MiracleGro VS Pee: Which Fertilizer Is Better? Surprising Results!
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 05. 2024
- In this video, I find out which fertilizer is better: MiracleGro fertilizer or pee! Some natural gardeners promote human urine as free homemade fertilizer, and human urine has an NPK ratio surprisingly similar to MiracleGro All Purpose (24-8-16). But how does it stack up in a controlled experiment? I designed an experiment to put human urine fertilizer to the test. In the end, we got shocking and surprising results!
With recent increases in fertilizer costs, finding ways to make homemade fertilizers and reduce costs is attractive. Using pee as fertilizer has a long history of use, but how does this free fertilizer stack up against "real" fertilizers sold at stores? This experiment was filmed over 5 weeks from design to final results. Be sure to stay until the end to see an explanation of the findings.
Please see the following high quality fertilizer PRODUCT LINKS:
Jack's 20-20-20 (1.5 lbs)*: amzn.to/3MfQhDY
Jack's 20-20-20 (10 lbs)*: amzn.to/44OoaTE
Jack's 20-20-20 (25 lbs)*: amzn.to/3Mgqrji
Jack's 10-30-20 (1.5 lbs)*: amzn.to/42poXZI
Jack's 10-30-20 (25 lbs)*: amzn.to/3I5lnvP
MiracleGro AP 24-8-16*: amzn.to/3MYupxt
MiracleGro Tomato 18-18-21*: amzn.to/43vwPJf
MiracleGro 15-30-15*: amzn.to/3VTcFGF
Jobe's Organic Fertilizer (4 lbs)*: amzn.to/3BTNJ8G
Jobe's Organic Bone Meal* (4 lbs): amzn.to/3nMuCtX
Alaska Fish Fertilizer (1 Gallon)*: amzn.to/3nTlqnx
Amazon Store Slow Release Fertilizers*: www.amazon.com/shop/themillen...
Amazon Store Soluble Fertilizers*: www.amazon.com/shop/themillen...
The following articles were consulted:
goveganic.net/gardening-how-t...
www.lowimpact.org/posts/takin...
www.permaculturenews.org/2011...
TABLE OF CONTENTS
0:00 Using Urine As Fertilizer
2:05 Setting Up The Experiment
4:05 Making The Fertilizers (Rocky Montage)
6:25 Experiment Rules And Fertilizing Plants
9:58 Follow-Up Fertilizing And Progress
10:52 Experiment Results!
12:24 My Explanation Of The Results
17:56 Adventures With Dale
If you have any questions about how to use human urine as fertilizer for plants, have questions about growing fruit trees or want to know about the things I grow in my raised bed vegetable garden and edible landscaping food forest, are looking for more gardening tips and tricks and garden hacks, have questions about vegetable gardening and organic gardening in general, or want to share some DIY and "how to" garden tips and gardening hacks of your own, please ask in the Comments below!
****************************************
MUSIC CREDIT:
Training in the Fire by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. creativecommons.org/licenses/...
****************************************
VISIT MY AMAZON STOREFRONT FOR PRODUCTS I USE MOST OFTEN IN MY GARDEN*
www.amazon.com/shop/themillen...
****************************************
VISIT MY MERCHANDISE STORE
shop.spreadshirt.com/themille...
****************************************
SUPPORT MY SECOND CHANNEL!
/ 2minutegardentips
****************************************
EQUIPMENT I USE IN MY GARDEN*:
Miracle-Gro All Purpose Plant Food amzn.to/3qNPkXk
Miracle-Gro Bloom Booster Plant Food amzn.to/2GKYG0j
Miracle-Gro Tomato Plant Food amzn.to/2GDgJ8n
Jack's Fertilizer, 20-20-20, 25 lb. amzn.to/3CW6xCK
Southern Ag Liquid Copper Fungicide amzn.to/2HTCKRd
Southern Ag Natural Pyrethrin Concentrate amzn.to/2UHSNGE
Monterey Organic Spinosad Concentrate amzn.to/3qOU8f5
Safer Brand Caterpillar Killer (BT Concentrate) amzn.to/2SMXL8D
Cordless ULV Fogger Machine amzn.to/36e96Sl
Weed Barrier amzn.to/3yp3MaJ
Organza Bags (Fig-size) amzn.to/3AyaMUz
Organza Bags (Tomato-size) amzn.to/36fy4Re
Nursery Pots amzn.to/3AucVAB
Heavy Duty Grow Bags amzn.to/2UqvsgC
6.5 Inch Hand Pruning Shears amzn.to/3jHI1yL
Japanese Pruning Saw amzn.to/3wjpw6o
Double Tomato Hooks with Twine amzn.to/3Awptr9
String Trellis Tomato Support Clips amzn.to/3wiBjlB
Nylon Mason Line, 500FT amzn.to/3wd9cEo
Expandable Vinyl Garden Tape amzn.to/3jL7JCI
****************************************
SOCIAL MEDIA
Follow Me on TWITTER (@NCGardening) / ncgardening
Follow Me on INSTAGRAM / millennialgardener_nc
****************************************
ABOUT MY GARDEN
Location: Southeastern NC, Brunswick County (Wilmington area)
34.1°N Latitude
Zone 8A
****************************************
*As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
© The Millennial Gardener
#gardening #garden #gardeningtips #urine #freefertilizer
I've been using urine as a fertilizer on my plants for years....ever since my wife started locking the door when I come home late from the bar
It's how I kill a beautiful bush of roses.
At the beginning they were blooming like crazy, but after a couple of months they were dead.
@@bestdjaf7499 You have to dilute it, not concentrated.
@@MickSupper
I don't dilute my drinks.
I am not gay.
Why would I dilute my pee!?
