Black Swan / Odile Variation - Zakharova, Osipova, Nunez

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 4. 06. 2024
  • Hi Ballet Lovers, here you have an incredible comparison between three unique and wonderful ballerinas in the world: the Black Swan / Odile Variation by Svetlana Zakharova (00:00), Natalia Osipova (01:32), Marianela Nunez (03:45)
    Which one do you prefer? Write in comments!
    Zakharova's music is different because it seems there are no other music versions on CZcams. Sorry for that!
    - GET our creative t-shirts:
    teespring.com/it/kitri-collec...
    - SUPPORT us on Patreon👇❤️
    / danceline
    ________________________________
    For requests, feedbacks or infos, or if you think one of these content should be removed for any reason, do not hesitate to contact us at: staff.danceline@gmail.com
    Follow us on:
    Instagram: danceline_ig
    Facebook: danceline.it
    * This CZcams channel may get commissions for purchases made through Amazon links above. Feel free to use them for supporting this channel.
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 1,8K

  • @DanceLineBallet
    @DanceLineBallet  Před 3 lety +646

    Dear Ballet lovers, don't forget to SUBSCRIBE if you enjoyed the video 😍 Thanks for your support!

    • @victoriapresser3569
      @victoriapresser3569 Před 3 lety +13

      I you only knew what a joy it is to be able to watch such wonderful dancers on CZcams, in the middle of the night, even. When I was younger, I was fortunate to see Baryshnikov and before that Nureyev. We don't get as many of the great European Ballets down here in Australia, although we have given the world some brilliant dancers of our own 😀❤

    • @victoriapresser3569
      @victoriapresser3569 Před 3 lety +3

      @Rodney Langston Just curious, but why?

    • @mariamartin8516
      @mariamartin8516 Před 3 lety +7

      Thank you for your beautiful posts!

    • @chelseawangthegreat1166
      @chelseawangthegreat1166 Před 3 lety +6

      Thank you for the videos! I will subscribe.🤩😍

    • @hectoraureliocarcasjulio5349
      @hectoraureliocarcasjulio5349 Před 2 lety +3

      Increibles aberturas y precisión de mivimientos. Bellísimo !!!

  • @beverlythebird5040
    @beverlythebird5040 Před 3 lety +3756

    Zahkarova made the character seem intimidating and unpredictable
    Osipova’s was graceful and mysterious.
    Nuñez’s was strong and majestic.

    • @marianotaglioni2605
      @marianotaglioni2605 Před 2 lety +31

      Osipova’s black swan is a joke

    • @sherrimiller5258
      @sherrimiller5258 Před 2 lety +118

      I like that you found the individual characteristics that each brought to playing/dancing this part. What a kind, positive comment. So rare on the internet.

    • @douchkanikoliic6182
      @douchkanikoliic6182 Před 2 lety +35

      Zahkarova was heavy on the stage floor. You should never be able to hear the steps hitting the floor. That’s a huge no no.

    • @abacusyou
      @abacusyou Před rokem +33

      I agree I think I prefer zahkarova for that exact reason it fit the character better.

    • @annalomantz9152
      @annalomantz9152 Před rokem +16

      У Захаровой техническое совершенство и лучшие шпагаты.

  • @williamdeng1870
    @williamdeng1870 Před 3 lety +3375

    Every audience has their own preferences, but this cannot change the charm of the three masters of ballet, their artistic achievements have reached the point of perfection.

    • @alainspiteri502
      @alainspiteri502 Před 3 lety +11

      W Deng : perfection no : Zakha is too big for a true teenager as the young Giselle also Aurora ; her excessives extensions more than 180 are not esthetic ( also Sylvie Guillem ) : all CZcamsrs millions and millions write the same thing it's tiresome. .

    • @katyabo1461
      @katyabo1461 Před 3 lety +4

      Absolutely!)

    • @micky4fun
      @micky4fun Před 3 lety +45

      @@alainspiteri502 -- Oh, my! Another "expert"...! Want to see you do it.

    • @alainspiteri502
      @alainspiteri502 Před 3 lety +4

      @@micky4fun yes , before play Toccata op-92 of Czerny

    • @Patricia94227
      @Patricia94227 Před 2 lety +8

      @@alainspiteri502 Don´t waste your time reading what is for you boring!

  • @calypsodream8059
    @calypsodream8059 Před 2 lety +1835

    Zacharova's arms as the wings of a swan are yet to be matched by another. They are utterly exquisite and mesmerizing.

    • @user-bh9zd4gz9z
      @user-bh9zd4gz9z Před 2 lety +10

      Да Руки!

    • @karennoble1076
      @karennoble1076 Před rokem +11

      Yes Calypso dream and it was Baryshnikov who picked her beside her other qualities for her arms and hands.

    • @pamelasertich9850
      @pamelasertich9850 Před rokem +6

      I completely agree

    • @Christina4758
      @Christina4758 Před rokem +3

      Love her arms but Nina Ananiashvili had the most magical ever IMHO.

    • @nelkatanelka
      @nelkatanelka Před rokem +13

      @@Christina4758 Let's not forget Ulyana Lopatkina and by all means, Eva Evdokimova.

  • @MarcelaGalarza-tz4hi
    @MarcelaGalarza-tz4hi Před rokem +347

    The way in which Zakharova moves her arms is simly unparalleled and hypnotizing!

    • @erinundra
      @erinundra Před 28 dny

      Some of those extensions she does that twists her torso out of alignment are just awful.

  • @user-jf6uv1sd2r
    @user-jf6uv1sd2r Před 3 lety +6991

    For me, Osipova is not just a ballet dancer, she is an actress. While i've watched her dance i saw the beautiful swan.

