RUSSIA vs USA Knife Sharpener? TSPROF vs Lansky, Wicked Edge, KME, Tormek T-8, Work Sharp Ken Onion
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 11. 2021
- Sharpeners tested: TORMEK T-8, TSPROF, Wicked Edge, KME, Lansky, Warthog, Speedy Sharp, Work Sharp Ken Onion, Smith’s. All of the knife sharpeners demonstrated for set up and use, sharpening performance, and blade edge durability. Also, two of the knife sharpeners used to sharpen a knife built from scrap metal. I purchased all of the sharpeners to ensure unbiased results. So, thank you for supporting the channel.
➡ Thank you very much for supporting the channel: / projectfarm
➡ An easy way to find past videos along with products tested: bit.ly/2FCrBpk A big thanks to Jim for putting this together.
➡ Merch: www.Project-Farm.com
➡ Click here if you'd like to subscribe: / @projectfarm
➡ As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
➡ Products Tested In This Video (in no particular order):
Lansky: amzn.to/3onD0fK
KME: amzn.to/3DdgKet
TSPROF: amzn.to/3MZPTcL
Warthog: amzn.to/3qAFs4X
Work Sharp Ken Onion: amzn.to/3qA7yNK
Wicked Edge: amzn.to/3Hk0H0X
TORMEK T8: amzn.to/3HmF8g8
Speedy Sharp: amzn.to/30pYFfa
Smith’s: amzn.to/30rbrKn
Digital Angle Finder: amzn.to/3wKrkap
Chef's Knives: amzn.to/30itwtI
Videography Equipment:
Sony DSC-RX10 III Cyber-shot Digital Still Camera: amzn.to/2YdXvPw
Canon 70D Camera: amzn.to/31b5Gy0
Azden Microphone: amzn.to/34d3DLE
Go Pro Bundle: amzn.to/3Ca0ZVN
This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC - Jak na to + styl
"I always purchase the tools with my own money..." so if they suck, he can tell us. That's the beauty of independent testing, folks.
That's a large part of why we respect this testing channel so much.
He isn't paid off to promote certain products. That's the best part as the testing is unbiased.
This couldnt be better said 👍🏼
This is kind of a “no duh” comment..
Yeap
The power of not sponsored
That asmr session caught me off guard. I love the project farm knife making session! Lol.
Appreciate all the work you put into these videos
Did you like the ASMR? I really value everyone's feedback.
No asmr please.
@@ProjectFarm I thought it was a good nod to the Japanese channel that makes knives out of anything and everything
@@ProjectFarm love the videos, not so much the asmr… I prefer the style of video that you have been doing! Keep up the great work
@@ProjectFarm I think Eric was a bit tongue-in-cheek. What makes your videos fun is that you take the subject matter seriously, but not TOO seriously. Also the upbeat and clear presentation and well thought-out tests, of course. Thank you especially for this video because I would have never found out about the Lansky Sharpener without your video. Was going to buy a Knife Sharpening Stone set and free-hand sharpen. And while that's cool, the Lansky is going to take a lot of the guesswork out of the process.
I started out with a lansky kit about 20 years ago. A few years ago I switched to the KME system. It was a familiar system that was similar enough to the Lansky to be instantly user friendly. But it is much more precise and infinitely more expandable. For personal use I think the KME is about the best balance of ease of use and precision.
I acquired a TSPROF and got a wizard status in my family. They are super happy with the fact that they can simply jerk the handle, and the knife gets sharper without any effort. I pre-set it to match the angle of my mum's kitchen knife, and she just uses the assembled and pre-set thing.
Thanks for sharing.
Я приобрёл 2 станка ТСПРОФ очень доволен, мне других не надо. Другие убрал в шкаф.
Wow!!! As a knife nerd this was the most complete, comprehensive and precise sharpener test I have ever seen! You covered every aspect of the subject and your methods for comparing the results were excellent! Thank you very much!
Thanks and you are welcome!
There's a 1 million grit stone to sharpen things and there is also that japanese who spends like 8 Hours to sharpen a knife.
He didn't test any of the japanese products, nor spent more than an hour with a knife.
@@outstanding1448 dang I hope he replies
I put myself forward in acknowledgement to the test range.
I have owned and gifted Lansky's in the 1970s. I am a major fan of TSProf (tech studio profiler). I Have many TSProf rigs and I buy Edge Pro Stones diamond matrix full weight stones to use in the tools. I gift sharpening rigs to my kin.
I will not gift the tool without Edge Pro Stones in a TSProf rig.