🤣😂
🤣🤣☠️
😂😂😂
We live in a slum in East Africa and teach sustainable, regenerative agriculture to the locals. We have a rabbit house with 170 rabbits, and the cages are designed where all the urine from the rabbits is automatically collected in a holding tank connected to our irrigation system. When we irrigate, a fertigator mixes the urine with the irrigation water and the dilute urine is sprayed on the crops. It is a gentle, balanced foliar fertilizer, and seems to discourage all manner of pests. When we turn the sprinklers on, you can sometimes see a cloud of bugs escaping the raised beds. We use the urine primarily as a fertilizer, but it seems to handle most pests. If that is not enough, tobacco grows on our compound almost like weeds, and mixing smashed tobacco leaves and some smashed hot peppers with the urine seems to take care of any pests not taken care of by the dilute urine alone. The cages also automatically collect the rabbit poop which is an excellent manure, and can be applied directly to raised beds without composting. We dedicate some fraction of our raised beds to growing timothy hay and alfalfa to feed the rabbits, so we have virtually no input costs in keeping the rabbits, and they provide most of our nutrient and pest controls needs for the compound. This alone justifies the keeping of the rabbit project. Now, this size of rabbit colony produces a great abundance of meat, and the meat is just a free benefit of the nutrient/pest control program. We are now investigating to expand the nutrient program by adding several tilapia tanks. Rather than recirculate and filter the fish water, we will simply use the fish water as a nutrient spray for the farm. Sort of like an open loop aquaponic system. Anyway, I am learning a whole lot from your channel, and we are finally achieving some really amazing results on this farm.
Wow ❤ amazing 🇵🇷✊🏻🙏🏻
Great ecology. I wish people didn't need to eat meat, but most do. But your use of resources is incredible.
Good Work
Yep rabbit waste fertilizer is known to be pretty good. I think I saw some setups where the rabbit hutch was placed over the plants.
Love it and thanks for the explanation 🇨🇻
A friend gave me some heirloom lettuce sets. I planted them in a planter. He stopped by a few days later an noticed that they were nitrogen deficient by the color of the leaves. He had some commercial fertilizer in his truck and offered me some but I told him I wanted to try diluted urine instead. I did, and in a couple of days the leaves were beautiful.
I was sold.
You need to add wood ash to the pee for fruit bearing plants. Also, the pee you used was too strong. The ratio is 1 part pee to 10 parts water.
For seedlings you need to mix 1 part urine to 20 parts water. The pepper was most likely burnt. For larger plants 10 parts water to 1 part urine. You were using it way too strong. Been using urine in garden for years.
It depends on how dilute your urine is. If you're dehydrated your urine will be dark. If you just drank a gallon on water it will be clear almost.
THANK YOU!!! I can't believe he dumped a cup of urine directly onto the plant. No wonder the pepper up and died and the lettuce had issues. I've used urine for 20 years.
@@saintmichael3879 🫶
Thought the same thing, used straight pee on a plant once and it died within hours. Figured it just needed to be more dilute. I use MG, but I do like 1/4 the recommended strength and just fertilize more often/as needed. Since your plant basically is forced to absorb chemical fertilizers, I figure consistent low doses are better for the plant, then hitting them hard every 2 weeks.
Also depends on diet
If you conduct this experiment again, may I suggest that you dilute the urine down 1:10 into a separate container and mix it well before you feed your plants.
In order to dilute the solution down it needs to be properly mixed with water before not after. Essentially you fed your plants full strength urine and washed it down with some water.
Yes, I was surprised to see this as well.
When he poured the 50% urine solution, (and not more diluted to say, 10%) I thought to myself "he's burning those tiny baby roots!"
Well, live and learn...
Is there any way to mitigate the sodium content? Mixing at 1:10 and using it as a supplement fertilizer only reduces your fertilizer cost by 10%.
Also, maybe a little mycorrhizae or lactoferment solution as a mediator would be helpful in both, and might help synthesize whatever nutrients are available in both.
Either way, this was a great experiment, and I'm grateful that he conducted it!
Also if he only used the urine from that 1st collection it would start to turn to ammonia after sitting for time and fermenting.
If you ad a teaspoon of baking soda it will kill the acid in the urine an mix 50/50
@@johnnylambert6003 1 teaspoon of baking soda per gallon of straight urine?
This is why I flush my plants with water before I feed them
Besides the 10-1-4 application being a bit strong at 1 to 1, better at least 1 to 5 dilution, consider the gradual concentration of salt, NaCl, from your diet. Most of our western diet is a bit rich in salt, tasty in our food, but easy to accumulate in the planting medium. Some folk are learning to moderate the NaCl but most of us use more than MDR 1,500 mg/day. Some plants can tolerate salinity, but not as much as we need, or like, so have to consider that.
The Pee also has Salt (NaCl). Miracle grow does not have any salt in it. Romans used Salt to poison the soil. That is what pee does poisons the soil. If you could remove the salt the pee would work better.
I drank pee and it didn't taste salty...
But seriously most salt comes out of your body in sweat not urine
Human urine is a good fertilizer for plants. It is a natural source of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium, which are essential nutrients for plant growth. Urine is also a good source of other trace elements, such as calcium, magnesium, and sulfur.
Urine can be used as a fertilizer in a variety of ways. It can be diluted with water and applied directly to the soil, or it can be composted and then used as a fertilizer. Urine can also be used to make liquid fertilizer, which is a concentrated form of urine that can be diluted with water and applied to plants.
When using urine as a fertilizer, it is important to dilute it properly. Urine is very concentrated, and if it is not diluted, it can burn plant roots. A good rule of thumb is to dilute urine 10:1 with water.
It is also important to note that urine should not be used on plants that are sensitive to nitrogen, such as tomatoes and potatoes. These plants can be damaged by the high levels of nitrogen in urine.
Overall, human urine is a safe and effective fertilizer for plants. It is a natural source of nutrients, and it is free and easy to obtain. If you are looking for a natural way to fertilize your plants, urine is a good option.