    • @sheeniebeanie2597
      @sheeniebeanie2597 Před 3 lety +60

      her in la bayadere it's like you never want to stop watching

    • @miranduri
      @miranduri Před 3 lety +60

      Definitely. She is perfection

    • @aleksssandRaa
      @aleksssandRaa Před 3 lety +58

      Absolutely. I see her as Giselle, it was perfect and she makes her role alive

    • @user-jf6uv1sd2r
      @user-jf6uv1sd2r Před 3 lety +53

      Yes, her soul is dancing, not only physical body.

    • @virgola2126
      @virgola2126 Před 3 lety +21

      Totally agree. Stunning performance.

  • @deborahclem4901
    @deborahclem4901 Před 3 lety +4364

    Zahkarova- “I’m way prettier and more elegant than boring Odette.”
    Osipova- “I stomped on Odette on the way over here and you all better not argue.”
    Nunez- “There is no Odette. I’m more sinister than you can handle. I MIGHT let you admire me.”

    • @Sshadowkate
      @Sshadowkate Před 3 lety +173

      Might have flipped Zahkarova and Nunez, but damn straight. No one fucks with the Odile.

    • @user-tb2wc8rc2e
      @user-tb2wc8rc2e Před 3 lety +106

      @@Sshadowkate yeah, agree. Zahkarova clearly invoked a more sinister presence.

    • @nortegar
      @nortegar Před 3 lety +7

      😂😂😂

    • @captainkielbasa5471
      @captainkielbasa5471 Před 3 lety +2

      that's why women should cover up. attention should be earned!

    • @julesghoulzz
      @julesghoulzz Před 3 lety +173

      @@captainkielbasa5471 wtf?

  • @danikamcleod707
    @danikamcleod707 Před rokem +166

    I love Zakharova. There's something so fluid and effortless with her movements.

  • @anaconcessabingham8405
    @anaconcessabingham8405 Před rokem +22

    Zakharova gave the great illusion of a swan more than the other two. All beautiful and graceful dancers.

  • @beatrixkiddo1279
    @beatrixkiddo1279 Před 3 lety +2546

    I, in my opinion, prefer Osipova most of the ballets, but in the Swan Lake, especially Black Swan, Zakharova took another place. She made it her own. Not only her technique but also her attitude and gestures are enough to say that ''I am a black swan.'' I cannot stay without saying , Nunez has so much control (especially turns) and acting talent. She is so calm and stable always. They are all amazing, at their own individual way.

    • @hejhej4441
      @hejhej4441 Před 3 lety +35

      I usually yawn while watching Zakharova as I personally think her dancing is reminiscent of a hypermobile' "perfectly technically programmed" robot. But her black swan is truly something else, extremely intriguing to watch her in this role.

    • @beatrixkiddo1279
      @beatrixkiddo1279 Před 3 lety +82

      @@hejhej4441 not agreed at all, I don't think she is robot because I think no ballerina should be called like that. I prefer to say her technicality is quite strict :) She is an amazing ballerina probably one of the best of our era. Her extentions and technic is unique... All ballerinas are different and beautiful. Btw you are right, she is at her top in this role.

    • @hejhej4441
      @hejhej4441 Před 3 lety +16

      @@beatrixkiddo1279 I know that she is famous for a reason and I know why many people don't agree with me. This was just my personal blunt opinion. Of course, dancers should strive to have as perfect technique they can but personally I care very little for "perfection" in that aspect as long as it looks good and fits the role. I like to think of ballet as an athletically demanding artform first and a sport second. I personally find it quite tiresome to see how this generation of dancers dancers are taught to strive after being able to get their foot to their ear (even if it isn't on time with the music) and to have their legs shaped like an "s" because they strive towards those hyperextensions and banana feet. I'd much rather see a dancers who sacrifice a little technique for artistry, acting and expression both through their face and body, that is what I think makes a prima ballerina stand out from the others. But I understand why technical perfectionism appealing to some, to each their own.

    • @beatrixkiddo1279
      @beatrixkiddo1279 Před 3 lety +19

      @@hejhej4441 I put my signature under every sentence you say. I also think like you. None of my favorite dancers throughout history have had huge extentions. Asslymuratova, Nureyev, Makarova, Plisetskaya ... (except Sylvie Guillem).
      For example: Assylmuratova's Nikiya's Death. None has ever been able to present it as well as Altnai. No extention as big as today's ballerinas, but the lines are very clear. Emotions are unique. Extention also comes from just there.. She is the only one.
      The ability to give the sense of art to the other party is only heartfelt, not the leg extention. Also, just because someone has a large extention does not mean they cannot give emotion. For example Sylvie Guillem. Art perception is based on where a person looks at it.
      Two issues are a bit tricky.
      You seem to be diverting the subject a little. :)

    • @hejhej4441
      @hejhej4441 Před 3 lety +6

      @@beatrixkiddo1279 I agree with you. I am also a fan of some ballerinas with high extensions that are very capable of translating their technique into artistry to fit their character, like Sylvie Guillem, so they can definitely coexist. I think that the reason as to why I don't enjoy Zakharova in most roles is because I personally don't feel her, even though I'm being blunt and expressing my personal thoughts. Where I come from we also tend to be very blunt with how we feel about something/someone even if it sounds rude (things like cursewords and insults are also taken way lore lightly than in other cultures, it's even fine for teachers to use them as long as their students have passed a certain age) not that it is an excuse. But just so that you understand that my sole intent isn't to undermine anyone as a dancer, but just to express myself in a way that people around me have expressed themselves since childhood) that pass through my head when watching her, I am not saying that she is an objectively bad dancer. We all have our subjective opinions and this is just mine. But overall I agree with you and I'm glad that you understand where I'm coming from.
      And yeah, I am diverting the subject haha. I guess this discussion wasn't what you signed up for when you wrote your original comment. But it was still interesting to hear what you had to say (or write).

  • @hermajesty52
    @hermajesty52 Před 3 lety +579

    Nunez captured my heart in this. So serene and in with the music.

