The Web Planet last!? How come everyone focuses on it's technical issues but not it's imagination and ambition? Even today's production with all the sfx has never attempted to produce a story without humanoids.
I have to agree, to an extent. It was one of the first Doctor Who DVDs I purchased/watched, back circa 2001ish - Yes I chuckled at the poor effects, but at the same time I admired the ideas and that ambition of what they were trying to capture, especially considering the small budget. It did used to be far more popular - mostly when people had read about it (the old Target novels) but not actually seen it, and were then a bit disappointed. But hey, couldn't the same said for 'Tomb of the Cybermen' when it was rediscovered? I will say the effects do let it down, but I do find it more entertaining that a few of the other Hartnell stories which - much as I love the first Doctor - can be a bit dull and heavy going occasionally.
Remember that this poll isn't really ranking the stories overall; it's ranking favorites only. So a low ranking simply means that the story is a top favorite of fewer people.
I can appreciate what this story did, and don't have a problem with people appreciating it. But it just has aged to the point where modern viewers going back to it can't get over the production choices as they've aged. Inventive, impactful, and leading in Sci-fi? Yes. But watching in full turns us newer viewers into pained puddles of flesh praying for the end...
It kind of makes me sad to see the Sensorites so low, it hold a special place in my heart because it was the 1st William Hartnell Story I watched when I was first getting into Doctor Who
Zaaaaaaarbi!! The Web Planet has always been a guilty pleasure. I've never been able to decide what is more abominable, the acting, the unintentionally hilarious choreography or the sloppiness of the direction. Vaseline on the camera lens, creatures that run into rocks or even the cameras and a general sense that Richard Martin just couldn't be bothered going back and fixing things. It also features some of Bill Hartnell's best fluffs. I don't know if it deserves to be at the bottom of the pile though... Other than that, other than moving a few serials up a few notches up and a few others further down, this is a very accurate assessment of the Hartnell era. My personal favourite is the Aztecs. Jacqueline Hill's greatest performance as Barbara and the wonderfully overcooked John Ringham as Tlotoxl, one of the best of the series' human villains and arguably, the only one who wins. Finally, congratulations on all of the wonderful feedback to your work on the Mission to the Unknown project. We all knew it was time that the BBC turned to you. Looking forward to your future endeavours! All the best from an elderly Whovian in Nova Scotia, Canada.
I’m happy The War Machines is so high! It’s my go to dvd when I stumble in drunk at 3am after a night out. In fact, I probably drunkenly say “Dr Who is required!”
Brilliant to see The Massacre, Myth Makers and Marco Polo score so highly, considering how few visuals we have for them. Great content as always Josh - your Hartnell impression is very good!
@@davidbanan. I agree with the Daleks being too long - could've easily been a 3 or 4 part serial but it's alright for what it is. And War Games is great at the length it is tbh
Just finished re-watching the Romans. What an amazing and efficient script. I particularly like the skillful way the Doctor and Vicki story is woven into Barbara's story with Nero. Both plot lines are kept separate but the numerous transitions between them are quick, clever and seamless. Dennis Spooner was one of the best script writers ever to work on Doctor Who. Vicki is also incredibly cute in this story. The Romans did well in this poll but probably should have been in at least the top five or even top three.
Thanks so much for putting this together! :) You wouldn't believe how many times we'll be racking our brains for some inspiration for our fan-series and your videos are an amazing resource! :) You rock!
I don’t often see people so young citing Hartnell as their favorite Doctor! One of the best things about this show is that every Doctor is someone’s favorite :3
I can agree with this list. I'd move a few things about a few spots, however I feel that the rankings overall are good. One thing that is difficult in evaluating 60s Who are the missing episodes simply because (unless they are animated) there is no visual representation to understand the story. As an example, I found it very difficult to get into Marco Polo when I listened to it as I felt that story would work better visually, however The Massacre seemed to work well as an audio story. I hope one day for The Massacre, but also The Smugglers which seems like a fun historical!
It's so fascinating how differently people perceive the stories! I could tell you what poll result bits I disagree with, but who cares! Even low-ranked stories, I still watch now and again. Cuz I love Doctor Who! Thank you Josh, looking forward to the next one!
My ranking. 29) The Savages 28) Mission to the Unknown 27) The Edge of Destruction 26) The Space Museum 25) The Massacre of St Bartholomew's Eve 24) An Unearthly Child 23) Planet of Giants 22) Galaxy 4 21) The Crusade 20) The Rescue 19) The Romans 18) The Aztecs 17) The Smugglers 16) The Time Meddler 15) The Ark 14) The Reign of Terror 13) The Myth Makers 12) The War Machines 11) The Celestial Toymaker 10) The Keys of Marinus 9) The Chase 8) The Tenth Planet 7) Marco Polo 6) The Sensorites 5) The Web Planet 4) The Gunfighters 3) The Daleks 2) The Dalek Invasion of Earth 1) The Daleks' Master Plan
My Top 5 of Hartnell's Era: 1. The Dalek's Master Plan 2. The War Machines 3. The Ark 4. The Tenth Planet 5. The Chase The Worst Arcs: 5. The Smugglers 4. The Sensorites 3. The Gunfighters 2. The Celestial Toymaker 1. The Web Planet (I almost quit the series trying to watch this one)
Planet of the Giants above The Sensorites Me: :-( The Edge of Destruction above The Keys of Marinus Me: :-(( Dalek Invasion of Earth above both The Aztecs and The Time Meddler Me: Oh c'mon! Dalek Invasion of Earth doesn't take #1 Me: Well, at least this is right.
I remember when I first watched the three exiting episodes of daleks master plan, I was craving more so for the first time I found and watched a reconstruction, that being your animated daleks Master plan that you made all those years ago Josh, the story instantly became my favorite Hartnell story and one of my all time favorites, and awhile after that I began watching all the missing episodes via reconstructions always making sure to watch any you made, so thanks for getting me into watching the missing episodes
Well, that was an interesting result. it proves what I've noticed many times that different generations like different stories. If this poll had been done in the sixties it would have been a massively different result. Nos. 1 and 29 would have been the other way around for a start. I mean no offence as this is a very interesting exercise but I think it proves what I've always said that opinion polls are only as good as those who bother to vote. I don't suppose many of the fans who watched these originally voted here. It's an interesting guide to what stories are popular amongst today's generation and to see how opinions have changed from one generation to the next but it has to be taken in context. The only way to get a true result is to ask everyone who has ever seen them but, of course, that is impossible. I'm not criticising and of course respect everyone's opinion.
