Which Country's Voting System is Best? | Explained by Dhruv Rathee
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 02. 2019
- How could Modi win with 31% votes? How could Donald Trump win elections with 3 million less votes than Hillary Clinton? All this is possible because of the way voting systems are designed. Different countries have different ways of voting. I explain various ways leaders are elected across the world -
1. First Past the Post Voting
2. Instant Run-off Voting
3. Proportional Representation
4. Two round Voting
*------------------------
JOIN MY COURSE:
The CZcams Blueprint Course: academy.dhruvrathee.com/youtube
✏️ Time Management and Productivity Course : academy.dhruvrathee.com
Learn how to manage time and maximize productivity in my specialised online course.
🤖 Master ChatGPT - Full Course : academy.dhruvrathee.com/chatgpt
Learn to harness the power of ChatGPT effectively and transform your life!
Use GET20 for a straight up 20% discount!
---------------------------------------------------
LISTEN TO MY PODCAST:
🎧 My Spotify exclusive podcast. Learn about how India works, only on Maha Bharat with Dhruv Rathee: spoti.fi/3IhBW51
FOLLOW ME ON:
▶️ Main Channel: / dhruvrathee
🎦 Vlog Channel: / dhruvratheevlogs
🩳 Shorts Channel: / @drshorts
📸 Instagram: / dhruvrathee
🐦 Twitter: / dhruv_rathee
MY VIDEO TOPICS:
🗺 Geopolitics: • Geopolitics
📘 History: • History Education
🔬 Science: • Science
☠️ Mystery: • Mystery Videos
💰Finance: • Financial Education
🇮🇳 Indian Current Affairs: • Current Affairs (India)
🌍 International Current Affairs: • Current Affairs (World)
DOWNLOAD MY APP:
📱Android app: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
📱iOS App: apps.apple.com/ie/app/dhruv-r...
This video is made solely with the purpose of spreading awareness and educating the viewers. The information demonstrated and explained in the video are true to the best of the our team’s knowledge and research. Nevertheless, if any error is committed, the same was never intended to be and is absolutely unintentional. In the event of any inadvertent error, kindly email us at contact@dhruvrathee.com (mail subject : FEEDBACK) for necessary action, to resolve any error/dispute amicably.
Unbiased, qualitative and legit content.
I wish Indian media do the same, instead of barking like dogs on useless topics, polarizing people and mishandling the freedom of speech being granted to them under the constitution of India.
Thanks Dhruv Rathee
@@HoneyHoney-vx4wr bro do you know what's the job of a journalist? To ask the questions that a normal citizen won't get a chance to ask! And that's what dhruv is doing. He's asking the same questions as a journalist would.
Sadly, in the modi government the journalists aren't given the freedom to openly criticize govt actions or policies. That's why dhruv has to live overseas and shoot his videos or else they will threaten to kill him or harm his family. (as they did with abhishar Sharma)
Channels are pressured to not have journalists criticizing the govt. If the channels don't agree, their airing is stopped during peak hours or the bjp party members aren't sent to do a debate on the channel.
That's like dictatorship ruling. Best example is NDTV. But they still choose to speak freely about the problems and bjp doesn't send representatives to NDTV. That affects their business TRP.
All these communal disharmony between the majority and minorities is only going to badly effect small businesses.
The best leverage of this situation is to corporates as they function in a democratic manner..
This situation in our country makes rich get richer at a faster pace. Kudos to looters 😭♥️🇮🇳
I just dont understand why anyone who raises any question against the govt is linked to pakistan in any possible way. Pakistan is a failed state. When we are among the top 5 economies of the wrold, doesnt it make sense to compare with other developed countries rather than pakistan
ओ भाई dhruv rathee... तू महान हैं😰
अब एक बार कश्मीर आर्टिकल 370 और
कश्मीरी पंडित और fake secularism
पर video बनाओ plzz. ✌ दो महीने से बोल रहा yaar 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Unbiased 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@HoneyHoney-vx4wr Tu idar Kya Kar raha hai??? Yaha Logical or Progressive baate ho rahi hai. Ja Zee News dek jaha Gobar khaneka benefits aur Ram Mandir ki baat hoti hai. Bhakto ka vahi proper channel hai. Vo dekar tum aur bade Deshbhakt ban jaoge. Hume yaha Antinational vali baat karne do.