    • @LanaW123
      @LanaW123 Před 3 lety +22

      Her swift head movements and tge way she felt the music. Osipova' s turns are amazing as always. With all my respect to zaharova, I don't find her captivating and fluid.

    • @doragrigera7022
      @doragrigera7022 Před 3 lety +13

      Marianela es maravillosa

    • @marjnussby1516
      @marjnussby1516 Před 3 lety +8

      Also, beautiful and smoothly executed extensions.

    • @sergeikoiwu400
      @sergeikoiwu400 Před rokem +4

      @@LanaW123 нуньес хороша в боях без правил а для балета она деревяшка вот если бы ей роль буратино то она лучшая

    • @primalcritters
      @primalcritters Před 4 měsíci +1

      Nunez makes me yawn. Svetlana actually looks like a prima ballerina Assoluta! Her lines, extensions, legs, Divine arms and hands I mean she is like an angel and fairy wrapped up in one and perfectly personifies the black and the white swan. Comparison, Nunez looks like a clumsy linebacker. She has good technique, but it's not astonishing is the problem

  • @user-es1rz1nn7h
    @user-es1rz1nn7h Před 7 měsíci +51

    Осипова-жто не человек-это космос, с такой лёгкостью и атлетизмом танцевать никто корме неё не может.. Просто фантастика.. 😮❤

  • @ekris7647
    @ekris7647 Před 2 lety +108

    Какие шикарные руки у Светланы Захаровой! Прямо крылья, столько изящества!

  • @ibuprofenPill
    @ibuprofenPill Před 3 lety +826

    Zakharova has grace and beautiful lines (that attitude is perfection), Osipova has the acting ability and technical power while Nunez has a fair combination of both. These three women are incredible.

  • @alicedotkay
    @alicedotkay Před 3 lety +882

    The way Marienela rolls down her pointe shoes is just so buttery soft and smooth!

    • @ThePenkiteTV
      @ThePenkiteTV Před 2 lety +17

      Technically flawless but I don’t think she portrayed the character as well as Osipova

    • @danza521
      @danza521 Před 2 lety +1

      Bbbbooooooriiiiing

    • @lsky4446
      @lsky4446 Před 2 lety +1

      JUST LIKE SYLVIE G!!!

    • @queenofpixels5458
      @queenofpixels5458 Před 2 lety +4

      While I normally love Marienela there were a few instances where I felt she just didn't complete a move. Like she was on to the next thing before complete extension. I'm probably not expressing that very well.

    • @robertofalcone8442
      @robertofalcone8442 Před 2 lety

      Condivido pienamente

  • @erinstahle6999
    @erinstahle6999 Před 2 lety +104

    I know nothing about ballet but this is the beauty I saw most in each.
    Zarakova's beautiful arms, Osipova's strength, and Nunez's fluidity.

  • @andreawaterstreet3901
    @andreawaterstreet3901 Před 3 lety +175

    Osipova is such a great actress interpretater. She personifies the haughtiness and disdain of the character, that these mortals are daring to behold her beauty.

  • @bergercookie
    @bergercookie Před rokem +189

    Osipova pulled me in with her passion and the quality of her movements! She extends everything full out and finishes every move with a passionate extension. She has so much respect in every single movement and such a flow I could feel her character as it built up in the iconic choreo!!! What an absolute goddess 🩰💃🏻💞💞💞💞💞👑👑👑👑

  • @ayanoaishi8489
    @ayanoaishi8489 Před rokem +32

    I could watch Osipova dance for hours! She seems so elegant and mysterious I love it

  • @user-sy3qo3lf2k
    @user-sy3qo3lf2k Před 3 měsíci +7

    Боже, разумеется Наталья Осипова лучшая и бесподобна

  • @eleneva
    @eleneva Před rokem +439

    Nunez' performance is literally hypnotizing 😀

    • @user-uf2er8yi9f
      @user-uf2er8yi9f Před rokem +4

      👎💪

    • @steveiliev8912
      @steveiliev8912 Před rokem

      Nunez is kind of hyper, uneasy!
      There are moments she looks like “fast forwarded” on the video!
      I have noticed same thing with Gillian Murphy!
      They dance like they are on cocaine or sort of!
      The other two are so smooth and fluid!
      But my vote goes to Osipova!

    • @philzmusic8098
      @philzmusic8098 Před rokem +5

      It's because she s t r e t c h e s the phrases; everything is unpredictable.

    • @RS-rz9xj
      @RS-rz9xj Před 9 měsíci +12

      You are right. She is the most aligned, placed, and timed. Hyperextension does not mesmerize me.

    • @letsparchmentitupyo7566
      @letsparchmentitupyo7566 Před 5 měsíci

      @@RS-rz9xj agreed!!

  • @elisek1067
    @elisek1067 Před 3 lety +178

    Amazing the three of them, Svetlana so artistic, Osipova so powerful, Nella so controlled each one of them unique!!!

  • @kabardinka1
    @kabardinka1 Před 3 lety +1627

    First off, it's absurd to compare dancers who are performing different variations. My preference for Osipova is because she's dancing a specific character, Odile, not just doing pretty ballet moves. Odile is about seduction, making a fool of the prince and court, not just entertaining them, and I think Osipova puts that over the best. When Osipova imitates Odette, it's almost as if she's doing it with a mocking smirk on her face and I love that interpretation. Whatever Odile is (Plisetskaya referred to her as an 'imp') she's evil and manipulative not just someone in a black tutu.

    • @hejhej4441
      @hejhej4441 Před 3 lety +50

      I agree with you. In that aspect Osipova is amazing, she's my all time favourite dancer. But in this role I prefer Evgenia Obraztsova since she has the most unique and multi-dimensional (if that's the right word) interpretation of Odile. I don't enjoy her Odette a lot, but I like how she plays Odile as this character who isn't just pure evil, but evil at the commands of her father whom she is still dependent on. Her acting is astounding in that role and the way she uses the music for dramatic expression also just that.

