Nagorno-Karabakh: Azerbaijan rejects accusations of ethnic cleansing | DW News
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 06. 2024
- They flee in cars, busses - and trucks. Vehicles choke the road leading out of Nagorno-Karabakh into Armenia. The people crammed inside have exhaustion etched on their faces. Many spent the night on the road. They fear they are leaving their ancestral lands for good.
Subscribe: czcams.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#NagornoKarabakh #Armenia #Azerbaijan
With Russia weakened due to its "special operation" in Ukraine, which was supposed to end in days or weeks, Turkey now dominates that area of the world. The Armenian prime minister knew Russia can no longer be a reliable partner, so he took steps toward the West, but he was too late and too slow.
Too little too late. They lose everything now because Russia wasn't a good ally.
on which route western countries gonna send help to Armenia??
@@anonymousman2521Training soldiers at the moment.
The Russians rightfully punished the arneanians
@@anonymousman2521 The level of delusion in that government thinking France is going to step in militarily and support them is insanity.
France can't help but even if they could (big if) like you said how are they going to get there?
The Azerbaijan spokesperson becomes rather shifty when trying to explain why UN observers aren't welcome to inspect the situation.
They were not called for during the first war. Why would they need them now?
This is not the first time.
Doesn’t sound shifty to me..
They do not want witnesses to Genocide.
UN Peacekeepers = United States. Besides, no one wants an foreign armed force in their territory.
Why you are so biased?
I consider that a specialist who has given information about what is happening in this region is a specialist in Armenia rather than in the Caucasus. He may servis for Armenian. In my opinion, if someone is a specialist on history or political needs to be objective and avoid from keeping a side
Armenians of Artsakh were under blockade not for 6-7 months, but more than 10 months. It started last December 2022.
33 years of occupation has ended now go cry a river
Those people fleeing know really well why they are fleeing… only we in Caucasus and former Soviet countries know why.
Two words: Ethnic Cleansing.
Because Azerbaijan has massacred Armenians half a dozen times
Azerbaijan started all the wars
@@rod9829 No but your parents know why ask them :) maybe your grandparents even better
@@mrSargi7 Oh yes they did kid they did, Armenia is innocent, long live the Great Ancient Empire sons of the Brave and strong! 😂
The Azerbaijan spokesperson has better English than half the Brits 🤣🤣
what this has to do with the core issue here its not even funny...
So what are you say man? What has that to do with anything? Racist pig
@@daved9302 😂😂😂😂😂 armenia 😂😂😂😂
@@daved9302nothing, and this is the perfect example of azeries intelligence, THEY HAVE NONE. All they know how and what to do, us murder , slatter, cut ears, tongues, throats, rapes and more horrific actions.
We cannot acpect intelligence from barbarains.
I talked to some of those people who fled, they pretty much make them sign a paper that they are leaving voluntarily before they can actually leave.
But before that they shelled them with bombs, terrified and blackmailed them. Now forcing Armenians to sign the paper that they "voluntarily leave" to show in un, security councils that Azerbaijan is very "friendly" - it's just Armenians are that "bad"
“Voluntarily” leaving after being blockaded for 9 months and shelled constantly. Right.
On how the tables are turned after 3 decades
It is a condition to let them to pass through
And who are you? Why should we believe you?
Put observers please
The Turkish emphasis upon NK being "internationally recognised" as part of Azerbaijan is hypocritical while they occupy part of Cyprus that is "internationally recognised" as Cypriot territory.
Cyprus is a turkish land , UN is a joke .
Syria
the republic of cyprus voted down a referandum to join with the north look up cypriot annan plan referandum 2004 the north voted %64 percent in favour while the south voted only %25 percent lol Turkey wants cyprus to unite.
@@Haykaana USA
Cyprus voted against making the Turkish occupation legitimate. @@HRLVR
No one mentions that 700 thousand Azerbaijanis became displaced since Armenia kept Karabakh under occupation till 2020. Only Armenian side of the story is covered.
No azeri admits why the war started.
Reminder: azeris massacred Armenians in Sumgayet Feb 1988
In Genje Nov 1989
In Baku Jan 1990
Operation ring in shahumyan.
Armenians in karabakh were forced to defend themselves, and all the land you lost was a result of counteroffensive against your attacks
Not mentioning your state level claims regarding Armenia internationally recognized territory.