Thank you Josh! That was a lot of fun. Rewatching The Crusade this weekend. Absolutely the best historical, definitely top five Hartnell serial. Honestly, it's tough to pick a #1. DMP is great, but it's kind of a The Chase 2.0, albeit an improvement in some ways. Keep up the great work. You are awesome.
Thank goodness the edge of destruction isn't last, as it is for a lot of people. I love that story, it's tight, very little time feels wasted and it is essential to the development of the relationships in the very first TARDIS team.
Love the color photos! Though it makes me sad that the whole series couldn't have been in color from the beginning. Look at those colors in Marco Polo!
+Josh Snares - Would love to see you balance these polls out by doing your own leave favourite to most favourite countdown at some point too :) Personally, whilst I'm still filling in a LOT of gaps in early DW, stories that I haven't seen for years or ever, my current favouritie would be a tie between 'The Dalek Invasion of Earth' (iconic Dalek story, plus I'm a big London history fan so love seeing all the locations), and 'The Tenth Planet' - after watching it a couple of months ago, the original Cybermen blew me away... and I keep walking around imitating their voices!
The Smugglers that low is a crime what is it? Shirtless Ben? Oh yeah it's missing! I love episode 3's cliffhanger. Galaxy 4 is great, especially the six-minute footage and Air Lock.
Planet of Giant, Gunfighters, Edge, Mission, and Rescue were too low and Toymaker, Reign of Terror, Chase, Tenth Planet, and The Daleks' Master Plan were too high in my opinion. Also, the Myth Makers should be number 1. It's amazing.
@@JoshSnares Yeah haha. I mean I'd probably have some hot takes in my own ranking of Hartnell stories, but at least "The Gunfighters" would be in the top five
This video has been been immensely cathartic to see that my opinions are not completely crazy... But once we hit Tom Baker that will probably not remain true...
Life Upgrade I agree! While Gunfighters is still decent Sensorites space museum and giants are way better. Crusade I find boring too and the Massacre is a drag bar the very last scene
For me this is the best Dr Who story ever, because I saw it originally in 1965 and for that time it was,quite simply, incredible., but sadly it does not appeal to today's audiences because what they want is this "flash-bang-wollop-let's-get-this-thing-over-and-done-with-and-move-onto-the-next-one. Really sad.
Never seen an episode of the first doctor, once I started getting into classic who was right before BBC stopped selling classic dvds to make way for the new blu rays :(
I find it ridiculous anyone could put Galaxy 4 above The Web Planet, and, having not seen it yet, The Smugglers' placement does scare me. Keys of Marinus deserves to be much higher, though.
It’s such a weirdly divisive era. It’s the only one where most of the lower ranked episodes could easily have been in the top 10 on another day. (Planet Of Giants?!? The Web Planet?!? Lord, even The Gunfighters ain’t that bad. Like, I’m American. It’s the one story that should make me raise an eyebrow in a “this would be like John Ford directing a movie about the Battle of Culloden” kind of way, but... I really, really like it. It’s fun.) Then again, I can’t argue with the top 10 y’all picked. So I dunno.
The Sensorites in its rightful place... a nice episode one and then... unforgivably BORING. Incomprehensible and yet wholly predictable. Way too long!! Get OVER it people. See also: The Space Museum - NEXT! Edge should be way higher... a gorgeous character moment for Barbara, creepy and clever, AND Susan gets to be a bit weird again ... we don’t deserve it. “DON’T YOU REALISE YOU STUPID OLD MAN THAT YOU WOULD HAVE DIED IN THE CAVE OF SKULLS” etc. - I quote that to my long suffering boyfriend constantly. I HATE this video but it’s wonderful, thank you ❤️
SORRY HAD TO SPLIT UP! Alright, so lemme leave some thoughts, my personal rankings, and the difference my rankings have from the list (sorry, if too long!) Did at 1 in the morning, sorry if their are spelling mistakes! I might do this for every future entry aswell, Tom Baker's might take a while. - 1 - The Daleks' Master Plan (Story No. 21) Difference (=) This was clearly an undeniable favorite, I would be surprised if this wasn't number one, their are so many things that this story has going for it, and frankly it's one of those Doctor Who stories despite it's humongous run time, I could watch time and time again. A classic for the lack of better words. - 2 - The Dalek Invasion of Earth (Story No. 10) Difference: (=) This, again, is another pick that I would have been surprised if it hadn't landed in the top three. This story is one of the best Dalek stories out there, the post-apocalyptic Earth setting and some incredible tense senses, not only makes this a great Doctor Who story but a great piece of 60s television in general. Also, the departure of the dear Susan! Ahhh! - 3 - The Aztecs (Story No. 6) Difference: (+1) The best historical episode of Classic Doctor Who hands down. One of the first stories that tackle the idea of meddling with time and the consequences of changing history. A nice morality story with amazing looking sets and costumes, and brilliant acting from all the mains. - 4 - The Massacre of St. Bartholomew's Eve (Story No. 22) Difference: (+8) Definitely a bit disappointing that this story didn't crack the top ten in the list, personally, it's one of my favorite historicals, and explores a time period of French history that I didn't even know existed until I watched this episode. It's a dark and bitter tale, that has an amazingly complex plot with significantly good acting from Purves and Hartnell. The final episode is one of the darkest from this era, and has, in my opinion, Hartnell's best monologue. - 5 - The Romans (Story No. 12) Difference: (+4) Not too surprised to see this one crack the top ten, typically heralded as one of the best historicals of the first doctor's. I think the problem with this story is time, it doesn't hold up as well in 2019 as it used too. I still find it an enjoyable romp, I have it in my top five! But, I see where criticisms can come from, but enjoy the hilarity this story provides regardless. - 6 - The Tenth Planet (Story No. 29) Difference: (-1) A great send