We're back at Notre Dame for Goodtimes's take on the Hunchback tale. Prepare for Jetlag as this adaptation gives us more AND less than ever before! phelous.com / phelous
Frollo is a kind man who raises Quasimodo as his own son after losing his family. *Frollo is an attempted murderer and rapist who beats on Quasimodo for going outdoors!* Quasimodo attacks Esmeralda with Frollo, and tries to drag her away. *Esmeralda gives water to Quasimodo because she feels sorry for him!* Esmeralda confesses to killing Phoebus. *Esmeralda claims she's innocent, and Phoebus isn't even dead!* Phoebus tells Esmeralda he loves her, but is then stabbed by Frollo, leaving Esmeralda heartbroken and telling Frollo to kill her too. *Esmeralda realises she loves Quasimodo!* CONSISTENCY?! WHAT IS CONSISTENCY?!?!
A lot of those things also appear in the book, but the book has so much more room to explain the motivations of the characters. And in the book, we are meant to pity Quasimodo but that doesn't mean everything he does is good. He was abused and brainwashed his whole life in the book. No wonde he didn't turn out as the best person. Esmeralda did indeed feel pity for Quasimodo, but she still was afraid of him as well. Of course, she never fell in love with Quasi and she dies in the end, just like every other character except for Phoebus and Pierre. In the book, Esmeralda did confess to attacking Phoebus but only after being tortured. She said it so the torture would stop.
I feel really bad for Beauty and the Beast and Hunchback of Notre Dame. Disney makes one movie each for those, and there's like 50 fucking thousand knock offs and cash ins.
The first adaptation that has both Phoebus and Pierre, and yet, Esmeralda manages to end up with Quasimodo. Weeeell, come to think of it, she kinda did in the book. But being dead and lying next to him, until their bones turned to dust...
BilboKoira I have the book coincidentally and haven’t gotten to that part yet. So I guess I was wrong in thinking that there were at least two people who cared about Esmeralda.
In the novel Pierre was more attracted to the goat than Esmeralda. You can tell that Victor Hugo's works are suscetible to Darkness Induced Audience Apathy.
The two earlier songs are kinda good, but the third mone, which already is too bland and a copycat, outright contradicts the point of the story. The song is about how his infatuation has freed him, but in the original story, such "love" puts you in danger or makes you evil (funny that an adulterer did that point, but that's another case).
thank goodness they never got to make an animated Harry Potter.... "his parents were killed by the evil wizaaaard, he was always a wizard himself, but lived with cruel relatiiiiiives, he went to a school of magic with his new friends, but the dark wizard comes back to seek his reveeeeenge"
Aside from the ending and cutting out the reason why Esmeralda had confessed to killing Phoebus because she was tortured until she confessed, this was surprisingly accurate to the novel. Though I will say that this ending where Esmeralda fell in love with Quasimodo while not as good as the ending of the Disney version where the city accepted him and praised him as a hero, it was not as insulting as him either secretly being an angel, being handsome all along, or Esmeralda leaving him to rot forever in prison while she just walked away with Pierre. Also I can assure you that this opening song is never going to topple The Bells of Notre Dame as the best opening song for this story.
Goodtimes!Frollo: (trying to stab Esmeralda) Be mine! Me: OR YOU WILL BUUUUUUUUUUUURN!!!!!!! Weirdly enough, I think these versions of Frollo and Phoebus are among the most accurate in any adaptation. I can only ask why so many adaptations won't accept the love between Pierre and Djali. In the book, those two were the _only_ ones who ended up happy.
To be completely fair, add some actual character development, and this would actually be a somewhat decent adaptation....although the logic of being stabbed in the back and only needing a sling for your arm would still be highly questionable.
Really, even Quasimodo's likability could have been salvaged if he had questioned Frollo or expressed unwillingness or reluctance to capture Esmerelda, if not outright trying to stand up to Frollo, and have Arch Judge-Deacon Frollo hit him and/or threaten him. Then they would have established the abusive relationship between the two, and that Quasimodo at least has the potential to be a better person than his father.
@@DalekTheSupreme i mean, none of that happened in the book tho. he was never supposed to be a sweet likable angel in the first place. he never question whether or not kidnapping someone is bad, he just simply did it because someone he loved asked him to do
@@andreamess5345 Right, the original character is, like you've said, basically a puppydog who will go along with anything as long as someone he loves tells him to do it., and he took psychotic glee in causing others harm, like smashing in a guard's face or pouring molten lead on the angry mob. There's a reason Quasimodo was considered part of the Universal Monsters for the longest time. To be honest, while this is going to sound like absolute sacrilege to Hugo purists, I prefer Disney's take on the character to the original novel - the original character just kinda feels like a cruel stereotype despite actually being the most heroic character in the book.
Too bad it's Sunday, Quasimodo would have kept his position as Pope of Fools tomorrow (wait, a character actually says something similar when Q is in the stocks).
the judge is deaf as well but hides it. Quasimodo getting punished and getting punished extra was the result of several misunderstandings created by this fact. he got sentenced for disrespecting the court when his answers did not match the judge's questions at all. It is a great scene in the book and I don't know if it ever made it accuratly into a movie
Count Orlok Subscribe to his Patreon and you get to see his content earlier. I just like to support him since his videos brought me a lot of joy during my stressful college years.
These animated Hunchback of Notre Dame adaptations really missed an opportunity by not having a rejected Pierre run off with Esmeralda's goat, like in the original story. Even Dingo almost got that right, except there Pierre leaves town with both the goat and Esmeralda.
For what it is, this has pretty good animation and is a decently accurate to the book adaptation - that doesn't make it a good movie, but it has a lot more going for it than the other ones Phelous reviewed. It failed as a movie by not establishing any reason to care for the characters if you're completely unfamiliar with the story and didn't seem to have very good storytelling, but I'm actually kind of impressed.
The problem is that they cared too much to be faithful to the book that they forgot to make us relate to the characters and make a story we can follow. The ending was rather forced and the last song opposes the message of the book.
wow. judging by the animation which is typical for Goodtimes entertainment and jetlag, I feel like I'm watching an anime version of hunchback of Notre Dame. and believe me if there was an anime version of the hunchback I'd be surprised.
