As long as we remain attache to the bodily concept of life, that means, identifaing the self with the body (I'm the body and its subsequents designation: l'm white, I'm man, women, jew, muslim, mexican etc.) As the orthodoxy leas us to think, the same Rab Tobias Singer poined out calling it ethnic religion, perhaps unaware of how pernicious this means, the question of: "Where was God in Auschwitz"?, will remain always a mystery! Perhaps, among others, one of the great contributions of the Hebrew State, was to reverse this curse...
The adversary showed his full hand at Auschwitz and places like it. He intended it to be utterly devastating for faith in G_d of any kind. The desolation in T.S.Eliots 'Waste Land' had its evil flowering there. Like Primo Levi, we are all forced to ask how can there be poetry, or music, after such a place ? The resilience of life as celebrated by Rabbi Sacks is part of the answer. Those who risked lives, and paid the price, to try to save others, are part of the answer. The countless little acts of humanity known only to G_d in such terrible circumstances, are part of the answer, and those who chose not to abandon innocents in their care, sent there, by going themselves, are part of the answer. The sovereignty of the inner Frankl in the face of the unspeakable, is part of the answer. The Almighty suffered there, in the person of everyone who did.
God created Adam and made him live in Paradise and gave him commandments. Adam was the one who sinned, then he gave his commandments to humans and they are responsible for their actions, as in the law, he holds accountable those who are 18 years old. And God helps those who follow His commandments
No, the real question is where was God during Auschwitz ? A survivor of this concentration, camp sums it up in a few statements. "The most important lesson one can learn from Auschwitz is that God does not exist." " By far the simplest explanation for Auschwitz is that there is no God to intervene in human affairs. No deity exists to care what we do to each other. All compassion and all hatred in the human universe is ours. We are on our own." I couldn't agree more with this survivor !
I'm so sorry Rabbi but I can't accept this reasoning. God watched his chosen people in inexplicable pain, agony and injystice and did nothing because we ( essentially your argument) have free will? God is guilty. And I have heard nothing from anyone to change that fact
I've struggled with this question my whole life. My grandparents were holocaust survivors and immigrated to Israel and talked very little about the horrors they've witnessed. My answer came to me after the attack of the 7th of October, when they found the charred remains, that was later forensic identified as a father bond by electric wire to his small child. There is no God, and if there is one - he's a sadist.
Wich, bay the way, greatly benefit the palestinians since constraind totaly by the python of Islam, given that they carry the same ethno-religious bias; howeber,with the disatvantage of being devoid of the influence of the European Enlightenment which advice to "open oneself to the ideas of the world" (like tha Vedas from India, and its profund wisdom)...
Islam is not a race. Enter Islam and you will be one of them. Islam preserves the rights of non-Muslims. To know Islam, read the Qur’an. Do not look at the wrong actions of Muslims.
@@El-Sahm Yes!, lslam in not a race, but because they remain stagnants in the corporal concept of existance they cannot only not achieve any kind of Brothrhood of Men, but they will fall, been on the material platform, to view, without understanding that this is only a circumstantial situation: friends and foes. Because, been stagnant in this conception (bodily conception), means, self center individual only interestead in their so call "love ones", which are their expansions (blood conections). In fact, in the name of all kind of religion technicalities, they will isolated God from the rest, justifing,like this, there envy, jealousy and malice. In the name of that conection, they wiil force themself, undere the pretex of "the are infidels", to dominate the so call enemy... always resentfull of the otherhood, which they consider non believer...
I so miss Rabbi Sacks and his wisdom. Thank you for making these videos and keeping his memory alive.
How moving, how inspiring, how wise AND needed for these days of distress....
It's so true, where were we.. Today again 7October I pray and read Tehillim for Israel ❤❤❤
I miss Rabbi Sacks -- what a profound lesson!
God bless Rabbi Sacks
This is a very powerful answer.
Amen and beautifully said! May we celebrate only joy with Moshiach
Beautiful Thank you 🙏🙏💜💜✡️🇬🇧🇮🇱
B''H Amen
❤❤❤❤❤
Let his blood be upon our heads and on our childrens heads😢😢New Testament🙏🙏
Glory to God in the Highest!
This was beautiful - thank you for sharing it.
♥
As long as we remain attache to the bodily concept of life, that means, identifaing the self with the body (I'm the body and its subsequents designation: l'm white, I'm man, women, jew, muslim, mexican etc.) As the orthodoxy leas us to think, the same Rab Tobias Singer poined out calling it ethnic religion, perhaps unaware of how pernicious this means, the question of: "Where was God in Auschwitz"?, will remain always a mystery! Perhaps, among others, one of the great contributions of the Hebrew State, was to reverse this curse...
