I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I love how even so many decades later she still gets joy when reminiscing her vengeance on her rapist. So satisfying to watch, she probably felt that way too.
I swear it takes ageing to truly appreciate Rosalie's character. When I was 12 i thought she was just a frosty bitch. Now I'm 22 I understand her traumatised, bitter, strong woman she is. She was betrayed, assaulted, left for dead. Her life its dreams, possibilities, family and the chance of a family all gone. Then she see's Bella willingly throwing away the humanity she so desperately longs for. It would piss me off too.
Yea Bella was so immature, I can see why Rosalie was annoyed with her. Bella’s personality eventually became an obsession/infatuation with Edward in these middle movies. She had no hobbies, no personality, no passions or desires outside of Edward. Both Edward and Bella’s existence and reason for living depended on each other. Rosalie should be annoyed with that alone 😂
Yes Team Rosalie all the way! I can understand why she's so mad at Bella for wanting to give up her human life and why she protects the unborn Renesmee so fiercely. She can never be a mother but she sure as hell is a dedicated aunt.
I also never understood why she had to be turned so early on like sure if you end up being 30 , turn to stay with that guy forever but why turn when you are 17 ...
And honestly Rosalie never tasted an ounce of human blood during her revenge on her attackers. That is the ultimate show of self-control. She was was killing, surrounded by blood as a newborn but wasn’t tempted; unlike Bella who everyone praised for not killing Charlie or the hiker when she was near them
Well, she's being truthful - she doesn't hate Bella. What she hates is the decision Bella made to turn her back on a normal human life, because from Rosalie's viewpoint, Bella has everything Rosalie desperately wanted but never got, and is just throwing it all away. They're different things.
I would totally watch a short twilight series were each episode highlights a differ Cullen's backstory. Starting with Carlisle's. Which may take more than a few episodes. His ends when he turns Edward. Then we follow Edward watching his mother dying and waking up to see Carlisle has saved him. Follow Esme down to the cliff cut to back when she opens her eyes to see Edward and Carlisle. Rosalie's will follow her life before and after being turned ending with Royce's blood spray on her wedding gown. Jasper's life may take a few episodes ending when he walks in and sees Alice waiting for him. Then we'll follow her through her battle with her visions in a poorly run asylum. Perhaps try to guess just who exactly turns her. A doctor? A nurse? A patient? Waking up in a graveyard staring at her tombstone but seeing the future clearly for the first time. Know her life was going to be so much better from then on. Timeline wise I'm not sure where Emmett comes in. Perhaps he longs to see the world outside the hills he was born into. A couple of episodes about their travels. A few episodes of Edward's hunter days would be kewl. Where he listened in on the thoughts of murderers and rapists and slaughtered them before they could hurt again. Just one short season ending when Carlisle comes in to tell them he's gotten a new job at a hospital in Forks.
@@Karolina-is6ro There's a bit more to Rose than a standard Kill Bill-style revenge scenario. The real driving force for her attitude and actions is her longing for a husband and family, and her consequent resentment of Bella, who has everything that Rose wanted but is throwing it all away - or at least that's how Rose perceives it. It's in portraying those aspects of the character where Nikki Reed comes into her own.
"there's nothing I'm ever going to want more than Edward," says Bella, aged 18, willing to never see her parents or friends ever again for a boy she's known for a year. Toxic relationships were definitely not as talked about in the naughties, evidently lol
@@leila_6740 I read the books when I was a young teenager and saw no cringe. Now I'm an adult and I reread the books and now I realize so many cringe and backward things in the series. Definitely not a healthy relationship
@@Kay-ne7cp It's opposite for me . I read the books few years back and thought how shallow Bella is . Afterwards I had to read Romeo and Juliet as a part of my syllabus . I guess it's not fair to compare Bella / Twilight to other contemporary books . It's fantasy yes but truly it's a love story . Juliet knows Romeo only for few days when she marries him and afterwards kills herself . When Romeo is banished she literally thinks she would rather have both her parents dead than Romeo banished . Still Romeo and Juliet is considered such a great love story . Bella is better than that at least.. She cared about parents enough . She was ready to sacrifice herself for her mother in the first book .. She's not all selfish . Yeah she got all dependent on Edward etc . And that's not something a normal modern girl of this age would do .. But Bella was ready to die for Edward many times .. at the hands of Volturi .. She was ready to risk a gruesome death for him ... And he was ready to die for her . Which is not how teenagers of this age love either .. There's nothing to learn from Twilight , Bella is not supposed to be a role model.. Just like there's nothing to learn from Romeo and Juliet except the author's assertion that True Love is beyond any rules and whatever shit ... You don't have to believe it and accept it as only truth . It's only one way to look at things .. If the characters of Twilight are unrealistic and shallow then so are the characters of Romeo and Juliet . And I don't see anyone criticizing Romeo and Juliet for being suicidal or selfish or unhealthily obsessed with each other , or not caring a bit about their parents . Only because Twilight is contemporary one could not expect Bella to be like contemporary and modern , emotionally independent women . Her insecurity about her looks and obsession about good looks are lot more cringe than her relationship with Edward ... I haven't read a shallower character .
Ok, this would've made a REALLY interesting movie right here. The story of a woman who turns into a vampire and hunts down her rapists? WAY more interesting than two teenagers blandly complimenting each other while everyone else does the work around them.
They should really make another movie just focusing on the Cullen's back story! I would love that! The only back story the explain in the series of movies is Edward, Rosalie, and Jasper. They don't talk about Esme killing herself after losing her child or Emmet being malled by a bear or Alice being locked in an asylum and having to go through shock therapy while everyone she knew pretended she was dead. Plus we know that Carlisle changed most of them but who changed him? The movie would be a hit!
Bella Kok carlisle father was some kind of witch or demon hunter i think. carlisle was helping hunt down a deranged vampire in the middle ages and went down into the sewers and got attacked from what i can remember
The last books explain everything, even Carlisle's backstory. He actually transformed while hidden in plain sight, which took an insane amount of inner strength. e_e"
the reason why Rosalie hates bella or at least annoyed with her is because she's jealous that she's human and she still wants to give up her humanity just to be with Edward I get it he's hot and everything but is not the only guy in the world for god sake
I agree, bella lost her independence and made her world revolve around edward and became a zombie when he left then took him back immediately.. its quite pathetic.
As a teen who read Twilight, Rosalie taught me to never trust a man before knowing him, certainly not enough to go up to him and his friends alone on the street in the dead of night She also taught me rapists deserve to be murdered brutally Go twilight xxx
Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I swear Rosalie story was probably the darkest and traumatic that the audience can actually feel where her bitterness is coming from. Well it's a relief that she seeked her revenge.
Mending Wall She never said the only reason she wanted to exist was for kids and marriage, it’s just something she wanted and strived for. Are you telling me that if a woman’s life goals are marriage and children that she can’t be independent? Because I disagree. Also, Rosalie evolves throughout the books / movies. She always had her own strong (yet unpopular) opinions, and basically did want she wanted.
@@librababyxo she doesnt have to say it, actions speak louder than words considering she is going this hard on a person simply for having a different plan for her life. If she wanted marriage and kids, fine. Not everyone wants the same . The way she pushes it makes it appear there is nothing outside of that world. How dare someone give up their life and not want kids
Mending Wall That’s not what Rosalie’s main focus was. She talked about how her life was frozen, she was stuck in a reoccurring cycle. Rosalie isn’t scolding Bella for not wanting kids, she’s scolding her for so willingly putting her life on hold for someone else.
@@librababyxo Rosalie shouldnt be the one to talk. She knew barely knew royce but she said herself that she was in love with the idea of love. So much so, she put everything into being with him. Bella is making a choice based on what she wants just as rosalie made decisions based on what she wanted: marriage and children. Rosalie shouldnt be so hard on bella who wants something so bad she would give up everything for. If it were for marriage and kids, rosalie would do the same thing.
