@@khadijatsule6512 basically after they announced they were dating, cube kicked them out. But then cubes stocks and sells was legit dropping by the hour so they took them back in😂😂
None of them look happy or like they’re enjoying the stage like usual, the mood is off and seriously awkward and the song sounds weird and like a cover. Never be the same without Edawn it’s disgraceful how he was treated and now Pentagon will suffer.
I'm not rlly part of the fandom but I can feel their sorrow...I miss E'Dawn and Yan an. I change say that the members misses them. The song doesn't sound right without both of them...I'm crying
one year later. yanan wants to come back but cube won’t talk to him. he posted about it on a personal account (forgot what for but it’s a chinese social media)
@@alexrm1316 Yanan left due to personal health reasons and Dawn got kicked out cause he and HyunA revealed that they have been in a secret relationship for a couple of years. They both still make music though, they joined Pnation last year.
well yeah but yanan will definitely be back while hyojong might get removed from cube ? so we have every right to be mad i miss yanan too, he’s my bias but i know it’s because of his health i’m sure hyojong would love to perform with them but isn’t allowed to
I may not be a part of the fandom but I'm still crying. Like u can actually feel their sadness through the performance. Shine is one of my favorite songs in kpop and in pentagon. Without E'dawn and Yanan in the performance doesn't feel the same as the old times. Universe stay strong! ~from a supporter of pentagon❤️
They're pentagon with or without E'dawn and Yanan ya know? I mean I'm ot10 all the way but Pentagon will make it without E'dawn because they're a amazing and talented group.
Must be hard on Hui. I'm pretty sure he has built a strong bond with E'Dawn since he was apart of Triple H. And him being the leader of Pentagon and having 2 members not on stage must be so different for him. Throughout the video I couldn't see Hui be as happy as he is When performing 'Shine'.
Even without E'dawn and Yanan they did a great job fighting Pentagon I'll support u guys as much as I can at the same I'm also miss E'dawn and Yanan too.
Without E'dawn and Yanan it feels a bit off, the off vocals are noticeable but its still a nice performance, i hope They can join soon so Pentagon can be complete
I just realized what this stage made me feel like. It felt like a cover group. A very on point cover group nonetheless. Kind of awkward, not that confident, and everything seems a bit off. Yanan and E'Dawn really brought a specific sound to Pentagon, and I didn't realize the impact until they're not there. I hope Yanan gets well quickly, and Cube gets off their fucking high horse and let's E'Dawn back into Pentagon.
i respect them sm for even still promoting and performing. They looked so tired and sad, but they still did their best, showing how professional they really are
This was the most underwhelming performance of theirs I have ever seen, Yanan and Edawn really do make the difference in how this group acts and sounds.
idk why but this stage feels so sad.. there’s a pain on their heart.. they didn’t look happy tho.. i miss yanan and edawn... so much I’M NOT CRYING MY EYES JUST SWEATING
Even though the overall performance was great (choreography was on point and their vocals were stable), the members look off. It looks like they tried to brush the two member's absence so UNIVERSE would not worry, but I can sense it by their voices and facial expressions that they are not fully into the performance. The happiness, hype, and overall positive energy we usually get in their Shine performance isn't there. I love you Pentagon! Stay strong loves.
"Shine" without E'DAWN feels a bit strange, but, in spite of that, we have to support them and give them a lot of love so that they can continue with their career and we can continue listening to them more time 💟
is it just me who can feel the sadness from our boys?? but they still did their very best and worked hardest to bring a very cool performance for all of us. FIGHTING PENTAGON!!! WE WILL WORK HARD AND WALK ON THE FLOWER PATH ONLY TOGETHER!!! 💚💚💚💚💚💚
this is like how people say "omg i can't imagine *insert group name* without *insert member name* " i've always felt like that for any group but to see it actually happen is heartbreaking
When exo lost some members and went to their shows without them, I was so damn sad :( I didn't want to see any other groups losing members... It's hella sad. ;-; I miss E'Dawn and Yanan so much (Yanan is sick tho)
*You're enduring your pain and I'm so sorry for being incapable to do more to resolve this issue. All of you, Pentagon, have the right to be sad, upset and disappointed to your fans and your company, of course, you do. I hope you can say it loud what you think about this concerne and what you want. Whatever your opinion and decision are I'll be there to support you. Love, Pentagon. I only want you to be happy beside who you decide.*
ME QUEMA ME LASTIMA ME QUIERO MATAR NO ES LO MISMO SIN E'DAWN Y YAN AN :C It burns me hurts, it's not the same without e'dawn and yan an, it's as if a part of my heart and soul went with them, my favorite song is shine, but I do not feel the same when listening with only 8 members to listen to it with everyone
Even though it feels weird see them performing shine without E'dawn and Yanan, let's stay positive and support them with full heart ❤️ Universe we can do this!
