Similarities Between Persian and Malay

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 4. 01. 2018
  • In this edition, Mahtab and Shafiq explore the similarities between Malay and Persian (Farsi). Although one is an Indo-European and the other an Austronesian language, there are many similarities between the two languages, mainly due to historical links between Malaysia and the Middle East. Malay is a major language of the Austronesian family spoken in Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore and also used in some parts of the Philippines as a trading language. Persian (Farsi) is one of the Western Iranian languages and belongs to the Indo-European language family. It is primarily spoken in Iran, Afghanistan, and Tajikistan, as well as regions which were historically part of Greater Iran. It is written in the Persian alphabet, a modified variant of the Arabic script. Persian has influenced many neighboring languages, and historically it was the first language in the Muslim world to put an end to Arabic's monopoly on writing in Islamic countries, and Persian poetry became the court tradition in many eastern courts. The Persian influence in the Malay Peninsula go back to many centuries ago. Many of the words found in common between Malay and Persian are the result of traders and merchants who historically created a strong connection between the two nations.
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 561

  • @aqimjulayhi8798
    @aqimjulayhi8798 Před 5 lety +43

    Malays don't really call 'port' as 'bandar' these days. 'Bandar' in Malay is a city or town, while the word for port is 'pelabuhan'. However, it does take you back in history when the old Malay kingdoms had trading ports that traded with Arabs, Persians, Portuguese and etc, and eventually the meaning of 'bandar' slowly progressed from 'port' to 'town/city'.

    • @mieaab
      @mieaab Před 2 lety +4

      The word shah bandar definitely means port master

  • @kerbaukewek8862
    @kerbaukewek8862 Před 5 lety +187

    Many Malaysian themselves got confuse. The reason why Malay got so many Indian's rooted word is not because of Indian origin people in Malaysia. The first language influenced Malay language is actually Sanskrit, back when the Malays were practicing Hindu with Buddha's influence religion. Then when Malays converted to Islam, a lot of Arabic words start to influence Malay language. And lastly our modern words are influenced by English because of British colonisation.

    • @ibnuabdrahim
      @ibnuabdrahim Před 5 lety +30

      biasa la puak chola nak claim sejarah tanah melayu

    • @suciretnowati8219
      @suciretnowati8219 Před 5 lety +38

      Malaysian is austronesian. Malay is not an indo european language. It has no indian root. Only indian loanwords, just like indonesian language.

    • @thecutiecat4671
      @thecutiecat4671 Před 5 lety +6

      @@suciretnowati8219 indon lang is from malay

    • @thecutiecat4671
      @thecutiecat4671 Před 5 lety +7

      @Jacky Phantom malay is austronesia. I suggest u to check video " melayu dari mana" on utube

    • @safuwanfauzi5014
      @safuwanfauzi5014 Před 5 lety +7

      @Jacky Phantom although we have loan word but some of them have 2 both in Malay and Arabic, that because Islam, that why Rencong, Surat ulu writing script replace by Arabic called jawi, it make read Quran easy, example tubuh in malay badan in Arabic, haiwan Arabic = malay is binatang, babi(Filipino also Austronesian babui) khinzir, pusara=kubur, tentera=askar an many more is because arabic is 2nd language before English in pre-colonial, just today malay use English word but already exist in malay like so, then, you, i, infrastructure=prasarana, intitusi=pranata, tular=viral many2 more

  • @divaaa1955
    @divaaa1955 Před 3 lety +17

    Hope this channel can put more l about Malay language. Love from Malaysia-Brunei 🇲🇾❤🇧🇳

  • @alv2724
    @alv2724 Před 6 lety +207

    Similarities between Indonesia and Malaysia. 100% would understand each other

    • @zak.886
      @zak.886 Před 5 lety +28

      Vremm Indonesian and Malay is the same language Indonesian is merely a dialect of Malay

    • @safruls676
      @safruls676 Před 5 lety +18

      @@zak.886 You are right. As far as I know, Malay language in Malaysia came from High Malay spoken in royal courts in Sumatera and Malay peninsula while Indonesian derived from Common or Low Malay spoken by traders merchants and common people.

    • @zidanraihan403
      @zidanraihan403 Před 5 lety +42

      Its actually.. Malay can fully understand indonesian.. But indonesian can sometime confuse with some malay word..

    • @yoniffafaniriano3397
      @yoniffafaniriano3397 Před 5 lety +14

      Zak yes, actually indonesian is like "modified malay" with some loanwords from indonesian local languages

    • @RyanMattjik
      @RyanMattjik Před 5 lety +1

      @@yoniffafaniriano3397 and also Dutch

  • @Mustafa9474
    @Mustafa9474 Před 6 lety +184

    Persian has so many similarities with many languages in northwest Asia and the Indian Ocean because it was the language of trade and diplomacy when Muslims dominated the Silk Road and maritime Indian Ocean trade. Arabic was the language of theology and science but Persian was the language of politics.