Bro make video on Cobrapost analysis plzz
Exactly
Yess same demand...
He has already done it
I feel, Australia has the best voting system(going by your explanation).
too complicate for our people to understand.
@@rahulagarwal841 All our people need to understand is that we have to vote by Ranking them in order of most preferred to least preferred.
Kya ranking and order. Thoda to dimag ko kasht do. Ek candidate bhi choose nahi kar sakte kya.
Are ek jo pasand ho usko vote karo. Baat khatam.
@@jagjeetsaini2436 bhai waha itni diversity nahi hai. Aur waha 85 lakh log rahte he aur yaha india me 14,000 lakh. Its not practical here.
@@rahulagarwal841 Upper house elections in India happen this way
I would like to add some details for the German system.
1.There is a 5 % threshold for parties. (But candidates of a a party with less than 5% can enter parlament if they win a constiuency with first past the post. This was the case in the 1990s with the Green party and Socialists)
2. There are levelling seats and overhang seats. They are meant to balance mismatches between First vote (first past the post vote or direct candidate) and Second Vote (party vote). To be honest noone really understands how that works exactly. But due to 7 different parties in the current parliament, there are getting more and more which means that parliament has more and more members. We ought to tackle that.
3 The problem with the vote for the party is, that you don't always know will sit in parliament in the end. Parties do say who is one the list, but if one of their 'big shots' doesn't make it( Eighter because they do not win their constiuency or the overall result is too bad) one of the elected backbenchers pulls back for whatever phony reason, and is replaced by the big shot.I find that quite frustrating.
Most party leaders run as a candidate in a consticueny and are no. 1 on the party list. Winning the constiuency in first past the post is simply just prestige.
Yes
Yes and it is because so that a party is able to gain majority than a coliation government full of 29 to 30 parties and which fall in two to three days really Germans have learned a lot from their dark past
Bro you should make a video on cobrapost. It's not getting media coverage.
true
Exactly
He has already made one.
true
@@AshishYadav-zk5bx he done when cobrapost done an operation against media houses .
Interesting video. Most of the people including me never thought about this. Thanks for making such kind of videos
ओ भाई dhruv rathee... तू महान हैं😰
अब एक बार कश्मीर आर्टिकल 370 और
कश्मीरी पंडित और fake secularism
पर video बनाओ plzz. ✌ दो महीने से बोल रहा yaar 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Deepali Sethi you 🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕
It has nothing else to thought about.
Look at all candidates, pick what you like and vote for him/her. Simple.
Hame bhi sabskribe karo, ham bhi dhruv ki tarah vedeo banate hai.
Àa
Nicely explained but at 1:26.. Akshay 35%,Salman 39%, Ranveer 16% and Hrithik 15%.. which comes down to 105%.. mathematically incorrect.. rest of the video is very informative.
no
He was just giving example, but I agree with you
Evm scam 😁😁😁
@@Storifiedyt and dhruv rathee is stupid he said bjp got 31% but he did not mention bjp har jagah election nhi ladi thi nda ladi thi aur NDA ka vote percentage 38(2014) and 45(2019) . bewakoof aadmi hai ye
Wow no one noticed this
Australia wala preference voting system . Was the best .
I also think so and agree with you. But there is one problem in India to implement the preferential system of voting and that is India's huge population. Australia's population is much lower compared to India. So, if preferential system of voting is applied in India, then it is not possible to manually calculate it. So, software based calculation will have to be made which might increase the chances of tampering or hacking. But of course, if that system is implemented properly with due due protection, that will be the best..
Yes, it is best.
Best hai
Even Ireland uses it.
It is an ideal system to conduct voting but it's realistically very difficult to implement at the scale and magnitude of Indian voters
It will be very difficult to explain rural voters from the most distant parts of our country the preferential voting system
And lastly the major problem is that the Election Commision in our country isn't independent of political influence whose best interest will be to keep the current system going
Big mistake of mine was to vote for Modi
I will not vote for Modi again
Edit : Me and My family never voted to BJP.. , I was jk.
