北螳螂拳-十二字訣(一) Seven-Star Mantis-The 12 Keywords Theory (Part1)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 6. 09. 2024
  • 華藝精武-李俊森師父, 黃志恆教練
    CWS-CMA - Master Li Chun Sam, Instructor Wong Chi Hang
    Thanks for watching and comment. We have to mention that, this video is just explained keywords theory, which is not the complete idea of the Mantis KungFu, The Praying Mantis Boxing was created a kind of complete style KungFu for the real situation.
    The founders of Northern Praying Mantis Inspired by the fighting movements of the mantis, came to develop 12 keywords theory , and merged the boxing skills of the 17 schools previously learnt by him , 8 kinds of major footwork of apes(monkeys) into the techniques, also summarizing the techniques of seven long-range and eight short-range, including eight “strong” techniques and twelve “soft “ techniques, as well as ight weakness points of human body which can be strike and what are the eight weakness points can not be strike. Finally, the style was very complete with advancing as well as retreating-evading techniques, such as dodge, earn, jump and change the situation, and thus created the Praying- Mantis KungFu preliminarily.
    -------------------------------------
    更多影片連結:
    北螳螂拳系-白猿出洞 Northern Praying Mantis Series-White Ape Exits The Cave
    • 北螳螂拳系-白猿出洞 Northern Pr...
    【課堂講解及應用節錄】北螳螂拳系-四路奔打 Northern Praying Mantis Series-Four Directional Strike[lesson excerpt]
    • 華藝精武【課堂講解及應用節錄】北螳螂拳系-四...
    【課堂講解及應用節錄】 北螳螂拳系-插捶拳 Northern Praying Mantis Series - Cha Chui Quan
    • 華藝精武【課堂講解及應用節錄】 北螳螂拳系-...
    【課堂講解及應用節錄】 北螳螂拳系-七手拳 Application of Northern Praying Mantis-Qi Shou Quan (lesson excerpt)
    • 華藝精武-【課堂講解及應用節錄】 北螳螂拳系...
    -----------------------------------------------------
    歡迎到本會網站,了解更多課程資訊:
    Website: www.cws-cma.com
    FB page: / sfcsli
    Instagram: / cws_cma_kungfu
    WhatsApp: 852-98438310

Komentáře • 117

  • @user-le8wl6lk2j
    @user-le8wl6lk2j Před 8 dny +1

    有用❤多謝師傅👍👍👍

  • @user-ke7nx8hl1b
    @user-ke7nx8hl1b Před 2 lety +9

    🙏李俊森師父很有台型兼解說清晰易明…
    本身又身體力行…且功力深厚有戰鬥力👍

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +2

      多謝欣賞及支持!

    • @user-ke7nx8hl1b
      @user-ke7nx8hl1b Před 2 lety

      佩服🙏🙏🙏

    • @pokuenkwan7278
      @pokuenkwan7278 Před 2 lety +3

      講得好好,不過打唔打得就,得啖笑。

    • @user-ke7nx8hl1b
      @user-ke7nx8hl1b Před 2 lety +1

      冠軍都有另一個冠軍
      你得啖笑吖?應該係總冠軍果個👍💯
      聽得出…

    • @alfredleung3647
      @alfredleung3647 Před rokem +1

      @@pokuenkwan7278 對,像武打明星一樣。

  • @ryantsang1103
    @ryantsang1103 Před 2 lety +5

    Thank you so much

  • @shulungliu9929
    @shulungliu9929 Před 2 lety +5

    好棒的解說!

  • @thomasli2561
    @thomasli2561 Před 2 lety +4

    Thank you very much. Excellent video.

  • @rightbsword708
    @rightbsword708 Před 2 lety +5

    百人有百解,總有知音人👍👍我最鍾意睇呢啲文字教學法,如李師傅願分享埋洪拳十二橋就好多謝😀

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +3

      多謝收看及支持!我們正準備分享洪拳的十二支橋,敬請留意,謝謝😊

  • @ChineseWrestlingCeKungFu
    @ChineseWrestlingCeKungFu Před 2 lety +5

    Great job!!!

