If everything is destined by Allah and if anyone commit any sin then, who is to blame?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 08. 2012
  • Answer By Dr Zakir Naik

Komentáře • 1K

  • @saitama3336
    @saitama3336 Před 5 lety +826

    Allah gave you a choice in your life but he knows in advance what u chose SIMPLE☺

    • @raze7804
      @raze7804 Před 4 lety +57

      Exactly!! This is what people don't get it.. Both some Muslims and non Muslims don't get this.

    • @notfaizan6899
      @notfaizan6899 Před 4 lety +21

      @PRIYESH BHAKAT Allah knows if u do good what will happen to you and if you don't then what will happen to you its ur choice Allah knows what will happen whatever you do

    • @notfaizan6899
      @notfaizan6899 Před 4 lety +24

      @PRIYESH BHAKAT no Allah gave humans free will they have choices Allah knows both possibilities if we choose to do the sin or the good deed but he knows humans make mistakes so if u repent u will be forgiven every time he is the most merciful may Allah guide you

    • @withcare1234
      @withcare1234 Před 4 lety +11

      Then why this test called life

    • @bohnonso2730
      @bohnonso2730 Před 4 lety +3

      @PRIYESH BHAKAT Dua changes Qadr

  • @_TrueFaith_
    @_TrueFaith_ Před 6 lety +189

    Got it! It's like what we will choose to do is written, and not what Allah has chosen for us to do...

    • @shammya9446
      @shammya9446 Před 5 lety +12

      Thanks .you got it.I got from you

    • @kasimiqbal3900
      @kasimiqbal3900 Před 5 lety +19

      So our choice is pre destined?

    • @raze7804
      @raze7804 Před 4 lety +12

      Actually in simple sentence what ever u are going to to is pre destined but then when u are going to choose between something bad and something right or whether u are going to do some thing or not.. That will be known by Allah at that very moment... And then it will be written in advance by Allah... So he will know what u choose.. U have the will to choose... But he will know ur will.. And that will isn't written in the destiny but Allah will write it in destiny in advance of what u chose.. So whatever you opt to do between the two Allah will know it and write it in advance beforehand... But other things is already written by the pen.. In ur destiny..
      For example... Im walking... This is already written in the destiny... Now I walk and come to choose where shud I walk to... Whwteher I shud walk towards a party pub where there is all sinning or whether shud I walk to a library where I can read islamic books or knowledge related stuff... Now thisss isn't written but will be written beforehand by Allah... Suppose U will choose to go to the party pub... But before that thought of urs to choose to go to the pub for dancing and etc... Comes into act... Allah will know it before it comes into ur mind and it will be written in advance that u chose the wrong path event hough when u had the free will to choose the right path. So Allah isn't to be blamed... U are to be blamed.. And thats how the pre destiny works... Hope u understand

    • @shahir7420
      @shahir7420 Před 4 lety

      @@raze7804 but,I have a doubt,Allah knows the future,what if a disaster like floods going to happen in future,and a set of sins like taking sand from rivers,mining stone etc of different people will result the flood in a longterm procces,and Allah know that flood will happen in a exact date,
      It is said that floods and natural disasters are testing mankind from Allah,after flood some people fear Allah and do good things.so that Allah pre determined that some people do the sins and it will result a flood and some other people get in right way by fearing Allah,is that all set by Allah advanced.
      *sorry for bad English,just a doubt,I'm a muslim

    • @OldFellaD1S4
      @OldFellaD1S4 Před 4 lety

      @@shahir7420 dude allah knows all among them. Which part actually make u confused bro?
      Allah have predict when we ll die, what will us do, everthing is predicted by allah.
      It is as same when u predict something. The different is dat we human being can be wrong, but allah will never be wrong

  • @faiez4906
    @faiez4906 Před 5 lety +456

    Even Allah know that i will view this video. this i my choice

    • @octazooka3452
      @octazooka3452 Před 4 lety +6

      Faiz Faizal or.... recommendations but same thing I guess

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety +3

      He knows everything but wants entertainment right ?

    • @nomsai5663
      @nomsai5663 Před 4 lety +1

      Compassion is Everything wdym “entertainment”

    • @FarmanKhan-fe9qe
      @FarmanKhan-fe9qe Před 4 lety +11

      @@compassioniseverything4262 he knows everything but he gave you freedom so in the hereafter you can't deny that you didn't commit any sin.

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety +1

      @@FarmanKhan-fe9qe
      But he knew we are going to commit one. Right?

  • @rohithvarma3925
    @rohithvarma3925 Před 5 lety +193

    Your way of explaining things are very simple. So wonderfully explained brother.

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem +1

      Quran 22.70
      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.

    • @2863
      @2863 Před rokem +1

      The teacher didn’t create the students and their consciousness. This metaphor is so wrong 😂

    • @shishirtimilsena8426
      @shishirtimilsena8426 Před 9 měsíci

      ​​@@2863yes in quran allah wote that he has sealed the heart and covered the sight of disbeleivers so there is no way you can make them understand. So if i am disbeliever on what basis allah will burn me in hell?

