The Secret of The Cabin Explained + Final Theory / RIP AOE / Attack On Titan
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 05. 2023
- in today’s video, we will explore the last key visual of attack on titan, and talk about the secret of the cabin with my final theory
Support me on ko-fi
ko-fi.com/mangahorse
Subscribe to my channel
czcams.com/users/MangaHorse?su...
Website (new):
mangahorse.com/
Blog (new):
mangahorse.com/blog-for-human...
Final season breakdown playlist 👇
• Attack on Titan Final ...
Manga chapter Review 👇
• Manga Chapters Review ...
My top videos playlist 👇
• Manga Horse Top Videos
Join my Discord Server
/ discord
Follow me on Facebook
/ manga.horse
Follow me on Twitter
/ manga_horse
Follow me on Instagram
/ the_manga_horse
Buy me Coffee
www.buymeacoffee.com/MangaHorse
Checkout My Pinterest (1M+ monthly views)
/ the_manga_horse
Everything in 1-Link
linktr.ee/Mangahorse
TOPICS:
Attack on titan
Shingeki no Kyojin
AOT
snk
Manga Horse
Anime
manga
theory
Discussion
review
aot cabin scene
aot cabin timeline
aot cabin eren
attack on titan final season
attack on titan final part
aot key
aot key visual
mikasa kills eren
mikasa ackerman
Mikasa
eren death
AOE
SoilerFree Playlist: (safe to watch, spoilers announced before)
• Foreshadowing & Armin'...
AoT Theories Playlist:
• The Organism Under The...
Support me on Patreon
/ mangahorse
Podcasts👇
Anchor
anchor.fm/manga-horse
Spotify open.spotify.com/show/5MvpqLw...
Google Podcast
www.google.com/podcasts?feed=... - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Just a minor mistake in the beginning that bird is actually captain Falcon.
I know many people say AOE is bullshit
But what i want is to end Aot with a good ending
Because then we can finally say Attack on Titan is masterpiece and no body can argue then
You are optimistic. People will always argue about the ending. Even if we will get some different ending that you like, you can’t expect everyone to love it too. Just like now! The ending is perfect for me…but still people fight about it. So yeah, there is no ending that will satisfy everyone, it’s not possible
Also, I made a video once explaining why the old theories (which are good) got mixed with stupid theories and all got the same name AOE
If you are interested to know the history of AOE czcams.com/video/UNnlZ3nH99g/video.html
its a master piece without aoe. theres nothing wrong with the ending people just need to cope and understand how the world is.
@@yujichan
>necrokiss
>no i don't want that
>ymir loved king fritz
>it was not her day to die that day
>thank you eren for killing so many people for OUR SAKE
>Eren, what a man you are...
@Mika Wow what a reasoning...
Average necrokiss enjoyer :
@@No-I-dont-want-that really you just going to by pass all the canabalism from start to finish in aot to focus on that? not the fact that ymirs kids ate her? lol you just dont like who eren loved, lets be real. The fact that people was ick over a kiss but fine with people eating each other blows my mind!
also eren crying before he dies to his best friend with just him is how it should be. He is alone with his best friend armin whom he can tell everything too and be himself. he is allowed to through a fit and armin is allowed to give eren a piece of mind before he goes to kill him.
as for ymir being inlove with the king is also right. She has had 3 kids by the man and also jumped infront of a spear to save him instead of chosing her kids which is actually happening in alot of families. people would rather stay in a realationship and get beat and let their kids suffer with them instead of leaving. you need to grow up and face the facts about alot of things.
An honor to follow your theories! Thanks for your hard work all these years! 心臓を捧げよ！
Thank you so much my friend for all your love and support, I absolutely appreciate it 🙏
And I’ll still be making videos as long as people are watching them😊
Cabin - The Bad Ending
Manga - The Good Ending
Anime - The True Ending (if AoE happens)
Fair or nah?
It’s just inaccurate. You are referring to the cabin and the end of the manga as if they are different. This is the ending of the story. I get that some people didn’t like it, but I think after 3 years you can just move on. There’s no reason to keep talking about something you didn’t like.