The mechanics of the TSProfiler are absolute to create sharp perfectly aligned 180 degrees out. a recipe for a true edge refined to fine machining and engineering.
@@Perceptence, I don't know, man, but the one sold by the "sharpeningsupplies" looks legit, although they seem to be the only supplier.
Sharpening japanese knifes, with a professional grit stone, is an Honor, having beneficial effects over the mind, like Discipline.
WOOOOO BEST PART OF MY SUNDAYS. Honestly this is the certified dad channel
Thank you very much! The positive feedback means a lot to me.
Still looking forward to the paint roller or brush
You are On Top once again! I have been sharpening by hand/stone for 65+ yrs. I also have the Workshop Top line Ken Onion. As well, a similar style I have not used with alingular arm setup. My "go to" is by hand. I just feel more comfortable. I customize blades to knives, for hobby, friends, and a very small few. Thank you as always! EXCELLENT, J
@@ProjectFarm and the negative one? gets ignored? don't misunderstand, I'm a loyal follower
Did u ever test sharpness of surgical scalpels compared to some of your sharpened knife edges
Awesome compilation! Loved the extreme magnification, really gives a lot of insight to what a really high quality sharp edge looks like.
One area that could be useful to know as well is how long it took to fully set up and sharpen a blade with each system
Thank you. Thanks for the constructive feedback.
Which part does this occur in video ?
@@cloudsculptor1 The first magnification is at 2:00, but the other ones are shown as well throughout the video
@@ProjectFarm Annnddddd what is the answer.? Give or take.? You don't even have to remember a whole year back.!!!
Wonderful reviews and just the right amount of information needed to make the best decisions regardless of budget. This was definitely an expensive test to do, and thank you so much for your efforts and saving us all a lot of money . Will always be one of the top channels on any platform! Cheers
Thanks and you are welcome!
This test had me on edge the whole time. I have a Lansky.
Thanks for sharing!
I use the Lansky as well. It it's exceeds the others by taking out the guess work and being readily available at almost every hunting/ sporting goods store. I've used mine for the last 8 years or so and haven't looked back.
same here, I have a Lansky and I take it with me to work. I work on a tug boat and the knives here get some true abuse. from using the chef knife to scrape old grease from the stove to chipping ice ... I end up using the bench grinder about twice a year to rescue them because someone chopped through bones or stuff I don't even wanna think about. The Lansky brings them back up to fillet cutting performance. I would never bring a more expensive grinding system to this environment.
I saw what you did there with your pun and I'm not disappointed.
The ASMR segment made me laugh aggressively. My kids just don’t understand me. Another great video
I was looking for a comment that mentioned this..
Thanks!
It was hilarious
One of us, one of us, one of us.
@@jwalster9412 ⁵⁷68
Hand down, the best impartial and unbiased test I have seen on youtube. Great job.
I have Lansky and KME, the KME is more precise and comprehensive but for my high end folders and slip joints, I always use my Lansky and the results are always phenomenal (hair popping, paper towel slicing sharp)! The most interesting part of this excellent test is the Lansky is near the top for the least money. If you buy the basic Lansky (non Diamond) but use the coarse Diamond home to get your burr as the first stone, you can get these results and maybe even a bit better for less than $60!
Thanks for sharing!
Suggestion: Wire brushes attachments for angle grinders. Lots of the "niche" angle grinder attachments make HUGE claims and the prices vary drastically, seems right up your ally
Good suggestion , I am sure Todd will figure out how to do accurate scientific tests he always does. its not gonna be straightforward like cutting disks...
I'd love to find one that holds up longer that 15mins. I use them to debark red cedar & for a roughly 8ft x 12in log I go through about 9 wire cup attachments.
Agreed - good suggestion
I'd love a steel wire brush attachment that doesnt make the angle grinder vibrate like crazy!
@@RogerSegerJr I usually use them for rust repair, so wide field of use!
Also, just learned the red cedar dust is toxic (only knew about walnut) what are your experiences? Do you feel the need to use pse?
I really appreciated the DIY segment. It was a nice break from the usual format, and reminds me of the old "project farm" days. I'd be up to see more of that!
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm u o I’llok ok liu
@@ProjectFarm I dont know if you got my suggestion of condoms. I am really curious to see which one works. I tried one back 25 years ago.
Man another great video. Your attention to detail and rigorous testing is what always makes or breaks a deal for me! I watch reviews on stuff im not even looking to buy because i enjoy the videos that much!! Keep up the great work!