Here are some additional tips for using urine as a fertilizer:
Collect urine in a clean container.
Dilute urine 10:1 with water.
Apply urine to the soil around the plants, not directly on the leaves.
Do not use urine on plants that are sensitive to nitrogen.
Be sure to test the soil pH before applying urine, as urine can lower the pH of the soil.
If you are using urine to make liquid fertilizer, be sure to store it in a cool, dark place.
how about for eggplant?
Excellent reply, sir!
What about urine that is tainted with pharmaceutical drugs? There is nothing natural on pharmaceutical drugs.
From being a fish keeper I understand the nitrogen cycle. Basically pee is ammonia, not great, you want bacteria to convert it first to nitrite, and then to nitrate before you put it on plants. So if you want to a really good fertilizer you want to setup a mini sewage treatment plant in your backyard. When I had my large fresh water aquarium setup I used to pump dirty tank water out onto the lawn and also dump all the muck from cleaning the filters on the lawn.
By the way, next do poop
I went 100% organic a couple of years ago and I've never had healthier plants than when I began fertilizing with pee! It works wonders for building soil and getting your compost...to compost! lol I do a weak application a couple of times for seedlings and then a stronger feeding or two went the plants are established and that's really all it takes. I'm raking in a massive harvest so far this year. Canning, dehydrating, and freezing my homegrown food every day for the last month or so. Shelves are stacked!
Ah...yep. I grow in the dirt with compost and I remineralize my soil every year with a complete mix.
I think you burnt that poor pepper right up. LOL That way WAY too much pee for those little guys...
you should try applying electroculture. Amazing technology
The moment I got to “weak application”, I could not stop seeing in my head scenes in which I made fun of you for this.
@@JanicePhillipsquick question why is pee diluted by ten parts water but the fertilizer is diluted 1 part to 100?
Yes, i put mine into the compost. Also compost chicken poo ans vegetable scraps.
Thanks for your thoughtful and informative experiment. I have been gardening and composting for years and I did my own experimentation by adding urine to my compost at various intervals. One result was a more rapid breakdown of the materials being composted and the end result was a robust, high nitrogen soil amendment. I used NO chemical fertilizers or pesticides and got great results. I didn't use a control along side the compost / soil mixture, but I had used Miracle Gro in previous years and the results were comparable. Gardening is the process of growing soil, not plants.
Not reporting/publishing negative results is a major problem with science. Thanks for sharing regardless of the results.
Salt! We excrete like 90% of our excess salt through our urine, so it really depends what your diet was like when you filled that jug.
Yeah like if you just added straight fertilizer with no water
Like maybe dont "ferment" ?
Fresh pee vs stagnant pee, may also be a variable?
Salt. Good point 👍
Brawndo's got what plants crave, electrolytes!
Glad you didn't delete this video. Every failure or success must be recorded and now that you've published this on CZcams your theory and results are cast in concrete. Whether your experiment is flawed is for the next CZcamsr to resolve. However you've answered a lot of questions and gave us closure for this. Great experiment you handled this like a real science project thanks for putting this up!
Add wood ass and burnt eggshell to the urine and the plants get much more nutrions.
Or just don't pour it without properly diluting it. Lots of studies were done on this and the piss needs to be dilute with 5-10 parts water. Not poured directly on a plant and then an equal measure of water, which would be 50-50.
I started trying it at home, and I disagree with most of the ratios I see here. I've decided dilution of 30:1 is my baseline. I wouldn't bother going below 20:1, perhaps 15:1 if it's a plant thta can really use the mineral ratios in our bio-product.
Of course, I began this experiment with repotted plants and dracena cuttings, in store bought potting soil. Even though I mixed together all my spent soil, and the unopened stuff, I'm sure it had significant added minerals anyway.
But once I started diluting it much more the results have been pretty good.
No, he did not answer any questions, the whole experiment is so flawed that it is useless. People do not grow anything in sterile coir.
This is the scientific process not a failure! 🙂 The goal of growing healthy plants with only urine failed I suppose. But as an experiment, evidence was obtained that could lead to the next iteration of the experiment. I think millennial gardener was hard on himself saying that.
I'd like to see a part two with:
1. More Samples of seedlings
2. Fresh urine vs aged (test if there is nitrogen gased off due to N cycle)
3. Your local top Soil test instead of no nutrient test, (since is probably how most people will be using it)
4. Intensity and PPM of urine vs MG (I'd like to know if they would perform the same with more diluted more frequent feedings )
So you want more samples, and fresher pee...and you have no idea why that might be a problem.
I've seen the same thing with people who advocate electroculture. When somebody runs an experiment, and conclude thst its bullcrap, everyone has an excuse for why it didn't work.
You have a favored result, and you're embarrased. So you try to discredit.
Where is this guy getting the urine? Is it clean, healthy, pee or not. Is there RX drugs in the pee? What's the person's water/food intake? Miracle grow is poison. That's a fact that's not going to change, but if dude is not taking care of himself and peeing straight medicated acid, he could change what he is doing to see different results.
@@A.E.Lanman777 I love how pissed off people are at his results. Poor babies.
@@A.E.Lanman777Clearly you didn't watch the entire video
He explains in detail where, when and how the urine was collected, What the donor's diet consisted of and what medications could possibly be in it. Why are you asking us to watch the video for you?
Nitrogen in urine does gas off and the nitrogen changes form. Urine is recommended to store air tight and use as fertilizer fresh, that is, within 24 hours. I am also interested to see the results of fresh vs month old.
Awesome! Great job doing a video that was fun to watch, nicely paced, and very thought-provoking. I definitely want to try a test like this, too. I had a garden expert tell me that plants need different amounts of N,P,K during the lifecycle, because N is good for green growth, P is for blooming/roots, and K is overall health.
