Sharpe Investigates Where The Second Battalion Is Hidden | Sharpe
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 10. 2019
- Sharpe attempts to find out where the Second Battalion is, only leaving him with more questions.
__
In the Peninsular War, a British sergeant is field promoted to a lieutenant in charge of a disrespectful rifle company. - Zábava
i like how carline realises that he’s not only unknowingly disrespected a superior officer but also some one he looked up to
Seems like he's not a bad person-but has the makings of a good officer with the right mentor.
He actually fights and dies bravely in the Waterloo campaign.
@@JM-dy4ty Many did. Poor bastards.
Maybe Sharpe needs to wear some kind of rank insignia.
Private Smith says he is a Major. Everyone just runs with it?
@robertmorris8997 That's not Sharpe, that's Private Vaughn!
New drinking game: Take a shot every time an entitled junior officer talks down to Sharpe until they find out he outranks them.
Though he's clearly not wearing insignia of rank, he is manifestly an officer, and quite a bit older than the kid Captain, so it should not take too much imagination for him to come up with the idea that the man is at least equal to him, and likely his superior. Now if the kid was a lieutenant colonel, that might be something different; but, the captain doesn't outrank very many officers.
Though the captain does somewhat redeem himself as in the book of Sharpe’s Waterloo captain Carline is mentioned as one of the mounted officers who die covering the battalion’s retreat to the woods after the battalion is caught in line by cavalry due to the prince of orange’s screw up
Now that's soldiering
I think they recognize the rank, it's the reputation that takes them down.
@@paulpeterson4216 My impression is they recognize Sharp as an officer who came up through the ranks. They presented as officers who came from family, influence and money. They may acknowledge the rank of fellow officer, they never forget the social standing. But Sharp has reputation.
Never run away from a Sergeant-Major, you will be the saddest drummer-boy in the history of the British Army.
To be fair this being Sharpe the 700 soldiers of the second battalion would still only be like 25 enlisted men.
Not a joke. Sharpe and harper have enough soldiering to be the remainder 675 and still come home in time for supper
True
@Robert Kaevur He isnt joking. Sharpe and his five rifles were able to capture and then quickly destroy an entire French fort during the battle of Vittoria
That's all he'd NEED.
@@biggfish7010 The fact that it was a FRENCH fort, says it all.
You have to give the actor credit, when he hears ‘ Major Richard Sharpe’ he knows he needs the appropriate
‘Oh Shit’ reaction
He was an war hero with multiple battlefield victories.
Not a gentleman, but an effective officer.
"Uhh oh yeah Erm...."
It'd be like in America, hearing "Major Richard Winters" or Audie Murphy.
This was another Henry Simmerson episode
It comes with the new understanding, that not only are you inappropriately addressing a superior officer, you were likely inappropriately addressing YOUR superior officer.
I swear the best part of this scene is Harper's sergeant reflexes overriding control of his body and forcing him to round up all the men.
Apparently senior NCOs are more force of nature than mere men.
One of Nature's Sergeants
Captain Carline actually became a pretty good officer in the novels, he had command of his own company but was unfortunately killed at Waterloo.
He rose above the title 'dancin' pumps'.
@@TankUni He did. And honorable man if I remember rightly.
I just noticed they use the same actor for him, Prince George and the officer from episode 1!
Ted Carew: "Mr. Carline said I was drunk... which I was, sir..." Possibly the best line of the whole show. Sgt. Carew recognising his limitations, but still pretty sure he's got it right. I've been there, too, Ted. I've been there, too.
Shame he lost his leg. Put him with the Chosen men. Teamed up with Patrick and Richard or with the 63rd and William they'd be an unstoppable force...more so than usual
Yep, showing up for Formation hungover, then PT.
Without a trace of irony in my old infantryman’s soul: “That’s proper soldiering”
@@903lew nice to know the language hasn't changed, I understood every word he said
@@BigBWolf90 He didn't lose his leg; see 3:47
"Oy! You! Drummer boy!" I would run as well if I saw the Sergeant Major running at me.
I've tried a few times... never turned out well.
