Casio CDP-S100 vs Roland FP-10 vs Yamaha P-45. Piano sound (Blind test)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 09. 2024
  • Описание: Casio CDP-S100 / Roland FP-10 / Yamaha P-45 blind test. Which digital piano sound do you like?
    Song: Academy theme from HoMM 4
    pixabay.com/ru... - image

Komentáře • 607

  • @revanthshahukaru7883
    @revanthshahukaru7883 Před 4 lety +246

    0:01 Piano 1- BLIND
    0:55 Piano 2- BLIND
    1:48 Piano 3- BLIND
    *******************
    2:38 Piano 1-REVEALED
    3:32 Piano 2-REVEALED
    4:26 Piano 3-REVEALED

  • @davidbower9025
    @davidbower9025 Před 3 lety +274

    All very fine pianos - but just adding a bit of support for the Casio CDP-S100 here! Not sure what mode that was in (maybe 'Bright'?) but I can honestly say the Grand Piano on the Casio sounds NOTHING like this demo! It's far better than shown here. The best advice really would be to go to a piano shop and try all three. That's what I did and I came away with the Casio. I think the Yamaha and Roland had a *slightly* better sound, but the action on the P45 was nowhere near as nice as the Casio. The keys seemed very slow to return, and felt very cheap. I thought the Roland's action was as good as the Casio, but was significantly more expensive. For me, it was as much about the feel as it was the sound, and at that price point, the Casio was way ahead. Of course, this is all very subjective, it really is a personal choice, but for a budget-friendly starter piano, the Casio for me was the clear winner. Online reviews are an excellent starting point, but you really have to see/hear/feel each piano personally to make the right decision for you. Happy shopping everyone!

    • @lugowo8986
      @lugowo8986 Před 3 lety +6

      Are you sure that casio sounded as good/subpar the yamaha p45? if truly so, then please tell me, therefore afterwards i would be convinced to buy the cdp s100.thank you.

    • @davidbower9025
      @davidbower9025 Před 3 lety +16

      @@lugowo8986 I would say the P45 sounded slightly better but not much, and the CDP-S100 felt much better. Definitely try them both out and see what you think, but the Casio is a lovely piano 😁 Good luck!

    • @lugowo8986
      @lugowo8986 Před 3 lety

      @@davidbower9025 aight thank you very much
      By the way, which do you prefer from p45 and cdps100, just for information?

    • @davidbower9025
      @davidbower9025 Před 3 lety +3

      @@lugowo8986 I bought the CDP S100 and I love it 😊 At that price its absolutely brilliant! Let me know if you get to try them both in a shop?

    • @lugowo8986
      @lugowo8986 Před 3 lety +1

      @@davidbower9025 alright, yeah unfortunately at my locals, not even a single shop provides, thus, i can't try it, the only choice is to buy it online, one last thing i wanted to ask, if you may, i've heard about this casio CDP S100 is short pivoted keys, what do you think about it? , is it true, or doest it affect you playing at all?

  • @DARIJASOUNDS
    @DARIJASOUNDS Před 5 lety +317

    I own both pianos: Roland FP-10 and Casio CDP-S100.
    The sound of a (compact, stage and upright) digital piano really is a matter of taste, and also depends on the settings of the individual piano and used speakers and/or headphones. Yamaha is like an upright piano, Roland is more warm and full and Casio sounds like a grand piano with an open ceiling. Also consider the number of polyphonies (Yamaha and Casio have 64, Roland has 96 polyphones). All models sound better with a good headphone or profetional external speakerss than the built-in speakers.
    With the further development of the virtual pianos up to the physically modeled pianos, the sound engine within the compact digital pianos is not really interesting and does not represent the first criterion for me. You can simply connect your stage piano to a tablet or computer and launsch a physical modeled virtual piano engine, and you get the best sound out there, with infinite possibilities for tuning right through to the length of the strings.
    The most important thing in a piano is the KEYBOARD. On all three keyboards of the named models, the keyboard of Casio is by far the best with well-scaled dynamics and pleasing surface texture (Scaled Hammer Action Keyboard II).
    In summary, a sound engine can be substituted for a better one, but you can not replace a bad keyboard.

    • @Wulfcry
      @Wulfcry Před 5 lety +20

      Well said most people treat the sounds from digital pianos as stock sounds without adjusting them to their taste.

    • @jasonshrestha
      @jasonshrestha Před 5 lety +5

      I have been looking for a comparison all over, i plan to use Keyscape, and get either yamaha fp-10 or Casio CDP s100. Which one would you suggest I should get for the best feel, the best response of the keys and durability. Thank you for this in-depth review @Mrfilariss

    • @mmhcreates
      @mmhcreates Před 5 lety +5

      Well said. For my personal taste I preferred the overall sound of the Roland and the Casio was a close second especially in the lower frequency range.

    • @AGAU1022
      @AGAU1022 Před 5 lety +28

      "the keyboard of Casio is by far the best with well-scaled dynamics and pleasing surface texture"
      I disagree. The FP-10 feels better to me.