Now after 2020 war , your all kind of lies were exposed.
stop making up numbers. the official soviet census of 1988 showed that 76 percent of the people living in the nagorno karabakh autonomous oblast were ethnic Armenians. this is a humanitarian crisis, once again caused by the turk. Many Armenians from diaspora will repatriate back to Armenia and it will thrive in the coming years. karabakh will be a cursed land to the turks and they will not thrive on it.
@@akhagop4123Gözünün içinə kimi yalan danışırsan. Sumqayıt hadisələri erməni qurğuları idi.
@@akhagop4123 Is this your way of rationalizing illegal invasions of another nation's internationally recognized territory not to mention trying to rationalize the ethnic cleansing of over 800,000 civilians?
Why are all you genocide/warcrimes/ethnic cleansing deniers all using the same exact arguments? You all go to the same seminar or something?
@@williamdavis9562where tf did 800,000 thousand come from illiterate. Artsakh had 94% Armenian population. And the people who were displaced probably wasn’t even 10.000. Yeah it’s sad, because we lived together, but you massacred Armenians in your country. Of course we were gonna be afraid to live with u.
30 years ago 1 million Azeris had to flee and now Armenians.
I am just curious why you picked an Armenian professor to get his opinion ? Shouldn't we listening a more objective person ? Secondly does the level of democracy really matter when one of those countries are illegally occupying the other one ? If democracy is more important than illegal occupation why all Westerns are trying to be good buddies with Saudi Arabia ? They don't have democracy, they don't have much human rights and they executed a journalist in their consulate in Istanbul... Are western values that straight forward or it can be adjusted according to their benefits ?
in short its just called "Double standards"
If western media tells you to go right always go left vise versa😂😂😂😂
DW: Talaat Pasha are you involved in ethnic cleansing?
TP: not at all ottoman empire is a multi cultural democracy, we love minorities!
DW: Thank you for these clarifications.
There are no limits how many genocides one ethnic can have. Apparently, there are no mechanisms that prevent the genocides. The question then, what’s the role of UN ?
The UN is useless.She's just a theatrical screen for all sorts of bad things.Remember the League of Nations of the thirties of the twentieth century...The same thing is happening now.
It’s all cosmetics. There’s no human rights, only interests. The world helped Ukraine because it was in America’s interests. But when Armenia, a pro-Western democracy, is attacked by Azerbaijan, a dictatorship, it’s not in the Wests interests so nothing is done. Azerbaijan is richer and has oil after all, and 80 million strong Turkey is much more important than 2 million Armenia (how many Americans can even point to them on a map). So, Armenians are abandoned, same reason why Rohingyas were abandoned in Myanmar. For both, no one cares as it’s not in any of the major powers interests to care. What’s happening in Ukraine is nothing about freedom, democracy or a rules based order, it’s all about geopolitical interests and the West getting a one up over Russia.
There are no human rights, no democracy, iit's all talks. Everything is based on interests. So called human values don't exist for majority. It's all talis. Storytelling
The UN is a toothless waste of money.
Also because Armenians chose to align with Russia. NK is also internationally recognized as Azerbaijan so this is far more complicated than just "interests." Also both Russia and Iran do not need more Western military bases next to their borders too.
When there is stability, the West is "bad" for myriad reasons. When war breaks out in the World, the West is still "bad" for standing idle. You can't have it both ways.
How about asking the up and coming, "Global South" to help out? They won't because it's not in their "interests" as well.
Once in history Britain helped armenians when it suggested that eastern Turkey should go to Armenia. But it was only words... In 1915 everybody has seen, what western help is worth.
Armenia did get the territory but it was soon taken back after the turks fought the brits, french, italians, armenians, greeks, and kurds, but still won😎
@@abthatdude7898🇦🇿❤️🇹🇷
Why would they help you when you cant help yourselves?
@@abthatdude7898Not really, most countries weren't interested so Britain was isolated in the war, and with war exhaustion at home they decided to give up the territory. You're trying to make it sound like some great victory of prowess but it wasn't.
British Armenian treachery
In 1991-92 ethnic Amenians killed around 30000 Azerbaijanis and expelled 1 million Azeri from Nagarno karabakhp and surrounding area.
That's a lie
@@nnn67670 that's not!!!
Some of your countrymen write there were 2000.000, then 600.000, then 700.000 Azeris. Why do you exaggerate the numbers?