    • @lankamakarova7530
      @lankamakarova7530 Před 3 lety +18

      Да! Осипова очень характерная, артистичная и особо шармантная! В ней, кроме техники есть душа. Душа образа и танца.
      Но, безусловно, великолепны все! Браво!

    • @lgomez3268
      @lgomez3268 Před 3 lety +12

      @@hejhej4441 I just saw a video of Eugenia Obraztsova, and you’re right, she’s fantastic...

    • @kabardinka1
      @kabardinka1 Před 3 lety +14

      @@hejhej4441 Well, Evgenia Obraztsova who's, of course, a wonderful dancer, is performing in the Bourmeister version of Swan Lake... very different ballet with different music (for this act), totally different choreography and a different vibe. I like that version but it's completely different from what Osipova is dancing. Who says Odile is Rothbart's daughter? She's this supernatural creature he's brought to the palace and, yes, I think she's totally evil, there to humiliate the prince and his parents. There is no nice aspect of her. I do like how Obraztsova is almost at times like a dancing doll, but I kind of think she loses it in the middle of the PDD and, for me, Osipova gives a much more focused performance. Different strokes for...

    • @hejhej4441
      @hejhej4441 Před 3 lety +6

      @@kabardinka1 I’m aware that she’s dancing a very different version. I was just speaking of the role of Odile in general and not this variation specifically. I’m not saying that Odile is Rothbarts daughter, I’m just saying that it is the vibe that Evgenia is giving me (a daddy’s girl who’s been told to be evil and seductive help her summoner and his evil plans) and commend her on such a unique interpretation.
      Wheter you want Odile to be multi-dimensional or pure evil is simply a matter of preferences. That is why different interpretations and different dancers exist and I still think Osipova is wonderful in this role.

  • @jenylogan1
    @jenylogan1 Před 3 lety +24

    They are all three superb ballerinas, but there is a refinement of detail in Zakharova that sets her apart.

  • @user-jp3xv6jd5q
    @user-jp3xv6jd5q Před 3 měsíci +8

    Осипова лучшая! Легкая, парящая, непревзойдённая! А какая техника! Совершенство, - это Наташа! Браво!
    ❤💐👑

  • @cris7730
    @cris7730 Před 3 lety +45

    Zakharova is at another level. The control, the balance, her extensions, and those arches! Beautiful.

  • @franovak2654
    @franovak2654 Před 3 lety +70

    I love Zakharova's piece music, it fits the Black Swan vibes perfectly.

  • @elsagreen1476
    @elsagreen1476 Před 9 měsíci +7

    Not to compare, because all three of them are incredible performers, artists and athletes - but watching Natalia Osipova dance the black swan literally feels like being bewitched. She's casting a spell as she dances. Absolutely out of this world

  • @Jabo__Jabo
    @Jabo__Jabo Před 2 lety +22

    I really loved seeing these three masters. (I enjoyed reading everyone’s opinion too) For me, Zakharova.

  • @markbeck8384
    @markbeck8384 Před 3 lety +115

    Wonderful artists. Zakharova was the most beautiful; Osipova the best actress and wonderfully in control; Nunez had, for me, the most interesting variation.

  • @jitkavongehr-habibjana5711
    @jitkavongehr-habibjana5711 Před 3 lety +42

    Osipova ist die Beste 💐

  • @TITANIClover202
    @TITANIClover202 Před 2 lety +166

    The way Marianela Nunez' movements are really on point with the music is absolutely captivating

  • @frankiefavero1666
    @frankiefavero1666 Před rokem +5

    Svetlana IS Odile! As someone who has grown up watching every interpretation of Swan Lake since the age of 3; when I saw Svetlana dance the Black Swan for the first time, my heart futtered almost as rhythmically as Svetlana's arms did... I had found my forever Odile ❤

  • @user-nn5xf4uy4h
    @user-nn5xf4uy4h Před 3 lety +54

    Про Захарову не пишу,она богиня необсуждаемая,Осипова браво!!!!

  • @Deedee-ee1sg
    @Deedee-ee1sg Před 3 lety +10

    Lovely compilation video of great dancing! Nunez has a hint of the great Pavlova! But my favourite is Natalia Osipova, who is the epitome of a Star Ballerina. A superb dancer, with immense charisma, incredible technique and thrilling to watch!!

    • @DanceLineBallet
      @DanceLineBallet  Před 3 lety +2

      Thank you 🥰

    • @sallygardiner7150
      @sallygardiner7150 Před 3 lety +1

      Having watched Osipova in several ballets; I find her interpretation is mostly the same; she also has a fast virtuousity; which is not the same thing as interpreting and emoting different characters, and drawing the audience into the story. Svetlana and are both Nela are great actors, and very compelling.

  • @taravolna6192
    @taravolna6192 Před 2 lety +15

    I can't tell which one was "better" for me.. but I did love the detail if Zakharova's hands - it's these small things that can really make a choreography

  • @cheridusek9185
    @cheridusek9185 Před 2 lety +73

    Nunez's dancing has an artistry and lyricism that makes Odile come alive.

    • @NEnigma777
      @NEnigma777 Před 4 měsíci

      I was yawning during her performance lol. I couldn’t even finish it because I was so bored

    • @primalcritters
      @primalcritters Před 4 měsíci +1

      I can barely watch her performance it's boring. Svetlana is the black and white swan.

    • @primalcritters
      @primalcritters Před 4 měsíci +1

      ​@@NEnigma777completely agree with you. I have no idea how people can even compare Nunez to Svetlana or even Osipova. Svetlana is the black and the white swan she looks like a magical fairy Angel ballerina. Simply Divine The Best of the Best of the best

  • @alexanderkowollik3681
    @alexanderkowollik3681 Před 3 lety +79

    Svetlana Zakharova dances music. Her movement, her fysics, her being, whatever you call it, she is the music she dances. True beauty.

