Classical Musicians React: SHINee 'Orgel' vs 'Trigger'
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 06. 2019
- For the 78th reaction video of Season 3 of this series, classical musicians react to SHINee's bsides 'Orgel' and 'Trigger.'
Listen to Orgel here: • SHINee (샤이니) - Orgel (...
Listen to Trigger here: • [Reupload] - SHINee 'T...
See whats new with CMR Season 3 here: • What's New With CMR Se...
*CMR Reaction Schedule: docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
*Will not react to list: • Will not be reacting to
*Support us on Patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
Send us things!
P.O. BOX 14933 ROCHESTER, NY 14614-1119
---------------------
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~ Channel twitter: @reacttothek
~ Channel tumblr: / reacttothek
~ Channel Facebook: / reacttothek ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Video edited by Umu Filmed by Jordan Moore (CZcams: / euphoniumplayer21797 ) and Umu Script written by fans on twitter!
Intro design by Alex Chen (website: www.acchen.com/) Thumbnail by Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Follow the ReacttotheK squad and keep up-to-date with our lives:
Umu:
IG: @_emcha_
Tumblr: attack-on-dango, omg-horns, kpop-favs
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Tumblr: / pjohnzzz
Charlotte:
Instagram: charmander_97
Her cat’s instagram: monty_le_chat_noir
Melissa:
IG: @melissa.447
Isaac:
IG: @Isaac.jr.li
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
CZcams: nerdymusicks
IG: @nerdymusick
Elizabeth:
IG: @ElizabethReacts
James:
IG: @jamesfhorn
Henry:
IG: @henry.carpender
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Jarod:
Instagram: @jarod_lau
Collin:
Website: www.collinholloway.com
FB page: collinhollowayguitar
Fiona:
IG+ twitter: @fifidoghorn
Aaron:
Insta: @aaronlee753 - Zábava
Our individual/unedited pair reactions for SHINee are available on our patreon! Pledge $5 and choose 3 different playlists to gain access to or pledge $14.99 and gain access to over 200 reaction playlists: www.patreon.com/reacttothek
(If you pledge $5 or more, you'll also get access to a visual effects artist reviewing Taemin's Flame of Love and SHINee's Breaking Down MVs!)
If you guys could react to A.C.E's Undercover that would be really awesome! They debuted in 2017 but I haven't seen them get much recognition for how good they are.
I think the gun in trigger may have colored their interpretation
Please react Jonghyun Lonely
Dang I *need* to see that flame of love video but I'm hella broke 💔
Please react to somi debut song birthday please
I love how Isaac always compliments Onew's vocals whenever he reacts to a SHINee song :')
SHINee
IS
ART
that's it.
Orgel is one of my favorite songs of all time ♥️ it's just SO SO GOOD!!! Thanks for reacting 😊
Orgel is one of my favorites it’s just so nice to listen to when it’s raining and the mood is dark, gives me the creeps
Trigger is not supposed to be taken so literally, its obviously a metaphorical take on the english saying (used more in older generations) "would you just pull the trigger already."
I cut this off a Google search:
pull the trigger (on something) To make a final decision or commit to a certain course of action (about something).
The song is more on being in a miserable and cornered situation where one has no other choice then to make a decision. I interpreted it as finally coming to the choice of cutting off or putting an end to a relationship.
No interpretation is wrong, im just disappointed that the reactors chose to ignore the musical cues and focus on the literal aspect of a gun and going off. I hate gun violence too, i get it, but Trigger is not a song advocating to go shoot up a place.
ikr?? i always so it as a metaphor of ending a relationship never as literal gun violence i was shocked that they interpreted this way lol
@@giuliaestrela8162 gun violence isn't an issue in South Korea like it is here in the gun nation (United States). So we might see it as something negative but it was never intended that way not to mention trigger is an old song. It wasn't ever about gun violence and it's sad that it's such a regular occurrence now in the USA that it's all everyone jumps to first.
@@val875 true, but that was their mistake. Becuase at first with just the title they said "ah we listen to this all the time in R&B" to then take it as "of course it was banned!" When I listen to kpop and jrock I HAVE to be open minded the fact of how society is out there. They don't have the level of gun violence that we have in the US so obviously Americans with no open minds will think of mass shootings with the song, and that is wrong.