off for a great Doctor, this story introduces quite a bit into the Doctor Who World that become mainstays for the series in the long and short term. This story of course introduces the Cybermen, who are undoubtedly the creepiest villains from the show, and regeneration! Changing the main actors, which is why the show has lasted this long! This story is also one of the first 'base-under-siege" stories we see, which of course, become quite prevalent in the next doctor's era. - 7 - The Time Meddler (Story No. 17) Difference: (-4) I'm actually a little surprised to see that this was in the top three, I thought it would be around where I ranked it. I think it's a great story, the first pseudo-historical, and introduces the first time lord antagonist in the show. The setting and acting in this one are great. I think the story suffers a little with it's pacing, but regardless, still good fun. - 8 - The Keys of Marinus (Story No. 5) Difference: (+8) Wow! This one didn't even crack the top ten! Big shock. I think this story suffers mainly because of Susan's characterization, this definitely isn't her best story not gonna lie, but I think the supporting cast make up for it by being memorable presences. The Voord gimp suits are a bit strange though, but I still love them. Every episode in this story feels like a self contained adventure, and makes it very re-watchable. Cool sets, cool all around! - 9 - Marco Polo (Story No. 4) Difference: (-1) I'm very happy to see this story crack the top ten, a great historical, that has the Doctor and co. running into trouble in Ancient China. Great supporting cast in this one, the mains are great as well. The sets and costumes for this one are phenomenal, and despite it run time, keeps you invigorated along the way. This story of course suffers from it being completely missing! Such a shame, as I'm sure if it existed, it would easily find it's way to top three. - 10 - The War Machines (Story No. 27) Difference: (-3) A decent story that introduces two companions that are more prominent in the next era of the show. Ben and Polly really are awesome companions, and one of my faves in their small time they spent with the first doctor. This story is a tense scientific story that has superb acting from Hartnell and cool on location filming. The War Machines themselves look a bit janky, but isn't that half the charm of Classic Who! Horrible send off for Dodo, but I mean, doesn't really matter right!
- 11 - The Chase (Story No. 16) Difference: (=) A fun story involving the Daleks that doesn't take itself too seriously and introduces one of the favorite companions from to 60s. The send off for Ian and Barbara was beautiful, and I'm very glad that it happened that way that it did. The story is a nice romp through space and time, and has some impressive sets, Purves is also the most handsomest companion! - 12 - The Ark (Story No. 23) Difference: (+8) I'm surprised to see this story under perform, I thought it would be a little higher. It's an imaginative story with a compelling plot and great sets. This is officially Dodo's first story, and she's actually not too bad in this one. I really like the main cast aswell, and the Monoids are just weird looking fellas, but still great! - 13 - The Rescue (Story No. 11) Difference: (=) A nice short but sweet story that introduces a new companion and has an interesting villain and great acting all across the board. A very re-watchable story with cool alien design. - 14 - The Daleks (Story No. 2) Difference: (-8) This might be controversial on my part, but this is easily the worst Dalek story of the 60s era. Their is nothing that is bad in the story except for it's pacing. This story could've easily been a 4 parter, but I just drags and drags. However, without this story and the introduction of the greatest TV villains of all time, Doctor Who would have never seen the light of day, so I have to give it props for that. Great atmosphere and sets aswell. - 15 - An Unearthly Child (Story No. 1) Difference: (-5) Eh, I think this story simply hit the top ten based off novelty of being the first episode alone. Because the story itself really isn't that great. The first part is amazing, it sets up the entire show perfectly in my opinion, and has a great balance of mystery and intrigue. Also, I don't think I've mentioned it yet, but the TARDIS is great! But the caveman part of the story is very cheap (shocker!) - 16 - The Gunfighters (Story No. 25) Difference: (+6) I think this story was ranked a bit low down actually. I know a lot of people think this story is crap because of the singing, "With rings on their fingers, And bells on their toes...". But I personally think that it's a fun story that doesn't take itself seriously and have nice pacing and an interesting setting. Underrated is a good word for this one. - 17 - The Space Museum (Story No. 15) Difference: (+7) Another story that I think has gotten shafted in this rank! I actually quite enjoy this story, and yes that means all 4 parts! The first part sets the story up magnificently, and really gives off a creepy aura of mystery. Again, this is a story I think doesn't take itself too seriously, but acting wise, Hartnell really is great in this one. - 18 - Mission to the Unknown (Story No. 19) Difference: (-4) A bit overrated, I understand the new recreation by the University of Lancashire just came out, which was brilliant! But this story just feels a bit un-needed in retrospect to the Daleks' Master Plan. It's still a good precursor with solid acting, but is also a bit meh when it comes to importance. Bit of a hot take sorry! - 19 - Planet of Giants (Story No. 9) Difference: (+6) I'm very surprised to find this story as low as it was, wow. I actually thought that I might be under reporting it in my rankings, but clearly not lol! This story is a fun take on scifi shrinking madness and I really think Susan shines quite a bit in this one. The sets also look really cool and imaginative. - 20 - The Savages (Story No. 26) Difference: (+3) A solid story that deals with an interesting concept, and a send off of one of the greats! I remember sobbing at the faint almost missed it style of Steven's departure, very sad indeed. But from what I could tell from the recons that sets look really cool, and the acting was solid. This story definitely suffers from being missing.