    • @chaali9961
      @chaali9961 Před 3 lety +4

      To me she seems a bit like she has no strength. Idk if you are a professional ballet dancer but her technique is good but not on osipovas or nunezs level. And that she operated her feet makes it seem fake and that is not REAL beauty to me. Just saying

    • @cris7730
      @cris7730 Před 3 lety +5

      She's beyond text-book perfect!

    • @chaali9961
      @chaali9961 Před 3 lety +1

      @@cris7730 I don't think so

    • @cris7730
      @cris7730 Před 3 lety +7

      @@chaali9961 Thanks so much for that update, Joel. Your personal opinion is not relevant at all. People just have different tastes.

    • @chaali9961
      @chaali9961 Před 3 lety +2

      @@cris7730 who asked you?

  • @alexiadesantis6204
    @alexiadesantis6204 Před 3 lety +138

    I don't understand anything about dance at all, I'm a figure skater, but Nunez really comes from another planet🤩. She is so perfect OMG🥰🤩

    • @fioredm1143
      @fioredm1143 Před 3 lety +12

      I preferred her too ... and like you I don't understand anything but I like ballet. Nuñez has a fluidity that hit me a lot ... mesmerizing and powerfull!!!

    • @angelacymerman282
      @angelacymerman282 Před 2 lety +4

      This!

    • @Blimpie1000
      @Blimpie1000 Před 2 lety +5

      @@fioredm1143 Fluidity was my thought about Nunez also

    • @walkingwith_dinosaurs
      @walkingwith_dinosaurs Před 2 měsíci +1

      Don't figure skaters also learn dome ballet?

  • @olgakononova5386
    @olgakononova5386 Před 3 lety +43

    Здесь лучшая Захарова!!! Настоящий чёрный лебедь! Удивительно музыкально: взгляд, жест, движение! Очаровательна, легка, грациозна!!!

    • @barchinbarchin9903
      @barchinbarchin9903 Před 2 lety +6

      Осипова грациознее

    • @user-jm4zd5fv9o
      @user-jm4zd5fv9o Před 2 lety +1

      @@barchinbarchin9903 и артистичнее Захаровой.

    • @user-pe9hm3si3y
      @user-pe9hm3si3y Před rokem

      Захарова высокого роста,а значит тяжёлая.

  • @ARA-14620
    @ARA-14620 Před 3 lety +65

    Natalia Osipova...the best,the absolute perfection,the wonderfool...

  • @isabs8616
    @isabs8616 Před 3 lety +169

    Natalia is so perfect, and expressive

  • @user-dd1dg7cc8o
    @user-dd1dg7cc8o Před 3 lety +49

    Очень интересный ролик. Три грации. Как будто три разных балета. Осипова по физике превосходит все грани разумного! Подобной балерины точно никогда не было, да и наверное уже и не будет. У меня она всегда вызывает чувство просто абсолютного восторга

    • @dogtalk_7775
      @dogtalk_7775 Před 3 lety +14

      Осипова ниразу, не лебедь, Захарова - сама элегантность,...

    • @sailorv8067
      @sailorv8067 Před 3 lety +8

      И не надо больше такого лебедя, на куропатку больше похоже...

    • @user-mr2xc8hf4g
      @user-mr2xc8hf4g Před 3 lety +2

      @@dogtalk_7775 да, читала, читала комментарии...
      Наконец, ваш коммент совпадает с моим мнением.

    • @user-fy4ss7rb7u
      @user-fy4ss7rb7u Před 3 lety +1

      @@user-mr2xc8hf4g Полностью поддерживаю

    • @Bastinda.
      @Bastinda. Před 3 lety +1

      @@user-mr2xc8hf4g девочки, я с вами

  • @user-dy6pu7hx9h
    @user-dy6pu7hx9h Před 2 lety +22

    ЗАХАРОВА восхитительна!!!!!

  • @rasteniaMk
    @rasteniaMk Před 8 měsíci +13

    Осипова очень красиво станцевала,настоящая лебедь,не просто технический номер,как отработала Маринелла,а именно станцевала!

  • @victoriapresser3569
    @victoriapresser3569 Před 3 lety +173

    For me, Osipova is the one who truly flies, she's like a feather, but in total control of her entire body and each movement.

    • @Andy-nq2so
      @Andy-nq2so Před 3 lety +6

      Agree! Each moment held and executed perfectly.

    • @joas3324
      @joas3324 Před rokem +1

      I agree.

  • @ejc480
    @ejc480 Před 3 lety +283

    Wow! Thank you for sharing this fantastic video. You’ve chosen 3 amazing dancers to compare. For me, Zakharova embodies Odile the best with Osipova in a close second place. Yet, I find Nunez’s dancing to be so satisfying to watch- her musicality and smooth control. They’re all gorgeous!

    • @sheeniebeanie2597
      @sheeniebeanie2597 Před 3 lety +2

      like light whipped cream has the consistency of butter

    • @atr46
      @atr46 Před rokem +3

      У Нуньес не та школа, это очень видно, сразу бросается в глаза. Нет такой отточенности поз, хотя очень технична, но где- то не так руки, стопы чуть-чуть. Захарова идеальна, а удлиненные линии тела перетекают друг в друга, очень красивые, лебедь . Она и Лопаткина для меня идеальные балерины.

    • @Fry-lx6bk
      @Fry-lx6bk Před rokem +2

      Same here

  • @user-hu2em6gd4k
    @user-hu2em6gd4k Před rokem +8

    У Осиповой танец естественный!!!!

  • @cellinimedusa4679
    @cellinimedusa4679 Před 2 lety +128

    Osipova is, as always, incomparable. Her routines are always more complex because she easily does complex and l think she is the most graceful dancer of all

  • @dj-jn7qs
    @dj-jn7qs Před 3 lety +140

    As only an observer, I can't state enough the importance of those movements of the hands, arms and head that Svetlana pulls off. Those little touches transform everything to a magical level. All great performances, but those little details take my breath away.

