It makes me so angry that this is the only version of this scene that I can find on CZcams, this is the best scene and yet the best version is a joke shitpost
@@osvaldodeleon256 Yea I agree, the scene is still immaculate without the music, doesn't feel awkward at all. If Nolan had done the scene without music, it still would've been perfect.
A lot of people find this funny, but I find it also pretty scary or personal without the music and just raw dialogue, especially when he screams “I DIDN’T ASK YOU THAT DOCTOR!!!”
Oppenheimer: We, we’ve freely used the atomic bomb. Roger Robb: In fact, Doctor you assisted in selecting the target to drop the atomic bomb on Japan, didn’t you? Oppenheimer: Yes Roger Robb: Well then you knew, did you know that by dropping that atomic bomb on the target you selected, that thousands of civilians would be killed or injured, is that correct? Oppenheimer: Yes, not as many as turned out… Roger Robb: Oh. Well, how many were killed or injured? Oppenheimer: 70,000 Roger Robb: 70,000 at both Hiroshima and… Oppenheimer 110,000 at both. Roger Robb: On the day of each bombing? Oppenheimer: Yes. Roger Robb: And in the weeks and years that followed? Oppenheimer: It has been put at somewhere between 50,000 and 100,000 Roger Robb: That’s 220,000 dead, at least. Oppenheimer: Yes. Roger Robb: Any moral scruples about that? Oppenheimer: Terrible Ones. Roger Robb: Yet you testified in here that the bombing of Hiroshima was very successful. Oppenheimer: Technically successful. Roger Robb: Oh! Technically, it was very successful. Oppenheimer: And it is also alleged to have helped end the war. Roger Robb: Would you have been supportive of the dropping of a hydrogen bomb on Hiroshima? Oppenheimer: That would make no sense at all. Roger Robb: Why? Oppenheimer: The target is too small. Roger Robb:: Well, supposing there had been a target in Japan big enough for a thermonuclear weapon, would you have been opposed to the dropping of it? Oppenheimer: This was not a problem with which I was confronted… Roger Robb: I’m confronting you with it now, sir. Roger Robb: Would you have been opposed to the dropping of a thermonuclear weapon on Japan because of moral scruples? Oppenheimer: Yes, I believe I would, sir. Roger Robb: Did you oppose the dropping of an atomic bomb on Hiroshima because of moral scruples? Oppenheimer: We set fourth our arg… Roger Robb: No you, you, you, you, you! I’m asking you. You! Oppenheimer: I set… Roger Robb: You, you, you! Oppenheimer: I set fourth our arguments against dropping it, but I did not endorse them. Roger Robb: You mean after working night and day for three years building the bomb, you then argued against the use of it. *laughs* Oppenheimer: I was asked by the secretary of war what the views of scientists were. I gave him the views against and the views for. Roger Robb: You supported the dropping of the atom bomb on Japan. Oppenheimer: What do you mean, support? Roger Robb: You supported it. Oppenheimer: What do you mean, support? Roger Robb: You helped pick the target, didn’t you? Oppenheimer: I did my job. I was not in the policy making position of Los Alamos. I would have done anything I was asked to do. Roger Robb: Then you would have built the H-bomb too. wouldn’t you? Oppenheimer: I couldn’t. Roger Robb: I didn’t ask you that, Doctor! Roger Robb: And the GAC report, which you co-authored after the Soviet atomic test, said A SUPER BOMB SHOULD NEVER BE BUILT! Oppenheimer: What we meant… What I meant was… Roger Robb: What you? Who? Who? Oppenheimer: What I meant… Roger Robb: And wouldn’t the Russians do anything to increase their strength? Oppenheimer: If we did it, they would have to do it. Our efforts would only fuel their efforts, just as it had with the atomic bomb. Roger Robb: “Just as it had with the atomic bomb,” exactly! Roger Robb: No moral scruples in 1945, plenty in 1949.
This conversation is still really intense even with the muffled audio, being unable to see the facial expressions or hearing the music. Like, it's not as cinematic, but I actually felt uncomfortable listening to this.
Would you ever consider doing one for Strauss' hissy fit monologue? they were shushing him because they didn't want him to be heard screaming from the hall
It makes me so angry that this is the only version of this scene that I can find on CZcams, this is the best scene and yet the best version is a joke shitpost
Just posted a 1 minute of this scene that has the music, and isnt behind a wall!!!
Right? I rewatched the film and came on CZcams just to get the _feels_ again
Goddamn it I can still feel Robert’s tension from outside
Hearing the dialogue without the music proves how important music is in movies
it's still really great but it is kind of awkward, still one of my favorite scenes in this masterpiece
I feel like without the music, you can sense the tension between Oppenheimer and the interrogator. This is a masterpiece!
@@osvaldodeleon256 Yea I agree, the scene is still immaculate without the music, doesn't feel awkward at all. If Nolan had done the scene without music, it still would've been perfect.