'shine isnt same without edawn and yanan' 'the stage is a bit strange' 'im so sad bcz knetz' OK GUYS THIS ISNT PENTAGON FAULT so pls guys say that they were good, beautiful on stage. hardworking....
No one said it was pentagons fault, no hate towards you or anything, I agree and yes even without edawn and yanan, pentagon was very hardworking and I'm proud of them 💕
Im so sad dawn isn't here, tbh he was the one that made me in love with pentagon with his amazing start on shine, but they are still amazing and I can't wait to see them grow!
I'm not sooo into this group but I was holding my tears but they fell down in the Yanan's part. I hope he and E' Dawn be okay and successful in the future
Probablemente no muchos entiendan este comentario pero quiero dar mi opinión :'v creo q sin E'dawn ya no es lo mismo y se nota demasiado que ya no está y obviamente no es culpa de sus compañeros ya q se veía q se querían mucho ☹️ pinshe empresa de mierda ☹️
Lo se bro lo se pero hay que superar esta pérdida yo sigo llorando porque ya no encuentro mas canciones de pentagon con los miembros completos pero espero que edawn sea feliz con Hyuna al menos eso si tendremos su felicidad 🙂
Flopped not exactly. They are doing better then even when Shine was released. It took a month for Shine to chart. and after the first week of sales the subsequent weeks sales was not very high in their first month. They charted with this song on Melon in the first hour and for a few hours/few days and are constantly on rising chart on Melon. The sales are less then Shine (although the week is not finish yet) but steady and more than any of their other albums. For a rising group under extreme pressure they are holding up okay. Let's hope the sale increase even more and they chart on Melon again. They have definitely gain some public recognition not a lot of people knew who they were but with everything that is surrounding them they also gain shame and public disdain.
Oh Ha Na I was going to tell you to get on defense because I’m sure there are people that really don’t damn agree and love their new comeback. Sweetie, call it a flop, but they’re achieving goals and working hard for it. A flop? Sweetie, it’s a bop 👏🏻👏🏻
Don't forget to support them, you know it's what Edawn and Yanan want, they've posted that much. I hate that Edawn and Yanan aren't there, but these 8 guys have been working hard for us and I won't let them feel they aren't loved and appreciated. This is a crucial time for them coming off of the success of Shine. They are innocent in all of this so they shouldn't have to suffer. It's hard on them more than it's hard on us.
He's been having health issues so he's taking some time off. We are anxiously waiting for him to return, but he needs this time to get better. Welcome to the fandom bts :-D
Everybody saying E'dawn should be here or to stfu saying E'dawn this or that, but i'm having the feels for Wooseok, i mean, the boy has to fill in the big stage presence of Dawnie in their most famous song... & Shin Won pulling the most iconic line ever? I mean, Yanan's *My baby* ? Please, clap clap to this guys 👏👏
can you *really* blame people for missing two members in an ot10 group? Yes, kudos to the other 8! They did amazing, but it shouldn't be such a bad thing for people to worry and miss the other 2 members...lol...
@@DianaLovesYou Eh? I just said there are 2 kind of ppl, those who are cryin' for E'dawn & Yanan, & those who tell them to stop talking about them... I was in the first group cause E'dawn is my BIAS, but i want to give credits to the other guys too. I will always think TENTAGON TENTASTIC is the best.
To cube: are you guys not guilty and shameful to do this to us...fans?... Our humble request: please bring back E'Dawn....his personal life is not so important for a group dance and singing songs!!!
the only fans cube considers as fans are those who k-unis who buy multiple albums and attends their fansigns, and capable of streaming s nonstop, many of them are against edawn's dating and other concerns they stated. at the end of the day, it's all business to cube. to them, the group needs profit to survive. edawn's presence in the group is a hindrance based on cube's knowledge. also cube has so much pride on their artist obeying their contracts, i think hyundawn break their contract, although as far as i know there's no dating ban in cube. cube is somehow overreacting right?
@@yahin06 So if there's no dating ban then what's cube issue? Hyuna told everyone so cube got upset? Ok they can get over that but there's no dating ban so there should be no issue at all.
