when he first started to sing this song in million star he sounded so powerful and used lots of energy, but this one he controlled his voice which is nicer not too much=)))
Don't know why after hearing 萧 sang at One Million Star, 背叛 and 新不了情, I did'nt want to listen to his songs anymore. Don't have the urge to listen to him again. However, after watching Yang Zong Wei at One Million Star, I keep listening to him like as if I am addicted to him and his songs. I realised Xiao has lots of fans but don't know why I am stuck to Yang like as if he has magnetic force but I feel very blessed to be able to appreciate Yang's vocal and personality.
I'm curious why you are here and write this comment if you don't like him... Hsiao obviously has a good voice, but he is just not your style. He has a lot of fans for a reason and if he doesn't attract you it doesn't really mean anything but a matter of taste. What bothers me is how you write this comment under HIS SONG and you make him sound like "unworthy" to have that many fans. If you don't like him, please just go away and listen to whatever you like. Thank you.
Rin Sawasaki haha..I was here becos I thot after so long why not give him a try again, mayb this time I will change my mind and like listening to him as that time i saw him in Taiwan tv singing competitions. He was one of the judges. Although he was very nice in the show, I also heard him sang, but no I didn't continue to find his videos or songs after that (means after this video). I myself also wonder why.
continue: I personally don't think Jane's version is too much, but a bit change from the original version can make it hard to get used to. She just put her own style and feelings in that piece and that's just like apple and orange. Jane's version is my cup of tea, however, Jam's also great. Anyway, Jane and Jam are the 2 talented young artist that I'll be proud of for long.
@procrastinatingpig 天生麗質, 蓄放皆宜!! 我都較喜歡他留辮子的rock樣, 因為他根本就是可以很rock!! and I agree with Elmosama that he brought new life to this song which let me know about him. He can sing all kinds of song very well, he's a real musician, a genius!
As a fan of Jane Zhang(張靓穎),maybe I can't agree with some of your ideas here, but I really adore Jam's performance. Actually, Jane and Jam are quite similiar in that they both have a stronger performance in live than that in CD's.
聽老蕭唱歌很享受
听你唱歌真是一种不可形容的享受~正！！！！！！！！！
我還是最喜歡這個版本
太好聽了˙˙好聽好聽
每天都要聽一下蕭敬騰的歌聲~
他的聲音真的很震撼
新不了情，真的是听了多少遍，还是那么动人
still got me goose-bumps all over....
仍是那麼動容, 會令人心痛,
我的眼淚, 又再俏俏地滑下來....
He's so good. My fiancee is crazy about his voice - and I agree. he sings so beautifully!
i fall in love with his voice *.*
OMG, he's go great!
It took Jay Chou few years to take the crown of music kingdom. It only takes Jam two weeks to shoot to the top. Amazing
我还是喜欢这个时候的老萧。。
虽然现在还是很喜欢老萧。。但没有以前那种很着迷的感觉了。。。
我也是被他的新不了情打動的....
當年才二十歲的敬騰, 居然可以把歌曲發揮得淋漓盡致, 令人痛徹心扉, 他沒有多說話, 但他的歌聲已經告訴了我他的音樂是什麼~
乾淨的歌聲 值得再聽!
Incredible vocals
他的聲音比他之前踢館的時侯更成熟了啊~ 很特別
只是輕輕的~~~就可以唱得這麼好!
「最佳新人獎」一定是~~~敬騰!
Got me goose-bumps all over :P
Powerful with distinctive personal style, yet very touching, --- my favorite version indeed!.
第一次係星光大道聽蕭敬騰唱呢首個係最正。我鍾意以前嘅佢多D。Original
真是好節目
好懷念此時的敬騰
高音到,低音準,好勁,勁鍾意^^
when he first started to sing this song in million star he sounded so powerful and used lots of energy, but this one he controlled his voice which is nicer not too much=)))
Jam is the best!!!
如今隔了一年來聽
還是很愛敬騰的獨特的唱腔
這個版本很舒服 感覺有比比賽鬆一點
萧敬腾的声音吸引着很多爱她的人~好喜欢他的声音~
剛剛開始的時候老大好可愛哦～～XD
he brought new life to this song. thumbs up!!
白馬王子蕭敬騰,永遠支持你!
Yes, it is wonderful. The best version
不贅言
讚!!