    • @servantofallah1698
      @servantofallah1698 Před 6 lety +11

      Muhammad Mustafa half of Persian vocabulary and words are Arabic

    • @servantofallah1698
      @servantofallah1698 Před 6 lety +9

      alireza monemi whole lotta bullshit, he said Arabic was the language of theology you whimp

    • @JavidShah246
      @JavidShah246 Před 6 lety +2

      Dhu mammut, if thats all he said then its ok pimp

    • @zareengulabi9569
      @zareengulabi9569 Před 6 lety +6

      Deborah Immanuel Look Arabs didn't invade Persia.I dont want to get into religion But Persia had great empire if Arabs would try to forcefully get into Persian land n establish their belief system than the the Arabs would all be killed by Persian army. That's the proof that Arabs never invaded Persia. They traded goods in Persian markets N that's hw the languages were traded to. Arabs use to work in Persia n study their just like Persians did in Iraq. No1 invaded any1.

    • @servantofallah1698
      @servantofallah1698 Před 6 lety +1

      Zareen GULABI al qadisiyah

  • @nextneonusantara
    @nextneonusantara Před 4 lety +15

    "Akhbar" is formal term for newspaper in BM but for daily use we call it as "Surat khabar"...

  • @kuntalsarma5106
    @kuntalsarma5106 Před 6 lety +57

    Both are blushing, they should go on a date

  • @yahyaayyashy7825
    @yahyaayyashy7825 Před 6 lety +82

    Wow! very interesting channel! I'm from Indonesia (basicly Melayu too) and I think there's so many similarities word between farsi and Melayu (I just knew that) 😂

    • @gothicanellemo
      @gothicanellemo Před 5 lety +8

      Yahya Boyaashi sebab bahasa melayu kita menyerap bahasa pedagang dari Arab dan Parsi.

    • @bidadari2syurga
      @bidadari2syurga Před 5 lety

      I like your comment because you melayu.

    • @sallahudinalayubi2286
      @sallahudinalayubi2286 Před 4 lety

      @@gothicanellemo
      persia

    • @lapakku122
      @lapakku122 Před rokem

      @@bidadari2syurga Sumatera (except Batak), Jakarta, dan Kalimantan Coast are Melayu..

  • @muhammadalfatih2640
    @muhammadalfatih2640 Před 6 lety +23

    Brunei uses Jawi to write in malay alongside rumi. It would be amazing to see the jawi spelling on the video.

  • @safuwanfauzi5014
    @safuwanfauzi5014 Před 5 lety +12

    Labuhan/Labuan=Port in Malay, Bandar is Persian word, Animal=Haiwan=Arabic , but Malay=Binatang, Grave, Kubur=Arab Malay=Pusara, Arnab=Rabbit, Malay = Kelinci, Masjid(Mosque)=Balaisah. in Malay word "Surau" or place for Solat(Prayer) still used Native word, but sometime can called "Mussolah"from Arabic, They are many word in Malay/Old Malay we do not use it anymore, like example, Anta Permana=Infinity/Infiniti in Malay speling, "Captain" in Malay is Nakhoda, but we borrowed from English "Kapten" with Malay spelling, Pustika = Kristal, Dipertua=Presiden. it used in 1940s example "Dipertua UMNO mean Presiden UMNO/President of UMNO, Adipati=Governor or Head of Province(Kepala Daerah, Kepala=Head, Daerah=Province). some of own Malay-Austronesian word are rarely use or didn't used it anymore, same like few other world. Word for World in Malay are Dunia borrowed from Arabic, which Hindi-Urdu(Hindustani), Bengali, Turkish, Tatar, Persian used it. pure Malay word for "World or Dunia" is "Buana" or Banua, yes, Benua and Banua have common connection all it about land, Benua is huge land, when Austronesian want to explore and travel they left the Benua or Vanua in Austronesian/old Malay, go to Island. Vanuatu/Vanua-Tu is country name after word "Vanua" mean Land or homeland.

    • @MalaysianTropikfusion
      @MalaysianTropikfusion Před 3 lety +2

      Not 'pustika' but 'mestika'. And it refers to a specific type of stone, which is called bezoar in English:
      en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bezoar
      'Mestika' are found in the guts of some animals. It is also believed to be found in their heads, sometimes. Rock crystals and precious gemstones are called 'intan', 'permata', 'manikam', and 'ratna' in Malay.

  • @ammaraslamhirai6549
    @ammaraslamhirai6549 Před 6 lety +14

    Amazing! all these Malay-Farsi words are also used extensively in Urdu.

    • @worldly8888
      @worldly8888 Před 5 lety

      You must check out the Urdu videos on this channel. YOu will be astonished

  • @omaronnyoutube
    @omaronnyoutube Před 4 lety +18

    I wish you could do more videos on similarities between Malay and Arabic, Filipino, Hindi, Persian, Portuguese, Sanskrit, Tamil and other languages like you do with the Indonesian ones.

  • @moristhetiger
    @moristhetiger Před 6 lety +51

    Because I speak Hindustani and because India is between the two nations all the words were familiar to me. All the words that were common between Persian and Bengali on this channel were also familiar to me.
    I didn't know that Akhbar is the plural of Khabar woow. Akhbar means Newspaper in Hindustani.
    The guy mentioned about roti and said that there are also words that have come from Hindi so let me give an example there are in fact a lot of such words look at the word Cinta which means "to love" in Bahasa Indonesia, it is from Sanskrit and it means "to think" in Sanskrit but it means "to worry" in Hindi. keep in mind that c is pronounced like Ch in Bahasa Indonesia. To say aku cinta kamu would sound a lil out of place for Hindi speakers.
    The word Bahasa is from Sanskrit and it is transliterated as Bhasha.
    The word Sukha means happiness in Sanskrit and Suka means to like for eg: the Malayasian brother said Saya Suka makan Anggor.
    The word Bandar which is from Persian means Port and the Capital of Brunei is Bandar Serai Begawan.
    I loved this video. Terima Kasih.

