Show Me A Nation Where Judges Appoint Judges: Harish Salve On Collegium System At Republic Summit
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 03. 2024
- Senior advocate and former Solicitor General of India Harish Salve was speaking as a special guest at the Republic Summit 2024. He advocated to abolish the Collegium System. Watch the video to know more.
#RepublicSummit2024 #BharatTheNextDecade #IndiasBiggestNewsEvent #HarishSalveAtRepublicSummit2024
#LatestNews #RepublicTV #RepublicTVLive
@revauniversity_official @MarutiSuzukiCorp @TheRavinGroup
Republic TV is India's no.1 English news channel since its launch. It is your one-stop destination for all the live news updates from India and around the world. Republic TV makes news accessible for you at your convenience, at all times and across devices. At Republic we keep you updated with up-to-the-minute news on politics, sports, entertainment, lifestyle, gadgets and much more.
We believe in Breaking the story and Breaking the Silence. But most importantly, for us ‘You Are Republic, We Are Your Voice.’
Also, Watch ►
Republic TV Live News Updates ►bit.ly/RepublicTVLiveNews
The Debate With Arnab Goswami ► bit.ly/TheDebateWithArnabGoswami
Patriot With Major Gaurav Arya ► bit.ly/PatriotFullEpisodes
Exclusive Sunday Debate With Arnab Goswami ► bit.ly/SundayDebate
Checkmate With Major Gaurav Arya (Retd.) ► bit.ly/3EtPj0s
The Grand Strategy With Maj Gen G.D Bakshi (Retd) ► bit.ly/3EPZ6xF
R.Explained ► bit.ly/3sOLT5K
R.Uninterrupted ► bit.ly/34isZdh
You can stay connected with Republic TV on -
Facebook - / republicworld
Twitter - / republic
Website - www.republicworld.com
Instagram: / republicworld
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va1w...
Telegram: t.me/RepublicLive
Koo: www.kooapp.com/profile/republic
Disclaimer: Republic Media Network may provide content through third-party websites, operating systems, platforms, and portals (‘Third-Party Platforms’). Republic does not control and has no liability for Third-Party Platforms, including content hosted, advertisements, security, functionality, operation, or availability.
You cannot run 21st century India with 19th century mindset courts.
Perfect words👏
True you are 🎉
Mr. Harish salve has saved freedom of press.. One of the best legal luminaries of the India.
We don't have freedom of press in India ...are u blind ...even recently our government suspended every account on twitter which posted in support of Farmer's protest...
@@Bookaholic_ Lmao there was no "farmer" or "protest" about this "farmer's protest". Only middlemen/ thugs/ Khalistanis and uncivilized hooliganism.
@@Bookaholic_ Farmers use sword in farming??😂😂😂 Bsdk Are you mad or you think all Indians are mad.😢😢😢
@@Argdut1106 don't spread your godi media knowledge here ..... around 600 farmers died during the first farmer's protest..... according to Andhvakt logic wrestlers were anti-nationals ...every protesting farmer is a khalistani .... every student who stand against bjp is anti-national....every journalist who stand against bjp is also anti-national.....keep your laughing ass shut and listen to some logic
@@Argdut1106 Your place should be in courts, not on CZcams.😅😅😅😅
You are other thughs of India.
And Indian constitution.
It's type of judicial corruption. Rightly said by salve sir.
Mr. Salve you are fantastic. You will be always one my most respected individuals, who's services are invaluable for the nation.
Bharat Mata ki Jai
W😊popppppp
@@ramamurthylingam999
Always a pleasure to hear Mr. Salve. Brilliant clarity, brilliant jurist.
What Mr.Salve has said is absolutely true.
Rare ... To see an Emotional Arnab hugging the great Adv. Harish Salve .