  • @mahamjavaid9884
    @mahamjavaid9884 Před 4 lety +8

    Subhanallah 💕 Shukar AlhamduLlilah. I was stuck with this question ♥I'm truly blessed .Thank u soo much Allah ♥

  • @cutekitty9044
    @cutekitty9044 Před 2 lety +6

    Mashallah thank you so much brother, an atheist girl in my RS class was very sceptical of the concept of predestination a few days ago, and I being a Muslim myself was so humiliated with not being able to explain to her. Alhamdolillah, I’ve actually educated myself now as well ❤️ May Allah bless you, ameen

  • @saccern4156
    @saccern4156 Před 4 lety +71

    Allah doesn’t control you actions. Allah knows what’s going to happen and Allah gave you the choice to be someone better.

    • @sphinkstrenic462
      @sphinkstrenic462 Před 4 lety +4

      Well-said. 👍

    • @saccern4156
      @saccern4156 Před 4 lety

      sphink strenic thank you brother/sister

    • @hamez1300
      @hamez1300 Před 3 lety +2

      If you cannot choose otherwise then the choice by most definitions isn't free.

    • @chaitanyag.8415
      @chaitanyag.8415 Před 3 lety +2

      Completely wrong.
      Your choices depends upon your nature/personality and you had no choice of choosing specific nature.
      Ex: I assume you are a good man so you will never murder or rape someone and it’s not your choice. Your good conscience will not allow you to do such actions or hurt others but psychopaths don’t feel that way. They don’t have sense of guilt like normal people do.

    • @saccern4156
      @saccern4156 Před 3 lety

      @@muhashartaj Sorry

  • @taintedtears6
    @taintedtears6 Před 8 lety +357

    Its easy to understand when you have brains working the right way.

    • @yashwante9398
      @yashwante9398 Před 5 lety +3

      Son of many fathers through haallaala we guys understand you as you all are suffering from seriously mental illness.

    • @raze7804
      @raze7804 Před 4 lety +20

      @@yashwante9398 please get out of this channel... U can go back to ur pundit caves.. Stop coming here and commenting nonsense we don't comment anything like this on ur religious channels.. So have some shame and get lost.

    • @yashwante9398
      @yashwante9398 Před 4 lety +3

      Tera baap ka channel hai kya, we pandits have never critized other religion like you do. You guys want everyone to wear burqa , give birth like animals and deam about 72 demon virgin

    • @Kingzimbabar132
      @Kingzimbabar132 Před 4 lety +8

      @@yashwante9398 han chutiya religon apni women ki shadi janwaron sei agar women ka husband mar jata ha tou uss par itna tashshadood hota girls ki birth mei un ko zammin mei garna wala chutiya religon hamari women hamara liya kimti han iss liya wo burka karti han tumhari women ni jo nangi phirtin han

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety +2

      Contradiction

  • @idreamofunicorns3335
    @idreamofunicorns3335 Před 5 lety +41

    Jazakallah!
    Imma a lil distracted (blame the wattpad!) on my path in my religion-islam.....i felt reallly guilty and from this moment m gonna start prayin more enthusiastically and shall be focused!
    Never forget quran!
    ALLAH BEFORE ANYTHING AND EVERYTHIN!
    motivate me guys😀🌈

  • @gufranaslam2162
    @gufranaslam2162 Před 5 lety +56

    I am also dont know about very well about destiny
    But now i have know very well about destiny
    Thank god
    And protect dr zakir naik

    • @electro639
      @electro639 Před 3 lety +1

      This makes no sense and I will explain why.
      A teacher makes predictions (high probabilities based on previous facts) but his predictions do not always happen the way the teacher predicts (some students surprise their teachers). Allah KNOWS before someone is born that he is going to the fire (nothing surprises him because he knows beforehand); why the need to play games with that human when Allah knows that he will be terrorized in hell by Allah after he dies?
      For humans, we have a choice; for Allah we follow a program (he is omniscient).
      Allah KNEW Adam and Eve would eat the forbidden fruit BEFORE he created them. He created them and put the forbidden fruit there to troll them because he knew they would eat from it. Allah plays more by telling them not to eat from it or they will be punished. After they ate it, they got PUNISHED. They got punished because they follow Allah’s program before they were born. It is totally nonsensical; a human-made story.
      Before God created an entity who was called Satan (shaytan), Allah knew Satan would fail at a certain hour, minute and second. Why to create an entity to be hated by Allah, the angels, human beings and that entity will be forever terrorized by Allah after the Second Coming? Is that a god of love? If you knew the future and you see that your son will rape your mother, torture little girls and boys in your community and make many people unhappy; will you bring that son to this world or would you choose not to get your wife pregnant? Allah did it on purpose and he made a big hell of fire to threaten all those who would dare have critical thinking.
      WAKE UP AND STOP TRYING TO COVER THE SUN WITH ONE FINGER.

    • @buggglitch1036
      @buggglitch1036 Před 2 lety

      @@electro639 😂😂🤣😂🤣🤣🤣👍🔥😍

  • @ibrahimajalloh2312
    @ibrahimajalloh2312 Před 6 lety +7

    Massah ALLAH dr zakir naik this video make me to understand any good is from ALLAH but any bad is from me thank you may ALLAH make everything easy for all of us.

  • @its_ashik_97
    @its_ashik_97 Před 5 lety +15

    I wanted to ask the same question sir. Thank you for making me understand.

  • @mohammedkamil5839
    @mohammedkamil5839 Před 3 lety +4

    Now it all makes sense. I had this doubt before but now it is totally cleared.

  • @ibrahimadan2437
    @ibrahimadan2437 Před 4 lety +6

    BEST ANSWER AND EXAMPLES FOR THIS QUESTION MA SHA ALLAH!!!