    • @jenylogan1
      @jenylogan1 Před 3 lety +3

      I love your observation, and you put it perfectly.

    • @kivukkk973
      @kivukkk973 Před 3 lety

      d j. Absolutely agree!!!

  • @gwenechotaylor96
    @gwenechotaylor96 Před 3 lety +106

    For me it's Osipova. I'm addicted!

  • @skrtskrt22
    @skrtskrt22 Před 2 lety +16

    love how each one had a specific skill that they focused on. jumps, then extensions, then turns. absolutely gorgeous all three.

  • @fthornberry3032
    @fthornberry3032 Před rokem +18

    I think Marianela Nunez is my favorite. Her movements are graceful and elegant, and with the music. Her feet feel like she does not even touch the floor. She is my favorite, followed by Zakharova. Great video.

  • @arwaelhendy6426
    @arwaelhendy6426 Před 3 lety +148

    Every one of them has her own perfection. All of them are really fantastic but i prefer Zakharova

    • @cynthiafletcher9845
      @cynthiafletcher9845 Před 3 lety +22

      Each dancer displays her unique talents beautifully. Svetlana uses her lovely hands and arms to manipulate the Prince. Her technique is also amazing.
      Osipova uses her power to convey a strong black swan, while Nela displays great attention to detail and wonderful musicality. Each has her own gifts to give an adoring audience. Great video and much thanks, C 💝💝💝

    • @cynthiafletcher9845
      @cynthiafletcher9845 Před 3 lety +8

      Yes, she use her sensuality and great technical skills to perfection. 💝

    • @harrietbryant7772
      @harrietbryant7772 Před 3 lety +23

      Svetlana, always Svetlana! For me, always the best.

    • @arwaelhendy6426
      @arwaelhendy6426 Před 3 lety +2

      @@cynthiafletcher9845 really true 👌👌👌

    • @cynthiafletcher9845
      @cynthiafletcher9845 Před 3 lety +6

      @@arwaelhendy6426 Thank you for your reply. I agree with your comments. Svetlana always delivers a memorable performance. C💝

  • @karennoble1076
    @karennoble1076 Před rokem +10

    For me the best especially as a vulnerable Odette is Svetlana Zhakarova. Great! as Odile here too!
    Her fluidity, her legendary arms and hands (Baryshnikov picked her out for them), artistry, lightness, etc. Her extensions too.
    The others are great as well but have more of athletic muscles, bodies, Svetlana has the ideal ballerina body/subtle muscles.

  • @henricoshawty85
    @henricoshawty85 Před 6 měsíci +6

    Ok. I am sorry but Svetlana Zakharova ate the role of the Black Swan...and she left no crumbs...PERIOD!

  • @balletshoes
    @balletshoes Před 3 lety +22

    Zakharova - ethereal! Osipova is a great jumper, but I have always found it to be my preference for lyrical ballerinas with long limbs and great use of the neck.

  • @user-vo4ef1mk1v
    @user-vo4ef1mk1v Před 3 lety +131

    Все балерины прекрасны и каждая по-особому!Нельзя их сравнивать!Просто любуешься их танцем,спасибо им за полную самоотдачу и любовь к своему искусству и зрителям!💖👏👏👏👏👏

    • @user-kg5cn3zb1k
      @user-kg5cn3zb1k Před 3 lety +12

      Очень точно подметили - каждая вносит свое, они прекрасны, глаз не оторвать... Спасибо автору - есть возможность увидеть многогранность образа Одили ( у нас в Одессе был радиоканал Гармония мира - и час классической музыки - вечером, после работы, слушала на кухне рассказ о либретто Лебединое озеро - и плакала... Удивительная история, а музыка Чайковского - это как бесконечность Вселенной....)

    • @user-nc3ox5ql5z
      @user-nc3ox5ql5z Před 2 lety +10

      Да ну, последняя тумбоподобна, не гнется. И кушать надо меньше

    • @user-jc4sn7up3q
      @user-jc4sn7up3q Před 2 lety +19

      Нуньез технична, но тяжеловата и старовата ! Нет легкости в танце как у Осиповой , и пластичности как у Захаровой ! Не русская балерина, не русская школа!

    • @user-gw1qw1nj3z
      @user-gw1qw1nj3z Před 2 lety +1

      @@user-jc4sn7up3q,русская школа у Захаровой? Захарова перевелась на последний курс АРБ...до этого училась в Киеве

    • @funnyskillet5953
      @funnyskillet5953 Před 2 lety +12

      @@user-gw1qw1nj3z Но ведь в Киеве изначально преподавали ученики Вагановой, а она символ русской школы балета

  • @moksha1167
    @moksha1167 Před 2 lety +14

    Zakharova is my favorite. She has the most elegant proportions and style. She happens to be 4 in taller than the other two.

  • @alain.10b95
    @alain.10b95 Před 4 dny +1

    Trois grâces, toutes fabuleuses. Il me serait impossible de dire laquelle est la plus remarquable dans ce rôle. Bravo à elles!

  • @elenavelena2424
    @elenavelena2424 Před 3 lety +13

    Светлана Захарова - бриллиант и настоящий лебедь! Восхитительный танец.

  • @1940mai
    @1940mai Před 3 lety +22

    Bravo Osipova, la thnique la grâce la perfection toute et la !!! 👍👏👏👏

  • @user-gs2ii5wx2i
    @user-gs2ii5wx2i Před 2 lety +135

    Захарова просто великолепна! настоящая птица, восторг!

    • @user-bh9zd4gz9z
      @user-bh9zd4gz9z Před 2 lety +3

      Да

    • @atr46
      @atr46 Před rokem +8

      У нее очень красивые линии

    • @user-kq5pf7lr8l
      @user-kq5pf7lr8l Před rokem +3

      Тоже она больше всех понравилась!

