Ex-Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi's Rajya Sabha nomination 4 months after retirement, raises questions
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2020
- Once a celebrated Chief Justice of India, many of his former colleagues and those within the legal fraternity question his wisdom of accepting a Rajya Sabha nomination within just 4 months of his retirement. However, he is not the first one to do so. Bisbo brings the event in context.
Twitter: @bisboworld
Scroll.in
Opposition lists five charges against CJI Dipak Misra as it moves impeachment motion, April 20, 2018
Ranjan Gogoi’s tenure as chief justice was marked by deafening silences on crucial issues, by Sruthisagar Yamunan, November 18 2019
Outlookindia.com
Ex-CJI Ranjan Gogoi Arrived With Messianic Aura But Left Behind A Legacy Scorched By Controversies, by Puneet Nicholas Yadav, December 2, 2019
Rediff.com
The troubling legacy of Ranjan Gogoi by Gautam Bhatia, December 31, 2019
The Indian Express
The Gogoi betrayal: Judges will not empower you, they are diminished men, by Pratap Bhanu Mehta, March 20, 2020
Times of India
Former Chief Justice Gogoi’s nomination to Rajya Sabha has cast doubt on the independence of India’s judiciary; Arghya Sengupta; Mar 21, 2020
Judicial independence threatened by stranglehold of a ‘lobby’ over it: Ranjan Gogoi, by Dhananjay Mahapatra and Diwakar, Mar 20, 2020
Gogoi compromised on judicial freedom; Mar 18, 2020
Govt defends RS berth for Gogoi, says Cong politicising judiciary; Mar 18, 2020
The Print
Those criticising Ranjan Gogoi nomination forgot he became CJI after being a dissenting judge; Hitesh Jain; Mar 19, 2020
Ranjan Gogoi goes to Rajya Sabha & what it says about 5 levels of honour judges post-retirement; 18 Mar 2020
The Wire
MP: India is Done With Whataboutery, My Lords! By Mahua Moitra, March 18, 2020
Ranjan Gogoi 'Doesn't Remember' the Electoral Bonds Issue in the Supreme Court, March 23, 2020
The Caravan
Sealed and Delivered, by Arshu John, February 1, 2020
Economic Times
Gogoi takes oath amid protests, walkout in Rajya Sabha; Rakesh Mohan Chaturvedi; Mar 20, 2020
Kurian Joseph hits out Gogoi for taking RS route; Samanwaya Rautray; Mar 20, 2020
At Rs 1,450 cr, BJP got 61% funding via Electoral Bonds before LS polls; Anubhuti Vishnoi; Jan 10, 2020
Mumbai Mirror
Till we care, all is not lost; Dushyant; Mar 20, 2020
• Rebellion at The Supre...
Such post retirement jobs of judges truly erodes our faith in the judiciary since they are the guardians of democracy. Such instances pose question on the controversial/ hot debate judgements even if these decisions were taken in the right spirits. Why cant govt. bring a law which says upon post retirement, judges should not take legislatures role for atleast 5-6yrs ? This would help us to harness their expertise as well as bring in more confidence in the system.
If they are the guardians of our democracy then they are a very weak one you know......
Be a good sheep and get rewarded
That is the most stupid argument I have come across, The only thing that can assure a sense of freedom and democratic rule is when you get to see that around yourself. And this idea of postponing the hiring of an intellectual is a loss for bureaucracy.
@@sujaykrishnanath82 You should see how SC was interfering on so many positive changes in the past, and no they are not weak more often than not they fuck the PMO ( and many other government bodies ) in so many ways.
Now a day every thing is for sale .it's sad but it's true 👍
Media- sold(4th pillar)
Judge- sold (3rd pillar)
Cbi,ED- under control (2nd pillar)
Govt- owned (1st pillar)
But "sab changa si"
@@lokeshmittal3071 Yeah well by that logic Watergate should not have been a scandal at all.
Also sold are
Activists
Intellectuals
NGOs
Cbi should be made independent
"You either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain."
-Harvey Dent
How true! And the way statues are tumbling one can be a villain even posthumously!
Best comment
Now the current sc judge SA Bobde riding super bike which is registered in the name of BJP leader's son...such a shame for democracy !!