I can say that urine is all my corn needed one year. It had a few yellowing leaves and I added some of my yellow and it’s yellow disappeared and it was the best corn I’ve ever eaten. I was going to plant it for shade (high desert) and let the deer eat it, but it was so beautiful and delicious I didn’t share with them. I did give them all of my broccoli this year and most of my cabbage 😊 I’m a carnivore.
I should try that cuz I live in high desert too.
yeah since going carnivore i dont grow as much veg. have you seen sun hemp for tall cover crop, deer prolly love it,
I am planning to plant food for rabbits and squirrels on my suburban lot and get myself a pistol crossbow. Seems like the easiest way for a carnivore to get food from their property.
Best venison I ever ate was the one I caught trespassing in my corn patch
Just tell everyone how you did it after they eat it
This is why you have a fence around your property isn't it..
10’!!! 😂😂😂
😆🤣😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Can't put raw urine on any type of plant. You Oughta try just putting raw chicken shit on a plant see what happens
😅😂
I never expected it to be a complete fertilizer, but I did expect that it had some of what a plant needs. I have had other people tell me that they thought human urine would kill the plants. So this is an interesting experiment to see. Thanks
It works very well as lawn fertilizer. Like really really well.
turns out an engineer makes some of the most easily digestible and informative gardening videos out there!
We are very plain folk 😆
Newer flower / rose gardener here. I live in a townhouse that recently allowed me to remove a dying bush from two areas in front of my unit. The plants weren’t doing great. Actually, one perennial flowering plant wasn’t flowering, my Stalk flower weren’t growing tall, my delphinium looked like
Sh!t and my rose was all but dead.
I tested the soil and found the P,K were both “adequate” but the Nitrogen was depleted. I peeeeeeed and diluted it approx 1/10 and watered the garden with that (and cheated with fish emulsion 0-10-10 and bone meal 0-20-0) and I think it works!
Within a few days my rose has new red shoots (red are blooms and not leaves) and my stalk is flowering / growing and the delphinium is growing new shoots.
I also added this to the flowers in an already established garden and same, the rose is going nuts with new shoots. My honeysuckle is flowering like mad and growing new shoots.
I am a believer.
I don’t use Miracle grow as I prefer organic
Alaska Fish Emulsion, Dr earth’s and superthrive.
Add the urine to compost. It helps break the cellulose from wood down to lignins. As far as testing, you could run a parallel test feeding MG to a compost. Then use the compost to grow plants for the experiment.
Tnx, I'm having trouble breaking down compose, will try that next :)
@@Eduardo_Espinozathrow a handful of grass fertilizer on a pile of compost stir it and spray enough water on it to make it damp but not soggy wet.
Drunk compost = Coca-Cola, beer, amonia or to make it
Organic- sugar, yeast, Urine
I tried this and the neighbors complained. Oh wait....I guess you meant collect it first?!? 🙂
Just be careful because this is the basis for some illegal activities. You might get some unwanted guests.
Hmm I see a few differences… miracle grow got 25% dilute pee 50%… and one other difference is urine has to be broken down by microbes vs the miracle grow comes broken down already…. So this mostly tests if you can piss in your plants vs if pee is a valid food source to create a healthy soil… which is what you want organic ferts to do
One thing I notice the soil health is probably better in the pissy soil as there’s algae growing on the perlite… I think a better experiment would have been to inoculate one soil with the urine first and allow the microbes 🦠 to create a rich soil/heslthy rhizosphere , and comparing that to a soil that had not been pissed in as a control
Also keep in mind that plants take take 2 weeks to react in organic feed so if the pepper didn’t make it past two weeks the soil was too hot to begin and might have thrived with one feeding
Interesting video. I will probably do one of these experiments myself …
Dude, I absolutely love the part where you faked out with the garden. Hose, that was very comical that was fantastic. You had me for a split second.
Yeah I agree. Definitely a good sense of humor helped with the entertainment factor of this vid. Reminded me of the bro science lifting guy.
Me too. I was impressed by the flow.
🤔
Such a funny way of getting important information out there and I can appreciate you for it.
I am in a FB group for tomato growing. there they recommend 10 to 15% urine in the water. the advantage is that it is free
He used full strength urine for his test. He should have used about 3tbsp of urine in his gallon test solution diluted with water. He used 1.5tbsp of miracle grow diluted with water for the other solution. Remember that urine was about half as strong as the miracle grow powder according to several sources so he should have used twice as much urine by weight as he did miracle grow by weight. That is what the problem was. Full strength urine is about a hundred times as strong as his MG diluted solution.
Great video, my bougainvillea plants were blooming when I bought them, last spring but haven’t done anything since..
Your logic makes sense. Wild animals pee in the forest and fields but their urine (and poop) is mixed with whatever else is in the soil to be used by the plants. I saw a video where someone added their pee to mulch which they kept in a wire cage. That mulch eventually found its way around trees and plants. The mulch contained worms so they were happy.
Great experiment, I think the PEE is an excellent amendment for soil that is already rich (compost etc.) in micro-nutrients, but still probably lacks sufficient N and K since these are required in large amounts. Another item to consider however is that the pepper plant may have been burned. I have come across references to university studies that have concluded that urine needs to be cut by a ration of 8 parts water to 1 part urine to avoid being burned. 50/50 may be too concentrated. Though I still think you are exactly right. Pee simply isn't a stand alone fertilizer, but may be quite useful as an augmentation.
10 or higher to be safe.
I would think the urine toxicity depends on what the human has been eating.
And their fluid intake and exercise routine. Im a heavy duty water drinker that also sweats a LOT, so my gallon of pee would be MUCH more clear than his was. And if you collect pee right after vigorous workouts, there will be significantly more ammonia in the mix.