The lacked of being open minded like a musician should
The discussions on Trigger were pretty disappointing imo. The music went along with the lyrics for me. To me, there’s a feeling of extreme bitterness and sarcasm, but there’s also a lot of anger. It goes through stages of sadness and despair, then bitterness and indifference, and finally that burst of anger and emotion. Following the burst of emotion (that EDM part) it slows back down into sadness, and that goes along so well with an actual circle of grief.
The whole idea of “shoot me and go” is pretty understandable. It’s in no way unheard of nor is it normalizing gun violence or anything (that discussion annoyed me the most). It can be easily just symbolic to how someone feels during a break up and not literal shooting, but it could also be an example of what someone who is really hurting might say in the moment. It’s a mixture of those two things (I believe). The song is dark because the lyrics and music are pretty emotional, but I feel such a connection to it (both of these songs) as well as many of their other songs. It feels like it completely describes what I’m going through whenever I listen to it which makes it so enjoyable (as well as the fact that they’re all so talented 💕).
Anyway, that’s all. Thanks for coming to my TEDTalk.
I also thought that the discussion for trigger was very lacking.
Agreed. It was surprising when so many of the reactors heard Trigger as “a banger” and “happy.” I hear it as ominous when the chorus hits, and angry when the edm hits. There’s a lot that I feel they missed, but it’s understandable if they were distracted by the lyrics or overwhelmed by something else for their first listen. I think it took me around 10 listens before I was able to not be overwhelmed by everything happening.
It’s one of my fav SHINee songs, so I may make an analysis video in the future to make up for the lack of in-depth commentary here.
@@ReacttotheK Yes. But it's their opinions :)
I agree, well described!
Thank you for this comment! Totally agree, and tbh it was actually a bit stressful imagining the song as "happy" by any means for me when I've always felt it invokes such a clear sense of pain, desperation, and bitterness... I agree that they may have been overwhelmed because the song is pretty strange and complex, but relieved to see here that I'm not alone in feeling these things.
SHINee always make such interesting music. It was always exciting back when they and f(x) were more active. Being pretty much the male and female equivalent of each other almost at times. I just loved the risks SM let them take
same,,, they are so experimental and always have creative music & consepts
it's kinda nostalgic remembering times when shinee's misconception and odd were released, also f(x)'s pink tape i just--
A loop of the intro of orgel has been my ringtone for like 5 years now lmao. Every now and again I like to use a loop of the intro for f(x)’s shadow too. I’ve always felt like they had a similar vibe.
YES I always say that Orgel and Shadow is literally perfectly related, just like f(SHINee) are sibling groups that are meant to be counterparts of each other
I have no idea how anyone could hear trigger as a happy song??? The whole thing is just a burst of emotions, anger, sadness, and the only "happy" parts are still bittersweet. There's nothing full sweet. It's like falling apart but desperately trying to grasp on the last positivity you have in a way. The end of a relationship and the way this toxic relationship is going they just can't see an end without it being the final end.
Exactly this!!
What I like about SHINee songs r that they r complex but in a good way. Their music evolve and don't stick on just "simple" beat. They might sound off at first but as u listen to it over and over again u find urself hooked into their songs.
Not being bias but even if u're not into kpop u would enjoy their music and not to mention that their harmony r ALWAYS on point. ❤💎
Saw SHINee in the title and clicked without reading the rest 🤩😍💙
For the first time I disagree with the opinions...and it's not because I'm a shawol. It's because in my opinion the music wasn't happy it was emotional and full of hurt. It's like being betrayed. You say someone stabbed you in the back..or they might as well stab you in the back....you don't mean It. I think it was taken more literally then intended.
This! I agree with you so much!
when you take the metaphor seriously..
I'd like to see a Woof Woof reaction though lmaooooo
SHINee always makes Great high quality musics, they create their own musics and they dont follow what is trend... i really love them so much
The "trigger" was supposed to end their relationship, I think. And wasn't actually referring to guns at all
I loooove trigger so much, and I just can't explain the feeling I get when I listen to it lol it's so stimulating? and i love onew's voice in it
Waiting for the day you throw the ultimate curveball that is Woof Woof 😂
Considering how they've made a cover of it, at least some of the reactors may have already seen it but I agree in that it would be amazing
The reaction is supposed to come out early August, so we'll get it soon!