A lot of people find this funny, but I find it also pretty scary or personal without the music and just raw dialogue, especially when he screams “I DIDN’T ASK YOU THAT DOCTOR!!!”
So much trouble Oppie had to go through just because Albert didn't have the courtesy to wish Strauss Good Morning.
damn this is a fucking masterpiece
Oppenheimer: We, we’ve freely used the atomic bomb.
Roger Robb: In fact, Doctor you assisted in selecting the target to drop the atomic bomb on Japan, didn’t you?
Oppenheimer: Yes
Roger Robb: Well then you knew, did you know that by dropping that atomic bomb on the target you selected, that thousands of civilians would be killed or injured, is that correct?
Oppenheimer: Yes, not as many as turned out…
Roger Robb: Oh. Well, how many were killed or injured?
Oppenheimer: 70,000
Roger Robb: 70,000 at both Hiroshima and…
Oppenheimer 110,000 at both.
Roger Robb: On the day of each bombing?
Oppenheimer: Yes.
Roger Robb: And in the weeks and years that followed?
Oppenheimer: It has been put at somewhere between 50,000 and 100,000
Roger Robb: That’s 220,000 dead, at least.
Oppenheimer: Yes.
Roger Robb: Any moral scruples about that?
Oppenheimer: Terrible Ones.
Roger Robb: Yet you testified in here that the bombing of Hiroshima was very successful.
Oppenheimer: Technically successful.
Roger Robb: Oh! Technically, it was very successful.
Oppenheimer: And it is also alleged to have helped end the war.
Roger Robb: Would you have been supportive of the dropping of a hydrogen bomb on Hiroshima?
Oppenheimer: That would make no sense at all.
Roger Robb: Why?
Oppenheimer: The target is too small.
Roger Robb:: Well, supposing there had been a target in Japan big enough for a thermonuclear weapon, would you have been opposed to the dropping of it?
Oppenheimer: This was not a problem with which I was confronted…
Roger Robb: I’m confronting you with it now, sir.
Roger Robb: Would you have been opposed to the dropping of a thermonuclear weapon on Japan because of moral scruples?
Oppenheimer: Yes, I believe I would, sir.
Roger Robb: Did you oppose the dropping of an atomic bomb on Hiroshima because of moral scruples?
Oppenheimer: We set fourth our arg…
Roger Robb: No you, you, you, you, you! I’m asking you. You!
Oppenheimer: I set…
Roger Robb: You, you, you!
Oppenheimer: I set fourth our arguments against dropping it, but I did not endorse them.
Roger Robb: You mean after working night and day for three years building the bomb, you then argued against the use of it. *laughs*
Oppenheimer: I was asked by the secretary of war what the views of scientists were. I gave him the views against and the views for.
Roger Robb: You supported the dropping of the atom bomb on Japan.
Oppenheimer: What do you mean, support?
Roger Robb: You supported it.
Oppenheimer: What do you mean, support?
Roger Robb: You helped pick the target, didn’t you?
Oppenheimer: I did my job. I was not in the policy making position of Los Alamos. I would have done anything I was asked to do.
Roger Robb: Then you would have built the H-bomb too. wouldn’t you?
Oppenheimer: I couldn’t.
Roger Robb: I didn’t ask you that, Doctor!
Roger Robb: And the GAC report, which you co-authored after the Soviet atomic test, said A SUPER BOMB SHOULD NEVER BE BUILT!
Oppenheimer: What we meant… What I meant was…
Roger Robb: What you? Who? Who?
Oppenheimer: What I meant…
Roger Robb: And wouldn’t the Russians do anything to increase their strength?
Oppenheimer: If we did it, they would have to do it. Our efforts would only fuel their efforts, just as it had with the atomic bomb.
Roger Robb: “Just as it had with the atomic bomb,” exactly!
Roger Robb: No moral scruples in 1945, plenty in 1949.
Goat
All those words is true?
Yes u can find it on Google Oppenheimer security hearings@@TheProtagonist2020
@@TheProtagonist2020transcript of the hearing was disclosed so I’m assuming Nolan took some from that like he did with Dr Hill’s testimony
Those are some thin ass walls
This conversation is still really intense even with the muffled audio, being unable to see the facial expressions or hearing the music.
Like, it's not as cinematic, but I actually felt uncomfortable listening to this.
A SUPER BOMB SHOULD NEVER BE BUILT!
John Connor be like to the human resistance 🤣
Would you ever consider doing one for Strauss' hissy fit monologue? they were shushing him because they didn't want him to be heard screaming from the hall
That would be perfect
Incredible acting!
The scene still works well even without the music meant to represent the chaos in Oppenheimer’s mind.
Honestly it would have been even funnier if you left the music in, imagining it muffled like it's emanating from the room itself is really funny
this is great lmfao
Really is such an interesting perspective on this scene
This scene cut us real deep just now.
Ted Cruz saw this and decided to go full Roger Robb on Zuckerberg 🤣
Just saw what u were talking about lol Mark got smashed down like Oppenheimer
How does one remove the music from a movie?
Ouch