“Is This A Threat?” Tushar Mehta vs Kapil Sibal over Kolkata Horror | Supreme Court, CJI Chandrachud
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 09. 2024
- A three judge bench of CJI DY Chandrachud, Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice Manoj Misra on 20.8.2024 heard the Suo motu matter over the death of a 31 year old trainee doctor in Kolkata’s RG Kar Hospital. Multiple times during the hearing, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta appearing for the CBI and Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal appearing for the West Bengal government were seen at logger heads with one another regarding the events that had unfolded in Kolkata. Watch the video for more!
Law Today brings you the latest breaking developments in the world of law and courts. Law Today keeps you up to date on all that is happening in Courts across the country along with analyzing legal issues that concern you. We bring you the top legal voices from India including judges, senior advocates, legal scholars and more. For ideas, suggestions and feedback, write to us at lawtodayofficial@gmail.com
Subscribe to Law Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of legal news from India and around the world!
WEBSITE: lawtoday.in/
TWITTER: / lawtodaylive
FACEBOOK: / lawtodayofficial
INSTAGRAM: / lawtoday.in
#SupremeCourt #TusharMehta #KapilSibal #CJIDYChandrachud #KolkataCase #RGKarHospital #IndianJudiciary #JusticeForDoctors #LegalDebate #LawToday #SupremeCourtHearing #WestBengal
It's a shame that even women in Sibbal's panel are smiling. May God save this country. Law and order is a joke.
C*ngress party rapist ke sath hai
People will not understand the damage caused to others till the same damage is caused to them. KARMA will give such women befitting Reply. Wait and watch
I noticed woman is laughing in sibbal,s panel Shame on this woman
Have u not go to work. Not eaten today. Why are u acting like she is laughing at the dead people. Don't be like children who don't understand context
Imagine not having the discipline and professionalism@@nowwhat6716
if shamelessness has a face, MR sibbal just met the criteria perfectly ..
उसका पेशा है, इस पर हम सवाल नहीं कर सकते, ये कोर्ट है, लेकिन हमारे वकील बहुत कमजोर हैं, उनके वकील गलत का साथ भी अच्छे से दे रहे हैं, लेकिन डॉक्टर की तरफ से वकील से कोई मदद नहीं कर रहा है।Ki unke tarf se vachil ka sath de par pata nhi kaise vachile hain ye sab...? बहुत सारे सबोट हैं तथ्य हैं वो राखो सामने पर नहीं तुम गलत वाचाइले के सामने झुक रहे हो...?
You said it perfectly.
congresawalo ko sharam nam ka koi cheez pata hey
Always and every time
Kapil criminal sibal
Sibal should answer first how 7000 goons enter the hospital .This is a failure of state machinery
He will simply say not true not true hahahahshshs
It's hardly 100-120 people...remaining 6000+were protestors
Guy is denying every thing. Even the pelvic bone broken. Heights
@@Yaastika The final pm report says there's no fracture observed as said in the initial reports.
Now, idk how the f#ck is that possible. The fractures just magically disappeared? Or is it that our forensic experts are just plain incompetent?
Congress party rapist ke sath hai
Sibbal is a freaking criminal 😮. How inhuman he and his team could be . Ruthless
But some b*stard of my homestate West Bengal could not understand.
this is true
@@nadugopalbarman5358#MamatamustResign #JusticeForMoumita
If the girl doesn't get justice (like Kamduni 2013) it will be the failure of Judiciary and the CBI as well. And that will be a matter of GREAT SHAME!
It will be matter of great disaster.
The women behind Kapil Sibal seems so excited and interrupting..:: how can a women be against this …. Shameless
If this matter had been happen with the women that is behind sabil he would have known what is going
She is wisping often in sibals ear
In her mind she is protecting mamta .psyche is very important
Congress party rapist ke sath hai
Relax they are lawyers. They are just doing their job.
Sibbal said " the collar bones and hip bones not fractured " ......he and his group of lawyer standing behind him doesn't have a daughter or wife or sister ....
These are people who will dance any tune laced with dollar or Rupee bills!
@@monoranjanbezboruah3402 integrity gone
Because these lawyers did the autopsy
Ah these idiots in chat ...
There are few females also 😢 how these people will face their families or their families also like this
No matter how high the level of education or professionalism is Sibbal has. He failed as a human being and he failed the teachings of his teachers and parents in his career and life.