I guess Pierre just gripped Esmeralda's wrist with such force that he cut the flow of blood into her hand off, and that's why it turned all white...? Nah, not really, there's no way a wimp such as Pierre can muster so much strength.
15:34 Man, those 15th Century electric fluorescent street lamps were always my favorite part of this story, even more so than the blues-singing synthesizer-playing gargoyles.
Didgeree Media Truth be told the only thing I respect I have for golden films they didn't sugarcoat real life tragedies...I don't think goldenfilms would want to do titanic
Didgeree Media The only possibly good thing about that would be the Nostalgia Critic review that would come after. That would be like what, four or five at the point
Liezl Bohnen reminder that good adaptations strive to be better than what they're adapting which requires skill and creativity (Disney) while bad adaptations just copy what they're adapting because it's easier and they just want money (Dingo, Goodtimes ect)
Universe Artist "Be better than what they are adapting". Well, if that's the case they failed, because they were not even close to quality of original book. Albeit closer than Dingo or Good times.
A good adaptation can be very good and still be very true to the it's source material. In fact when the adaptation becomes too different it can be seen as failing in being an adaptation
Servo Augusta I mean, when an adaptation becomes too similar that can also be a failing, really whether or not it's a good thing should more important than how close to the original the thing is or isn't
His downward spiral was better established in the book He gradually lost each of his morals and became consumed by his lust for Esmeralda The moral dilemma he experienced was also explored a bit more if I recall correctly It’s been a while since I read the book but I know it was a hell of a lot better than this dumpster fire of a film
Ridgwaycer and you can’t blame this version of the story either because that was exactly how it was in the novel. But then again in the novel they tortured her until she confessed to murdering Phoebus. Also Phoebus decided to not come forward and say that he was really alive until she was being led to her execution just because he is that much of a douche waffle and the court didn’t care anyways because they also believed her guilty of being a with.
Pierre: But what of me?! *I* would be the one to be hanged! Ursula: That's riiight! Life's full of tough choices, inn't it? Also, I've realized this is the *second* shitty adaptation that has Esmeralda getting together with Quasimodo in the end. But you've got to give this one credit for not doing the "handsome all along" fakeout.
It's just like the disney version, just with a greater level of book accuracy! All it's missing is character development/compelling characters, consistency, beautiful animation, gripping music, well-done voice acting, and well tuned atmosphere. On the bright side, though, they did get rid of those gargoyles... only to replace their role as comedic relief with Pierre. I'm suddenly missing the gargoyles more than I ever thought I would.
Except for Esmeralda surviving her mother not being there and Quasimodo not getting whipped this is one of if not the most accurate adaptation of The Hunchback of Notre Dame a lot of the quotes are directly from the book including Esmeralda shouting murder when Pierre gets knocked down
The 1982 live-action British version follows it almost similarly, but retaining everything from the book and following it pretty much to the letter for the most part with the main exception of the 1938 film ending where after being discovered and the gypsies come to the rescue as they battle the guard, Esmeralda escapes with Pierre (who she falls in love with in this as a shoehorned plot aside from the main one once rejected by Captain Phoebus) while Quasimodo creates a distraction and is chased to the rooftops before pulling Frollo (an archdeacon as in this and the novel) from the roof, then holding on to one of the gargoyles for a moment as he realizes he's screwed if he lets them save him, thus he lets go. They keep much of the dialogue, much of the themes, and is perhaps the one other accurate version besides this one. I personally consider it my go-to film adaptation due to the few changes not being all that bad and an homage to the few decent things from the classic black-and-white version that was almost in-name-only, i.e., the ending while having properly adjusted the love story (not compositing the two guys into an honorable swashbuckler and changing the genre as was the fault of the original while keeping the added romantic element that makes for good Hollywood). You should Google it.
4:35- Sorry, Quasimoto, but we're giving the role of Spider-Man to Tom Holland instead. 5:18- HEEEEEEEEEEEEEE! 7:28- Or maybe what happened to Palpatine in Revenge of the Sith also happened to Frollo. 14:18- Stupid goat. He spelled "Phelous" wrong. Top notch on the Simpsons jokes.
5:18 HIDDEN OLD MAN! (Edit: I'm glad to see him in full again, and I hope he does read another Creepypasta) I woke up to this review, means I'm gonna have good times today. Amazing.
Watching this I realized that the VA for Frollo has to be Scott McNeil, I recognize that angry raspy voice acting anywhere! There totally could have been more DBZ references in this review.
Was watching a Little House on the Prairie DVD. Good times distributed them apparently. I snickered like an idiot. I want to see Old Man on the Prairie.
What is your name sir? Captain Phebis the Shadow Perv, at your service! The captain was right there to save Esmeralda only because he was stalking her!!
Is it wrong that I kind of found Esmeralda hot here, I'm mean she is definitely not Disney version hot, but she isn't bad of a looker here either compare to all the other women in these movies.
Ziltoid the Omniscient i thought pink eyes Esmeralda is beautiful she is beautiful at least unlike stupid ugly ass esemermelody with her annoying talking musical instruments Bleah!
Why is Esmeralda, a french woman abducted by the gypsies as a child, the only dark skinned person in the whole gypsy tabor? Is she a Romani gypsy abducted by a bunch of french posers in this version? And damn, just because Disney decided to adapt a dark, Gothic story that's utterly unsuitable for children into a family film, it doesn't mean YOU have to, every mockbuster animation studio ever sans Video Brinquedo.
@@fightingmedialounge519 Well, yes, of course. The difference is that Disney somehow succeeded in doing so. But these knock-off artists, don't seem to realize that Disney succeeded despite their choices of stories for adaptation, not because of them.
The Disney one is based off the stage musical. And actually even Victor Hugo himself rewrote his story later to have a happier ending because the original is so depressing.
You realise that ANIMATION is not solely for children right? Or are you a idiot For those who can’t READ: I’m on about animation in general not Goodtimes but I thought that was obvious 🤦♀️
Seeing Kathleen Barr was in this annoys me just as much as seeing Christopher Lee in the Beauty and the beast one. The Great and Powerful Trixie was in some movies she's not proud of, it seems
This adaptation just might be the most faithful adaptation of The Hunchback of Notre Dame as well as the closest we will get to an anime adaptation of The Hunchback of Notre Dame.