Few things scarier in military life
Never, ever run from a senior NCO. It only makes them angrier and I guarantee that whatever tricks you think you know, or places to hide, they know them ALL. NCOs aren't even fully human anymore - the moment they get those stripes they become a god-damn spirit that feeds off the terror and suffering of privates that think they're clever.
If you could, youd just drop dead then and there. Razzman, never wants a friendly chat,
Aye. And they take it half and half. Half in the belly...then the other half in the belly.
You can run from a Sergeant Major, but you'll die tired.
They're like some kind of non-giving up... soldier guy!
He left his leg at Talavera he says, though at 3:46 all he needs is to look behind him.
is that his foot?
@@vulkanofnocturne Yes it is 🤣
That mistake was in the original release 😁
Though serving with Sharpe means he knows what he needs to do survive having him as his BN Commander. The others aren't so lucky.
Alex Witte I thought that was the stump of his leg that was raised behind him and the prosthetic was attached to his knee but now I’m not so sure...
That little pause and nod of despair Harper gives when the old man is shuffling to attention is just perfect.
Officer realises sharp out ranks them: "oh, I'm sorry sir... grovel grovel"
Sharpe realises officer out ranks him: "right you, this is how this is going to play out..."
Now that's soldiering
Rank wasn't everything back then. Being a war-hero counted for more.
They're both of similar rank I think. Sharpe is a brevet major, basically a honorary rank but bureaucratically speaking he's still a captain
@@00_rei90 thats interesting didnt know that. they have similar to that in some guards regiments today then. "Sergeants" are really corporals or something. They are called sergeants, wear three stripes but only lead a section and have "corporal" on their pay statement....
@@fishyc150 In the Guards, Corporals are called Lance Sergeants. Full Sargeants are still a separate rank and outrank Lance Sergeant.
Brevet officer ranks are a bit different and tend to only be found in war time. Basically when the Army massively expands for war, they promote experienced officers to higher ranks. Once the war is over, the brevet rank is removed to avoid the situation where 75% of your peace time officers are Majors or above.
To avoid bloat at the upper levels once the people that only joined for war have left
The British Army at that time was structured around primogeniture. Eldest son got everything. Second son could choose the army or be a minister. Dad would buy him an officer’s commission in a regiment. If he made it to colonel he ran the regiment and the government gave him a fixed annual sum of money to run it. Any corners he could cut went in his pocket. Usually it was bad food and shoddy equipment. In this case he cut the entire regiment. Corruption was built in so second sons could retire in comfort.
Just like modern day Russia :)
There were also opportunities to make extra money, especially in the Navy. Taking enemy ships intact allowed the Captain to claim those ships and their contents as lawful prizes, to be sold off and the money distributed among the officers and crew. A successful Captain could become very wealthy, and if they weren't content to use the meager allowances provided by the Naval Board then they could use their profits to outfit their ships themselves. Not sure if the Army had any similar opportunities of enrichment but wealthy Commanders were still able to outfit their own men with superior equipment if they could afford it
@@FerretJohn I believe in the Army horses could be taken as prizes, I'm guessing cannons might've been taken aswell (though that is just a guess, but it makes sense for it to be true)
@@konstantinosnikolakakis8125 Ordnance was a completely separate thing to the army in those times. So I'd say ordnance would of kept anything to do with artillery.
What's new.
Calling the officer of the day "dancing pumps" that's soldiering.
Well, Dancing Pumps isn't very bright, is he...
I heard "dancing pomps"
What does Dancing Pumps even mean?
@@levilevis9032 what do you think lad?
@@SStupendous I'm Norwegian so the slang doesn't really translate too well, I have no idea honestly.
And here we can see how someone talking to you in a very calm voice can be way more scary than someone fiercely yelling at you.
The Sergeant's job is to yell. It's the officer's job to state how they want the world to be.
You evidently haven't been screamed at by a Station Warrant Officer (GSM, for you pongos)
It's a lulling quiet. Let's idiots bury themselves deeper in the shit. Smarter people realise, this and stop whatever rubbish they are going.
Velvet glove (soft calm approach) followed by iron fist to knuckle the offender they won't smarten up.