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem

      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.
      Quran 22.70
      it is so sad that we Muslims abandoned the Quran.

  • @huangleonjin5985
    @huangleonjin5985 Před 3 lety +1

    ALHAMDULILAH I FINALLY UNDERSTAND THIS. JAZAKALLAH DR. ZAKIR NAIK

  • @rahmamuktar2880
    @rahmamuktar2880 Před 5 lety +2

    MashaAllah clear explanation jazakaAllahu khairan

  • @aarzisiddique7476
    @aarzisiddique7476 Před 4 lety +4

    This video has cleared my big doubt.. jazak Allah

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem

      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.
      Quran 22.70
      but do we Muslims read the Quran, it is so sad.

  • @nasirabubakar7147
    @nasirabubakar7147 Před 4 lety +4

    What a talented scholar! May Allah bless Naik

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem

      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.
      Quran 22.70
      but do we Muslims read the Quran, it is so sad.

  • @ai_60_arhamshaikh78
    @ai_60_arhamshaikh78 Před 4 lety +1

    destiny very well explained in 5 mins...jazakallah

  • @rawdatulilm
    @rawdatulilm Před 3 lety +1

    Alhamdulillah ❤️❤️❤️ my doubt has been clarified.

  • @shahanahassan9234
    @shahanahassan9234 Před 6 lety +28

    Thank you very much....ma doubt cleared.....😊😊😊 jazakallah khairan....

    • @brawadis6579
      @brawadis6579 Před 4 lety

      @Adam A. That baby will directly go to jannah. And in this situation he is not born to be tested, but he is test himself for the parents and other people who are chosen for this test.

    • @BenefitOfIslam
      @BenefitOfIslam Před 4 lety

      @Adam A. Of course the baby will go to Jannah. Allah made huge Jannah for us humans. The baby is test for the family that If the family do sabr at that time,

    • @Nope877
      @Nope877 Před 4 lety

      Brawadis so the baby is there by himself with out his loving parents? That’s cruel.

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem

      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.
      Quran 22.70
      but do we Muslims read the Quran, it is so sad.
      read Quran, zakir naik is today with us, but not tomorrow. it is the Quran that will last with us.

  • @daniashoaib9407
    @daniashoaib9407 Před 3 lety +4

    We could not blame Allah for the destiny He had made, even for our single act because it's not that we have to commit that act as Allah has Destined but we will be intending to do that way.
    *Islam is a glamorous beauty for a heart!*

  • @PlatformTRW
    @PlatformTRW Před 3 měsíci

    Thank you so much, I’ve looked up a few videos and read a few articles that haven’t been able to explain this properly like you. Thank you

  • @toufeeqbeigh5152
    @toufeeqbeigh5152 Před 4 lety

    Mashallah
    Explained very well may allah bless you dr zakir Sahib

  • @alfiyanfahrezi9433
    @alfiyanfahrezi9433 Před 4 lety +49

    In my opinion,
    If a man wake up in the morning, he has Choices.
    1. He can get up and do fajr
    2. He can miss fajr
    3. Or he can just sleep again.
    And many more possibility that man can do, right? If that man choice option number 1, Allah already knows, even that man doesn't choose option number 2 or 3 , Allah already knows , why? Because Allah already creates all of this choices, fate, destiny,
    Based on Hadits, that's everyone has a "Chair" for him/her in jannah or hell
    Wallahu 'alam

    • @raouflamri1172
      @raouflamri1172 Před 4 lety +1

      Allah knows everything and with his will everything happens....yes we have to work and think and do our best to go to jannah....in the same time Allah knows and created every single action and that's basically is his knowledge that we can't access to
      QURAN SURAH AL ISRA 85
      17:85) And they ask you, [O Muhammad], about the soul. Say, “The soul is of the affair of my Lord. And mankind have not been given of knowledge except a little.”‘

    • @OldFellaD1S4
      @OldFellaD1S4 Před 4 lety +1

      You re right. Actually which path we ll take later on between heaven an hell, allah already predict it on.
      Everyone wont complain if he get heaven right?
      But the problem appear when someone go to hell. Imagine after allah create several human being, and he directly put those man to hell. Those man will say?
      "oh allah why u put me to hell? What sin i have done?"
      "u ll do bad thing, u ll worship idol, u ll kill"
      "when i do it..?"
      Based on this, allah can predict future of us. But allah cant just directly put us in heaven or hell without a test. Allah cant just punish us for thing dat we haven't done yet. Because he does it, he ll become injustice. So that is why we re doing this test right now, we ll responsible for what have we done.
      But allah also mention in quran surah al fussilat chapter 41 verse 33 : allah will show the sign of truth to every single human being until they realize dat islam is the correct religion. Based on this we can say in every human being lifetime, allah will show them the truth.
      Later on neither we accept it or ignore it, it is all up to us. The choice is yours. We re responsible for our own action. In the day of judgement later on, no one will complain to allah for what have they done. Allah will show them the replay of moment when allah show them the truth.

    • @coasel1919
      @coasel1919 Před 3 lety

      @@OldFellaD1S4 its wrong to say "cant" "wont" is a better way to say it 👍

    • @disappointment2657
      @disappointment2657 Před 3 lety +2

      But my question is that Allah writes the option that you will choose so who is to blame?