  • @adminnoba5981
    @adminnoba5981 Před 2 lety +4

    Magnificent!!!! Thank you so much!!!

  • @synbee6282
    @synbee6282 Před 2 lety +2

    Very good 👍

  • @williamc9578
    @williamc9578 Před 2 lety +2

    這係對傳統拳擊嘅各種類型(螳螂)技術嘅演示同解釋。 在實戰或拳擊比賽中,情況不會如此,但技術元素仍然適用。 戰鬥唔係練習固定序列嘅固定模式。 速度,力量,閱讀對手嘅動作(擂臺經驗),以及規則都需要考慮在內。 但是,憑藉訓練有素的技術,再加上速度和力量,絕對比打王八拳優越。

  • @dergsx1
    @dergsx1 Před 2 lety +2

    以前學過七星,謝謝老師的示範與講解🙂受益良多。感謝老師!

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +1

      多謝收看及留言😊

  • @alejandrogallardopavez
    @alejandrogallardopavez Před 2 lety +2

    Oss máster ...namaste..muy bueno...excelente

  • @tc47101
    @tc47101 Před 2 lety +2

    Rất hay 😄😄😄👍

  • @zhanyiwong9722
    @zhanyiwong9722 Před 2 lety +5

    好影片!某受益良多!

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety

      多謝收看及欣賞😊

  • @HabitHero4649
    @HabitHero4649 Před rokem

    永遠に見れるぐらい面白い

  • @anthonyperry5233
    @anthonyperry5233 Před 2 lety +3

    教得幾好喎

  • @KeytoKungFu
    @KeytoKungFu Před 2 lety +3

    Very good video. I do not speak Cantonese but its important to say that Gou Lau Cai has not to come nessecarily with a punch afterwards. Sometimes it happens in forms, sometimes not. Sometimes a performance of a form is just done incorrect. Often quan pu give an answer. Lets take Beng Bu Quan as an example. In the beginning of the second road there is a Gou Lau Cai. But WITHOUT a straight punch afterwards. 14 of 15 quan pu we work with say this. But people got so used to do the punch after the gou lau cai that they do it all the time in forms. Its important to see the difference between the Quan Pu entry "gou lau cai" and "gou lau cai tong chui". If there is done a straight punch afterwards in the form beng bu quan the follow up technique "fan che shi" cannot be done cause of a violation of the hand method. (there will be wrong hand to hand contacts) Furthermore Gou Lau Cai is a different technique than the technique "double sealing hands". Sorry for spamming here on your CZcams account but its just so interesting and it burned on my heart for some time.

    • @hemispace641
      @hemispace641 Před 2 lety +1

      You're not Spamming the channel. You have a very interesting question here:
      2nd Road of Beng Bu. How do you perform it? Option #1 or #2 below:
      1. Tiao sao, Pek Chui, Fan Che
      2. Tiao Sao, Pek Chui, Choi Sam Sau, Fan Che
      3. Neither
      I'm sure neither one is "incorrect". Just exploring your variation of these particular techniques. Nobody wrong here, except possibly me.

    • @KeytoKungFu
      @KeytoKungFu Před 2 lety

      @@hemispace641 Hey there, could you write the technique names in mandarin?

    • @hemispace641
      @hemispace641 Před 2 lety +1

      @@KeytoKungFu My humblest apologies. I speak neither Mandarin or Cantonese, but I will try:
      1. 右抅摟採手, 跨虎番車式, 登山左揷掌
      2. 右抅摟採手, 登山左揷掌
      3. 皆不

  • @barrybostain623
    @barrybostain623 Před 2 měsíci

    When you strike to opponents neck with the hook, which fingers do you concentrate on?

  • @user-vv7sj2nu2f
    @user-vv7sj2nu2f Před 2 lety +3

    你的螳螂拳很厲害我有自學螳螂拳以你的影片的打法我學會一些

  • @joechoi3661
    @joechoi3661 Před rokem

    好正!謝謝!

  • @quarnrules
    @quarnrules Před 2 lety +3

    Marvelous

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety

      Thanks for watching and comment

  • @danielpileci7321
    @danielpileci7321 Před 9 měsíci

    Exelent,sifu,!