    • @nihazdamba
      @nihazdamba Před 6 lety +7

      syed moris yup... Our ancestors... Take everything from ancient traders... When Hinduism came... We inserted Sanskrit... Then Islam came... We took Arabic and Persian... Later when English colonization... We took English loan words... It's like mix and match... Hahahahaha
      In fact not only we took the loan words, but we also apply the writing system... We have kawi (Sanskrit like alphabet, but it's sooo ancient) , jawi (Arabic alphabet like Persian and Urdu), and rumi (Roman Alphabet like current Malaysian writing system) writing systems...
      Since English colonization we started using ABC in our writing system....😂

    • @moristhetiger
      @moristhetiger Před 6 lety +2

      That is fantastic, having so many elements in your language.
      I wish to learn Indonesian/Malay, I plan to do it when Duolingo starts teaching it, they plan to do it by July 2018.

    • @moristhetiger
      @moristhetiger Před 6 lety +1

      Do you also speak regional dialects in Malaysia besides Malay, the way they do in Indonesia.

    • @nihazdamba
      @nihazdamba Před 6 lety +1

      syed moris yup... There are some variation of Malay dialects in Malaysia... Which are... "northern states" "Kelantanese", "Perakian", "Negeri Sembilans", "Sarawakian", "Sabahan" and many more...
      Some malaysian Malays had Javanese and Bugis ancestry from Indonesia... Where the languages are very different to Malays..
      Most understood dialect would be the "Kuala Lumpur's dialect"...
      Not to confuse with languages, Malaysian Chinese usually can speak in mandarin, hokkien, hakka, Cantonese and many other Chinese language/dialect, while Malaysian Indian usually can speak in Tamil, Punjabi, Malayalam, telegu and other Indian languages...
      East malaysian (malaysian Borneo) also have their own natives languages such as Iban, Kadazan, Melanau, Murut, Bajau, Bidayuh, and many more... Which more related to Tagalog and other Filipino languages...
      However we have a standard Bahasa Malaysia/malaysian language as our national language, English as a cumpolsory language to be taught at school since we are commonwealth nation... Arabic also widely taught in Muslim religious schools...
      Is good to know u will learn Malay, if u know Arabic, Sanskrit, and English you'll definitely spots those languages inside Malays vocabulary... Gudluck!! 😀

    • @moristhetiger
      @moristhetiger Před 6 lety +5

      That is interesting, in India also we have a lot of languages that are spoken and some of the languages are very distinct.
      aku bisa berbicara Malay, sedikit. I know some words from the Internet hahaha. Would be great knowing more about the language.
      Terima Kasih, Senang bertemu dengan anda.

  • @jeanclaudevandamme6430
    @jeanclaudevandamme6430 Před 6 lety +8

    Just watched all your videos. Very interesting to see that we have so many similarities with other Languages :) Great job, keep up the good work dadash

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +1

      bobby khoshtip
      Sepas az shoma! :) ... Hope you enjoy our future videos as well!

  • @syamilhakimi2383
    @syamilhakimi2383 Před 3 lety +9

    Hello brother bahador theres something weird i just read about oldest malay language PHARAOH=PERAHU
    Mat heru/mat horus =matahari
    Heart/ati=hati theres more! Some of the old language still being used until now!
    😟 Goosebumps

  • @october267
    @october267 Před 5 lety +61

    indonesian+malaysian team against the philipino team

  • @clarifier88
    @clarifier88 Před 6 lety +41

    I'm malay and port is pelabuhan and bandar means city. Cant find port as bandar in our Kamus Dewan (official dictionary).

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh Před 6 lety +12

      Azhar Az Bandar is the root of the term "shahbandar" who was the noble in charge of tax collection at the ports. Early cities in the Malay world were ports- Banda Aceh, Bandar Melaka etc for instance.
      Kamus Dewan is modern Bahasa Melayu- pelabuhan literally means the port area of a city, but traditionally the whole city was both. Just that now people prefer to separate term

    • @clarifier88
      @clarifier88 Před 6 lety +3

      Hence I stand corrected and the term bandar for port is obsolete, except if the video put some description stating that the old malay vocab is included which they are not. Plus I am pretty sure that almost none in Malaysia use bandar for port nowadays.

    • @clarifier88
      @clarifier88 Před 6 lety +2

      Omid Reza *dewan. Its 100% arabic loanwoards but we changed the spelling and the pronounciations

    • @ammarulzakibinrahman4502
      @ammarulzakibinrahman4502 Před 6 lety +2

      I'm guessing that the person is Indonesian Malay which still use bandar as port. He sounds Indonesian too. Too shy to be a Malaysian.

    • @clarifier88
      @clarifier88 Před 6 lety

      oh ya, i forgot to include indonesian malay. I guess they still use some very old malay terms then. Welp, thank you.