最高境界
这样唱才最感人，最令人怀念，尤其尾音，他现在都没了，真可惜！我认为两年前的他才是萧敬腾！
Jazz, blue and great, Yeah
best of the best
歌壇最缺乏的是這時候的蕭敬騰擁有的特質，現在的歌星哪個不是油頭粉面，奇裝異服! 把東西全堆在唱歌的人身上，為甚麼就認為會好看? 大家懷念這時候的蕭敬騰是不無道理的。
Walao~A...~~~y u so GREAT ?!!! Beh tahan !!!
華納過度包裝(包括髮型和服裝)，對蕭敬騰不能不算是一種傷害。老蕭的商業味日濃，他唱歌的時候太在意觀眾的存在，彷彿動作、走步都要像歌星，就是這樣，感染力就被減弱了，其實他唱歌的功力有增無減，但看起來就不及從前自然了。讓蕭敬騰自己來包裝自己最好，這樣外表、氣質、歌藝會比較和諧一點。我也是很喜歡初出道的他。
Really great!!
我也有同感！蕭同學最初唱法有種自然屬於他自己的唱腔，有如璞玉！令人陶醉感動，眼睛有水！如今已不復見．唉~~~~
聽老蕭講解為何他要改變以前的唱法吧
czcams.com/video/wtOehCF7GMA/video.html
he sings this song very very well here, fainting ...........
最初的 蕭式唱法... 絕!!
SuperMan! SuperVoice!
i love u...
enjoyment..
goodjob
以前的咬字也很不一樣，
很喜歡現在的他
但是時不時也是會回來懷念以前的他。
This is all about soul
此君将来必定成为一代宗师。古往所谓的音乐才子，大师，神级歌手，创作歌手全被他比下去了。 应该封他为什么好呢？他已经超越了神界。大家来想想吧！
me too!!!!
2:26 一绝！
渾厚的聲音直接把我轟殺了 不需要讓我心碎 哈哈
萧同学~萧敬腾 好口爱涅~~\(≧▽≦)/~
Don't know why after hearing 萧 sang at One Million Star, 背叛 and 新不了情, I did'nt want to listen to his songs anymore. Don't have the urge to listen to him again. However, after watching Yang Zong Wei at One Million Star, I keep listening to him like as if I am addicted to him and his songs. I realised Xiao has lots of fans but don't know why I am stuck to Yang like as if he has magnetic force but I feel very blessed to be able to appreciate Yang's vocal and personality.
I'm curious why you are here and write this comment if you don't like him... Hsiao obviously has a good voice, but he is just not your style. He has a lot of fans for a reason and if he doesn't attract you it doesn't really mean anything but a matter of taste. What bothers me is how you write this comment under HIS SONG and you make him sound like "unworthy" to have that many fans. If you don't like him, please just go away and listen to whatever you like. Thank you.
+Rin Sawasaki couldn't have agreed with you more.
Rin Sawasaki haha..I was here becos I thot after so long why not give him a try again, mayb this time I will change my mind and like listening to him as that time i saw him in Taiwan tv singing competitions. He was one of the judges. Although he was very nice in the show, I also heard him sang, but no I didn't continue to find his videos or songs after that (means after this video). I myself also wonder why.
JAMGOGGO: They did it all for the show. Can't really have their best singer lose twice to Jam can they?
this was during the time of 星光 =="
着个版本是最最最最最最最吊的. 前无古人, 后无来者.
我已经把它转换成mp3了, 天天在车上听.
continue:
I personally don't think Jane's version is too much, but a bit change from the original version can make it hard to get used to. She just put her own style and feelings in that piece and that's just like apple and orange. Jane's version is my cup of tea, however, Jam's also great. Anyway, Jane and Jam are the 2 talented young artist that I'll be proud of for long.
Key Hwang and 小胖老师给他伴奏...超美耶..!!
@procrastinatingpig 天生麗質, 蓄放皆宜!! 我都較喜歡他留辮子的rock樣, 因為他根本就是可以很rock!! and I agree with Elmosama that he brought new life to this song which let me know about him. He can sing all kinds of song very well, he's a real musician, a genius!
"如"何廝守到老
As a fan of Jane Zhang(張靓穎),maybe I can't agree with some of your ideas here, but I really adore Jam's performance. Actually, Jane and Jam are quite similiar in that they both have a stronger performance in live than that in CD's.