@@lba6859 because it's not only Garabakh, before that in 1918-19, 1987-88 armenians killed Azerbaijanis
The historical facts are that thirty years ago It was Armenia which adopted aggression , violated international laws and not only forcibly occupied Nagorno Karabakh and many other regions of Azerbaijan but also committed ethenic cleasening of Azerbaijani people in that occupied areas.
Exactly. I find it funny how now the international community is paying attention to the conflict when its Armenians who are losing. Where was all this attention when Azeris needed it during the Khojlay Massacre? Western double standards at its finest. Karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan.
@@TheRepenter1996 Nagorno Karabakh belongs to Artsakh and Azerbajian belongs to Iran Inshallah 👍🇮🇷🇮🇷💪💪!!!
@@lou6749 sure bud.
Took 30 years But Azeris got their land back, alhamdullillah.
@@TheRepenter1996 This land is ARTSAKH not Azeri ALHAMDULILLAH,the Azeri land is originally Iran Persian inshallah ALHAMDULILLAH !!!
@@lou6749 reality in the ground has a different story.
But keep believing your delusions while Azerbaijan takes back and fixes the mess Armenians left behind in Nagorno Karabakh.
Allah bless Aliyev and the Azeri Army, ameen.
I'm just curious, were you DW guys so worried when almost 1 million Azerbaijan people forced to leave their land in 90s
Armenians didn't commit atrocities, azerbaijanies did.
Wake up to reality
In 1994, when Armenia invaded Karabakkh, they displaced 600.000 Azeris. No one is talking about that!
Still, that region is home to 120.000 Armenians. They should be taken care of and live as equals to other Azeris. Hope Azerbaijan can achieve that.
And most importantly Nagorno Karabakh has returned to its rightful owner Azerbaijan, the Western media has double-standardized their reporting, during the war of the 1990s when Armenian separatists occupied the legitimate territory of Azerbaijan the Western media was silent and when Azerbaijan took its rights back, thousands of sorrows and sympathies flooded into the separatists who were driven from the land they seized and occupied, What a ridiculous thing!
@@arjanasimov5933when is Azerbajian going to be returned to its rightful owner of Iran ?? Explain ..
@@lou6749where did you hear from.thats blasphemy
@@lou6749 Your statement is out of context, this is the legal status of legal ownership of nagorno karabakh land! It is explicit and clear that the international community has declared that Nagorno Karabakh is Azerbaijan and the separatist state of Artsakh is illegal in the eyes of the international community! That's my explanation!
@@lou6749 hahaha. 👍
Comparing this to Ukraine isn’t accurate. The Azeris didn’t invade a sovereign nation. Nagorno-Karabakh is internationally recognized Azeri territory.
So how's it different to Serbia regaining kosovo
Turkey the ally of Azerbaijan in this war did in Cyprus . Turkish double standards
Azerbaijan is still occupying internationally recognised Armenian territory. Is your memory shorter than a few years or is your dictator drugging you all?
Azerbaijan didnt exist when armenia was a country for many many centuries. It was originally armenian land
"we nothing to hide that's why we are hiding it." -someone with nothing to hide
U just can't live peacefully with terrorists.
Yes yes,
All of the Armenian terrorists must leave or be arrested
If DW was a thing back in 1917…
Headline: ‘The Ottoman Empire rejects accusations of ethnic cleansing’
DW 1900s Headline : "European Illegal Immigrants Rejects Accusations of Native American Ethnic Cleansing"
DW is the moutpiece not journalist
@@fajarkurniawan9434 DW 2030 Headline: "Americans Rejects Accusations of Second-Native American Ethnic Cleansing" 😆
Let's see, who owned the lands until the Russians came? Seljuk Turks Ottoman Turks and Azerbaijani Turkish Khans, Akkoyunlu Turks, Kara Koyunlu Turks, Safavid Turks, Avshar Turks, Qajar turks. Shall I list more? The land of the Turks for at least 900 years
You can go 2500 years ago, you will be shocked who owned the land.
They all came from the karakum desert in Central Asia. In terms of history not long ago
Im my humble opinion Karabah is an international recognized to be part and parcel of Azari land in which Arminians captured in more than 30 plus years ago and for that reason alone the proper Arminia should stop supporting the separates ethnic Armenian, thus seek lasting peace.