This is a very crucial example of why human values should have much weightage in the curriculum.
Xllent
Have any one present here seen such t type incident before whole india and in many countries have come to roads and also wemens of Bengal came to occupied all roads and streets in mid।night in protest of such crime and cruallity against a meritorus woman doctor?
May be Sibbal does not get those great teachers. So he is fallen from heavenly grace.
Sibal argues with the CBI Attorney General and when the Supreme Court Justice intervenes then he immediately says " I agree, Milord, true ,Milord , no problem, Milord "
What a guy !
Getting a justice in India is never been easy, feeling very sad for the girl😢 RIP 💐
Kapil Sibbal was saying yes to CISF initially and as soon as it was given as an order from judge he's like they can't work together! 🤕
His argument is really shameful 🤬
🎉😢😢😢🎉🎉🎉😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢@@romeshraina4997😢😢😢😢😢😢 ko
Close observation bro...
No he said yes if cji wants they totally agree for cisf but he just made his point that cisf is wholly responsible for that
There may be prob with two forces working together but whole responsibility will be on cisf he just stated that
He just explained his concerns here
He didn't oppose it
@@prashiknaranje08 pls bro knows if he would have clearly opposed it people would've called him hypocrite.
His concern is just his hidden opposition. Every one knows that.
Solid argument by Mr.Tushar Mehta❤
i like the way he behave in the court, Do not laugh when you are debating over a murder of girl, do not interrupt when other person speaking. Some people at least take some tuition from him.
One group is fighting for truth.
One more group is standing with criminals and lies.
What a shameful profession.
Shame on you Kapil.
He is a shameless lawyer who is money centric!!
He is known for it. This is not the first time.
This judiciary is garbage profession in loose democracy.
Excellent
Mr sibbal is not with the criminal he is standing for Mamta Banerjee
Making halwa out of it .
Sibbal is just a joker 🃏.. Shameless
Sibal has no daughter?the ladies behind him are shamelessly laughing.they are bothered about fracture.here one precious life lost due failure of state.
He has 2 sons, shame on the entire family
It’s Horrible to watch Mr Sibbal’s insensitive argument and there’s barely any attempt by the state to find out all the culprits behind this crime.
So the TV serial or series are right in showing one advocate speaking confidently takes away the case and the other standing like a dumbass loses (though he may be representing the actual victims)
@@Saswatim8Hope it doesn’t go that way here and truth comes out!
By the God grace which lawer support the culprit..one day when their daughter would face same thing then they would go with the rapeist ...?
This stupid Kapil Sibbal is doing everything to earn more money, he is not bothered for any kind of humanity at all, he can do to the lowest of the human dignity to earn money, what a mentally sick person he is 😧😳😲‼️
Didi has done it , so why would Didi be interested to know 😇
Kapil Sibbal is a real threat to integrity and well being of this Nation...
Congress and TMC both are threat for the society
Sibbal has started talking RUBBISH
C*ngress party rapist ke sath hai
Shameless
West Bengal needs cm Yogi adityanath
Arresting 37 out of 7000 is a great milestone by the West Bengal govt.
Sibal account or money transaction to be checked. Who he is defending the rap*** and killers? Shame on you 😡
Absolutely
Don't understand why is cji so soft on sibbal and harsh on attorney general
Coz sibbal is head of bar association
Cos he is his close friend
Because they get share out of the scrupulous income of the Kapil Sibbal.
On goons side soft and on victim side harsh how these chair behave is well known it is just eye wash that sc is doing something preset
@@tarunroychowdhury1619
This is the correct reply
Women lawyers standing behind sibal and not even showing any sign of uneasiness are the perfect example of what everything is bad in our society.
It's one thing when some men try to defend themselves. But when a woman defends the incident, it can't get any bad.
Excellent question...
If give money they will say nothing happened
Why was the post mortem done in the bloody same hospital
THIS CASE MUST GET COMPLETE JUSTICE without Cover up.
Why Sibal Laughs?...........Shame !!! Shame on him !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Feeling sorry while watching someone supporting culprits 😢😢
Actually they are not, they are fighting from the side of Mamta.
@@shivkanya7518who has given crores to divert and close this case. Shame being an Indian.
