In 1899 a wise man once said: When the time comes, you gotta run and don’t look back. In 1911 another wise man said: Go and don’t look back. Unfortunately, both John and Jack looked back :(
@@HISTORYSQUARE That's not what he said. He said John at the end of rdr1 become as mature as Arthur as the end of rdr2, which is true. John's mistake you are refering too doesn't happen at thé end of rdr1
@HISTORYSQUARE Arthur was a mistaken man too, historysquare. The life of outlaws is harsh and ends quick if you're honest. There's no place in the world of outlaws for good men and in this point of history there was no place in the world for outlaws either.
The fact Arthur was written into the first one without even existing yet is insane the level of story telling rockstar do is amazing imagine if they made films instead of games!!
@j.t.lawler608 I mean, he did say that Arthur was written into the first one.... soooo, maybe check your reading comprehension skills as well. And to the original commenter, rdr was not written with Arthur in mind. which, in retrospect, is actually harder from a writing perspective. Writing a comprehensive and emotional story driven by a complex and morally grey character with an open-ended ending while remaining consistent with earlier projects that take place after the story you are currently writing is a far more commendable achievement. Rockstar may have a lot of issues, but no one can deny their absolutely phenomenal writing prowess.
I like that a lot of men would maybe take some offense or be saddened that their son learned to fish from another man, but John seems genuinely happy Arthur taught his son.
Arthur saying you got to run and don’t look back also reminded me of that Michael quote from GTA. “One day you wake up and your legs just give, and you can’t run anymore”
Probably the best story I think I’ve ever played. Both games were so well detailed and fit with each other perfectly. This is all rockstar at its finest.
Moral of the story, live wild, live free. When you think you’ve got your forever anything, life does take it away, and when it does viciously so. These games really brilliantly shows the harsh reality of loss
The wise words of a man long forgotten but left a impact in our hearts::::I gave you everything I had I did my best😢😢😢😢😢 ~Dutch Vanderlinn , Arthur Morgan😢 you will never be forgotten even after you are long gone.
When i was a young boy and finish rdr 1 when John dead i wasn't having any feelings but when i finish it again and seeing John die it was so fu*k sad 😔
My very own John Marston is my Uncle Dan. Has property in Ocala, out fashioned cowboy. Horse riding, gun shooting, quick draw son of a gun! Just visited him not long ago he might have 3 years if he’s lucky to live but he’s a fighter like John. We all got someone we see as a legend in our family….at least I hope everyone does
I wish there was more epilogue content in RDR1 like there was with RDR2, Jack really is an interesting character due to him being really the last outlaw from the original van der linde gang, and falling into the same trap his father did with revenge and anger.
In the RDR2 Epilogue, I always get so emotional when one of the characters mention Arthur or repeat something Arthur did. Like how John repeated going fishing with Jack when a few years back Arthur did the same. I haven’t played the first game yet, but this series never fails to make me cry. 😕😕 rip Arthur
When I played RDR2 I quit when Arthur died, but went back to RDR1 when the scene played out I was hoping John would go as well, but it broke me when he had turned towards barn door...
What’s impressive is that rdr1 was set after rdr2 even though it released first and rockstar had to basically put all the details from rdr1 into rdr2 but the only downside is that they were talking about so much things from rdr2 in rdr1 and we just didn’t rlly understand what they meant
I would love a trilogy or duology of movies that retells the stories of RDR1 or 2 (and I say 2 or 3 movies because 1 just isn't enough, even if it is 3 hours) I'd find it hard for them to fuck it up because the script and story outline is basically written for them already, they'd just need to condense it.
In 1899 a wise man once said: When the time comes, you gotta run and don’t look back.
In 1911 another wise man said: Go and don’t look back.