- 21 - The Edge of Destruction (Story No. 3) Difference: (-6) Yeah, I don't like this one as much. I still think this story has a lot to offer in terms of characterization and development of inter-TARDIS relationships early on in the show. But 50 or so minutes in the TARDIS is a bit of a drag even for a two parter. It also has a VERY unsatisfying conclusion. Hartnell has another great monologue in this one though. - 22 - The Myth Makers (Story No. 20) Difference: (-4) This story would be heralded if it survived. Tonally it's a bit all over the place, with pieces of comedy and serious historical drama mixed together, makes it seem a bit weird at points. The acting is great in this one however, and the setting is brilliant. Not much complaints, but wish it was a surviving episode! - 23 - The Reign of Terror (Story No. 8) Difference: (-4) A pretty average historical drama with the Doctor and co. The mains in the story are quite good in terms of acting, and I really enjoy the political drama similar to The Massacre. However, this story really drags on for far too long, I'm sorry, but the animation looks awful aswell. Still a little enjoyable, but mostly boring and predictable. - 24 - The Crusade (Story No. 14) Difference: (-7) I think I'm going to have to re-watch this one. I can't really remember much about the story, I not sure if that's just me (probably). The sets are cool however, and Jean Marsh is always a plus! - 25 - The Sensorites (Story No. 7) Difference: (+1) A fairly average story where Susan really shines for the first time in the show. The first two parts are a tense space thriller with interesting characters and great build-up. But then the story crashes and burns. This story REALLY comes to a grinding halt in it's second half and becomes a political snooze fest. - 26 - The Web Planet (Story No. 13) Difference: (+3) A imaginative and ambitious story that has some "interesting" effects and sets. For some reason the camera men thought it might be a good idea to smear Vaseline? on the the cameras the achieve some sort of low-oxygen atmosphere feel. I'm not too sure about this story. I congratulate it for being unique, but the budget at the time just doesn't hold up. - 27 - Galaxy 4 (Story No. 18) Difference: (=) A simple morality tale based on not judging a book by it's cover isn't that bad, but I feel this story has a lack of substance. It suffers a lot from being a mostly missing story. The sets a kinda cool? The only take away I have is needing to have a life size Chumbley robot pet. - 28 - The Celestial Toymaker (Story No. 24) Difference: (-7) Kinda surprised to see it as high as it was on the list. A story that involves a great villain, but because of it's missing state really fails as keeping me engaged. I remember falling asleep to this story multiple times while watching and having to rewind and re watch many scenes. It's boring, and they drop the n-word in the second episode, not cool. - 29 - The Smugglers (Story No. 28) Difference: (-1) I expected this story to be near the bottom. Nothing exactly wrong with this story, but nothing great about it either. The only talking point is that it happens to be Ben and Polly's first adventure in the TARDIS. Completely inoffensive, decent sets I guess, but very skippable, and starts to drag even for a 4 parter.
While not really reflective of my own thoughts, I’m at least glad Time Meddler is up there. Are you going to explain all the stories of all the Doctors in relation to each other or just keep it era themed?
Bit sad about results. Considering some of these have not been shown since release. Unknown why Marco is so high and yet as someone said the web planet and sensorites are so low. But good work josh. We love you really
Trying to find the first video on this; but none seem to be titled as such. Would’ve presumed Hartnell would be the first but it starts with “welcome back” gone back 7 months but can’t see the first.
I really don't want to dislike The Web Planet but it's definitely one of those moments where it's a really good idea on paper, but had such piss poor execution and confined to a time where the SFX were not the greatest, forced it to be not as good as it could've or hell, even should've been. It was definitely a story ahead of its time and I feel like if you remade the story today, it would work so much better.
I want "YEEHAW" as my new ringtone.
YEEEEEHAW!
YEEEEEHAW!!!!!!
YEEEEEHAW!
YEEHAAW
Josh Snares I will be added Hartnell and Troughton to my family tree Ok?
The Web Planet last!? How come everyone focuses on it's technical issues but not it's imagination and ambition? Even today's production with all the sfx has never attempted to produce a story without humanoids.
Totally agree. Used to be much more popular in it's day.
I have to agree, to an extent. It was one of the first Doctor Who DVDs I purchased/watched, back circa 2001ish - Yes I chuckled at the poor effects, but at the same time I admired the ideas and that ambition of what they were trying to capture, especially considering the small budget. It did used to be far more popular - mostly when people had read about it (the old Target novels) but not actually seen it, and were then a bit disappointed. But hey, couldn't the same said for 'Tomb of the Cybermen' when it was rediscovered?
I will say the effects do let it down, but I do find it more entertaining that a few of the other Hartnell stories which - much as I love the first Doctor - can be a bit dull and heavy going occasionally.
Remember that this poll isn't really ranking the stories overall; it's ranking favorites only. So a low ranking simply means that the story is a top favorite of fewer people.
I can appreciate what this story did, and don't have a problem with people appreciating it. But it just has aged to the point where modern viewers going back to it can't get over the production choices as they've aged. Inventive, impactful, and leading in Sci-fi? Yes. But watching in full turns us newer viewers into pained puddles of flesh praying for the end...
I appreciate it, but I can't watch it. That lowers the value of the experience for me. Except that first episode. I adore the first episode.
The Sensorites that low is a crime!!!
The sensorites that high is the crime!
Honestly, the Web Planet being last is a testament to how consistently good the early serials were
It kind of makes me sad to see the Sensorites so low, it hold a special place in my heart because it was the 1st William Hartnell Story I watched when I was first getting into Doctor Who
it holds special place in my heart too it's good
The space museum is so underrated, i really love it
Shame about the Web Planet being so low. I gave it a 9. Maybe I was just in a very weird mood when I watched that story.
Zaaaaaaarbi!! The Web Planet has always been a guilty pleasure. I've never been able to decide what is more abominable, the acting, the unintentionally hilarious choreography or the sloppiness of the direction. Vaseline on the camera lens, creatures that run into rocks or even the cameras and a general sense that Richard Martin just couldn't be bothered going back and fixing things. It also features some of Bill Hartnell's best fluffs. I don't know if it deserves to be at the bottom of the pile though...
Other than that, other than moving a few serials up a few notches up and a few others further down, this is a very accurate assessment of the Hartnell era. My personal favourite is the Aztecs. Jacqueline Hill's greatest performance as Barbara and the wonderfully overcooked John Ringham as Tlotoxl, one of the best of the series' human villains and arguably, the only one who wins.
Finally, congratulations on all of the wonderful feedback to your work on the Mission to the Unknown project. We all knew it was time that the BBC turned to you. Looking forward to your future endeavours!
All the best from an elderly Whovian in Nova Scotia, Canada.
I’m happy The War Machines is so high! It’s my go to dvd when I stumble in drunk at 3am after a night out. In fact, I probably drunkenly say “Dr Who is required!”
Brilliant to see The Massacre, Myth Makers and Marco Polo score so highly, considering how few visuals we have for them. Great content as always Josh - your Hartnell impression is very good!
THE ARK was a fascinating story and separating the first two and last two episodes was a great idea
With a few exceptions, this list largely aligns with my ranking of these episodes; The Edge of Destruction is definitely underrated!