Lol you jealous of him getting a Harley Davidson
What is wrong in riding Harley Davidson.
Is there any law in constitution that a judge who is also a citizen of India cannot ride Harley.
exactly ... that's why you should leave and find luck in other countries
@@abir95571 did i mention here that India is a bad country ?
@@arafataktar6871 We all know which country you want to be in and what country you like.
SEALED COVER !!!
I also wanna thanks bisbo for doing video on the first Assamese CJI of India
Love from Assam .
Welcome Soumya
Such unbiased views are nowhere to be seen in the entire Indian news outlets. It seems like facts are the only thing that matters to Bisbo. Please never stop making videos man.
PS - Make a video on present India-China border fight.
Such praise, thanks
@Prabhu Agrawal can u explain how?
nancy den don’t expect logic from those who throw profanities - if he had logic he would have led with that instead of name calling
Yes so true. I was surprised at the unbiased video.
Highly educated criminal. Shame on Gogoi!
News presented in one of the finest manners!!!! Waiting to see more from you
Thanks Anirudh
Your courage to take on such a sensational issue is appreciated. Keep going 👍
Watching this episode right after reading news ofcurrent CJI S.A Bobde sitting on a Harley owned by a Bjp leader's son. 😁😁😁😁😁
His Son is a Businessman.He can do what he want.
Nice one Bisbo....
But the Ayodhya issue is a settled matter and to be noted that the case is taken as a civil case (Property dispute) and the verdict is given on the basis of archeological surveys. And the Muslim brothers were given a greater amount of land. This was the best judgement anyone could get.
Great work Bisbo.....go ahead.
I request you to do a video on the mass religious conversions in Nagaland and atrocities of Missionaries. If this question is secular enough.
Right!
"Ye bik gayi hai, ye government" ......
Enjoyed the video, It reminds me of my childhood, though the characters were fictional then.
Well made videos and well gathered content.
You inspired me to start my own channel
Great to know. Good luck
@@BisboWorld Thank you! Hope to work with you soon :)
3:40 - 2016 Lok Sabha elections ? 🤔
Typo😕
I just came here to see if anyone noticed this mistake of LOK SABHA ELECTIONS😂😂
2014 tha typo ho gaya
@@ramkumarsuresh it said against Congress too. But bhakt madarchots ko toh har baat bjp ko hi target lagti hai. Bhosdiwalon congress ki tarah tum bhi desh ko bech rahe ho aur drma kar rahe ho.
Well said Bisbo , how our heroes have fallen !
Agreed to all except Rafael... If it's not in sealed cover, everyone would have known weapons are used in the fighter... Remember there was a attempt to steal it in Paris to get these information....
This channel is just too good👌
Thanks Aayush
Your drawing and animating is class and the best simply amazing!
Thank you so much 😀
Plus my favourite video was the pink ball video and the thai cave rescue you research is impressive and a lot of detail like the drawings
Democracy is sealed in a cover.
Your channel will go to the highest level of all the channels to the present ...
Thanks for your wishes Raj
Thank to bisbo for this well explained video🤗❤️👍
Congratulations you woke up in 2020, this is going on since 100s of years.
If this is wrong, than it shows how shady our constitution is, and need an improvement . But than again previous government did the same, so in the end the outcome is very important rather than how and what is been done .
Thank you Bisbo, please keep this quality content coming! You guys deserve at 1 lakh views but this tik tok and Instagram generation likes shit, not valuable information.
Welcome Kunal. Appreciate
ok boomer`
Bisbo u have the power to question and criticise the govt and it's decisions. U are amazing and more power to u❤❤🔥
Brilliant 💯, Once again Bisbo delivers !!!!!!
Thanks Sanjay!
Good one Bisbo!
great work Bisbo
Very informative video with good use of animations. And as always an unbiased view is what makes your channel better than several others.
Thank you very much Srinivas!
Bisbo..these are wonderful videos for competitive exams...thanks very much
You are most welcome Pavan. Never realised they could be of help in exams!
Well done. Great courage. Keep going ..
nice i never knew about this thanks bisbo
My pleasure 😊
Correction : Justice Krishna Iyer did not join politics post retirement, we was politician earlier who joined judiciary post leaving politics.