Thanks, will do!
Excellent editing and pacing. Researching knife sharpening as a beginner and this was incredibly practical, objective and professional. Thank you very much!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Freakin' love knife sharpening videos. Let's hope there's part 4.
Thank you very much!
Agreed! If there is a part 4, could you include a pro service, such as Knife Aid?
Your homemade knife made me think we need a “best prison shank” test.
100%
"And prisoner 262 bled out in only 13 seconds, very impressive!"
my money is on the shard of glass/ceramic
"We're going to test that!"
The first test would be how easy it penetrates an inmate, then how easy to it is to hide it on self and in the cell.
We can also test how good it can hold in a prison riot.
And for the destructive test we’ll see how good too does digging tunnels.
I love both the test methodology and the commentary. For the commentary, I like the speed (its like 2x speed) and the excitement when there is a superior result. Keep up the good work. I’m looking forward to more reviews of stuff I’d like to buy.
Thanks, will do!
Another excellent review. Very concise and succinct. I don't think there's a better channel for reviews this in-depth. Cheers!!
Thanks!
Well done indeed as a professional Chef, one note to pass on dull knives really really cause too much force which makes the worst accidental cuts ever. I have a Santoko with a 15 degrees and a Wusthoff Trident set @ 22 degrees or close to it. that have served me well for 30 years. Awesome job testing. I think I might grab the KME sharpener here very shortly.
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
The wicked edge would be where I'd spend my money for your knives. I've had it for about a year and I will never use another for precise high quality edges & knives.
I own a KME and Tormek unit, the KME is great for sharpening chef knives.
@@RogerSegerJr oh yes literally 4 times the price for a 1% increase in performance. why not.
Don’t hesitate! KME is where it’s at. Best customer service / support of any company I’ve ever dealt with.
Fastest notification yet! Love these knife testing videos.
Thank you very much! Enjoyed your video today! Very informative and helpful!!
@@ProjectFarm Perhaps a test of slicing featuring a ripe tomato? That's how we're gonna use the things, after all. My guess is anything under 200 on that scale would do the trick.
@@ProjectFarm I think the ability to hold the edge is more dependent on the knife than the sharpener, different kinds of steel, etc. This bears testing, IMHO.
if so about knives , i think you gonna like this channel
czcams.com/channels/g3qsVzHeUt5_cPpcRtoaJQ.html
i think project farm will be impressed also if he have not already been there
You made me laugh when you whispered. There is someone that is doing that but isn't doing his job at all. With that said I have the lansky system but I end up going through the course stones quite fast. I still want the Russian made system because of the base and how it keeps the knife in the best angle.
So awesome! I got the kme years ago... I've sharpened dozens of knives with all sorts of steels using the 4 included diamond stones... they are still sharpening to this day!
Thanks for sharing.
I really like your videos and the objective perspective you take, where you just present the results and let the viewers decide which compromize between price and quality they want. However, I think you have missed 1 important factors in this test: How many sharpenings will it take before the sharpening tool cannot sharpen to the initial standard,
Absolutely loved this video. My favorite part is demonstrating the edge stability, something that doesn't get talked about enough. Super informative and very fun to watch!
Thanks for the feedback.
Very interesting video mate, I've bought several products based on your unbiased testing. For example I bought an Audew portable jump starter, and some liquid wrench penetrating fluid as I needed to remove some very seized engine mount bolts. Thanks so much for taking the time to do these videos, we all appreciate it.
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
Another VERY impressive video. Very informative. Excellent testing techniques. And no bias from using donated products. Bravo!!!
Thanks!
Thank you for not folding into sponsors. I know it's more money but it's honest reviews doing honest tests. At the best of your ability. Everyone needs more project farm in their life even if they don't know. You have confirmed some of my beliefs and disproved some and I'm good with that
You are welcome!
I’ve love my Lansky! Seems like a good future project for you to add the most significant bells and whistles from the “top performers”. to the “best sharpener for the money”! I’d love to see a any improvement to consistency and ease of use. Love your channel, long time viewer.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
I have the non-diamond Lanksy system and it works very well for the money. It's not the fastest and it can have trouble with heavy, small or oddly shaped blades. But for 90% of knives it works great.
@@ProjectFarm have you looked at it used the Spyderco Tri-Angle Sharpmaker? I swear by it 👍
I love my speedy sharp. If I have a lot of knives and axes to sharpen, I have an old WEN wet wheel.
Hi Todd, thanks for everything you do! I've made several purchases over the last few years based on your data and look forward to every test.