Use it myself. Only people who know Sharpe realise this. If some fool pushes back on him, then be as hard as required!!
true
Playing blind man's bluff with a pair of shapely young ladies when you should be turning out the guard
Now that's soldiering
@TheSmithersy True. British Navy used Rum, sodomy, and the lash
@@toddkes5890Not necessarily in that order :)
That's exactly why the British Army stopped selling commissions
Or better still bedding them.
You mean "playing .... WHILE turning out the guard"
That's soldiering!
That akward moment when he realizes that he just insulted his superior officer
It was hard to get the next few sentences out as he tried desperately to swallow the words that'd just come tumbling out of his mouth.
Can we appreciate the cameo of the Sergeants missing foot at 3:47? Love the Sharpe series. Still, funny moment.
Looool thx
3:45
Getting the “amputated” leg of a soldier in the shot. That’s cameramanship!
Embezzling funds from a fictitious 2nd battalion, now thats soldiering.
Sargent Bilko would be proud.
It actually happened, a major problem until it was stamped out
I always find it funny when the snobby rich officers talk down to Sharpe and then shit themselves when they realise he's a famous war hero who outranks them
1:01 You can easily read Sharpe's thoughts here: "I was putting my ass on the line every day of my entire adult life to protect this shit?!"
Harper's thoughts: "Try being a Irishman and having to protect this shit."
It get's even harder in the Yorkshire episode.
@@robertnett9793
British soldiers were paid a shilling a day during the Napoleonic Wars. During the First World War, they got paid 3 Shillings and 6 pence... A week.
Britain's always treated its army like shite.
Right? The bad guys won the Napoleonic Wars.
This and the millowners episode in Yorkshire are excellent. They both show how rotten life could be for a soldier back home in those days and why so many joined to get away
To be fair, the series also shows how terrible military life was for enlisted men. There's a reason why Wellington describes his soldiers as scum of the earth and the series continuously has soldiers deserting, looting, raping, being flogged, dying of disease, etc.
@@fraserclayton7468 True too. Bernard Cornwell is a fantastic author of this period
One finds it astonishing that anyone was willing to fight to uphold such a system.
@@marktaylor6491 Agreed. I think some of the most powerful lines in the series are spoken by Matthew Truman in the Yorkshire episode, where he asks the people what Napoleon ever did to them that the British government made them fight and die to bring him down
@@royalhero4608 I'll leave this answer to those more knowledgeable of Napoleon, but I'd wager one of the things the British held against him was the mortal sin of being French. :P
There's a part of me that desperately wants to believe that smack accompanied with "move yerself!" was unscripted.
I like that the props department gave Harper's rank insignia a read border because it was taken from a red coat. They could have just given him a fourth chevron on his uniform and be done with it. Very nice attention to detail.
This series had flaws, not least the low budget, but Sean Bean was perfect in the role. One thing about this particular story arc, I get a weird archaic-modern vibe off the Rifleman green formal uniform, as if this is some alternate reality where Sharp had to take the eagle at Talavera in the face of French machine-gun fire. I love it.
The green uniform was indeed the precursor to camo
What I found regrettable was the exclusion of Lossow and the "King's German Legion"! It seems it's still a problem for the Brits to see their boys fighting alongside Germans, even if it's part of the history!
sean was so perfect for the role the author of the books rewrote the charater in the later books to resemble Sean more. As in the early books he is described as having black hair for example.
@@Exodianecross1978
The problem was that the scenes with cavalry were expensive enough without adding more. You'll notice that there's rarely more than ten horsemen on screen at once and often enough anyone on horseback is just standing still due to the lack of trained horses.
It had nothing to do with British nationalism and everything to do with the shoestring budget.
@@Exodianecross1978 Actually we have no issue with having German allies shown.
Indeed: you won't find a single written nor televised work on the battle of Waterloo, that doesn't give generous credit to the Prussian forces. Indeed: ex-Army major Gordon Corrigan one said "Would Wellington have won the battle without the Prussians?. Wrong Question: He wouldn't have fought the battle, if he hadn't known the Prussians were on their way."
Someone's collecting the rum ration for 700 men who don't exist.