    • @mahendra4352
      @mahendra4352 Před 5 lety +2

      I'm a beginner looking for my first piano. Currently I'm eyeing a S100.
      Is there actually a way to upgrade a sound engine ? Is it akin to Android OS upgrade on mobile phone ?

  • @PeaceLilies03
    @PeaceLilies03 Před 3 lety +15

    Got the Roland FP10 because of blind tests like these, thank you :)

    • @Sundance_
      @Sundance_ Před 2 lety +1

      Have you experienced any key sound after usage? I want to go for Roland but I read some comments about that raising key sound, made me concerned

    • @zimpinzonkerenda
      @zimpinzonkerenda Před 3 měsíci

      Los tres me gustan pero prefiero casio BBB ❤🎉

  • @ayrtoninchejanampa6874
    @ayrtoninchejanampa6874 Před 5 lety +148

    For those who are going to buy a piano, do not get carried away by the comments, get carried away by your tastes, the three piano were recorded online, so just listen and choose the one you like best.
    I forgot, in a matter of touch of keys, it is always good to try it yourself, here in the comments there are many opinions and you will not necessarily agree with that

    • @monaj5783
      @monaj5783 Před 5 lety +4

      I liked 1, do you know which one was it? Most comments saying Yamaha, is it correct?

    • @ayrtoninchejanampa6874
      @ayrtoninchejanampa6874 Před 5 lety +2

      @@monaj5783 Yes, piano 1 is the Yamaha P45, the video also shows

    • @monaj5783
      @monaj5783 Před 5 lety +7

      @@ayrtoninchejanampa6874 oh it does, the last piano was painful so i didn't finish the video, i was wondering how everyone knew, thank you 🙏🏼

    • @lukaso4644
      @lukaso4644 Před 3 lety +2

      roland fp10 but cant afford it so going with cheapest casio xD

    • @haneenashraf7964
      @haneenashraf7964 Před 3 lety

      This is the best commend 💖💖💖💖

  • @maryfisher6569
    @maryfisher6569 Před 3 lety +12

    Great video. I just purchased a P-45 and LOVE IT!!! I had an upright grand and this sound almost exactly like it, touch as well. I havent stopped playing it. It was brand new and still in box at a flea market for 225. Can't beat that price!

    • @goodcyrus
      @goodcyrus Před rokem +2

      Hot bargain ... as in stolen item probably

  • @fomalhaut86
    @fomalhaut86 Před 5 lety +91

    Roland has a LOT more dynamic range than the competition. It also has more resonances modeled. That and the natural note decay is what sets it apart form the competition. It is easy to hear if You know what to hear for :)

    • @graceongiphonesg
      @graceongiphonesg Před 5 lety +7

      I tried the Roland FP 10 at a showroom played pop piano on it and I love the mellow warm tone and slightly yellowish keys. It Sound closer to a real grand piano. The upper notes of other brands always puts me off with its shrill sharp tone.

    • @AGAU1022
      @AGAU1022 Před 5 lety +9

      Yamaha (first one) is the brightest and also just seemed louder overall, so I thought it sounded the best at first and the Roland sounded the worst, but once I adjusted for this by turning the volume up the Roland sounded the best, much more realistic. The Roland also feels the best to me in store. The Casio is in between the two in terms of brightness, so a fine compromise. Casio pianos are much better than people say, especially for the price, but I think paying a bit more for the FP-10 is worth it.

    • @paolopantaleo7135
      @paolopantaleo7135 Před 4 lety +2

      Roland has still that very slightly robot talking feeling, as it is synthetized. In 10 years it will probably sond like a real piano :P

    • @runder2022
      @runder2022 Před rokem

      No

  • @sbstx1
    @sbstx1 Před 2 lety +19

    All nice digital pianos in their own way. Love the way fp10 sounds around the 4:00 mark. It has a certain drama that strikes a chord with me. Feels like it has very good dynamic range.
    Love the music and the way it’s played! Awesomeness

    • @Neerano
      @Neerano Před 2 lety +1

      That is because it sound mellow while p45 is bright. Mellow may sound more romantic/melancholic in certain pices.

    • @goodlookinouthomie1757
      @goodlookinouthomie1757 Před rokem +1

      @@Neerano Yes, I noticed this with my PF10. I almost always have it set Piano#4 because this is the brightest and almost everything sounds better to me that way.

  • @Quisspo
    @Quisspo Před 4 lety +46

    Piano 2 > Piano 1 > Piano 3.
    After conclusion: yeah that is what I expected. That is why I will buy a Roland one soon :P
    Yamaha is no slouch either, but I personally prefer the warm bass in the Roland piano

    • @cappujhino
      @cappujhino Před 4 lety +2

      Exactly what I thought. Also gonna buy the Roland.^ ^

    • @congdungnguyen7354
      @congdungnguyen7354 Před 4 lety +1

      I bought roland but for Yamaha sounds better

    • @abigailaldea7956
      @abigailaldea7956 Před 3 lety +3

      I like the Roland, soft but solid sound.