We should vote most honest man on planet right now kejriwal
Are u fooling that u voted for Modi
Ya you will not vote to modiji because of triple talak has been banned 😂😂😂
@@pratiktagare4578 still bill doesn't pass and it will never
Kejriwal eat 2cr RS samosa 🤣🤣🤣🤣
You can be a very good teacher... Proper explanation, proper presentation, everything perfect 👍
Ys
Proper manipulation also all statement against BJP . For example his lesser of two bullshit
@@adityapratapsingh1036 shut up
BJP will definitely do EVM tampering to win the election, They have all the power and money to do so. We need another "Independence from this Fascist Regime
Proper explanation, proper representation and what not everything perfect, this implies he is already a very good teacher.....the question is wether we are very good learners or not? This election will tell😀
Each and every word in video given in std. 11th NCERT "Construction at work"
But I took Science stream. So.....
@@KD-hg4lz don't go on words understand what I mean to say
Construction 🤭
I took science mate
Bhai kya kare phir b India ka adha janata 7 pass b nhi rahenge ...sab seekhana padta hai
Extremely good summary of various voting systems! Thanks!
Quality rich content. I didn't know about these topics. 👍
Parth Mullick kaash high school me polity padhi hoti aapne (don’t get offended bro which ppl r likely to)
@@navi6030 exactly
@@navi6030 isme offend hone wali baat kya hai. Mai social studies me acha nh tha. So padhta bhi nhi tha to pata bhi nh mjhe kuch khaas.
@@navi6030 high school me only indian system ke baare me batate hai.. dhruv has covered other county system also
@@tarang926 I agree but not completely they usually or you can say every aspect of our political system is being compared with US and England. You can also see israel, Zimbabwe and few other countries being compared at some point
*COBRAPOST*
Right
😂😂👍👌
I will make it :)
@@dhruvrathee ok bro title aur front aisa dalna ki log video ko dekhte hi open kre
@@dhruvrathee Thank you so much..
Very well explained and presented. Getting hooked on to your videos for some easy to consume knowledge and thought provoking facts. Well done Dhruv!
Thanks for explaining FTPT & PR through your entertaining example. The ming boggling examples in ncert make things more difficult than simple. Tysm
Akshya - 35%
Salman-39%
Ranveer-16%
Hrithik-15%
........................
Total =105%of 100%...
Wow! What a calculation bro...
Kki khi 😂😂
@@dipratnapatil6632.. haha... gahrai may kho mat jana.....youtubers jante hai ki kaise subscribers badhaya jaye
Like our election commission system and governor giving oath basis of that kind of percentage
@Shiba prasad broo gd one 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣😂🤣😂👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👍👍👍😂😂😂🤣
This 5% r those people who r already dead lekin party wale unka proxy vote Avi v dalte h 🤣😜
😡 NO MORE NAMO 😡
I WILL NOT DO SAME MISTAKE AGAIN 😡
Exactly
I regret that I voted for feku
Isme bhi bjp n?waaaah bosdiwalo waaaaaaaaaaaah🤪🤪 Jb se desh aazad hua hai tab se Yahi chl rha h voting system ab isme kaise Bjp ka galti hai be??
Yess ❤️
Anil parmar sir.
Chemistry wale?
Correct me if u disagree with me.
Actaully me hota kya hai ke hamare ek MP ko hame chunnna hota hai ,to us time voting ke waqt waha 15 se 20 candidates khade hote hai aur jab result aata hai to hame pata chalta hai ke
100 me se 18 vote A ko mile 12 vote B ko mile aur baki sabhi candidates ko 10 se kam vote mile.
To the point is that ke 100 me se 18 votes lane wala candidate waha ka MP banjata hai, jab ke proportinately 82% logon ne use vote hi nahi.
Solution: ek tarika hai mere nazar me ( agr is pe vichar kiya jaye to)
Wo tarika ye hai ke 2 stage voting system
Jahan par 1st stage me upar wale results hame milenge. Aur uske baad jo 2nd STAGE hoga usme ham top 3 candidates ko hi allow karenge.
Fir janta ko un tino me se kisi ek ko chunna hoga. Aur us tarha fair MP select hoga.
Please dhruv sir agar aap ye padh rahe ho to reply kijiye please🙏
you are right . this kind of system should also be applied in upsc examination too. there should be a representation of millions who scored lesser marks than those who qualified.