1. He became the first minister of law, justice, home, irrigation, power, prisons, social welfare and inland navigation in the first communist government in Kerala headed by E. M. S. Namboodiripad that came to power in 1957.
2.He was appointed a judge of the Kerala High Court in 1968. He was a member of the Law Commission from 1971 to 1973 where he drafted a comprehensive report, which would lead to the legal-aid movement in the country.[3] He was elevated as judge of the Supreme Court of India in 1973.
3.He retired as a judge on 14 November 1980. He stood for the nation's President in 1987, as the Opposition's candidate against R. Venkataraman, the ruling Congress's nominee who won.
So Justice Iyer remains the only SC Judge who earlier had a career in politics and later a career in judgeship.
Thank you sir
Kudos bro for speaking on a sensitive matter
Good topic bisbo 👌
2016 Lok Sabha Elections? It's 2019
Meant to be 2014
Such a wonderful content ❤️💕
Sooooper work bisbo
1st to watch and very happy
Gogoi is a shame to us, our democracy and specially for Assamese people who thought he really cares about them but instead he was just fulfilling his own political desires.
Keep up the good work!!
Thanks, will do Dr.!
Great work bisbo. Will be waiting for your next video.
Thanks Surya
One of the best YT channel. 1M soon
I just subscribed finding this channel informative!
You die a hero or live long enough to see yourself die as a villain.
Good one.
♥️💜💚Not only Judges but many beurocrats are also appointed after retirement especially by ACC ...such appointment are not HEALTHY
Bisbo will be soon banned it seems.. be careful guys..
Great job an eye opener for all.
We trust bisbo's Limerick.
Thanks Swapnil
@@BisboWorld hi man, i have been following your channel since long time. Some how you are not getting more number of views than you deserve.
Love ur video bisbo awsm 1 man .
Its good to see the reality on your channel, not many people are fearless like you to tell reality, hats off to you and also Dhruv Rather.
Dhriv Tatti dalla hai AAP ka video editing karta hai un ke liye
Dhruv tatti dalal hai
Well made video, good job 👍
Thank you Aman! 👍
Great video Bisbo👍👍
Thanks
keep the good work pal
Money money money...🎶🎶money money money.🎶🎶
Well information...
Thanks Hassan
Good job bisbo
This channel deserves atleast a million subscribers
Shame to have such person like Bloody Gogoi in judiciary...indian law is always questionable but why....because of currupt judges like gogoi...he sold his soul for money and position...
Thnx
Good one. Bisbo is better than all the news channel who are affiliated to one or the other parties. True journalism has died. Its all paid journalism now. U can do a video on paid journalism.
Lol
Worth thinking and analysing.
Yes sir
Massive video by Bisbo again.
u guys deserves atleast 1 million subscribers
Thanks Shajid
Sir,
A a small mistake- at 3:38 you mentioned "2016 Lok Sabha elections" but the Loksabha elections took place in 2014.
Also, I like your channel very much, very informative.
Yes Dr. it should be 2014. Thanks for pointing out
Your channel has more spines than the bureaucrats and the judiciary
but why do judges accept these government offers . Why can't they enjoy their retirement life? Are they influenced by the political power or money?
Amit, 65 is no age for a person to retire. Many are still at the peak of their wisdom
You are amazing. Wonderful video 😍❣️❤️❣️
Thanks Harsh
@@BisboWorld Thanks to you bisbo for this work.it is among best.
the best criminals are the most well-read.
Nice job
Thanks Abhi!
Gogoi as CJI was always suspicious
Very informative video... But in the video you have got the images of Justice Indira Banerjee and Justice Indu Malhotra wrong at 2:44... One has been described as the other... It needs to be interchanged..
Oh my, apologies
How about honey Trapped CJI?!
Arm twisted to give controversial judgements to appease his black mailers/ GOI
Are you saying, our judiciary was never independent ?
Now government with his fullll existence & public ..."struggle for existence"😀
Bisbo, please take proofreading a bit more seriously. There have already been a lot of typos in recent videos.
You are turning into a big channel and small mistakes like these can be very detrimental to your reputation.