  • @CalaTec
    @CalaTec Před 2 lety +5

    I've never played any piano, but I want to buy one and I want the Roland FP10. I saw so many reviews and listen to them the lasts couple of days and I was able to identify each by ear, which surprises me.

  • @heinrichhegenberg8353
    @heinrichhegenberg8353 Před 3 lety +6

    I'm looking for a begginer e-piano and stumbled upon this video. What I can't believe is the choice of song. It brought me back to the old days in an instant. It took me a while to remember why the f*** the music sounded sooo familiar!

  • @anniesmith2
    @anniesmith2 Před 4 lety +41

    Roland # 1, Just got mine and I love the sound. Advise to me...sound over features.... unless you absolutely need the features.

    • @ItzMinzzz
      @ItzMinzzz Před 4 lety

      do have that plastic key noise on ur fp10 ???

    • @jrnelson2106
      @jrnelson2106 Před 3 lety

      I thought the Roland sounded the worst low dynamics

    • @codelif
      @codelif Před 3 lety

      Actually to me sound isn't really a problem. Cause I use it with my laptop so I can change the sound fonts all I want so I am going for the cdp s100. And the casio sound is not that bad if i wanna use it solo.

    • @arjenbij
      @arjenbij Před 2 lety

      @@jrnelson2106 This has nothing to do with dynamics, the yamaha is overly bright. The Roland has string resonance which makes the sound more complex and richer.

  • @allyzally
    @allyzally Před 4 lety +11

    That’s brilliant , I have ordered a Roland and was having second thoughts about it but this has confirmed that I made the right choice, thanks so much for this and lovely playing.

    • @robmandeville5180
      @robmandeville5180 Před 4 lety

      I can not WAIT till the FP10's are in. I've had one on order for a month!

  • @jon_is_nerd1730
    @jon_is_nerd1730 Před 4 lety +38

    Was the Casio in the grand setting? That sounded like it was the bright setting. Ngl, the Casio (what I have) is really nice sounding and has a very acoustic sound in both the low and high ends of the keyboard. When I went to purchase my Casio I looked at the Yamaha and quite frankly I preferred the casios touch and tone quality. However, I guess everyone wants a different sound. In the end I’m simply practicing to play in a grand and that’s what you get with all of these options.

    • @recorr
      @recorr Před 3 lety

      same feeling, i didn't recognize the sound of the grand piano standard of the casio that looks much like roland, i think

  • @ThePandaGuitar
    @ThePandaGuitar Před 4 lety +317

    Piano 2 by far, without watching the rest of the video. Piano 3 sounds like plastic, and I was going to buy the last one before watching this video, lol!

    • @kittygumdrop7442
      @kittygumdrop7442 Před 4 lety +18

      lol same! I was specifically looking for reviews on the 3rd one til I heard this.

    • @tibisuperlegoarms
      @tibisuperlegoarms Před 4 lety +11

      Same! I was looking for an affordable digital piano and I was quite sure I would have gone for the Casio cdp s100 because after reading his features it looked better then the Yamaha,then I found this video and I'm so grateful for this! I'm happy to say that I've gone for the yamaha p45,it sounds warm and realistic.
      PS,I already have an upright piano and the p45 is a great digital piano,even comparing to my acoustic one(of course it is a budget piano,but it's totally worth considering its price)

    • @tibisuperlegoarms
      @tibisuperlegoarms Před 4 lety +3

      @@DanielSekovski I know the privia and of course It's much better! But It isn't on the same prize range,you usually find the p45 around 400/450€ and the privia costs about 550€,it costs as much ss the p125 and the fp30.
      I found the p45 on a really good price,I spent 450€ for the piano plus the yamaha l-85 stand (390 for the piano and 60 for the stand).
      Of course the choice depends by what you need,I already have an upright but I had to buy a digital to study and to play anytime with headphones on,so I didn't need an expensive piano.
      But I can just recomend it! Yes, it isn't an expensive piano but to me it's totally worth for the price.
      You're right that the px1000 is better but it is more expensive,it depends by how much you're going to spend :)

    • @EvangelionGames-ro3xt
      @EvangelionGames-ro3xt Před 4 lety

      ThePandaGuitar omg me too

    • @PaulBell88
      @PaulBell88 Před 4 lety +3

      @@DanielSekovski But black keys are lighter than white, making it maddening.

  • @zhuuxi
    @zhuuxi Před 5 lety +16

    Wow, from merely the first few notes, this song suddenly reminds me of Heroes of Might and Magic 4, which I played when I was still a primary school student! At that time this very Academy theme song impressed me very much. Simply...amazingly....NOSTALGIC!

  • @GiulianoM14
    @GiulianoM14 Před 5 lety +35

    Wow, even hearing them with my phones speakers I could tell the difference. I instantly preferred the second one. Roland made such a good work on the FP-10. Definitely getting that one.

    • @noadnie8210
      @noadnie8210 Před 2 lety +2

      I also like Roland most, all yamahas are too bright for me

  • @stevenwarner9156
    @stevenwarner9156 Před 3 lety +17

    I got the Casio right as number 3 but got the P-45 and FP-10 mixed up. Very impressive sound by Roland, particularly with the rich harmonics in the bottom end which remind me of some higher priced (but not by that much) Yamahas.