    • @jamieammar6131
      @jamieammar6131 Před 2 lety

      Lol this doesn't make sense at all. If God created all the options for one person..either he goes to A or B or C, but he will choose one. So if it's fixed, it's predestination, no matter how many paths there are. If there many paths are to choose from, and if it's written then he has free will to chose among either, then it is not predestination. Mental gymnastics won't work with this crazy concept. From the beginning if Islam people had been debating about it. Still doing.

  • @ChemistryforthAndth
    @ChemistryforthAndth Před 4 lety +4

    Superb explanation....sir I am Sikh but I have understood my holy book by your speeches

    • @abuumar0805
      @abuumar0805 Před 4 lety +3

      May Allah lead you to the right faith. Allahumma amin

  • @samuelachhangte8130
    @samuelachhangte8130 Před 4 lety +2

    This is what almost everyone ask I believe...good answer

  • @mahmudhasanabir3160
    @mahmudhasanabir3160 Před 5 lety +2

    That's why Allah forgives whoever asks for it

  • @sarfarazpanjwani5946
    @sarfarazpanjwani5946 Před 4 lety +3

    It's True...It's mentioned in the Holy Quran.....Allah knows well what is in your inner selves...and according to that Allah shapes your life...and according to that he makes you do things...he knows whether u fear him or not...if you fear him love him then he will not let you go astray...if he knows that you don't care for him...he will send you astray

  • @irenbillahsaleh7659
    @irenbillahsaleh7659 Před 4 lety +2

    ZazakaALLAHU Khairan Sir for clearing this destiny concept. Otherwise till death i will blame ALLAH invariably. Alhumdulillah now i come to know. May ALLAH Bless you & your family always. Amin.

  • @rafiqaakhtar9604
    @rafiqaakhtar9604 Před 5 lety +1

    Tysm for clearing my cnfusion....

  • @allfights1794
    @allfights1794 Před 4 lety +1

    I got the answer pf my question too.
    Alhamdulillah

  • @msyaukat
    @msyaukat Před 12 lety +9

    thank you very much. very enlightening ... :-)

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem

      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.
      Quran 22.70
      but do we Muslims read the Quran, it is so sad.
      read Quran, Zakir naik might be today with us and not tommorow, but Quran is always there forever.

  • @laddutricks5233
    @laddutricks5233 Před 5 lety +3

    Best answer

  • @nahidsultana1569
    @nahidsultana1569 Před 4 lety

    Beautifully explained... JazakAllah Zakir Nayak... The forgotten legend...

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem

      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.
      Quran 22.70
      but do we Muslims read the Quran, it is so sad.

  • @footballworldwithmrpopo2698

    now i got it thnx dr. ZAKIR NAIK

    • @zamabuu7707
      @zamabuu7707 Před 4 lety

      @Adam A. in the day of judgement no one will resurrected as baby, therefore if Allah put those who died at young age to paradise it will be fair because they were not among the part of test, similarly Allah has the right to test them right there and those who pass will go to the paradise while those who fail then they will have the reason to go to hell.

  • @RIMJANESSOHMALOOG
    @RIMJANESSOHMALOOG Před 4 lety +5

    I think this is a simplification of Qadar to make us feel happy. I think it is NOT only knowledge of the future. In a hadith the prophet said that if we tried and didnt achieve something (paraphrasing), dont say 'if I did this or that..', say Qadr Allah ma sha'a fa'al (it is the power of Allah and He does as He wills). The statement is a submission to Qadr of Allah. The way Dr. Naik explains it gives the impression that we have complete free will. Al Qadir is a name of Allah. He has the power over absolutely all events that happen all the time. Allah allowed things to happen and prevent other things to happen. So it's not only knowledge, it's more than that.

    • @jzfg758
      @jzfg758 Před 4 lety

      @@linsaknsah3175 I think he explains it to answer that specific question...and humans cannot understand fully about qadr,it's knowledge is with allah...and there is a Hadith which says don't discuss much about qadr ...
      And Allah says in Quran if any bad happens to humans it is not because of Allah but because of his own self ,that is what dr.zakir Naik explained

    • @jzfg758
      @jzfg758 Před 4 lety +1

      @@linsaknsah3175 no brother you should not think like this...if u think like this then what is the role of our Noble prophet (saw)...
      He advised us in so many things..
      And there is also a Hadith which says Dua can change the decree...
      And we should follow prophet advice in this specific issue that is not to think more about qadr ..
      We cannot think more than our given Knowledge...so try to be a good Muslim each and every day Allah will be with us 😊...

    • @jzfg758
      @jzfg758 Před 4 lety

      @@linsaknsah3175 we too have some free will brother , but Allah swt has knowledge of future ...thats so simple

    • @jzfg758
      @jzfg758 Před 4 lety

      @@linsaknsah3175 ok bro

  • @farahkasi5888
    @farahkasi5888 Před 3 lety +4

    Plzzz plzzzz i request u all who can read my comment plzzzz pary for my family we're going through very very critical phase of our life..may Allah show his mercy to us and he will for sure.. plz plzzzz recite a drood once and pray for my family 😭😭😭😭🤲

    • @roxyrabbits2369
      @roxyrabbits2369 Před rokem

      Is everything good now?