You mention that if the viewers would like to see anything tested to mention it so I have a couple of ideas with the example I'm currently using.
*Spray adhesives
(Lepage heavy duty)
*Nitrile gloves
(Gorilla)
*Hand degreaser
(fast orange)
*Multipurpose cleaners
(super clean- purple container)
These are all things I use in the shop and would love to see some comparative testing against other products.
Thanks again!
Suggestion for a video: Walkie Talkies. Specs vs actual and price points are all over the place. The Farmabago would definitely need to be featured in this video.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Oh man what a great idea!
I have a Uniden set that is supposed to be rated for 32 miles, but I barely get a mile. Maybe 2-2.5 miles if out on a lake...
I suggested condoms.
@@TheWormzerjr "Ribbed for her pleasure. We're gonna test that."
Really like the pace at which you present and speak; very easy to understand and stay interested.
Thanks!
Just saw older video which tested both. Great channel!
Thanks!
The ASMR segment slayed me. Great job as always Todd!
I know these videos must take up an incredible amount of time to do as well as edit. I think people would love to see a video on your process for each of these test videos. Starting at your concept for making a video, doing research on what brands to buy for testing, how you design and build testing rigs, failures, successes. Just all the behind the scenes stuff for what you accomplish in a typical week. Break it down day by day, getting good B-Roll. It might be a good premise for a second channel Or as a midweek upload to tease the main video on Sunday.
Yes please!!!!
In project farm we trust!!!
It's such a coincidence, I suggested a knife sharpener brand test in your last video. I'm quite sure you had this lined up already though. Thanks PF!!
Thank you very much!!
Dude, that should be a bumper sticker!
@@kobrien6657 Definitely should be!!!
@@ProjectFarm How much time went into this video? This seemed to be a lot of repeated testing for science. It is very good you do this testing, one more idea: what if you could tell in the end if certain product that you recommend not available what should be the features on a different one that we should look for. For example in EU we don't always have the same brands as there.
Awesome video!! Thank you so much for making it!
Glad you liked it!
Just found this video in your rotation. I have the normal work sharp electronic unit and it has done a fine job for me. But I also use a wood block leather strop to take care of the burr after. I am really considering the Lansky unit now, that is a fair price for what it does. Thank you!!
One thing to note on the Tormek is that the stone is about 220 grit out of the box but can be easily dressed to much finer grit with a dressing stone to hone a much finer edge.
The ASMR at the end really threw me for a loop. I had to double check to make sure I was still watching the same video. Lol.
Thanks for the feedback.
Awesome review (as always) Thank you. I have the Ken Onion Work sharp and am very happy with it. I will be looking into one of these others as an alternate in case of a prolonged power outage. Awesome knife you made!
Thanks!
Great video comparison ! I have the TSPROF, so this was of particular interest. Thanks for sharing !
Thanks and you are welcome!
I love hearing your enthusiasm, plus the ASMR part is funny! What a nice knife you made. These products are fascinating.
Thanks!
I've tried a few different styles of sharpeners.
Went back to a stone.
Watching you whip that knife up out of scrap was great.
Thanks for the feedback.
This guy knows his way around the shop,and farm. Probably my favorite channel no it is my favorite.
Thanks!
Fantastic stuff, thank you for such in depth testing on re-edging a knife. Outstanding information keep the great work!!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Amazing how precise your testing is, whenever I'm going to buy something I always check if you have tested it. Thank you!! You should definitely test some sets of ratcheting wrenches! Would love to see the results.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm Definitely ratchets.. I have gone through tons of them over the years.
The day will come, when manufacturers will tag their stuff with "Tested by Project Farm"
My craftsman 1/2" ratchet handle broke. It had a lifetime guarantee. The company went under; pretty sure the pledge of replacement won't be honored by the new brand, will it? **sigh**
HF actually sells some pretty good wrench handles:in 1/2" I bought one made of composite with TPM sides and a socket release button, with about 50 clicks/360°. Another has a heavy handle a tilt head and a release button with ~72 clicks. Yet another has a chromed shaft, TPM/rubberized grip and very distinct clicks - 72. Also a set of stubby ratchets with tilting heads on sale - included a 1/2", a 3/8", and a 1/4" drive. They were all under US$20. The crapsman was ~$35.
I want him to test my current wife with the women I want to leave her for to make sure im doing the right thing.
The build quality on the TSPROF is insane, it reminds me more of a mechanical stopwatch than a knife sharpener
Thanks for the feedback.
