What are these ridiculous comments about comparing ballet dancers. “Natalia did it better” “Marianela did it better” both are yes different but beautifully unique. Every dancer will deliver their own interpretation with their little nuances, this it what I love about ballet.
Actually, Alina does it best. Just kidding. She was just the first I ever saw dance this iconic role back in 2006. BUT, you're absolutely correct. There's no point comparing these wonderful dancers. As you say " ... [they each] deliver their own interpretation with their little nuances, this it what I love about ballet.". However, I have recently come to love Nela so much. There truly is something very special about her, an aura perhaps.
I love Natalia Osipova. She is one of my favorite dancers. Yet, with all due respect to her, Nela is the Svetlana Zakharova of the Royal Ballet. Even so, Natalia, Nela, and Cojocaru (when she was still there) are the three queens of the Royal. 💖
I think it's fair to compare ballet dancers' different interpretations of a role. Marianela Nunez is my favourite ballerina, but I think Natalia Osipova's interpretation makes a better Giselle. I'm not calling one dancer's ability greater than the other, they are both wonderful artists. And I'm not saying that anyone who champions Ms Nunez in the role is wrong. I'm stating my preference for one interpretation over another and I don't think it's offensive to say that.
I love that I can see how much Marianela loves ballet through her acting as Giselle, who also loves dancing despite her heart condition. So much dedication goes into being a professional dancer and you can’t do it without the passion and love for dance.
oh i love how Nunez dance and always looking at her mom like "mom! see this! i did it!" is so pure and endearing at the same time. She presented Giselle as a young girl with passion with cuteness so well. While in Osipova giselle she seems like floating into the clouds, dancing like flowers flowing all around her, soft and elegantly catches audiences heart and makes you understand how she is outstanding in her village. These ballerina always interpret their character in different ways and in most unique way possible I love them so much and one cannot compare with each other at all!
Nunez just makes me smile. Her joy of exquisite dancing is palpable and knowing her Giselle's moment before the princess richly pours out her happiness of found love in Albrecht; which we learn tragically is not providence. Nunez is a Royal Ballet treasure.
Wow. She’s amazing. I love her personal style and interpretation of this piece and she smiles radiantly whenever she dances, she gives such joy to everyone who watches 💖
Eso es interpretar! Hoy parece primar el bailarín gimnasta, al artista.... es un placer contemplar la maravillosa expresividad y la perfección técnica de Marianela
John Doe I'm firm on my opinions. Yours don't change mine. I find Nunez more natural and just as dramatic. Not only her variation is a delight to watch, her acting before Giselle death is incomparable. I saw her tear up in the scene. Last but not least I find her more attractive and calming to look at. Natalia has ugly shoes and she has gained weight recently don't know if it is due to a break up.
WOAH WOAH WOAH WOAAAH! Acting: Ok let's just say it's the best acting that exists! Dancing: You can see she is Giselle! Just dancing for everyone! Iconic moment: Okay, i'm beginning to feel like this Giselle is a true dancer! BETTER THAN NATALIA OSIPOVA!!! Reason: Natalia Osipova made a big mistake on changing the choreography. She made most of the moves harder. GISELLE WAS A PEASANT GIRL! SHE DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO DO HARD STUFF SINCE SHE DIDN'T HAVE A TEACHER! MAYBE SHE LOVES TO DANCE SO MUCH BUT WITHOUT LESSONS YOU SURELY CAN'T BE THAT GOOD!
HorrorFlood every dancer has different style to dancing, for example natalia, when she dance , she look powerfull, so spirit, she is to fast when piruette..
This is ballet... everyone can dance in ballet drama, and besides, Giselle is supposed to express herself by dance. And this is just your opinion, no need to hate on Natalia Osipova so much. Also, in my own opinion, Natalia had a more ecstatic, in love spirit than her, and her acting is more natural, so I prefer her. However, I think Marianela has skill too, all of her moves are so graceful and on point. Their dancing styles are different, and it is this dance you prefer, but you don't have to be such a hater about it.