Long live the Media n Judiciary of Bharat
😂arnab😂
This guttermouth will hug any BJP sidekick to please his political paymasters 🤧🤬
Qqq
Arnob and Harish are the two sides of same coin of
Blatant false narrative
Bravo ! Very few people would speak out in such clear and unbiased manner ! Kudos to you ! Hoping and praying for a follow through on this.
One of the finest judicial mind in the world
One of the most powerful, productive interview ever seen on a news channel...This was awesome and will go a long way for a nation that is becoming a powerhouse of the New World...Super
The British legecy in Bharath still continuing. Has to see changes.
Like upsc , there should be judges selection process. Every judge should come through this selection process. No mid level entries should be allowed. There should be entry at bottom most level and grow up the ladder upto Supreme Court.
Correct..
Promotion of judges may be based on previous judgements and corrections by appeal courts.
The UPSC itself is a flawed system. That's why the lateral entry system for policy advisory & formulation was brought about. If the judiciary adopts that, it's 10 steps back. At least right now, the appointment of HC judges is still better than that.
Judges need to be selected vide all India entrance exam from all domain not on choice of chandachud ji.
Our low meritious judges don't value time as no time schedule in listed case . Simple non sense.
Excellent❤ Well said Mr Salve “we do not need courts who pokes its nose in every matter of Government.”
Indian law system nd judiciary was far better during British India….
That was just down to earth. I reckon 2024 May will see Judiciary in sinc with democracy of the future.
Mr. Harish Salve is an Indian Christian and although his father was a congress chela, he remains true to his Bharatiya sanskriti and culture and fights for our Bharat, for the truth and for righteousness!!!! God bless. Jai Hind. Vande Mataram 🙏😍🥰🙏
Brilliant Just Brilliant Arnab now I want debate exclusively on Judiciary and reforms for Coming decades I India 🇮🇳
Excellent interview. Fully agree with Sri Salve. After LS elections are over, BJP Govt must review the system of collegium with all legal luminaries like Sri Salve, Sri Tushar Mehta etc.
BJP once tried to abolish Collegium system of judges appointing judges but Supreme Court nullified it, unreasonably perhaps unwilling to lose it's supremacy.
@@rajendranv9732My suggestion is Collegium is to be expanded to include PM, FM, HM, Attorney General, and Solicitor General and attorney or solicitor to recommend the names to PM and in turn to President for appointment of both HC and SC judges. In the process merit is ensured . Everymonth one day Govt pick the persons of integrity, fully scrutinized by Intelligent Bureau and forward this govt. In case of adverse remarks, that person should not be made. The authority vests with HM for thorough scrutiny. Considering the voluminous cases pending, I suggest who ever comes to power can create SC for Constitutional Matters, SC for Economic Offences including money laundering, SC for Civil disputes and SC for criminal cases. This will reduce the burden. So also for HC. Once the verdict is pronounced, if the case is on appeal to SC , no stay order is to be given and it must be referred to trial for SC. Listing of cases must be with another person appointed by Govt and he must ensure that quick disposal of listing. If need be Govt can consider retired judges to speed up the trial. Moreover Central agencies must be given full powers to enter any state and if the agencies are attacked by the people in the state , Delhi police can take suo motto of this incident and States have no role to play. In my NJAC can be introduced again with the modifications and it must be final where in Court can make suggestions only . If anything is wrong , pl make comment without involving any political colours. I feel that the burden can be reduced. Govt cdn also scrutiny of legal system in other democratic countries and embrace the clauses.
100%
salve sir is extraordinary
Thank you Mr. Salve speaking the core truth on our justice systems. To me it looks like justice inconsistency is actually a question to be heard on true justice scale by those who are not biased and punitive under the contempt of court rule. Justice is where the true balance is in balance without any bend.
We just hope that the balance of justice pervails
In 1990 kashmiri pandits were mass murdered , kar sevaks of ayodhya were mass shot dead, but never s kotha took cognizance
Republic summit is great always, your real wish India from roots to grow and work hard to common public with the use of 4th pillar of democracy.