@@MangaHorse lmao bruh what? Do you even know what he means?
Yup, I do. Wouldn’t reply if I didn’t
@@MangaHorse this is based on the 3 timelines theory & AoT pretty much being Isayama’s love letter to Muv luv.
Even if AoE happens, I’ll still consider everything that happened in the cabin & manga timelines as canon. all timelines are canon.
Never said they won’t be canon. I just reject the notion of you using the term AOE to refer to the muv-luv theories that came MUCH MUCH before the term AOE was even suggested (I have an entire video explaining how all those theories got mistakenly mixed up under the same name)
The muv-luv references and all the old theories were GOLD…while the AOE movement which came out only years later is mainly driven from ships, and based on Akatsuki no Requiem and the theory about Historia ending up with Eren.
So like I said. I know what you are talking about. And obviously I also know what I’m talking about 😅
AOE isn’t dead yet you would be more surprised if it happens
Just by putting AOE in the thumbnail, anyone has the power to summon a very specific part of the fanbase.
I figured my videos aren’t getting any views anyways, so why not 😅 but yeah, I wasn’t lying, AOE is dead…it just died a while back 🥲
@@MangaHorse I'm glad it did.
RIP, see ya, wouldn't wanna be ya.
@@MangaHorse what about sim song official poster now some will say Mikasa is just resting there after a tough fight 😂
@@pratikanbhule2275in the same position where an aot character is when he/she dies
So in this vast and apparently endless multiverse of Attack on Titan, how many outcomes did you think happen? I mean, we've seen two already so far. Do you have any versions of endings to add?
By the way, I've come up with a plan called Heraclius Plan to combat both the Rumbling and the 50-Year Plan. If you would like to listen, please tell me. Because I would really like to see will this plan worked or not because in my view, it is the best way to save both Paradis and the rest of the world.
No way of telling. But seeing Mikasa OVA had yet another alternate reality, I would say they are probably more out there. I would say endless, but that’s just me
@@MangaHorse Well, I guess it's one of those mysteries that might never get solved. Also, do you think that Hange and Armin are too naive? The point here is that I just cannot believe that they wanted peace so bad despite seeing it themselves that Marley has no interest of negotiating and is nothing but a bully that needed to take down. Believe me, I tried to play by rules when I was a kid and it got me nowhere. So the fact that they cannot even see that despite what they went through made me upset.
Naive and hopeful are both very close to each other. I think they were being hopeful rather than full-on naive. Armin is established early on to be very smart and though unrealistically optimistic at times, he’s also proven that he will do what has to be done if he’s got no choice. For example, he’s had to kill ppl who were once his comrades and he has done it very swiftly when he’s had to (of course, he experiences the immediate remorse and guilt but ultimately understood he had to). MAYBE you have an argument for Hange being naive bc she doesn’t always seem to realize the danger of the environment (still not stupid either). In Armin’s case, unless we were viewing him differently, Armin would never co-sign a rumbling. He’d have to be seriously backed into a corner, but I think that a lot of ppl saw Eren’s actions as something purely of a martyr/savior, rather than the complex selfish/selfless nature it was. If we are being completely honest, Paradis was not in a situation that warranted a worldwide rumbling. A Marleyan rumbling? I’d agree. The whole world? They haven’t even seen most of the world yet to come to that decision.