I actually couldn't stop laughing for 5 minutes when Quasi asked "Can I come too?" and then got kicked off by Phoebus. I don't know why I thought that was so frigging funny. XD
I'm surprised that this other than the Disney version is the closest to an complete version of the story. Better than the main character being handsome and having wings.
Hey, I found out there's an animated tv series based off The Hunchback Of Notre Dame. I discovered it on accident on Tvtropes, it's apparently called The Magical Adventures Of Quasimodo. Looks pretty dumb all things considered, so you consider checking it out and reviewing it... and no, I'm not making it up, it actually does exist (don't know if it'd be easy to find or not)
Interesting also that the little mermaid despite it being the movie that started renaissance and one of the most popular princesses only had one as I'm aware of.
But those came from Disney themselves, I'm talking about other companies taking the fairly tale and make their own to cash in on the Disney movie. So far all their was is the one good times movie and that's it not even a Dingo version of the little mermaid exists.
Your channel is full of amazing content, but nothing ever beats these reviews. They never fail to make me laugh; keep up the great work. YEEE HEEEEEEEEE
You say that Quasimodo and Esmeralda “ninja turtle” their way across the rooftops at the end. I’d much prefer to say that they ran across the rooftops a la Lupin the 3rd in “The Castle of Cagliostro”.
Wait so Esmeralda is accused of the murder of the captain that is still alive and at the trial? I mean, he's still alive. Right there. Watching. He's not murdered Majin Judge.
That does ring a bell but i'm not too familiar with the structure of Orthodox Christianity to be honest. Tsar seems more familiar a russian title and was sort of a link back to Phelous's " Tsar of reviews" joke, but I think you may be right about the Patriarch being the most senior religious figure in Russia.
The Hunchback of Notre Dame Hall of Fame Disney: Best Hunchback film (it's my favorite Disney movie, so of course it's the best) The Secret of the Hunchback: Ripped off many elements from the Disney version (ex. singing gargoyles and Frollo singing in front of a fireplace) Golden Films: Most ridiculous story-wise Goodtimes: Most accurate to the original novel...surprisingly Dingo: Visually the worst...just...ew
When the intro kicked in I got a massive wave of nostalgia as I remembered watching this...then terror when I remembered what it was actually like. I was going to pull a "TO BE FAIR" on myself and say that they managed to get the most from the book into this version but then it cancels itself out by having that stupid ending. I get people wishing that had happened in the Disney version, because Quasimodo was actually sweet and had chemistry with Esmerelda, but in this? I was hoping they'd pull a "Secret of the Hunchback" ending and have him fly into the sun, never to return.
"His heart was as thick as the sky"? So... his heart was so thin, anything could pass through it like it didn't exist? If anything, I do like the art in the film... not the animation, but the art doesn't look too (remembers Pierre's escaping eye)... it was okay. Very okay art.
Eh, the backgrounds aren't too terrible. Kinda bland an' empty, seems like. More or less meant the characters, but eh. It's a Good Times flick, so I'm prolly giving them too much credit regardless. I mean, it's sure as Hell no Disney picture! Better than Dingo, though.
I've started reading the actual novel recently, and, after reading some of it, the Goodtimes version actually seems to be the most accurate adaption. Granted, it's still full of shit like the others, but this one seems to have the most similar plot points and characters. Take that as you will.
0:50 From the makers of "The World of Richard Simmons" and "Candy Kisses Natural Lipbalm," comes the literary classics you know and... know, brought to stunning animated Technicolor life!
5:22 Are we just going to ignore the blatant up-skirt shot? I know Disney had their Esmeralda a bit overly sexualized but at least they didn't take it to that level, instead they hid subliminal messages in Frollo's fireplace like NORMAL perverted animators XD
I like the art style of this movie... it has a kind of "cheap old anime" aesthetic. Kinda like... Sailor Moon '92 but with less effort? It looks kinda like they made a flip book animation out of a Manga
Frollo is a kind man who raises Quasimodo as his own son after losing his family.
*Frollo is an attempted murderer and rapist who beats on Quasimodo for going outdoors!*
Quasimodo attacks Esmeralda with Frollo, and tries to drag her away.
*Esmeralda gives water to Quasimodo because she feels sorry for him!*
Esmeralda confesses to killing Phoebus.
*Esmeralda claims she's innocent, and Phoebus isn't even dead!*
Phoebus tells Esmeralda he loves her, but is then stabbed by Frollo, leaving Esmeralda heartbroken and telling Frollo to kill her too.
*Esmeralda realises she loves Quasimodo!*
CONSISTENCY?! WHAT IS CONSISTENCY?!?!
It's consistently inconsistent!
VauschthePuca or is it's inconsistency consistent 😉😂
Why no Frollo boss fight with a Hellfire remix?
You are searching for consistency in a Goodtimes-movie?
You is the pope of fools!
A lot of those things also appear in the book, but the book has so much more room to explain the motivations of the characters. And in the book, we are meant to pity Quasimodo but that doesn't mean everything he does is good. He was abused and brainwashed his whole life in the book. No wonde he didn't turn out as the best person. Esmeralda did indeed feel pity for Quasimodo, but she still was afraid of him as well. Of course, she never fell in love with Quasi and she dies in the end, just like every other character except for Phoebus and Pierre. In the book, Esmeralda did confess to attacking Phoebus but only after being tortured. She said it so the torture would stop.
I think frollo got his raspy voice and grumpy personality from inhaling fumes from all the baby fires
Or from the fire of Notre dame
He belongs in a great big FAYAAAA!
AUGHAUGHAUGHAUGHAUGHAUGH
@@MinscFromBaldursGate92 YAH!!
Twin Victim Nuns: *scream*
"Quasimodo, his heart was as big as the sky" *cracks his fist over Pierre's face into a rock*
😂😂😂😂
Well it is Pierre so he was doing us a favor
He was trying to put out our misery
7:56 i can watch this all day
Ummmm.... they meant it literally! Yeah, that's it.