Unfortunately, both John and Jack looked back :(
Jack lived bro
@user-ls8sd7wz4t we know but he looked back to get revenge like John for arthur
He carried on the cycle and if his is the same as Arthur or John he will die aswell@@Germn_Mice
That’s is the only reference of Arthur in RDR1
@@Mustang_Rider86Arthur wasnt a character when rdr 1 was made theres no references to him
“ don’t look back “ now where have we heard that before 😢
No where since rdr1 was the first
@@supergamingclips1not chronologically
@@duhbigweiner665 yes
@@supergamingclips1 pluh rdr2 takes place before rdr1
@@duhbigweiner665 exactly
"When the time comes, you gotta run, and dont look back." - Arthur Morgan 1899
John should have listen
@@mrsnuffles398John went on a path of revenge after Micah’s death
Damn if theres only option "Run away"
Or "Sacrifice" If they remake the game
This is over
@Containeds "vengeance is a luxury we can't afford", and unfortunately, Mr. Marston found out the hard way 😢
I think John became as mature as Arthur when Arthur gave his life for John to have the life he did
No john made too many mistakes despite arthur saving him.
He went back to the place arthur saved him from.
And now do did jack
@@HISTORYSQUAREwas stuck in his ways. He was an outlaw
@@HISTORYSQUARE That's not what he said.
He said John at the end of rdr1 become as mature as Arthur as the end of rdr2, which is true. John's mistake you are refering too doesn't happen at thé end of rdr1
@HISTORYSQUARE Arthur was a mistaken man too, historysquare. The life of outlaws is harsh and ends quick if you're honest. There's no place in the world of outlaws for good men and in this point of history there was no place in the world for outlaws either.
Wonderfully said! @@itsshrimp91
Ross : "Enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can"
Adult Jack : lol
Lol
Jack pulled a reverse card
a whole 15 years later
Teen jack* He's 19 while killing Ross
@@jsp94018 is considered adult but each one is fine
He should’ve taken Arthur’s advice and not looked back
he didn’t really have a choice, they took his family and used him to kill the remaining members of the gang. then they killed him too
@@OGBOBBYJ1400 I think there talking about John killing Micah causing Ross to find them causing his death
@@MemeDeeeyeah John's bullet led edgar ross to John
@@MemeDeeeeven if he didn’t kill micah they would have still reach to him
@@LxzaaNo they wouldn’t have Done it micah was working for the pinkertons which is why they went after John when he had killed micah
The fact Arthur was written into the first one without even existing yet is insane the level of story telling rockstar do is amazing imagine if they made films instead of games!!
No. Arthur wasn't written in first one. What gives you that idea?
@j.t.lawler608 I mean, he did say that Arthur was written into the first one.... soooo, maybe check your reading comprehension skills as well. And to the original commenter, rdr was not written with Arthur in mind. which, in retrospect, is actually harder from a writing perspective. Writing a comprehensive and emotional story driven by a complex and morally grey character with an open-ended ending while remaining consistent with earlier projects that take place after the story you are currently writing is a far more commendable achievement. Rockstar may have a lot of issues, but no one can deny their absolutely phenomenal writing prowess.
@@dobil6815he was but wasnt
@814- no he wasnt 😊
@@Yo00o09mflstop, too much brain hert
this makes grown men cry
So true
I cried at the end of rdr1
Nah
@@wiz6587you must be a child then.
It sure does
The way John says "that's nice" breaks my heart. It sounds so serene and full of love.
I literally just finished this mission about 2 hours ago… now I have depression again just like I had with Arthur
Don't worry your not alone friend
I played rdr2 first
Seeing john trow away arthurs words was truly even more heart breaking
@@HISTORYSQUAREmakes sense, as 2 is a prequel
Same
u do not have depression lmao its just a game its not that serious stop being dramatic
I like that a lot of men would maybe take some offense or be saddened that their son learned to fish from another man, but John seems genuinely happy Arthur taught his son.
Because he knew he was a good man. The fact that I know they both die makes it sad.
He was offended . He said he was in the cattle mission
This GOAT Game deserves a great movie. 😢
Movie can't replicate the interaction we have with the game.
@@debojyotijana9187but it can tell the story
Jack Black said the same about both RDR and GTA games
Hollywood would shit all over it
If they could make a movie, they should make one for each chapter of the game
“You don’t get to live a bad life and have good things happen to you” -Arthur Morgan
Rdr1 John was as stoic and fearless as any man could ever dream of being.