Lots of variables with the pee
Also, their meds. I am on some meds that would kill plants. 😂
@@SameCoin12
He explained he was not on any meds
Depends on how fresh the pee it. Very fresh it is sterile and the N is in the form of urea, nontoxic. But let it stand around a while contaminated and it will ferment into ammonia and become toxic. Space agencies are planning to use human pee when growing food or oxygen producing plants for long term space travel.
@7thsluglord363 looking at the thumbnail of apple cider coloured whizz, my first thought was, "My God are you dehydrated!!" Idk maybe it turns brown when it sits?? But that can't be true because I had a barbarian ex who used bottles and they didn't turn brown....
That was a great video, and I think your method seemed pretty solid. That being said, MiracleGro I think is meant to provide "complete" nutrition where soil biology is lacking. If you were to try repeating this experiment, maybe try adding the soil biology to that inert coco-coir/perlite mix. You wouldn't be adding an additional fertilizer per se to the experiment because what the biology is doing is just making whatever is there accessible to plants. (I could go on a very long rant about this, but I don't want to write you an unasked-for essay in your comments, lol).
Great experiment. Was thinking that if you took multivitamins and minerals or increased your dosage of them maybe the results might be different with the urine. Just something to consider.
What about Meth?? That gets things done!
Nice experiment! I would love to see a 2nd version of this experiment with the plants planted outdoors in garden soil to see the results there.
The next part of your experiment should be a taste test.
the lettuce or the fertilizer😆
Great experiment. Thanks for sharing. You have a great sense of humor. Good video.
Keep the video up, along with the comments!
This is how we learn !!
Thank you for your work !
You’re welcome! I appreciate you watching.
Hey great video! Good thoughts and point of view, the other thing to consider is the salt load from urine. That amount of salt in coir is like you said, not going to have enough micro nutrients and the salt load could start to effect the roots and ability to absorb the nutrients.
Cool test, thanks! Have you used anything like azomite, rock dust, etc?
There is another Chanel that pays for element analysis of that type of trace elements compared to tree leaves and urine and the rock sample had less trace elements than urine or tree leaves
My initial thought was that the nutrients come in a form that plants can not use. For example we pee out creatinine, which does contain nitrogen. But plants may not be able to use it directly and need microbes to break it down first. And these microbes might be missing in the pod, but would exist in soil.
Certainly an interesting experiment, thanks for sharing.
I use straight ammonia as a nitrogen fertilizer. 2 cups per 3 gallons of water and pump spray this mixture on the base of the plants.
I would enjoy seeing a redo of this experiment using normal garden soil, not inert material. Also, mix the urine and water together first prior to watering. You could be burning the plants with straight urine. (Ever notice a dead patch of grass where a dog peed, which, after recovering from the urine burn, turns dark green and lush ?) My guess is the plants will perform equally well with the revised protocol.
In the saltwater aquarium hobby, the fish waste needs to be broken down from ammonia into nitrites and then from nitrites to nitrates or usable nitrogen. Same thing happens in a waste treatment plant.
I wonder if you had the bacteria and time to change that urine into usable nutrients, if it would have made a difference.
Exactly thank you!
Can you expound on this?
I want to start using ray aquarium water on my plants..
@@jaimethiessen When fish pee or poop the water becomes toxic when it builds up so you need to add something to the water in the fish tank that dissolves their waste or changes it into something safe for them to swim in because your freshwater or salt water tank is not a real environment.
Ok. Moreso in Saltwater. Freshwater aquarium water can be used directly?
@@jaimethiessen Yes, probably, not sure. Now it makes sense what he said about the soil. The actual earth like real salt water would be able to break it down naturally instead of using somewhat fake soil in planters. Both tanks freshwater and saltwater need to be cleaned for the fish?
I was having issues growing some plants on my soil. Once I tested, it turned out they were low in Zinc. I didn't even know that was a thing. The micronutrients explanation makes sense. May be adding the micronutrients they may be more compatible.
I loved watching this!! Great experiment!
My grandfather planted lemon tree for my grandmother. He was retired, war vet and drank a lot of beer and deliberately peed on the lemon tree to feed it. It was a small dwarf lemon tree and made hundreds of lemons, always full of juicy lemons better than anything you could buy in the supermarkets.
Nice beer to lemonade conversion happening
@@ravish05 when life give you beer, make lemonade
I think he salted his plants, plus he added an organic fertilizer(with to much salt) to lifeless soil(no microbes). Think you grand father was doing the experiment correctly.
Nice IPA
Could it be the "fermentation factor?"
I have never thought of urine as a complete fertilizer though it does contain more than N, P, and K, but another variable is pH, and urine can have a very high pH especially if consuming a lot of veggies. When I was on a very low carb diet, I was checking the pH of my urine daily, and there were times when it was about a 9! Few plants like or can tolerate a high soil pH (tomatoes are very sensitive, in my experience, to strong urine whether that's from high pH or high nitrogen and can easily decline as your experiment showed), and you don't have compost in your mix for helping to buffer the pH of the urine so you will need more water to reduce the PH. I suggest a redo of the experiment with a lower concentration (maybe 10-50%) the whole length of the experiment--just more volume as the plant grows. I believe you said that the plants looked equally healthy for the first two weeks. Perhaps the 2-week mark is when you jumped the concentration.
Another good experiment would be to see how long plants can remain happy on urine alone without supplementing with other nutrients.
The nitrogen content of urine is also affected by diet. I consume a lot of a food that increases nitrogen content.
I agree, a diet very high in whole food plant foods, especially veggies and fruits, tends to leak to high alkalinity in the urine and saliva.
A diet very high animal protein (especially meat) tends to lead to a more acidic urine and saliva. A diet high in junk foods also tends to lead to a more highly acidic urine and saliva. A diet high in both of the just former will tend to lead to a very highly acidic urine and saliva.