  • @kampingchan1073
    @kampingchan1073 Před 4 měsíci +1

    師傅講解得好清楚,人帥氣,如果50幾歲跟你學仲老唔老?

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 4 měsíci

      多謝收看,當然唔會啦

  • @constantinestone5483
    @constantinestone5483 Před rokem

    ,thank you .

  • @wengchunwingchun398
    @wengchunwingchun398 Před 2 lety +4

    👏👏💪💪💪

  • @santarosajames9540
    @santarosajames9540 Před 2 lety +1

    Muy bueno..me gustaría un subtitulada en español.. desde Argentina 🇦🇷 gracias 🌊

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety

      Thank you for watching and comment! Could you try to use English subtitles in this video to translate Spanish?

    • @santarosajames9540
      @santarosajames9540 Před 2 lety

      Si..se traduce al Español los comentarios..a mí me gustaría ver un subtitulado en el transcurso del vídeo.. para entender cada cosa que dices...la explicación de los movimientos...si se puede hacer? igual gracias por contestar..te saludo desde Mar del Plata 🌊 Argentina 🇦🇷🌬️

  • @user-je1xu3wq4h
    @user-je1xu3wq4h Před 2 lety +2

    好功夫💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    我就要決定自己的路 讓我修練兩天

  • @AnaClaudia-xu5si
    @AnaClaudia-xu5si Před rokem

    Gratidão

  • @ecnivmarng7163
    @ecnivmarng7163 Před 2 lety +6

    要同現武嘅連環直捶鬥快, 不過多數唔夠快,佢隻手一定已經收咗,另一隻又已經伸出來打你。呢種技術除非用喺自衛術,否則唔得

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +6

      多謝收看及留言,其實出拳的快、慢,是無分現代或古代,試想下這個問題就連一般人都會想,又點會先賢沒有考慮到呢?十二字訣未完,請留意下一節,自有分曉。

    • @ecnivmarng7163
      @ecnivmarng7163 Před 2 lety +4

      @@cwscma多謝指教!請體諒小弟的意見。其實我一早欣賞到閣下之書籍與videos了。多謝!

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    我昨天開始有少少確認 電話有問題
    怎麼了 激動嗎兄弟 我是一個非常警覺的人 還不出來打一打我 就不夠厚道了

  • @user-qd7oj4ep2b
    @user-qd7oj4ep2b Před 2 lety +2

    我都想學,

  • @markwong4266
    @markwong4266 Před 2 lety

    You know so many styles.....what lineage are you under Jing Mo in HK? Even your CLF does not look familiar with our CLF lineages.

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +3

      Thanks for watching! My Sifu is Master Lam Wing Kit, and my lineages of Eagle Claw, Tai Chi is from Master Cheung Chun Ting, Northern Mantis is from Master Chiu Chi Man, Hung Kuen is from Master Hong Hoi, Lui Hap BaT Fat is from Master Cheung Cheung Ting and Master Chan Jik Jan..., I have become a member of Jing Mo HK since about 1983-1984. We are not under Jing Mo HK, we are just following the spirit of ChinWoo to learn, practice and research KungFu.

  • @user-fo4wl3nt1k
    @user-fo4wl3nt1k Před 2 lety +5

    唔錯,表演得幾好,可以考慮拍戲。

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +1

      多謝留言及收看。

    • @alfredleung3647
      @alfredleung3647 Před 2 lety +1

      @Sue Mui @對,理論與實際完成兩回事,一山還有一山高,對手永遠不是想像中那麼簡單。太極拳百幾式,名家如楊露禪、吳鑑泉等前輩都要窮終生去鑽研。

  • @user-sp3yp2eb4y
    @user-sp3yp2eb4y Před 2 lety +1

    看來很不錯,對決散打或搏擊不知如何?