    • @aishahussaini96
      @aishahussaini96 Před rokem

      May Almighty Allāh grnr you all goodness and relieve your family of every difficulty and provide for you all from sources you never could Imagine.
      بارك الله فيكم

  • @syedmajidahmed8292
    @syedmajidahmed8292 Před 2 lety

    Alhamdulliah for Islam ❤️ it gives me peace serenity and happiness

  • @WorldUnitedGamers
    @WorldUnitedGamers Před 6 lety +5

    From what I understood, destiny is not a bunch of action that were written for us to obligatorily do(out of free will) but it's a bunch of results of the choices that we make in this life but were written in advance, or am I wrong?

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem

      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.
      Quran 22.70
      but do we Muslims read the Quran, it is so sad.

  • @zyanharris9615
    @zyanharris9615 Před 5 lety +14

    Allah has seen every single person future before creating universe

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety +1

      Life is repeat telecast. LoL. Go eat some almonds. It is good for brain.

    • @zyanharris9615
      @zyanharris9615 Před 4 lety

      @@compassioniseverything4262 😠...I said the same thing...you eat some

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety +1

      @@zyanharris9615
      Spoiler alert: God knows everything but still wants to keep a close eye on his creation because he is not sure. What logic!!!
      This teacher student analogy is a upright bullshit thing. Teacher is not ilme gaib. Teacher won't know for certain if someone is gonna pass or fail.
      This dude zakirkir is insanely illogical and so is the crowd.

    • @muhammadsuleman3958
      @muhammadsuleman3958 Před 4 lety +1

      @@compassioniseverything4262 Uts pretty simple and logical!! As a metaphor consider u!! You can see in future that a dog is killing a cat.. You put this things in it, the choice of kiling or not! But you know it in the future..Believe me the God cant come into your mind..As long as you're an atheist yes you can criticize any illogical thing just because you want to enjoy your life without any boundaries and believing in God forces you to choose a religion which makes u bound by morality which u hate!!
      If life was ruled by atheist they would surely have fucked the deads because they were horny and dead is just dead nothing is getting harmed and u are getting your dick satisfied..So sorry for ur life bro!!

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety +1

      @@muhammadsuleman3958 ur comment is as insane as u. Go get some life man. Ur conscience don't need a religion to tell right and wrong. God never communicates through prophet but to everyone, not in the form of arabic text but naturally through instilling feeling and emotion. No one is sitting and judging u up there. Its upon ur conscience to live by. I can clearly see u r brainwashed stooge, hence no point in arguing

  • @Rafm1236
    @Rafm1236 Před 3 lety +1

    We should take a moment of Gratitude, as we see how Submission to God is for some people be easy, but some people be denying and continue his denial so hard.

  • @shehmikeerthu3337
    @shehmikeerthu3337 Před 4 lety +2

    I always had this doubt.Thanks for clearing sir.

    • @hewadsaad3014
      @hewadsaad3014 Před rokem

      Do you not know that Allah 'fully' knows whatever is in the heavens and the earth? Surely it is all "written" in a Record. That is certainly easy for Allah.
      Quran 22.70
      but do we Muslims read the Quran, it is so sad.
      follow the Quran, Zakir naik is with us today, but not tommorow, but Quran is there forever.

  • @pepabukas
    @pepabukas Před 4 lety +17

    Allah is All-knowing, so he already knew what choice did u made..

  • @nonviolentguy
    @nonviolentguy Před 5 lety +7

    Mind blown!! Thank you for clearing this. 😊

  • @anwarseena2640
    @anwarseena2640 Před 4 lety

    Masha Allah..very good example

  • @Xavier..............
    @Xavier.............. Před 4 lety

    The most satisfying answer ever..

  • @husnainahmed6716
    @husnainahmed6716 Před 5 lety +4

    Amazing explanation subhanallah

  • @kanizfatema2923
    @kanizfatema2923 Před 3 lety +4

    Allah swt allows us to commit sins to see whether we repent and learn from our sins and be a better person or continue doing sins till the day we die...we are humans,we all do mistakes and sins...bt the best ones are those who repents and promises to change before Allah swt ❤❤

  • @ADILKHAN-uo9cp
    @ADILKHAN-uo9cp Před 5 lety +1

    Alhamdulilah.... concept is clear.

  • @AbidKhan-ww5dm
    @AbidKhan-ww5dm Před 4 lety

    It is mercy of Allah
    who give us Jakir Naik

  • @bryanbradley6871
    @bryanbradley6871 Před rokem +4

    But the teacher didn't design that person to fail... A prophet can see the future and God (according to Islam) designed it to be that way... According to Islam Allah is the creator of the video game and he designed everything and every story in the game was decided by the creator of the game and the beings in the game have no choice, so if in the game the being picks up a rock and throws it in a pond, the creator of the game designed him to do that

    • @jacksonmandela4121
      @jacksonmandela4121 Před 11 měsíci

      its more of a if else statement. so free will exists in a way. but the destiny is pre determined. and uh its takes a higher intellectual being to understand the true meaning of fate. so its better to leave things as it is

    • @edgeofmirror1346
      @edgeofmirror1346 Před 8 měsíci

      Great example❤

  • @sadianadeem9667
    @sadianadeem9667 Před 4 lety +9

    This is the best explanation I have ever heard, this guy is a genius.