@@notadri yaaaaaaaas
@@notadri I hope they are reacting to the concert's version. 😁
YEEEEES but she needs to show them the concert performance xD
i feel like they really missed the point with Trigger, it was clearly metaphorical and not as actual 'shooting' but ending of a relationship
I immediately recognized Key in the thumbnail 😂😂😂😂 I didn't even look at the title just the picture yeet
if y'all loved orgel, y'all would love the entire the misconception of me album
SHINee is so perfect
SHINee's music is always this weird but it turns out AMAZING
Finally reacted to SHINee in a long time. Thank you. 😍😍😍
when I first heard Orgel I was so spooked I barely sat through half the song before deleting it off my playlist; fast forward few years later when I re-listened again I was totally blown by how effective the song was evoking creepy vibes. only shinee :')
so happy to see some shinee content : ) great video as always!
What does she mean by "middle schoolers jamming to this at a school dance"?? Lol this is not a clubby song, nor is there a "negative message" behind it. They're obviously using those terms metaphorically which is what art is all about.. I've never seen musicians/artists not pick up such obvious metaphors and take everything literal?! disappointed.
But your channel is still one of the best reaction channels!
trigger and orgel are my all time favorite jams, simply because the music is so beautiful. I think most of them missed the point with Trigger, probably cuz they mostly tend to give comments during the song and maybe miss parts of the song. One of the main things being that when they say pull the trigger, they are talking about their relationship rather than a real gun. It's like a situation where you are in a relationship you are pretty much still committed to and in love, but you know your partner has 'moved on' and is 'over it'. The only reason you are together is that they are too guilty to really take that step. And you just want them to end it as you come to terms that it is over.
Okay maybe this is looking at it too much but I love when they laughed at "hey little shawty" because that was my reaction but also that it was big in 2008. The whole Odd album was just making nods at their early stuff and where they came from and they started in 2008. Also the part where Onew sings "lucifer." anyway I love shinee and they are the most adventurous people musically.
Orgel is one of the best songs, a masterpiece.
I was looking forward to another SHINee reaction and I'm so glad you did these songs! Though I'm a little disappointed that everyone took the lyrics so literally. Do they not understand metaphors? Anyways, thank you for reacting to SHINee.
You got me lowkEY dead laughing at Key edits thanks
Also wow the TASTE ♥
Thank you for another SHINee reaction!
SHINee reactions are everything thank you! Love orgel and trigger! Hope to see an undercover and tonight reaction!
Ya'll are reading into the lyrics too much. They are saying to pull the trigger on the relationship. To end the relationship. Not for her to shoot them literally.
I'm gonna say I'm really disappointed in them with the Trigger breakdown. They obviously weren't being literal? Idk. That kinda upset me. Trigger is one of my favorite songs.
Exactly!
SAME THO. that whole gun violence convo upset me more tbh.
@@tiff2813 same
Ive always interpreted pull the trigger as shinee telling their SO to go ahead and break up the relationship since its both already painful and destructive.
Orgel is a freaking MASTERPIECE.
OMG!!!! How long it's been since a SHINee's reaction!!!! 🎉
Thank you 🙆🙆🙆
Henry is clearly a Shawol. I love how everytime you put a shinee song, they always love it, and even if they dont they appreciate their voices/music in general. Thats SHINee for you. Always amazing. DO EVIL AND NIGHTMARE PLEASE
Orgel has always been one of my favorite Shinee songs. I'm so glad you featured this ^~^ This has been the first time I listened to it since...
I love the fact that THE ONE WHO LOVES SHINee's SONGS IS THE ONE WHO LOVES HIGHCLASS ART
Means, *Shawols are genius.*
I'm so happy you chose those two songs (and put them together in one vid!). I LOVE how this channel looks at b-sides too and does really interesting analyses. Trigger and Orgel really are two v interesting songs for me as a non-musician and I've loved them since they were released.
The editing in this video is 👌
Also, I live for people praising SHINee's vocals
I think Orgel is the only time I requested a song and it got reacted to! I LOVE that song, so so good.
Orgel and Trigger yessss I love this songs so much. ❤
React to Taemin Solo pleeeease
I Love you 💙
Onew sings
Isaac: WoW... Interesting voice... ❤
Every effing time! 😂
Omg thank you for this!!! Orgel is my favorite non title track by Shinee!! Actually everything in the Misconceptions Albums is just awesome
2:51 I'm screaming no one's talking about all the Keys LMAO the editor is a genius
I've been waiting for this reaction since you put it on the scheduel, omg i'm glad it's finally here!!!!