Of course, sometimes mistakes happen. When they do, you must put up a comment with corrections and pin it .
Yes thanks, we do that in video description
2016 lok sabha elections?😂😂 there’s a mistake there.
2014
Which software you use for animation and how many people are there in your team ??
Adobe Photoshop & Animate. In the next few months we are going to put tutorials of how we make our video.
👏👏👏
Funny how people forget that in Supreme court judgement is not reached by single person, but by the bench on basis of numerical majority i.e. 3 judge bench - 2-1 or 5 judge bench 3-2 etc. RJB -Ayodhya Judgement was unanimous judgement by 5 judges. Bit disappointed with Bisbo Here for not researching more.
Also sealed cover practice is used to protect Privacy of Individual Litigant - especially in case of Alok Verma
In rafael case it was used so that sensitive information, about pricing which not only included price of aircraft but also additional equipment bought and fitted in the aircraft to give it more strategic advantage cannot be disclosed in public.
In Rafale case bench, we have physically shown and named all 3 judges, in Ayodhya we have given name of all 5 judges in footnote.
@@BisboWorld Doesnt really change anything. If a judge disagree's with the verdict reached by his brother judges, then he has all right to write a dissenting judgement. Like Justice Joseph wrote a separate judgement in Rafael case, which agreed with rational of overall judgement, but he gave his own reasons too.
Also Ayodhya Judgement could have created communal atmosphere, so the court handled it in a way that would not create any controversy.
looks like you’ve figured out the mantra to getting more hits, likes and comments.. hope you use this medium for conveying unbiased information in order to update the masses and NOT bite that bait of mere hits, likes and comments. Good Luck!
We strive for neutrality and will remain so.
@@BisboWorld your biased comments on lynching and article 370 show ur neutrality
please make a separate video on electoral bonds
Night is darkest just before dawn
Judiciary must keep a safe distance from executive and legislative worlds. This will help them work without partiality. At the verge of retirement ,the top bureacrats and judges seems to be more interested in clearing their way for transition to politics rather than working impartially.
This appointment looks like a reward from the political masters.....
make on ind vs china man, e are pleading you and i need a reply for this
Which app do you use to animate ?
2014 not 2016 lok sabha
No politics, just facts. Thanks for your videos. Given a thought to starting a Podcast ?!?1
Whom to believe nowadays and whom not to🤣🙏
What a disgrace.
There were no lok sabha elections held in 2016.
💚💜♥️SEAL cover are non transparent unhealthy trend . CJI Ranjan Gogoi seem to be influenced by Political alliances
Scary... They hv managed everyone who came in their way...😮
What a shame without knowing full facts persons are making videos & just like me people are watching because we all are interested in the controversial topics & always ready to deliver our judgement on the character of the person standing in front of us.
Yes I agree that post retirement job should not be given but if you do so so many tribunals & commissions will go vacant because of the criteria that they should have retired judge.So we must demand for cooling period for the jobs.
If you think judiciary is not independent & Ranjan Gogoi sir has been compromised then you should know the fact he didn’t taken a single penny as a Rajya sabha member.
He taken up the seat just to give the opinion of judiciary on the laws framed by the parliament.
Just think twice before you judge someone
Very good point made of cooling off period
Very nice video. But please correct a mistake. Justice krishna Iyer was politician/advocate first, only later he became a nominated judge in SC. He did not took post retirement. He is one of the greatest judges in India.
Ram Mandir always belonged to us (Hindus)
😂
@@faizansiddiqui2168 why are you laughing?
@@-SurajMondal- if u look closely he is crying also with fake laugh!
Bro but there should be independent judgements on the case and LK advani used it as a election tool u can see it in the polls before rath yatra 2 seats after rath yatra 80 seats
You don't have to proof everything! Sometimes silence is the best thing you can do!
To fight ba rule you will have to pick up the swords,this is not the 1st time such things happening very similar event happened in Congress time you are just a google away!
Jai Shri Ram 🙏
We want this video in bisbo hindi...
What about past govt appointing CJI in rajya sabha?
Nobody noticed his joke on puttimg 269 instead of 270
Make video on Galvan valley incident
♥️♥️♥️💕💕💕