Stalin gave it to you stop pretending
These cultures been killing each other forever 😮💨
The Turkish genocide that started before 1915 is continuing.
Where was the entire world when not only Karabakh but also 7 regions around were occupied by Armenian separatists and over 1 million Azerbaijanis were forced to leave their homes in severe winter days with bare feet? These territory is internationally recognised Azerbaijan territory and Armenians leave this territory because it is not there land and they made genocide towards Azerbaijanis, please search Khojaly genocide. How many Azerbaijanis suffered Armenians anti - humanitarian activities? Armenians are afraid of their past deeds, the same may happen with them, but they forget that Azerbaijan is one of the most tolerant, peaceful and friendly countries.
No one talks about all the Armenians they kicked out of Baku in 94
You mean after Armenia invaded Nagorno Karabach in 1992 and ethnic cleansed 1milion Azerbaijanis? Not only from Nagorno Karabach but you also took 7 more regions bordering Karabach and no Azerbaijani was ever allowed to enter those regions again.
You mean after that? 🤔 Stop acting innocent 🙏🏼
@@yogzhub8245 yeah right after that why doesn’t anyone talk about the Armenians that used to live in Baku.
@@AG-tv7dv Well thats your answer, and why did you guys kick out Azerbaijanis from Yerevan? Majority of the population in Yerevan was Azerbaijanis in Soviet time.
Anyone can look up the information about this conflict. It's all on wiki nicely summarized.
Fact is - Azeris suffered way more than Armenians (numbers wise in deaths and displacement) and at the same time had their territory occupied for 30 years.
Impossible to hide the truth nowadays. Sorry
@@sergeybebenin no one’s hiding truth besides Azeris and nobody needs your sorry
Infernal Turks helping the invading Afgans , bot none helping the ancestral Armenians...very strange...
Armenians decided wrong, they choose Russia not the West according to the interview.
What’s the difference between NK and Kosovo? Azeri oil money…
The difference: “120,000 Armenians in NK fighting to set up a Banana Republic surrounded by Azerbaijan versus 2 million Albanians living in the Republic of Kosovo safe from recorded murderous Serbs ! The Banana Republic is counting on surviving on handouts from Western countries ! In reality a Banana Republic of 120,000 people can not be a viable State fulfilling its needs . So the hidden agenda is to have it join Armenia!!! That is take land internationally recognized as Azerbaijan and give it to Armenia which by the way after 30 years of independence still can NOT feed itself and lives off of handout from French US and Russia!!!
Can United Nations send blue helmets ?
Or what is the use of UN today?
Debate climate change with oil executives and they promise that they will surely transition to oiil ..hmmm .. I MEAN transition to green energy.
RU will deny the deployment of blue helmets and furthermore the EU does not want to anger Aliyev. Otherwise he won't let them buy his gas
LGBQT More priority....BesidesUN says that land belongs to Azerbaijan they can do what they want in there land including taking out terrorists.
UNITED NOTHING. Oil and gas smell good
Disarming the Artsakh Defense Army was an Act of Ethnic Cleansing!!!!! And Dismantling Democracy in Nagorno Karabakh is also an act of Ethnic Cleansing!!!!!
Ronald Suny needs to pull his head out of his back and actually do a bit of research before going on live tv and being one sided
What does F1 do to show Azserbajan is screwing over a smaller country? Nothing!
Formula 1 is corrupt sport. Like Azéri. Rally is beter
Because they are 'stomach" people-all those from f1. Everything that interests them- money and pleasure. It doesn't interest them that the cost of their pleasure is lives of innocent people..
They pump russian petrol recycled there.
Heartbreaking
Same thing will happen if Russian army leave Ukraine
not at all. lands didnt belong to them in the 1st place
Do you know 30 years ago?
And lands didn't belong to Azeris either@@agustinenzoa4447
Be quiet 😒
Only 40000 Armenian people living here
Azerbaijan's Taqqiya: that's not ethnic cleansing.
I have a question for armenians and their supporters that if UN and most states, even the prime minister of the Armenia Republic recognized Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan why you consider that it belongs to Armenia although there are many historical facts ? I think it may be related to not having historical knowledge.
Really creepy guy this azeri official
JEALOUS MUCH?
7:15 Russia was only obligated to protect the Armenian territory, it did not include the occupied areas.