'Democracy' .a criminal who doesn't respect right to law-abiding citizens will get best legal care and human rights advocate
Specially those advocate girls.... heartless people 🤬🤬🤬
Shame on all the lawyers who are opportunistic and supporting the culprits..shame shame shame
Poor sibal sounds so helpless and agreeing to all. I am sure if hon:cji has asked for cm to step down , he would ve agreed to that too.
Why Mr. Sibel is behaving as strange as if he's not concerned about the young doctor?
As a schoolboy we had a play that described the different professions like teacher, doctor, lawyer etc.
Lawyer's profession was described as :
“झूठे को सच और सच को झूठा यही है इनका काम"
Jokers like Sibbal, are treating this case with sarcastic smiles and just like any other case. It's a shame on humanity. No lawyer should fight a case in favour of the Govt or police of West Bengal. Have some shame Sir.
Supreme court taken action against the WB govt and Mr Kapil sibal immediately 😢😢😢
Supreme Court bhi bik gaya hoga.
Kahan bika hai , Justice Dene ki kosis kar reh hai , Don't worry , Upar wala sab kuch dekh raha hai
Honurable Tushur Metha Sir Lord Hara Hara Mahadeva and this nation is with you for being honest and Lord Shiva will destroy the Evils.
Why does Sibal need a score of lawyers ???
Both sibal and singhvi should be debarred from entering Supreme Court!
Rightly said.Also Bhusan
Both of them are known as devils’ lawyers.
Both singvi and kapli should not be allowed to argue in any court. They don't want justice.
But how? The commission applies to everyone 😂
Cibal is head of bar council
Kapil charges crores. Check the contract. The case can be closed immediately.
Lying by omission is a great weapon as long as nobody catches it. The fact is the general diary was done at the time you have mentioned. The actual FIR was done after 13 hours and that too by parents not the authority of the hospital. Whereas it should have been done by hospital authority at 10 am. Don't lie as somebody will catch it. Btw, are you indi it cell or tmc it cell ?
Who is bearing his fees???
Hope not by WB Govt.
@Chromatic-v9s chati chata
Crore and Arabs it doesn't mean ,sibbal only performing his duty, as per advocate act
Both sibal and Singhvi charge two to five crores .
Recently Kerala Govt paid a few crores to Singhvi
Why such big and mighty importance given to this Kapil Sibal who can twist the facts by having his palm greased always.
Truly said, he always proves himself to be one of Congress Veterans
He is head of bar council association.
Congress party rapist ke sath hai
💯% correct 👍
MR.TUSHAR MEHTA IS A GREAT ADVOCATE IN INDIA. HE IS RIGHTLY DEFENDED THE CASE.
Very well put together by SG
Hat's off for the patience and seriousness regarding such a sensible issue. And equally disgusting to look at the attitude of Mr. Sibbal.
Shame on supreme court for allowing Kapil sibal, to enter court.😡😡
Kapil Sibal should be send to Pakistan.
💯 Right Sir 😢😢😢
Right
You are right he should be sent to Pakistan,it is very shameful to SC if they don't give justice
How long these arguments would go on without any resolution, the poor girl suffered 😢😢😢
@@MohammedAli-sj1rmafter that everyone will forget 😕
WHY on earth is Mr. sibbal, always on the WRONG SIDE?
Because the WRONG side has all the power and money !
Money Money Money
Yess He Opposes You Jumla Dal
Money honey
Money
What a shame for the criminal still standing because of 💰...
How these lawyers move so free in the society.
Shameless Lawyer lying by the teeth with zero regard for the brutality and lawlessness
In longo ka zamer Mar chuka hai
Kapil sibal let your client in Kolkata rape and murder case be not touched by any body. Keep him with you. But give back the doctor who was raped assaulted abd murdered as she was intact . No body will say a single word
Seriously I was shocked why these people are supporting culprit where entire world knows what is true ,still why they need proofs? Why these lawyers supporting this much don't have girls in thier family today doctor tomorrow thrier family members like wife ,daughter,granddaughter will suffer
To file an FIR, kapil sibal's client need a Mefical Borad, one Magistrate snd so on.😢😢
Congress party rapist ke sath hai
ए लोग, अच्छा काम करने नहीं जानते हैं और किसी को अच्छा काम करने देता। They have all the blessings of family that's most undemocratic, ill-wishers of our Nation and overall the most anti-societal. Have always been very very cruel to those who do not accept/approve their/these unprincipled activities.