@@Katara0403 no dating ban but the moment they announced they were dating, those so called "profitable" fans were enraged. cube cannot overlook it because it's not like pentagon can afford to loose so much fans, the fandom isn't that big yet to ignore those who are aginst it. but still i think kicking them out is an overreaction.
I am sad about edawn and yanan too. But please can we appreciate the strenght and the talent of the other members that slay and work hard for universe even in this situation?💙
but im just crying..For the first time i seen My Kino crying on fansign.. If u listen and read the lyrics of Just Do It You ..its telling about their life after this issue.. How cube treats them and also people arounds them reacting .. I want Ptg lives very well and healthy but their life never changed..just becuz their get attention but ptg never get any first win for music show for two years debut..Cube never treats ptg better even their bathroom was awful cuz they have to share the water to bath..I cant imagine if ptg have to deals of this..
It takes years for some groups to get a win on the show. I would mention examples of groups, but I don't want people to get all upset for mentioning other groups but you may know the ones I'm talking about. Pentagon will get their win one day. It just takes time especially with how much competition they have. They're getting more popular so that's a good sign.
As a fan ,it hurts to see them incomplete, what's more to the remaining members. All we can do is make them feel our love and support. PENTAGON, FIGHTING!💙💙
boy how crazy and amazing it would be to have e'dawn and yanan to walk onto the stage in the middle of the performance to join the group... i'd cry an ocean of happy tears.
Edawn was the glue holding this team together, without him doesn't feel right. He would usually sit down at the start, but seeing him not there breaks my heart
The performance feels odd. You can tell by the audience. Most of them are not that excited because E'Dawn and Yannan are missing. Wish those 2 are back sooner :(
honestly it pains me to see the boys incomplete because of how *hard* they fought to keep Pentagon as 10 members just before debut. Props to all the the boys for stepping it up, especially Hui and Wooseok. (Boy Wooseok had to cover both his parts and e'dawn's which both are big parts). I just want all the boys back together again, I miss my boyos :((
![Hyuna & Dawn - Favorite Moments [ENG SUB]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/u3ZBep8iTcA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Hyuna & Dawn - Favorite Moments [ENG SUB]](/img/tr.png)
![Pentagon - Shine (Accustic Ver.)ㅣ펜타곤 - 빛나리 [Show Music Core Ep 587]](/img/n.gif)
Feels weird not seeing E'dawn tapping the ground at the beginning :c
It's because he was kicked out
ikr
@@worldwidekpopfan4212 I know he was kicked out :c
its not pentagon anymore it like octagon and its not shine anymore
This video feels really awkward without E’dawn
Wooseok looks so uncomfortable doing E’Dawn’s intro :( my heart hurts
Pentagon will always be Ten not a member less :(
pentagon left the chat*
octagon entered the chat*
@@official_xenon9845 more like square kek
He does and its so sad and by their expression i can tell they miss E'dawn
True like E'dawn and yanan i miss them
same sis i can feel the agony while wooseok is doing the intro :
I started crying as soon as I realized that E'Dawn wasn't there sitting on the floor...
SAME tears sprung in my eyes at this
Same bro same 😢😓
I’m trying not to cry rn cuz my parents are home 😩
Same
stormlee13 yeah and when the fans scream he would put a cute smile on his blushing face :c
Doesn't feel the same. I remembered watching shine and always feeling hyped whenever it plays. But this just feels so empty and sad.
Yeah
Yeah agree
I feel you.
agree
I know right
I'm so frustrated that E.Dawn isn't able to perform just because Knetz 😧😣 Shine isn't the same without him and Yanan
he was kicked out of Cube with Hyuna
They have gone back on their decision, he is still in cube as of right now and same with hyuna
Peyton McGarity what do you mean?
@@khadijatsule6512 basically after they announced they were dating, cube kicked them out. But then cubes stocks and sells was legit dropping by the hour so they took them back in😂😂
OF COURSE. BECAUSE KNETZ ARE SHOWERING CUBE ENT. HATEFUL COMMENTS JUST BECAUSE THEY LET THEIR IDOLS/ARTIST TO HAVE A RELATIONSHIP. SICK RIGHT?
feel incomplete without e'dawn & yanan :'(
anyway they did great as always 💕
Edawn and yanan..... 😭
I know what happened to E’dawnn but what happened to yanan??