  • @wenderis
    @wenderis Před 6 lety +12

    One quite interesting word: bazar. Turned to bazaar in english, pasar in malay/indonesian.

    • @worldly8888
      @worldly8888 Před 5 lety

      That one I think most languages use, no?

  • @facai.7553
    @facai.7553 Před 5 lety +15

    There are many similarities between Malay with Indo, Brunei, Singapore, and Fillipino. And now I know that there were similarities between Malay language and Persian. Thanks for the video!

    • @Esperalzi-Esfaral
      @Esperalzi-Esfaral Před 4 lety +5

      Similarity between Malay and Indo?A no-starter statement! Indo IS Malays. More appropriate to say many similarities between Malay and Tagalog. Brunei and Singapore officially call their language 'Malay' too in case if you are not aware.

    • @alifhashim3752
      @alifhashim3752 Před 2 lety +3

      @@Esperalzi-Esfaral Brunei and Singapore were originally Malay kingdoms, therefore they speak Malay till today. The Indonesian language is chosen from the Johor-Riau language group which is from the original Malay language. However, over time Indonesia has modified its language to be more of local dialects mixed with Dutch. So the language has moved away from the Malay of Malaysia, Brunei and Singapore.

    • @Esperalzi-Esfaral
      @Esperalzi-Esfaral Před 2 lety +2

      @@alifhashim3752 I do agree with you..

    • @muhammadsecret8783
      @muhammadsecret8783 Před 2 lety

      @@alifhashim3752 LOL have you seen Singaporean Malay speak Malay ? Similar like Indonesian language. Just watch Lee Kuan Yew speak Malay or their Malay TV channel. Malay in Malaysian is a bit different

    • @alifhashim3752
      @alifhashim3752 Před 2 lety +3

      @@muhammadsecret8783 Lee Kuan Yew was speaking 100% same Malay as Malaysia. Im Malay. I know the difference between Indonesian and Malaysian Malay. Malaysians and Singaporeans Malays are exactly the same and are brothers and we have families on both sides of the causeway (the 1km bridge that separates Malaysia and Singapore). Heck, we were for a short while even one nation until 1965. Also I am a Malay Singaporean, so I should know better about my late Minister Mentor and PM. Just by adding Muhammad in your name does not make you a Malay, so dont try to act like you know about us. Your statement clearly shows you are not Malay or from Malaysia or Singapore!

  • @farithsulaiman9728
    @farithsulaiman9728 Před rokem +2

    Kata "Banda" masih digunakan dalam bahasa Melayu pada nama tempat di Negeri Melaka, iaitu Banda Hilir dan Banda Kaba. Kata "banda" bermaksud pelabuhan. Ada perkataan lama dalam bahasa Melayu, iaitu "ab-banda" yang bermaksud pintu air.

  • @izzatfeisal8125
    @izzatfeisal8125 Před 4 lety +6

    There are some basic words in Malay that sound like Persian too like small 'Kecil' colloquially pronounced "kechik" like کوچک and the word big 'Besar' like بزرگ

  • @mieaab
    @mieaab Před 2 lety +4

    They both look suitable to be a Happy couple 😁.

  • @vnllvw7421
    @vnllvw7421 Před 5 lety +6

    Turkish and Bahasa Malaysia please there are a lot of same words we use

  • @mehdijahandar3391
    @mehdijahandar3391 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Loved it

  • @deasmokeyweed
    @deasmokeyweed Před 4 lety +18

    yow so glad to see this , plus i'm malay and half persian :D

    • @zulkifliadam5109
      @zulkifliadam5109 Před 3 lety +2

      Whoopp

    • @mieaab
      @mieaab Před 2 lety +1

      Great to hear this

    • @deasmokeyweed
      @deasmokeyweed Před 2 lety

      @@mieaab 🤜🤛

    • @simplicityfx70
      @simplicityfx70 Před 2 lety +1

      I am persian and i want to learn malay how long do you think itwill take me to learn based on the fact that there is similarities between?

    • @deasmokeyweed
      @deasmokeyweed Před 2 lety

      @@simplicityfx70 depends .... three months if you lived among the Malays 😂😂

  • @AllTimeEnt
    @AllTimeEnt Před 6 lety +22

    its an interesting conversation

    • @onesk8er
      @onesk8er Před 5 lety

      ohh! its exactly the same

  • @mehrankhoshnevisan
    @mehrankhoshnevisan Před 6 lety +2

    Interesting video.But the music at the background is so loud.

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +1

      Thank you Mehran, I tried to lower the music so the voices can be heard well. Thanks, I'll make sure to really lower the volume of the music for future videos.

  • @azizanzaki8143
    @azizanzaki8143 Před 6 lety +20

    Love from Malaysia

  • @syedriduwan3000
    @syedriduwan3000 Před 4 lety +8

    I am so flabbergasted when I was in Pokhara Nepal, the local also call the grape as anggur

  • @buriednavid
    @buriednavid Před 6 lety +14

    this is so interesting

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +1

      Thanks Navid:)

    • @buriednavid
      @buriednavid Před 6 lety +2

      no problem man, keep up the good work! greetings from denmark

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +3

      We have many more videos coming up. Thanks Navid jan. Appreciate it:)

  • @sakthysakthy7915
    @sakthysakthy7915 Před 5 lety +2

    nice video... I like it

  • @pedrobelmont8496
    @pedrobelmont8496 Před 6 lety +4

    Do you have any information about how are the Things in Iran?I saw the Social Media was Shut down...And are occurring many manifestation against the Government....