YES Edge is my Favorite story form the begining boxset Child is boaring, Daleks Is Boaring
Planet of Giants being _that_ low on the list is a crime
The Daleks being _that_ high is also a crime
@@NagromVoice daleks is too long in my opinion but you know I'm a guy who wishes that The War Games should be 1 or 2 episodes longer
@@davidbanan. I agree with the Daleks being too long - could've easily been a 3 or 4 part serial but it's alright for what it is. And War Games is great at the length it is tbh
Just finished re-watching the Romans. What an amazing and efficient script. I particularly like the skillful way the Doctor and Vicki story is woven into Barbara's story with Nero. Both plot lines are kept separate but the numerous transitions between them are quick, clever and seamless. Dennis Spooner was one of the best script writers ever to work on Doctor Who. Vicki is also incredibly cute in this story. The Romans did well in this poll but probably should have been in at least the top five or even top three.
Thanks so much for putting this together! :) You wouldn't believe how many times we'll be racking our brains for some inspiration for our fan-series and your videos are an amazing resource! :) You rock!
Oh thank you! Keep up the good work!
'The Celestial Toymaker,' is #21?!
That's my favorite First-Doctor Story you're talking about! (I rated it a 9/10) ;)
only 9/10?
The Savages near the bottom? One of my favorite Hartnell stories.
This was the big shocker for me too...
Never knew the Ridley Scott factoid.
Crazy, huh?
Is there a way of us seeing the numbers/average ratings for each story?
stephen noonan yea I understood that thanks. I just meant it would be interesting to see how close the stories were by seeing the actual results
Was hoping to also get the average vote with the ranking, but all is good
Half of these don’t deserve to be so low. Sensorites Giants and Space Museum deserve to be on the top 5 or top 10 atleast!
agreed. But don't worry, nothing scored lower than a 5!
I totally agree with you on this
.
I'd be interested to see their position overall in the entire cannon of Doctor Who
really?, i mean giants was supposed to be 4 parts
I don’t often see people so young citing Hartnell as their favorite Doctor! One of the best things about this show is that every Doctor is someone’s favorite :3
I can agree with this list. I'd move a few things about a few spots, however I feel that the rankings overall are good. One thing that is difficult in evaluating 60s Who are the missing episodes simply because (unless they are animated) there is no visual representation to understand the story. As an example, I found it very difficult to get into Marco Polo when I listened to it as I felt that story would work better visually, however The Massacre seemed to work well as an audio story.
I hope one day for The Massacre, but also The Smugglers which seems like a fun historical!
It's really interesting seeing how all the different opinions have merged to make this list! Can't wait for the rest! #JusticeForTheWarMachines
It's so fascinating how differently people perceive the stories! I could tell you what poll result bits I disagree with, but who cares! Even low-ranked stories, I still watch now and again. Cuz I love Doctor Who! Thank you Josh, looking forward to the next one!
Which one of your children do you love the most?. YOU LOVE THEM ALL!.
Heartbroken that "The Web Planet" is the least-liked story. Come on.
I agree. Some of the work on the Web Planet is amazing.
Even if it wasn't you'd still say the same for the least like episode, even if you don't like it
My ranking.
29) The Savages
28) Mission to the Unknown
27) The Edge of Destruction
26) The Space Museum
25) The Massacre of St Bartholomew's Eve
24) An Unearthly Child
23) Planet of Giants
22) Galaxy 4
21) The Crusade
20) The Rescue
19) The Romans
18) The Aztecs
17) The Smugglers
16) The Time Meddler
15) The Ark
14) The Reign of Terror
13) The Myth Makers
12) The War Machines
11) The Celestial Toymaker
10) The Keys of Marinus
9) The Chase
8) The Tenth Planet
7) Marco Polo
6) The Sensorites
5) The Web Planet
4) The Gunfighters
3) The Daleks
2) The Dalek Invasion of Earth
1) The Daleks' Master Plan
Layton Mathieson thank u for giving the keys of marinus a higher spot. It’s amazing..
Brilliant count down. Looking forward to the next one. Well done Josh and congratulations on your work on the Mission to the Unknown recreation 👍🏻
Thank you!
My only gruff is An Unearthly Child didn't make the top 5. Another great video. Your voice is slowly becoming my oxygen.
Yes, this is about how I thought most of these would rank up. I knew the Dalek stories would be high or tops.
My Top 5 of Hartnell's Era:
1. The Dalek's Master Plan
2. The War Machines
3. The Ark
4. The Tenth Planet
5. The Chase
The Worst Arcs:
5. The Smugglers
4. The Sensorites
3. The Gunfighters
2. The Celestial Toymaker
1. The Web Planet (I almost quit the series trying to watch this one)
Planet of the Giants above The Sensorites
Me: :-(
The Edge of Destruction above The Keys of Marinus
Me: :-((
Dalek Invasion of Earth above both The Aztecs and The Time Meddler
Me: Oh c'mon!
Dalek Invasion of Earth doesn't take #1
Me: Well, at least this is right.
Truth
I remember when I first watched the three exiting episodes of daleks master plan, I was craving more so for the first time I found and watched a reconstruction, that being your animated daleks Master plan that you made all those years ago Josh, the story instantly became my favorite Hartnell story and one of my all time favorites, and awhile after that I began watching all the missing episodes via reconstructions always making sure to watch any you made, so thanks for getting me into watching the missing episodes
Well, that was an interesting result. it proves what I've noticed many times that different generations like different stories. If this poll had been done in the sixties it would have been a massively different result. Nos. 1 and 29 would have been the other way around for a start. I mean no offence as this is a very interesting exercise but I think it proves what I've always said that opinion polls are only as good as those who bother to vote. I don't suppose many of the fans who watched these originally voted here. It's an interesting guide to what stories are popular amongst today's generation and to see how opinions have changed from one generation to the next but it has to be taken in context. The only way to get a true result is to ask everyone who has ever seen them but, of course, that is impossible. I'm not criticising and of course respect everyone's opinion.
Thank you Josh! That was a lot of fun. Rewatching The Crusade this weekend. Absolutely the best historical, definitely top five Hartnell serial. Honestly, it's tough to pick a #1. DMP is great, but it's kind of a The Chase 2.0, albeit an improvement in some ways. Keep up the great work. You are awesome.