I don't understand how you can accept different realities and not accept the possibility to have AOE showing exactly that... a different reality where Eren decides to keep fighting and refuse to stop the rumbling at 80%
Theoretically anything can happen, nothing is 100%…It’s just I personally don’t see AoE as probable at this point. If I’m wrong I would gladly admit that when the time comes, but for now my theory is more logical in my opinion
@@MangaHorse it's good to know you're open to the possibilities as I myself believe they going to show us more different realities not just the cabin one and manga reality, they might show us more of those realities created by Mikasa desire
The person that was causing mikasa headache was the founder of all the Titan Ymir *spoilers*
That is correct 👌
Lol nope it was her timeline flashbacks
Sorry friend but you are wrong. It literally says this in the manga when Mikasa tells Ymir “so you were the one always looking inside my head”
Isayama can’t explain it better than that 🤷♂️
@@MangaHorse thats what she assumes lol, its all an assumption, the truth will be revealed in the anime. Chapter 139 was meant to be a pure delusion. Also let me make it clear, Mikasa never freed Ymir. Ymir love plot for King Fritz came out of no where because its all meant to be a delusion. So is alliance getting all their wishes granted. AoE theorists already theorized A LONG TIME ago Chapter 138 would be the Divergence point lmao so idk what you ppl are on about. Even the poster itself confirms AoE with the same filter as Mappa uses for showing memories, and with Eren's firey aura around him in the shadows, there's nothing around Armin, but its consistent around Eren, (berserk fire titan form) AND not to mention, Falco is the bird flying up there above them already confirmed as ppl looked deeper into the image and see its his titan form and not a normal bird.
@@MangaHorse "Mikasa tells Ymir" lmao yet Ymir doesn't say shit if she was or not and laves it off with a vague unanswered, up to guess answer. She didn't free Ymir and Ymir isn't looking into her head. She's just getting timeline memory flashbacks. In 138 the same thing will happen, she already started getting timeline flashbacks in Cour 1 when she went to pathes, its becoming more frequent. Theres so much AoE evidence but you ppl are kinda too ignorant to realize it. Anyways, we'll be saying we told you so when Fall comes. Cour 2 will def be 2+ hours
If you look very closely in the windows of the cabin you can see Mikasa holding Eren's head and kissing it.
Pay attention to how the whole cabin scene is drawn as well. It's just like Eren and Armin's conversation in chapter 139. There are blank spaces on the edges of the pages instead of the panels covering the whole page (or a side of the page), giving it an empty feel. It either implies that the whole scene takes place in the Paths or that the whole thing is a memory.
Believe me, I’ve seen it plenty of times and did countless videos on it. I compared it to the conversation he had with Armin and they are completely different. There is no doubt these are not the paths…Isayama didn’t give you all those clues for no reason. This is an a reality, only an alternate reality.
@@MangaHorse You said it yourself, alternate realities, that proves AOE because this reality is a memory in paths, this cabin reality is one in many different realities converging. The anime would be the reality that would diverge from the cycle, the infinite loop, where Eren lives, he will win and break the cycle of hatred, AOE will come, and we will fucking.
Sorry to disappoint my friend, but it doesn’t 🙏 AOE is a talking about different ending, I’m talking about alternate realities and additional content WITHOUT changing the ending. If you see this as same, then I’m sorry, but like I said it completely different.
In addition AoE is a new term. You may think it’s been around for a long time, but that’s a misconception.
If you want you can check out this video where I explained what is AoE
czcams.com/video/UNnlZ3nH99g/video.html
@@MangaHorse No need to be sorry, we'll see, but from the tone of your reply you're always so sure
Nothing is sure
If you follow me channel you probably know I never said I was 100% right.
So no need to interpret my tone. My content speaks for itself
I'm back for the abyss to watch the madness unfold
never noticed how cabin eren isn't the one saying forget about me the second time. you're right, why would that reappear again in the panel after falco flew?? great video/theory!
well seen as often here👍
Lets go AOC
YEAH!!! I’m telling you spoon, I made some mistakes and also made some nice predictions, but I was never really upset if something didn’t happen.
But this time is different, I’m so invested in my idea that I will absolutely be disappointed if I’m wrong about it 🥲 but even more than that, I’m curious to see what will happen
AOC lol 🤡🤡🤡🤡
Why everyone hate the original ending I don't see any problem
Don’t worry, a lot of people like it, like myself. The people that didn’t like it are just very loud, but the ending is great
@@MangaHorse bro people have opinion try respecting it just because their opinions doesn't matches ur it doesn't make the loud i have seen many ending lover's giving death threats to a fanfic so it's on both side
a bird, a butterfly and my red scarf!