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +5

      Sure my friend, but social media is working fine at the moment, I was talking to my cousins in Iran yesterday. I would rather talk about politics elsewhere though, we can chat on facebook.

  • @tahirmahmood9687
    @tahirmahmood9687 Před 6 lety +5

    Love this channel. Keep these coming

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety

      tahir mahmood Thank you!! We're going to have many more videos coming. Hope you enjoy them :)

  • @naziparii
    @naziparii Před 6 lety +6

    so good

  • @patrickr6505
    @patrickr6505 Před 6 lety +3

    Interesting..

  • @darklatte2509
    @darklatte2509 Před 5 lety +14

    persian merupakan tamadun yang sangat tua.. banyak perkataan yang menjadi asas kepada bahasa2 kemudian. tidak hairan untuk menemuakan berbrapa perkataan yang sama seperti yang diguna pakai sekarang.

    • @MalaysianTropikfusion
      @MalaysianTropikfusion Před 3 lety

      Bukan Persian, tapi Parsi. Persian tu nama bahasanya dalam bahasa Inggeris.

  • @wehsueh7252
    @wehsueh7252 Před 6 lety +34

    Malay Archipelago country Philippines Malaysia Indonesia

  • @thelastmark2216
    @thelastmark2216 Před 6 lety +2

    Btw Bahador, why dont you ever get infront of the camera?

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +6

      I plan on it. For now, I've just been organizing and coordinating the material/video, but Shahrzad helps me a lot, so for sure in some of the upcoming videos, I'll be in front of the camera as well :)

    • @worldly8888
      @worldly8888 Před 5 lety

      @@BahadorAlast Now you are there :)

  • @muhammadadamrizailani1400

    Am Malay in America 🇺🇸🇲🇾

  • @JingLiSH
    @JingLiSH Před 6 lety +5

    cantonese vs. vietnamese ^^
    actually there'd also be tons of similarity btwn mandarin vs. korean
    mongolian vs. uyghur
    uyghur vs. hindi or persian
    hokkien vs. japanese

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety

      Thank you. Those are all excellent suggestions and we'll definitely try to work it out to have them done! If you have any other suggestions or feedback, please make sure to contact us on Instagram, because CZcams comments can easily get missed. Shahrzad: instagram.com/shahrzad.pe or Myself: instagram.com/BahadorAlast
      Thanks again :)

    • @fazrazfarzam4688
      @fazrazfarzam4688 Před 6 lety

      Uzbek vs. Persian!

  • @TanvirMuraadR
    @TanvirMuraadR Před 6 lety +5

    بہادر شما کار خوب می کنی ! 👍

  • @normanaffendi3011
    @normanaffendi3011 Před 5 lety +31

    Malay = Arabic+Persian+ Sanskrit

    • @annaeembinannahari2516
      @annaeembinannahari2516 Před 5 lety +5

      + English

    • @mohamadhakim7881
      @mohamadhakim7881 Před 5 lety +1

      @@annaeembinannahari2516 English for only the things which appeared after British colonised us. Before those years our language was heavily influenced by these 3 languages. Sanskrit and Persian derived from the same Mother Language which is Proto-Indo European.

    • @annaeembinannahari2516
      @annaeembinannahari2516 Před 5 lety +8

      @@mohamadhakim7881
      Ye bang. Saya faham. Bahasa melayu juga bahasa ibunda saye. Bahasa Melayu kite ni Austronesian language campuran Arabic, Farsi, Sanskrit dan juga bahasa English.

    • @HH-he4pw
      @HH-he4pw Před 5 lety +6

      You forgot austronesian language

    • @manjawa5623
      @manjawa5623 Před 5 lety

      Norman Affendi betul tapi tak tepat...

  • @abstractmusic5219
    @abstractmusic5219 Před 6 lety +22

    Do Persian and Mandarin next! 🤓Great channel! 😉

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +4

      PersianEyes
      Thank you :) ... We'd love to, but I have not found many similarities, except for "tea", which is common in many languages around Asia.

    • @Wizard_of_North
      @Wizard_of_North Před 6 lety

      Bahador Alast Please make a video, similarities or challenge between azerbaijani or azeri and persian )) it would be very interesting

    • @kimimon9057
      @kimimon9057 Před 6 lety

      Soheila-Talks does it has Many similarities?

    • @hatemabu-assad6959
      @hatemabu-assad6959 Před 6 lety

      elmir quliyev They have done this!

    • @hatemabu-assad6959
      @hatemabu-assad6959 Před 6 lety

      elmir quliyev they did Azerbaijani with Persian

  • @pedrobelmont8496
    @pedrobelmont8496 Před 6 lety +2

    How about Telegram its working? ????

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +1

      Pedro Belmont
      Telegram is currently working fine in Iran! We're conversing with our relatives in Tehran, Qom, and Shahrzad's relatives in Mashhad.