    • @user-zm3kx1fb2r
      @user-zm3kx1fb2r Před 2 lety

      散打搏擊來跟槍對決也不知如何

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +13

      多謝收看!其實我們只是分享先賢祖師留給我們的智慧和經驗,客觀來講,散手及博擊運動和現實應用需要考慮的情況不同,而古代所講究的是以實際情況作考慮;能夠流傳至今的傳統武術及其經典套路,其實便是把他們的心得和想法,以套路和拳經等方式記載下來,簡單來說散手就如文字,每字均有其多於一種的作用及意思,而文章及書籍就是套路。
      我們不能只靠文字便能明白整篇文章的意思,所以有閱讀和理解,隨了要知道每一字的意義和用法,更要知道看前文後理,才能明白文章想表達什麼;如「自」字,可以自己、自然、自從⋯,至於點解就要看放在那裏了!而套路是由散招組成,先賢以自己的戰術和心得來篇成,因此他們就象經典典籍般,我們可以從中得到很大裨益和啓發性。不過大部分的招式是十分之抽象,加上串連起來的時,使之更加莫名其妙,其動機和心思,隱藏的玄機,即使是何等熟練,非有明白的老師指點是不可以能理解,更何況一般人!所以若我們不懂得如何理解,或是錯誤理解,縱使是多麼寶貴的套路不但會失真,並且對他們來說,都只是傳統遺留下來的包袱,及一大堆不設實際的動作而已!
      正如計算機及電腦所用「二進制語言」0和1,就是從我國著名的「易經」中得到啟發而發明;當我們質疑自己文化的實用性,倒不如撫心自問,其實我們是真正認識他呢?了解多少呢?
      所謂「道可道,非常道」,當中體會,要靠自己學習、了解和領略。習武其實是一種「道」,故日本人稱之爲「道場」,以武來認識及完善自我,修練自己,啓發潛能,尊重他人;同時藉着習武的特性,需要知行合一,才能夠明白箇中道理,同時懂得欣賞各種人和事物,開拓視野及知識,正如學音樂不是為了做音樂家、畫畫不是為了做畫家。縱觀,外國人對我們的文化仍然趨之若鶩,便可知道我們的文化在他們心目中價值及作用。

    • @eric880000
      @eric880000 Před 2 lety

      防身健體的武術,跟殺人伎倆是無法評比的
      非要說武術對決,那大多取決於 ~ 規則對何方有利 !
      散打搏擊的,用拳擊規則跟拳擊手對決有優勢?
      遇上泰拳的規則,討得了便宜?
      只看其他拳種在搏擊擂台上成績是不公平的。

  • @angustiger1538
    @angustiger1538 Před 2 lety

    請問,可以去邊度拜呢位大師學拳?

  • @lucaspage4906
    @lucaspage4906 Před 2 lety

    明明一下可以破到ge 攻勢,係要用4-5下去化。練傳武個個閃電俠黎,人地打一下,佢地可以打四下。

    • @lucaspage4906
      @lucaspage4906 Před 2 lety

      仲要破一個勢,有4-5個variations,運算快過alpha go

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    我是一個沒有主見的人 我需要被別人安排 我只需要服從

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    我要自己走自己的路 再見了

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    前輩的酒量非常好 但是我的酒量也不差
    我套路的說話 可是看過美國FBI書本學回來的。

  • @wbortherjohn4924
    @wbortherjohn4924 Před rokem

    👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @redtang6415
    @redtang6415 Před 2 lety

    錄音好細聲

  • @azukinakamura5401
    @azukinakamura5401 Před 2 lety +1

    電影都是虛構的

  • @eric880000
    @eric880000 Před 2 lety

    武術的價值不在擂台上的成績,尤其是 博擊擂台 !
    吃瓜群眾只視輸贏而不知~
    武術對決,那大多取決於 ~ 規則對何方有利 !
    散打搏擊的,用拳擊規則跟拳擊手對決有優勢?
    遇上泰拳的規則,討得了便宜?
    只看其他拳種在搏擊擂台上成績是不公平的。

  • @hungfeimak218
    @hungfeimak218 Před 2 lety

    好似玩一樣

  • @arinaina4262
    @arinaina4262 Před 2 lety +3

    香港功夫片中,只有壞蛋才使螳螂拳,英雄好漢都打洪拳和詠春。

  • @alekx58
    @alekx58 Před 2 lety

    Wang Wang Tang

  • @SuperD300S
    @SuperD300S Před rokem

    真打死得

  • @roidfung9319
    @roidfung9319 Před 2 lety

    螳螂拳能否應用在擂台上?