@@naxsalas714 I want to know too
@@naxsalas714 they said he's sick,,
Nax Salas YanAn left for health reasons and E’Dawn well everyone knows..😔😔😭
None of them look happy or like they’re enjoying the stage like usual, the mood is off and seriously awkward and the song sounds weird and like a cover. Never be the same without Edawn it’s disgraceful how he was treated and now Pentagon will suffer.
They look like they miss E'Dawn
They don't look they're enjoying.and happy it sounds sad and disgraceful without Edawn
yes, girl! that's true🥺
Pentagon Will Not Suffer Cube Will
Pentagon's Naughty Boy is pretty good tho
I'm not rlly part of the fandom but I can feel their sorrow...I miss E'Dawn and Yan an. I change say that the members misses them. The song doesn't sound right without both of them...I'm crying
1:15 THOSE 'MMM' 'MMM' ARE FROM E'DAWN, I'M CYING IN THE CLUB TT
Multi Fandom ;v me too sis😭
SSAAAAAAME
😭😭
Nul sarang haneun JIJIRI JIJIRI!!!! 24/7 💔
I still miss e’dawn
Is it just me or do they look down? Or dispirited? They don't deserve this stress Cube is giving them. Fighting, Pentagon!✊❤️
Vermillion they look so sad........
you could said he's e'gone
@@Vannilla I shouldn't have laughed, but I diiiiiiid 😂😂😂
True
they're look dont have much power here imo
I came here to see how they survive this song without edawn 🙁🙁
same, i feel uncomfortable seeing someone else singing edawns parts
Me too
Call me REN d
Same
Samee
Yanan with health issues and Edawn being kicked out of cube...
I cant help to see Pentagon with only 8 members...
Cube what have you done
when i hear CUBE i sigh
RileyThetic
Yanan is still in Ptg.
one year later. yanan wants to come back but cube won’t talk to him. he posted about it on a personal account (forgot what for but it’s a chinese social media)
Why did yanan and edawn leave pentagon?? It’s not the same without them😭😔
@@alexrm1316 Yanan left due to personal health reasons and Dawn got kicked out cause he and HyunA revealed that they have been in a secret relationship for a couple of years. They both still make music though, they joined Pnation last year.
em I'm sorry everyone but.. It's not just E'Dawn who's missing but also Yanan.
Uh, yeah? Everyone knows that?
well yeah but yanan will definitely be back while hyojong might get removed from cube ? so we have every right to be mad
i miss yanan too, he’s my bias but i know it’s because of his health
i’m sure hyojong would love to perform with them but isn’t allowed to
My baby:( and hmm hmm aaaaaa E'Dawn and Yanan
Even before Edawn was kicked out nobody mentioned Yanans missing presence.
Yan an💕
I may not be a part of the fandom but I'm still crying. Like u can actually feel their sadness through the performance. Shine is one of my favorite songs in kpop and in pentagon. Without E'dawn and Yanan in the performance doesn't feel the same as the old times. Universe stay strong! ~from a supporter of pentagon❤️
JLadylou Buer I feel like you
I feel the same..... That energy is not there and looking at this performance I can feel the sadness......
Agree. He looks the saddest among them all
I appreciate your support but did you really need to say that you're an army it's like advertising them and giving attention to BTS just saying
Potato ARMY i understand. I won't do it again. I'm sorry
What is Shine without Pentagon?
*What is Pentagon without Yanan and E'dawn?*
That's nothing.😭😭miss Edawn so much .but he's happy with Hyuna
It’s a good thing that yanan is back.
They're pentagon with or without E'dawn and Yanan ya know? I mean I'm ot10 all the way but Pentagon will make it without E'dawn because they're a amazing and talented group.
@@anandtolui3040 it's Hyuna ,not hyana
@@johngolok2369 oops sorry it was a typo 😅i fixed it
How can they be *tentastic* without ten members😢
No one can replace Yanan's "my baby!"
And no one can replace E'Dawn's part
😢😢😢😢😢😢
Must be hard on Hui. I'm pretty sure he has built a strong bond with E'Dawn since he was apart of Triple H. And him being the leader of Pentagon and having 2 members not on stage must be so different for him. Throughout the video I couldn't see Hui be as happy as he is When performing 'Shine'.
Mystical Ch3Rome it’s breaks my heart seeing cube take away hui’s best friend
Mystical Ch3Rome just asking considering I don’t know much about Pentagon but who's Hui?
Jimins his hair will be the death of me hui is the one who starts singing at 0:24-0:25 with the stripped white and blue shirt
Wait why is Yanan not on stage?