管你們在批評
喜歡就好
張靓穎的版本 我聽不怎麼習慣
但是我也很欣賞她
感覺她也是很"真"的一個人
本来36拍的编曲就很好，不知道为什么要多此一举改shuffle...
开场的嗓音实在是太惊艳了。。。
這版本是表現他最純粹的強跟屌
後半段的尾音 用了很多高難度的強震音
也只有這版聽的到
無論何版本都會有人喜歡 jam光跟自己比就可以 有粉多版本來比 所以應該沒必要跟別人比哈哈
三各版本都強
可能前兩版聽多了
現在比較喜歡新版的
這個最棒
之後的都沒蕭風
我不知道大家喜歡以前的他還是現在的他
我只知道我愛死他了....
還是比較喜歡以前的老蕭~~
他唱的key比曹格唱的略低
所以更顯示聲音的渾厚
曹格則是細緻
各有特色~~都很棒
He sang a lot more better compared to when he sang at one million star.
Damn just why nobody mentioned this video?
現在都很好的啦！但願他好好保重身體，保重聲帶可能剛剛看了他和張雨生的合唱，有點感觸~~~
@weekiatconqueror you are right. from low C to high Bb.
我还是比较喜欢他留辫子的样子。Rock 味十足。
希望他能保持自己，不要被娱乐园磨没了棱角。
喜欢他不唱歌时候的羞涩样子，和唱歌时候的张狂。
他唱歌有爆發力，但不用一直用爵士方式唱歌，所以後來老師們有幫他做調整
不， 此君的确有此实力。多几年你就了解我所说的。多听几遍他所窜译的歌曲， 他其实给了这些歌曲应有的灵魂， 他把一些给唱坏的歌曲修补好了，重新注入生命。
用心去听歌吧！年轻人。
以前的他.. 唱歌真的是很動聽
即使我是男生也被迷上他的聲音
可是..現在他被唱片公司變得商業化了...
連唱腔都變了..
聽老蕭講解為何他要改變以前的唱法吧
czcams.com/video/wtOehCF7GMA/video.html
唉.你終於黎香港開show..但係我買唔到飛!我等左好耐..都係冇份
對於樓下ccsj1ss 的評論我不太認同
但我也不認為他是在批評
第一 張靓穎也是年輕人(大陸新生代的女歌手 我也欣賞她)第二 張靓穎版本的新不了情 我不認為是徐徐道來 她的版本我還認為改編的too much 之前聽過感覺如此 現在再回頭重聽一遍也有此感受
@aneki78 之前在KTV的時候敬騰有唱過原key囉~真的超厲害!!
第三 我認為男人跟女人詮釋傷痛的方式本來就不太一樣 每個人對於感情的演譯更是不盡相同 單說年輕人對於生活及感情缺乏領悟我不認同 每個人的經歷不會一樣 對於感情 不應該以年齡作為經驗值的判斷 只能說人生的每個階段 都有各自不同的感受及體悟 一段無法延續的感情 只要是真心的人 相信誰都無法無不痛徹心扉
還我霸氣
怎麼變成這樣T-T
现在他唱的比较不一样了。比较正常又温柔。24/20 而且是楊宗緯的 key (Eb major)。如果萧敬腾和楊宗緯合唱 新不了情... 每個人会狂起来。
@freethinkermike It's not C.. it's in the key of Eb..
是#Eb调吧∩__∩
强喔xDD
這版本的和超級星光大道的感覺差好多喔@@!
any idea wat key is Jam singing for xing bu liao qing?
@freethinkermike 是#D 调耶
曹格版本比較深情，，
蕭唱得太雄渾了 ，反而少了令人心碎的感覺
can any 1 send me this video?
pls.....
better than Kyuhyun version =)
@assermanyt btw how old ar u?
为啥听完以后起鸡皮嘎达呢。。。
特别是上高音之前。。。
老胖老師憑什麼給3分?
@marco9515 我也是!!
think its F
比pk時唱得更好
@xuyang87 C. 標準男聲
這首歌不適合用這種唱法(ff).用樂譜上的記號來說,三人聲音強度的差別:蕭敬騰是ff,曹格是f,楊宗緯是mf.(所以曹格在唱的時候收放自如.而蕭要減弱音量會比較難以控制,不小心會太over.楊在三人之中算是弱聲,但是稍微用力一點就可以彌補.)