I don't think they had a graduation concept, they just called a member leaving graduation to make it seem cool, but in reality only 3 members left while the group was active (Soyoung, Bekah, and Kahi) the rest left when AS was on hiatus
I really want to clap for Raina, she literally sang like 60% of the whole song for Because Of You. She even sang the chorus part, I swear she is one of the best kpop main vocalists.
BEKAH IS THE COOLEST MEMEBER OF AS... nothing will change that. Kahi and Bekah are the best members in as... soo sad, after Bekah and Kahi both graduated, As has been falling and deteriortating
Bekah will always be the coolest member of AS. Truly a gem in the kpop industry. I felt bad for Jooyeon during "Because of You." She looked like she was going to break down in tears. Bekah
It's my absolute favorite. I grew out of Kpop, and thought the songs I used to love were trash now. But not "Because Of You". I will defend that song to the death.
i will never forget BEKAH from my heart. because she's my favoarite member of the group. i want to cry when i watch this video and others. BEKAH's smlie make me smile too. i don't want to think about her graduation. that's make me feel sad. no one can rap better than her. her rap style is so smart. BEKAH, you'll always be in my heart. so i love you ♥
After School now. Soyoung Graduated in 2009 Bekah Graduated in 2011 Kahi Graduated in 2012 Jooyeon Graduated in 2015 Jungah Graduated in 2016 Uee Graduated in 2017 Nana Raina Lizzy E-Young Kaeun Are what remain of After School now
I can see it in Bekah's eyes.... when she raps her verse in because of you, bekahs like as she struts " SWAG SWAG SWAG SWAG, FUCK YALL LEEET ME SHOW YALL HOW TO REALLY DO IT BEFORE I LEAVE BITCHESS"
I think it was stupid to send Lizzy and E-Young backstage for "Because of You", they should had rearranged the choreography and song to include them. But again, that's on Pledis.
I found After School when they released Flashback and I swear to god, everytime I saw their old videos I fell in love with Bekah more and more and hahahaha I'm crying RN bc ;-; I wish she wouldn't have left Y____Y
It's sad how groups just disband or leave because there just sick of being a Kpop and stuff I miss a lot of this group and other groups that disbanded.
I’m a SONE and Taeyeon bias but I’ll never disregard the fact that Uee and Afterschool is my introduction to and “first love” of Kpop. I don’t have a favorite lineup because stating so would mean leaving out a member, every member is Afterschool. I wish this group was still around, they are so cool and underrated.
They had so much charisma, than the other kpop all girl group. That one reason why they are my favorite group. I do not know them that much, one reason is because I did not have a laptop.
샴푸 몇 번 봤다고 알고리즘이 세상 모든 샴푸 다 추천해주네
쯧쯧
당신의 TS
샴푸는 엘라스틴. 만두는 고향 ㅎ
the algorithm is right to do it
For me, this line up was the best. I just wished they didnt do the graduation concept. I miss Bekah :(
The only thing good about the graduating concept is that the band will keep moving forward when others will break.
But the graduation system just went on and now they never had a comeback. Damn Pledis.
I don't think they had a graduation concept, they just called a member leaving graduation to make it seem cool, but in reality only 3 members left while the group was active (Soyoung, Bekah, and Kahi) the rest left when AS was on hiatus
Kahi told Pledis to stop adding member after the release of Because Of You, but Pledis kept adding members so she left the group.
This lineup was the most iconic as far as After School goes. Once Kahi and Bekah left, it all went downhill
I really want to clap for Raina, she literally sang like 60% of the whole song for Because Of You. She even sang the chorus part, I swear she is one of the best kpop main vocalists.
BEKAH IS THE COOLEST MEMEBER OF AS... nothing will change that. Kahi and Bekah are the best members in as... soo sad, after Bekah and Kahi both graduated, As has been falling and deteriortating
First Love was an awesome song though
I agree i like the old member better but i do like their new songs
It's sad how they just went after they graduated i wish all kpop groups don't have to leave.
And now they're coming back!
They were never the same group after Kahi and Bekah left. It was the beginning of the end.
This is the last performance of Because of You with it's original line up (7 members 2009)
Bekah will always be the coolest member of AS. Truly a gem in the kpop industry. I felt bad for Jooyeon during "Because of You." She looked like she was going to break down in tears. Bekah
i miss this generation of kpop:'(
Because of you definitely 1 of the best kpop song ever imo.....
It's my absolute favorite. I grew out of Kpop, and thought the songs I used to love were trash now. But not "Because Of You". I will defend that song to the death.
SPILL BESTIE
Jooyeon was holding back tears through the entire Because of You performance. You can especially see it during her second line. :(
best line-up, Shampoo is tailor-made for After School, as well as Because of you. Both super catchy songs.
어릴땐 몰랐는데 커서보니 가희 너무 예쁘다❤ 베카 랩도 쫀득하고 이때가 좋았지 ..
2023 and im still here . miss them so much
i will never forget BEKAH from my heart. because she's my favoarite member of the group. i want to cry when i watch this video and others. BEKAH's smlie make me smile too. i don't want to think about her graduation. that's make me feel sad. no one can rap better than her. her rap style is so smart. BEKAH, you'll always be in my heart. so i love you ♥
This makes me miss Kahi and Bekah
And now they're coming back!!!
After School now.
Soyoung Graduated in 2009
Bekah Graduated in 2011
Kahi Graduated in 2012
Jooyeon Graduated in 2015
Jungah Graduated in 2016
Uee Graduated in 2017
Nana
Raina
Lizzy
E-Young
Kaeun
Are what remain of After School now
Derek Phan Lizzy 2018
하나같이 이렇게 다 이쁘냥.........