    • @Sticknub
      @Sticknub Před rokem +2

      same here

    • @P4P1Kpl
      @P4P1Kpl Před 11 měsíci

      hey. could you check it? "At the begining Yamaha and Roland have long sound but Casio is like cutting the sound check the very beginning of each samples. Casio for me (not even beginer) sound cheap or fake." I'm interested in buying my first piano and I need a comparison between Roland FP-10 and Casio CDPS110. What do you think?

  • @traciezou3768
    @traciezou3768 Před 4 lety +5

    thank you for the blind test, I was wondering which one to choose, Roland FP-10 it is, sounds very settle, I love it!

  • @margaretmirnaya4693
    @margaretmirnaya4693 Před rokem +1

    Thank you for this video! I bought Roland FP-10, and I'm in love with it sound - deep, full, warm... And I alco like the melody you play, I cannot find any tutorials that sound like your variant... :(

  • @Oliver-uh5ze
    @Oliver-uh5ze Před 4 lety +9

    fp10 has string resonance effect. it makes the sounds in same harmonic range much richer.

  • @juuls7082
    @juuls7082 Před 4 lety +31

    P1 0:00 P2 0:55 P3 1:48
    P1 0:16 P2 1:10 P3 2:03
    P1 0:27 P2 1:21 P3 2:14
    P1 0:36 P2 1:30 P3 2:23

  • @ted4ps581
    @ted4ps581 Před 3 lety +5

    After testing all three in a music store, I decided on the P-45. Best sound and features for the price.

    • @HT-ho7pn
      @HT-ho7pn Před 2 lety +1

      Thoughts abt roland ?

    • @JAnx01
      @JAnx01 Před 2 lety

      @@HT-ho7pn I have a Roland FP-30X. The speakers are horrible.

  • @pedroanshori8646
    @pedroanshori8646 Před 3 lety +15

    Yamaha P45: Strong
    Roland FP10: Calm
    Casio CDP S100: Clarity
    I prefer Roland

  • @banzarexi
    @banzarexi Před 5 lety +191

    The last one was definitely the most unsuccessful. To me the most successful roland. Second place is yamaha.

    • @vccranker
      @vccranker Před 4 lety +22

      That’s funny. For me, it’s the complete opposite. First and third were super clear and second was slightly muffled or dull. Third sounded slightly more harpsichord like, but almost indistinguishable from the first, which sounded like a real piano.

    • @littlelamb6804
      @littlelamb6804 Před 4 lety +24

      Roland sounds so rich and full.

    • @kesterrose3529
      @kesterrose3529 Před 4 lety +7

      Baring in mind the third didn't have a sustaining pedal, which makes the sound test a little bit unfair imo. Personally, Yamaha wins for me, and would like to hear Casio with a pedal but by this recording it definitely comes last for me.
      Roland is a close second though, the sound is slightly fuller but also sounds more electric than the first to me, if that makes sense.

    • @MrProcesorek
      @MrProcesorek Před 3 lety

      Same

    • @ron4u2k
      @ron4u2k Před 3 lety +2

      The Roland immediately sounded smooth even in the blind test..but I thought it was played more softly which added the soothing effect of Roland

  • @sarichardmarx
    @sarichardmarx Před 3 lety +5

    All my guessing were right. From 1st to 3rd. I can simply notice the difference. Casio sounds a bit light and treble even if you play the bass note. Roland sounds more echoing and a bit bass while yamaha sounds similar with roland but I cannot hear echo in it. Roland always wins my heart.

  • @mr_x1703
    @mr_x1703 Před 4 lety +15

    love the warm and mellow tone of the roland the most

  • @911Teddy911
    @911Teddy911 Před 4 lety +20

    form me i prefer the fp10 because it has the most number of polyphony (96) and the perfect sound not too bright but no too warm and btw i was impressed by the key bed it has escapement like a real grand piano if you play the key very slowly you feel a click in the middle of the key travel and that piano when i played on it really inspires me !

    • @akmroberts
      @akmroberts Před 3 lety

      True but bear in mind that the function of escapement is to rapidly repeat the note - the click in the middle of the analogue keypress is a side effect of this mechanism. The digital equivalent of escapement is a third sensor to pick up key retake before complete return, e.g. on the Kawai MP11.

    • @simcax6087
      @simcax6087 Před 3 lety

      @@akmroberts They say the roland fp10 has 3 sensors as well. Is that true?

    • @nathanfuzaro4792
      @nathanfuzaro4792 Před 3 lety

      @@simcax6087 yes

    • @goodlookinouthomie1757
      @goodlookinouthomie1757 Před rokem

      FP10 is a lot brighter than this video suggests. Although this was 2 years ago so maybe the firmware has updated.

  • @xiaochengpeng2581
    @xiaochengpeng2581 Před 4 lety +22

    While most people think fp10 is the best, I actually prefer yamaha... Roland's sound is just too soft to me.