I really do not like how they fucked up those aspects of his Character in the prequel.
@@Broken_Savior it made sense though, cause he was younger
@@elkreizi17 for 1899 maybe but not at all for epilgue
He had a good role model
You better run and don’t look back - Arthur Morgan 😭
Arthur saying you got to run and don’t look back also reminded me of that Michael quote from GTA. “One day you wake up and your legs just give, and you can’t run anymore”
Jack looks like he's on drugs
John Marston💔
R.I.P Rip Van Winkle
@@frontfacingmrkrabs indeed
RIP Uncle 🕊
@@oss8298RIP indeed😢
The pain in his voice remembering Arthur
Probably the best story I think I’ve ever played. Both games were so well detailed and fit with each other perfectly. This is all rockstar at its finest.
First I thought "Haha, funny cowboy game", now that I have finished the game, I'm fucking depressed
my first play through of Rdr i was 10 and in my head i was just thinking “but he said he’d catch up😭”
😭😭
Still the only 2 games that have made me cry as if a actualy new them such great story writers
Rdr1 was ahead of its time
"I'll catch up"
😢
John only had 4 years of happiness
I want Jack to be main protagonists in RDR3
I love how Jack calles everybody uncle
🥺💗 RDR and RDR2 are such beautiful and heartbreaking games.
we need RDR1 remasterred with RDR2 engine
No we don’t it’s already perfect no need to ruin it because you want 2080pUHD graphics and 200fps
@@Nine05mafiA__ttv need for pc
@determinator704 they don't need to change the story just improve the graphics
no that would ruin the game
y
@@DeadX2
Moral of the story, live wild, live free. When you think you’ve got your forever anything, life does take it away, and when it does viciously so. These games really brilliantly shows the harsh reality of loss
Both the games ending made me cry
Better writing than most modern movies
Man these 2 games are truly gems and I will forever think about and play them they truly were the best… memories.
Soon as that music started playing I started tearing up
When the time come u gotta go and dont look back
Authur morgan you will be missed
Rdr is the best game ever made it has so much detail if everything that you see in the mission or encounters make sense in the missions
“dont look back”
literally john remember arthur😢
Marston is legend
The sad truth of the story always have to come at some point 😢😢
John’s death was so sad he made sure to get his family out he knew he wasn’t going to see them again and made sure they were safe
Rockstar should remake this game
The epilogue hits harder when you know what’s guna happen
God I love this game 😢😢😢 the best experience I’ve ever had
The sad thing is, that Jack never realized that the men he met with Arthur is the same man who killed his father
Yes he does
@@jessepinkman8847 how?
@@foody15in Jack killed agent Ross, which was Milton's partner and the one that killed John
@@toyotafanboy this doesn't make any sense.I asked ,how did he knew it was the man he met with Arthur
@@foody15inbro jack aint stupid
as someone who played rdr1 this gives me bad memories
That barn haunts my dreams
Arthur and john both gave their lives for his family
Both Arthur and John stood to defend there loved ones and do the right thing they are the Heros of the Game❤😢
The wise words of a man long forgotten but left a impact in our hearts::::I gave you everything I had I did my best😢😢😢😢😢 ~Dutch Vanderlinn , Arthur Morgan😢 you will never be forgotten even after you are long gone.
"The day John Marston stopped shooting."
I forgot Jack said that at the beginning of the final mission
When i was a young boy and finish rdr 1 when John dead i wasn't having any feelings but when i finish it again and seeing John die it was so fu*k sad 😔
My very own John Marston is my Uncle Dan. Has property in Ocala, out fashioned cowboy. Horse riding, gun shooting, quick draw son of a gun! Just visited him not long ago he might have 3 years if he’s lucky to live but he’s a fighter like John. We all got someone we see as a legend in our family….at least I hope everyone does
no.. not everyone does.
Oh John... What if you took Arthurs advice...
John was a good father
"And don't look back" well there he remembered Arthur
No he didn't
A wise man once said " if you stare into the fire long enough you'll see the whole world pass by."