Mr. Sibal at least try to do something right at this stage of your life
CJI must give verdicts based on facts not sermons . Punish the principal he must be sacked forever. Why did he not file the FIR ? Sack the police officer for not sealing the area and evidences destroyed . Who decided on cremating the body in a haste ? First sack them and jail them . You are so quick to jail CM and deputy CM and keeping the good politicians forever. How do you think this country will run and sanity restored ?
KS has lost all his humanity, sense of shame and self respect.
Did all 7000 people jumped from the Sky ? What the Police were doing , till that huge gathering.?
Bengal Police are paid agents of Trinamool Congress and Mamta Baboonji.... probably the Bengal police helped in the destruction of evidence
Shame on whom who are advocating in favour of criminals, crimes.
The whole world is watching!!!
Huge respect sir 🙏Adv Tushar Mehta sir🇮🇳🕉️🙏
Oh God,please have mercy on us women and stand with us at all times,give full strength to the lawyers who fight for womens' right🙏
Ngi ki briew na Rilum ngi kham pher ka jingmut jing pyrkhat ban ia ki briew na Rithor 😊
You already have enough rights and priviledges.this is not rape.stol demonizing men just to get priviledges and laws to harass men
One wonders why this very OLD Kapil Sibal is fighting cases for all the Villains for the sake of amassing wealth (because, only Criminals who earn enormous wealth through illegal corrupt means can afford to pay him). Will he carry all this ill gotten wealth when he DIES. Let him do some little good deeds and learn to speak little truth before he dies, at least.
Almighty will punish him properly.
Find his children
Inquiry must further be conducted to verify how why and by which power vested people has Kapil Sibal has been roped in to defend the miscreants.
Lady advocates with Sibbal, shame on you .
Very true
If an example of any shameless person has to be given anywhere in the world, then the name of Mr. Kapil Sibal would be the most appropriate.
Mr.Sibbal is taking wromg note the case
CJI sir, what tamasha is going in your court, Mr Sibal, is very evidently playing you. Today before you goto bed and have sometime, watch this entire proceeding, PLEASE.
They were classmates..u know buddiez secrets 😂😂😂!
Feeling very painful when sibbal's women lawer is laughing also. So sad.
They are not women they are demons.
Seems like kabil sibal fought for KASAB too
firstly know how judiciary works. Kasab was appointed a lawyer by the govt itself . That how court works. No he dint represent Kasab
@@bharathkiriti7024But surely he is fighting for the rapist which I don't think you have any doubt
Yes he did
@@arunavabasu5768 he is fighting for the "state" the state hired him as defence lawyer.
All the rapists will have defence lawyers. First get basic education on how judiciary works
Kapil Sibal is a shameless lawyer who always fight cases for the culprits.1) Against Ram temple 2) Against Ram sethu 3) Against a innocent doctor and so on ......
He always Stand against the Evil things...Goons of Jumla Dal😀
Add Siddaramiah corruption case as well, Sibal is fighting for him.
@@imashussain5087anpadh teri maa bhi hoti tab bhi ye laddta case, paisa chahiye isee bass. dhang se baahar ni nikala tu, abhi itna bada ni hua tu jo ye samjh sake
@@imashussain5087stands against evil things? Standing against the victim and her family and the protestors protecting state and its criminals are you blind?
That's why he is referred as just a big lawyer...not a respected lawyer..
Can someone make me understand why state spending so much on Sibbal and when they are also in the same page to provide justice then what is he defending or saving the accused??
Someone has to, seriously, in detail, explain about the appointment of principal at CNMC... Nation wants to know this...
Nothing will happen to Mamata didi & West Bengal.
Modi jee & Central Govt can't do anything despite knowing WB is out-of-control from Centre. Didi knows it very well 90% Goon public are with his Party & she will continue as CM.
Spineless Modi & Shah.. Give it to YoGI
Absolutely because we have a spineless central government
It is because we the majority dumb Bengal public will shamelessly go and vote for the same evil Mamata banu again .
Only way is unknown encounters like happpened in pakistan.
why CJI is soo scared of sibal ?
look like whole proceeding is to protect west bengal govt 😢
The whole system is corrupted by money power....
Earlier i had respect for sibbal.... Not from today onwards.
Why is the lady counsel not being sllowed to speak. Make domination???