“Don’t make a mess of memories, just let me heal you scars” 🥹
@@MangaHorse it just has a deep meaning, can't wait to see this animated!!!
Me too! This year we will finally see it 🤩
@Mika yep, manga ending is a masterpiece, trolls just need something to be fight on, now they will curse Mappa for animating manga ending
I don’t think anyone in this comment tried to troll 😅 it’s just a line from the “Under the tree” by SiM
I don't think the "cabin in the woods scene" is an alternate reality. This is physically impossible. If Eren and Mikasa had escaped, then Eren would not have met Zeke, and would not have influenced his father in the past, moreover, he would not have influenced the titan who ate his mother. This is a vision that Eren sent to Mikasa. He did this to show what their life could have been like, and to show that their relationship was doomed anyway due to the 13 year life curse. So that Mikasa can let Eren go. And kill him. And yes, Eren could contact her, this does not contradict the Ackerman protection rule, he showed it to her in real time, he did not erase her memory like Armin, for example. We saw earlier how he contacted her 2 times (Hitchcock's rule by the way - show 2 times) - addressing all the Eldians and addressing the group when they were on the plane.
That’s because you are looking at the events as a line with different branches coming out of it, what makes you feel like they all share the same past. That’s not how physics works, but I knew people will ask exactly that so I explained exactly that in this video (you can look for the chapter you want) the first thing you need to understand is that “time” is not actually a straight line…It’s more like a never ending circle that you can’t see all of it…
If you are interested, here’s the video with a complete scientific explanation for Eren’s situation and also alternate realities
czcams.com/video/NuBKfHMOoSM/video.htmlsi=50Y2DOrnpQ8Kb_r6
@@MangaHorse I understand what you are saying, but I don't agree with you. It was you who decided that time works this way and not differently in Attack on Titan. But not Isayama. He never said that in the scene in the hut it was Eren from another universe. From a plot logic point of view, it would look strange and out of place and out of nowhere. Also, this was never mentioned in the work itself. Plus, as I said, the universe where Eren and Mikasa ran away cannot exist even as a parallel universe, I already said why: it will break the logic of the time loop, which you described in the video you sent me above.
But if you say that this is a completely separate universe that does not intersect with the main one, then this is stupid. Then Eren would not have been able to have the powers of the titans and he would have died in the first arc when he was eaten. This chapter clearly shows that this “other universe” starts precisely after Mikasa’s other answer, which means that in this “other universe” exactly the same events took place as in the “main” one up to this point. But this cannot be (I have already explained why). It's just a "what if". Eren shows Mikasa a cabin in the forest. Just like he shows Armin volcanoes, the ocean, etc. in chapter 139.
Okama razor - the simplest explanation is the truth. My explanation is the simplest.
Isayama uses the principle of determinism. What happened happened. There is only one past and one future. Eren is a slave to his visions of the future, that scene of “freedom.” In other words, Eren is a slave to freedom.
Okay, I get your point. I have my own point of view, I hope you understand it. Let's not argue. Maybe they’ll explain it in more detail at the end of the anime, we’ll see.
@yuritrapeznikov9204 no my friend, it wasn’t me who decided that…It was Albert Einstein and many other after him…
Now, if you want to argue with them on the subject be my guest, but they are the “fathers” of modern physics, I am simply following them and explaining what they discovered years ago
Everything I explained in the video I linked was scientifically accurate according to theoretical physics
@@MangaHorseLmao you're seriously narcissistic, it's honestly comical & pathetic. There is different types of "time travel" used in different shows/books, but in this one there is no " parallel universe with s different Eren" Isayama has made it clear in this story there is one universe, with one timeline, and nothing can be changed.
Other dude explained it perfect tbh, but your narcissistic pea brain stopped you from comprehending it.