The only movie that nailed Rosalie's look! Every other movie had Rosalie looking a mess. The book describes her has being perfect polished. The other movies did her no justice.
wisdaeim williams keep in mind of the life you'll give up. What live do you have? Would it be worth giving up to have vampirism running through your vains?
I wish monsters were real not just monsters but all manner I beasts but I'd rather be the ultimate monster like Typhon the father of monsters being a monster is 1 thing why not have all their power in 1 physical form . You just can't let it control you because if you do then your the monster not just your power
Maddy Krebs So true. A woman who was raped, then turned into a vampire, then goes hunting down her rapists, and eventually learns to trust someone and fall in love again. It's dark, interesting, complex, and explores the ramifications of being a vampire and emotional damage.
@@ursaminor9780 thats why Rosalie was bitter and angry fir many years because her life and peace was taken away from her. That's why in the first film she always looked mean and angry because of pain.
Technically she didn't tear him up. She made it clear that she was super careful not to spill his blood so that she wouldn't be tempted. She and Carlisle are the only 2 in the coven who haven't tasted human blood.
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I agree. Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I wish Stephanie Meyer had never made the twilight books about Bella. She knows how to write good mythology and background stories but they are overshadowed by Bella’s melancholic self hating and overall whining
Melancholic self hating and overall whining? Well, in the books, Bella, at least I perceived her as, humorous and more lively than in the movies. Here she looked dull and seemed like she was going through a rough patch...
Dookhun Roumaiy exactly! She was very opinionated, stubborn, and even had a temper! Something the directer didnt make sure was potrayed. Bella didnt look like she had any character growth whatsoever, and looked bored to death half the time.
Damn. That revenge must have been extremely satisfying. To make your enemy tense, making him dread, making him anticipate all the havoc that is to befall him and then actually killing him....God, it just sounds so amazing.
Even better when you realise she didn't just kill him, she tortured him. As she says in the book "He screamed when he saw me. He screamed a lot that night." Brrrr! Damn, ice cold, girl!
My favorite part of rosalie's retrospect was when she says " I was a little theatrical back then". The shine in her eyes and her wounded smile was priceless. The ones who raped her deserved every bit of her histrionics in how she dealt with them. Rosalie is my favorite character in the saga. Her smile reminds me of the cat from Alice in wonderland. It draws you in.
I like how they also gave her fiancé a bottle at the end, to show he hadn’t changed and he was still a drunkard. But now he wasn’t drinking out of joy or addiction, it was fear and anxiety
The best scene in the entire series is when she busts through that door and makes him whimper. Amazing visual especially the bridal getup. These movies are background noise while I'm writing things or doing hobby related stuff. They aren't bad because of moments like these.
Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
Welp, at least she's honest. It's true that she doesn't hate Bella - she hates the decision that Bella is making. And I really don't blame her for not liking Bella, because Bella is a threat to her family. In Twilight she is worried that Bella will expose them as vampires, then in Eclipse she knows that the Volturi will kill them if Bella remains human. I'd be pissed too.
Captain Marvel Wilson they honestly have everything against the cullens. (I’ll try to avoid using a “in the books” standpoint). But if you look throughout all the movies and out everything together it enhances what is frequently reiterated in the books. The Romanians from Breaking Dawn part 2 hate the Volturi because all they do is sit around and make strict laws and dictate and decay on their thrones. The volturi is strict. Later in this movie when they plead to Jane to spare Bree she says that the Volturi don’t give second chances. Technically there’s laws around the interaction of humans and vampires and the Volturi do not like being undermined. They want to be feared. They want to be respected. The longer they let the Cullens keep Bella as human makes the Volturi look weak and soft. More so, the Volturi (and it shows by their company) love to recruit the most talented vampires. Hence Jane for her gift of pain, her twin Alec for his gift to numb sensations, Demetry and his gift of tracking, Felix and his strength. The Volturi and Aro specifically have been wanting to recruit Edward and Alice for ever and never can, that’s why Aro is always so happy to see Alice because she can see visions and it’s even more of a reason that they don’t harm the Cullens. They’d be wasting talent they hope to one day have at their side.
True Fact: In the book Rosalie said she has a clean record of never tasted human blood nor kill any human from her thirst (except for her revenge) so her self-control is almost good as Bella and Carlisle, also she tortured Royce to death by saying "he screamed a lot that night",
It sucks when so many people say Twilight isn't a good series. I mean yeah it could've been put together with more detail, but someone worked hard on this, and I think the author and the director did a great job with the characters. You watch the movie scenes and you could almost FEEL what they're feeling but you feel it more in the books. It's a great series.
There were times when Stephanie Meyer wrote cringe-y lines and metaphors, but there were other times when she really went into a deeper level of writing with a lot of character development.
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I love how the books and movies were like “Hate Rosalie! She doesn’t want Bella to be happy as a vampire with Edward!” And then the whole fandom collectively went “she’s a smol bean and we love her with everything we have”
People who hated Rosalie or any character in any fandom will usually never admit they did once realizing that its not beneficial to do so. She's now being seen as more than just an angry and shallow pretty girl. Because she's now seen as a victim and a sympathetic rational but hypocritical person. Its no different than people admitting they were in the wrong. Nobody likes to be wrong or be seen in a negative light. I hated her, sharing experiences with a fictional character makes you realize you're not so different. I just don't have the immortality or want to wear a wedding dress and murder.
Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
Rosalie's character alone makes the whole bella-edward-forever-love thing crappy. She is so so mature. While this vampire thing seems so fascinating, her character brings in the reality, the human part, the necessity of a moving life, and kind of destroys the lovey-dovey concept portrayed in the movie
I understand Rosalie imagine never growing old and like she said the"possibilities" especially someone like her who wanted to have a family a blood related family and growing old, gotta be freaking boring to live forever and never changing and there is Bella who only cares about Edward, what about her parents? doesnt she have other aspirations in life than to be with a guy forever? i never understood her, i found their relationship toxic, side characters have more interesting stories
Humanoide #707 Rosalie could adopt, and she can die, just not in a predictable fashion. She could explore Mars, the moon, the deep sea. She can do extremely dangerous work (for humans) and die knowing she helped humanity. This could also be a superhero movie. Maybe the Cullens can make a pact where they agree to kill each other after a certain amount of years that they pick from a hat but the other doesn’t know how many years they have left, for the sake of their mental health
@@ber1779 Even if she adopts, her kids are going to grow old and die before she does same as the grandkids that is just sad and dying from old age is different from killing eachother, I really see that vampire thing as a curse and they see that way as well as far as I understood since they believe in the soul, idk if you saw Goblin, he lost so many people in all the time he lived, they grew old and it was heartbreaking, besides you have to understand that Rosalies goal was to raise a family and grow old, leave a legacy not adopting and see her kids and grandgrandkids grow old and die in a loop while she stays the same, I feel like she lives in a constant state of depression, imagine for normal people days are endless when you suffer that and you dont want to do anything but she is a vampire that cant die and cant take antidepressants and has to move places every few years and kill animals to drink
Ikkk I totally understand and agree, I was so annoyed when Bella was bragging about her new born and she’s literally leaving everything behind just for a boy. Idk why everyone isn’t with Rosalie when she’s actually so realistic and doesn’t live in a fantasy like Bella, she knows the consequences about being a vampire, Rosalie isn’t living in a fantasy but the life she wanted as a HUMAN, to have a husband and child and to grow old, FYI is no one knowing that Rosalie lived in the old days where women thought of that life style, and yeah Rosalie envies Bella bc Bella had a choice and she didn’t, Bella is a bad example 😂 and she’s only 18 still having a life ahead of her but she chose to stop b4 it even started, I feel so sorry for Rosalie and she’s basically the character I like in the story if I was her I be thinking “argh does this girl think she’s not like the other girls?!” Sis leave b4 it’s too late 💀
@@sammii_V YES! At the beginning I though Rosalie was just a mean girl but after reading her story it all make sense, she didnt choose this, she said it herself that she would rather be dead, yes she fell in love with Emmet but this is not the life she wanted, she is just stuck in it, imagine moving every damn time and then she meets Bella who has so many options yet she chooses wrong, and like I said they are toxic, he wanted to die because he thought she was dead, that is not healthy, he is just like her he doesnt think about his parents. I feel for Rosalie.
Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
Stephenie Meyer could make so much money writing prequel books. Even if they never made it to the big screen again, they’d sell out. “The Host” was amazing, she can write well. She has a basis for the characters already. My inner 13yr old heart really hopes it’ll come true some day.
In the book, she did vaguely say she tortured them long before killing them especially her fiancé. I think I remember reading something about how she peels his skins layer by layer...
Here's what Rosalie said in the book "I saved Royce for last. I hoped that he would hear of his friends' deaths and understand that I was coming for him. I hoped the fear would make the end worse for him. I think it worked . . I was overly theatrical, I wore a wedding dress I'd stolen for the occasion. He screamed when he saw me. He screamed a lot that night. Saving him for last was a good idea, it made it easier for me to control myself, to make it slower." Whoaaah! Don't mess with Rosalie!
Wow this shows how sheltered Bellas life really was. So many people have gotten hurt while someone is always around to save her ass before she even gets touched by anything such as a rock. I see both parties she doesn't want Bella to be a vampire bc she thinks it's best that she goes on with her life instead of a world of never changing forever. Where Bella doesn't want to grow old while her vampire lover stays the same forever. But whos to say if the story continued that she wouldn't grow tired of Edward?
Okay, so this is what I heard-I think Stephanie herself said it. Once a vampire falls in love, they'll always be in love. When Rosalie said FROZEN in this scene, that's how it works with love for them. Who they're in love with-will be the people they'll be in love with forever. I found a slight problem with this, but if that's what Stephanie said then I guess we just gotta go with it.
@@Nai-robi0871 In the guide book she wrote she explained it. They are frozen. Everything about them freezes after they change, their physical appearance, their personality. She said not much can change about them so when there is a change like love that also freezes so they love forever.
So if they freeze and not much about them can change how can a vampire fall in love once they are changed? Since Edward falls in love with Bella and in the last movie it seemed like a male vampire they know falls in love with their vampire cousin.
I think the reason intended or not.. Is to bring the two clans together through the child... That's why Bella has these two guys after her.. Its fated.. Non of it accidental. The relationships had to happen as they did to make that world a better place... Also I have met plenty of people who seemed to be "nothing special" and always have guys fighting over them. It's a real thing
I can say without a doubt that this was the best part of the franchise We got this empty nothingness of a girl with two abusive boyfriends when we could’ve had Rosalie hunting down her rapists
i rewatch this every few months just to see the scene where she bursts into his room in the wedding dress with the red eyes and the bad ass smile omg 🤪
no in the books they actually become friends. Rosalie becomes her confidante. their relationships blossomed much more beautifully on paper than it ever could on film
I agree actually I enjoyed more the Twilight saga on the books than in the films because there were parts of the book that wasn't put or even explored in the movies don't judge me I like the movies but if I have to choose between the Twilight Saga and The Vampire Diaries I will go with The Vampire Diaries honestly. One more thing yes I found Bella annoying as much as Elena of The Vampire Diaries. I like more Katherine than Elena.
Yes they do wind up liking each other in the books. Sure Rosalie was spoiled and vain when she was human, but all she really wanted was to have a husband and children. Really, it's no wonder she didn't like Bella, because from her viewpoint, Bella had the chance to have a human husband and lead the ordinary human life that Rosalie so wished for, and just thrown the opportunity away. They do become friends once Bella understands where Rosalie is coming from, and Rosalie gets to be an aunt if not a mother.
Bella explains in the last book that Rosalie finally came around after having Renesmee. She said that she finally did something that Rosalie would have done if she had been in her shoes.
Its funny because Rosalie notices that Bella makes the exact same mistake she once did. Edward wanted Bella for one thing, her blood was more appealing than any other human, he isn't exactly hiding that fact either. Bella feels special and is in love with the attention and the fact that Edward is singling her out despite being so many levels "above" her. The love is one sided. Bella has no redeeming qualities other than her blood, Edward has basically nothing special left after he turns Bella into a vampire and lifts her up to his level. Notice how in Twilight Breaking Dawn 2, Edward is nothing but a plot device, the big, attractive mystery of a character is just gone. Rosalie knows exactly that this love isn't justified and that at the end of the day, Edward wanted Bella to stay human for her blood and Bella wanted to enjoy being a vampire, like the naive, dumb girl she is.
Rosalie isnt very logical either. She admitted when she met Royce she was in love with the idea of being in love and he was the most eligible bachelor in town. She wanted emmet changed simply because he looked like her friends son. At the end of the book, bella opens her mind to edward for the first time and he can see the love was real
I love how 18 year old Bella thinks she's "never going to want more than Edward...." but like, you don't know that shit at 18 years old. Yeah, your relationship may work out and you may stay together for the rest of your lives, but you don't KNOW that. Her becoming a vampire wouldn't change that, they could still hate each other. woah I just got wayyy too invested in this. lol. But for real though.
once you're a vampire you're frozen- personality, appearance, who you're in love with. none of that ever changes so technically they'll never fall out of love
It is a curious thing, how she managed to torture Royce and her other attackers, because Rosalie states in the book that she did it bloodlessly because she knew if she drew blood, she wouldn’t have been able to control herself, and she didn’t want any part of them inside her. It’s a canon fact that she’s never drank human blood.
Unfortunately the book doesn't really go into any detail about exactly what she did to them, except that she took Her time doing it (as Rosalie says "He screamed when he saw me. He screamed a lot that night.") and that she took care not to spill their blood. Dislocated every joint and broke every bone one by one, perhaps?
Rosalie's n Alice's story intrigues me the most among Cullen's. I wish we could have gotten some sort of spin off on just Cullen's back stories... including of course Jasper's struggle, Carlisle's self discipline, Esme's pain & Emmet's bear fight that he always hold a grudge about.
I remember reading Eclipse as a child and not understanding she was raped. As a character when I see this scene as well as New Moon where she states she doesn't want that life and wished someone would vote no for her. I can't help but feel for Carlisle and Emment during that scene. Carlisle sees the Cullens as his children. So imagine him hearing his daughter say she hated the decesion he made to save her life. Imagine not regretting his decesion to save her but feeling guilt she was unahppy. Imagine Emment hearing her say if her life had a happy ending she wouldn't be alive, and that she wouldn't have chosen this life she has with Emment. I always feel he doesn't regret Carlisles decesion to save her. Still must be hard for them to here. No doubt the trauma of her rape affected her years later and I don't think she regretted being with Emment or a part of the Cullen Family. I'd like to think getting to help care for Rennesme helped her heal. I remember in the books Rosalie and Alice spoiled her with clothes and took pictures everyday. While Alice did not really desire for a baby like Rosalie, I'd imagine it would be wonderful to have a child to help care for. Just hoping Leah would get her chance! Perhaps with Nessie who would be her step niece if Charlie married her mother.
At first I thought Rosalie was a total b word until this scene. Very powerful. I like how she is genuinely trying to warn Bella not to make the wrong choice. It shows she's still a caring person.
Rosalie is one of my favorite characters. She’s that one person who just doesn’t seem to let anything get in her way. Even though she can be savage, she still has a good heart ❤️
Rosalie, Alice, even Victoria were all much prettier than Bella. I'm not saying Bella is ugly, but she's not all that for two hot guys to be fighting over. On top of that, her personality is dull.
I agree. Also, Kristen was always told that she was a bad actress because of Bella, but really she was spot on. The character herself was the issue. Bella wasn’t even remotely interesting until breaking dawn.
Bella only got interesting after being turned into a vampire, which I think is kinda one of the points of Bella’s story. That she was always meant to be a vampire. That’s why her human life/personality seemed so boring, because that wasn’t who she truly was.