Finally it seems you've got someone to do the animation for you.
Alalal
P
It's brut india
and its good
Brut india
@@Stophurtingmelol my fellow memlord
Great Video. You should do more informative videos like this.
तेरा बाप मेरा खर्च चला रहा है
तू मर मैं क्यु मरूँगा
बात करने की अक्ल नहीं और मुझे समझा रहा है
@@SonuHembrom
तेरा बाप मेरा खर्च चला रहा है
तू मर मैं क्यु मरूँगा
बात करने की अक्ल नहीं और मुझे समझ रहा है
@@navneetkumar3521
tera baap hoga lodu
Aur tume kya problem hai Maire copy paste se tera paper use ho rha hai
Sar ghum gya Mera to😂😂
Thx for the video bhai, gives a good insight into the different voting systems used in democracies. Mann ki baat boldi bhai.
Let's make trending 1st👌👌👌👌👌👌
Aise hi trending me nhi ayega😹har jagah share maro tb hi ayega
i
top India mixture
Yeh video trending pe nahi aayega
@@mamunlxr2386 mujhe bhi ye hi lgta ye video election ka mahol tb dalna chayie tha
@@HoneyHoney-vx4wr iss baat me fact he mene bhi dekha he..
Instant run-off voting system is the best... It is also used in Delhi Bar Association's elections. But there is an addition. Anybody who gets less than 20% of 1st preference votes is not considered for next round. For example, all other candidates get diverse voting from 1st preference to last preference. But Hrithik gets 15% first preference votes and most of the 2nd preference votes. Akshay has only 10% first preference votes. So, normally only Akshay would be eliminated, and Hrithik's score would be the highest. But with this addition, Akshay and Hrithik are both eliminated because their first preference votes are less than 20%, and hence their second preference votes would go to other candidates. I think that this is really good system.
I fully agree
It is best
Love Australia's voting system 3:07
Two parties, boring
Australian system is best but it probably won't work in india for now because of the education level of masses .
Thank you for making such type of videos..please keep making such type of videos and keep us learning. You are doing a great job. I am actually your new subscriber and in this time I learn many new things. Thank you for that. You have all our support!
i support dhruv
Ye brut. Kya hai
You describe us NCRT class11 political science text book..😂😂😂😂
Yes because you have forgotten
Sahi bola😜😆😆
@@omprakashratre4647 FORGOT , E RELATING TO EDUCATION
rituraj boro sahi bola bhai
Bhai very good
Parliament me bill pass karao ispe..preference base pe ho voting
A wonderful explainer...Thank you so much sir...It has just clarified my concept brilliantly.... I feel pleased to have you indirectly as one of my teachers..whose concept is so touching...
Manmohan Singh became pm with 28.55 percent
So whats your point ?
Wo system ke baare mein baat kar raha hai kisi ke party ka nahi
@@maryamkidwai2543 well said
@@maryamkidwai2543 intro dekh le bhai sabse pehle he usne aakey modi ki baat ki! Kyu? Aur bhi example rakh sakta tha :)
@@maryamkidwai2543 to bhai usme modi ka naam lene ki kya baat thi
India should hace Proportional Representation system.....
BSP have 4% vote share but not even single seat in lokshabha
While Shivsena have less than 2% vote share with 18 seats in loksabha....
Its clearly a MOB DEMOCRACY.....majoritian dictetership
Taki or wo murti ban wa paye apni
No bro
BSP contested at lot of seats that's why they have high vote share. Shiv Sena contested at few seats that's why they have less percent.
@@sumitroy3483 Lol....then what about BjP 31%vote share but 55% seat in loksabha......
This electoral system does not represent will of majaority 69% voted against government ......thats why we face large scale riots... Violence....
"""Bharat band and fast upto death"""
Because majority 69% do not trust government representative.....
@@democraticindian6772 do you have any idea how hard it is to win electorally in India?? If it was simply based on popular vote, then every time UP & Bihar based party will win national elections as together they comprise almost 1/4 th of Indian population).
I think we can elect our MPs and MLAs using Instant Runoff method, I think it's a great method and just want to know why are we not thinking towards implementing it in our country.
Thanks a lot for enhancing our knowledge.