    • @joeritchie8653
      @joeritchie8653 Před 4 lety

      I agree that Roland is too soft. It would hard to get it to cut through a mix.

    • @jsonkody
      @jsonkody Před 4 lety

      it's possible to tweak in app

    • @user-fn1ot9es3b
      @user-fn1ot9es3b Před 3 lety

      true! the roland blends really smoothly but louder playing on that sounds a bit held back to me

  • @FutureArtGroup
    @FutureArtGroup Před 5 lety +258

    FP-10>P-45>S100

  • @marike1100
    @marike1100 Před 4 lety +18

    I prefer the P45 in this video. Roland's SuperNatural modeling is very good, but at times the piano sounds a bit dark or slightly muffled because of the missing upper harmonics.

    • @theoneaboveall886
      @theoneaboveall886 Před 4 lety

      Or in others words, Roland Sounds Very very Jazzy, yeahhhhhh

  • @JourneyMaster
    @JourneyMaster Před 4 lety +3

    Last month. I bought the Yamaha P-45, but decided to return it, and got the Roland FP-10 instead. Both are good keyboards, just that, after seeing some of the reviews, than playing the Roland FP-10, I decided it was a better choice for me.

  • @Hlebka
    @Hlebka Před 3 lety +4

    Definitely Yamaha P45: better sound and very well balanced.
    Casio sounds plastic like a toy with lots of EQ, and artificial dynamics.
    Many people are wondering "Why is the sustain on casio is so short?" "Did you use a pedal " Thats just the way Casio is, I tried it at local shop and was really disappointed with how short the notes were

  • @alygator6128
    @alygator6128 Před 2 lety +4

    Damn, I haven't played in a few years due to not having one, but I can't still nail this blind test. These three companies really have unique sounds, btw this is a beautiful song ! I'm so looking forward to start playing again... You won't escape me forever FP10 !

    • @unotoli
      @unotoli Před 2 lety +1

      Check FP-30X sound is much better. Otherwise Pianoteq7.5 + FP10 is the sweetest combo.

    • @alygator6128
      @alygator6128 Před 2 lety +2

      @@unotoli I finally bought my FP10 after waiting for like 4 years and tbh I'm so happy, maybe I'll upgrade later on for a FP30 but for now it's perfect ! I played on acoustic pianos for like 10 years and this Roland feels perfect to me !

    • @ryanbianchi6582
      @ryanbianchi6582 Před 2 lety

      It’s a $100 difference. If you were planning to upgrade, you should have just paid it from the start

    • @alygator6128
      @alygator6128 Před 2 lety

      Update, I started learning the song in this video a few weeks ago and I finally finished learning it today! Such a nice song to listen to and play 😍

    • @alicoach1587
      @alicoach1587 Před 2 lety +1

      @@alygator6128 What is the name of the song?

  • @babarossaalbert5011
    @babarossaalbert5011 Před 4 lety +24

    Could you please publish the sheet of that lovely Song or do a Tutorial ?

  • @suppohkram
    @suppohkram Před 4 lety +6

    P-45 sounds brighter and is more articulate, whereas FP-10 is mellower (more mellow?) and borderline muddy. But another way of saying that is that the blend is nice. I can see FP-10 being much more effective for softer or melancholy passages/pieces, which makes me like it most. The S100 sounded awful at first, as if the notes lacked any nuance, but after a while I sorta got used to it, and I didn’t mind it so much.

    • @lonely_potato4660
      @lonely_potato4660 Před 2 lety

      I think “ more mellow” would be more grammatically correct.

  • @MrJsinwrld
    @MrJsinwrld Před 4 lety +8

    All have good sound... But in richness I'll go for yamaha b45

  • @aquapro8375
    @aquapro8375 Před 2 lety +2

    И все таки я не ошибся, когда купил Yamaha P-45. И это радует)))

  • @teron9997
    @teron9997 Před 4 lety +6

    That last one sounded like a bright piano

  • @qtlandon8477
    @qtlandon8477 Před 4 lety +34

    yo! what is that song called!? Its literal fire!
    EDIT: Ok i know what its called now. For all of you who dont know, its called The academy theme from homm 4. ;)

  • @FaeSparrow
    @FaeSparrow Před 7 měsíci

    This video made me decide to buy a Roland fp10 instead of the Casio. Someone called it a bit 'dark and muffled' - but honestly, I really like that! It has a much warmer feel to it.

  • @masterfireworks1734
    @masterfireworks1734 Před 3 lety

    So cool you did this Video. Thousands of people need this for their decision wheter Yamaha P-125 or Roland FP-30 or Kawai ES-110.

    • @ayrtoninchejanampa6874
      @ayrtoninchejanampa6874 Před 3 lety

      The roland has a slightly heavier action than the Kawai and the Yamaha, I think you can say that Roland is the best, but in terms of sounds if you have to choose according to your tastes.

  • @tszabon
    @tszabon Před 3 lety +4

    I have Roland FP-30 and I love it. FP-10 sounds the same.