Lawyers like Kapil Sibbal & Abhishek Singhvi are always representing high profile accused people . They are shameless & unfortunately lawyers in our country.
How on earth do an army of goons descend on a hospital and carry out vandalism , if it were not planned or organised .
the CJI most powerful man in Indian judiciary is so soft spoken and has very clear english speech.
Thanks to Christian Countries
Shut up bullshit@@leenathewise8384
why dont u study law n sit there ? oh just so simple to write anything here right
How mr Sibbal get courage to fight case against this only for his monitory and political gain it’s shame on humanity and inhumane behaviour
Im pretty sure sibbal is getting more than 10lakhs for one court trial? And the family which is affected? Who lost their only daughter? They're getting only 10 lakhs WITHOUT justice? Unacceptable
Bhai 10 lakh se Jada lete hai
All criminals must hire sibbal as their lawyer
A shameless man
I hate Kapil sibbal every time.. He criminal saviour
Poor sibal. Blabbering on behalf of his didi
Not allowing the CJI even to make his point regarding the vandalized is amazing and says a lot about the state
The Culprits must not Escape.
Cji is scared of sibal, he keeps on interrupting cji, and cji is obliging. These judges can not and wouldn't be able to provide justice.
calcutta high court doing good job and then why to do suo moto
Sibbal always try defends culprit, he preach people but working for money not for morality
Hunger for money not ending
जिसने एक डाक्टर बेटी का बलात्कार किया और हत्या किया उसको डिफेन्ड कर रहा सिब्बल 21 बकीलों के फौज के साथ, उसमें महिला बकील भी हैं जो इस पापी सिब्बल को हेल्प कर रही है, शेम शेम
The judgement,which ever and whenever it is pronounced is awaited by the whole country,may revolutionise the judicial system and people will perceive it.
CJI never asks Mr sibbal to stop interruption. What kind of woman lawyers are supporting this case with him? Am shocked to see them.
Junior lawyers who adapt & accept sibbal are the worst kind no one ever can get justice
Old age advocate should retired
Kapil Sibal should be sent to Jail immediately
ये घटिया सिस्टम में क्यूं आशा करते हो महाराज
All judges of Supreme Court judges should be dismissed which is protecting an anti human government in west Bengal
Sibal keeping his track record intact defending rapists, extremists, rioters, and anything vile. Wonder which party he is affiliated to!!!!
Money is the only Motto for Sibal no Empathy or Sympathy….Why the Victim’s Body was BURNT abruptly Mr. Sibal????
Complete failure of law and order in West Bengal.Kapil Sibal arguments is based less.
Kapil Sibal should not have defended the perpetrators of the worst crime in the history of West Bengal. It goes against his reputation.
Mamta ne paise diye honge case ladne ke liye
As a Bengali I'm ashamed of calling Kolkata my hometown. This government has ruined my state. It's shameful a woman is our CM and she is trying to defend the miscreants.
This Kapil Sibbal should be kicked out of the fraternity of lawyers who is presenting this profession as a source of earning money for greedy people.
I’m shocked !!Kapil Sibal thinks he is so bigger than CJI office.chair!!he needs to brush up his basic court behavior classes and behave professionally.!!when asking why delay in filing FIR,he dares to brazenly interrupts and tries to brush aside,Without answering!!is this permissible to ignore !!!!???First let him learn to present the case in chronological sequence of events from
AM-PM ,not present hotchpotch way,confuse the learned Councils and waste precious time of CJI.we should not tolerate such intentional unempathetic behavior at all. Iam hurt by this arrogance my lord.you must bring an order sir to put such people in place and keep up our country’s honour and justice for having lost a precious daughter🙏🙏.Dr.Shashikala
beacuse he was raised by the congress
There's no end to this drama. Who is shielding whom.
I WANT TO ASK ONE QUESTION TO MR. SIBBAL:
If Kapil SIBBAL'S daughter had been in place of the VICTIM, will he would made these STUPID arguments ???
No empathy
Paise ke liye shayad ye apne beti ko bhi bech aayega
What sibbal wants to prove? Is nothing happened to the lady doctor? I never believe in Sibbal for any humanitarian step.
such a mess of the hearing, the judge must enforce that no one interrupts each other. the lawyer even interrupt the Chief Justice of India! The audacity, no respect.