Worth watching just for 2:48 alone! Haha, fab video: looking forward to the other results! :)
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEHAW!
Thank goodness the edge of destruction isn't last, as it is for a lot of people. I love that story, it's tight, very little time feels wasted and it is essential to the development of the relationships in the very first TARDIS team.
Love the color photos! Though it makes me sad that the whole series couldn't have been in color from the beginning. Look at those colors in Marco Polo!
This was just wonderful! Looking forward to the next episodes!
congrats on mission to the unknown. brillant
+Josh Snares - Would love to see you balance these polls out by doing your own leave favourite to most favourite countdown at some point too :)
Personally, whilst I'm still filling in a LOT of gaps in early DW, stories that I haven't seen for years or ever, my current favouritie would be a tie between 'The Dalek Invasion of Earth' (iconic Dalek story, plus I'm a big London history fan so love seeing all the locations), and 'The Tenth Planet' - after watching it a couple of months ago, the original Cybermen blew me away... and I keep walking around imitating their voices!
Great review yet again ! ! 😊Daleks Master Plan is my top story ! Such a great shame only 3 episodes exist 😢
The Smugglers that low is a crime what is it? Shirtless Ben? Oh yeah it's missing! I love episode 3's cliffhanger. Galaxy 4 is great, especially the six-minute footage and Air Lock.
Blasphemy
The Web Planet is clearly the most superior doctor who story of all time.
fantastic video, your videos are always amazing!!!!!!!!!!
Well done!
I’m not surprised The Daleks Masterplan is at #1.
Planet of Giant, Gunfighters, Edge, Mission, and Rescue were too low and Toymaker, Reign of Terror, Chase, Tenth Planet, and The Daleks' Master Plan were too high in my opinion. Also, the Myth Makers should be number 1. It's amazing.
Wow definitely some hot crowdsourced takes here.
you're not wrong
@@JoshSnares Yeah haha. I mean I'd probably have some hot takes in my own ranking of Hartnell stories, but at least "The Gunfighters" would be in the top five
Gunfighters is #1 in my rootin tootin heart 💜
Glad to see that The Gunfighters wasn't totally slaughtered in the polls!
Dalek Masterplan at no 1? You hear this, BBC?
This video has been been immensely cathartic to see that my opinions are not completely crazy... But once we hit Tom Baker that will probably not remain true...
Yesss, The Daleks' Masterplan is my favourite Hartnell serial. What a masterpiece. Or Masterplan.
Sad that The Myth Makers is so ranked so low. It's my favourite Hartnell story and if any episodes from it turned up I would lose my mind!
The Gunfighters at 22 and The Massacre at 12? This is not right at all! ;-)
i'm calling the police on everyone who voted against The Gunfighters
@@JoshSnares If you don't like the gunfighters we can't be friends!
Yea, Gunfighters and Massacre should be lower on the list.
Life Upgrade I agree! While Gunfighters is still decent Sensorites space museum and giants are way better. Crusade I find boring too and the Massacre is a drag bar the very last scene
And Romans should be way lower too it’s so OTT
Such a underated doctor
For me this is the best Dr Who story ever, because I saw it originally in 1965 and for that time it was,quite simply, incredible., but sadly it does not appeal to today's audiences because what they want is this "flash-bang-wollop-let's-get-this-thing-over-and-done-with-and-move-onto-the-next-one. Really sad.
My favourite era of the show pretty much, so that all of these aren't at number one is a travesty!! 😜
My personal top 5 Hartnell stories:
1 (YEEHAW) The Gunfighters
2. The Romans
3 The Tenth Planet
4 The Chase
5 The Massacre
Web Planet should be #1 but hey what can you do
Great video man!
Nice seeing the Tenth Planet so high. Love that story.
The web planets puts my internal organs into a blender when i watch it
Celestial toymaker was my favorite Hartnell adventure. I’m a big Steven Taylor fan
Gosh I love this
Never seen an episode of the first doctor, once I started getting into classic who was right before BBC stopped selling classic dvds to make way for the new blu rays :(
Don’t forget to subscribe to the official Josh Snares CZcams channel. Now who would ever forget that?
😂😂😂
Y’all, Planet of Giants is Top 5 FOR SURE
this was fun :) please could you include a quick recap at the end of each future poll video? be nice to see them all listed
I find it ridiculous anyone could put Galaxy 4 above The Web Planet, and, having not seen it yet, The Smugglers' placement does scare me. Keys of Marinus deserves to be much higher, though.
Sad that Sensoites and Planet of Giants are so low, as they were some of the first stories I saw.
So josh is there any particular reason the first doctor is your favorite? Just curious
i just think he's neat
Fair enough
It’s such a weirdly divisive era. It’s the only one where most of the lower ranked episodes could easily have been in the top 10 on another day. (Planet Of Giants?!? The Web Planet?!? Lord, even The Gunfighters ain’t that bad. Like, I’m American. It’s the one story that should make me raise an eyebrow in a “this would be like John Ford directing a movie about the Battle of Culloden” kind of way, but... I really, really like it. It’s fun.)
Then again, I can’t argue with the top 10 y’all picked. So I dunno.
Man, i laughed so hard with your "YYYYEEEEEEEHAAAAAAAAAWWW"
We love a bit of yeehaw!
Great impression!
“The Daleks” is too high.
That intro was f**king perfection!
Really surprised at The Time Meddler reaching No.3!
The tenth planet should be number 1
The Sensorites in its rightful place... a nice episode one and then... unforgivably BORING. Incomprehensible and yet wholly predictable. Way too long!! Get OVER it people. See also: The Space Museum - NEXT!
Edge should be way higher... a gorgeous character moment for Barbara, creepy and clever, AND Susan gets to be a bit weird again ... we don’t deserve it. “DON’T YOU REALISE YOU STUPID OLD MAN THAT YOU WOULD HAVE DIED IN THE CAVE OF SKULLS” etc. - I quote that to my long suffering boyfriend constantly.
I HATE this video but it’s wonderful, thank you ❤️
take back what you said about The Space Museum, you coward.
omg i'm going to start using that quote on my bf now haha
SORRY HAD TO SPLIT UP!