Thank you for reacting to SHINee!❤ You can never go wrong listening to ❤SHINee❤ because they never disappoint!😊
your all reaction makes me smiling .. SHINee creativity experimental has made their song become a beautiful arts song
If they like creepy songs, then they'll love Nightmare from the same album as Orgel ;)
I LOVE nightmare AND evil *_*
New experience for Trigger! Thank you for this review!
9:22 “wow very interesting voice” again, came from isaac🙌🏼
Thank you Thank you Thank you Thank you Thank you Thank you Thank you Thank you
Yaaay omg I love both these songs so much, very happy to see them on the channel.
Been waiting for this for so long!! 😭😭 Thank you!!!!! 😍😍😍
it's funny how isaac says in almost every shinee reaction that onew has an interesting/unique voice, like, remember him already .
YES LOVE SHINEE
You know what? Ive been waiting for you to react to Trigger and finally you made it. Aaaa thank you so much 💕💕💕
Finally I find it.actually I was seeking for a description for oragel. Thank u for this. I'm going to write this❤️
I am the happiest person cause of this video! I've been waiting for a reaction to orgel and it delivered! Truly a one of a kind song
Charlotte and Peyton have been my favorite pair for such a long time! They just getting better and better with every video.
all of shinee's songs never gonna let us down✊🏼
Never expected to see reaction to Orgel. It has always been my fav song and I'm glad it is recognized
와 이거 드디어 리액션 했네 리스트에 오르골 있어서 언제 나오나 기다렸는데ㅠㅠ 이제 영어 잘 하시는 분이 자막만 달아주시면 완벽 그자체
Really thank you for this! This is so unexpected haha, like wow thank you for reacting to Orgel I love the song so much it's basically my HS anthem lol. And for trigger I have no more to say, the fact that ODD is really my favorite album from SHINee so it's just so good! I enjoyed the reaction so much 😆
Orgel is one of my favorite songs ever ahhhh, I could keep listening to it over and over again and never be bored. Thank you guys for reacting to it!
Orgel is my fav. Thank you for the Reaction.
Thank you for react to SHINee! I think they are really amazing artists.
Can you react to Password? I think that is a Japanese song but it's really cool.
i love your shinee reactions so much :(
YES IVE BEEN WAITING FOR SO LONG OMG THE BEST SHINee SONGS HANDS DOWN
Trigger is one of my favorite songs by SHINee
The way you presented shinee got me to tears. Thank u❤️
OMG YES I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR YEARS FOR THIS!!
I'm always here for SHINee reactions
OH MY GOD, i see shinee and i clicked and like!!! Thank youuu
Estava esperando essa reaction desde do ano passado... thankss!
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS SO MUUUUUUCH. KSKFKSKA.
Orgel has always been a favorite mine. That album was sooooo gooooood
I was waiting for their reaction on SHINee. Thank you Umu and thank you reactors💜
SHINee Finally 😭😭
Orgel is my fav tho!! Thank you for another shinee content. Their musicality is interesting to be talked
Lyrics for the song ,,ORGEL"were written by our dear Kim Jonghyun💜💜💜one of the most my favorite songs!
I loved the editor's puns
And to answer Kevin's question while quoting Key's Show Me: "that's the key"
As well as with the "it's odd" then the odd album kept flashing hahahha
YESSSSS THANK U FOR THIS UMUUUUUUU
8:10 god Charlotte is such a mood 10/10 me too girl.
shinee shaping music.....thts it yeah
SHINee is art ❤
i love this so much ;-; the misconception of us is the best tbh
Shinee’s musics are just AWESOME
yes, orgel is one of my favourite songs ever, I love it, thank you ;-;
Orgel is my favorite SHINee song of all-time, so I was really excited to see the reaction and discussion of the song!
YES MORE SHINEE REACTIONS !! PLEASE DO MORE SHINEE REACTIONS :D
I used to think you just give your friends react to whatever fans asked you to. But idk for SHINee case, it seems like you do choose their song very well and not restrict to MVs only. Thank you for choosing good songs of SHINee to react with 😊
i really love it when you reacting to shinee😍
OMG THANK U FOR THIS VIDEO PLS DO SHINEE MORE🙏
Fiona looks amazing with her new haircut 🔥❤️