What's ridiculous is your glorification of Russian technique. Why the hell should the entire world about what Russian ballerinas do? I don't care about an impoverished, sickly thin Giselle. I'd rather prefer Fracci as Giselle over any Russian ballerina, Ulanova included. And FYI, putting a hand on the waist does not 'define' a character. Get over yourself!
Osipova is a different Giselle. But I do wish that she focused less on the gymnastics in this variation. Giselle had a weak heart, so moving around like an athlete should have been impossible.
What are these ridiculous comments about comparing ballet dancers. “Natalia did it better” “Marianela did it better” both are yes different but beautifully unique. Every dancer will deliver their own interpretation with their little nuances, this it what I love about ballet.
Yes i agree with you.. cause every dancer have diferent style, diferen unique
I totally agree!
Actually, Alina does it best. Just kidding. She was just the first I ever saw dance this iconic role back in 2006. BUT, you're absolutely correct. There's no point comparing these wonderful dancers. As you say " ... [they each] deliver their own interpretation with their little nuances, this it what I love about ballet.". However, I have recently come to love Nela so much. There truly is something very special about her, an aura perhaps.
I love Natalia Osipova. She is one of my favorite dancers. Yet, with all due respect to her, Nela is the Svetlana Zakharova of the Royal Ballet. Even so, Natalia, Nela, and Cojocaru (when she was still there) are the three queens of the Royal. 💖
I think it's fair to compare ballet dancers' different interpretations of a role. Marianela Nunez is my favourite ballerina, but I think Natalia Osipova's interpretation makes a better Giselle. I'm not calling one dancer's ability greater than the other, they are both wonderful artists. And I'm not saying that anyone who champions Ms Nunez in the role is wrong. I'm stating my preference for one interpretation over another and I don't think it's offensive to say that.
Nela has full control over her powers, that hop sequence, just look at her control there.
And she is good in acting..
I love that I can see how much Marianela loves ballet through her acting as Giselle, who also loves dancing despite her heart condition. So much dedication goes into being a professional dancer and you can’t do it without the passion and love for dance.
Yes she dance beacuse love to dance.. 💖💖
The skirt makes her performance more magical (it looks like in slow slow motion )
oh i love how Nunez dance and always looking at her mom like "mom! see this! i did it!" is so pure and endearing at the same time. She presented Giselle as a young girl with passion with cuteness so well. While in Osipova giselle she seems like floating into the clouds, dancing like flowers flowing all around her, soft and elegantly catches audiences heart and makes you understand how she is outstanding in her village. These ballerina always interpret their character in different ways and in most unique way possible I love them so much and one cannot compare with each other at all!
Nunez just makes me smile. Her joy of exquisite dancing is palpable and knowing her Giselle's moment before the princess richly pours out her happiness of found love in Albrecht; which we learn tragically is not providence. Nunez is a Royal Ballet treasure.
Wow. She’s amazing. I love her personal style and interpretation of this piece and she smiles radiantly whenever she dances, she gives such joy to everyone who watches 💖
I love how Nela give life to every character she dance
Well idrk ab that cause she kinda turned into a ghost in act ii so.. ://
I think Natalia and Marianela are equally as amazing, just in their own way! 🙂
Señor Gabi every dancer has different style..
Biansa Wira exactly
Best Giselle ever seen! Clean and lovely!
Mi bailarina favorita es marianela nuñez
The coordination of the tempi of the conductor and her dancing is a study in inspired collaboration.
Marianela = divne!
Eso es interpretar! Hoy parece primar el bailarín gimnasta, al artista.... es un placer contemplar la maravillosa expresividad y la perfección técnica de Marianela
How she put the character into her dance burst my tears...don’t you all feel it too?🥰
She has both "Sense and sensitivity". I always find myself sharing the emotions that she conveys.
her smile is so sweet, she's the best giselle for me
I love how Mayara is in the back as a corps dancer, but is now performing Myrtha as a principal. Amazing 🤩
que pedazo de artista, como expresa, como siente, como se mueve
Dio quanto è brava Marianela
This is absolutely my favorite version of this, I was so sad when I got deleted. I haven't seen this is years so thank you so much for reuploading
Nela is so amazing
Безупречная техника!!! И шарм!!!
seeing nela dancing so happily and enjoying all the movements makes me smile 🥰
This was done technically very well.