What were they thinking believing moscow will help them? Remember, no one will help you if you have nothing to offer, sad but always true
Azeris, have the upper hand, big time!! None is going to help the Armenians. They have nothing to offer. No matter the protests in Yerevan or whatever they do. They are going to have to accept it or else...Even Israel supplies Azerbaijan with armament.
Thank you very much for bringing up the facts
And is sad but I don't think it is safe for armenians yo stay
Why western media were celebrating Armenia 's victory in 1994 but crying now? I think the only solution to the problem is autonomy under Azeri sovereignty.
3:00 This azeri official said people have not been forced to leave but the war and starvation in the blockade they created in Artsakh for 10 months before they attacked them on 19th September to 21st was nothing??? how come this misinformation that Armenians of Artsakh who lived there for thousands of years and have churches dating from the 4th century suddenly decided to leave? They are in grave danger and what Aliev's regime poses upon them is nothing short of GENOCIDE.
Azerbaijan is just talk talk now, nothing committed in international treaty.
Azerbaijan is ridding high over a military operation over a minority.
Past promises made by Azerbaijanis to Nagorno-Karabakh have been unceremoniously u-turned.
International community (in particular EU) must force Azerbaijan to commit assurances in writing, in international treaty.
Do note Azerbaijan is an authoritarian regime, not far from Putin’s regime.
How many treatys did the armenians respected in 33 years of occupation.justice served to armenians
@@ozzyozboy6471Justice is when you commit a crime to correct a crime? An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind. Azerbaijan will always be blind under a dictator.
@@cianmcguire5647terrible analogy. An eye for an eye does not leave the world blind.
@@AtomicVoid95 And a lack of thought does not limit speech clearly.
Internationally what? What about UN conventions about Armenian troops leaving from Nagorno Karabakh and stoping occupation territories of Azerbaijan??? Were not the things internationally?))) or international things for you are what you interested in?
DW is very bias aganst Azerbijan. one sided views in this puppit show
UN, did nothing- watched when Azeri Turks been expelled thirty years ago. Only been giving 30mins get out.
Why this media not looking in Palestine, kashmir, Iraq,Syria, Afghanistan, Yemen
6:00 this guy speaks the truth.
This is like saying german speaking people of Alsace should run to Germany when France got those lands back after WW2, because there would be ethnic cleansing. There is no precedence of ethnic cleasing or anything like that in Azerbaijani history. Europe and these so called professors should be ashamed of slapping this expectance of ethnic cleansing on them. It is actually what Armenians did when they captured NK in 91.
Azeri doesn’t have much history to begin with maybe that’s why.
so what is the accusation based on?@@AG-tv7dv
Thats not the reason, the reason is because he is lying.
Azerbaijan has an extensive history of ethnic cleansing and rhetoric from the state suggesting they will do it again.
Who's claiming it? Pointless conversation without any proof
Armenians flee and replace with Azerbaijani Turks in Armenians populated areas . These Turks are too brilliant coz nobody do anything in this situation
Put ur money where ur mouth is.
Very partial analysis!
1) karabakh is ajarbaijan sovereign territory... Half a million arazi people ethnically cleansed in 1994 - no mention of it ...
2) Blaming Russia because it is busy in Ukraine, but west is doing to protect ethnic Armenian since 8 month of blockade??
This land belongs to azarbaijan but ethnic Armenian must be protected under international law ...
Just do a quick google search and your points will be refuted
Also just because it's recognised territory of Azerbaijan it doesn't give them right to kill innocent and do ethnic cleansing. That's exactly what u are doing now
International Law - good joke 😂
@@oneway1119no cleansing is taking place, they are emigrating with the coordination from Armenia. No one is forcing them to leave
Also why would Russia defend Armenia when they defected to the western camp at least the Azeris have been honest about their position towards Russia from the very start
@@heyyo162 No cleansing? Azeri forces starved women and children for nine months. Is the the action of a peaceful nation?
We need to ensure that the male artsakh defense forces get a safe conduit across to Armenia as well as per the agreement in order for peace to be restore. Both sides committed atrocities in the past no more bloodshed
@@kzgntosbaga6255 then that doesn't help peace cause every male of fighting age was part of the defense. Are they going to imprison all?
@@kzgntosbaga6255So by your logic, every fighting age male is a terrorist cause they’re ere all apart of the defense force.