Honestly I don’t think it was ALL about looks. Jacob liked Bella even before he was a wolf. He had a major boy crush on her. I think they mostly looked at it as personality too. Jacob liked her personality and Edward was just naturally attracted to knowing more about her
I read the books before I saw the movies. There were a lot of scenes that didn’t live up to the way I read them... This scene definitely was exactly how I pictured it. That smile. 😍
This is why I hate drunks and youths they do shit like this when they know what there doing even know they been drinking and sorry is not good for forgiveness
It's kinda neat that Rosalie's dream is what Nikki's real life is now. She's married to another one of my all time fav actors and has a little baby. Sooo happy for her :)
Can we talk about the fact that minor character's like Rosalie, Alice ect.... are way more intresting that Bela and Edward ? I mean Alice and Rosalie are women who have really suffered ! There are strong. I don't think that it is the case of Bela.
So they give a random vampire an interesting backstory, some vampires even go thousands of years back, even more fascinating. But nah, let's focus on a random human who has no redeeming qualities other than getting the hottest and most emo vampire to fall for her, for literally no reason. Stephenie Meyer, you've made a mistake by turning interesting characters into a plot device to serve your self-insert tween porn.
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
It's funny all of these people are vampires because they died a tragic death while human and bella is kinda spitting in their faces saying hey that looks like fun i would love to be a vampire idk why you guys look so sad. It's like wanting the last slice of pizza super bad but your sibling takes it and just throws it in the trash.
Rosalie,esme & alice are my favorites ❤❤❤ Rosalie didn’t deserve to go through that while being human Esme didn’t deserve to be abused physically & lose her baby & Alice didn’t deserve for her family to think she was crazy bcuz she had visions ❤️🩹
I kinda dislike the way Bella brushed off Rosalie’s story. “I understand that you can't have a normal life, but I want my vampire bf for eternity.” like? If I were in Bella’s shoes I would at least offer Rose some comfort. Bella just stood there, open-mouthed and whined about her boyfriend as usual. 🙄
@@rondameravella2885 I think it is mentions that the only that change is their wound being healed but everything else stay the same so due wouldn’t stick
I love how she wears a wedding dress whilst enacting her revenge, so iconic
Ughhh her mind
I say good on rose he earned it
I'd never think of that Rose is a genius
Same
I'd do it
I really enjoyed when she said "I was little theatrical back then!"
😂😈
Back then!
Remember Bella "Ive already ate" *Shatters glass in anger*
Just came here to see that scene...
Me too
Jenelle Lutchman what an understatement
@Paris Xoxox literally nobody is making bella the bad guy, calm down
I laughed when she entered the room while wearing that wedding gown and she said that she was 'theatrical back then'
Leo Bernabe lmao epic!
That was the scene that made her my favourite LMAO.
Right!!
If I was gang raped by my fiance and his friends and then turned into a vampire, I'd probably do the same thing.
I never got this part until now!! lol
Its funny that the character flashbacks were far more interesting than the main plot
FightingWolfFist Ikr
FightingWolfFist yea
Someone actually has a small channel and they have done short films on the other characters back story!!
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
The Carlisle ones were my favorite.
I love how even so many decades later she still gets joy when reminiscing her vengeance on her rapist. So satisfying to watch, she probably felt that way too.
Tamzin Brady Yeah, same
@@sandranorman5469 I'm very sorry to hear that about your daughter. I would too.
Sandra norman I’m sorry. People can be evil. I would say the same thing if I was you
Sandra norman I’m so sorry to hear that sadly , I can relate
@@keriastaton4850 im so sorry that happened to you stay strong 👑💖👑💖👑
I swear it takes ageing to truly appreciate Rosalie's character. When I was 12 i thought she was just a frosty bitch. Now I'm 22 I understand her traumatised, bitter, strong woman she is. She was betrayed, assaulted, left for dead. Her life its dreams, possibilities, family and the chance of a family all gone. Then she see's Bella willingly throwing away the humanity she so desperately longs for. It would piss me off too.
Yea Bella was so immature, I can see why Rosalie was annoyed with her. Bella’s personality eventually became an obsession/infatuation with Edward in these middle movies. She had no hobbies, no personality, no passions or desires outside of Edward. Both Edward and Bella’s existence and reason for living depended on each other. Rosalie should be annoyed with that alone 😂
Yessss
Yes Team Rosalie all the way! I can understand why she's so mad at Bella for wanting to give up her human life and why she protects the unborn Renesmee so fiercely. She can never be a mother but she sure as hell is a dedicated aunt.
I also never understood why she had to be turned so early on like sure if you end up being 30 , turn to stay with that guy forever but why turn when you are 17 ...
And honestly Rosalie never tasted an ounce of human blood during her revenge on her attackers. That is the ultimate show of self-control. She was was killing, surrounded by blood as a newborn but wasn’t tempted; unlike Bella who everyone praised for not killing Charlie or the hiker when she was near them
"Hate. I don't hate you. I don't particularly like you" boooommmmm
Heder Block 🌚🌚🌚
SHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH THIS IS A BONDING MOMENT SHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH DON'T MESS THIS UP
Bella, I envy you
You're not alone, sweetheart. A lot of people don't like Bella.
Well, she's being truthful - she doesn't hate Bella. What she hates is the decision Bella made to turn her back on a normal human life, because from Rosalie's viewpoint, Bella has everything Rosalie desperately wanted but never got, and is just throwing it all away. They're different things.
How come the minor characters are the only interesting ones in this series
Yeah, I wish that rosalie just had her own mini movie
Lima Bean agreed
I would totally watch a short twilight series were each episode highlights a differ Cullen's backstory. Starting with Carlisle's. Which may take more than a few episodes. His ends when he turns Edward. Then we follow Edward watching his mother dying and waking up to see Carlisle has saved him. Follow Esme down to the cliff cut to back when she opens her eyes to see Edward and Carlisle. Rosalie's will follow her life before and after being turned ending with Royce's blood spray on her wedding gown. Jasper's life may take a few episodes ending when he walks in and sees Alice waiting for him. Then we'll follow her through her battle with her visions in a poorly run asylum. Perhaps try to guess just who exactly turns her. A doctor? A nurse? A patient? Waking up in a graveyard staring at her tombstone but seeing the future clearly for the first time. Know her life was going to be so much better from then on. Timeline wise I'm not sure where Emmett comes in. Perhaps he longs to see the world outside the hills he was born into. A couple of episodes about their travels. A few episodes of Edward's hunter days would be kewl. Where he listened in on the thoughts of murderers and rapists and slaughtered them before they could hurt again. Just one short season ending when Carlisle comes in to tell them he's gotten a new job at a hospital in Forks.
And after that a season two with the volturis
Lima Bean agreed
Nikki Reed is such a good actress. I like her facial expressions and how she made you to understand the character.
Maybe she should have given kristen some lessons on facial acting
@@Karolina-is6ro There's a bit more to Rose than a standard Kill Bill-style revenge scenario. The real driving force for her attitude and actions is her longing for a husband and family, and her consequent resentment of Bella, who has everything that Rose wanted but is throwing it all away - or at least that's how Rose perceives it. It's in portraying those aspects of the character where Nikki Reed comes into her own.
Laurie Faith Prescott Actually Kristen nailed it. She played Bella to a T. Read the book you’ll see what I mean.
@@chooseyourpoison5105 I want Karolina in Vampire Diaries. You are my poison. My poison are grapes too.
She is literally one of the only characters to have emotions in this franchise.
"there's nothing I'm ever going to want more than Edward," says Bella, aged 18, willing to never see her parents or friends ever again for a boy she's known for a year. Toxic relationships were definitely not as talked about in the naughties, evidently lol
Finally someone who agrees with me!