U.S. elections are unique, since it is not based on the principle of pure democracy, it is a republic.
Kudos to Dhruv for his brilliant presentation on psephological systems. Keep up the show. Best wishes. :-)
what🤦♂️
Ys
Very informative and timely video...great job keep it up!!
Bro plzz talk about indian air force what happened plzz tell?
My vote for *SRK* 😂😂😂
kkkkkkiran
Shahrukh Khan should be ashamed of himself, his PR team is making fake accounts of so many well-known and popular twitter accounts and than spreading propoganda through those fake accounts that how he donated 15 crore to Pulwama martyrs which is totally fake and a complete lie. Shame on him, what's the point of being rich, when he have to spread fake news through his PR agency? But one good thing came out of this that now he have no choice but to really donate 15 crores. 😏
@@everythingisawesome2903 mahendra Sing how much gave??
@@everythingisawesome2903 fake news Ko fake news se ans diya...haters ne fake Pak donation news spread Ko thi uska kya?
Akshay 35% + Salman 39% + Ranveer 16% + Hrithik 15% = 105%
Lol
are bhai bat ko samjo,calculation ke chhakr me q pd rhe ho
Thanks, very helpful.
Bhai haters Akshay k nhi salmon bhai k hai 😂😂😂
Support from signatures mash team to your wonderful work! 💝
One of the best videos so far. Caught my complete attention for almost 10 mins..
Explanation was on point. Keep it up brother!👍🙏🙌
जैसे राष्ट्रपति का चुनाव होता है, prefential system is good, thanks,love n blessings for this debate Dost Dhruv...
Following are the facts about winning election with lower percentage of votes in first past the post voting method
1. Population in each constituency is different.
2. Number of voters casting their votes on election day in each constituency and on each booth.
3. Percentage of voting is higher in losing party's constituencies compared to percentage of voting in winning party's constituencies.
Best video ever...., keep spreading knowledge wd us
Poora video se pehle hi comment wah 👏👏
@@sanat7171 lol
India should hace Proportional Representation system.....
BSP have 4% vote share but not even single seat in lokshabha
While Shivsena have less than 2% vote share with 18 seats in loksabha....
Its clearly a MOB DEMOCRACY.....majoritian dictetership
😂😂😂
You Provide Quality typ content
Best period of Indian economy par ek vidoe
That's why we called- सारे जहां से अच्छा हिंदुस्तान हमारा हमारा.........।।।💕🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Dhruv correct the calculations.Your example of film stars adds upto 105%
Good observation bro. Nobody realized it.
5% videshi log hai
Anything possible with EVM.
Like his lies
@Ron Swansong MAGGOT FR LYF!!!
I think this video is
one of its kind!
Gyan chakshu khul gaye!!
Bravo!!👍👍
Sir, thanks for this video.
Really required concept to be understood.
I am curious to know how did you get the information about the vote percentage of parties in India and America? Please respond to my query.
I am also curious to know that?
Cobrapost analysis...plxz
I watched this video on Brut channel 3 days back. A great explanation which makes people think how and who to vote. I am waiting for your take on cobrapost 'operation karoke'. Can we expect you will make a video on it??
Here again, we are in a dilemma when it comes to the Delhi Election.
Can a Technology like a Block chain help us in creating a Better voting system?
If yes, then is it realistically possible to implement it in a country like India?
You should make a video on A.P.I party and its policy
Appreciable ,apart from politics, it's good to see that ,Dhruv you also make informative videos...
you are doing a good job.. keep it this way..
What will you do in case of two candidates getting the same fewest votes? Who will you eliminate first?
Make a video on best type of government. That helps a lot.
CZcams India is hungry for creators like him. Well done Dhruv 👍.
U missed a point, include this in future..
A County in Switzerland has best voting system for a democracy and it's called true democracy..
Its direct democracy as like ancient Greece . It also comes with disadvantages , cannot be termed as best as a whole .
@@Abhinavsingh-250as Still better than what we have here in India. After all, the Greeks already saw the disadvantageous.
Its not effective in large democracies like india where literacy rate isn't high
Arey pagla gaya hai Kya? The population I of Switzerland is not even the population of West Bengal. And apart from that we have 500+ languages & ethnic tribes..