@@denisships2861 the leaders should be arrested actually, but I doubt it'll happen, since western countries would have a heart attack then.
@@denisships2861that’s why Azerbaijan asked Armenia on 09/11/2020 to take all the separatists and troops from Nagorno Karabakh. In there years they didn’t listen and now they’re facing the reality.
Did this "professor" just said "unprovoked"? So killing 6 people by laying mines on public roads is no longer considered provocation? Sooo much bias towards a country who rightfully liberated its own land, it makes me sick.
Are the ethnic Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh Azerbaijani citizens or Armenian citizens?
This is a new Holocaust
we Americans stands besides you Armenians
I hope my government act and do something to help Armenians
Lol yeah right, another illegal war perhaps?
And just like that your comments dissapear. Good job youtube or DW!
I thought the ethnic Armenians fired the first shot.
Ukrain have gas and oil, Armenia doesn’t 😂🤦🏻♂️
Well, ethnic Azerbaijanis we’re doing the same thing Thirty and plus years ago I mean so many things getting more clear, the more and better military you have that’s how things go Azerbaijanis got stronger militarily that’s it
Actually they're doing nothing smiliar to what the Amenians did to them in the 1990s.
Armenia invades Nagarno Karabakh in the 1990s: Ethnically cleanses 800,000 civilians.
Azerbaijan reinvades Nagarno Karabakh in 2020: 20 civilians die.
Nothing near the same thing.
for the last 30 years Azervaijan, being supported by US Army, who trained them , then by Israel army who support them by drones, and been trained and supported by Turkish army, which is NATO , and they also use Syrian terrorist in a war 2020 and they are a 10 million population against of 2 million of Armenians, resistant , and defend 44 days in 2020 war, totaly left alone in this war, without any outside support.
You’re absolutely wrong, Nagorno-Karabakh is ethnic ancient Armenian country during Soviet Union. It was autonomy republic like an Nakhichevan, which also was giving to Azerbaijani by Russian bolsheviks ,to create a new republic. Learn the history first, before you speak, because Armenian was dividing an 4 pieces during WWA1 , the mystery of history, basically the same thing happening today between British Turkey and Russian problem then and now.
@@williamdavis9562 800k Azeris in Artsakh? Almost sounds false considering there were until recently on 120k Armenians there. If you’re talking about the population swaps of 30 years ago sure. We can talk for hours tit for tat. That’s doesn’t change the fact that this is ethnic cleansing.
@@ding0792 so 800,000 Azerbaijanis or not ethnically cleanse cleaned back in the 90s
Just google Ramil Safarov and you will understand what are the levels of anti-Armenianism in Azerbaijan. In no other country would that ever happen...
Google Zori Balayan and how he explained killing an azeri child in Karabakh. Or you can find everything in video about killed Azeris by Armenians on 26/02/1992 in KHOJALY.
Ramil Safarov killed an Armenian for insulting our flag and country on purpose. This is an ordinary act from an Armenian.
@@norvin46 I googled him and apparently he was freed from suspicion by interpol. On the other hand Safarov was made a hero and normal people in Azerbaijan find his action justified. First of all, if you read his confession it is obvious that the flag story was fabricated. But even if it were true, in no other nation does this justify murder (especially in the sleep of the victim).
@@norvin46 The massacre in Khojaly was of course horrific and a war crime but didn't the pogroms in Baku and Sumgait happen first?
Of course both counties have been involved in atrocities during war, but again I think the case of Safarov and the fact that it happened during peace time, is unthinkable for any civilized nation.
What would EU and US do if Serbia for example tries to reclaim its separatist region of Kosovo, same as Azerbaijan did with Nagorno?
Both Eu and US recognize Karabakh as Azerbaijani lands though
@@mailio4536 since when? There's a literal UNGA resolution recognizing Karabakh as Azerbaijan's territory (UNGA/10693). France is the only EU member that voted against it.
@@fahadahaf i meant Azerbaijan, brainfart. my bad lol
As I understand this is Azerbaijani land invaded by Armenia with support of Russia.
the young ones are kidnapped, killed or tortured. Turkish authorities are very good at it. no humanity in them
No they are leaving on their own. Armenians refused every compromise, all or nothing. They are getting nothing.
they leave because they know Azeris will murder them@@almazchati4178
We didnt consider armenians as human
Turkish authorities have a lot of experience of genocide against the Armenians.