I can see it in Bekah's eyes.... when she raps her verse in because of you, bekahs like as she struts " SWAG SWAG SWAG SWAG, FUCK YALL LEEET ME SHOW YALL HOW TO REALLY DO IT BEFORE I LEAVE BITCHESS"
Raina always sounds perfect at the end :)
애브터스쿨 영원하라~~~♡♡♡
I love after school soo much never would I ever thought that they will ended 😭😭😭
Don't know what you mean by "end" but they haven't disbanded yet.
it's 2017 and AS is still on a whole different level, their songs have soul, BEKAH i miss you, AFTER SCHOOL i miss you :(
Kahi's speaking voice is really sweet! and damn gorgeous Bekkah -_-
I end up crying in watching this video again..I really love after school so much :( T.T
still my favorite group in 2017.
I think it was stupid to send Lizzy and E-Young backstage for "Because of You", they should had rearranged the choreography and song to include them. But again, that's on Pledis.
I found After School when they released Flashback and I swear to god, everytime I saw their old videos I fell in love with Bekah more and more and hahahaha I'm crying RN bc ;-; I wish she wouldn't have left Y____Y
Missing you // still listening 2018❤️
Quiero volverlas a ver, espero verlas algún día de nuevo juntas bailando y cantando esta hermosa canción
fans screamed Bekah a lot. i can hear it. T__T they surely miss her.. always stay in my heart ~
I miss all the graduated members.
Me too :(
They all looK freaking BEAUTIFUL!
베카 매력적이다
i miss bekah, it took a lot on all of them when she left, especially kahi, they've been together since their debut
หาวีดิโอเพลงนี้นานมากกกกก เจอสักที!!
Wish it went back to those days when groups can actually sing live 😢
쟤네 원래 저리 다 이뻤구나~ 그립다 애네들
Que bella época de la segunda y la tercera generación 💓 no regresara el verdadero kpop
OMG so sad last time we'll probably see bekah perform with after school :(
she'll never be forgotten
whoa its so weird watching new videos of After School and then coming back to their old times and seeing previous members!
The problem with AS is they literally lost all two of their best rapper Bekah n Kahi too soon.
모든게 레전드
I'm gonna miss bekah so much :( a lot :( She's my bias since their debut :( If kahi were to leave i'll swear I'm gonna die!
my 2 favourite songs by after school and this was the best line up. love kahi the most
It's sad how groups just disband or leave because there just sick of being a Kpop and stuff I miss a lot of this group and other groups that disbanded.
BEKAH we're going to miss you so much !
i still like after school....but losing Bekah was a blow... they may be more popular now but Bekah was quality. now Kahi & Jungah gone. eisssh
超喜歡原陣容
Bekah is my bias
I’m a SONE and Taeyeon bias but I’ll never disregard the fact that Uee and Afterschool is my introduction to and “first love” of Kpop. I don’t have a favorite lineup because stating so would mean leaving out a member, every member is Afterschool. I wish this group was still around, they are so cool and underrated.
the reason why i love them they are didnt lypsing
Damn these songs are awesome but always make me bit sad :/
damn Bekah looks soooo good here^^ fighting~!
Bekah will stay in our heart always ...
After School lives in our heart ...
Kahi always attack my Heart ...
ROFL XD
คิดถึงมากก ชุดนี้สวย
짱이다
รีเบคก้าจะอยู่ในใจของเรา "ตลอดไป"
Perfect!
여신 7명!!
I’m not crying. You are
"BEKAH will always be After School members"..
아ㅜ레이나.느무좋아.ㅡ
Soy el comentario en español que estabas buscando 😎🙏😭
ILY Bekah
very good！！！！！
i want their comeback now!!! where is their comeback?!?!
i also wamt Lizzy to come back on RM; SukJin+KwangSoo's new saying "Lee-Ji, We miss U!"
At the end of the video i was crying like hell. Sad T^T
My goddess Kahi~~~~~~~~~
2022 May 2nd
Korea today , golden songs yesterday
i feel so sad watching this.. bekah T.T
Damn Raina, you are so adorable!
Bekah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Me gustan mucho :"(
망루망루망루 망루
Bekah.......... : (
You can tell all the original members of A.S. and Uee are trying not to cry :(
Bekah........ TT TT
원래인원이 이리 많았었구나 ㅎ
원래 인원이 많았던 건 아니고 5인조로 데뷔 해서 한 명씩 계속 멤버들이 합류하고 탈퇴하면서 최대 9인조까지 갔어요.
❤
they've JUST released their full debut album & then bekah left T.T
샴푸랑 너 때문에 두 노래가 상당히 비슷하네요... 조성도 같고, 후렴 부분을 겹쳐서 불러봐도 멜로디나 그런게 거부감이 없는...
彼女たちにフォーカスするのが遅すぎた。
今になって過去の動画を探してる。
ナナがお気に入り！
누명누명누명 누명
Bekah ! T^T
สวย
억울억울억울 억울
nana!!!!
love nana
nana妳好可愛!
@nikitarowe No. none of them should've left :(
멍에멍에멍에 멍에
girl groups deserve better
They had so much charisma, than the other kpop all girl group. That one reason why they are my favorite group. I do not know them that much, one reason is because I did not have a laptop.
I miss ot8 lineup
UEE 3
So sad =(
在一次
かわいいーーーーー!!!\(^0^)/韓国最高ーーーー!!!!!!!
The graduation concept was the worst! AfterSchool had so much potential and they wasted it :(
Pledis… you really screwed yourself over by letting this group go.
What were they talking about
and now 2017 uee f
graduated...what will happen to as 🤤🤤🤤
@fendy88ful she wants to go to hawaii and pursue her dreams as a designer
세계 최초의 사건을 저지르는 거야