    • @user-qy3lb2wo5j
      @user-qy3lb2wo5j Před 2 lety +2

      怎麼可能呢,上了擂台不就和大陸的傳武一個樣咪……XD

    • @alexanderlee3226
      @alexanderlee3226 Před 2 lety +3

      不行的,实战不会有人和你碰胳膊。

    • @alfredleung3647
      @alfredleung3647 Před 2 lety +1

      @@alexanderlee3226 @勝負在於半秒至一秒間,所謂一膽二力三工夫,李小龍的截拳道概念也基於此。他以前於半年內,從邵漢生前輩學習少林的節拳與北螳螂的崩步拳,化了十年苦練其中腳法當中有旋風腿、偏腿、鴛鴦腳....等等。石堅前輩曾說他的截拳道只不過西洋拳加一隻右腳,可見他懂得的招式不多,但快準勁就可制敵,有如獨行俠決戰,一拔鎗就命中。傳聞以前石堅與關師傅,因少小磨察雙方露了兩手,事後有人問他勝誰負,他引述霍元甲前輩的訓示,無堅不刻,惟快不破,可知他們的一輩,確是尊師重道,秉承遺訓。

    • @alexanderlee3226
      @alexanderlee3226 Před 2 lety

      @@alfredleung3647 边去,霍元甲天津都知道是码头力工出身,什么事迹都是加工的。假的。至于什么乱其八糟理论都是tmd扯淡,武侠小说看多了!

  • @lileo5217
    @lileo5217 Před 2 lety +3

    多考虑实战多接触擂台竞技吧!

  • @roys2010
    @roys2010 Před 2 lety +6

    對泰拳很容易被ko

    • @ihhen8500
      @ihhen8500 Před 2 lety +2

      這拿來拍戲的,誰說是比賽和打架QQ

    • @eric880000
      @eric880000 Před 2 lety

      泰拳用拳擊手規則跟拳擊手打有勝算?
      說的好像泰拳天下無敵。。。
      贏的一直是 規則 !
      無視規則的實戰,打得贏球棒隊?

    • @Sto08
      @Sto08 Před rokem

      還是要優先著重力量和速度,不然這樣肯定擋不住。這技巧是可以,就看腰馬、橋手夠不夠力

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    一個打13個的叔叔 我給他煙 他跟我說煙貴 我就知道 你們很熟悉我
    但我還沒有熟悉你們

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    我大不了做一個閑人 也不會走的

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    藏頭露尾不是英雄好漢所為

  • @jerryhuang8134
    @jerryhuang8134 Před 2 lety +1

    徐晓冬上

  • @chamyuiyau730
    @chamyuiyau730 Před 2 lety

    神乎其技

  • @billyleung2379
    @billyleung2379 Před 2 lety +3

    大佬呀,示範出拳嗰個打到斜曬,你步法好的話直接出手 KO 啦,使鬼又勾又卸咩…..

    • @alfredleung3647
      @alfredleung3647 Před 2 lety +1

      Billy Leung@説對,當對手永遠是白痴,肯替他做媒。

  • @hungfeimak218
    @hungfeimak218 Před 2 lety +4

    中國花拳繡腿、不堪一擊

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    我不會再透露我的秘密的 你們簡直就是無賴

  • @bopang2228
    @bopang2228 Před 2 lety

    一打坏人就露馅

  • @vincentnutriment7554
    @vincentnutriment7554 Před 2 lety

    Chances to use this in a real fight are equal to zero.
    Parrying a punch from a boxer is just not possible
    As experience proved it

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +2

      Thanks for your watching and comment! This video is just to explain what are the keywords meant, like we find a word in a dictionary, this way just is one part of process to learn any other language, and which is not equal to we will succeed and become fluent in it, there still have too many factors.