The books were better I swear 😭 they had absolutely no cringe. I’m on the second book tho and it’s heartbreaking
@@leila_6740 I read the books when I was a young teenager and saw no cringe. Now I'm an adult and I reread the books and now I realize so many cringe and backward things in the series. Definitely not a healthy relationship
@@Kay-ne7cp I agree their relationship was definitely not healthy. Edward was mentally abusive
@@Kay-ne7cp It's opposite for me . I read the books few years back and thought how shallow Bella is . Afterwards I had to read Romeo and Juliet as a part of my syllabus . I guess it's not fair to compare Bella / Twilight to other contemporary books . It's fantasy yes but truly it's a love story . Juliet knows Romeo only for few days when she marries him and afterwards kills herself . When Romeo is banished she literally thinks she would rather have both her parents dead than Romeo banished . Still Romeo and Juliet is considered such a great love story . Bella is better than that at least.. She cared about parents enough . She was ready to sacrifice herself for her mother in the first book .. She's not all selfish . Yeah she got all dependent on Edward etc . And that's not something a normal modern girl of this age would do .. But Bella was ready to die for Edward many times .. at the hands of Volturi .. She was ready to risk a gruesome death for him ... And he was ready to die for her . Which is not how teenagers of this age love either .. There's nothing to learn from Twilight , Bella is not supposed to be a role model.. Just like there's nothing to learn from Romeo and Juliet except the author's assertion that True Love is beyond any rules and whatever shit ... You don't have to believe it and accept it as only truth . It's only one way to look at things ..
If the characters of Twilight are unrealistic and shallow then so are the characters of Romeo and Juliet . And I don't see anyone criticizing Romeo and Juliet for being suicidal or selfish or unhealthily obsessed with each other , or not caring a bit about their parents . Only because Twilight is contemporary one could not expect Bella to be like contemporary and modern , emotionally independent women .
Her insecurity about her looks and obsession about good looks are lot more cringe than her relationship with Edward ... I haven't read a shallower character .
Ok, this would've made a REALLY interesting movie right here. The story of a woman who turns into a vampire and hunts down her rapists? WAY more interesting than two teenagers blandly complimenting each other while everyone else does the work around them.
Marvel Disneyfan ikr 😂
I Spit On Your Grave has a similar revenge-fantasy premise. But no vamps. XD
Bella is the only teenager xd her bf is an old man who doesnt age
And the way her and emmet ?!?!? Like yes a story!
You have *_I Spit In Your Grave_* already. Is the same, but without vampires.
They should really make another movie just focusing on the Cullen's back story! I would love that! The only back story the explain in the series of movies is Edward, Rosalie, and Jasper. They don't talk about Esme killing herself after losing her child or Emmet being malled by a bear or Alice being locked in an asylum and having to go through shock therapy while everyone she knew pretended she was dead. Plus we know that Carlisle changed most of them but who changed him? The movie would be a hit!
Bella Kok
carlisle father was some kind of witch or demon hunter i think. carlisle was helping hunt down a deranged vampire in the middle ages and went down into the sewers and got attacked from what i can remember
Wait what? Where is this info? About their back story's?
The last books explain everything, even Carlisle's backstory. He actually transformed while hidden in plain sight, which took an insane amount of inner strength. e_e"
Ikr! And a movie about the Volturi. Omg, the Volturi was the only thing that was "vampiric"
Efsun Çakmak
Those guys freak me out to this day, and we still know little about them.
probably the deepest scene in the entire series
Rosalie looked her best in this film than in the entire series
gee geeme those wigs were horrendous tho
It’s the hair
gee geeme she looked good in all the other movies too. She’s pretty
How dare those men treat her with all that disrespect! Glad she took the revenge on all them bastards
Twilight 1 she was the prettiest. Breaking dawns she was nice too. In 2 and 3 she look awfully fake and overdone
i actually fully understand where rosalie's coming from. bella is really annoying
Yeah and I wouldn't want to be damned to an eternity with Bella either
the reason why Rosalie hates bella or at least annoyed with her is because she's jealous that she's human and she still wants to give up her humanity just to be with Edward I get it he's hot and everything but is not the only guy in the world for god sake
Blanca Rosales but the one she loves
Bridger L. you are the annoying one 🖕
I agree, bella lost her independence and made her world revolve around edward and became a zombie when he left then took him back immediately.. its quite pathetic.
"They left me in the street thinking I was dead, believe me I wanted to be" My heart just sank🥺
As a teen who read Twilight, Rosalie taught me to never trust a man before knowing him, certainly not enough to go up to him and his friends alone on the street in the dead of night
She also taught me rapists deserve to be murdered brutally
Go twilight xxx
Preach 🙌🏼🙌🏼
You can’t trust nobody.
Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
Ok
And in a wedding dress
"Frozen, never moving forward" damn, that line.
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I swear Rosalie story was probably the darkest and traumatic that the audience can actually feel where her bitterness is coming from. Well it's a relief that she seeked her revenge.
rosalie is one of the most underrated characters in the whole series. she’s so .. everything. i love her. easily my favorite character :))
Im not sure about independent. She based her whole meaning for existing about marriage and kids.
Mending Wall
She never said the only reason she wanted to exist was for kids and marriage, it’s just something she wanted and strived for. Are you telling me that if a woman’s life goals are marriage and children that she can’t be independent? Because I disagree. Also, Rosalie evolves throughout the books / movies. She always had her own strong (yet unpopular) opinions, and basically did want she wanted.
@@librababyxo she doesnt have to say it, actions speak louder than words considering she is going this hard on a person simply for having a different plan for her life. If she wanted marriage and kids, fine. Not everyone wants the same . The way she pushes it makes it appear there is nothing outside of that world. How dare someone give up their life and not want kids
Mending Wall
That’s not what Rosalie’s main focus was. She talked about how her life was frozen, she was stuck in a reoccurring cycle. Rosalie isn’t scolding Bella for not wanting kids, she’s scolding her for so willingly putting her life on hold for someone else.
@@librababyxo Rosalie shouldnt be the one to talk. She knew barely knew royce but she said herself that she was in love with the idea of love. So much so, she put everything into being with him. Bella is making a choice based on what she wants just as rosalie made decisions based on what she wanted: marriage and children. Rosalie shouldnt be so hard on bella who wants something so bad she would give up everything for. If it were for marriage and kids, rosalie would do the same thing.
The only movie that nailed Rosalie's look! Every other movie had Rosalie looking a mess. The book describes her has being perfect polished. The other movies did her no justice.
Other movies?
@@jasmineh.3002 There are 5 movies
They told Nikki to dye her hair blonde and afterwards it was breaking and falling out so they told her to wear a wig instead. I guess that was better
I wish vampirism was real. So I could get MY revenge, like Rosalie did.
wisdaeim williams keep in mind of the life you'll give up. What live do you have? Would it be worth giving up to have vampirism running through your vains?
Do what you gotta do, but do it smart. Don't give up what's good in your life by being impatient.
You & me both. I’d make it slow and painful
I wish monsters were real not just monsters but all manner I beasts but I'd rather be the ultimate monster like Typhon the father of monsters being a monster is 1 thing why not have all their power in 1 physical form . You just can't let it control you because if you do then your the monster not just your power
I don't know if you were actually raped,or assaulted by someone but if so I'm sorry you had to go through that in life.
Ironically Rosalie is Damon's wife in real life LOL
one of the hottest vampires ever. he´s in TVD (The vampire diaries)
I was waiting for that one Ian Somerhalder comment
@@izzydizzy9759 he's not even hot tbh.
에드머약혼자 본인 he’s in a show called vampire diaries it a great show you should watch it.
Emmett
Rosalie's story is way better than any of the crap in twilight
Εισαι ηλιθια
Maddy Krebs So true. A woman who was raped, then turned into a vampire, then goes hunting down her rapists, and eventually learns to trust someone and fall in love again. It's dark, interesting, complex, and explores the ramifications of being a vampire and emotional damage.
@@ursaminor9780 thats why Rosalie was bitter and angry fir many years because her life and peace was taken away from her. That's why in the first film she always looked mean and angry because of pain.
Everyone's backstory is more interesting than Edward & Bella.
Maddy Krebs Agreed
Her flashback gave me LIFE I wish they could have show her tearing him up!