"A long dream"
Yup, it was a long………….”Dream” 👀 😅
you can see the shadows in the window eren and mikasa kissing 😂😂
I dont understand what does CABIN mean for this anime. Everyone speaks about CABIN now. Cabin eren , cabin scene etc. But can someone give me a synonym of it..? which meaning of CABIN i dont get it
The cabin is an alternate reality. A “what if” situation of how things turned out under different circumstances, all coming down to Mikasa’s choice
In our reality she said to Eren “we are family”
And in the cabin reality she told his they should run away together
@@MangaHorse makes sense now. thank you very much.
I do hoped we get a new ending similar to the one we got in the manga but much better than what isayama had executed in the release. 😊
Hope you won’t be disappointed
@@MangaHorse yes because I can definitely see isayama learning from his mistakes and making a better ending this time for his series on the anime so that it'll pleased the fans who didn't like the ending we got in chapter 139 I hoped it is better this time in the anime.
I think you are going to be disappointed, but good luck 👍
@@MangaHorse I mean what am I supposed to be disappointed for I just wanna see her one more time that is
@@MangaHorse He still committed mass genocide and killed off 80% of the global population by stomping them all to death. Not only that, but his plan to protect Paradis ultimately failed, since a few decades later Paradis would be bombed and destroyed, thereby Eren's mass genocide backfired on him somehow (even Historia could've actually been dead thoguht that bombing though and
The chapter ended abruptly after an unnamed boy traveling across the woods and stopped by at the massive tree where Eren was buried. Although not 100% confirmed completely, it's highly implied that Eren plans to use the boy by giving him Titan powers so he could start the entire thing all over again.
So yeah the cycle just repeats itself and it never ending for the story. Think about it what do you think of this?
That bird is falco
Anime-onlies got so confused after seeing this PV 😂
I can’t blame them 😅 if I didn’t know I wouldn’t be able to even tell this is AOT. I saw some people saying the left shadow looked like Patrick from sponge bob and it made me laugh 😂 that’s why he’s in the thumbnail and vid
Who was making Miksa see things pls
SPOILER ALERT 🚨
.
.
.
.
.
.
It was Ymir
Finnaly we had the good ending, the true manga ending in the anime as well, Rip all the Aoe theories at last, I want to go to all comments who laugh at me for saying we gonna get the same ending 😝😝😝😝
It doesn't matter if they show the See you Later time-line. They are going to recap all previous time-lines. We all have to wait till fall to find out if there's and AOE/ANR or not.
@kekkolione817 it most certainly has more than 1 timeline. That is a fact by now, this is something almost everyone agrees on, actually
@kekkolione817 they are actually not my friend, they are events, and the different timeline is a fact in this fandom.
But I won’t fight with you on this, no need, you will see tomorrow yourself, so save yourself the pointless argument. Have a great day friend
@@MangaHorse I made the comment 5 months ago, I still hope AOE happens, but If we get the manga ending I'll hate it with a passion, but I'm going to move on from this anime. AOE theory ends tomorrow. I'm not moving the goalpost past that.
Amazing how you acknowledge this is a different reality, then suggest it’s missing a scene but deny Aoe when that could explain it along with other hints that are there.
How’s Aoe dead in all of this?
I see your confusion. You probably new to my channel. First of all, “AOE” is a made up term which is kinda new. The original theories of different ending were actually good and are much older then the term “AOE”
Aoe is by definition a different ending, and What I was suggesting doesn’t include a different ending, everything stays the same. Therefore they are completely different.
If you are confused here is a video I made about the history of AOE, and the Original theories that started it czcams.com/video/UNnlZ3nH99g/video.html
@@MangaHorse there is no confusion at all. I’ve clearly said that you deny Aoe and asked how is it dead to you.
It doesn’t matter what the term is, what matters is the end result, someone just labeled it Aoe after finding the clues, because that’s what it would be, an anime original ending.
