have outstanding talent!
    I'm going to recommend You to The Great Courses Program. At this point, I'll have to send them the information from a forward email.

  • @Angry.Dinosaur
    @Angry.Dinosaur Před rokem +35

    I feel stupid watching this. This was far more involved than I thought. Thank you sir.

    • @premodernist_history
      @premodernist_history  Před rokem +28

      I feel the same way when studying history. The more one learns about the past, the more one realizes how little one knows.

    • @mejsjalv
      @mejsjalv Před rokem +4

      Don't! History is long and far too complex. A lot of people complain "why wasn't I thought this in school?". Keep in mind that aside from teaching you geography and history, your teachers most likely had to spend time putting order in the class and attending to their resposibilities as the adult in charge and a lot of that is also part of your formation. In this day and age, if you want to know more about the stuff from school, just look up whatever topic that makes you curious in the technological wonder you hold in your hand or keep in your pocket.
      I'm not even American but I really enjoy learning about this stuff. "What's that going to help me in life??"... Well, now in my 40's, I can say it helped me keep myself entertained to develop a taste for history topics from all over the world. Especially during the recent lockdowns and the times I have been unemployed. Other than that, I also get to talk about stuff with people. Or just kill some time learning about something I did not knew about.

  • @corringhamdepot4434
    @corringhamdepot4434 Před rokem +18

    Wouldn't Alaska also give the US some control over the North West Passage that was being explored around this time. If it ever became a viable route.

    • @kodiakkeith
      @kodiakkeith Před rokem +7

      The NW passage was a "thing" in the mid/late 1700s. By this time the idea had been long abandoned.

  • @DBag-1212
    @DBag-1212 Před rokem +1

    Awesome video I love your channel. Can't wait to watch you grow

  • @patrickraymondthierry2334

    Such great content. Very well researched and spoken!

  • @huntabascan
    @huntabascan Před rokem +7

    I am in so much odd with many when I am trying to tell this and other stories. I grew up in Hungary, where I had books in my grandmother attic, waiting for burning in the 1960 is. She was a member of the party, and got lot of books, including some related to this topic. I still remember as a child telling people, I will live in Alaska. I was ridiculed, a bit treacherous, but now I am here for passing the age of sourdough. And this justified my memory, and my point. Thanks,

    • @Dutch_Uncle
      @Dutch_Uncle Před rokem +2

      I have worked as a tour guide in Alaska, and I asked a Russian guide/escort of a Russian tour group how the US acquisition of Alaska was explained in her school days. She said that the line was that the US had leased Alaska, and did not return it to Russia after the term of the lease expired. The party line in the classroom.

    • @huntabascan
      @huntabascan Před rokem

      @@Dutch_Uncle I think that is just so silly, she messing up royally. Even, if she says that how started, Who leased it, the czar made a sale and it is provable. And the US at the time hag it asa a territory, because the. uS government was decent, and let the Statehood be chosen by the people. She is another outlandish lunatic, because she does not think or ignorant. First of it, this land was taken in by Kathrine the great, second of it, if she is right, then the Japanese Island, Kuril or those near by India should go back. Im so fed up with idiocy that takes lives for no reason.

  • @atimholt
    @atimholt Před rokem +4

    I've been living in Alaska for the last couple years now. This is stuff I need to know!

  • @russellrichards2834
    @russellrichards2834 Před rokem +1

    Great subject, great content , more please . Thanks for your hard work .

  • @Mark-im6pm
    @Mark-im6pm Před rokem +1

    Thank you! Very well done and those extra pieces added to the enjoyment

  • @covercalls88
    @covercalls88 Před rokem +3

    Great to know about Alaska. History is not always as portrayed. I wonder how a few of generations from now will they view what's going on now.

  • @mrcharlyie5393
    @mrcharlyie5393 Před rokem +4

    Can't belive the ice expedition Simpsons scene ended up becoming true

  • @Grev333
    @Grev333 Před rokem +1

    Your content and presentation are mostly excellent. I think upgrading your thumbnails could net you some well deserved views and subscribers.

  • @alexvlk
    @alexvlk Před 7 měsíci +1

    A suggestion? Request? Desire. A historiography on WHY and where these misunderstandings occur. Would be enjoyable.