I feel really bad for Beauty and the Beast and Hunchback of Notre Dame. Disney makes one movie each for those, and there's like 50 fucking thousand knock offs and cash ins.
Rachel Reviews which one was dingo because I couldn't make it halfway through the review without throwing up at the animation.
The source material is Public Domain, that's probably why.
Isn't it stupid that they have a "Gaston" in these hunchback rip offs and not in the beauty and the beast ripoff
Well depending on how you look at it you could say the Disney film is a rip off of the book
At the time, the Disney's ones are the only animated ones that are good.
Pierre: "I joined the Gypsies and got married to Esmeralda."
Frollo: "You is the husband of Esmeralda!?"
The first adaptation that has both Phoebus and Pierre, and yet, Esmeralda manages to end up with Quasimodo. Weeeell, come to think of it, she kinda did in the book. But being dead and lying next to him, until their bones turned to dust...
Yeah, it was a bit of a one-sided relationship, wasn't it? 🤭😄
Oh wow😅
"Leave him he's no great loss!" That was an absolutely horrible thing for Pierre to say and I'm horrible for laughing at that 🤣🤣
BilboKoira I have the book coincidentally and haven’t gotten to that part yet. So I guess I was wrong in thinking that there were at least two people who cared about Esmeralda.
In the novel Pierre was more attracted to the goat than Esmeralda.
You can tell that Victor Hugo's works are suscetible to Darkness Induced Audience Apathy.
We will avenge you my friend
@@unamed2516 it IS hilarious though, the music doesn’t help 😂
if the hunchback doesn't have secretly have wings by the end of this I'm going to be disappointed.
PhantomDragon3 sadly, science has not made great progress, so Quasimodo is not yet able to fly (SCIEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNCCCCCEEEEEEE!!!!!)
But... the future refused to change.
Spoilers: Prepare to be dissapointed.
I love how Esmeralda's eyes are blue. You know why her name is Esmeralda?
BECAUSE OF HER GREEN GODDAMN EYES YOU FUCKLE STICKS
THIS COMMENT IS SO AGGRESSIVE I LOVE IT
Akshually is because of an emerald necklace she wears. The green eyes thing comes from the disney version
XD
@@IosonoRob WAAA WAAAAAAAAA!
Since this movie's Esmeralda has neither a necklace nor green eyes it was a failure no matter which version you take into account
I love it when theme songs are clearly made with like, zero knowledge of the actual film and probably on a tight deadline.
MrBrassBalls I can't help but find it kinda catchy
I want to hear the extended version where they just spout out the entire story.
The two earlier songs are kinda good, but the third mone, which already is too bland and a copycat, outright contradicts the point of the story. The song is about how his infatuation has freed him, but in the original story, such "love" puts you in danger or makes you evil (funny that an adulterer did that point, but that's another case).
''His heart's as big as the sky!''🎵
Quasimodo proceeds to deck Phoebus in the face.
I love how these Jetlag cartoons always gotta have an opening song where the lyrics are pretty much a summary of the whole film
Title card and I'm already screaming "WHAT THE HELL IS WITH ALL THESE GOODTIMES SONGS EXPLAINING THE DAMN STORY?!?!?!
"We will sing you the whole damn story, no need to watch this piece of SHIIIIIIIIT!"
"In wonderlaaaaand"
"Old Maaan in Wonderlaaaand, anythiiing goeees in Wonderlaaaand".
"In spite of how he looked, the lady chose to stay..."
thank goodness they never got to make an animated Harry Potter....
"his parents were killed by the evil wizaaaard, he was always a wizard himself, but lived with cruel relatiiiiiives, he went to a school of magic with his new friends, but the dark wizard comes back to seek his reveeeeenge"
Aside from the ending and cutting out the reason why Esmeralda had confessed to killing Phoebus because she was tortured until she confessed, this was surprisingly accurate to the novel. Though I will say that this ending where Esmeralda fell in love with Quasimodo while not as good as the ending of the Disney version where the city accepted him and praised him as a hero, it was not as insulting as him either secretly being an angel, being handsome all along, or Esmeralda leaving him to rot forever in prison while she just walked away with Pierre. Also I can assure you that this opening song is never going to topple The Bells of Notre Dame as the best opening song for this story.
Goodtimes!Frollo: (trying to stab Esmeralda) Be mine!
Me: OR YOU WILL BUUUUUUUUUUUURN!!!!!!!
Weirdly enough, I think these versions of Frollo and Phoebus are among the most accurate in any adaptation. I can only ask why so many adaptations won't accept the love between Pierre and Djali. In the book, those two were the _only_ ones who ended up happy.
🎵 God have mercy on her. God have mercy on me. But she will be mine or sheeee wiiiiilllll BUUUUUUUUUUUURN!🎵
To be completely fair, add some actual character development, and this would actually be a somewhat decent adaptation....although the logic of being stabbed in the back and only needing a sling for your arm would still be highly questionable.
Really, even Quasimodo's likability could have been salvaged if he had questioned Frollo or expressed unwillingness or reluctance to capture Esmerelda, if not outright trying to stand up to Frollo, and have Arch Judge-Deacon Frollo hit him and/or threaten him. Then they would have established the abusive relationship between the two, and that Quasimodo at least has the potential to be a better person than his father.
Yeah got to agree
@@DalekTheSupreme i mean, none of that happened in the book tho. he was never supposed to be a sweet likable angel in the first place. he never question whether or not kidnapping someone is bad, he just simply did it because someone he loved asked him to do
@@andreamess5345 Right, the original character is, like you've said, basically a puppydog who will go along with anything as long as someone he loves tells him to do it., and he took psychotic glee in causing others harm, like smashing in a guard's face or pouring molten lead on the angry mob. There's a reason Quasimodo was considered part of the Universal Monsters for the longest time. To be honest, while this is going to sound like absolute sacrilege to Hugo purists, I prefer Disney's take on the character to the original novel - the original character just kinda feels like a cruel stereotype despite actually being the most heroic character in the book.
Well it's obvious why Judge Majin Buu put Quasimodo in the stocks. He may have been a terrible judge, but he was a brilliant scientist.