Technically she didn't tear him up. She made it clear that she was super careful not to spill his blood so that she wouldn't be tempted. She and Carlisle are the only 2 in the coven who haven't tasted human blood.
Nah, if you've read the book, she slowly tortured him to death. They couldn't really show it and keep a PG rating
ChooseYour Poison it’s pg-13 and also how did she torture him? I’ve never read the books
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
@@lydiaruby89 if she didn't tasted human blood how come her eyes were red back then.
That moment when you realize that Rosalie is more interesting than the main character.
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
She is just gorgeous inside & outside
Sylla Atlas nikki reed. She is even as a person on the inside. She just had a baby :) check out the movie thirteen with her
Jj
True
Yeah especially when she snatched Ian Somerhalder from her close friend Nina Dovrev😉😆
I agree. Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I wish Stephanie Meyer had never made the twilight books about Bella. She knows how to write good mythology and background stories but they are overshadowed by Bella’s melancholic self hating and overall whining
Desirae Powell Ik ! Bella pissed me off a few times lol
Melancholic self hating and overall whining? Well, in the books, Bella, at least I perceived her as, humorous and more lively than in the movies. Here she looked dull and seemed like she was going through a rough patch...
Dookhun Roumaiy exactly! She was very opinionated, stubborn, and even had a temper! Something the directer didnt make sure was potrayed. Bella didnt look like she had any character growth whatsoever, and looked bored to death half the time.
They should have included all the Cullens backstories
Lol she wanted make herself the protagonist.
All Rosalie ever wanted was a husband, a family and to be loved 😭❤️
Damn. That revenge must have been extremely satisfying. To make your enemy tense, making him dread, making him anticipate all the havoc that is to befall him and then actually killing him....God, it just sounds so amazing.
Even better when you realise she didn't just kill him, she tortured him. As she says in the book "He screamed when he saw me. He screamed a lot that night." Brrrr! Damn, ice cold, girl!
@@chooseyourpoison5105-he deserved it he took advantage of her
@@maricelatorres9719 Yep he deserved everything she did to him and more
My favorite part of rosalie's retrospect was when she says " I was a little theatrical back then". The shine in her eyes and her wounded smile was priceless. The ones who raped her deserved every bit of her histrionics in how she dealt with them. Rosalie is my favorite character in the saga. Her smile reminds me of the cat from Alice in wonderland. It draws you in.
I like how they also gave her fiancé a bottle at the end, to show he hadn’t changed and he was still a drunkard. But now he wasn’t drinking out of joy or addiction, it was fear and anxiety
“I don’t care how miserable your human life is” lmao
The best scene in the entire series is when she busts through that door and makes him whimper. Amazing visual especially the bridal getup. These movies are background noise while I'm writing things or doing hobby related stuff. They aren't bad because of moments like these.
I love how he’s so terrified he doesn’t even want to look at her.
Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
No... Bella was afraid of loosing Edward. She wanted him forever..
“hehe, Hate you. I don’t hate you. I don’t particularly like you, but.” 😂 you go Rosalie!
Welp, at least she's honest. It's true that she doesn't hate Bella - she hates the decision that Bella is making. And I really don't blame her for not liking Bella, because Bella is a threat to her family. In Twilight she is worried that Bella will expose them as vampires, then in Eclipse she knows that the Volturi will kill them if Bella remains human. I'd be pissed too.
You just summed up the things that don’t make sense in this franchise. What is it that the Volturi have against the Cullens when Bella is human.
Captain Marvel Wilson they honestly have everything against the cullens. (I’ll try to avoid using a “in the books” standpoint). But if you look throughout all the movies and out everything together it enhances what is frequently reiterated in the books. The Romanians from Breaking Dawn part 2 hate the Volturi because all they do is sit around and make strict laws and dictate and decay on their thrones. The volturi is strict. Later in this movie when they plead to Jane to spare Bree she says that the Volturi don’t give second chances. Technically there’s laws around the interaction of humans and vampires and the Volturi do not like being undermined. They want to be feared. They want to be respected. The longer they let the Cullens keep Bella as human makes the Volturi look weak and soft. More so, the Volturi (and it shows by their company) love to recruit the most talented vampires. Hence Jane for her gift of pain, her twin Alec for his gift to numb sensations, Demetry and his gift of tracking, Felix and his strength. The Volturi and Aro specifically have been wanting to recruit Edward and Alice for ever and never can, that’s why Aro is always so happy to see Alice because she can see visions and it’s even more of a reason that they don’t harm the Cullens. They’d be wasting talent they hope to one day have at their side.
Christian Soto I’ve heard people who’ve read the books say they don’t even explain much.
@@chooseyourpoison5105
That's true and Bella did say that the data for her transformation has already been set
I love the pure joy she exhibits when she talks about getting her revenge. The little smirk, it just makes her radiate with happiness
Lol literally Rosalie's story is better than the whole plot of the whole franchise.
True Fact: In the book Rosalie said she has a clean record of never tasted human blood nor kill any human from her thirst (except for her revenge) so her self-control is almost good as Bella and Carlisle, also she tortured Royce to death by saying "he screamed a lot that night",
Rose: i was a little theatrical back then
My mind: A LITTLE
and she did it without spilling their blood so she wouldn't be tempted to have an ounce of their dirty blood in her system. what an absolute queen.
It sucks when so many people say Twilight isn't a good series. I mean yeah it could've been put together with more detail, but someone worked hard on this, and I think the author and the director did a great job with the characters. You watch the movie scenes and you could almost FEEL what they're feeling but you feel it more in the books. It's a great series.
Weird J I totally agree
yeah
There were times when Stephanie Meyer wrote cringe-y lines and metaphors, but there were other times when she really went into a deeper level of writing with a lot of character development.
LuckyFin ur right!
LuckyFin
Totally agree, the books have a lot to detail and I just finished the first book of twilight less then a week.. love it
It's so unfair :( I always felt so sorry for Rosalie.
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
I love Rosalie 😍❤️
Riane Quinn aw thanks xx ❤️❤️
DanceMoms Forever
I don't because Edward cheated on Bella with Rosalie Edward was a cute couple with Bella
DanceMoms Forever she’s beautiful right?❤️
Omg ur the only famous youtuber i know thats watches and comments on other videos like a normal person....
I love how the books and movies were like “Hate Rosalie! She doesn’t want Bella to be happy as a vampire with Edward!”
And then the whole fandom collectively went “she’s a smol bean and we love her with everything we have”
I’m more of the opinion that anything Bella thinks is a good idea it’s best to think the exact opposite.
People who hated Rosalie or any character in any fandom will usually never admit they did once realizing that its not beneficial to do so. She's now being seen as more than just an angry and shallow pretty girl.
Because she's now seen as a victim and a sympathetic rational but hypocritical person.
Its no different than people admitting they were in the wrong. Nobody likes to be wrong or be seen in a negative light.
I hated her, sharing experiences with a fictional character makes you realize you're not so different.
I just don't have the immortality or want to wear a wedding dress and murder.
Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
@@hjk8692 Also, Stephanie gave us an actual back story versus what some writers do where they just throw you a villain or stereotypical mean girl.