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety

      LOL

    • @sadianadeem9667
      @sadianadeem9667 Před 4 lety

      Compassion is Everything “LOL” at all non believers, Islam is the fastest growing religion. 💪

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety +2

      @@sadianadeem9667
      It is not something to be proud of. Have u seen the state of Muslims in india, pak, bangla, nigeria etc due to explosive population growth? 90 percent of them haven't even read Quran once. 80 percent watch Bollywood (which is against Islam) , 90 percent don't perform namaaz everyday. Arabs don't even consider em muslims, FGM is insanely high in Islam, many Arabs have more than 4 wives( not permitted in islam). Literacy is least.
      These are facts u can conveniently ignore but I cannot. Meanwhile u can take pride.

    • @imtikhabmohideen2432
      @imtikhabmohideen2432 Před 4 lety

      I am a Muslim and I would say lol to most of his logics. 🙃😁

    • @Docan690
      @Docan690 Před 4 lety

      @@imtikhabmohideen2432 whose logic??

  • @GeraltOfRivia69
    @GeraltOfRivia69 Před 4 lety +1

    I was thinking the same, confirmed now

  • @selfeducation8018
    @selfeducation8018 Před 4 lety

    thank you Dr Zakir Naik

  • @schirtzlaw
    @schirtzlaw Před 4 lety +29

    It’s very deep so I’m still confuse

    • @dajjal239
      @dajjal239 Před 4 lety +12

      It's like what we will choose is written(Allah knows)and not what Allah chosen for us to do
      😊

    • @manhar89
      @manhar89 Před 4 lety

      Hes chutiya

    • @TheJwaad
      @TheJwaad Před 4 lety +12

      Let's say someone had the superpower to see the future, a human. That human sees your future, and sees that in 10 mins you'll trip over something. Is it his fault that you tripped ?
      No, it isn't, it's your own fault for being clumsy, he/she just knew it was going to happen.
      This begs the question of if he/she knew you were going to trip why wouldn't he stop you. Im nothing like a scholar, but maybe he/she saw further and saw that you falling actually saves you from something much worse.
      Hopefully that helps someone understand what Zakir was saying, or atleast, what i think he was saying.

    • @compassioniseverything4262
      @compassioniseverything4262 Před 4 lety +1

      @@TheJwaad
      When u cnt convince. confuse.

    • @b.rjoshi1757
      @b.rjoshi1757 Před 4 lety

      Everybody is confused, you, me, zakir and allah. 😆

  • @Yu-jr9uf
    @Yu-jr9uf Před 6 lety +4

    I think shekh answered well, Allah has a knowlege of future and unseen,, he gives you choises and a brain to think but he really knows what you will going to choose. Alhamdulillah it is not his fault to know what you will going to choose since has a knowledge of everything. Just beleave in Allah and doing righteous deeds.

  • @solihashah1
    @solihashah1 Před 7 lety +2

    agreed !

  • @sairaafzaal7017
    @sairaafzaal7017 Před 3 lety +1

    clear
    ALLAH ap ko ajar dei ameen

  • @mandeepsingh-jh6rb
    @mandeepsingh-jh6rb Před 4 lety +3

    There is difference between prediction and being destined.. not convinced with the answer.

    • @nammkyarakhah5596
      @nammkyarakhah5596 Před 4 lety

      a good teacher can predict more accurately ..
      Allah is all knowing his prediction accuracy is 100%

    • @rihamnurxm8849
      @rihamnurxm8849 Před 4 lety +1

      @@shahrozemalik155 I'll read it inshaaAllah. Thank you,
      jazaak(i) Allahu khairan!

  • @hamez1300
    @hamez1300 Před 3 lety +13

    Simply by knowing the future you can already tell it's predetermined. If you cannot choose otherwise then by most definitions free will can't exist.

  • @shaziyasiddiqui5341
    @shaziyasiddiqui5341 Před 4 lety

    Alhumdullilah....now I understand

  • @Planet_homoeopathy
    @Planet_homoeopathy Před 3 lety

    Allah knows you better and He has written best for you🥰🥰

  • @daimsaeed
    @daimsaeed Před 4 lety +6

    But Allah doesnt predict, he has full knowledge so I dont understand

    • @nongon9553
      @nongon9553 Před 4 lety +1

      It is just a parable of a human predicting he set so that it will be easier to understand. In the case of Allah, he doesn't predict, but simply knows everything. By his omniscience he knows in advance what you will do making your own choice, wilfully and consciously, so you can't put the blame on him just because of that.

    • @FarmanKhan-fe9qe
      @FarmanKhan-fe9qe Před 4 lety +3

      Allah already knows what we will do but didn't make us to do that. That's the reason we call him all knowing. Everyone has feelings of anger but Allah knows who will control it.

  • @abhayjain4821
    @abhayjain4821 Před 4 lety +3

    So Allah is testing us even when he already knew who will go heaven or hell at time of making earth.

  • @moonchild2225
    @moonchild2225 Před 4 lety

    It basically means that Allah SWT knows us better than we know ourselves.

  • @amandadarkwood535
    @amandadarkwood535 Před 5 lety +2

    Basically there’s no predestination Allah just knows what choices people will make

  • @boomontory38
    @boomontory38 Před 5 lety +3

    Finally i got the right answer.. Thanku

  • @John3121000
    @John3121000 Před 12 lety +31

    logical for those who have brains.

  • @azaanosama4836
    @azaanosama4836 Před 4 lety

    Mashallah Sir May Allah pak bless you always

  • @nimrak5391
    @nimrak5391 Před 4 lety +1

    Amazingly explained

  • @withcare1234
    @withcare1234 Před 4 lety +3

    Dr Naik, then why this test called life, when he knew what I would do on earth.