    • @minonaano2763
      @minonaano2763 Před rokem +6

      Ага, ворона.

    • @Aft296
      @Aft296 Před rokem +5

      У Захаровой совершенно нет артистического таланта, везде одинаковая - гимнастка в балетной пачке и всегда с одним и тем же выражением лица. Скучная и самовлюблённая!

  • @alis7208
    @alis7208 Před 2 lety +80

    Захарова больше всего мне понравилась-плавные прыжки, изящные руки🥰

    • @Aft296
      @Aft296 Před rokem +4

      Скучная эта Захарова, машет длинющими ручищами и выражение лица без всякого выражения, техника отличная, так гимнастки работают, а для балерины этого мало...

    • @user-ul2hd3ej1o
      @user-ul2hd3ej1o Před rokem +1

      ​@@Aft296это вы Волочкову в молодости описали 😂 Захарова все же осмысленно танцует

    • @viki56k88
      @viki56k88 Před 3 měsíci

      ​@@Aft296 Почти везде коза длинноногая. Здесь хороша

  • @TheLordSheogorath
    @TheLordSheogorath Před 3 lety +22

    Nunez's transitioning moves are SO SMOOTH! It's so pleasant to watch!

  • @user-jn6il1ql6c
    @user-jn6il1ql6c Před 3 lety +47

    Наталка Осіпова - найкраща!

  • @Layevskay
    @Layevskay Před 3 lety +41

    Люблю руки Захаровой. Самые шикарные руки балета Захаровой и Лопаткиной.

    • @olgarebman2538
      @olgarebman2538 Před 3 lety +2

      И самые длинные

    • @helibergen9985
      @helibergen9985 Před 3 lety +2

      У Захаровой руки лучше,красивее. У Лопаткиноц через чур уж длинные,непропорционально.

    • @user-ii5sd9pt8g
      @user-ii5sd9pt8g Před 3 lety +4

      Инна, а вы видели руки Плисецкой??????
      Умирающего лебедя посмотрите в ее исполнении!!!!!!!!

    • @user-dq5qg8pe5v
      @user-dq5qg8pe5v Před 3 lety +5

      @@user-ii5sd9pt8g В Плисецкой много экспрессии, в Лопаткиной есть всё, она чудо!

    • @user-fl6je6nk2k
      @user-fl6je6nk2k Před 3 lety

      @@helibergen9985 зато какие "мягкие"

  • @nadya7575
    @nadya7575 Před 3 lety +62

    Все три по-своему великолепны! Впечатлили очень. Светлана такая легкая, настоящая птица😊

  • @user-op5kv3ff1x
    @user-op5kv3ff1x Před 2 lety +11

    Нереальное мастерство и грация, сколько же труда и боли вложено в такую красоту, помимо прекрасной плавности и выразительномии движений так же мимика отражает музыку. Красота!!!!!

  • @sweetcherry2740
    @sweetcherry2740 Před 3 lety +23

    Осипова - чудо! Такая гармония - блеск и заглядение👏💕

  • @TansyBlue
    @TansyBlue Před 3 lety +87

    Marinela Nuñez has to be my favourite, she uses every single accent and tone in the music. All three are perfection though. Svetlana's little gasping gesture about 15 seconds in - incredible.

  • @user-dk3zu5qq1x
    @user-dk3zu5qq1x Před rokem +3

    Браво, Светлана. Свой стиль и своя красота танца. В детстве я любила фильм Я вас любил. Там я познакомилась с балетом. Поняла бесконечный труд балерин и сколько нужно терперь, чтобы получилось искусство.Светлана Захарова везде в искусстве.

  • @celestestaniforth495
    @celestestaniforth495 Před 2 lety +16

    Osipova is stunning, in her portrayal, technique, and dance quality, 😊

  • @BrunoAuzierDancer
    @BrunoAuzierDancer Před 3 lety +46

    Osipova has the perfect balance between technique and expression! Amazing as always, also I enjoy watching Marianella so much 😍

  • @user-ox4gq3kz8h
    @user-ox4gq3kz8h Před 3 lety +25

    Сердце замирает, когда смотришь такое блестящее исполнение !

  • @sharitags
    @sharitags Před 2 lety +6

    Svetlana’s arms and hands - perfection!

  • @user-jv1fn2ru6u
    @user-jv1fn2ru6u Před 3 lety +13

    Осипова КРАСАВИЦА. Молодец -1000%😍

  • @liliagarifullina6336
    @liliagarifullina6336 Před 3 lety +104

    Осипова такая ладная, гармоничная, такие грациозные движения, вращения, прыжки...прекрасная балерина.

    • @user-dq5qg8pe5v
      @user-dq5qg8pe5v Před 3 lety +14

      А мне больше всего Захарова понравилась.

    • @janaselle8063
      @janaselle8063 Před 3 lety +8

      Гимнастка отличная!

    • @user-bz1ny7yf7e
      @user-bz1ny7yf7e Před 3 lety +9

      @@janaselle8063 она не гимнастка,она балерина!А вы профан!🤣🤣🤣

    • @janaselle8063
      @janaselle8063 Před 3 lety

      @@user-bz1ny7yf7e 🤣🤣🤣

    • @vesjolojavdovauser-gq1oy6lt4q
      @vesjolojavdovauser-gq1oy6lt4q Před 3 lety +19

      Осипова прекрасней всех

  • @user-us3yo2qm6s
    @user-us3yo2qm6s Před 3 lety +78

    Большой лебедь, маленький лебедь. Осипова восхитительна,какие красивые руки, выразительное лицо! Очень очень красиво! Наташа, счастья во всём тебе!

    • @user-fb9bx9du2y
      @user-fb9bx9du2y Před 3 lety +9

      Захарова,лучший лебедь!