This is excellent speech of very very renowned lawyer of world known explaining about the preset position of Bharat and also expressing about the present judiciary and collegian system existing in Bharat
Thanks
Vote for Modiji, judiciary reforms after 2024 elections
Judicial reforms is an urgent need for our country.
Desperately needed. Judicial system in India is a joke
@@srijitsinha1471 Judicial control.
.mvbbvvvbjbbkbbbnnvbbbbbbbb
Jbvnn
Hb.
...yu....
, x
.. Ch Cf.
..
.....
. .....
....
😅@@infi44
😂😂😂 Make It Simple... Appoint MODI As A CHIEF JUDGE OF INDIA... Everything Will Be Solved... Jai Shree Ram 😅😅😅
Mr Salve and you Mr Arnav are real heros and fighters for truth, justice and India
Really
Salman khan
The marvellous man...most successful.. constitution should cherish in everybody's ❤
Thanku Republic for giving us this great opportunity to listen one of the finest child of MaBharti.
Best way to thank someone by hugging him publically definately exhibits extreme gratitute. Gracious persons like Salve must be recognised and honoured the way Arnab did on his show.
Salute to Salveyji for his bold and unbiased comments on present judiciary system in India.
Fantastic Harishji, salute dilse, whenever sir you r arguing case, they way in which you sir put your argument, are fantastic.
You are Sir Gem and true Deshbhakt. God bless you and serve long long time.
Fantastic video.
Lovely questions and answers.
Arnab: It was a pleasure to see you thanking Me Salve.
Excellent Mr Salve Salute Arnab Republic Congratulations Shubhkamnayen
Great Salve sir.
Wish to meet you soon
Very matured and committed.
What immense gratitude!
-We need accountability for IAS officers.
- We need to support free speech and demolish laws against that are against free speech like section 295 A erc.
-We need judiciary reforms(By hiring more judges+ dividing IPC into different Category and then also assign judge based on different category.)
-We need educational reforms(We need to add CIVIC duties and basic ECONOMICS in our Primary education)
- We need to do economic reforms(Decreasing excise duties on raw material, Providing more security of business etc.)
- We need to add petrol and Diesel into GST( so that people don' t have to pay VAT and Excise duties on it).
- We need make Farming a business( by Privatization of the industry) not a social service, this itself can push Indian into a middle income economy.
- Gov needs to decrease the size of Government and increase the size of Governance(We have so many unnecessary amount of Ministries).
- Gov needs to do a lot of social reforms(Wakf act+ Place of worship act+ implementing UCC and CAA and NRC etc.)
At last there is many more thinks that needed to be done and my faith in BJP is decreasing Day by Day specially regarding the social reforms.
Really true, the common people are the sufferer, even in corruption cases the accused and even convicted people who are using the public funds for payment to costly advocates to argue in their favour,
Don't u think we need more lawyers nd judges also nd more court
All judges should come under scrutiny and Accountability, like all other employees.
Also working schedule and timings must be adopted, no extra special holidays.
With time limit for disposal of cases. RTI act too for public scrutiny.
great respect for him
Super point out sir
Harish Salve is the biggest pioneer, whip sharp & straight talking Advocate. He's simply incredible.
Hats off to you Salve sir. You are so candid
I do not know who is the Father of Collegium System in India.! But, I know, the Chief Judicial Officer India, proposes, and the Chief Executive Officer, arranges everything and gets it done. Thats how, in India, people gets everything done! This is India, and in no time, India will be be on the top of the Universe. !!!
Harish Salve Sir is The Most Respected in True Indians ❤ Along with Modiji 🎉🎉
Jai Bharat, we want such legal luminaries to protect BHARAT.
What a lawyer of Maa Bharati!
A million salutes to thee, Sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️
We have great respect for Harish Salve
Simply an outstanding interview. Sincere Namaskar to Salveji.