0:29 ♡0:44♡♡
Perfekt 😍 🤩😍
Ela é muito linda
is natalia in the background watching her? thats so cute :)!
I fcking loved it ❤️ omg
This is in The Royal O.H right? Anyway, Amazingly-Beautiful performance
beautiful❤❤❤
1:05
A ce soir 🎉
Marianela and Natalia danced it a little differently. Does anybody know if it is their choice or the choice of choreographer or other?
It’s their choice. They have a different style.
Wow
🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Angel…!
1
Questa ballerina eccelle in tutto!
Θέλω κάποτε να χορέψω σαν και αυτή
Incredible. So much charisma and charm. You can see the traces and style of British ballet from her. Better than Natalia
John Doe
I'm firm on my opinions. Yours don't change mine. I find Nunez more natural and just as dramatic. Not only her variation is a delight to watch, her acting before Giselle death is incomparable. I saw her tear up in the scene. Last but not least I find her more attractive and calming to look at. Natalia has ugly shoes and she has gained weight recently don't know if it is due to a break up.
@John Doe yeah but technique wise marianela >>>>>>>>>>>>> osipova
@John Doe what a joke, love natalia but she has many faults when it comes to technique.
@John Doe well, technique is not subjective
@John Doe are u saying that things like ending a pirouette in the 6th position is subjective? not even students in ballet schools do that.
WOAH WOAH WOAH WOAAAH!
Acting: Ok let's just say it's the best acting that exists!
Dancing: You can see she is Giselle! Just dancing for everyone!
Iconic moment: Okay, i'm beginning to feel like this Giselle is a true dancer!
BETTER THAN NATALIA OSIPOVA!!!
Reason: Natalia Osipova made a big mistake on changing the choreography. She made most of the moves harder. GISELLE WAS A PEASANT GIRL! SHE DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO DO HARD STUFF SINCE SHE DIDN'T HAVE A TEACHER! MAYBE SHE LOVES TO DANCE SO MUCH BUT WITHOUT LESSONS YOU SURELY CAN'T BE THAT GOOD!
HorrorFlood every dancer has different style to dancing, for example natalia, when she dance , she look powerfull, so spirit, she is to fast when piruette..
@@biansawira2511 Imagine changing a tradition that you love the way it is.
This is ballet... everyone can dance in ballet drama, and besides, Giselle is supposed to express herself by dance. And this is just your opinion, no need to hate on Natalia Osipova so much. Also, in my own opinion, Natalia had a more ecstatic, in love spirit than her, and her acting is more natural, so I prefer her. However, I think Marianela has skill too, all of her moves are so graceful and on point. Their dancing styles are different, and it is this dance you prefer, but you don't have to be such a hater about it.
too slow version.....
whats with the hand at the waist?? i wish the theatres outside of russia cared about character dancing this just looks ridiculous
mar nev Her hand at the waist makes it more flirtatious , it adds to the character of a " peasant" girl.Don't be so rigid- ballet is not !
What's ridiculous is your glorification of Russian technique. Why the hell should the entire world about what Russian ballerinas do? I don't care about an impoverished, sickly thin Giselle. I'd rather prefer Fracci as Giselle over any Russian ballerina, Ulanova included. And FYI, putting a hand on the waist does not 'define' a character. Get over yourself!
Natalia was so much better!!!
Yes i think so.. but marianela is good in acting..
and who asked you? bitter osipova fan
@@stellalana5987 a person who needs to come on another artists video to compare her to another person is, at the bare minimun, bitter.
Natalia is so much DIFFERENT...and thank god for that!
Osipova is a different Giselle. But I do wish that she focused less on the gymnastics in this variation. Giselle had a weak heart, so moving around like an athlete should have been impossible.
1:20