It’s tempting. I love the design. And it seems to work well.
If you have expensive knives and like to keep them sharp, well worth the price.
You have always seemed to me to be the shopsmart grandfather who knows how to do just about everything in the shop. And this one was no exception. Thoroughly enjoy all of your material you produce. Thank you
Thanks and you are welcome!
Thank you for another great video. I truly appreciate all the time and effort you put into each and every video you post. I trust the results of every test. This channel is where I come to make my purchasing decisions.
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
I picked the kme over the others when I was choosing a guided system because of price and the extras you can get if you want. Convex rod, different grit stones, recurve stone, strops, and the laying films. They make almost anything you would need to make what ever edge you need. I still prefer freehand sharpening on longer blades due to the angle changing from tip to heel on fixed systems.
Agree with you on this. My hunter buddies also use KME to sharpen their broad heads for archery season. Very versatile kits and accessories. Don't forget the strop either.
@@Tester13032 yes I forgot about the smaller jaws for that stuff I think they might even have an 🪓 attachment
The KME is my favorite too of the guided systems although I went with whetstones for myself, I like the more time and attention you have to put in it. My first knives already came out scary sharp so I'm a happy camper. But I get the appeal of the KME, it has just the right amount of features without being as in depth as that TSProf, and I imagine availability of different stones and accessories might come into play as well. But you know, sometimes I use sandpaper on a flat ceramic tile for things like tools when I need to do some proper re-beveling of rusty blades or chisels, so there's a use case for very basic setups like that too.
Thanks for the feedback.
The home made knife looks great!! I used to use an orthodox sharpening stone to sharpen my knives. I need to buy a new one, with a blade guide, because my left arm suffered serious nerve damage from being struck by lightning, & my left hand is no longer as steady as it once was!! Another tool for you to test are soldering irons. 3 types: Cordless battery powered, butane/propane fuelled, & mains powered. Mine are gas powered. I have 4 for various jobs.
I carry the Weller WPS18MP with me (field service.) It uses a wall wart to power it yet it has lots of capacity! I got it at Home Depot. They said it's equivalent to a 60W iron yet only uses like 15W. It's impressive! It regulates the temperature too, and has an LED which lights red when you turn it on and changes to green when hot. It also has a white LED work light.
You survived being struck by lightning? Damn man, hope you're healthy (or as good as possible) now!
@@kenmore01 I have a vintage Weller 8200 soldering gun I like to use when I'm wiring stuff out in my garage and a Hakko FX88D that I like to use on vintage tube radios on my work desk in the house. Sometimes, like if I need to solder to a chassis I'll use the weller with a custom tip made of solid copper and it works a treat.
@@Dirkietje8 I’m about as good as I’ll be now.
@@kenmore01 Weller makes excellent products. My main workhorse iron is a gas powered Dremel unit. It can be used as a blowtorch too. Excellent for heat shrinking and radiator repair jobs.
Great video. I’ve had my KME for years and love it
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Great testing. I second most of the opinions that I see here in the comments. I trust your content because you purchase everything yourself, you set up your tests thoughtfully, and you present unbiased results. Bravo! Keep up the great work!
Thanks, will do!
The speedy sharp is awesome. I have had one in my pocket for the last ten years. It's by far the best every day carry sharpener I have ever seen.
Thanks for the feedback.
Considering the compact factor, it seems like a good product
I love it as well, have had one for many years and they make great stocking stuffers.
I can sharpen an axe or a pocket knife very quickly.
For my kitchen knives I use a work sharp
The TSPROF is a work of art. I'd definitely have to keep it on display. Great video as always Project Farm. Curious what you do with all the products you test when you're done with them.
Thanks! I have a person selling the good products so the money can help those in my community.
@@ProjectFarmalways good to see someone giving back even when not prompted to. Good man
That thing definitely is well engineered!
Man, you are awesome... Thank you for the time and effort you put into your channel and helping us.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Awesome precise test, thank you! 🎉
Thanks and you are welcome!
I love the simple Smiths sharpeners. Small enough to live in a work bag or glove box. Can be easily used in the dark and with cold hands.
Thanks for the feedback.
i keep a lansky on my closet shelf and a smith's in my car door!
I've always liked the tormek it may be expensive but you aren't limited to just sharpening knives you can sharpen chisels axes and even lawn mower blades for example
Yeah, i have the T7. Shame he didnt have the proper knife-jig (doesnt it come with the case anymore? mine did?) for the test, i think it would have helped its case slightly. The lansky holder idea was great :D Works well for the blade untill its curved tip.