Mr. Salve is a Jem of Bharath... Thank You So Much Much Much Much Sir❤❤❤😊🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
A big salute to Aadarniya Harish Salve Ji and team Arnb.
God bless them all.
जय हिंद, जय भारत।
ONLY JUDGES CAN APPOINT JUDGES question is the process should be objectic and honour equality & fairness
I really appreciate the bold views Mr. Salve has expressed. 👍👍👌
Show Me A Nation Where Judges Appoint Judges - nice
Mr. Salve is a legend. He does many cases for GOI free of cost .very rare quality among present legal fraternity.
SRI HARISH SALVE , IS ONE OF THE HONEST INDIVIDUAL WHO IS CAPABLE OF GIVING JUSTICE IN TRUE SENSE WITH OUT HELPING ROUGES RASCALS AND RAPISTS, FANATICS AND ANTISOCIALS AND ANTINATIONALS. HATSOFF THIS GENTLEMAN . THE HONEST CITIZENS ARE WITH YOU ,DEAR SIR.
Judges should not appoint judges...politicians should and remind them of the very same, everytime the need arises....That is the real essence of democracy...
Independence will be impacted
@@vanacharlasaipavankumar6331 people choose their representative to from govt and the elected govt should have the right to choose the judiciary system members. Judges choosing next judges has no democracy in it and looks like a British era monopoly.
If they don't like politician choosing judges then allow people to choose the judge but then we will have election for every thing.
So the best democratic solution is to allow elected politician to choose the judges.
This will happen when people of India become more aware about their voting rights and choose good politician.
@@kaptainkc7415That will be disastrous.
@@kaptainkc7415 they are elected it does not mean they have every right to do whatever they want. Government will end up controlling courts like other institution. it will be disastrous for India.
Respected Salve ji is a great patriotic highly admirable person . His assesment about judiciary system is 100% correct . Really very disturbed disgusting judiciary system
I had tears in my eyes at the end of this video.
When Arnab was arrested it was a shock.
Thank you Salveji🙏 koti koti Pranaam🙏 Jai Hind Jai Bharat Jai Shree Ram 🙏
Overwhelmed me.......
I thank whole heartedly our Arnob and the great legendary Salve ji..
Person sitting in TN is my longing to hear from Sir..
In the recent case against a TN minister is really a.....
Harish Salve is an intelligent man.
Excellent. Superb interview.
Mr. Salve you have been a Super Lawyer. Jai Hind Jai Bharat.
Very learned&wise man who is straight forward&courajeous.
Great interview. The present system of judges appointments made by other judges is like the examiner and student are the same!
The judiciary in India has been elevated to the highest position of ‘My Lords’ representing The Lord on earth. Being representatives of The Lord , they have allowed themselves the power not to declare their assets, have opaque appointments system ( where as they want transparency for everyone else) , want to be on every committee conceivable which appoints people to highest positions in the land( next they may want the power to appoint the president and prime minister)
The judiciary in India is harming democratic society by their judgements and eroding the trust in the government in the eyes of foreign governments
The first next government should completely remove the corrupt judiciary and replace with a system which is suitable for India and send the present self appointed judges to their homes
Finally someone showed guts to say about largest conspiracy of indian judiciary 🙏🙏🙏hats off salve sir 👏👏🔥🔥 this system has to be changed
100% correct
Never seen a student setting papers and simultaneously giving 100% marks
Woonderful talk. As he pointed out, it is high time now that our entire judicial system is revamped to suit the changed times. Precious time of SC is now spent on cases which could be deliberated at High Courts. Bail applications coming up at SC are examples. Such cases could be heard and disposed by HCs, based on the set directions of the SC. Clear-cut demarcation needs to be set regarding the limits of Parliament, Executive and Judiciary, and each wing to ensure to avoid inference. Initiative in this direction from the Hon'ble Top Court will be well-appreciated.
Always is PLEASURE to listen Mr Salve.