    • @kakalakiakka4545
      @kakalakiakka4545 Před 4 lety +2

      Recap the teacher classroom example and u Will understand

    • @abd0019
      @abd0019 Před 4 lety +1

      Bro Allah knows everything who is going to heaven and hell but if the life is not on earth Allah put directly to a person to hell and heaven the person asked Allah why you put me on hell.So Allah knows everything we don't know so the life is test for us to know how we are lived in this earth (sorry for my bad english)

    • @TheJwaad
      @TheJwaad Před 4 lety

      Even if he knows you're going to fail, he still lets you have the option of trying.

  • @richandroyal1085
    @richandroyal1085 Před 5 lety +6

    All examples are given based on human characters, but Allah is almighty his character cannot be like human character.

    • @simrahansari5925
      @simrahansari5925 Před 4 lety

      Watch the video again n during the last part of the video listen carefully because that is based on logic and understanding not on the basis of human examples

  • @ladibeats
    @ladibeats Před 2 lety

    Thank you. Alhamdullilahi

  • @bash5987
    @bash5987 Před 4 lety +1

    Ur destiny can only be changed by Dua

  • @acbg1234
    @acbg1234 Před 4 lety +8

    You cant compare a teacher with god. The teacher didnt create the student, and failing the test is nowhere near the same as sending someone to hell. The main rule of islam is that everything happens because of the will of allah. Sending an individual to hell is the will of allah. Zakir Naik’s argument makes no sense

    • @Rafm1236
      @Rafm1236 Před 3 lety

      Arrogant, people know you cant compare a God to anything, its just for the sake of example, Atheist are hypocrites: They dont believe in The Mysterious essence of God, but only to believe in another "Mystery" of nothingness.

    • @afkhustle5217
      @afkhustle5217 Před 2 lety

      What are you talking about? who said that is the "main rule" ?? stop spitting nonsense.. No one is sent to hell just because Allah wants to, you think Hitler is to be sent to hell just because Allah wants to ? or because Hitler killed more than 6 million people for no reason????? please use your brain before you type.

    • @-LTUIiiin
      @-LTUIiiin Před 2 lety +1

      @@afkhustle5217 If I decided to drink a glass of water, did I make the decision to drink water or was it Allah's decree?

  • @waleedehsan2307
    @waleedehsan2307 Před 2 lety +4

    This man is comparing a “prediction” to “knowing” for certainty. That student could possibly write random words and that will be the right answer to the test, hence his prediction could be wrong. But if God already knows for certainty, that’s a completely different thing.
    If he already knows exactly what actions you’re going to take, then he willed it to happen that way because he was the creator of everything, simple. So you have no “free will” following this line of logic.
    Imagine a line with a start and end point, the end point is Hell for person X as determined by God since he already knows the future. Now person X supposedly have “free will”, so make your “free” choices in life. But whatever free choice person X makes, in the end Person X will end up in hell because that is what the future God had made....
    It’s a pointless test if God somehow knows everything and is going to put you where he intended you to go before you were even alive.

  • @worldentertainment3039

    I now understood Alhamdulilah

  • @robertblack3867
    @robertblack3867 Před 5 měsíci

    Beautifully explained, alhamdulillah

  • @rayeesishrat
    @rayeesishrat Před 4 lety +5

    Totally Wrong Defined.
    Firstly We can't compare Allah with a human being to predict.
    Secondly Its not that Person will be doing that's why its written in decree. Because "There is a hadith in Sahih Bukhari that Moosa As had a debate with Hazrat Adam As and Moosa blamed Adam that If you had not done that deed, we wouldn't have been here in this world(suffering). On that Adam as replied to Moosa as and said Hey Moosa you are blaming me for the act which was written for me by my Lord before 40thousand years of my creation. Then Prophet Mohammed (saw) said that This way Adam defeated Mooses in arguement and he repeated this statement 3 times."
    So till now what I have understood is that Its all what Allah has planned for us and His mercy encompasses everything, means everything.
    Jazak'Allah Khairan

  • @gyancurious6751
    @gyancurious6751 Před 7 lety +7

    He is answering that Allah knows everything in advance , he gives choices to an individual and knows what he is going to select and accordingly it is written down. So once it is written down it can't be changed this in itself is predestination.I know he is sugar coating this fallacy of predestination in Islam.
    There are many Quranic verses and Hadith's which clearly states about predestination contrary to what he is trying to convince
    *Quran **32:13**: If We had so willed, We could certainly have brought every soul its true guidance: but the Word from Me will come true, "I will fill Hell with Jinns and men all together."*
    The above verse is self explanatory and for me this concept of predestination is simply unacceptable and a very mean depiction of the creator.

  • @sisterindeen8333
    @sisterindeen8333 Před 4 lety

    Wow excellent explanation

  • @naz905-l7
    @naz905-l7 Před 4 lety

    Wow masha Allah

  • @kontial
    @kontial Před 10 lety +6

    zakir naik we are not talkin about prediction but about predestined actions...your explonation is not relevant to issue given.