    • @alfahet8871
      @alfahet8871 Před 3 lety +8

      @@user-fb9bx9du2y Лучший Белый лебедь, а Черный только Наталья.

    • @user-um1rp3kx2h
      @user-um1rp3kx2h Před 3 lety +7

      @@user-fb9bx9du2y лучший лебедь- Лопаткина!

    • @user-dp8gh5tm4r
      @user-dp8gh5tm4r Před 3 lety +8

      Лучший лебедь Плисецкая!!!

    • @takanoichi7405
      @takanoichi7405 Před 2 lety

      Неплохо.короткие кривоватые ножульки.индоуточка-плясунья

  • @discosdevinilo5559
    @discosdevinilo5559 Před 2 lety +18

    Osipova es una excelente bailarina, es muy elegante, los movimientos precisos, seguidos, sin titubeos. Me encanta Osipova!!

  • @matricaria1855
    @matricaria1855 Před 2 lety +24

    Все великолепны. Захарова - прекрасная балерина в образе лебедя, Осипова - прекрасный лебедь в образе балерины, Нунез - специфическая грация.

  • @asclepius3117
    @asclepius3117 Před 3 lety +116

    Three great ballerinas but Osipova is on a class of her own.

  • @geraa8995
    @geraa8995 Před 3 lety +38

    Каждая по-своему хороша. Но Захарова - нереальная красота.

    • @Anaida_Nalisko
      @Anaida_Nalisko Před 3 lety +7

      Для меня тоже Захарова лучшая..

  • @user-ux6wg5pn8f
    @user-ux6wg5pn8f Před 4 měsíci +13

    Мне очень нравится Осипова, её танец завораживает!

  • @serenaholovaty1784
    @serenaholovaty1784 Před 2 lety +14

    Es realmente impresionante la fuerza de Natalia, la flexibilidad de Svetlana, y la técnica y control de Marianela. Las tres son bailarinas E-X-C-E-L-E-N-T-E-S ✨👏

  • @marinailienko5130
    @marinailienko5130 Před 3 lety +64

    Осипова- великая балерина и актриса! Браво,Наталья!

  • @carmen9330
    @carmen9330 Před 3 lety +28

    Great compilation! Usually Osipova is my all time favourite...but here I must say Svetlana does it for me as well...but brava to the all 3 of them 👏👏👏

  • @3caninos
    @3caninos Před 5 měsíci +4

    All 3 ballerinas are magnificent. 🩰 But I really love how Osipova moves, almost as if she actually is a swan! Her arms are poetic and lyrical. She holds my attention like a phenomenon. Beautiful! 👏

  • @user-vc2tf1wd5f
    @user-vc2tf1wd5f Před 3 lety +7

    Все балерины хороши ,!!!!?👏👏👏👏👏НО МОЕ СЕРДЦЕ ОТДАНО СВЕТЛАНЕ ЗАХАРОВОЙ !!!!!ДЛЯ МЕНЯ ОНА ВЕЛИКОЛЕПНА !!!!👏👏👏👏👏

  • @user-qc5rw7ut3m
    @user-qc5rw7ut3m Před 3 lety +63

    Осипова гениальна. И невероятно хороша и харизматична.

    • @user-km2gx1fn3g
      @user-km2gx1fn3g Před 3 lety +5

      смотрела бы бесконечно. .. великолепна. .

    • @user-dq5qg8pe5v
      @user-dq5qg8pe5v Před 3 lety +3

      У Осиповой очень отточенная техника, она филигранна. Но Захарова мне понравилась больше здесь.

    • @user-qc5rw7ut3m
      @user-qc5rw7ut3m Před 3 lety +5

      @@user-dq5qg8pe5v Для меня в Осиповой главное даже не ее феноменальная техника, а глубокий драматический талант. Это то , что в первую очередь отличало таких гениальных балерин, как, например, Плисецкая и Уланова .

    • @janaselle8063
      @janaselle8063 Před 3 lety +5

      @@user-qc5rw7ut3m Ну только с Плисецкой не сравнивайте пожалуйста. Плисецкой нет подобных!

  • @user-nx9xz3np5e
    @user-nx9xz3np5e Před 2 lety +14

    Браво!!! Наталья Осипова Супер!!!!!! Она -вообще человек,?! Блестяще!!!!!!!!!

  • @deborahlipsi730
    @deborahlipsi730 Před 2 lety +11

    They are all so incredible! I am honored to watch them.

  • @gabryc.3004
    @gabryc.3004 Před 2 lety +3

    Osipova, per me la migliore di queste tre.... Grazie MILLE GRAZIE per aver inserito questo video... Mi piacciono molto i confronti... Spero ne mettiate sempre molti ancora

  • @mariainesandradealcantara9979

    BRAVO SVETLANA !!!!!!!!!PERFECT ODILE!!!!!!!!

  • @nastasiaandreeva1522
    @nastasiaandreeva1522 Před 2 lety +41

    Мне очень понравилась Осипова. Легкая, как статуэтка. Прекрасные линии, красивые руки и артистизм!

  • @user-ct7yf4db7t
    @user-ct7yf4db7t Před 3 měsíci +1

    Захаровой в этом трио нет равных. Блестяще!!!

  • @orsolalelli8593
    @orsolalelli8593 Před 3 lety +11

    Osipova 🤩😍

  • @ludovicabittolo
    @ludovicabittolo Před 3 lety +18

    Osipova was my personal favourite 😍

  • @YDVDNVRR
    @YDVDNVRR Před 2 lety +5

    Osipova is magnetic. WOW!!!

  • @user-ih3su9jv6k
    @user-ih3su9jv6k Před 2 lety +7

    Благодарю!все балерины очень талантливо исполнили свои партии!Все прекрасные балерины!Браво!Всех благ всем!Новых замечательных партий!Мира!Любви!💖