  • @LionZ_
    @LionZ_ Před 6 lety +3

    Nice tepih ... Keep the rug in future videos

  • @momoy88
    @momoy88 Před 3 lety +7

    Apa khabar semua?
    Khabar baik atau tidak baik?
    Hari ini saya pergi ke bandar
    Hari ini saya makan kismis dan anggur
    Isnin
    Selasa
    Rabu
    Khamis
    Jumaat
    Sabtu
    Ahad

  • @aimanmarzuqi4804
    @aimanmarzuqi4804 Před 5 lety +2

    There are plenty of Persian loanwords in many Muslim cultures since Persian was a popular lingua franca among Muslims for a long while.

  • @engkausial
    @engkausial Před 6 lety +2

    i think malay misinterpret persian loanword bandar which mean port. we malay understand bandar as city. this maybe due to most of earliest city in malay archipelago was built near the port as we are maritime country. now in malay the port is called "pelabuhan" while bandar is referred to city even it is far from the sea.

    • @damhaziaf
      @damhaziaf Před 5 lety

      Sama ada dia ni Indon tak pun video ni depa dah script awai awai

  • @cyrusbayat5785
    @cyrusbayat5785 Před 4 lety

    لطفا مقایسه فیلیپینی با فارسی را نیز قرار دهید با تشکر

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 4 lety +2

      خیلی دلم میخواد این کارو بکنم. ولی تعداد واژهای مشترک بینشون خیلی کمه

    • @cyrusbayat5785
      @cyrusbayat5785 Před 4 lety +1

      @@BahadorAlast به هر حال ممنون ویدیو های جالبی دارید

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 4 lety +1

      @@cyrusbayat5785 سپاس❤ خیلی لطف دارین

  • @muktharubarify1
    @muktharubarify1 Před 6 lety +4

    Do a video on Dravidian language

    • @sonofpharaoh9716
      @sonofpharaoh9716 Před 5 lety +1

      Preferred M A L A Y A L A M

    • @k.h5971
      @k.h5971 Před 5 lety +1

      preferred K A N N A D A

    • @worldly8888
      @worldly8888 Před 5 lety

      @Hare Krishna They do have Tamil videos on this channel. I enjoyed it!

  • @khalidzaki6699
    @khalidzaki6699 Před 4 lety +1

    Roti is the Is the most common Word for bread eaten with curry in Urdu. Howe , there are other words for bread in Urdu : Nan , tandoori roti sheer mal , taftan , kulcha etc. These are all varieties of bread also called chapati . Most of the words are used in Urdu as well .

  • @azlateef3799
    @azlateef3799 Před 6 lety +2

    Does shafiq have his own channel?

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +1

      No, he does not. But we plan to have him back for future videos.

    • @azlateef3799
      @azlateef3799 Před 5 lety +2

      Why no more Malay vs. ? Huhuhh

    • @azlateef3799
      @azlateef3799 Před 4 lety +1

      @@BahadorAlast when will you bring him back??

  • @dionakgamer7769
    @dionakgamer7769 Před 5 lety +2

    Wow all this word are similar with nepali word. I never knew some words in Malaya language are so close to Nepalese language.
    Persian way of pronouncing is very similar to nepali since nepali is similar to hindi and urdu and many be little bit, like .1 or 1% is Tibetan but not sure

  • @Tawanpawatt
    @Tawanpawatt Před 2 lety +1

    Even malay with indonesia and filipina sound a bit different but with persian sound mostly the same

  • @DesiRockMetal
    @DesiRockMetal Před 4 lety +2

    All these words are used by Bangladeshis too. Except for wheat, which is gom in Bengali. But, still close to Persian and Malaysian (gandum).

  • @MukeshPathak-dxb
    @MukeshPathak-dxb Před 6 lety +1

    This Video could also be titled as Similarities between Persion, Malasian and Indian.

  • @irilhamramadhan
    @irilhamramadhan Před 5 lety

    Make video similarities indonesian language and malay language

    • @roslihashim2766
      @roslihashim2766 Před rokem

      Just 70% word samiliar...like British and American

  • @abc_cba
    @abc_cba Před 5 lety +1

    Whenever you hear the word Bahasa in Indonesian or Malaysian languages , it stems from the Sanskrit Hindi word Bhasha (pronunciation is Bhaa-Sh-aaaa) . Make sure it's Bha (very typical to Indian languages) as in Bhutan and not Ba as in Bangladesh.

    • @shzltx1821
      @shzltx1821 Před 3 lety

      Previously, Malay use ‘h’ a lot too, but the modern Malay tends to simplify them. For example, chakra - cakra, chenderawaseh - cenderawasih, chawan - cawan, etc

  • @jonathanh7917
    @jonathanh7917 Před 6 lety

    Do Indonesian Language vs Malay

  • @kalaananth6371
    @kalaananth6371 Před 3 lety

    Cool

  • @Karla_1987
    @Karla_1987 Před 5 lety

    But jaanvar is not haywan in Farsi?

  • @biruly
    @biruly Před 2 lety +2

    Both are very Polite and well mannered.

  • @Oz-qc1we
    @Oz-qc1we Před 3 lety

    I am malay too long time ago marchand from persia and arabic peninsula came to malaysia that's why..