My well water is somewhat acidic. Back when I used to grow stuff (gave up because way too much shade, not enough sun), I used to mix fresh urine with a a little epsom salt, some kelp powder, and a very little bit of wood ash, all in a lot of well water.
To throw another spanner into the works, I don't think that coco coir was buffered so it'd probably throw things out of whack short term.
You can start out any seedling inside any size pot. What you need to keep in mind is not to over water the soil. Remember you’re not watering to soil you are watering the plant. Water accordingly.
This was a great video. I think you're on the right track with your micro-nutrient theory. Good science, good conclusion.
Been a fan for a few years and I must say this is one of your best videos! I laughed out loud multiple times. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us. Wishing you and Dale all the best.
This was a very intelligent and creative gardening experiment. Great work! And thank you for sharing your findings with us! I'm very impressed with your well-spoken conclusions and I love meeting the clever mind behind another great gardener! I look forward to seeing more of your videos.
Wrong... urine has to be digested by soil microbes to be beneficial... not a fair experiment
I will respond under here so maybe it gets seen. So one big problem i see with your experiment @The Millennial Gardener. You use the same scoop with out cleaning it to pour both the pee and the miracle grow into the pots. This was slightly rinsed when you added rain water but you did not do this each time. This is grounds for cross contamination of the different fertilizers and taints the experiment. I applaud the effort and the idea, I suggest a more mindful application of these ideas. I only say this to attempt to assist, not as a knock on your abilities or your channel. I support everything you are doing. I think your doing great, keep it up!
I like to see a repeat of the experiment with a compost tea used to inoculate the roots.
He didn’t use the pee in the right concentration. 1:10 is what I’ve read so he killed it by burning it with too strong a dose. Another person posted that seedlings require even more dilution, 1:20. Using a sample size of one also isn’t scientifically worthy of showing any results anyways. What if the one plant had some root damage from the transplant? He just turned off many ppl from using a free natural fertilizer.
Awesome video
I was under the impression that the urine needs to decompose for at least a month before its
Usable
A video of this experiment in garden dirt would be interesting aswell.great job
Thank you
Is urine any good at catalyzing the composting process? Have used it to break down maple and oak leaves. Seemed to work well.
Something I was wondering as well
It's not compete until you harvest and sample the product to see which tastes better. Come on, take one for the team. 🙂 Btw, the P should have been kept on the fridge, because warm temps damage any vitamins and minerals that may have been in it. I would also guess that fermented P can't be a good fert either.
Urine should be stored in a cool dark area and fermented for 30 days for sterility before use for agricultural purposes.
Urine at room temperature converts to ammonia.
You can see my videos of a garden fertilized with urine.
Human wee is used by those wishing to dye with plant-sourced indigo dyes by purely natural means (ie without industrially-produced chemicals). It is referred to as a Sig vat, and the chemical changes needed are caused by the fermentation of human urine ... very interesting process.
You obviously already know that your sample size was too small, N=40 is considered a bare minimum for statistically significant results. Also, the urine was way too strong, I have seen it recommended to be applied no more than once per week at a 5% or less solution. I'd like to see such an experiment redone with these considerations.
I was going to say the same thing.
He's an engineer, and they typically work with small sample sizes, for example when doing materials stress and strain testing, or failure analysis. They believe the small sample is a pretty close approximation of the population. A real scientist (that is, not an engineer) knows that ain't so. Even a biologist, with limited math skills, knows enough to make the sample size large enough to yield statistically significant results, and would verify a conclusion by hiring a statistician to validate the work.
exactly what I was thinking
@@DanielinLaTuna Engineers typically work with HUGE quantities, for example when making 10 Million mobile phones or 10 million cinderblocks and do pull a few here and there for quality checks (and yes, they understand the math involved in sampling and testing.) An engineer gets fired if they don't know their math inside and out because the thing doesn't work. Perhaps you are basing your impression of engineers on too small a sample size, or perhaps you have been faking your data in a rush to get your papers published.
@@asicengineer thank you! My dad is an engineer. Let’s just say without his work, and those who work with him, the military would have a lot of training accidents.
that, and down here in Australia native plants suffer from phosphorus toxicity as we have a primitive soil.
I used to have an orange tree that was growing in clay soil. I don't know if pee helped it at all, but I didn't add anything else and it grew loads of big oranges each year. I'm certain the soil itself had all the nutrients the plant needed.
trees roots go much deeper than veggies
Great informative video! I love doing garden experiments!
Thanks for posting this experiment. I saw another comment on CZcams on another channel that stated that the author's father used only urine and wood ash and had incredible (enviable) yields. I"m sure dilution is important and he was growing in garden soil.
Especially with urine AND woodash, you really have to dilute.
“Babe I’m not drunk I’m just fertilizing the garden”
Good video. You might want to factor in the salt load from Urine. ( one reason you should not drink it with no other water) I use a 20 to 1 dilution for my lawn.
Thanks so much for taking so much time with this test. I had no idea the urine was actually a good fertilizer!
I believe that human urine ( or any mammalian urine for that matter) has had enough trials over many years, decades, and centuries to be relied upon as a safe organic soil amendment for hungry growing plants. we can all go back and forth about the proper ratio to administer, but the safe road of diluted solution can't possibly be harmful to plants. Thanks for be brave enough to publish the video.
You are incorrect. This is called a false positive.
This happens in the early stages of the plant and provide plenty to talk about as growth is natural.
Julius Hensel detailed this clearly, as the manure companies had been pushing their waste to the minds of rot.
Thank you for experiment. I noticed that the urine concentration is way too strong than the MiracleGrow, Urine was dilute 1:1 and MG was diluted more than 1:100, bc the half cup of MG is already diluted. Ideally urine should be 1:10
In addition, nightshade like pepper and tomato seedlings are very sensitive to amonia and they wilt and die with the smallest amount of amonia in soil.