    • @adamsuhail9689
      @adamsuhail9689 Před 7 lety +3

      Fisnik Krasniqi Yes,when the example is given the term was "predict"..But for the context when it comes to Allah,He "Knows" thats why he writes as the destiny or Qadr in advance. To make it simple, Allah "Knowing" doesn't interfere/effect the test that is currently undergoing for man and jin alike that will therefore determine where we'll be in the afterlife. Peace

    • @Ali_Imran_Khan
      @Ali_Imran_Khan Před 7 lety +5

      Debunk-Isslam yes but i think you are thinking that the test is for Allah no the test is for us similarly the teacher knows what will be in the test and the teacher knows the answers too but the student dont know what will come or the answer is what but the teacher knows

    • @idreamofunicorns3335
      @idreamofunicorns3335 Před 5 lety

      Huh!?

    • @KA-tj1pr
      @KA-tj1pr Před 5 lety +2

      @Debunk-Isslam let me explain you it in this way... See its mentioned in a hadeeth that before makin a human being.. Allah had asked every individual soul that you have 2 options one to become a human... And another to be an angel. Then he further said if u choose to be an angel u will be perfect
      But if u choose to be a human being and obey my commands u will be even more greater than the angels. Here we see that Allah had given us a WILL or rather a choice to choose. HENCE WE human beings are capable of choosing things on our own. We r the ones with the choice. But Allah before hand knows what choices we r gonna make. So its completely on us what decisions we make. Everything good we do iz from Allah. Every calamity that befalls us, every wrong doing, every sin that we commit is by our own hand and not from Allah as i have mentioned that MAN was given Choice or rather freedom of choice. I hope you would have understood. And i hope that i hadn't offended you in any way. If i did i sincerely apologise.
      P. S. Dont mind the GRAMMAR. 😅

    • @user-iq5nu7tc6x
      @user-iq5nu7tc6x Před 5 lety

      @@KA-tj1pr Wait every soul had a choice of becoming a human or angel? Can you link the evidence? Jazakallah Khaiyran

  • @sl9wdive
    @sl9wdive Před rokem

    I was so shocked when i read Islamqa website and they gave a completely two different answer. Thankyou for clarifying this, i was so confused

  • @meesumnaqui7930
    @meesumnaqui7930 Před 4 lety +4

    There is a clear logical fallacy and he is moving in circular manner. His logic is absurd and rather silly. I am a believer but have guts to say I don't understand the concept of Qada and Qadr. Interestingly this question has a better explanation more rational and logical given by Imam Jafar as Sadiq.

    • @abdullahnaeem9991
      @abdullahnaeem9991 Před 4 lety +1

      He is comparing a teacher to Allah SWT.Thats one mistake
      Secondly he compares the prediction of a teacher to the destine of allah which is also wrong
      He could have explained much better

    • @muhammadtalalkhan8647
      @muhammadtalalkhan8647 Před 4 lety

      @@abdullahnaeem9991 He is not comparing, he is trying to make people understand by giving an extremely simple example which can be understood by people with small minds. But unfortunately I can see yours is much smaller as you even fail to understand such simple example. People who can think can understand what he is trying to tell.

  • @economicslearning2146
    @economicslearning2146 Před 5 lety +1

    Best explanation 😊

  • @Black-lc2um
    @Black-lc2um Před 3 měsíci +1

    Allah destined everything about us. We do what Allah wrote in our fate. If we commit any sin that is also destined by Allah, so that He can show us how Merciful our Lord is. To show He is the only All Powerful ❤❤. Ya Allah give them hidayat. There is no such thing called "Own desire"

  • @anaabudujana1605
    @anaabudujana1605 Před 3 lety

    Mashallah nice video and very good answer

  • @SalmanKhan-wr4or
    @SalmanKhan-wr4or Před 4 lety

    so satisfying answer

  • @iftekharahmedifty8269
    @iftekharahmedifty8269 Před 5 lety

    Excellent answer

  • @yarka_somalia
    @yarka_somalia Před 4 lety

    Ur very understandable dr naik mashallah

  • @ArchitectNazreenAkhtar
    @ArchitectNazreenAkhtar Před 4 lety +2

    Allah knows already that who is sinner and who is winner..but if he punish us just because he knows it would be seem injustice to us.. so Allah led everything happen..so that after we can too see what we have done..and will not complain

  • @areejanjum1038
    @areejanjum1038 Před 5 lety

    Whattt an explanation !! All crystal clear !!!

    • @fihamahmed5574
      @fihamahmed5574 Před 5 lety

      @Adam A. There are difference of opinions regarding this. Some scholars say - the baby will go to paradise. And, there are other scholars who say that the baby will be tested in the hereafter. And, Allah knows best.

    • @MaxPower-cm6ie
      @MaxPower-cm6ie Před 5 lety

      @Adam A. u don't belong here. Stop crying and shut your mouth

  • @theanesthetist5172
    @theanesthetist5172 Před 4 lety +2

    It's a very complicated topic and in Hadees I guess, we have been forbidden to think too much about this.. if it's true , then it's part of faith and not be explained 100% logically, we have to put faith in it as.it.is.

  • @mrzakeey1108
    @mrzakeey1108 Před 3 lety

    Beautifully explanation

  • @faadumofahmaan8386
    @faadumofahmaan8386 Před 4 lety

    thanks

  • @drifterx4810
    @drifterx4810 Před 3 lety

    Finally understood!

  • @akunamatata2597
    @akunamatata2597 Před 3 lety

    Allah hu Akbar indeed Allah is great

  • @huzjezbuzrezbazraznphez2379

    I don’t think we are destined. Allah just has pre-knowledge of what we are going to do. He did not make it happen. He just knows everything that we are going to do. It’s not a prediction, it’s pre-knowledge.