  • @arzhangemamifar7702
    @arzhangemamifar7702 Před 6 lety +5

    LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE from Iran .

  • @muhamadrasul9251
    @muhamadrasul9251 Před 6 lety +1

    There are many loan Arabs word in Indonesian and some are also understand by Persian like the world Hamil which is Pregnan, not exactly the same in Persian but there is Persian word sound like that

  • @amir1577
    @amir1577 Před 6 lety +6

    mahtab is so lovely

  • @wrathoflichking9603
    @wrathoflichking9603 Před 4 lety +8

    And yea....dont ever said all asian look alike...you can clearly see the difference between east asian and southeast asian by their looks😂😀

    • @malayanavgeek1124
      @malayanavgeek1124 Před 3 lety +1

      Most people think Asian is just like people who look like chinese look with a small eye... But.. The brown one which is basically austronesian

  • @jaisrauf374
    @jaisrauf374 Před 5 lety +3

    Do again Indonesia and other leangue

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 5 lety

      We will have many more Indonesian videos. Stay tuned and enjoy :) Could you please reach us on Instagram (@BahadorAlast or @shahrzad.pe) for future suggestions so we don’t miss your comments on CZcams and that we can actually talk about the format of what you’d like to see! Thank you:)

    • @worldly8888
      @worldly8888 Před 5 lety

      They have done lots of Indonesian videos

    • @worldly8888
      @worldly8888 Před 5 lety

      This channel is full of Indonesian videos

  • @najibyusoffchannel1417

    Do Malay and Arabic pls

    • @worldly8888
      @worldly8888 Před 5 lety

      They have done Indonesian and Arabic, did you watch it?

  • @junapudiraj
    @junapudiraj Před 5 lety +1

    My home town is also called BANDAR which means a port i already know it earlier

  • @ghettofab511
    @ghettofab511 Před 6 lety +5

    I thought beydaan was a Somali word 😮 it's used as a girls name, we also call the southern coastal province benaadir

    • @ghettofab511
      @ghettofab511 Před 6 lety

      we also say neef and hayawan too

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety

      Very interesting Sasha! Thank you. We'll definitely do a Somali video in the future.

    • @MalaysianTropikfusion
      @MalaysianTropikfusion Před 3 lety

      It's badam, actually. They're not planted in Somalia, are they?

  • @mohammedfarouqabdul-jalil9309

    Since when was port bandar in Malay? Port = pelabuhan

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 5 lety

      In old Malay, more authentic, bandar was used for port, you can look this up :)

  • @SantomPh
    @SantomPh Před 6 lety +1

    do differences between Brunei Malay and Peninsular Malaysian Malay. Also, it is not "Malaysian"- the language is spoken in four other countries and is official in three of them (Singapore has it as a national but not official language). Do not give a country essentially founded in 1957 ownership of a language that is over 500 years old.

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +3

      Thank you for watching, but the flag corresponds to the country of the participant.

  • @nonames8335
    @nonames8335 Před 5 lety

    Rabbit = arnab (malay)
    Rabbit = arnab (arabic) it is correct?

  • @yimveerasak3543
    @yimveerasak3543 Před 5 lety +1

    We dont say port as bandar. Bandar means city. Port is pelabuhan. I dont know if this guy is from Brunei or Singapore. Im from 🇲🇾 Persians did came to Malayan peninsula as scholars and merchants. Some married locals. They speak both Persian and Arabic

    • @azlateef3799
      @azlateef3799 Před 5 lety

      Bandar is town, city is bandaraya...

    • @AlKuufi
      @AlKuufi Před 5 lety +1

      We bruneians too call it pelabuhan

  • @jojo7772
    @jojo7772 Před 5 měsíci

    How to getting know a persian girl?

  • @azizahamdi
    @azizahamdi Před 4 lety

    Why you use Arabic words and there are Persian substitute for the same in Farsi, like Haiwan حيوان which is Jonawer جوناور and Qaleb قلب for heart which is دل dil and Gheza غذا for food which is خوراك khorak... And there are many more such words

  • @nasr2603
    @nasr2603 Před 5 lety +4

    I think it is because Malay language was a lingua franca long time ago

  • @testpower7135
    @testpower7135 Před 4 lety +7

    great.. so now I can have a Persian wife

  • @ibnuabdrahim
    @ibnuabdrahim Před 5 lety +3

    minah parsi tu pandang dan senyum lain macam je kat mamat melayu tu, lirikan dan jelingan mata tu manja semacam.. ehem2..

  • @Rei-eo1ze
    @Rei-eo1ze Před 6 lety +1

    Please make 'Similarities Between Indonesian and Malaysian' lol

    • @roslihashim2766
      @roslihashim2766 Před rokem

      Indonesia mix Malay, dutch,local ...so different vocabulary and pronounce...70% same Malay word..

  • @tengkuikmal3516
    @tengkuikmal3516 Před 6 lety +9

    THAT IT.. I WANNA GO PERSIA!

  • @omaronnyoutube
    @omaronnyoutube Před 4 lety +1

    Let's do 'Similarities Between Indonesian and Malay' next time. We'll see what's the same or similar and what's different, particularly in the use of vocabulary.

  • @xwatch2581
    @xwatch2581 Před 5 lety +1

    Napas ( breathe) also in Tausug language from sulu Philippines

  • @donq2957
    @donq2957 Před rokem

    How do you say mofo in your language?