Agree
Yes, the amount of urine should have been a tablespoonful vs half tablespoonful of MG powder both diluted properly per feeding.
but it was very entertaining...
The miracle grow was NOT diluted 1:100. The way miracle grow is labeled so that the NPK ratio on the label represents the ratio after mixing with water. The actual salt granules are very concentrated, and then they are diluted to the labeled NPK when you follow the mixing instructions. So to get half strength miracle grow, you use half the amount of salt granules with the normal amount of water listed.
Likewise, he said that the urine has a natural NPK ratio of like 10-2-4, so to get the miracle grow to match that he had to half the strength of 20-8-16, down to 10-4-8.
He did everything correct, only differences is that he maybe should have used a fertilizer that was originally 20-4-8, that way it would completely match the urine in the NPK ratio after diluting.
@@gabumonboys Thank you for your comment about miracle grow concentration, you are correct, we generally follow the Miracle Grow instruction on how to dilute the fertilizer and it works! which is not the case in urine, what I know is urine contains on average 10-20 grams of Nitrogen per one litre of urine, that a crazy amount of nitrogen. and a considerable amount of this nitrogen is in the form of amonia which is really potent and sometimes toxic to plant especially seedlings if not diluted correctly, which is not the case in this experiment.
Yes, I agree with other comments. Pee was way too concentrated. Also don't ferment your pee but use it as fresh as possible because the nutrients deteriorate quickly.
I'm very curious to see what would happen with just one scoop of MG at the start.
They don't need much in the way of micro nutrients, but they do need them.
But I would really like to see this with more identical fertilizers, those micro nutrients really make a difference.
The main problem here is dosage. By nature p is a great herbicide. If you want to get rid of weeds in your yard and don't want to use weed killer, 99% of the time it kills anything that you have growing you want to kill. At least in my experience that's the case. When it's full strength or half.
The only time that urine actually makes good for fertilizer when it's one part urine to 10 part water. Other than that it doesn't work as it's too strong.
Urine is actually toxic enough to kill athletes foot fungus.
I've used white vinegar to kill weeds between the bricks in my patio, but only because I didn't want the lingering odor of human urine in our seating area. I have used possible further out to discourage rodents, though.
I haven't been able to kill any weeds where I whizz, but I shall keep trying
He used full strength urine for his test. He should have used about 3tbsp of urine in his gallon test solution diluted with water. He used 1.5tbsp of miracle grow diluted with water for the other solution. Remember that urine was about half as strong as the miracle grow powder according to several sources so he should have used twice as much urine by weight as he did miracle grow by weight. That is what the problem was. Full strength urine is about a hundred times as strong as his MG diluted solution.
Good video bro. You put a lot of work into this and it shows. Happy gardening.
Thankyou. To overcome the limitations of urine I process it by putting it over my garden compost pile - not only does it speed up the process but super charges it.
I would love to see pee vs nothing just to see how much it helps
Need a control without any fertilizer.
There are more videos.
It helps so much you wouldn’t believe. Try it out you will be amazed. I use 1 liter of urine and 8 liters of water. Actually there is nothing better than urine
@@Vertikala-pc5ig The harsh reality is that most commercial fertilizers have salts in them. They seem good in the short run, but it kills the biology in the soil in the long run. Requiring even more fertilizer later.
I'm gonna try it, nothing to lose 😂
Interesting experiment. Thank you! Please also consider doing the experiment in living soil (your normal garden soil, topped-dressed w some compost soil)? It would be interesting to see if urine would do better where there is active soil life/biology all around it to diffuse it & break it down, maybe helping the plants utilize it's micro-nutrients better. My garden plants do very well this way & it's lowered disease & pest pressure.
Active soil life is assumed, but not always correctly, it my intention to work with the naturally occurring microbes in the soil. There is the emerging field of regenerative ag which deals with soil biology.
Thank you, I have wondered about this as well. My neighbor uses urine, although I never asked how it is used or if it is combined with other fertilizers, but I appreciate your test! I think I will stick with my Miracle Grow!
Loved the video lol, anything for science, only thing you're missing is a control setting with plants just getting water.
I use human urine in my compost piles. It is mixed with hen house liter and veggie stalks including corn stalks. I do have good luck with this, and believe it is better than direct addition to a plant.
Urine kicks compost into high gear.
If you chose to do this again next year, I would very much like to see a comparison of the two "fertilizers" with good soil. Perhaps using some garden soil mixed with added perlite for drainage?
No experiment survives first contact with data, but it was a relaxing pleasure to watch you go through the process. Or at least the first iteration of the process; I'd value an experiment to test your hypothesis about missing nutrients, and the many commenters' hypothesis that half diluted urine is too harsh.
loved this, and all good! the micronutrient thought makes sense.
I have never in my life been so entertained or laughed so hard on a garden video but yet learned so much!😂
Dude, this is the best garden video I’ve ever seen! That music and preparation for the showdown on Pee vs. MiracleGro had me cracking up
Laughing so loud my cats were looking at me like I am crazy😂
This was an good experiment, thank you. I was wondering if you had considered adding a control plant as a third category by feeding it just water? This could be compared to the urine to see what the urine did to aid in growth.
I have the same question / request for a water-only control group.
We did this test some years ago and posted it. Couldn't tell the difference! Remarkable how well urine worked.
Was it in soil or in a sterile medium? I specifically avoided soil, since soil has all sorts of nutrients and uncontrolled variables. I used coir to ensure no contamination from soil.
I thought I would add some points here. Synthetic fertilizers are designed to grow crops through a chemical process. To use human urine naturally, you have to allow natural process of converting it through nitrification and mineralization that would prove your results otherwise. There are bacteria like nitrosomonas and nitrobacter that convert ammonia (for instance) to nitrates, which is excellent for plants. The trace minerals would be included in what you eat naturally, so its there. To properly utilise the natural elements , you must create a natural environment for the bacteria to thrive and create a symbiotic relationship so plants can grow. This is how aquaponics for instance operate.