@@bottomtext1276 health problems
Even without E'dawn and Yanan they did a great job fighting Pentagon I'll support u guys as much as I can at the same I'm also miss E'dawn and Yanan too.
Universe. I know I mean we all know we are sad about losing Yanan and E'Dawn. But Let's continue to support Pentagon❤️
Hey Naughty Boy is nice
Without E'dawn and Yanan it feels a bit off, the off vocals are noticeable but its still a nice performance, i hope They can join soon so Pentagon can be complete
True I also hope that everything will be normal because it is a little calmer the audience
I love pentagon but the stage just isn't the same without yanan and e'dawn
Yup
I just realized what this stage made me feel like. It felt like a cover group. A very on point cover group nonetheless. Kind of awkward, not that confident, and everything seems a bit off. Yanan and E'Dawn really brought a specific sound to Pentagon, and I didn't realize the impact until they're not there. I hope Yanan gets well quickly, and Cube gets off their fucking high horse and let's E'Dawn back into Pentagon.
every member bring a specific sound to Pentagon. OT10 is Pentagon
Ikr Idk the name, when the tall guy covered Hui part during the intro he seems so awkward and he seems like he feels sorry
@@jul2447 it's wooseok and he covered edawn's part , hui is still here but it's not the first time that they sing this redistribution
@@greensun8086 thanks and sorry I actually wants to wrote Edawn 😅
@@greensun8086 Yeah, they all have very unique voices that sound wonderful all together ❤️ I hope we can have Pentagon as OT10 soon
Remember kids, Pentagon is a 10 membered group not 9, not 8. :))
I love wooseok and i know that he’s the best member to fill E’Dawn’s spot but man do i miss E’Dawn in this group.
I see sadness in their eyes or i am just hallucinating ?😢 e'dawn and yanan where are u boys?😢
Bea Guro It’s definitely as or if not more stressful for them to be on stage during this mess. They’re keeping at it and they’re strong though
U r not alone babe
Bea Guro I can feel the sadness!
Me toooooo:((
I was about to comment the same!
i respect them sm for even still promoting and performing. They looked so tired and sad, but they still did their best, showing how professional they really are
This was the most underwhelming performance of theirs I have ever seen, Yanan and Edawn really do make the difference in how this group acts and sounds.
THE ENERGY IS MISSING!!!!!!!!!!!!
idk why but this stage feels so sad.. there’s a pain on their heart.. they didn’t look happy tho.. i miss yanan and edawn... so much I’M NOT CRYING MY EYES JUST SWEATING
I can feel it too :(
:( so sad
What did yanan do ?
@Akassi Alice M Elliam Yanan left become of mental/health issues. He said he might come back at some point.
Even though the overall performance was great (choreography was on point and their vocals were stable), the members look off. It looks like they tried to brush the two member's absence so UNIVERSE would not worry, but I can sense it by their voices and facial expressions that they are not fully into the performance. The happiness, hype, and overall positive energy we usually get in their Shine performance isn't there. I love you Pentagon! Stay strong loves.
Jem Lee that right I always feel happy when I see Shine but this time I feel just sadness. .....
Why does this feel like a sad version of shine😭
Yanan/e'dawn i wish you were there
You can see the sadness in their face while performing this. ):
yeah
It's so clear I'm sad
I miss E'Dawn, everybody miss E'Dawn
But why . I found E'DAWN ....1:15 💔💔💔💔
"Shine" without E'DAWN feels a bit strange, but, in spite of that, we have to support them and give them a lot of love so that they can continue with their career and we can continue listening to them more time 💟
don't forget yanan
@@snasker936 do not worry, i did not forget him. I really hope he gets better soon, but for the time being he need to rest and some time.
The song actually sounds deeper hence a little bit different and off without edawn and yanan...
I found E'DAWN!!!! 1:15 🤣💔💔💔💔💔😭😭😭😭😭
They're not so happy as the old performances. My heart, I just can't
NO E'DAWN NO PARTY :(
there are still 8 members but why does the stage feel so empty? i miss e'dawn and yanan so much, it's so lonely~
Kx same thoughts
I was thinking that too🤧 its not the same without them
I have a feeling they will return and be the 10 members again
:c
Kx wait what happen to them? Did they disband or something?