Too bad it's Sunday, Quasimodo would have kept his position as Pope of Fools tomorrow (wait, a character actually says something similar when Q is in the stocks).
the judge is deaf as well but hides it. Quasimodo getting punished and getting punished extra was the result of several misunderstandings created by this fact. he got sentenced for disrespecting the court when his answers did not match the judge's questions at all. It is a great scene in the book and I don't know if it ever made it accuratly into a movie
Buu sentece you to become chocolate!
I think Esmeralda screaming "murder" in this movie is the kid's show equivalent of screaming "rape."... Weird.
The problem of being a hot chick in medieval france.
that line was in the book
Tiffany Stewart Ok, maybe it just came across as weird because it’s a Goodtimes movie,
@@avalasialove yes
Hopefully Old Man just foreshadowed a new creepy pasta reading from him soon.
Kyle Weaver Old Man reads Slenderman
5:41 aww man now that's what I call a... GOLDEN SHOWER😎
>video was released July 7th, 2017
>comment was made _2 weeks ago_
*_WHAT IS THIS MAGIC?!_*
Count Orlok Subscribe to his Patreon and you get to see his content earlier. I just like to support him since his videos brought me a lot of joy during my stressful college years.
Old Man reads... Beauty and the Beast
WHAT A TWIST
Scott McNeil as the Narrator,Scott McNeil as Frollo,Scott McNeil as multiple extras...he's too good for this crap...
Still better than Scott McNeil as Crazy Poacher in Ninja Turtles Next Mutation.
Wait, he was the Narrator?!
What? Scott McNeil the voice of Koga from InuyYasha was the narrator? WTF?!
@Mary Wallace
He also voiced SINDRYYY in Dawn of War.
@@MinscFromBaldursGate92 And Tahu in "Bionicle: Mask of Light".
These animated Hunchback of Notre Dame adaptations really missed an opportunity by not having a rejected Pierre run off with Esmeralda's goat, like in the original story.
Even Dingo almost got that right, except there Pierre leaves town with both the goat and Esmeralda.
For what it is, this has pretty good animation and is a decently accurate to the book adaptation - that doesn't make it a good movie, but it has a lot more going for it than the other ones Phelous reviewed. It failed as a movie by not establishing any reason to care for the characters if you're completely unfamiliar with the story and didn't seem to have very good storytelling, but I'm actually kind of impressed.
AbraCadaveric agreed but they could of used more bonding.
AbraCadaveric so yeah while this isn't the worst cash in by Goodtimes entertainment, it does leave you asking a few questions.
The problem is that they cared too much to be faithful to the book that they forgot to make us relate to the characters and make a story we can follow. The ending was rather forced and the last song opposes the message of the book.
Destroyer of Destruction damn.
What happened? I do thik the film was okay, but a definite proof that faithfulness to the source material is not intrinsically good.
wow. judging by the animation which is typical for Goodtimes entertainment and jetlag, I feel like I'm watching an anime version of hunchback of Notre Dame. and believe me if there was an anime version of the hunchback I'd be surprised.
There is a (surprisingly decent) anime Cinderella, so a Hunchback of Notre Dame wouldn't surprise me much
There's an anime of another Victor Hugo classic, Les Miserables, called Shoujo Cosette that's actually pretty dang good.
By the art style, I'm pretty sure the animation in this was outsourced to a Japanese animation studio, which was common in the 80s/90s
There is also a Anime version of the little mermaid but unlike other versions it actually uses the original fairy tale's sad ending
Brandon Lyon Phelous has to review that one
I like the edits with him falling off the building. Lmao
I guess Pierre just gripped Esmeralda's wrist with such force that he cut the flow of blood into her hand off, and that's why it turned all white...? Nah, not really, there's no way a wimp such as Pierre can muster so much strength.
Esmeralda must've got the same lip gloss Belldandy wore in the 1993 Ah My Goddess OVAs.
Oh you have GOT to be kidding me. Now I have that damned "have you ever" song stuck in my head. This is why you shouldn't fall asleep to this stuff.
Im cryin
_"Do you know of Quasimodo? His heart was as big as the sky! Got hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, and that soon caused him to die!"_
Quasimodo and the bell are my OTP. I'm going to write a Beauty and the Beast AU fanfic about them.
jesus...
Yes, I do need Jesus in my life...
Jessica Wood I'd read that. I have nothing else to do.
Who is the Beauty and who is the Beast? Gotta ask
15:34 Man, those 15th Century electric fluorescent street lamps were always my favorite part of this story, even more so than the blues-singing synthesizer-playing gargoyles.
Useless is completely Quasimodo now!
Boo!!!
Oh, shut up or I'll read you all a Creepypasta!
Completely now Quasimodo useless is!
BOOO
Quasimodo is entirely deprived of the necessaries qualities of being useful.
Good thing there weren't any gargoyles singing the blues this time around
That would have ruined an otherwise PERFECT adaptation!
Personally I feel this movie was in dire need of blues-singing gargoyles throwing fireworks around.
"Sacre Bleu this, BITCH!"
Stephen Brown "perfect"
I'm just waiting for Goldenfilm's Titanic
Didgeree Media Truth be told the only thing I respect I have for golden films they didn't sugarcoat real life tragedies...I don't think goldenfilms would want to do titanic
Didgeree Media The only possibly good thing about that would be the Nostalgia Critic review that would come after. That would be like what, four or five at the point
The sad thing is, this is the best written animated Hunchback IMO. Still sucks though
So... is the Dingo version still the most accurate?? Because that's a rather scary thing to consider...
Wow, the version with Colonel Sanders is the most accurate one.
Depressing...
Liezl Bohnen reminder that good adaptations strive to be better than what they're adapting which requires skill and creativity (Disney) while bad adaptations just copy what they're adapting because it's easier and they just want money (Dingo, Goodtimes ect)
Universe Artist "Be better than what they are adapting". Well, if that's the case they failed, because they were not even close to quality of original book. Albeit closer than Dingo or Good times.
A good adaptation can be very good and still be very true to the it's source material.