First elect the local minister having highest number of votes. Then, the party having highest number of constituencies can choose the chief minister of that state. Then the party having highest number of chief ministers can choose the prime minister of country.
Excellent videos.. fantastic bro.. keep it up.. but slow speed I watched at 1.5xor 1.25x
Hame to aadat ho gyi h sari videos 2x me dekhne ki
Which is the best country of South Asia? Please make video on this topic.
very informative.. keep up the good work.. from Adelaide Australia. What you said is all true regrading Australian voting system..
Why all the teachers are not like you? Very good explanation
Bro please answer this:---
Why our government waste money on construction of
statue?
To pay respect to those who deserve it
To divert our attention from main issues
@@rohangupta5006 which is ???
@@ykd0011 45 year high unemployment, falling GDP, negative growth rate in manufacturing sector etc
@@rohangupta5006 to usme gov kya kar sakti he.
Congrats dhruv bhai
Your subscribers increasing rapidly
Means Andhbhakti is decreasing
I have been waiting for this topic for so long.
Thanks Dhruv for giving such a beautiful and thought provoking insight on various voting systems.
Along with appropriate voting systems, based on some criteria, candidates should also be allocated money and publicity space.
Otherwise jiski media uske bol, baki candidates/parties ka public naam bhi nahi janegi, let alone their past achievements and manifestoes
Go and read a good book then, u r waiting for this guy to use theories and concepts to prove his point?
He didn't prove anything.....He just explained how different voting systems work.....
Hinduo ki maa c**d di Pakistan ne😂😂😂😂
You seems idiot to me
Thanks. This was really informative!
We want a 2nd part of this video with a list of countries and their electoral system
Respect
Admiration
Inspiration
That's what I feel whenever I see your videos.
@@PinklinqMobiTech Most of the facts mentioned in his videos (90-95%) are correct ✔️.
His videos are a useful source of reference.
@@PinklinqMobiTech
How could news and facts inspire somebody. I'm basically impressed by his speaking skills and order of presenting the facts.
An introvert can learn to speak up from him.
Kabhi facts ko cross check bhi karna.... Bariki se... Sab khatam ho jaega
Hey Dhruv,can u make a video on the problems of Indian education system?
Search soch channel he described better in video
He is a problem of our education system so someone else should do it
@Nihal Raoy?
superb explanation brother!!
System of proportional representation by means of single transferable vote.
President of India
Rajyasabha
And some committee of L.S
Use such system.
Instant-runoff system ,which is used in Australia is the best way of representative democracy.
Cobrapost reaction
हमारे भारत का वोटिंग सिस्टम सबसे ज्यादा बेहतरीन है
What is form 26? Can we view the details entered by a candidate before contesting for elections. If it is not accessible for the public or press, who has the rights to view the details of a form 26? Do they carry out a background check on all the details? Please explain.
i think germany's system will do great...mix of first past the post and proportional representation
I am from Nepal and we got the same system like Germans do. But, when intentions are corrupted what can you expect?
Instant-Runoff is best in my opinion.
I think "Instant runoff voting system" is the best.
Good job👍 .... please make more videos about election process in other countries.
Australian one sounds good
Thank you bhai!
And yes..you r getting smarter and smarter day by day...😋
Germany's mixture voting system is more democratic i feel. In india its practically not possible population being one of the factor, we have preference voting system for President's elections though.
I would like to know your analysis on Sharada scam, National herald, Nirav Modi pnb scam. That will boost your unbiased reporting
I wasn't able to understand anything.
It went straight above my head
You underestimate yourself. Watch once more or twice, you'll get every bit of it.
Hello dhruv!
I think INSTANT-RUNOFF voting system is the best.. is system se real democracy highlight hogi
Too interesting video, really i was not aware of this...
Its really grt info...
Can you make a video about politics in india? What is seats? And all basic stuff to have a brief idea about it .
Thank you sir.
Lots of love
Fawad Khan 35%
Fahad mustafa 39%
Faisal qureshi 19%
Ahsan Khan 12%
Wow what a calculation
A very knowledgeable video. Thank you Dhruv. It was completely new topic for me.
Great information, thank you so much for the video. Looking forward for a video on different educational system around the world.
Gulaam hat chal indian voting system makes it a biggest democracy in the world