Karl Johan Lea but where's the rum gone?
@@FatGouf Hic. No idea. Hic.
asking the real question right here.
Hic. I agree with Mr Wibble if you don't mind sir. Hic.
@@FatGouf Check the Navy.
Harpers reaction when the old guy comes shambling up to the line 🤣
You can see the 'Oh for feck's sake...' on his face.
Now this is soldiering.
3:30 When Sharpe sees that besides the missing unit, he had at least acquired one experienced soldier.
Howling when I saw ted hobble in the armoury and he turns round and you can see his foot hanging out of the back of his smock 🤣😂🤣😂🤣 love it!!!
Major Sharpe? More detective Sharpe in this one.
I’m definitely going to watch this series again, quality TV and none of the current silliness 👍
are you saying you don't like 5 minutes of content, and 15 minutes of dramatic fluff???
Also watch: Codlitz (Seasons 1 & 2)
As I was a-walking down Radcliffe highway
A recruiting party came a-beating my way
They enlisted me and treated me till I did not know
And to the Queen's barracks they forced me to go
When first I deserted, I thought myself free
Until my cruel comrade informed against me
I was quickly followed after and brought back with speed
I was handcuffed and guarded, heavy irons put on me
Court martial, court martial, they held upon me
And the sentence passed upon me, three hundred and three
May the Lord have mercy on them for their sad cruelty
For now the Queen's duty lies heavy on me
When next I deserted, I thought myself free
Until my cruel sweetheart informed against me
I was quickly followed after and brought back with speed
I was handcuffed and guarded, heavy irons put on me
Court martial, court martial, then quickly was got
And the sentence passed upon me, that I was to be shot
May the Lord have mercy on them for their sad cruelty
For now the Queen's duty lies heavy on me
Then up rode Prince Albert in his carriage and six
Saying "Where is that young man whose coffin is fixed?
Set him free from his irons and let him go free
For he'll make a good soldier for his Queen and country
The Deserter, by Fairport Convention, from the Leige and Lief album.
BBC Panorama: The case of the Second Battalion with guest host, Major Sharpe of the South Essex Regiment
That's funny
(Dramatic music begins)
Lol
"You've heard of me?"
Everyone has heard of him.
The moment when you realise you've been mouthing off and talking down to a senior officer... then realising that senior officer is a war hero
Many years ago, as a very young, idiotic airman on night flying, I said to a nearly deaf Flight Sergeant pilot, 'What are your gold wings for?' He was very apologetic when he explained that he used to be on pathfinders, flying the Mosquito. My respect climbed vertically for him at that moment. It also taught me that the old farts that you see before you, weren't always old farts.
Lesson learnt then. Bet that old sergeant had some wonderful stories, and was a mine of information.
@@tonyhaynes9080 Never underestimate an old man in a profession where most die young
This is where standardized rank insignia for commissioned officers comes in handy.
Did not come in until the 1850s.
3:15, "Come with me" said in a way you NEVER want to hear as a junior officer in a situation like that...
Running away from a Sargeant Major? That's far from soldiering, thats suicide.
Thats drummer boying.
I love how the captain got shot down. :D He was so smug when he spoke to Sharpe not having enough smarts to show as much repentance as possible so his punishment isnt so harsh. Well I guess he didnt know that the man talking to him outranked him but still at least from the tone Sharpe spoke in that captain could have guessed whats coming.
Doesn't it turn out that Carline was simply bored and miserable and soon for on Sharpes good side once the battalion picked up?!
@@TheHilltopHermit yes in the books he does pull himself together and become a good officer and a company commander. But he dies at Waterloo.
@@Apollo890 did they do him dirty in the TV show and change his character arc? It's been so long. I've read both books and seen the shows though.
@@TheHilltopHermit not really, they just seem to forget him he doesn't appear in any other episodes.
lol I love the captain realization that he has been talking to a major, and a scary one at that. that was a oh shit look, and wishing he could sink through the ground when he shut his eyes
Definitely a "come to Jesus" moment!
2:40 THUD! "Move yourself!"
Gets me everytime...