What I mean is that you acknowledge the clues and made your theory which makes less sense than Aoe, not saying it doesn’t make any sense, just less. If anything the ending doesn’t need to expand the cabin scene, it needs to expand on the characters overall
Like I said. You asked me and I provided an answer. I also added the actual video I explained exactly what I believe in so there won’t be no confusion about what I believe in. That’s the confusion I was talking about
And the term extremely matters. Because once there were good theories but later they got mixed with stupid ideas and all mistakenly got under the same name “AoE”
I don’t know since when you are a fan, but I’m following in since 2011, so I was literally here seeing this process takes place. And all that is explained in that video I added.
In conclusion, my Idea has nothing to do with AoE, but it is connected to some of the original theories we had years ago
"RIP AOE" omegalul
“We will remember you AOE”👋🥹💀
A very good video, I still believe in AOE💪
That’s perfectly fine my friend. I’m not telling people what to believe in. I just share my own personal opinion and people are free to agree or disagree
@@MangaHorse Its all good because I have no enemies and I also respect your opinion and I lobe watching ur vids but I believe in AOE due to all the foreshadowing and giod reasoning it had since the start,you keep doing your great vids. Have a good day💪
The thing is even though Mikasas dream was living the simple life with Eren, Eren would of been bored out of his mind. Eren needed a drive for freedom, it never would of worked between them.
Yeah but that’s not a dream my friend, it’s an alternate reality. It did happen, only not in the reality we have been following
@@MangaHorseI meant dream as like her life long goal, the thing she always wanted, more than anything. There is probably no reality where Mikasa lives a long life with Eren.
Yes, there is no world where they are together fir the rest of their life. Their will always be something to end it. Just like the butterfly said in Mikasa’s OVA. That she would never be able to save Eren, he will always die
it's just sus because Idk I'm not sure if they showed the cabin in the actual manga ending I haven't really found anything I didn't read the manga because of the anime but the poster is sus why would they show the cabin is it just a vision of a different timeline or an aoe
Oh of course they showed the cabin. It’s on chapter 138 “a long dream”
@@MangaHorse ohh see I didn't know
No worries. I figured you missed it. It’s around the middle of chapter 138 if you want to check it out
@@MangaHorse I'll read the manga once the anime is over I hate how people spoiled so many things with the manga it sucks man
1:35 HaHa litle Bird this Bird is Falco
you don't understand mess of memories to understand AOE
The same in the first min.. of the last ep
And eren and armins titan shadows
That "Little Bird" is Falco's Jaw Titan if you look closely...No bird has Claws on the Wings like Falco's Jaw Titan.
AOE is not Dead. People just don't want to have hopes for it...AOT is incomplete without ANR Ending. All those Questions will stay as Questions if the ANR ending won't happen and the story will not make any sense.
Its all just a " Mess Of Memories " as said in the Under the Tree song...all those memories are messing up that is why it has a Glitched Effect on it....Cuz Eren and Armin's Colossal titan wasn't in the Cabin Timeline and also Falco's Jaw Titan. its kind of like a mixture of memories.
The original ending was so ass I just want Eren to win
Eren got everything he asked for, Including for his friends to have a peaceful life, so he didn’t actually lose. But thinking he could live after all this killing is extremely optimistic thinking
Oh I know and I’ll keep thinking
Rip aoe🙏
We Will remember you AoE 🥲
Can I ask you what 'See you later, Eren' actually means if there is no aoe?
@@No-I-dont-want-that it's only means delusion and cope.
@@GamersArea Yeah, that was expected. You can't give any answer to my question. "Delusion" and "Cope" are the only words you can use.
I’ll gladly pick up that question because I talked about it in a lot of videos. Here’s one of them, but I talked about it more in later videos as well 👇
czcams.com/video/ZFE70kgghtM/video.html
Aoe can't be dead because it was never alive to begin with 😂
😂 nahh, it lived alright. But it wasn’t under the AOE umbrella. Every theory that came after and got the name OAE was pure nonsense no doubt
people still believe even after this its going to happen.
*AOE* Cumfirmed!
EREN DID NOTHING WRONG 🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣
Falco is literally in the image LMAO what do u mean aoe is dead? Also aoe theorists have said 138 would be divergence point
Aoe is dead stop coping and just watch the ending