    • @zjaeger1800
      @zjaeger1800 Před 2 lety

      helpful comment! Im maybe about to buy a FP-30 due to its higher polyphones. Can you explain why the FP-10 sounds the same? How can that be considering a price difference around 200€?

  • @mrdeen5532
    @mrdeen5532 Před 4 lety +6

    No 2 i liked more than others.

  • @midohamada8875
    @midohamada8875 Před 5 lety +4

    Thank you very very much for this video .. Casio is out of the deal .. yamaha and roland win and for me, their piano sounds are the same so we may prefer one of them depends on other features such as weight, connectivity and so on

    • @innosanto
      @innosanto Před rokem

      Casio has the best keyboard, the sound can be changed with sound engine.

    • @e0236
      @e0236 Před 8 měsíci

      @@innosanto how can I improve the sound (without connecting to a PC)?

  • @darkstalkeralbatross5754
    @darkstalkeralbatross5754 Před 4 lety +1

    Piano 1- 0:00
    Piano 2- 0:55
    Piano 3- 1:48

  • @aefonta
    @aefonta Před 3 lety +13

    Roland the best by far... But i've tried the casio keybed and find it very nice. I was considering buying it as a midi controller but i'm not sure if that is possible (i hope to connect it to a Nord Electro). Also haven't tried the FP-10 keybed yet...

    • @alohaspirit1506
      @alohaspirit1506 Před 3 lety +2

      Yes, I was in a store and the Roland was the best for me, but I want to buy the Casio because it's red! My musician friend told me that Casio is like a transistor to a stereo.

  • @michelgardes
    @michelgardes Před 4 lety +2

    Watching this video changed my mind. Thanks.

  • @Bro-u9m
    @Bro-u9m Před 5 lety +17

    Roland👍

  • @k.silberberg5137
    @k.silberberg5137 Před 2 lety

    No.1. Honest. Clear. Not too perfect. I love it.

  • @AGAU1022
    @AGAU1022 Před 5 lety +6

    Yamaha (first one) the brightest and also just seemed louder overall, so I thought it sounded the best at first and the Roland sounded the worst, but once I adjusted for this by turning the volume up the Roland sounded the best, much more realistic. The Roland also feels the best to me in store. The Casio is in between the two in terms of brightness, so a fine compromise. Casio pianos are much better than people say, especially for the price, but I think paying a bit more for the FP-10 is worth it.

    • @ayrtoninchejanampa6874
      @ayrtoninchejanampa6874 Před 5 lety

      That's why it's always good to try the pianos to choose which one you like, as I always say everything is a matter of taste

  • @halukyildiz4126
    @halukyildiz4126 Před 2 lety +1

    i am not a player or expert...and i dont have any of them....but in first listening...i blindly chose Roland....i think it sounds natural...casio more digital than Yamaha...but the best is Roland....as here i listened....

  • @AndrewSowerby
    @AndrewSowerby Před 5 lety +36

    The FP-10 is just ahead of the P45 - I was surprised.

    • @xXCloudFantasiXx
      @xXCloudFantasiXx Před 5 lety +12

      Thats your opinion. I think the Yamaha has the better Sound

    • @AndrewSowerby
      @AndrewSowerby Před 5 lety +37

      @@xXCloudFantasiXx well, obviously it's my opinion - I wouldn't be giving anyone else's opinion ;)

    • @vccranker
      @vccranker Před 4 lety +1

      I thought the Yamaha sounded the best. The Casio, sounded close, but slightly more like a harpsichord, while the Roland sounded slightly muffled. But it may just be settings, placement of mic, or?

    • @joeritchie8653
      @joeritchie8653 Před 4 lety

      I think that slightly muffled sound is a characteristic of Roland because they use the Steinway and Sons NY piano as their piano sound. Steinways always sound like that to me.

    • @user-zr5hz3bi1w
      @user-zr5hz3bi1w Před 4 lety

      @@xXCloudFantasiXx thats your opinion. you can see many opinions here.

  • @SPADEZ71X26
    @SPADEZ71X26 Před 4 lety +34

    i literally just bought an FP10, then watched this video. thank god i made the right choice!

  • @bellescarla7307
    @bellescarla7307 Před rokem +1

    What piece is this? Very beautiful! Nostalgic!

  • @sublyme2157
    @sublyme2157 Před 4 lety +2

    Piano 1 is the only one that sounded real to my ears. Piano 3 sounded like a cross between a piano and harpsichord. Piano 2 was ok I guess. Thanks for the comparison!

  • @tlmn777
    @tlmn777 Před 3 lety +4

    Roland FP-10 однозначно, звук детальный от "а" до "я" в этой ценовой категории! У P45 звук выразительный, но менее детализированный: средние частоты отсутствуют практически абсолютно, поэтому он и кажется выразительным! Casio в этот ряд вообще не становится...

  • @hughmungus2691
    @hughmungus2691 Před 4 lety +2

    Brilliant video idea. Two thumbs up if I could.