Look up Baku and Sumgait pogroms and Ramil Safarov. No co-living is possible.
Right, just like Khojaly massacre in 1992, mass killings and deportations of Azeris in late 80s in Armenia.
@@chesstictacs3107i have yet to see one piece of evidence for this false claim
Turkisg genocide of Armenians 1915 onwards.
Did the older lady really say they are like a dogs?
Armenians should be thankful to Azerbaijanis because they didn’t massacre them like Armenians done 30 years ago. We will never forget Hocali massacre done by Armenians.
What goes around comes around. Thousands of Azeris have been uprooted from their homes decades ago . Civilians can stay or go . If I were them I could stay and comply with the Azerbaijani laws and take care of my family. At least the spoilers separatist have been defeated.
What goes around comes around??
Azerbaijan started the first war and also did many progroms and expelled al Armenians from Azerbaijan.
Neither side is innocent.
we love Arzebaijan
🌹
9 months blockade and starvation - no such a case.
Artsakh people being asked by azeri soldiers with AK pointed at them if they're leaving their homes voluntarily and they of course say "yes" - no such a case.
Azerbaijan NEEDS to be investigated lol 😂
Would say rather than standing the humiliation of an autocratic regime at Baku , the proud Armenians choose otherwise , Any nation bowed to an authoritarian regime must stand up and take the hard decisions !!
lol proud ? By running away? Real proud would have been fight to last man. Not running away
@@Leo-sk3qc So says who is wholly protected by Putin and Erdo and Israel ..!! always got beaten badly when one-on-one .. !!!!..
@@HKasparyan nope it was 1 on 1 there was no one to help Azeris
@@Leo-sk3qc .. living on Pluto !!! And pls remain as such ..!!
@@HKasparyan if Turks got involved they would wipe Armenia off the map like b4, and if Russia get involved u will become armenSSR Again
When was the last time the Turks told the truth?
We told the truth, we will finish leftovers
Why nobody talks about what armenians did 30years ago? Why you western countries don't care what happened to those who lived in Karabagh and other regions surrounded it? Because you don't care humanitarian aid you just want your partner armenia to take benefit. Let me remind you 30 years ago armenians chased away all Azerbaijani people in winter without cars or supplies, my husbant was a baby at that time his mother talks how horrible the situation was when they left Karabagh with a baby without any vehicle in winter by walking and hiding from the armed enemies.
Well one thing is certain. Russia looked weak and helpless during all this.
Nagorno Karabakh just small part of bigger plan of neo Ottoman. Cyprus, Khasmir, Sinji Ang, liberation of whole Palestine land
Because Karabakh is not their land, they know that and that is why they leaving our land. Karabakh's real people return back 30 years later. Now Armenians leave Karabakh on car but 1990s Azerbaijanis left on barefoot. That's difference.
We can talk tit for tat about Azeris/ Armenians being forced to leave their lands. However, Armenians have been in Karabakh for centuries. Will you bulldoze the churches and monasteries to hide this? Your weak lies only show everyone the lack of legitimacy in all of Azerbaijan’s claims. Azerbaijani identity only dates back to 200 years ago. The sad truth is your dictator needs the Armenians as an enemy to maintain power.
Application support? Really?
Armenian professor from the US is not an expert. He is far away from the region and supporting one side because of his origin.
This is what ethnic Azerbaijanis experienced in the war of the 1990s when Armenian separatists occupied the legitimate territory of Azerbaijan, killing and expelling ethnic Azerbaijanis from their homelands, the legitimate land of Azerbaijan recognized by the United Nations and the international community, this is a fact! And now Nagorno Karabakh has returned to its rightful owner, Azerbaijan!
Karabagh was never Azerbaijani. Armenians were there almost 3000 years . Azerbaijan is only 100 years old country. Karabakh is Armenia. Oil and gas played big role here. Corrupt EU and UN to blame. Shame to humanity that allow terrorist and dictatorship countries become to power.
Land Stalin gifted you
@@sirwhitemeat9785 The world and the international community recognize that, Whatever reason you put forward, the facts speak that legally Nagorno Karabakh has returned to its rightful owner, Azerbaijan!
@@varujanavedyan168 Ask the world and the international community on what basis Nagorno Karabakh is Azerbaijan!