Rosalie's character alone makes the whole bella-edward-forever-love thing crappy. She is so so mature. While this vampire thing seems so fascinating, her character brings in the reality, the human part, the necessity of a moving life, and kind of destroys the lovey-dovey concept portrayed in the movie
I understand Rosalie imagine never growing old and like she said the"possibilities" especially someone like her who wanted to have a family a blood related family and growing old, gotta be freaking boring to live forever and never changing and there is Bella who only cares about Edward, what about her parents? doesnt she have other aspirations in life than to be with a guy forever? i never understood her, i found their relationship toxic, side characters have more interesting stories
Humanoide #707 Rosalie could adopt, and she can die, just not in a predictable fashion. She could explore Mars, the moon, the deep sea. She can do extremely dangerous work (for humans) and die knowing she helped humanity. This could also be a superhero movie. Maybe the Cullens can make a pact where they agree to kill each other after a certain amount of years that they pick from a hat but the other doesn’t know how many years they have left, for the sake of their mental health
@@ber1779 Even if she adopts, her kids are going to grow old and die before she does same as the grandkids that is just sad and dying from old age is different from killing eachother, I really see that vampire thing as a curse and they see that way as well as far as I understood since they believe in the soul, idk if you saw Goblin, he lost so many people in all the time he lived, they grew old and it was heartbreaking, besides you have to understand that Rosalies goal was to raise a family and grow old, leave a legacy not adopting and see her kids and grandgrandkids grow old and die in a loop while she stays the same, I feel like she lives in a constant state of depression, imagine for normal people days are endless when you suffer that and you dont want to do anything but she is a vampire that cant die and cant take antidepressants and has to move places every few years and kill animals to drink
Ikkk I totally understand and agree, I was so annoyed when Bella was bragging about her new born and she’s literally leaving everything behind just for a boy. Idk why everyone isn’t with Rosalie when she’s actually so realistic and doesn’t live in a fantasy like Bella, she knows the consequences about being a vampire, Rosalie isn’t living in a fantasy but the life she wanted as a HUMAN, to have a husband and child and to grow old, FYI is no one knowing that Rosalie lived in the old days where women thought of that life style, and yeah Rosalie envies Bella bc Bella had a choice and she didn’t, Bella is a bad example 😂 and she’s only 18 still having a life ahead of her but she chose to stop b4 it even started, I feel so sorry for Rosalie and she’s basically the character I like in the story if I was her I be thinking “argh does this girl think she’s not like the other girls?!” Sis leave b4 it’s too late 💀
@@sammii_V YES! At the beginning I though Rosalie was just a mean girl but after reading her story it all make sense, she didnt choose this, she said it herself that she would rather be dead, yes she fell in love with Emmet but this is not the life she wanted, she is just stuck in it, imagine moving every damn time and then she meets Bella who has so many options yet she chooses wrong, and like I said they are toxic, he wanted to die because he thought she was dead, that is not healthy, he is just like her he doesnt think about his parents. I feel for Rosalie.
Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
Stephenie Meyer could make so much money writing prequel books. Even if they never made it to the big screen again, they’d sell out. “The Host” was amazing, she can write well. She has a basis for the characters already. My inner 13yr old heart really hopes it’ll come true some day.
I wish they could've shown what Rosalie did to her so called future husband!
Game of Thrones knows how to handle rapists.
One character shoved a sword right up his junk.
But Twilight's audience is young. Too graphic. XD
In the book, she did vaguely say she tortured them long before killing them especially her fiancé. I think I remember reading something about how she peels his skins layer by layer...
sonali sheeva i remember that she never made them bleed in her torture methods because she didnt want make their blood part of her body
Here's what Rosalie said in the book "I saved Royce for last. I hoped that he would hear of his friends' deaths and understand that I was coming for him. I hoped the fear would make the end worse for him. I think it worked . . I was overly theatrical, I wore a wedding dress I'd stolen for the occasion. He screamed when he saw me. He screamed a lot that night. Saving him for last was a good idea, it made it easier for me to control myself, to make it slower." Whoaaah! Don't mess with Rosalie!
@@chooseyourpoison5105 I wonder if there will be a backstory of him reincarnating and meeting Rosalie again 🤔? Interesting factor.
Wow this shows how sheltered Bellas life really was. So many people have gotten hurt while someone is always around to save her ass before she even gets touched by anything such as a rock. I see both parties she doesn't want Bella to be a vampire bc she thinks it's best that she goes on with her life instead of a world of never changing forever. Where Bella doesn't want to grow old while her vampire lover stays the same forever. But whos to say if the story continued that she wouldn't grow tired of Edward?
Okay, so this is what I heard-I think Stephanie herself said it. Once a vampire falls in love, they'll always be in love. When Rosalie said FROZEN in this scene, that's how it works with love for them. Who they're in love with-will be the people they'll be in love with forever. I found a slight problem with this, but if that's what Stephanie said then I guess we just gotta go with it.
@@Nai-robi0871 In the guide book she wrote she explained it. They are frozen. Everything about them freezes after they change, their physical appearance, their personality. She said not much can change about them so when there is a change like love that also freezes so they love forever.
So if they freeze and not much about them can change how can a vampire fall in love once they are changed? Since Edward falls in love with Bella and in the last movie it seemed like a male vampire they know falls in love with their vampire cousin.
I think the reason intended or not.. Is to bring the two clans together through the child... That's why Bella has these two guys after her.. Its fated.. Non of it accidental. The relationships had to happen as they did to make that world a better place... Also I have met plenty of people who seemed to be "nothing special" and always have guys fighting over them. It's a real thing
@@angelinaschlesinger because meyer is stupid af and this series isn't logical at all
I can say without a doubt that this was the best part of the franchise We got this empty nothingness of a girl with two abusive boyfriends when we could’ve had Rosalie hunting down her rapists
She was the only one that I liked out of all of them I liked her story more cuz her stories stand it out more
she was the only one i hate in them all
@@kunchitv why? I mean she is really the most innocent out of all of them, and she has the best and saddest backstory out of all of them,
She has such a good story telling voice.
I almost thought she was going to say "a baby" at the end
hautxtalons I thought it would be "To be human again."
me too
I think she says "a baby" in a deleted scene.
When she came through the door in her wedding dress and I grinned. One thought crossed my mind. "Fabulous."
i rewatch this every few months just to see the scene where she bursts into his room in the wedding dress with the red eyes and the bad ass smile omg 🤪
“I was a little theatrical back then.” 😂👌🏻
actually in the end bella and rosalie like eachother
Not really. She only likes bella because of her baby.
no in the books they actually become friends. Rosalie becomes her confidante. their relationships blossomed much more beautifully on paper than it ever could on film
I agree actually I enjoyed more the Twilight saga on the books than in the films because there were parts of the book that wasn't put or even explored in the movies don't judge me I like the movies but if I have to choose between the Twilight Saga and The Vampire Diaries I will go with The Vampire Diaries honestly. One more thing yes I found Bella annoying as much as Elena of The Vampire Diaries. I like more Katherine than Elena.
Yes they do wind up liking each other in the books. Sure Rosalie was spoiled and vain when she was human, but all she really wanted was to have a husband and children. Really, it's no wonder she didn't like Bella, because from her viewpoint, Bella had the chance to have a human husband and lead the ordinary human life that Rosalie so wished for, and just thrown the opportunity away. They do become friends once Bella understands where Rosalie is coming from, and Rosalie gets to be an aunt if not a mother.
Bella explains in the last book that Rosalie finally came around after having Renesmee. She said that she finally did something that Rosalie would have done if she had been in her shoes.
Roslie is right blood is the one and only thing Bella would want more then anything, even edward
Rosalie and I share two things in common: our dislike for Bella, and the fact that I was once also young and in love with the idea of love.
“Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned....”
She wasn't scorned she was raped
@@ishtarbabylon4869 and beaten to the point of death
Its funny because Rosalie notices that Bella makes the exact same mistake she once did. Edward wanted Bella for one thing, her blood was more appealing than any other human, he isn't exactly hiding that fact either. Bella feels special and is in love with the attention and the fact that Edward is singling her out despite being so many levels "above" her. The love is one sided.
Bella has no redeeming qualities other than her blood, Edward has basically nothing special left after he turns Bella into a vampire and lifts her up to his level. Notice how in Twilight Breaking Dawn 2, Edward is nothing but a plot device, the big, attractive mystery of a character is just gone.
Rosalie knows exactly that this love isn't justified and that at the end of the day, Edward wanted Bella to stay human for her blood and Bella wanted to enjoy being a vampire, like the naive, dumb girl she is.