The entire comments made by Mr. Salve in this Vedio is absolutely correct.
Mr Harish Salve is the most knowledgeable Lawer 🎉
S C should take the advise of SALVEJI keeping its ego , narrow mindset & take steps to reform itself exposing itself to transperancy, accountability to restore ths confidence of the public
Long live ! Sir Salve
Hats off SALVE Ji for your straight talk. Now I salute you on knowing your association with GURU JI...PALKIVALA Sahib. Judicial Reform is now the need of the day. Upmanship & Opportunism must go leaving space for ACCOUNTABILITY & COMMITMENT.
Judges appoint friends and families. Gifts, return gifts!!
💯 percent right salvayji
What a personality we need him
Honest to the core fantastic.
Great respect for Harish Salve.
What he says about Hindi in courts is correct. Majority of the litigants do not know English and the judiciary does not transact in Hindi. Entire working of is in English in majority of the courts. Court working should be keeping with the changing times. The outdated system won't be able to deliver. Appointment of judges should be as per the global practices.
Can’t get better than that. Salute 🫡 to Mr Salve.
He is got much better clear legal idea than many Judges of our Supreme Court. Brilliant Mind.
From Slave to British 🇬🇧 made judicial System to Congress/ Communist party Slaves our Judicial Independence is under scrutiny of public & mind you the people of Bharat 🇮🇳 understand everything.
Collegium System has TO END & CONSTITUTION NEEDS TO BE RESPECTED BY JUDGES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 🇮🇳 FIRST AND FOREMOST.
Mr. Harish Salve is a force to reckon with! A great lawyer and a great human who fought for his birth country, Bharat, for one Rupee!
And, though I’ve marched for Arnab’s release from jail, I don’t like his hyperactive behaviour! He needs to mellow down and stop the noise in his shows!!
Very specific great knowledge and experience explain in the plain simple words is our Harish Salve.
Thanks Shree Harish SALVEJI
Your thoughts are excellent. Hope it will be implemented soon.
What a top class lawyer he is.
Vested interest comes into play when a group of veteran judges appoint top judges of the country.While institutions elected by the people just keep looking on. Helplessly.
Mr. Salwe, we all Bhartiyas are proud of you and as a Maharashtrian I have immense respect and love for you sir ❤,
Hope you will continue to serve Maa Bharti in future also the way you have been served till date.. ❤
Harish salve himself has given very good reasoning why collegium system is must needed. He himself said that it was introduced because of the excessive interference of that era goverments in the institution of law. If previous goverments has done that in the past, who will ensure it will not happen again in the future, even if we agree that its not possible in modi government, but who will ensure that it will never happen in the future, say in 15 or 20 years from now.
Its very straight and clear, the collegium system was introduced because goverment can easily influence any court of law without this system.
What a conversation....
मेरा भारत महान !
Looking at Sir like Harish Salve and more like him makes you feel immense happy and deeply reassured about Hindu DNA / GENE'S are far superior and highminded, gracious, logical, intelligent beyond expression very very Bright minds. We are coming back to own our right place in the world .I.e.AT THE TOP.❤❤❤
Salute you Sir for the best comments ever made...
Judiciary reformation is a must to happen . Give armour power to lower courts
It is high time to reform the selection of Judges to the High Courts and Supreme Courts. Selection of judges by Judges is to be aɓolished and an innovtive method to select judges is to be evolved .
Great and ever outstanding Harish Salve
Mr salve we are in democracy
Mr salve the boss❤
made 3 mins of work into 3 months of work - Great man!
Jai hind sir
We never forget that our elected representatives remain outside the preview of judicial punishments even so
Beautiful..
Epitome of Juristic Wisdom..🧑💼..Salute Salve for Patriotic response he has shown in Kulbushan Yadav case🫡
Superb sir Shree Harish SALVEJI
SIR Salveji is most knowledgeable and brilliant person in field of law i have ever seen