In fact when the adaptation becomes too different it can be seen as failing in being an adaptation
Servo Augusta I mean, when an adaptation becomes too similar that can also be a failing, really whether or not it's a good thing should more important than how close to the original the thing is or isn't
What a shame there's no Bevanfield version.
bevanfield?
Theyre a shitty little animation studio that made a version of beauty and the beast that was completely horrific. Phelous did a video on it.
The hunchback of notre dame story is better off without bevanfield.
so that's what's been missing from my life. no lie, i would watch the shit out of that just for the impending awfulness.
@@joereddam2729 You know that ugly guy whose neck Old Man likes to break? He's from that company's version of Beauty and the Beast.
Why does Frollo suddenly turn evil? In the beginning he seemed like a kind man who took Quasimodo to be his son, but then hes evil all of a sudden
His downward spiral was better established in the book
He gradually lost each of his morals and became consumed by his lust for Esmeralda
The moral dilemma he experienced was also explored a bit more if I recall correctly
It’s been a while since I read the book but I know it was a hell of a lot better than this dumpster fire of a film
llllllust and wrong decisions
Praise Sigmar!
Poor application of narrative causality. He's bad because the story demands it.
In the original book, the Judge like Quasimodo was deaf & he assumed that Quasimodo was mocking him, failing to realize he was deaf!
Anybody notice that Phelous promises us no times of joy...yet all his videos of these are just joys to watch??
Have you EVER...
...
...
...
...
...EVER FELT LIKE THIS
Rainy Meadows When strange things happen... are we going around the twist.
So if Phoebus is still alive, why did Esmerelda confess to killing him?
Ridgwaycer Continuity; it's not just for the coherent anymore! XD
Ridgwaycer and you can’t blame this version of the story either because that was exactly how it was in the novel. But then again in the novel they tortured her until she confessed to murdering Phoebus. Also Phoebus decided to not come forward and say that he was really alive until she was being led to her execution just because he is that much of a douche waffle and the court didn’t care anyways because they also believed her guilty of being a with.
*"Great Continuity"*
@@morganyoung3557 wow😶
its in the book?
Pierre: But what of me?! *I* would be the one to be hanged!
Ursula: That's riiight! Life's full of tough choices, inn't it?
Also, I've realized this is the *second* shitty adaptation that has Esmeralda getting together with Quasimodo in the end. But you've got to give this one credit for not doing the "handsome all along" fakeout.
So so far it's Phoebus 2, Pierre 1, Quasimodo 2
@jbiehlable According to fanfiction, Frollo has the majority. Because fanfiction is horrifying
The poor unfortunate soul
Pierre can't catch a break
Majin Judge didn't sentance Esmeralda because he suddenly went to sleep for a month, so he was replaced by Golden Judge.
PikaTheProsperous I still think they would have been better off with asking Perfect Judge to help...that perfect Jawline...
TheNMan64
At least everyone got to see Judge 17 again.
RassilonTDavros too bad we got judge-Ren the gray, he should've had a personality similar to Son judge-ku
@TheNMan64
Japan does not like judge Tien.
It's just like the disney version, just with a greater level of book accuracy! All it's missing is character development/compelling characters, consistency, beautiful animation, gripping music, well-done voice acting, and well tuned atmosphere. On the bright side, though, they did get rid of those gargoyles... only to replace their role as comedic relief with Pierre. I'm suddenly missing the gargoyles more than I ever thought I would.
Wouldn't say consistency is that much of a problem. Also wasn't pier always a coward.
and Jason Alexander
I love the gargoyles.
Except for Esmeralda surviving her mother not being there and Quasimodo not getting whipped this is one of if not the most accurate adaptation of The Hunchback of Notre Dame a lot of the quotes are directly from the book including Esmeralda shouting murder when Pierre gets knocked down
The 1982 live-action British version follows it almost similarly, but retaining everything from the book and following it pretty much to the letter for the most part with the main exception of the 1938 film ending where after being discovered and the gypsies come to the rescue as they battle the guard, Esmeralda escapes with Pierre (who she falls in love with in this as a shoehorned plot aside from the main one once rejected by Captain Phoebus) while Quasimodo creates a distraction and is chased to the rooftops before pulling Frollo (an archdeacon as in this and the novel) from the roof, then holding on to one of the gargoyles for a moment as he realizes he's screwed if he lets them save him, thus he lets go. They keep much of the dialogue, much of the themes, and is perhaps the one other accurate version besides this one. I personally consider it my go-to film adaptation due to the few changes not being all that bad and an homage to the few decent things from the classic black-and-white version that was almost in-name-only, i.e., the ending while having properly adjusted the love story (not compositing the two guys into an honorable swashbuckler and changing the genre as was the fault of the original while keeping the added romantic element that makes for good Hollywood). You should Google it.
Robert Corbell most accurate animated adaptions then
For all the downsides, this is probably the best animated adaptation while the 82' is the best live-action.
Robert Corbell agreed
Robert Corbell well most accurate
4:35- Sorry, Quasimoto, but we're giving the role of Spider-Man to Tom Holland instead.
5:18- HEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
7:28- Or maybe what happened to Palpatine in Revenge of the Sith also happened to Frollo.
14:18- Stupid goat. He spelled "Phelous" wrong.
Top notch on the Simpsons jokes.
dude your comedy is on point! I'm trying to quietly watch this while my fiance is asleep but I cant stop laughing!! fuck your funny!!! 😂
5:18 HIDDEN OLD MAN! (Edit: I'm glad to see him in full again, and I hope he does read another Creepypasta)
I woke up to this review, means I'm gonna have good times today. Amazing.
Watching this I realized that the VA for Frollo has to be Scott McNeil, I recognize that angry raspy voice acting anywhere! There totally could have been more DBZ references in this review.
Oni Queen or Gundam Wing!
Oni Queen (Imitates Waspinator) Frollo-nator will destroy Melody-Bots!
Or Ruby-Spears Mega Man. That's clearly his Dr. Wily voice.
(warning! Levels of lust dangerously high)
SNOOOORT
OVERRIDE!
Too bad it's Quasimodo Sunday, this review would have been full of DBZ references tomorrow.
the old man meme show was filmed in front of a live paris audience.