Nice to see there's at least one person Sharpe likes stationed there
Interesting, Captain Carline knows who commands the 2nd battalion,but not where it is. Rations and pay are drawn for 700 men, no guard mounted. It seems more like a men's club than an army base. Yet when Sharpe arrived to get replacements for his battalion, he only found 11 men unfit to fight.
And most likely the salary for the missing 689 soldiers is going right into the coffers of the 2nd Battalion's commander.
my dyslexia kicked in when I saw the title of this video and I thought it said "Sharpe investigates where the second bathroom is hidden"
Smacking a snotty Subaltern round the back of the head, now that's soldiering!
a slap across the face is an insult, a slap round the back of the head is a wake up call
Called a 'Snot Klap' .. "Geklap dat die snot spat" (smacked that the snot flies) 😁.
@@AnikaJarlsdottr So sayeth the Wise and Powerful Gibbs.
Arrr,, Gibbs and Sharpe. Hardarses to the end. Both had their rules and eyes/ears everywhere. Don't attempt to play either as fools.
Not worth the pain.
Why does everyone feel the need to remind Sharpe he captured the french eagle? He was there, he wouldnt forget that!
sucking up and wishing to bathe in his reflected glory...
they say it more to remind themselves than him just to point out how stupid they have been in misjudging Sharpe.
The beginning of this episode is filmed at Tilbury fort, A prime example of a multiple cross fire design that stands next to the River Thames in Essex...
OH boy!! The ball of "who's in charge of the matter" is being bounced around like a tennis ball.
British for sure
@@SantomPh Bureaucratic shitstorm for sure.
Sean Bean is an excellent actor! He excells at the parts he plays!
Nobody does a death scene quite like Sean Bean. Plenty of practice is why.
They move fast so if I reveal their location they will quickly move to another, meaning the second battalion might be airborne... I think I should pause there.
I just discovered a filming glitch. When the quartermaster and sharp walk into Joansford Barracks Armoury, just before the quartermaster turns around to view the books, you catch a glimpse of his foot in a sock, the foot he lost at Talavera.
I always promise I’ll just watch one or two parts of these episodes but then I end up watching the whole, damn thing.
The London to Chelmsford coach went the long way around, via Tilbury.
"Come with me".
The most terrifying words an officer can speak to any junior rank.
And he speaks it with a quiet, calm voice. Anyone who's ever served knows that's a really bad thing.
Thinks the junior.... Gulp, I hope my will is in order. Wtf, dear God..."
The three words that indicate to a junior officer that they're in the crapper.
Never run away or turn your back from a drill instructor!!!!
Just when I forget about him, Sharpe wanders right back in the feed.
I loved the Sharpe series so much! Rare to get this quality today.
Can you suggest me series like this?
Can you upload the scene where Lt Gibbons wants to duel Sharpe and Hogan shuts him down immediately? That’s gotta be the funniest ‘Sharpe’s reputation at work’ moment, that or the Colonel that wants to fight him with Fredrickson encouraging it at dinner before mentioning who Sharpe is ‘that the same Sharpe who...’ lmao
czcams.com/video/Xdww4LPVfco/video.html
This one is the Fredrickson at dinner scene:
czcams.com/video/hUReNg1LulE/video.html
Love both those scenes. Politely reminds these new to war officiers who bought their way in that they need to learn whats going quickly before someone kills them. Money doesn't make a good soldier. May buy position and means, but can't stop a bullet or sword.
As Sharpe says "Dangerous out on streets at night, madam. Best take a man with you."
And best of all, she knew it.. haha
Fantastic Series.. not much changes.. Grift is timeless
After intensive training by Sharpe and Harper, those eleven soldiers went on to defeat an entire French army... of 62 soldiers.
I loved this series!
"Awkward Squad" never fails to crack me up 🤣
3:47 I love how you can see the leg Carew left at Talavera poking out the back of his trousers.
Can't unsee the foot. *CAN'T UNSEE THE FOOT!*
Explain your concern!
Notice that despite the lackadaisical nature of that poor band of misfits, Sgt. Carew was upright and worthy of his station. Now that's soldiering!
