I bought a fake Marshall Emberton II and compared it with the original.
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
- I have recently bought a fake Marshall Emberton II off eBay. The seller was claiming it to be refurbished, however I have bought the original, comparing it - so you don't have to fall into the same trap!
What's in the video?
00:00 - Intro
00:14 - Packaging
01:24 - The Emberton II
02:14 - Device behaviour
02:56 - Sound
Song used from the CZcams Audio Library: Knowpe - Noir Et Blanc Vie
Thank you , I saw discount 70% and bought online , I thought it was my lucky day , then after reviewing your video , I realize I bought a fake one …..now I am so disappointed , thank you again
I received today an received fake . Trap in 72% discount
Please share the link where I can get the fake one
Thanks a lot because of this I return my fake one to the seller I already buy my original one to the official store which is 50% much expensive. The fake one sounds cheap and no bass which is quite dissapointing.
Glad to hear you didn’t fall for it! Thanks for sharing.
Please share link
Where can I get a fake Emberton 2 speaker
I have a genuine one from Marshall themselves and it also makes a sound when switching tracks and pausing.
That's mighty strange, I have an EU model with the latest firmware from the app. And I am fairly happy it does not make any sounds switching tracks :))
@I review things Very strange indeed. If you have a look at Flossy Carter's review of the original Marshall Emberton, his one also makes a sound when switching tracks and pausing. I very much doubt he bought fakes - Marshall likely sent him the Emberton to review.
Older models have sound when switching tracks, on play/pause and when maxing the volume, they also have better clicking main button and louder on/off sound. I have two, "first generation" with silver grill and white logo and black and brass color I bought a month ago. Marshall changed all that for some reason, probably for "quieter" experience, but less clickable button was the first thing I noticed and it still bothers me.
@@ZJavakh That makes a lot of sense. Thanks!
That might be because it is direct from the factory and not authorized by marshall. I do have the same as you it is a genuine marshall and straight from the factory but they said it is not authorized by marshall itself
I just returned 2 sets of fake Marshall Major IV headsets. They looked very nice, operated correctly and felt top notch but once the sound was turned on...yuck!. The proof is always in the pudding.
Good comparison! And helpful! But, at no time did you point to or label which was fake and which was real! The textures are completely different so it would have helped! When comparing the textures you said the real one was smooth but the fake was sticky!! You can't see sticky!!! Overall it was good but you were left to assume which was which ! We all know what that does!!??
🟦…I was just gonna post the same sentiment,...
...So ridiculous that he doesn't positively identify the units THROUGHOUT the ENTIRE video!
Wow you saved me. Now I notice - bought fake.
I just met up with someone who was selling one on fb marketplace and I’m glad I didn’t get it. Pretty sure it was a fake. The app didn’t connect and the sound sounded barely better than my iPhone.
Gondammit. I was wondering how could such an expensive speaker sound like trash. Thanks for this. Im going to return it.
I bought a cheap fake from Thailand. Sounds great, looks great... but I don't want to compare to the real one that's 5x the price. I'm sure the real one is much better when the sound is compared up close.
And which on is a fake?
The best judgement you can do is to teardown that fake emberton, once you open it you'll be amazed with the amp worth a penny😂 the cheap amp is just beneath the power button.
I'd recently ordered 80% off Marshall Emberton II on Instagram, So it means it's fake? Okayy I will cancel it. Thank you for this video.
You from in ph?
Thank's bro
Is it really fake the one from ph?
How to cancel the order?
How about in Flipkart. There's sale now
which one fake which one is original?
Check 02:33 - the one at the bottom is the fake!
yah loh！he never say which one is fake😂
At 0:03, the lower side unit seems fake.
A "close-out" store near me is selling this for $30. I think that pretty much guarantees it's a fake.
There's so many difference between the quality sound?
i got the fake one today - the logo is not plugged yet. take it as bad experience ... the store has block me ... real bad day
I thought you opened the grill, maybe some difference
Thank you that you save my money 😉
How can we order online?