I had a truly fuck-awful day. Thankfully this review was up when I got home from work! It really cheered me up, especially the best Old Man cameo yet!
My God!! I was watching Phelous reruns all morning and this video just popped up. You're my hero, Phelous - HHHHEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!
Are there more The Hunchback of Notre Dame cartoons? We need more gags about Quasimodo falling to his death.
You have 67k subscribers
And you deserve every single one of them
Tristan Goldsmith He deserves more.
The Reaper Of Crows true af
Tristan Goldsmith like a 100k
Hi-ho, I come from the future. He has 108k now.
Was watching a Little House on the Prairie DVD. Good times distributed them apparently. I snickered like an idiot. I want to see Old Man on the Prairie.
What is your name sir?
Captain Phebis the Shadow Perv, at your service!
The captain was right there to save Esmeralda only because he was stalking her!!
Is it wrong that I kind of found Esmeralda hot here, I'm mean she is definitely not Disney version hot, but she isn't bad of a looker here either compare to all the other women in these movies.
She definitely beats out her doofy Esmeralda counterparts: Pink-eyes, Pierre in drag, and Talking Musical Instrument Girl.
Ziltoid the Omniscient i thought pink eyes Esmeralda is beautiful she is beautiful at least unlike stupid ugly ass esemermelody with her annoying talking musical instruments
Bleah!
Gaz membrane Very true, i'd put her in a close second.
@@SchlubbyTomHanks ) Wich version has "pink eyes"?
UHV or Burbank?
@@steamboatwill3.367 The secret of the hunchback was the one with ol pink eyes
What is the sentence, your honor?
''Buu make Quasimodo dead!''
Why is Esmeralda, a french woman abducted by the gypsies as a child, the only dark skinned person in the whole gypsy tabor? Is she a Romani gypsy abducted by a bunch of french posers in this version?
And damn, just because Disney decided to adapt a dark, Gothic story that's utterly unsuitable for children into a family film, it doesn't mean YOU have to, every mockbuster animation studio ever sans Video Brinquedo.
And it was even questionable when Disney did it.
@@fightingmedialounge519 Well, yes, of course. The difference is that Disney somehow succeeded in doing so. But these knock-off artists, don't seem to realize that Disney succeeded despite their choices of stories for adaptation, not because of them.
@@ser6Ijvolk fair point.
The Disney one is based off the stage musical. And actually even Victor Hugo himself rewrote his story later to have a happier ending because the original is so depressing.
You realise that ANIMATION is not solely for children right? Or are you a idiot
For those who can’t READ: I’m on about animation in general not Goodtimes but I thought that was obvious 🤦♀️
So I guess Kagome just got tired of the feudal era. At least she tried to blend in this time.
Jessi TheGhost are you assuming that Esmeralda is...
Yes scotty. Underage.
Phelous' Hunchback reviews goes quadrilogy
Mixey Boy MAH GOLLY GEEEEEEEEEEEEE WILIKERS! IT'S A COMPLETELY USELESS MIRACLE!
Phelous is going PULSE!
Seeing Kathleen Barr was in this annoys me just as much as seeing Christopher Lee in the Beauty and the beast one.
The Great and Powerful Trixie was in some movies she's not proud of, it seems
the new adventures of he man was made by jetlag and she was there too, maybe she was one of their in house voice actors like Gary Chalk
Well, unlike Christopher Lee in Bevanfield, Kathleen Barr was a regular in GoodTimes productions.
Saruman 1 - 0 Trixie
Spike's VA was in Robin and the Dreamweavers, speaking of My Little Pony VAs in shitty animated features.
She’s probably not too proud of being in MLP anymore given how garbage it is
@@The3y3 Didn't she also play Evil Lynn and Queen Marlena in the 2002 He Man show? Scott Mcneil was in it too he played Ram Man Merman and Stratos
This adaptation just might be the most faithful adaptation of The Hunchback of Notre Dame as well as the closest we will get to an anime adaptation of The Hunchback of Notre Dame.
I actually couldn't stop laughing for 5 minutes when Quasi asked "Can I come too?" and then got kicked off by Phoebus. I don't know why I thought that was so frigging funny. XD
I'm surprised that this other than the Disney version is the closest to an complete version of the story. Better than the main character being handsome and having wings.
a new phelous review that's always a good time
Rory Lumley No Dingos required!
Watch out though, you might get Jet Lag.
Golden Films related pun!
for you
Burbank related pun.
(1:48) That arm scar speaks volumes considering the movie you're watching...
Notre Dame is a church in Paris, not a town....
Paris is a town.
Paris is a planet
@@dilflover07 Paris is a state of mind, man
@@damienthonk1506 in Texas
@@damienthonk1506 it’s a city, mate. The Capital of France
They did MORE Notre Dame? I'd drink right now to get this out of my head, but I gotta work in a little bit. It's gonna be a long day.
Hey, I found out there's an animated tv series based off The Hunchback Of Notre Dame. I discovered it on accident on Tvtropes, it's apparently called The Magical Adventures Of Quasimodo. Looks pretty dumb all things considered, so you consider checking it out and reviewing it... and no, I'm not making it up, it actually does exist (don't know if it'd be easy to find or not)
I remember watching it in Belgrade when I was little.
DeepEye1994 Brate Srbine ? :D
Celeste Irizarry There is that series on CZcams in Serbian,just search Magicne avanture Kvazimoda,I also think it is awfull.
Omg, I remember watching that series as a kid.
Warning: No actual good times were present in the making of this feature.
This has been a Phelous review. He has the Good Times so YOU don't have to!
what about when Pierre got sucker punched?
The goat is the best character. Regardless of the adaptation, that goat is always my favorite.
Is anyone going to mention the Esmeralda panty shot during her dance...?
Perfect entertainment for them kiddies! X_x
Zucca Xerfantes I don't think they mind.
I find that very entertaining.
Yum yum.
For what most people consider one of Disneys lesser films, it sure did get a hell of a lot of rip offs.
Interesting also that the little mermaid despite it being the movie that started renaissance and one of the most popular princesses only had one as I'm aware of.
Brandon Lyon No, it had two sequels. Maybe even a TV show.