Rosalie isnt very logical either. She admitted when she met Royce she was in love with the idea of being in love and he was the most eligible bachelor in town. She wanted emmet changed simply because he looked like her friends son. At the end of the book, bella opens her mind to edward for the first time and he can see the love was real
南雲Haruya maybe he wanted her to stay human because he had no choice. You’re dumb and cancelled bye
@@daniellemartinez8810 He wanted her to be human to be alive blood as well. You need to chill. 😑
I love how 18 year old Bella thinks she's "never going to want more than Edward...." but like, you don't know that shit at 18 years old. Yeah, your relationship may work out and you may stay together for the rest of your lives, but you don't KNOW that. Her becoming a vampire wouldn't change that, they could still hate each other.
woah I just got wayyy too invested in this. lol. But for real though.
kalyn nowlan well sometimes you just know.
once you're a vampire you're frozen- personality, appearance, who you're in love with. none of that ever changes so technically they'll never fall out of love
This scene makes me wish this movie was R rated so I could see the torture in more detail
But damn! Rosalie is the real badass!
It is a curious thing, how she managed to torture Royce and her other attackers, because Rosalie states in the book that she did it bloodlessly because she knew if she drew blood, she wouldn’t have been able to control herself, and she didn’t want any part of them inside her. It’s a canon fact that she’s never drank human blood.
Unfortunately the book doesn't really go into any detail about exactly what she did to them, except that she took Her time doing it (as Rosalie says "He screamed when he saw me. He screamed a lot that night.") and that she took care not to spill their blood. Dislocated every joint and broke every bone one by one, perhaps?
I hate but also appreciate those people in my life. They tell you the annoying side truth when you think have it all planned out. Lol
Rosalie is literally so beautiful, my fav character
Rosalie's n Alice's story intrigues me the most among Cullen's. I wish we could have gotten some sort of spin off on just Cullen's back stories... including of course Jasper's struggle, Carlisle's self discipline, Esme's pain & Emmet's bear fight that he always hold a grudge about.
She looks so good when she enters that room, the dress, her hair, the eyes and the evil smile GOOD LORD
I remember reading Eclipse as a child and not understanding she was raped. As a character when I see this scene as well as New Moon where she states she doesn't want that life and wished someone would vote no for her. I can't help but feel for Carlisle and Emment during that scene. Carlisle sees the Cullens as his children. So imagine him hearing his daughter say she hated the decesion he made to save her life. Imagine not regretting his decesion to save her but feeling guilt she was unahppy. Imagine Emment hearing her say if her life had a happy ending she wouldn't be alive, and that she wouldn't have chosen this life she has with Emment. I always feel he doesn't regret Carlisles decesion to save her. Still must be hard for them to here.
No doubt the trauma of her rape affected her years later and I don't think she regretted being with Emment or a part of the Cullen Family. I'd like to think getting to help care for Rennesme helped her heal. I remember in the books Rosalie and Alice spoiled her with clothes and took pictures everyday. While Alice did not really desire for a baby like Rosalie, I'd imagine it would be wonderful to have a child to help care for. Just hoping Leah would get her chance! Perhaps with Nessie who would be her step niece if Charlie married her mother.
I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO THOUGHT THIS-
@@nerd_liv I’m glad someone else did😂😂😂
Who’s Leah
At first I thought Rosalie was a total b word until this scene. Very powerful. I like how she is genuinely trying to warn Bella not to make the wrong choice. It shows she's still a caring person.
Really shows how rough life was in those times.
Rosalie cullen and damon salvatore would actually make a great couple
love the fact that the actors are married in real life
“I was in love with the idea of love”😍🙌🏾
I LOVE Rosalie’s hair in this scene
Rosalie is one of my favorite characters. She’s that one person who just doesn’t seem to let anything get in her way. Even though she can be savage, she still has a good heart ❤️
Rosalie, Alice, even Victoria were all much prettier than Bella. I'm not saying Bella is ugly, but she's not all that for two hot guys to be fighting over. On top of that, her personality is dull.
Amethyst Maries exactly
Amethyst Maries yap
I agree. Also, Kristen was always told that she was a bad actress because of Bella, but really she was spot on. The character herself was the issue. Bella wasn’t even remotely interesting until breaking dawn.
Bella only got interesting after being turned into a vampire, which I think is kinda one of the points of Bella’s story. That she was always meant to be a vampire. That’s why her human life/personality seemed so boring, because that wasn’t who she truly was.
Honestly I don’t think it was ALL about looks. Jacob liked Bella even before he was a wolf. He had a major boy crush on her. I think they mostly looked at it as personality too. Jacob liked her personality and Edward was just naturally attracted to knowing more about her
Stand for a real queen.
Rosalie's story is the most painful 😭🤧💔
Watching her walk in dressed as a bride was the best thing in the entire franchise!
I read the books before I saw the movies.
There were a lot of scenes that didn’t live up to the way I read them...
This scene definitely was exactly how I pictured it.
That smile. 😍
I’m glad Nikki Reed found Ian Somerholder and had their beautiful little girl. She has her happy ending.
her character once said (about emmett) that she got "one half of her happy ending" wish she could've had a happy ending like nikki
she's gorgeous
I love the range of emotions she shows on her face after she says, "I was a little theatrical back then." Very well done
Damn. Rosalie had much more depth to her character than Bella. Her story was so great. It's a shame it's just shown in a flashback.
“I got my revenge on them!” My favorite line from her
This scene makes me happy knowing she gets to help raise Renesmee
"You'll be one tough little newborn" "Tough enough to take you on" and she fucking did!!
This is why I hate drunks and youths they do shit like this when they know what there doing even know they been drinking and sorry is not good for forgiveness
Me too I hate them when they do that messed up stuff that they have no business doing
It's kinda neat that Rosalie's dream is what Nikki's real life is now. She's married to another one of my all time fav actors and has a little baby. Sooo happy for her :)
Can we talk about the fact that minor character's like Rosalie, Alice ect.... are way more intresting that Bela and Edward ? I mean Alice and Rosalie are women who have really suffered ! There are strong. I don't think that it is the case of Bela.
Nikki Reed is gorgeous and her baby is so cute
So they give a random vampire an interesting backstory, some vampires even go thousands of years back, even more fascinating.
But nah, let's focus on a random human who has no redeeming qualities other than getting the hottest and most emo vampire to fall for her, for literally no reason.
Stephenie Meyer, you've made a mistake by turning interesting characters into a plot device to serve your self-insert tween porn.
南雲Haruya stfu and go back to your cave
😂😂😂
H677
Emo vampire! 🤣🤣🤣
I agree also, Knowing Rosalie’s story, Rosalie makes a more likable character than Bella. Rosalie wanted a family of her own and she didn’t mind getting old and “loosing her beauty”. Rosalie never wanted to be a Vampire. While Bella was afraid of getting old and “loosing her beauty” and that’s why she wanted to be a Vampire. (I know that Bella also wanted to be with Edward forever but that’s not the only reason she wanted to be a Vampire)
It's funny all of these people are vampires because they died a tragic death while human and bella is kinda spitting in their faces saying hey that looks like fun i would love to be a vampire idk why you guys look so sad. It's like wanting the last slice of pizza super bad but your sibling takes it and just throws it in the trash.
But her death was tragic too
"I don't hate you!..... I don't particularly like you." *MOOD*
Rosalie,esme & alice are my favorites ❤❤❤
Rosalie didn’t deserve to go through that while being human
Esme didn’t deserve to be abused physically & lose her baby &
Alice didn’t deserve for her family to think she was crazy bcuz she had visions ❤️🩹
Rosalie is so pretty 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
I kinda dislike the way Bella brushed off Rosalie’s story. “I understand that you can't have a normal life, but I want my vampire bf for eternity.” like? If I were in Bella’s shoes I would at least offer Rose some comfort. Bella just stood there, open-mouthed and whined about her boyfriend as usual. 🙄
Damn Rosalie's revenge was so awesome.
If rosalie wants grey hair she can always dye it
This got me lol
@@rondameravella2885 I think it is mentions that the only that change is their wound being healed but everything else stay the same so due wouldn’t stick
Its so hard to believe sometime that this woman is the same little bad ass girl from Thirteen. She played the hell outta that movie!!