    • @hemispace641
      @hemispace641 Před 2 lety +2

      Boxers punches get parried all the time. Both in boxing and in MMA. Do you not think parrying a punch is a useful technique?

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +3

      @@hemispace641 I think the coming next videos which can give you the answer. Traditional KungFu techniques which were created from many experienced generations, and were used for how to smarter combat. The problems how to use successfully are how would we learn and practice. We have to mention that, this video is just explained keywords theory, which is not the complete idea of the Mantis KungFu, The Praying Mantis Boxing was created a kind of complete style KungFu for the real situation.
      The founders of Northern Praying Mantis Inspired by the fighting movements of the mantis, came to develop 12 keywords theory , and merged the boxing skills of the 17 schools previously learnt by him , 8 kinds of major footwork of apes(monkeys) into the techniques, also summarizing the techniques of seven long-range and eight short-range, including eight “strong” techniques and twelve “soft “ techniques, as well as ight weakness points of human body which can be strike and what are the eight weakness points can not be strike. Finally, the style was very complete with advancing as well as retreating-evading techniques, such as dodge, earn, jump and change the situation, and thus created the Praying- Mantis KungFu preliminarily.

    • @hemispace641
      @hemispace641 Před 2 lety +1

      ​@@cwscma Thank you for that very informative and detailed reply, CWS-CMA. Looking forward to more videos from your channel.

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    還是你們是警察 我不會睬你們的

  • @user-ef4yy7bi7j
    @user-ef4yy7bi7j Před 2 lety

    重看不中用。

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    你哋係咪玩到冇撚嘢好玩
    我效忠的是公司 十多年來全依靠三隻字 安然無恙

  • @user-ik8vi9pg5h
    @user-ik8vi9pg5h Před 2 lety +3

    無法實戰 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @eric880000
      @eric880000 Před 2 lety

      你應該去參加 球棒隊! (合法攜帶冷兵器)

  • @TheRomanianWolf
    @TheRomanianWolf Před 2 lety

    Why don't those "instructors" ever work out??? I don't think he can bench press even his own weight!!!

    • @cwscma
      @cwscma  Před 2 lety +3

      Thanks for watching and comment. We have to mention that, this video is just explained keywords theory, which is not the complete idea of the Mantis KungFu, The Praying Mantis Boxing was created a kind of complete style KungFu for the real situation.
      The founders of Northern Praying Mantis Inspired by the fighting movements of the mantis, came to develop 12 keywords theory , and merged the boxing skills of the 17 schools previously learnt by him , 8 kinds of major footwork of apes(monkeys) into the techniques, also summarizing the techniques of seven long-range and eight short-range, including eight “strong” techniques and twelve “soft “ techniques, as well as ight weakness points of human body which can be strike and what are the eight weakness points can not be strike. Finally, the style was very complete with advancing as well as retreating-evading techniques, such as dodge, earn, jump and change the situation, and thus created the Praying- Mantis KungFu preliminarily.

    • @TheRomanianWolf
      @TheRomanianWolf Před 2 lety +1

      @@cwscma thanks for the explanation! Perhaps you should add the history part from above in the clip description.
      Regards!

  • @Hahahaha-to4vf
    @Hahahaha-to4vf Před 5 měsíci

    把我的真心當玩具 你們還是夠陰險的
    我之前說了那麼多真話 被你們當猴子耍了 你哋班人真係

  • @checkkilam5894
    @checkkilam5894 Před 2 lety +2

    表演得幾好都無用啦,去打實戰先有用架,上台打啦,

    • @pokuenkwan7278
      @pokuenkwan7278 Před 2 lety +1

      同意,講得幾好都冇用,紙上談兵。

    • @alfredleung3647
      @alfredleung3647 Před 2 lety +1

      那有這麼多不同派別師傅前輩,願意傾囊傳授,他們大多數已不在人世,任佢講,是否全部屬精武會留存的工夫,實耐人尋味,可能是霍元甲前輩第一代弟子,與劉振聲、趙連和同一輩份,有沒有人信?

  • @sanday777
    @sanday777 Před 2 lety +1

    🤡🤡🤡