Aw they don't look happy, like they forced a smile. it's not the same with E'dawn and Yanan
Their face tell me they are not happy as before😢
This just broke my heart not seeing E'dawn tapping on the floor or without Yanan. 😭💔
is it just me who can feel the sadness from our boys?? but they still did their very best and worked hardest to bring a very cool performance for all of us. FIGHTING PENTAGON!!! WE WILL WORK HARD AND WALK ON THE FLOWER PATH ONLY TOGETHER!!! 💚💚💚💚💚💚
Pentagon is dead dude
PENTAGON FIGHTING.
PENTAGON ALWAYS 0T10
Shine is not SHINE without YanAn and EDawn.
Everytime I watched the MV, I'm smiling but this time 😭 Anyways so proud of this group
*my baby, e'dawn and yanan..*
*they will always be in my heart.*
*i love you, pentagon.*
*please bring them back!*
this is like how people say "omg i can't imagine *insert group name* without *insert member name* " i've always felt like that for any group but to see it actually happen is heartbreaking
When exo lost some members and went to their shows without them, I was so damn sad :(
I didn't want to see any other groups losing members...
It's hella sad. ;-;
I miss E'Dawn and Yanan so much (Yanan is sick tho)
*You're enduring your pain and I'm so sorry for being incapable to do more to resolve this issue. All of you, Pentagon, have the right to be sad, upset and disappointed to your fans and your company, of course, you do. I hope you can say it loud what you think about this concerne and what you want. Whatever your opinion and decision are I'll be there to support you. Love, Pentagon. I only want you to be happy beside who you decide.*
Edawn we miss you
ME QUEMA ME LASTIMA ME QUIERO MATAR NO ES LO MISMO SIN E'DAWN Y YAN AN :C
It burns me hurts, it's not the same without e'dawn and yan an, it's as if a part of my heart and soul went with them, my favorite song is shine, but I do not feel the same when listening with only 8 members to listen to it with everyone
Can we stop talking about E dawn and appreciate how the 8 members are doing their best to keep the fans entertained
They don’t look as happy. This performance is usually so hype but they just look sad. Fighting for OT10
I can clearly tell that they are either fake smiling or not smiling :'C
HeyImRoxy 432 theres barely any energy in this performance they’re literally just doing it in a routine like way
It hurts, when E'dawn is still here everyone is shouting in the intro but then they look not comfortable
Necesito ver por última vez esta canción con E'dawn y Yan An en vivo :,l
No E'Dawn and Yanan :(
It's not the same anymore
Even though it feels weird see them performing shine without E'dawn and Yanan, let's stay positive and support them with full heart ❤️ Universe we can do this!
Pentagon is dead, let's be honest
Guys please give them support, they work so hard to maintain ot10 vibes.
The saddest thing of the year
'shine isnt same without edawn and yanan' 'the stage is a bit strange' 'im so sad bcz knetz'
OK GUYS THIS ISNT PENTAGON FAULT
so pls guys say that they were good, beautiful on stage. hardworking....
yeah it's not their fault, but it's true. The atmosphere is definitely different, and it's obvious.
No one said it was pentagons fault, no hate towards you or anything, I agree and yes even without edawn and yanan, pentagon was very hardworking and I'm proud of them 💕
Special thanks for wooseok,kino,and shinwon for covering their missing members
Cube please bring back e'dawn 😥😥we miss him alot
Im so sad dawn isn't here, tbh he was the one that made me in love with pentagon with his amazing start on shine, but they are still amazing and I can't wait to see them grow!
I'm not sooo into this group but I was holding my tears but they fell down in the Yanan's part. I hope he and E' Dawn be okay and successful in the future
it’s weird to see them perform shine with eight but they did such a good job
pentagon hwaiting
*This isn't Pentagon that i know ... i miss Yanan and E'dawn..*
it was so weird to not see e’dawn tapping the floor....