Also,did he reprofile the stone from 220 to 1000?Should make a difference in the result.
Thanks for sharing.
Their diamond wheels let you quickly do carbides and tool steels as well.
@@mileshartman8717 Doubt it makes much of a difference when the edge was polished to that degree by the strop.
you helped me decide on the KME. Thank you!
You are welcome! Glad I could help!
Another excellent test & comparison! Great job!
Thanks and you are welcome!
I really appreciate the level of detail you include in every video. Seeing the proper use of each tool is critical in the overall enjoyment factor. This makes other channels knife sharpener reviews just seem cringe worthy. And I know you know who I am talking about. Thank you for providing this enjoyable content.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Yes, thank you for using a strop!
Two things I would love to know: 1. How long did each sharpening take, and 2. How much blade material was removed (do some methods wear your knife down faster)?
I use a lansky for most sharpening for the last 20 years. On an ats34 knife that I have had the entire time there is barely any noticeable wear. Sharpening is about 5 minutes. I only sharpen until I can shave my arm. With daily use this will last around a month
Thanks for the constructive feedback.
How much comes off is all up to you. The worse off a blade is to start with, the more that has to be taken off to repair it. It's also up to you as far as how much YOU grind off with the sharpener. Yes, you CAN oversharpen your knife, and take much more off than necessary. Stop frequently while sharpening and inspect, once its ground off, obviously you can't put it back on.
I'm gonna tell you what. I use a worksharp and it you don't keep the blade moving you can easily put a trough in the cutting edge. I ruined 2 cheap kitchen knives before I got the hang of using it. A tiny belt sander is all it is.
This guy is such a Godsend!! Couldn't tell you how many times I've used his videos to determine my purchase
Thanks for sharing.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND EFFORTS IN MAKING THESE VIDEOS AVAILABLE TO US
You are welcome!
Woodworking finish next?
Alot of debate in the community about which is the most durable
Thanks for the suggestion. Thanks for the feedback.
Great videos regarding knife sharpening devices!; Among several ones I own, decades old Lansky set and an old, Smith's Arkansas' stone set, the ones I use the most. Really appreciate your dedicated work, Todd. Merry Christmas to you & family!!. 🎅
Thanks! Merry Christmas!
When you pulled out the TS Prof, I swore to myself, that thing has to work. It's a very nice looking unit, in addition to its performance. As always, outstanding work sir. Thank you.
You are welcome!
You're such a smart guy. Would love to watch videos of you fixing/engineering/fabricating things.
Thanks!
Most of these require too much time and setup for me and perhaps others who merely slicing, say, a tomato. I bought that $9 Rada sharpener that you reviewed in April 2020 and I simply pull it from the drawer and make a few passes. It's great; tomatoes don't stand a chance. Still, this was a fascinating video.
Yup, the KISS principle is lost on several of those kits.
Never go full Rada type sharpener. After a year or so the edge will start to get groovy in the bad sense and then there is no more hope other than a full re profiling of it. All drag type sharpeners are problematic in time.
@@dragoscoco2173 Thanks. The knife on which I use the Rada primarily is old and thus disposable if need be. I'll keep an eye out for the "groovy."
I'm particularly impressed by the TS prof's level of adjustability and the amount of information available to the user. That is what enables repeatability and consistency. It also looks gorgeous. The Tormek's edge was the most beautiful under a microscope. I love the polished look. I wonder if it has any influence on the actual performance of the blade.
it does, there is a reason I use brasso or another polish after sharpening my knives
@@frogz Could you describe how you use the polish? I'm curious to try it myself.
btw knife polishing is a band idea for sharpness. Knife edge has to have a microsaw.
@@muxahx3096 this is not necessarily true. A micro saw toothed edge will slice more aggressively if the blade is dragged, but the points of those teeth also blunt and dull faster. A very smooth but sharp edge will slice with hardly any pulling and will remain sharp longer. Some engineering journal actually published a study on this. Micro-sawtoothed edges are not universally desirable.
In the tests done in this video, the test cuts were done with a direct push, not with a dragging motion. Without a dragging motion this kind of test would not show any advantage to having microsaw structures because sawing necessarily requires the sawteeth to drag across the thing being cut.
@@Berkana exactly 👍👍 spot on chap and well articulated if I do say so myself
Cheers
Wow that was alotta work. Thanks for the review
Thanks and you are welcome!