  • @emmakoh9194
    @emmakoh9194 Před 5 lety

    Okay.. so similarr.

  • @AmirulMuhd
    @AmirulMuhd Před 5 lety +3

    port = pelabuhan
    persian bandar = port
    bandar melaka = pelabuhan melaka
    pekan melaka dulu kan tempat kapal berlabuh besar kemungkinan influence british kuat. bahasa english kan bnyk detail. jadi bhasa kita la ni bnyk pasal jadi translate dri english.
    tgk aku tulis pon campor aduk harey!! harey mana dtg plak ayat ni?
    satu je belanda,english, india, arab xder.. “amuk” itu je dlm bahasa kita yg depa xda..😆

  • @shirokun4742
    @shirokun4742 Před 5 lety +1

    Bandaragah means port in hindi

  • @ayrikamitiskanal1305
    @ayrikamitiskanal1305 Před 6 lety

    The word news and the news are not Arabic,It is Persian and there was newspaper During the Achaemenid and a newspaper called " khabar " !! Many Persian words came to the Arabic, such as love, poetry, news, tea and many other words .Approximately 5,000 words from the ancient Iranian languages have entered the languages of the Semitic group such as Hebrew, Akad, and Arabic. If r بسیاری از واژه های پارسی به عربی راه پیدا کرد همانند عشق ، ادب ،خبر،چای و کندگ = عربی شده خندق بسیاری از واژه های دیگر .

  • @kibruazkaenk1510
    @kibruazkaenk1510 Před 6 lety

    What about Indonesian

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety

      We've done several Indonesian videos, including Indonesian with Persian. Here is the link to that video: czcams.com/video/duWx5BlWTeg/video.html

  • @carlmyname265
    @carlmyname265 Před 6 lety

    Malay gene kind of like a hybrid gene its mix with alot of races practically they came from mountain people of taiwan travel across the sea and began to stay there and got influence with hindu and budha before islam and other came.

    • @sonofpharaoh9716
      @sonofpharaoh9716 Před 5 lety

      My ancestors were from many ancient Kings from Roman Empire, Persian, Jewish, Arab, indian, chinese and Malay..but I am considered Malay..

  • @leenal-sayed9444
    @leenal-sayed9444 Před 6 lety +27

    Similarities between Arabic and Persian please!

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety +4

      Leen Sayed Definitely! We have it planned. Stay tuned, it's coming:)

    • @97Alfinsyah
      @97Alfinsyah Před 5 lety

      nice . i'll waiting this session

    • @worldly8888
      @worldly8888 Před 5 lety

      @@BahadorAlast I watched that one. It was nice, you are amazing people.

  • @Hushiization
    @Hushiization Před 6 lety

    Lama-lama bikin similiraties between Indo and Malay

    • @azlateef3799
      @azlateef3799 Před 5 lety

      Hampir 95% serupa

    • @ODOYCHEAPFRED
      @ODOYCHEAPFRED Před 5 lety

      Ngapain itu.. Mah.. Sama aja.. Haha gw ke malaysia aja pake b indo ngerti mreka..

  • @shahiskandar8717
    @shahiskandar8717 Před 6 lety

    The video thumbnail though..lol...Not all Malay came from Malaysia.. We are all over Southeast Asia. Nusantara Countries : Indonesia/Malaysia/Singapore/Brunei

    • @BahadorAlast
      @BahadorAlast  Před 6 lety

      I understand but our friend Shafiq who participated in the video is from Malaysia

    • @shahiskandar8717
      @shahiskandar8717 Před 6 lety +1

      Ah yeah...make sense....

  • @hshshhshd2489
    @hshshhshd2489 Před 5 lety +2

    Malay is Bani Malai from Nabi Ibrahim's third wife (her name is Malai)
    Malay live in Nusantara, convert to Islam after Hijrah( dakwah from Macca to Nusantara )
    before that, some Malay is in Nabi Ibrahim's Religion and some Malay is Hindu Religion.
    (thats not india, thats a religion, same like Bali & Thailand Hindu/Buddha)
    Malay is 1st Muslim in Nusantara before Java & etc in Nusantara..
    Malay Teach Java about Muslim after Java attacking Siam Budha(thats time, Malay & Siam in war)
    but Arab always teach us (Nusantara) time to time.
    some Malay married with Arab and some Malay Married with any Muslim in Malay place.thats why malay have many genetic.
    but still the 1st is from Malai.

  • @aghaabbas6845
    @aghaabbas6845 Před 6 lety

    Strange we say bandar Gah in urdu

  • @harryrinaldi2812
    @harryrinaldi2812 Před rokem +1

    The similarities of Malay and Persian is because of the Arabic influenced.

  • @TranquillityInFlames
    @TranquillityInFlames Před 4 lety +3

    rabbit
    arabic - arnab
    malay - arnab
    hebrew - arnav

  • @jessicajesaugustine
    @jessicajesaugustine Před 4 lety +2

    Malay and Farsi words are more to the Arabic. I know. My husband is Persian.

  • @qseki
    @qseki Před 5 lety +2

    Ni mesti teringin nak kucing parsi tapi dapat awek parsi