  • @goodcyrus
    @goodcyrus Před rokem +1

    1ST AND 3RD ONE HAVE SHRILL HIGH END. THE 2ND ONE SOUNDS LIKE A REAL PIANO HEARD THRU A SMALL RADIO. ARE THESE THE SPEAKER OUTPUTS OR LINE OUT? HUGE DIFFERENCE

  • @Alexarntzen
    @Alexarntzen Před 2 lety +2

    Went in blind, and thougt sound 3 was the best. Luckaly it was the S100 which I just have ordered :D

  • @MrKen-gi7ci
    @MrKen-gi7ci Před rokem

    Yamaha P-45 : 2:38
    Roland FP-10 : 3:33
    Casio CDP-S-100 : 4:26

  • @jmacias4654
    @jmacias4654 Před 3 lety +2

    A mi parecer el P-45 tiene un sonido mas profundo. Mi elección Yamaha P-45 "Me atrapa"

  • @nytrex_tlnb
    @nytrex_tlnb Před 5 lety +20

    Roland is better
    But Yamaha is very good

  • @mrAlabaster
    @mrAlabaster Před 3 lety +7

    I need the sheets for this wonderful piece of music

  • @rafaelescudero9687
    @rafaelescudero9687 Před 5 lety +7

    Definitely the yamaha p45, its affordable, good price and great quality sound

  • @rogercarroll2551
    @rogercarroll2551 Před 4 lety +5

    The Roland !!!

  • @jennyc1520
    @jennyc1520 Před 4 lety +4

    What is the name of this music? Could I find the sheets somewhere please?

  • @ohaiderepeeps828
    @ohaiderepeeps828 Před 4 lety +1

    Piano 1 0:00
    Piano 2 0:55
    Piano 3 1:47

  • @danoslehoy
    @danoslehoy Před 4 lety +2

    It should be seen what sound was used in each register. It seems to me that it is not a fair comparison.

  • @RobManser77
    @RobManser77 Před 3 lety

    Is it just me, or:
    1. Fine.
    2. Is there a thick sock over the microphone?
    3. Yuk.
    Are there variables here accentuating this? Differences in recording? Modes the pianos were in?

  • @windproxy4362
    @windproxy4362 Před 10 měsíci

    Thank you. This helped me a lot.

  • @raniericampos9050
    @raniericampos9050 Před 3 lety +1

    Does anyone know the name of the song?

  • @SONOMA_VALLEY_TOM
    @SONOMA_VALLEY_TOM Před 4 lety

    Exact same opinion and circumstances as PandaGuitar. Casio is on sale at Musician's Friend. But I much prefer the sound of the Roland. Thanks for the demo shoot out. Stopped me from making a bad purchase decision!

  • @bleuneptune
    @bleuneptune Před 4 lety +1

    My guesses and preference 1.Roland. (a bit digital like) 2. Yahama(favorite.. smooth, with more depth) 3. Casio (my least favorite... too bright, too digital like) God... I like the second the best the 1 and 3 are both a bit too digital like. Finally, Roland is not disappointing now!!! And I always guess Casio correctly because they just sound very digital and not natural smooth enough.

  • @user-fq4uc6gl8v
    @user-fq4uc6gl8v Před 3 lety +5

    Очень понравилась в звучание ямаха, глубокий звук, объемное звучание. Касио сухо звучит. Благодарю за познание и воспроизведение.
    .

    • @nadezhda8556
      @nadezhda8556 Před 3 lety

      Такое же мнение.

    • @tlmn777
      @tlmn777 Před 3 lety +2

      Может у P45 звук губже, но у F10 от более детализированней на средних тонах!..

  • @hcho8164
    @hcho8164 Před 4 lety +6

    I wish people played classical music that have been recorded by great artists from the past. This way we can compare apples to apples.

  • @S_Z.
    @S_Z. Před 2 lety +1

    3 out of 3 🤘🤘

  • @CouyosenciaX
    @CouyosenciaX Před 4 lety +4

    If the Casio's sustain had been longer, maybe it would sound better.

  • @recorr
    @recorr Před 3 lety +3

    i don't know how you did to make casio sounds so bad !
    Mine in Grand Piano sounds much like the Roland.
    Very strange.

  • @ei..
    @ei.. Před 3 lety +1

    I like the sound of the Rolad the best, but it sort of sound like is coming more from the left side. Is this just something with the recording?

  • @terrib5262
    @terrib5262 Před rokem

    This is very helpful! Thanks!

  • @fathulbari2010
    @fathulbari2010 Před 3 lety +1

    Roland FP 10 of course 👍

  • @abrahampatterson25
    @abrahampatterson25 Před 2 lety +3

    Piano 2 (Roland FP10) is by far the best keyboard of the 3. The Yamaha comes very close in sound quality but the Roland has many more features than the yamaha that aren’t talked about in this video. The Casio isn’t a terrible option to save money, but if you’re planning on performing with this keyboard, it sounds like literal fart cream. I would Buy the Roland FP10 if money were not much of a matter, but now it sells for closer to $7-800 and the yamaha is still around $500. The yamaha I feel is the smarter buy on a budget, but the $200 is definitely worth a world of difference. Sorry Casio, you have some good keyboards but not this one.