Alright, so lemme leave some thoughts, my personal rankings, and the difference my rankings have from the list (sorry, if too long!) Did at 1 in the morning, sorry if their are spelling mistakes! I might do this for every future entry aswell, Tom Baker's might take a while.
- 1 -
The Daleks' Master Plan (Story No. 21)
Difference (=)
This was clearly an undeniable favorite, I would be surprised if this wasn't number one, their are so many things that this story has going for it, and frankly it's one of those Doctor Who stories despite it's humongous run time, I could watch time and time again. A classic for the lack of better words.
- 2 -
The Dalek Invasion of Earth (Story No. 10)
Difference: (=)
This, again, is another pick that I would have been surprised if it hadn't landed in the top three. This story is one of the best Dalek stories out there, the post-apocalyptic Earth setting and some incredible tense senses, not only makes this a great Doctor Who story but a great piece of 60s television in general. Also, the departure of the dear Susan! Ahhh!
- 3 -
The Aztecs (Story No. 6)
Difference: (+1)
The best historical episode of Classic Doctor Who hands down. One of the first stories that tackle the idea of meddling with time and the consequences of changing history. A nice morality story with amazing looking sets and costumes, and brilliant acting from all the mains.
- 4 -
The Massacre of St. Bartholomew's Eve (Story No. 22)
Difference: (+8)
Definitely a bit disappointing that this story didn't crack the top ten in the list, personally, it's one of my favorite historicals, and explores a time period of French history that I didn't even know existed until I watched this episode. It's a dark and bitter tale, that has an amazingly complex plot with significantly good acting from Purves and Hartnell. The final episode is one of the darkest from this era, and has, in my opinion, Hartnell's best monologue.
- 5 -
The Romans (Story No. 12)
Difference: (+4)
Not too surprised to see this one crack the top ten, typically heralded as one of the best historicals of the first doctor's. I think the problem with this story is time, it doesn't hold up as well in 2019 as it used too. I still find it an enjoyable romp, I have it in my top five! But, I see where criticisms can come from, but enjoy the hilarity this story provides regardless.
- 6 -
The Tenth Planet (Story No. 29)
Difference: (-1)
A great send off for a great Doctor, this story introduces quite a bit into the Doctor Who World that become mainstays for the series in the long and short term. This story of course introduces the Cybermen, who are undoubtedly the creepiest villains from the show, and regeneration! Changing the main actors, which is why the show has lasted this long! This story is also one of the first 'base-under-siege" stories we see, which of course, become quite prevalent in the next doctor's era.
- 7 -
The Time Meddler (Story No. 17)
Difference: (-4)
I'm actually a little surprised to see that this was in the top three, I thought it would be around where I ranked it. I think it's a great story, the first pseudo-historical, and introduces the first time lord antagonist in the show. The setting and acting in this one are great. I think the story suffers a little with it's pacing, but regardless, still good fun.
- 8 -
The Keys of Marinus (Story No. 5)
Difference: (+8)
Wow! This one didn't even crack the top ten! Big shock. I think this story suffers mainly because of Susan's characterization, this definitely isn't her best story not gonna lie, but I think the supporting cast make up for it by being memorable presences. The Voord gimp suits are a bit strange though, but I still love them. Every episode in this story feels like a self contained adventure, and makes it very re-watchable. Cool sets, cool all around!
- 9 -
Marco Polo (Story No. 4)
Difference: (-1)
I'm very happy to see this story crack the top ten, a great historical, that has the Doctor and co. running into trouble in Ancient China. Great supporting cast in this one, the mains are great as well. The sets and costumes for this one are phenomenal, and despite it run time, keeps you invigorated along the way. This story of course suffers from it being completely missing! Such a shame, as I'm sure if it existed, it would easily find it's way to top three.
- 10 -
The War Machines (Story No. 27)
Difference: (-3)
A decent story that introduces two companions that are more prominent in the next era of the show. Ben and Polly really are awesome companions, and one of my faves in their small time they spent with the first doctor. This story is a tense scientific story that has superb acting from Hartnell and cool on location filming. The War Machines themselves look a bit janky, but isn't that half the charm of Classic Who! Horrible send off for Dodo, but I mean, doesn't really matter right!
- 11 -
The Chase (Story No. 16)
Difference: (=)
A fun story involving the Daleks that doesn't take itself too seriously and introduces one of the favorite companions from to 60s. The send off for Ian and Barbara was beautiful, and I'm very glad that it happened that way that it did. The story is a nice romp through space and time, and has some impressive sets, Purves is also the most handsomest companion!
- 12 -
The Ark (Story No. 23)
Difference: (+8)
I'm surprised to see this story under perform, I thought it would be a little higher. It's an imaginative story with a compelling plot and great sets. This is officially Dodo's first story, and she's actually not too bad in this one. I really like the main cast aswell, and the Monoids are just weird looking fellas, but still great!
- 13 -
The Rescue (Story No. 11)
Difference: (=)
A nice short but sweet story that introduces a new companion and has an interesting villain and great acting all across the board. A very re-watchable story with cool alien design.
- 14 -
The Daleks (Story No. 2)
Difference: (-8)
This might be controversial on my part, but this is easily the worst Dalek story of the 60s era. Their is nothing that is bad in the story except for it's pacing. This story could've easily been a 4 parter, but I just drags and drags. However, without this story and the introduction of the greatest TV villains of all time, Doctor Who would have never seen the light of day, so I have to give it props for that. Great atmosphere and sets aswell.
- 15 -
An Unearthly Child (Story No. 1)
Difference: (-5)
Eh, I think this story simply hit the top ten based off novelty of being the first episode alone. Because the story itself really isn't that great. The first part is amazing, it sets up the entire show perfectly in my opinion, and has a great balance of mystery and intrigue. Also, I don't think I've mentioned it yet, but the TARDIS is great! But the caveman part of the story is very cheap (shocker!)
- 16 -
The Gunfighters (Story No. 25)
Difference: (+6)
I think this story was ranked a bit low down actually. I know a lot of people think this story is crap because of the singing, "With rings on their fingers, And bells on their toes...". But I personally think that it's a fun story that doesn't take itself seriously and have nice pacing and an interesting setting. Underrated is a good word for this one.