So basically, you can check just by using the mobile application, right? If it's connecting then it's real?
I wouldn't 100% rely on that because the fake manufacturers will eventually find a way to spoof the bluetooth ids or whatever, but that would be my first quick test!
If u buy it use low price fake always the best option 😊
How can i order
Both seem fake to me
Original emberton has “emberton” logo imprinted deep and not raised up as seen in both samples
you're wrong, the Emberton logo indeed is raised on the original. Got it next to me :)
@@i-review-things yah true ,
Why not put a caption on the video which one is fake and real ? Or an arrow to let us know which one is which on your video
algún comentario en español porfis
??
There’s “UK CA” printed on genuine Emberton but not on fake one
well, they could easily reproduce this based off this hint :)
Is the fake one still worth to buy because its cheap?
trust me, the sound was as good as a tin can. Wouldn't recommend it for 10 bucks
Its true in Philippines sale of marshall?
fake
does the fake speaker connect with the marshall mobile app?
@2:50...try watching the video.
never :)
No
which box is real at 0:24, also which silica gel is real at 1:24?
At 0:24 the box to the right. The original box (sold in Germany) does not have any "genuine" sticker in Chinese letters. And for 1:24 the silica pack on the right is the one from the original box, I wouldn't use this as a benchmark to verify if its legit though ;)
So I can confirm that mine Emberton 2 have all the same components as your real one here. Thanks a lot, good guy.
where is the original ang fake Inyour video
They look identical to me
I this same manufacturing but only grade that why they said fake
How do you know it's fake?
By comparing it to the original device from a large media store & validating photos with the Emberton Support 😋
does it by any chance work in stack mode?
In order to support stack mode you have to have both two original devices because they need to be paired in the Marshall App
@@i-review-things yeah, I just saw some aliexpress sellers that explicitly claim they cannot be paired with the app so stack mode obviously doesnt work
just a minute of sound comparison would have been better
True, I sadly don't have the equipment to make this audible on youtube
Could you please show the sound difference?
Super hard to make an audible comparison on CZcams. Trust me, the fake sounds like a tin box! 😉
Please try to improve your presentation to have more subscribers
does the fake one have app support?
no it does not :) will never get recognized
Its not the same becos dat is emberten 1 va emberton 2 the rubber case really not the same
From where did you buy the fake emberton?
eBay, sold as “refurbished”
@@i-review-things please share link bro
Shit I just bought a fake one
我買到假貨了，價格跟原價插不多，我買willen 和 emerton2，在台灣蝦皮買的，但可能從大陸寄過來，willem 正版官網賣3880，我買3100，emberton2 正版官網賣6490，我買5800元。 willen 連不到官網，也不能用stack模式，按鍵也要按很多次才有反應，橡膠套有一邊，沒有完整包覆，外箱還有防偽貼紙。我猜想中國盜版工廠，會和正版商品零件拆換，冒充正版。
另一台emberton2 就能連到官網，其他外貌也很像真的，我還要去正版商店看一下有甚麼不同，紙箱就和正版的 不同的樣子，看其他部影片查的
Mana yang fake
You will get a lot more views if you would talk nobody want to be reading stuff life is too busy for that
I make the opposite comment on all the videos where people don't shut the fuck up, so there's that.
Ga jelas😂😂😂 amatiran
Worthless comparison 👎
That's your own fault, Sir...that's why you only buy stuff at the authorized dealer such as Best Buy (in the US) or any authorized electronics store depending where you are.
Reviews like this is kind of BS, maybe you're just trying to attract lots of viewers. Such a waste of some people's time...😂
Thanks for the positivity, bud.
Bro he's legit helping people tell if they have a fake or not wth is your problem? You have mental issues bro. Maybe you scam people by selling these fakes and don't like him pointing out the difference. Psycho
Nah bruh. This sure helps a bunch. I mean, not everyone have direct access to Marshal's official store, thus they have to buy from reselling channels, right? Having a comparison sample does help people to know better about their product. Keep up the good work tho, OP.
Your fault is you feel free to judge others. And BS is yourself.