Recognizing sgt carew, now that's soldiering!
When all else fails at finding the truth ask the Sargeant who in the case just so happens to be the quartermaster for the base.
Usually how it works....
The reaction Harper had to the old man is funny!
Anybody notice how the soldier that lost his leg should just have looked behind his back at 3:47 ? :D
i watched the entire series,
now i want to watch it again.
Sharpe and Harper's uniforms here are lovely
One of my favourite episodes. Also the first book I read.
3:45 You can see the red-coated actor's foot (tucked up and wearing a sock) as he turns around. His character is supposed to be missing a leg as discussed in the preceding scene a few seconds earlier.
Good show ...
Drinking a shot every time an entitled young officer talks down to Sharpe until they find out he outranks them. THAT'S soldiering!
It does never get old.
Reminds me of that bit in Boondock Saints when that Detective gets mouthy... and finds out he just mouthed off a FBI higher-up WAY above his paygrade.
I always loved Sharp!
That drummer took off like "Oh shit!"
3:46 You see his foot from his half leg hahaha
Now that's bloopering.
They should've chopped off his leg for real for more authenticity
3:47 you can actually see the guys foot stuck up behind him 😂 good editor.
Great series of movies.
this episode infuriated me when I first saw it especially what they did to the Dog
I love these
Dam good episode that.
Agreed
I suspect the logic behind sending Sharpe to investigate is they knew something was going on, but needed particulars and proof of corruption since I suspect Girdwood had insulated himself with "friends". Whereas Sharpe was willing to step on any toes to get to the truth. I wouldn't take this as systemic of the entire system back then since if it was you'd have an entire phantom army with officers embezzling funds left and right and the enemy finding no guards at whatever outposts they came across like this one. This is just the upper brass trying to find out "what" Girdwood was playing at since they couldn't afford to have a somehow non-existent company.
Do remember that this is the training battalion, not the fighting one.
I Love this Clip Gem's from The Series? I Gather it is? Well Clip's & Short snippets are Enjoyable plus Nice. I do Think the possibility of Seeing the Series would Be just Grand.
when he said "you dont know? you are officer of the day!" i could imagine gordon ramsay... saying something about catch of the day
War never changes.
A good one!
When he turns to the desk you can see his foot strapped up behind him 😂
Interesting to notice the younger actors in the cast getting their first or second big job in telly
Adam James (Captain Carline) did a fantastic job as Don Pedro in the David Tennant/Catherine Tate Much Ado About Nothing as well as a fun minor role as the irritating idiotic DI in the Doctor Who standalone episode Planet of the Dead. I haven't seen him as Harold Godwinson in 1066 yet but I have heard good things about it.
Sharpe's Regiment is his first credited role.
@@richgoranson2439 Made a lot of people's careers, really.
You have to wonder why the sarge was actually given a wooden leg into which to prop his real one rather than just being told to limp. The sound of the leg being hit could have been added in post.
did they ever took a pause after that long filming it
Never understood what happened to his cover in this episode and others. Did someone sit on it? LOL
Sharpe re-incarnated as 007
"WHO the devil are YOU?!?!"
"Sharpe......Major Sharpe. You've heard of me?"
"You stopped a whole bunch of bad guys from doin' lots of very bad stuff, like nuking Miami with stolen nuclear weapons!!!"
So I’ve never seen this movie but I have heard of it, and when watching this I very quickly recognised the place where they shot these scenes - Tilbury Fort. I used to be an Army cadet there.
Now that I think about it, I do believe our sergeant said there was a famous show taken here, not that I remember what it was called though XD guess I figured it out
Tilbury fort and coalhouse fort 5 minutes away has been used for loads including Wonder woman and Batman begins
@@jamaize1 I saw it in both of those (when she's fighting the Germans and when he is in the prison, I believe, though it's been a while since I've seen Batman) but it wasn't as clear in those I don't think and also I knew about that before watching those.
"Ya don't knorr?"
Gotta love that Sheffield accent.
0:09 i swear i can hear someone saying "jeez"
Another new drinking game for watching an episode of Sharpe. Down a shot every time Sharpe says Baaastad!