- 17 -
The Space Museum (Story No. 15)
Difference: (+7)
Another story that I think has gotten shafted in this rank! I actually quite enjoy this story, and yes that means all 4 parts! The first part sets the story up magnificently, and really gives off a creepy aura of mystery. Again, this is a story I think doesn't take itself too seriously, but acting wise, Hartnell really is great in this one.
- 18 -
Mission to the Unknown (Story No. 19)
Difference: (-4)
A bit overrated, I understand the new recreation by the University of Lancashire just came out, which was brilliant! But this story just feels a bit un-needed in retrospect to the Daleks' Master Plan. It's still a good precursor with solid acting, but is also a bit meh when it comes to importance. Bit of a hot take sorry!
- 19 -
Planet of Giants (Story No. 9)
Difference: (+6)
I'm very surprised to find this story as low as it was, wow. I actually thought that I might be under reporting it in my rankings, but clearly not lol! This story is a fun take on scifi shrinking madness and I really think Susan shines quite a bit in this one. The sets also look really cool and imaginative.
- 20 -
The Savages (Story No. 26)
Difference: (+3)
A solid story that deals with an interesting concept, and a send off of one of the greats! I remember sobbing at the faint almost missed it style of Steven's departure, very sad indeed. But from what I could tell from the recons that sets look really cool, and the acting was solid. This story definitely suffers from being missing.
- 21 -
The Edge of Destruction (Story No. 3)
Difference: (-6)
Yeah, I don't like this one as much. I still think this story has a lot to offer in terms of characterization and development of inter-TARDIS relationships early on in the show. But 50 or so minutes in the TARDIS is a bit of a drag even for a two parter. It also has a VERY unsatisfying conclusion. Hartnell has another great monologue in this one though.
- 22 -
The Myth Makers (Story No. 20)
Difference: (-4)
This story would be heralded if it survived. Tonally it's a bit all over the place, with pieces of comedy and serious historical drama mixed together, makes it seem a bit weird at points. The acting is great in this one however, and the setting is brilliant. Not much complaints, but wish it was a surviving episode!
- 23 -
The Reign of Terror (Story No. 8)
Difference: (-4)
A pretty average historical drama with the Doctor and co. The mains in the story are quite good in terms of acting, and I really enjoy the political drama similar to The Massacre. However, this story really drags on for far too long, I'm sorry, but the animation looks awful aswell. Still a little enjoyable, but mostly boring and predictable.
- 24 -
The Crusade (Story No. 14)
Difference: (-7)
I think I'm going to have to re-watch this one. I can't really remember much about the story, I not sure if that's just me (probably). The sets are cool however, and Jean Marsh is always a plus!
- 25 -
The Sensorites (Story No. 7)
Difference: (+1)
A fairly average story where Susan really shines for the first time in the show. The first two parts are a tense space thriller with interesting characters and great build-up. But then the story crashes and burns. This story REALLY comes to a grinding halt in it's second half and becomes a political snooze fest.
- 26 -
The Web Planet (Story No. 13)
Difference: (+3)
A imaginative and ambitious story that has some "interesting" effects and sets. For some reason the camera men thought it might be a good idea to smear Vaseline? on the the cameras the achieve some sort of low-oxygen atmosphere feel. I'm not too sure about this story. I congratulate it for being unique, but the budget at the time just doesn't hold up.
- 27 -
Galaxy 4 (Story No. 18)
Difference: (=)
A simple morality tale based on not judging a book by it's cover isn't that bad, but I feel this story has a lack of substance. It suffers a lot from being a mostly missing story. The sets a kinda cool? The only take away I have is needing to have a life size Chumbley robot pet.
- 28 -
The Celestial Toymaker (Story No. 24)
Difference: (-7)
Kinda surprised to see it as high as it was on the list. A story that involves a great villain, but because of it's missing state really fails as keeping me engaged. I remember falling asleep to this story multiple times while watching and having to rewind and re watch many scenes. It's boring, and they drop the n-word in the second episode, not cool.
- 29 -
The Smugglers (Story No. 28)
Difference: (-1)
I expected this story to be near the bottom. Nothing exactly wrong with this story, but nothing great about it either. The only talking point is that it happens to be Ben and Polly's first adventure in the TARDIS. Completely inoffensive, decent sets I guess, but very skippable, and starts to drag even for a 4 parter.
Great ranking. Good to seeThe War Machines so high.
While not really reflective of my own thoughts, I’m at least glad Time Meddler is up there. Are you going to explain all the stories of all the Doctors in relation to each other or just keep it era themed?
Bit sad about results. Considering some of these have not been shown since release. Unknown why Marco is so high and yet as someone said the web planet and sensorites are so low. But good work josh. We love you really
Please let the Aztecs be number 1. There's no doubt in my mind that it's the best Hartnell episode.
The Reign of Terror is one of my favorites
Did anyone scavenge Peter Purves's discarded prop,and if so what terrible fate befell them?
9.99K Subs!
I have a video planned for when we hit 10K!
@@JoshSnares I can't wait!
I'm sure it'll be Fantastic! (Crappy attempt at a 9th Doctor reference, for no reason)
An Unearthly Child is just another level. The first part is actually perfect. Actually.
Fun fact I was watching this video before getting stuck in a lift with my friend
That is a fun fact
Trying to find the first video on this; but none seem to be titled as such. Would’ve presumed Hartnell would be the first but it starts with “welcome back” gone back 7 months but can’t see the first.
Yeah this is the first one, I just forgot to record a “welcome to” 😂
Yeah!!!!
can you re-edit all of these videos (BDWP) and upload them on spotify as podcasts?
The worst stories? Propably "The Reign of Terror" and "Planet of Gigants", the best? "The tenth Planet", "The Asteks", "The Rescue". In my opinion 😉
The Gunfighters is worse than The Web Planet. Just FYI.
Wrong!
Brilliant!
I love the time meddler
I would love to see The Daleks Masterplan and Marco Polo. My favorite show of William Hartnell is The Daleks
I really don't want to dislike The Web Planet but it's definitely one of those moments where it's a really good idea on paper, but had such piss poor execution and confined to a time where the SFX were not the greatest, forced it to be not as good as it could've or hell, even should've been. It was definitely a story ahead of its time and I feel like if you remade the story today, it would work so much better.