Probablemente no muchos entiendan este comentario pero quiero dar mi opinión :'v creo q sin E'dawn ya no es lo mismo y se nota demasiado que ya no está y obviamente no es culpa de sus compañeros ya q se veía q se querían mucho ☹️ pinshe empresa de mierda ☹️
Ensima hace mucha falta en el inicio de la canción
Se ven tristes :(
@@sugesuge6197 siii se nota muchisimo q ya no está :'v
😢😢
Lo se bro lo se pero hay que superar esta pérdida yo sigo llorando porque ya no encuentro mas canciones de pentagon con los miembros completos pero espero que edawn sea feliz con Hyuna al menos eso si tendremos su felicidad 🙂
Normally there would be legit screams during edawn's parts but now:( look at what you've done cube 😢
Pwark Jisung im so mad at cube ent 😒
I’m just happy they’re slowly but surely rising to bigger fame because it’s what they deserve 💕
The mic yoongi keeps dropping every time their new comeback actually flopped
Oh Ha Na Well shit. I actually loved their new comeback so 🤷🏽♀️
Flopped not exactly. They are doing better then even when Shine was released. It took a month for Shine to chart. and after the first week of sales the subsequent weeks sales was not very high in their first month. They charted with this song on Melon in the first hour and for a few hours/few days and are constantly on rising chart on Melon. The sales are less then Shine (although the week is not finish yet) but steady and more than any of their other albums. For a rising group under extreme pressure they are holding up okay. Let's hope the sale increase even more and they chart on Melon again. They have definitely gain some public recognition not a lot of people knew who they were but with everything that is surrounding them they also gain shame and public disdain.
Oh Ha Na flopped? nah sis
Oh Ha Na I was going to tell you to get on defense because I’m sure there are people that really don’t damn agree and love their new comeback. Sweetie, call it a flop, but they’re achieving goals and working hard for it. A flop? Sweetie, it’s a bop 👏🏻👏🏻
Pentagon is not pentagon without their other 2 sides
pentagon is 9, dont forget about it guys.💜 our precious boys, pentagon is the best!!
Don't forget to support them, you know it's what Edawn and Yanan want, they've posted that much. I hate that Edawn and Yanan aren't there, but these 8 guys have been working hard for us and I won't let them feel they aren't loved and appreciated. This is a crucial time for them coming off of the success of Shine. They are innocent in all of this so they shouldn't have to suffer. It's hard on them more than it's hard on us.
Why was Yan an not there? I'm new to this fandom.
He's been having health issues so he's taking some time off. We are anxiously waiting for him to return, but he needs this time to get better. Welcome to the fandom bts :-D
Everybody saying E'dawn should be here or to stfu saying E'dawn this or that, but i'm having the feels for Wooseok, i mean, the boy has to fill in the big stage presence of Dawnie in their most famous song... & Shin Won pulling the most iconic line ever? I mean, Yanan's *My baby* ? Please, clap clap to this guys 👏👏
can you *really* blame people for missing two members in an ot10 group? Yes, kudos to the other 8! They did amazing, but it shouldn't be such a bad thing for people to worry and miss the other 2 members...lol...
@@DianaLovesYou Eh? I just said there are 2 kind of ppl, those who are cryin' for E'dawn & Yanan, & those who tell them to stop talking about them... I was in the first group cause E'dawn is my BIAS, but i want to give credits to the other guys too. I will always think TENTAGON TENTASTIC is the best.
oh, my bad, I think I misinterpreted what you were saying O:
I feel sad because of E'Dawn. Stay Strong My Co-Universe💖😭
e’dawn has such a unique and beautiful voice. he really brought so much to this song. it’s upsetting not seeing him here:((
To cube: are you guys not guilty and shameful to do this to us...fans?...
Our humble request: please bring back E'Dawn....his personal life is not so important for a group dance and singing songs!!!
the only fans cube considers as fans are those who k-unis who buy multiple albums and attends their fansigns, and capable of streaming s nonstop, many of them are against edawn's dating and other concerns they stated. at the end of the day, it's all business to cube. to them, the group needs profit to survive. edawn's presence in the group is a hindrance based on cube's knowledge. also cube has so much pride on their artist obeying their contracts, i think hyundawn break their contract, although as far as i know there's no dating ban in cube. cube is somehow overreacting right?
@@yahin06 So if there's no dating ban then what's cube issue? Hyuna told everyone so cube got upset? Ok they can get over that but there's no dating ban so there should be no issue at all.
@@Katara0403 no dating ban but the moment they announced they were dating, those so called "profitable" fans were enraged. cube cannot overlook it because it's not like pentagon can afford to loose so much fans, the fandom isn't that big yet to ignore those who are aginst it. but still i think kicking them out is an overreaction.
@@yahin06 cube overracting because hyundawn doesnt discuss with them firat before tell the public about dating newd
I am sad about edawn and yanan too. But please can we appreciate the strenght and the talent of the other members that slay and work hard for universe even in this situation?💙
Min Miin thanks for thinking the same way♡
Min Miin 💙💙💙
And what happen to Yanan?tell me please
HafidFaris i only know he has some health problems but there isn't any specific information unfortunatly, but norhing too serious as far as i know
ale 23 oh okay,thanks for the information
Correre a escuchar la original para sentirme mejor..... 😭😭😭
Omooo..I don’t feel like this is PENTAGON..it’s like a puzzle but missing two pieces..