My only question for God is "how could You take Rabbi Sacks from us, when we need him so badly?"
You just missed the point of the whole video.
@@user-qz6ml3hb9u ---- whAt is the point of the video? Please explain! 😦😦😦🦋
He’s probably needed in heaven to speak on behalf of the people of Israel and the world 🙏🏻
What a beautiful video.
Long live the State of Israel 🇮🇱 and the Jewish people 🇮🇱!!!
Yet the question remains to be fully answered!!?
What is required to provide an answer that you would consider complete?
@@halswitkay6643 WHERE WAS HE FROM THE BEGINING OF TIME? WHAT IS HIS FULL PLAN? MOST IMPORTNANTLY WHY ?
@@dima-rafael HaShem created time. His full plan, crafted in His infinite mind, cannot be understood by mortal humans with finite minds.
What empirical evidence you have to support your claims?
@@dima-rafael What empirical evidence do you have to refute my claims?
Ole !
AMEN! 🌈🎆⚘
The adversary showed his full hand at Auschwitz and places like it. He intended it to be utterly devastating for faith in G_d of any kind. The desolation in T.S.Eliots 'Waste Land' had its evil flowering there.
Like Primo Levi, we are all forced to ask how can there be poetry, or music, after such a place ?
The resilience of life as celebrated by Rabbi Sacks is part of the answer. Those who risked lives, and paid the price, to try to save others, are part of the answer. The countless little acts of humanity known only to G_d in such terrible circumstances, are part of the answer, and those who chose not to abandon innocents in their care, sent there, by going themselves, are part of the answer. The sovereignty of the inner Frankl in the face of the unspeakable, is part of the answer.
The Almighty suffered there, in the person of everyone who did.
HaShem Bless may Israel
🤍🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🤍
God created Adam and made him live in Paradise and gave him commandments. Adam was the one who sinned, then he gave his commandments to humans and they are responsible for their actions, as in the law, he holds accountable those who are 18 years old. And God helps those who follow His commandments
No, the real question is where was God during Auschwitz ?
A survivor of this concentration, camp sums it up in a few statements.
"The most important lesson one can learn from Auschwitz is that God does not exist."
" By far the simplest explanation for Auschwitz is that there is no God to intervene in human affairs. No deity exists to care what we do to each other. All compassion and all hatred in the human universe is ours. We are on our own."
I couldn't agree more with this survivor !
I'm so sorry Rabbi but I can't accept this reasoning. God watched his chosen people in inexplicable pain, agony and injystice and did nothing because we ( essentially your argument) have free will? God is guilty. And I have heard nothing from anyone to change that fact
I've struggled with this question my whole life. My grandparents were holocaust survivors and immigrated to Israel and talked very little about the horrors they've witnessed.
My answer came to me after the attack of the 7th of October, when they found the charred remains, that was later forensic identified as a father bond by electric wire to his small child.
There is no God, and if there is one - he's a sadist.
😢
God didn't do it! Those who did it are sadists & need to repent!
Wich, bay the way, greatly benefit the palestinians since constraind totaly by the python of Islam, given that they carry the same ethno-religious bias; howeber,with the disatvantage of being devoid of the influence of the European Enlightenment which advice to "open oneself to the ideas of the world" (like tha Vedas from India, and its profund wisdom)...
Islam is not a race. Enter Islam and you will be one of them. Islam preserves the rights of non-Muslims. To know Islam, read the Qur’an. Do not look at the wrong actions of Muslims.
@@El-Sahm Yes!, lslam in not a race, but because they remain stagnants in the corporal concept of existance they cannot only not achieve any kind of Brothrhood of Men, but they will fall, been on the material platform, to view, without understanding that this is only a circumstantial situation: friends and foes. Because, been stagnant in this conception (bodily conception), means, self center individual only interestead in their so call "love ones", which are their expansions (blood conections). In fact, in the name of all kind of religion technicalities, they will isolated God from the rest, justifing,like this, there envy, jealousy and malice. In the name of that conection, they wiil force themself, undere the pretex of "the are infidels", to dominate the so call enemy... always resentfull of the otherhood, which they consider non believer...
2:33 You committed a Holocaust against the Palestinians to steal their land
Exactly
Utter crap.
God was nailed to a cross 1941 years previously.
if your god is the type that can be nailed to a cross then it says something about what type of god he must be
@@DJminecraft958They’re always around
@@DJminecraft958 The type that wants all His children to reach salvation.
@@orrinkom3829 Indeed, we are. As is the Lord Jesus Christ.
@@DJminecraft958Yes indeed. That is the whole point.
“Sometimes God allows what he hates to accomplish what he loves.” Joni Eareckson Tada, The God I Love