Outstanding. I wish I could justify that wicked edge system but I'm sure the bean counter would be none too pleased. Thank you as always for your reviews, fantastic work
Thanks and you are welcome!
I love how thorough this dude is in his testing. It's absolutely hypnotic to me.
Thanks so much!
@@ProjectFarm Automatic bro. Thank you.
Wow, I was just gonna comment how interesting the different schools of thought are between knife sharpening but an ASMR moment of Tool Time with Todd. That knife turned out amazing. I love what remains consistent about your channel but appreciate when you try something different for us.
The pen lol. The day he loses that pen will be a sad one.
Thanks!
Great info just when I'm thinking about getting a sharpener. Thanks!
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I have one of those Smith sharpeners. Keep it in the camper. Glad to see he reviewed it.
Thanks for sharing.
Amazing to cram so many sharpeners into a less than 20 minute video. And that Lansky is pretty damn impressive for value. I think a lot of people would’ve liked to see the work sharp precision adjust in that comparison though that’s the top budget sharpener out right now but still a great comparison video! Thanks!
You are welcome!
So cool to get a review on this..knife sharpeners are hard to determine without using one and you eliminate the need..thank you
Thanks and you are welcome!
Every video is a win. Thanks for all the hard work.
You are welcome!
And on THIS EPISODE of "Will it shiv?"
Haha, great work with the ASMR, very calming.
Thanks!
Best and most useful channel on all of CZcams!!
Thx for all your efforts 👍
Wow, thanks!
The most honest and unbiased reviews on the web as far as I’m concerned. Thanks!
You are welcome!
Nice bullet space pen!!! I love them, they get so small, they fit in a pocket but big enough to write with when the cap is put on the back.
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I love my Ken Onion Worksharp! I will admit it definitely has a learning curve, one thing that took me a while to figure out is making sure I run the knife along the rollers to maintain a consistent angle!
Thanks for sharing.
They rock. And you don't have to sharpen as often. Love mine too.
Personally, I love my whetstones and self-made leather strop. But the Lansky, KME and TSProf are really good concepts (like the Wicked Edge, but that one is really way too expensive) and you get the quality you pay for. Lansky is the least in terms of ease of use and the personally I think the TSProf might be harder to get the right diamond plates for?
The Tormek, while it is the most versatile, you could do chisels on it for instance, is a bulky apparatus that would only see about enough use for it to be justified in a woodworking shop with a couple of guys. It also makes the grind slightly hollow, which is great for cutting meat, but it doesn't have enough metal behind the edge to sustain heavier work like bushcrafting IME.
If you're on a really tight budget: wet sandpaper (grits 220, 600-800, 1200-2000, and possibly even a 5000 grit one to finish if you can find it) put it on a ceramic tile that is flat. Instead of a leather strop you could use one of those paint stirrer wooden sticks, soft wood will burnish your knife's edge too. Honestly, you'd be hard pressed to find the difference in edge quality with a proper setup.
Thanks for the feedback.
I'm kinda suprised he featured Tormek because to me that is not made with knife sharpning in mind, its more for tools like planer and chisel etc, but good for the farm to cover all the basis.
Wet sanding is how I work all my hand plane blades. I've never found anything that makes them as sharp.
Sharpen my chisels and plane irons on my KME. put them in at an angle and haven't had any problems, but i'm picky on sharpness, not geometry.
I highly respect this channel and thank you for all your hard work to leed good ol boys like me what will help get a job done. I love me some work sharp so I'm happy to see them represented here. I'd love to see the TSPROF vs the Pro Precision Adjust and more of the angle sharpeners
Thank you for the video idea!
One of my favorite channels right now. The knife you made out of scrap is actually pretty impressive
Thanks!
Great video. Thanks! I was looking at replacing some missing stones for my Spyderco Sharpmaker that I have had since the mid to late 90's and I appreciate these tests, as I may replace the whole thing, probably with a Lansky. Ironically, I chose the Spyderco over the Lansky back then as it was cheaper and now that is reversed (depending on what options you get, of course). I had also noticed that the Sharpmaker made a great edge, but not as durable an edge as I would prefer.
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
I have never had much luck with those Spyderco bars. Too much like work.
Your videos remind me of Jafromobile haha. I love it when things are to the point, efficient, and I don't have to listen to stories about the current weather or what the dog did today for 10 min before getting to the good stuff. Jafromobile always compacts his videos as well, 100% knowledge 0% bs lol. Well done sir.
