Hey All! The study/annotated score used in this video will be available for as low as $1 a month on my Patreon! Hope to see you there! www.patreon.com/naetemusic
You should play the sections you’re commenting on! Would make this much easier to comprehend for noobs like me (as it stands, I’d almost rather just read your words so I can listen to the section at the same time). I am all for a second or third part! It would be fantastic to finally see somebody do a song-by-song analysis of SMiLE, especially focusing on how the different songs and modules interconnect like a 3-dimensional sonic jigsaw puzzle lol. Bonus points to discuss the songs in order of when they were written/recorded so we can get a better idea of Brian’s musical trajectory during that period.
You have done a great job with this video and it is super understandable for everyone! Good job, mate. Bloody love this track and you have given me a further appreciation for it.
Thanks for the video! I just want to say thank you Naete for your amazing content. I’m pretty young and have been a Beach Boys and Brian Wilson fan for a while and ever since I saw your Smile video I have watched most(if not all)of your videos and they are what got me listening to classical music and have sparked my interest in learning music theory(something that I have previously abhorred)and learn how to compose music myself, in fact I have recently started work on my own music more, and soon I’m planning to actually release it, and I probably wouldn’t have ever done any of that if it wasn’t for you, so thanks for all the amazing content and keep up the good work!
First, thanks for all your Beach Boys coverage. One correction: @ 4:30 in, where you’re working with the horn call & bass line in bars 2 & 3, the French horn notes should be named in concert pitch [E, B & A, respectively] rather than in the up-a-5th transpositions found in the “score”.
What made you decide to notate the song in E major rather than A? The B major feels more like a secondary dominant to me, the F#m more of a sixth, etc. Though at the end, when those “god only knows what I’d be…” counter melodies alternate between D and D#, the D does sound like a flat 7.
1. The official score is notated in the key of E but more importantly 2. Its quite clear to the ear that the opening stanza is in E, but as I mentioned in thee video your ears are deceived quite a bit throughout the piece because of the use of inversions
Hey All! The study/annotated score used in this video will be available for as low as $1 a month on my Patreon! Hope to see you there! www.patreon.com/naetemusic
His understanding of harmony is just fucking unmatched its untouchable
100% agree.
God Only Knows what music would be without him. Such a talent, Love You Forever Brian
You should play the sections you’re commenting on! Would make this much easier to comprehend for noobs like me (as it stands, I’d almost rather just read your words so I can listen to the section at the same time). I am all for a second or third part! It would be fantastic to finally see somebody do a song-by-song analysis of SMiLE, especially focusing on how the different songs and modules interconnect like a 3-dimensional sonic jigsaw puzzle lol. Bonus points to discuss the songs in order of when they were written/recorded so we can get a better idea of Brian’s musical trajectory during that period.
Comment to make this a 2 or 3 part series.
Yes please
Been waiting for this one! great job!
Possibly the greatest song of all time. Certainly one of the most moving. Makes me cry, every listen.
I would love to see more in this series!!!!
Definitely in the works! Thank you for watching!
You have done a great job with this video and it is super understandable for everyone! Good job, mate. Bloody love this track and you have given me a further appreciation for it.
Thanks for the video! I just want to say thank you Naete for your amazing content. I’m pretty young and have been a Beach Boys and Brian Wilson fan for a while and ever since I saw your Smile video I have watched most(if not all)of your videos and they are what got me listening to classical music and have sparked my interest in learning music theory(something that I have previously abhorred)and learn how to compose music myself, in fact I have recently started work on my own music more, and soon I’m planning to actually release it, and I probably wouldn’t have ever done any of that if it wasn’t for you, so thanks for all the amazing content and keep up the good work!
This comment means so much to me. I pray for the highest success in all your endeavors and am glad beyond belief this channel played a part in it
A recording of Sruf’s up (1967 smile version) would be legendary!.
I love your channel. You do a great job. Here is a suggestion of an artist you could talked about : Elliott Smith
Wonderful. I would enjoy hearing your take on the BBs "Shortenin' Bread". (The good unreleased version from the Adult/Child album)
The one and only
Very helpful
Glad it helped further your understanding!!
@@NAETEMUSIC I like surfer girl
First, thanks for all your Beach Boys coverage. One correction: @ 4:30 in, where you’re working with the horn call & bass line in bars 2 & 3, the French horn notes should be named in concert pitch [E, B & A, respectively] rather than in the up-a-5th transpositions found in the “score”.
What made you decide to notate the song in E major rather than A? The B major feels more like a secondary dominant to me, the F#m more of a sixth, etc. Though at the end, when those “god only knows what I’d be…” counter melodies alternate between D and D#, the D does sound like a flat 7.
1. The official score is notated in the key of E but more importantly
2. Its quite clear to the ear that the opening stanza is in E, but as I mentioned in thee video your ears are deceived quite a bit throughout the piece because of the use of inversions
Brian Wilson tribute- God Only Knows (vocals by Jon Anderson) czcams.com/video/NghKIniP7yI/video.html
Don't forget Sondheim, Bacharach, Lloyd-Webber, etc.
Til I die?
very interesting analysis SPOILED for me by the headache inducing spinning background - so unnecessary and distracting, what a pity.
Comment to make this a 2 or 3 part series.