Don’t look back
As a wise man said when he was about die in a mountain
Those who know😢
Here
Damn game series makes me cry so many times. No other game ever hit like that.
It's a coincidence how John has the same Mark as red Harlow on his face 😅
I like Hosea the most but Arthur Morgan and John are the best duo
Damn, Arthur's objective only lasted 4 peaceful years
4???arthur died in 1899
@@hazlouneyounes44164 *peaceful* years
I’m gonna use some cheese.”- Arthur Morgan 1899
I wish there was more epilogue content in RDR1 like there was with RDR2, Jack really is an interesting character due to him being really the last outlaw from the original van der linde gang, and falling into the same trap his father did with revenge and anger.
Big W Edit also w game as well
Thank you for your support🫀
@@industry_gamingno problem
The ending of rdr1 was so sad
they Always do ...... the good ones
In the RDR2 Epilogue, I always get so emotional when one of the characters mention Arthur or repeat something Arthur did. Like how John repeated going fishing with Jack when a few years back Arthur did the same. I haven’t played the first game yet, but this series never fails to make me cry. 😕😕 rip Arthur
Now Jack don’t pay to much attention to Milton and focus with the guy behind him he’s important for later.
Fucc why he gotta die for😢
Man this makes me sad all the time my guy😩
Damn😔
Why does 12 year old Jack look like he’s been battling a meth addiction for the past 25 years?
😂
people back then used to age very fast
Most people back than looked like this
Harder times back then
Finally someone said it
When I played RDR2 I quit when Arthur died, but went back to RDR1 when the scene played out I was hoping John would go as well, but it broke me when he had turned towards barn door...
I have to cry every time i see rdr story. Its so deep. An absolut masterpiece.
“Gyatt” - John marstons famous last words to his son
Who misses arthur
👇
According to the likes
No one
Who misses Arthur -🤡👶. Just replay the game
What’s impressive is that rdr1 was set after rdr2 even though it released first and rockstar had to basically put all the details from rdr1 into rdr2 but the only downside is that they were talking about so much things from rdr2 in rdr1 and we just didn’t rlly understand what they meant
Two man more like legends brothers you'll say arthur and john rip gun shooting legends ❤💯🗿🙏
If Arthur hid Jack, he could've killed Milton and Ross
Then they would be replaced, possibly with someone who wouldn’t give anyone a chance to leave the gang like Milton did
John from 1900: Keep riding and don’t look back.
Arthur from 1899: I want you…To not look back. Like I said.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
John said it in 1911
Enjoy your fishing kid while you still can
- Edgar Ross, 1899
John legit just became a continuation of Arthur. His surrogate pops
Fantastic they brought back the same actors!!!
This makes me want to cry he has had a rough life
Guys do you remember when gta 1 and rdr1 was realistic and now look at the gta 6 trailer and rdr2 now its insane
Jack and Ross first met by a river, and that’s where they’ll meet again. Only the next time only one walks away
It’s crazy how much Jack grew and John aged in just 4 years 😂
The red dead redemption games are the only ones that made me shed a tear
I would love a trilogy or duology of movies that retells the stories of RDR1 or 2 (and I say 2 or 3 movies because 1 just isn't enough, even if it is 3 hours)
I'd find it hard for them to fuck it up because the script and story outline is basically written for them already, they'd just need to condense it.
Bro this scene with space song is so heartbreaking for a rdr player😢
Jack looks like if he just wake up from an after school nap
When I saw Arthur kneel down to Jack almost mad me cry because of his smile and how we all miss him
Arthur deserved so much better and I don't know why but this makes me cry. Don't anyone else cry watching this?
Love how John said we won’t see any of those guys show up but mf literally lives outside of blackwater the town that started all this😂😂
RDR1 Will forever be a staple in my gaming highlight memories. I remember thinking they would get to live out on the ranch.
"Looking back" it runs in the family
Arthur's death was a before and after in my life, I couldn't stop crying for hours, this game is a masterpiece of video games
Damn You Ross.
"The last enemy shall be destroy..."