Thank you very much! As a former military guy, I greatly appreciate getting right to the point. lol
@@ProjectFarm Haha that explains it! Respect! I got an LMTV and I'm obsessed with military history/tech, not too much but enough to make me appreciate it. Hoorah! :P
I bought a Lansky kit several years ago for my rather expensive set of professional knives and I couldn't be happier. Easy to keep honed and very repeatable sharpening once every couple of months. Highly recommended.
Thanks for the feedback.
would never imagine having this test. as always the best!!!
Thanks!
As a South African, I was delighted to see the Warthog being tested. I was a bit surprised at the bluntness of the knife after you used the Warthog though. In my experience, working through the coarse, medium and fine stones and then finishing off on the steel sides, all with just a downward stroke motion, not a sawing motion, produces a very sharp knife. I personally prefer using a standard benchstone or a Lansky, but if I need to sharpen a knife relatively quickly and without too much fuss, I grab the Warthog. Great video btw! Thanks for the time, effort and money you put into your videos
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
As a Tormek owner for about 20 years, I can tell you the you can make razor blades weep with it, if you take the time with the correct fixtures which you did not use. I realize that there are much cheaper methods, the Smith that you used among them. They will work for about a year for a few bucks. I use the Tormek for everything including planer and shaper blades so it pays for itself.
Thanks for the feedback.
With the extra blade and long knife jigs, the Tormek costs $900. To me, anything above $200 is justifiable only if you have many, many blades, such as knife shops, restaurants, barber shops, etc. And yet, restaurants and barber shops are perfectly happy with a steel rod and a leather strap.
@@jmchez Basically. I agree with you. I was doing woodworking at the time, and running to the PC or the store everytime I needed a planer blade was not convenient. Also, I sometimes did not know how long various blades would remain available. When I got mine, they cost less and since I was (am) a business owner, there are advantages.
Aside from these justifications, my personal philosophy has always been that I buy the best....I'm currently 74, work full time as a factory automation designer, and thus far, I've never been sorry, and there will come a time when I will sell it for about what it cost me.
I have a gatco, same as the lansky and have always been impressed by its performance , i always strop with 2 different compounds. Thanks for confirming what i have seen for years, great performance for not that much money!
Thanks for sharing!
I am greatly impressed with your diligence.
Thanks!
The Lansky system is the best “bang for buck” system out there. For the average user at home, you are not going to notice the difference between the Lansky and the Wicked edge. Especially considering the outlay. Lansky has hit the mark providing a great product at an affordable price. Job done.
Q
I've had a Lansky for 30 years and love it. It has stones instead of diamonds. Keep playing to get some of their diamonds but haven't done it yet. The stones still work just fine
I agree, but the best and simplest method is to still just hand sharpen your knives. There is no need for jigs and contraptions. The are very uneccesary and a waste of money. All you need is a decent sharpening stone.
@@orion7741 I have to disagree. Fact of the matter is, unless you are sharpening knives professionally, you won’t be able to get the EXACT degree of angle to sharpen on every stroke. Is this stroke 22 deg? Is this stroke 20deg? You don’t know. For the average joe that wants their knife sharpened once a year, these systems get the edge consistently at the correct angle, each time, every time. It takes the guess work out. Which is what you need for a sharp knife. So yes, you DO need these systems.
Nope, the Work Sharp Precision Adjust is. I got it for $50 CAD when I couldn't find the Lansky anywhere for under $70, which is just a clamp and some stones... Not even a stand so it's not too practical or easy to use.
Excellent video. Just wanted to point out however, that "sharpness" is not a black and white thing. In the context of this type of video, you used an objective measure of sharpness (Bess scale), which makes sense given the need to control for as many variables as possible. In real life, "sharpness" is varied depending on the type of knife and use. For example, It's possible to get a blade incredibly sharp, but at the cost of durability (how long will that sharpness last). That's why lots of times as a knife sharpener, I won't go past a certain point even though I can get it much sharper. You did a great job of trying to address this with the edge retention testing at the end. Also, in some other applications, you'd want more of a toothy edge vs polished to get micro-serrations that can aid in slicing. Overall amazing video!
Excellent points.
Thanks so much!
I have noticed that getting my M390 benchmade a mirror edge it seems to have a harder time cutting because it isnt toothy
As always fantastic video! Appreciate your videos!
Thanks and you are welcome!
You continue to be awesome! Every single video you make some how seems to be very applicable to my life right now.
Thanks! Glad to hear!
Thanks again for this quality content. I am a Science teacher and use your videos when explaining valid and reliable testing and producing accurate scientific reports.
Awesome! Thank you!!