Im so proud of mah Boiiis❣️
im sorry but this was so painful to watch without yanan and e dawn
Same I can't do this. I have a brick in my throat.
But we still have the MV 💔....Nul sarang haneun JIJIRI JIJIRI!!!! 24/7♾
Idk why but Pentahon sounds like a group doing a cover of shine E'Dawn's voice is so unique please bring him back
This is the loneliest Shine performance I've ever watched 😞
but im just crying..For the first time i seen My Kino crying on fansign.. If u listen and read the lyrics of Just Do It You ..its telling about their life after this issue.. How cube treats them and also people arounds them reacting .. I want Ptg lives very well and healthy but their life never changed..just becuz their get attention but ptg never get any first win for music show for two years debut..Cube never treats ptg better even their bathroom was awful cuz they have to share the water to bath..I cant imagine if ptg have to deals of this..
It takes years for some groups to get a win on the show. I would mention examples of groups, but I don't want people to get all upset for mentioning other groups but you may know the ones I'm talking about. Pentagon will get their win one day. It just takes time especially with how much competition they have. They're getting more popular so that's a good sign.
Wait why was kino crying????
@@nikevuna6724 at a fansign event, while talking about the 10members, how they used to take turn for bathing....he cried on the spot
As a fan ,it hurts to see them incomplete, what's more to the remaining members. All we can do is make them feel our love and support. PENTAGON, FIGHTING!💙💙
E’dawn 😭😭😭 Côme back soon please 😥😢😢
2019? Btw who miss E.Dawn because i miss him so much and he is my bias😭😭😭
The first time i like pentagon cause Edawn at intro shine,but now??😭😭😭😭
I CANT WATCH PENTAGON PERFORMANCE WITHOUT CRYING😭😭😭😭 EDAWN MADE THIS SONG ICONIC SRSLY!! AND WE NEED YANAN'S MY BABY!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭😭
boy how crazy and amazing it would be to have e'dawn and yanan to walk onto the stage in the middle of the performance to join the group... i'd cry an ocean of happy tears.
This feels so wrong without the ex members 😭 cube messed up real time
😙😙😙😙😙😙😙
There's something wrong. Their performance is not energetic as before. Bring back e'dawn!
Mary Hillary Jasa and yan an 🙃
:(
YUTO KNOWS EXACTLY WHAT HIS DOING WEARING THAT SHIRT AND CHAINS
Jhelzsie Santiago SIS I A G R E E
CoolMacTinus212002 obvs sad about that too but Im sure he’s coming back. Cube can’t be that stupid
Edawn was the glue holding this team together, without him doesn't feel right. He would usually sit down at the start, but seeing him not there breaks my heart
While watching this I was in tears seeing E'Dawn not tapping the ground for the intro and his rapping voice
STAY POSITIVE UNIVERSE 💚
Se siente horrible el no escuchar a E'Dawn :'''(
Escuchar "My baby" sin Yan an es horrible, ademas de que hace mucha falta E'Dawn, ¡Maldita CUBE!
Lo mismo pienso
De ley... era mi voz favorita.... 😞😞😞😞😞
Se escuchaba hermosa esa canción con su voz :(
:'v
I miss Yanan doing the MY BABY part😭❤️
The performance feels odd. You can tell by the audience. Most of them are not that excited because E'Dawn and Yannan are missing. Wish those 2 are back sooner :(
No es lo mismo escuchar el "ma beibi" de otra persona🤧extraño a Yanan y E.Dawn😭
x2 :c
Porque sacaron a yan han
Fue lo mismo que pensé...
@@btsvv3589 no lo sacaron si no que esta inactivo por que problemas de salud, corriganme si lo dije mal (?
Without Yanan, the height difference between Wooseok and the rest is very obvious lmao at least with Yanan there was a "transition "
honestly it pains me to see the boys incomplete because of how *hard* they fought to keep Pentagon as 10 members just before debut. Props to all the the boys for stepping it up, especially Hui and Wooseok. (Boy Wooseok had to cover both his parts and e'dawn's which both are big parts). I just want all the boys back together again, I miss my boyos :((
No me cansaré de decirlo, extraño a E'Dawn y a Yanan 💔💔💔😭😭😭