  • @MrWonszBoa
    @MrWonszBoa Před rokem

    Tip: hit the 1, 2 or 4 keys on your keyboard to jump between the pianos in this video.

  • @vadimsemenov7082
    @vadimsemenov7082 Před 4 lety +3

    Yamaha звучит ярче, но у Roland есть эффект резонанса струн и при длительной игре не возникает ощущения отдельно звучащих нот , как у Yamaha. Casio-здесь не конкурент.

  • @obligatorynagger
    @obligatorynagger Před 5 lety +5

    Hi, can you please compare the action and touch sensitivity of the Casio and Yamaha? Which one is better?

  • @corndogconnoisseur
    @corndogconnoisseur Před 3 lety +1

    As much as I want a Yamaha or Roland Digital Piano, I just don't have that kind of budget for a musical instrument that I want to play as a hobby. The Casio CDP-S100 is pretty much the best Digital Piano that barely fits into my budget so it's kind of disappointing yet expected when I can clearly recognize which of these sounds and perform better.

    • @goodlookinouthomie1757
      @goodlookinouthomie1757 Před rokem

      Yeah I feel you. It was a big spend for me, but the way I see it, one of these costs no more than an XBox and that's what I'd be wasting my time on if I wasn't learning piano.

  • @jfan4reva
    @jfan4reva Před 4 lety +1

    Listening, I was hoping #2 was the Roland. If you weren't doing a side by side comparison, the Casio would be an acceptable keyboard, but hearing all three together, you can tell the small, but clear difference. Yamaha for brilliance, Roland for warmth. (Casio for price?)

  • @sypher0101
    @sypher0101 Před 2 lety +1

    Didn't quite like sound #3. The higher note sounds like its from a 1800s saloon. There was no ring to it when played (not sure of correct term).
    I liked #2 a little more than #1. It felt a little softer/warmer sound, if you know what I mean.

  • @anmolagrawal5358
    @anmolagrawal5358 Před 5 lety +9

    I think Roland clearly wins as it sounded the best to my ears. While the Casio one feels unnatural, Yamaha doesn't sound too good either, the sound doesn't seem to harmonize that well. So it would be hard to judge b/w Yamaha and Casio. Out of the three, my pick would definitely be Roland.

    • @graceongiphonesg
      @graceongiphonesg Před 5 lety +2

      Yes, roland very rich warm mellow tone and does not sound annoying for higher chords or notes.

  • @Astronomater
    @Astronomater Před 4 lety

    Liked piano 2 the most but they were all competent. I am currently in the market for one in this price range. My choice is the FP-10 due to its 3 year warranty.

  • @Adelfus
    @Adelfus Před 3 lety +2

    My top:
    1) roland
    2) yamaha
    3) casio
    I'll buy roland fp-30

  • @joeritchie8653
    @joeritchie8653 Před 4 lety +7

    I liked all three. For myself I am more interested in the key action because I plan to use whichever one I buy as a virtual piano controller. I tried out the P 45 the other day and the key action seemed weird because I felt like I had to push through something to get the keys to go all the way down.

    • @cmfrtblynmb02
      @cmfrtblynmb02 Před 4 lety +1

      Yeah. What is not included in this video is the key action. Yamaha is the worst among 3 in terms of key action. For a beginner level pianist, this is what matters most IMHO.

  • @tetianabudakova776
    @tetianabudakova776 Před rokem

    The 1 is the winner for me!

  • @phonepianist
    @phonepianist Před 3 lety +6

    Ahhhhhhh,I got the first one correct,the last one is quiet thick,I forgot if it's Roland or Casio,confirmed not Yamaha :(

  • @arnavkulkarni2370
    @arnavkulkarni2370 Před rokem +2

    FP-10>>>>P-45>S-100

  • @joseantoniomedinaperez8106

    Yamaha es el mejor a mi gusto!

  • @user-cj2ch6gd1k
    @user-cj2ch6gd1k Před 5 lety +6

    CDPS100,P45と比較するならB1でないとおかしい。FP10は、ES110,PXS1000,P125と比較すべき機種。
    さらに、このデモンストレーターのCDPS100の時のダンパーペダルの踏み遅れで、ダンパーがかからず、音がブツ切れになっている。CDPS100は、内蔵スピーカーから出す場合、低音がこもった音になる。P45やB1は、内蔵スピーカーから音を出しても劣化が少ない。CDPS100は、LINE出力でスタジオPAを通した場合は、同様の場合のB1やP45より音がいい。

    • @lirending1
      @lirending1 Před 5 lety +1

      oh ok. I got it.

    • @sean5171
      @sean5171 Před 5 lety

      I had a casio electrical piano, the sustain damper is not full sustained, it feel like half pedaling. From here both yamaha P45 and roland fp10 sounds equally good. It depends on which sound of piano you are use to listen.

  • @Mister.Chills
    @Mister.Chills Před 2 lety +1

    Whats the name of the song?

  • @Quest4Truth1968
    @Quest4Truth1968 Před 3 lety

    Great work
    Thanks!