  • @zacharyharrisnc
    @zacharyharrisnc Před rokem +10

    Would be really interested to learn more about what was going on in the other colonies at the time of the revolution.

    • @raa836
      @raa836 Před rokem +1

      Totally agree

  • @P-B-G_YT
    @P-B-G_YT Před rokem +8

    It's not that I necessarily like the topic of the Alaska Purchase, but because I live less than 100 miles from the Alaska Border, in Whitehorse, Yukon, that I find the topic interesting.

    • @Dutch_Uncle
      @Dutch_Uncle Před rokem +2

      I have enjoyed visits to the Beringia Exhibit in Whitehorse whilst driving the Alaska Highway. My only chance to use an atlatl.

    • @P-B-G_YT
      @P-B-G_YT Před rokem +1

      @@Dutch_Uncle Funnily enough, I've also thrown an atlatl spear at the Berengia Center more than a decade ago.

    • @Dutch_Uncle
      @Dutch_Uncle Před rokem +2

      @@P-B-G_YT It looks like a hard way to get food, but hunger is a powerful motivator.

  • @kevinlindstrom6752
    @kevinlindstrom6752 Před rokem +1

    Very cool detail. Thank you for sharing all of that.

  • @michaelfitzgerald434
    @michaelfitzgerald434 Před rokem +1

    Quite excellent, thank you! You have an excellent narration style.

  • @paulpavich4174
    @paulpavich4174 Před rokem +3

    "the reason for this is a little arcane, but if you got this far in the video you're probably really into this"😆

  • @sminthian
    @sminthian Před rokem +4

    I used to live in Kodiak and Dutch Harbor, and have moved around a lot in between. It would have been neat if we bought coastal land next to Canada to drive straight up.

    • @MarloSoBalJr
      @MarloSoBalJr Před rokem

      The initial plan was to take the territory of British Columbia but UK & US agreed on the 49th Parallel.
      Off that at the same time, Alaska was purchased.

  • @christosvoskresye
    @christosvoskresye Před 2 měsíci +1

    The timing is what surprises me, coming as it did immediately after a very destructive civil war.

  • @peterk.4266
    @peterk.4266 Před rokem +1

    A fascinating channel. Very good job dude.

  • @user-wl1uz5sb9f
    @user-wl1uz5sb9f Před rokem +5

    Great video! Extremely underrated!

  • @jeffshoemake7348
    @jeffshoemake7348 Před rokem +3

    I'm just here for that kickin' Strong Bad shirt.

  • @ADPuckey
    @ADPuckey Před 5 měsíci +1

    Nice informative video of course, but I'm most grateful for finding out about Maximilian I of Mexico via your timeline. I feel like I'm going crazy, I had no idea the Habsburgs were involved in Mexico

  • @DillonPlaysGuitar
    @DillonPlaysGuitar Před rokem +2

    Wow you really do cover all historical peiods huh
    Great channel wish you luck expanding it

  • @paulbuschman8318
    @paulbuschman8318 Před rokem +11

    Excellent!
    I wonder how the "Seward's Folly" myth arose and what were the motivations behind it or those with interests in creating that narrative... In other words, why were they critical of the purchase?

    • @Rynewulf
      @Rynewulf Před 11 měsíci +3

      Maybe early opponents of colonialism and imperialism, who took the chance to criticise territorial expansion? I know there were similar complaints that led to Cuba not being annexed, and challenges to taking Peurto Rico and the Mexican territories

    • @Ben.....
      @Ben..... Před 3 měsíci

      Likely a partisan attack at the time that makes for an easy keyword for tests in primary school

    • @kenneth9874
      @kenneth9874 Před 3 měsíci

      Political, one side trying to discredit the other

  • @josephpadula2283
    @josephpadula2283 Před rokem +3

    My family came from Italy and had a very successful business selling ice and coal to homes……

  • @AntiNihilist
    @AntiNihilist Před rokem +2

    Me. A ten year old. Playing Yukon Trail: "People thought there wasn't gold a few hundred miles from the Yukon!? What are you stupid?"

  • @davidllewis4075
    @davidllewis4075 Před rokem +1

    You have filled a vast gap in my knowledge which I did not know existed.