You should do an experiment with real soil. What if Pee and real soil works as a team to produce good plants
That wouldn't be controllable. Everyone's soil is going to be different, so the results would be unreliable. I have very sandy soil where I live, so my results could be dramatically different than someone who has a heavy clay soil, or a loamier native soil. The only way to do this reliably is to use an inert medium.
I think urine is still fine to use but you have to use it as a supplement only. For example use miracle grow or whatever you normally do but then also mix urine in diluted with water when you are watering other times.
Urine is great for turning the blooms of French hydrangeas from blue to pink. Accidentally discovered this is a young boy peeing on my moms hydrangea plant, LOL!
Great 👍 experiment thanks 😊
This was a GREAT video! The experiment was interesting, full of good information, and also humorous! My husband and I laughed multiple times while watching! 😂 Thank you for all you do, we have learned a lot in the couple months we have been watching your videos.
This teaches a wrong result. The urine needed to be diluted to work, otherwise it would pickle the plant like dog piss pickles the grass. If he used 10 tablespoons of Miracle Grow per gallon it would have been a fair comparison. Entertaining stuff but do it again with 5-10 times diluted pee to show people a meaningful result.
I appreciate that you decided to post anyway. You've contributed data to humanity.
Age of the urine matters. Notice old pee smells like ammonia? Duh 🙄
Results need updating to allow for this variable.
Awesome comparison. Thanks!
You’re welcome!
Human urine has a lot of sodium. It prevents uptake of water and can stunt growth. You could test the salinity of your urine with a dip test. And at the end of the experiment take X grams of soil from each pot (around the roots), add a few mL of water and do a saline test at the end to see if you're salting the plants.
Like you said though, there are a lot of micronutrients missing that real soil would help with.
Next step is compost/potting soil/natural soil - and do 6 seedings. Though also only having 1 in each isn't a very definitive test. having 10 in each soil type/fertilizer type would start to give you a much better idea, but that would be 60 plants...
I LOVE when gardeners test what they are talking about, not just passing on "here-say". This was so interesting. Great montage too 😂
Hearsay
It's only a partial test. I'm willing to bet that in good soil, you don't normally need either. And when there's a shortage, the pee solution will work perfectly. The soil and all the organisms in it provide the micronutrients (and some of the macros). Do this experiment with 3 containers, all in proper gardening soil. We're not at farm scale where the soil can be leeched over years and years of use, so I don't think we need to supplement. I grow hot peppers every year, and I usually forget to feed them at all. They still come out amazing and burn your face off.
@@Arthur327327 always love the spell checkers- what would we do without you in the comment section 🤷
I remember growing up the horse would pee in a spot on the turf and that spot would go dark green and grow like crazy.
Isn't it funny to think that is how we probably figured this stuff out. Our great great...grandfather noticed the same thing and became a land baron. 😊
What have you been eating Dude! Thanks for sharing your experiment!
Glad to get this problem solved Thanks for this info
You’re welcome!
Millennial Gardener providing a valuable community service 👍👍
Glad you enjoyed it!
@@TheMillennialGardenera week of good pee wasted on a pee plant I wonder how that pee plant tasted like 😂😅?? Very pissy
Not only urine is a good firtlizer, but it also can be used to calm skin irritation and heal wounds faster.
Useful experiment thanks
Great video thanks. Im def gonna experiment
I'd be interested in a follow-up experiment comparing inert medium to potting soil and/or untreated compost or soil from the yard.
If the pee-plants do much better on pre-fertilised potting soil it would further strengthen the hypothesis that urine is lacking in one or more micronutrients.
Thank you for the ten-minute long entertaining advertisement for miracle grow. Great job with controlling all the parameters of the experiment
Exactly. It wasn't an experiment it was a 'how not to use urine as a fertiliser' demonstration. Urine should be used fresh and diluter 10:1 with water.
I used to take a leak in my mother's garden regularly. Can attest that the tomatos and peppers grew well, and were delicious.
Good workout. Interesting 🤔 but nasty experiment 😝. Great time at shoreline. And thank you for explaining the end results.
I usually purchase any broken bags of fertilizer at a discount from the Home Depot with a military discount. And save them for a later day when perlite and other broken bags are sold at discount. Then mix them together and generously spread the barrels across the entire garden. And turn the mix into the soil before watering and tarping and leaving covered for two or three weeks to kill of weed growth. Then uncover and begin planting seedlings and seeds.
I have had great yields from our family garden. With the included addition of Miracle Grow after a month and an additional application a month later then no more but fresh water up to harvest. Yummy
Then turn the soil water, tarp and repeat the entire process.
I will be copying your black can composting x2 because you are on it!
Very good explaining of garden success and failures.
Keep up the great sharing., AL
I'm curious if salt content in pee had an effect.
He used full strength urine for his test. He should have used about 3tbsp of urine in his gallon test solution diluted with water. He used 1.5tbsp of miracle grow diluted with water for the other solution. Remember that urine was about half as strong as the miracle grow powder according to several sources so he should have used twice as much urine by weight as he did miracle grow by weight. That is what the problem was. Full strength urine is about a hundred times as strong as his MG diluted solution.
If you have that much salt in yer pee, yer garden is th least of yer worries. Just don't pee in th same place all th time.
I developed wrlds best garden system. Chicken wire vases lined with leaves. Can dip in water to save water. Mulch all surfaces, breathes better, roots grow beneath vase or if lay on side, endless advantages mobile garden. Plants exploding in these vases. Cut 32" x 48" give u 20" tall 4gallon pot, dynamite (shaped long root system)
Plant tomatoe 1gallon dirt, add dirt as tomatoe grows so stem forms more&more roots.
Ocean water is same as human womb. Plants like it. Heals cuts fast. Table salt poison.