@@varujanavedyan168 >Armenians were there almost 3000 years . Azerbaijan is only 100 years old country
Tell us about independent state named "Armenia" before 1918? And spare me your BS using ethnicity vs state years counts comparasion.
International law, sovereignty, integrity of a country according to international law, and the war against separatist-terrorist actions have nothing to do with dictatorship or democracy. Being elected democratically doesn't allow or give a right to Armenian leadership to occupy and terrorize azerbaijani people who have a leader who is "elected" undemocratically.
7:46 "Suddenly without provocation, on September 19th, the Azerbaijanis attacked". Is this man serious? Isn't occupying the land of a country that is internationally recognized as hers provocative enough?
This is how Ukraine war started ..by some $tupid separatist..saying this land belong to Russia …when clearly it was not ! …same way here …karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan….if you are Armenian & live there …stay ,take the passport & live peacefully…but if you think or someone else washed your brain telling you separatist ideas …leave to Armenia. ..& also live peacefully …
Mr. Ronald Suny is of the opinion that we should go in because of "democracy". Ok, but isn't Nagorno-Karabakh internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan? What will we do there? How long should we be there? And what is the end goal?
Will we go into Catalan because they voted to be independent? Or any other region that sees itself as its own state? Or only the democratic one?
It's a sh** show and it's going to get worse. I don't have any answers to these questions but one thing I do know for sure is that one way or another we will be blamed by one side or both no matter what we do or don't.
Those who are not real citizens of karabakh they are going back. Who are real they should stay.
The guy in the university spoke like a average guy in the street than a prof. 250% biased full of hate, and full of BS
"Azerbaijan has nothing to hide, but we don't think there's any need for international observers" How so?
It's Azeri land why are you trying to stir up the situation
Excellent point.
@@deepseashark5951 It's not the land that matters it's the homeland. Educate yourself if your dictator fails to do so.
Genocide is best carried out without witnesses. The Azerbaijanis have learned from how their Turkish allies dealt with the Armenians.
They kicked out 700k azeris from karabakh and 7 surrounding regions by 1994 and no azerbaijany left in there! Its a karma
WHOLE population of Karabakh was 189 000 and they kicked out 700 000? 🤣
@@delta_glider4362 read the timing. Up untill 1994 total population of occupied karaoakh and occupied 7 regions around it were near 800k. After occupation went down to 150k no azeris left there
In 1987-1994 when azerbaijanis had to leave Karabah and Armenia, they were leaving bare footed thru mountains in fear of being killed. People in Xodjali was actually killed by arnenians. Now Armenians leaving in a comfortable cars and in peace.
so this man admits that this was all pashinyans fault by default
Thank you for covering this. I only hope Armenian and Greeks can visit our ancestral lands some day in peace and safety. Last time my family was in Eastern Turkey we were spit on. I can only imagine how much worse its become with Turkik-Azeris openly killing natives of the region.
And the armenian are innocents ?? Get up the high horses dude ...
you try to kill people in their homeland and except them not to fight back?
Yes, my brother, very true
This is hilarious, there are a lot of people from armenia who work illegally in Turkey. They even work as nanny. Why do they work in Turkey then?
@@gaffuraltntop8723 wow, just because you said this, we believed you. Any facts?
I’m just watching.
I don’t think any Armenian in Azerbaijan is going to be alive….. if don’t leave or escape from this country…. the president? I don’t trust him… talk show 😂.
Is interesting about the Azerbaijan leaving in Armenia if they stay or decide run away
And you call this racist a proff? Fire him!
This is evidence why Genocides must be recognized by the perpetrators. Can you imagine Germany attacking Israel? The whole world will be in arms. It should be the same reaction when Turks are attacking Armenians. Unfortunately, the world needs to learn from repeating the history
Why would the united state help Armenia when they are allies with Russia and also the western powers are helping Ukraine, so that’s most of the resources that are willing to give in foreign aid
There have been several hints and one overt admission from US and German diplomats that the west mediated an agreement between Armenia and Azerbaijan where Armenia would officially recognize Artsakh as Azerbaijani territory and in turn Azerbaijan will respect the rights of the Armenians living there. Armenia officially did this not long ago, but Azerbaijan broke their promise. Now the west needs to prove it's a reliable security partner to save face.
Yes UN should arrest killers of half million azaris in 94