But those came from Disney themselves, I'm talking about other companies taking the fairly tale and make their own to cash in on the Disney movie. So far all their was is the one good times movie and that's it not even a Dingo version of the little mermaid exists.
I loved the Disney hunchback of Notre Dame.
Hunchback's my favorite Disney movie
I like Esmeralda's design here.
11:26 "Everyone is miserable and then they die," aka every Victor Hugo novel ever.
1:40 Remeber when Alan Menken called “The Bells of Notre Dame” the single best opening he’s done for any movie or musical?...
I had a mini Phelous marathon last night, it went on from 1am until about 7am this morning. Keep up the great work!
wow
I was wrong
this is the version I saw as a kid
thanks mom and dad
“YOU IDIOT”-Frollo
As someone who has read the novel, I can safely this is the most faithful cartoon adaptation of Notredame da Paris. Wait, what? Why?????
Your channel is full of amazing content, but nothing ever beats these reviews. They never fail to make me laugh; keep up the great work. YEEE HEEEEEEEEE
ITS ALWAYS GOODTIMES WHEN PHELOUS UPLOADS A NEW ANIMATED MOVIE REVIEW
Wow...Just how much of a deformed bell ringer can we take?
As much as Phelous says we can.
You say that Quasimodo and Esmeralda “ninja turtle” their way across the rooftops at the end. I’d much prefer to say that they ran across the rooftops a la Lupin the 3rd in “The Castle of Cagliostro”.
In the novel, Quasimodo did help Frollo in his kidnapping of Esmeralda.
21:17
That's actually him shaking his fist in anger gesture like he's saying "you'll pay for that!!"
LOL
Is it just me, or did this seem oddly... anime-ish to anyone else?
From what I heard apparently Jetlag is an American-Japanese studio?
Yes. Like Saban's Adventures of the Little Mermaid....kinda a hybrid.
ShyTenda Phew, my opinion isn't unpopular.
Yes, and it makes me uncomfortable.
You're not the only one.
Wait so Esmeralda is accused of the murder of the captain that is still alive and at the trial? I mean, he's still alive. Right there. Watching. He's not murdered Majin Judge.
I'm guessing Scott McNeil needed some serious money if he's doing voicework for Goodtimes of all people.
Falcovsleon21 I am shocked he didn't phone it in.
It was Canada in the 90's
Useless is Quasimodo now! HE IS POPE OF FOOLS!!!
Watermelon Dreams Yoda talk like I do, exaggerated this is.
So if he was in Russia, would that make him the patriarch of fools?
Brandon Lyon Tsar of Fools.
But isn't the patriarch the highest raking official of Orthodox Christianity just as the pope is to Catholics.
That does ring a bell but i'm not too familiar with the structure of Orthodox Christianity to be honest. Tsar seems more familiar a russian title and was sort of a link back to Phelous's " Tsar of reviews" joke, but I think you may be right about the Patriarch being the most senior religious figure in Russia.
I like to think Frollo fell in love with Pierre, not Esmeralda, after seeing him balance a cat on a chair on his nose
The Hunchback of Notre Dame Hall of Fame
Disney: Best Hunchback film (it's my favorite Disney movie, so of course it's the best)
The Secret of the Hunchback: Ripped off many elements from the Disney version (ex. singing gargoyles and Frollo singing in front of a fireplace)
Golden Films: Most ridiculous story-wise
Goodtimes: Most accurate to the original novel...surprisingly
Dingo: Visually the worst...just...ew
Golden Films: THE HANDSOM OF NOTRE DAME!
When the intro kicked in I got a massive wave of nostalgia as I remembered watching this...then terror when I remembered what it was actually like.
I was going to pull a "TO BE FAIR" on myself and say that they managed to get the most from the book into this version but then it cancels itself out by having that stupid ending. I get people wishing that had happened in the Disney version, because Quasimodo was actually sweet and had chemistry with Esmerelda, but in this? I was hoping they'd pull a "Secret of the Hunchback" ending and have him fly into the sun, never to return.
So now that we have seen all these versions of Hunchback, are we finally in agreement that Disney did Hunchback BETTER?
Mmmmm............not exactly.
Yes
"His heart was as thick as the sky"? So... his heart was so thin, anything could pass through it like it didn't exist?
If anything, I do like the art in the film... not the animation, but the art doesn't look too (remembers Pierre's escaping eye)... it was okay. Very okay art.
Eddie Price you mean background Art?
Eh, the backgrounds aren't too terrible. Kinda bland an' empty, seems like. More or less meant the characters, but eh. It's a Good Times flick, so I'm prolly giving them too much credit regardless. I mean, it's sure as Hell no Disney picture!
Better than Dingo, though.
I think they said "as BIG as the sky" tbh.
@@NodDisciple1 they did
I've started reading the actual novel recently, and, after reading some of it, the Goodtimes version actually seems to be the most accurate adaption. Granted, it's still full of shit like the others, but this one seems to have the most similar plot points and characters. Take that as you will.
CoolNyanCat I love your icon. Creepy willy wonka Tom and Jerry pic is perfect.
did Phoebus do the jacking motion there too
"Probably a weird thing to just tell ya, but I'm really simple, byyyyeeee!" Oh my god best line ever!
0:50 From the makers of "The World of Richard Simmons" and "Candy Kisses Natural Lipbalm," comes the literary classics you know and... know, brought to stunning animated Technicolor life!
5:22 Are we just going to ignore the blatant up-skirt shot? I know Disney had their Esmeralda a bit overly sexualized but at least they didn't take it to that level, instead they hid subliminal messages in Frollo's fireplace like NORMAL perverted animators XD
Me likey.
It's not an anime version without panty shots 😍
this honestly seems like one of the better animated good times movies
Apparently the legendary animator Shingo Araki worked on these Jetlag films.
He worked on various famous anime shows and films before that. He did gain a paycheque for the films that aren’t quite mockbusters though.
This is honestly the best of these bad hunchback movies.
I like the art style of this movie... it has a kind of "cheap old anime" aesthetic. Kinda like... Sailor Moon '92 but with less effort? It looks kinda like they made a flip book animation out of a Manga